edema. However, diastolic heart fail- phy using color Doppler imaging dur- episodes of diastolic dysfunction and
ure occurs more frequently in patients ing the acute phase of pulmonary systolic dysfunction (Mansoor et al.,
with preserved systolic function, thus edema with a follow up exam per- 2001). Systolic dysfunction occurs
it has been attributed primarily to the formed 2-3 days later. The left ven- when there is less forward movement
disorder of diastolic dysfunction tricular ejection fraction during the of blood from the heart prompting an
(Gandhi et al., 2001). acute episode was similar to the mea- increase in diastolic volume and dias-
Although diastole involves the surement obtained 2- 3 days after pre- tolic pressure precipitating pul-
process of cardiac relaxation, active sentation (N = 30). Thus, a normal monary vascular congestion leading
energy requiring processes occur dur- left ventricular ejection fraction in a to pulmonary edema. In diastolic
ing this phase. The changes in cardiac patient with co-existing hypertension heart failure, the myocardium is less
pressure that occur during diastole and flash pulmonary edema suggests compliant, such that the left ventricle
are the result of isovolumetric relax- that the pulmonary edema is due to is unable to accept an adequate vol-
ation from the time of the aortic valve diastolic dysfunction. Transient sys- ume of blood from the venous system
closure to mitral valve opening; early tolic dysfunction and severe mitral and to fill at normal low pressures
rapid filling after mitral valve open- regurgitation were found to be infre- (Beattie, 2000). The net result is a rise
ing; and low blood flow during mid- quent causes for development of flash in diastolic pressures in order to pro-
diastole; and lastly late filling (high pulmonary edema (Gandhi et al., vide adequate ventricular filling.
blood flow) from atrial contraction. In 2001) Heart failure resulting from diastolic
diastolic heart failure, the left ventri- Other clinical conditions that have dysfunction occurs when elevated fill-
cle is stiff (reduced elastic recoil) with been identified as contributing to the ing pressures are necessary to achieve
impaired relaxation causing a reduc- development of flash pulmonary normal ventricular filling (Grossman,
tion in filling. Higher diastolic pres- edema include: a) myocardial 2000). The increased resistance to
sures are required to maintain ade- ischemia, b) acute aortic insufficiency, diastolic ventricular filling is most
quate ventricular filling (Redfield, c) acute mitral regurgitation, d) mitral commonly due to myocardial abnor-
2004). stenosis, and e) renovascular hyper- malities (myocardial hypertrophy,
The literature has shown a strong tension (Walker, Walker, & Nielsen, fibrosis, ischemia, or cardiomyopa-
association between hypertension 2001), but this paper will primarily thy), and less commonly to mechani-
and development of diastolic heart focus on diastolic heart failure as it cal abnormalities like mitral stenosis
failure, as well as a strong association relates to development of flash pul- or constrictive pericarditis (Hanley &
with development of flash pulmonary monary edema because diastolic Welsh, 2004).
edema. One study described the pres- heart failure has received less atten- Hypertension is frequently pre-
ence of systolic hypertension (systolic tion and yet is believed to be highly sent in patients presenting with flash
arterial blood pressure greater than prevalent. pulmonary edema. Chronic hyper-
160 mmHg) in 85% of patients pre- tension that is poorly controlled can
senting to hospital emergency rooms Cardiac Disease result in development of systolic and
with flash pulmonary edema diastolic dysfunction that may predis-
(Kramer, Kirkman, Kitzman, & Little, Flash pulmonary edema occurs as pose patients to the development of
2000). Studies that performed a consequence of a disruption in the flash pulmonary edema (Mansoor et
Doppler echocardiography after the normal pressure-volume relationship al., 2001). Even labile elevations in
acute episode found preserved sys- during the cardiac cycle. Ischemic blood pressures of patients with bilat-
tolic function (left ventricular ejection heart disease/coronary artery disease eral renal artery stenosis have been
fraction of 50% or greater) in the has been linked with development of shown to be associated with an
majority of patients presenting with flash pulmonary edema. Acute increased risk for development of
flash pulmonary edema. Even though myocardial ischemia has been shown flash pulmonary edema (Bloch, Trost,
systolic function was assessed as nor- to cause systolic and diastolic dys- Pickering, & Sos, 1999). As noted by
mal, the evaluation was obtained after function. Cocaine abuse has been Vasan & Levy (1996) long standing
treatment of the hypertensive episode associated with development of flash hypertension is a primary predeces-
and resolution of the pulmonary pulmonary edema for multiple rea- sor to development of left ventricular
edema, thus the presence of transient sons including its precipitation of hypertrophy (LVH). Hypertension
systolic dysfunction as a precipitating myocardial ischemia (coronary artery leads to remodeling and augmenta-
cause could not be excluded vasoconstriction), acute rise in blood tion of the left ventricular mass that
(Mansoor, Shah, & Scoble, 2001). The pressure (peripheral vasoconstric- can result in diastolic dysfunction,
primary cause for flash pulmonary tion), and development of systolic as systolic dysfunction, or both.
edema, systolic versus diastolic heart well as diastolic dysfunction (Lange & However, it is important to realize
failure, was addressed in a study that Hillis, 2001). that not everyone with LVH will
examined patients with two-dimen- The existence of coronary artery develop heart failure. Athletes some-
sional transthoracic echocardiogra- disease can cause intermittent times acquire what is called physio-
heart failure continues to be cardiac tive value, greater than 90%) (Silver et sent, then associated with long-
catheterization allowing direct mea- al., 2004). Intermediate levels of BNP, standing volume expansion
surement of volumes and pressures, between 100 and 500 pg /mL had less (Mason, Broaddus, Murray, &
but at significantly higher cost and diagnostic discrimination. BNP levels Nadel, 2005).
risk (Gutierrex & Blanchard, 2004). It may be elevated in critically ill
is usually not necessary to determine patients, even in the absence of heart Flash Pulmonary Edema: A Case
the etiology for the heart failure since failure; however, BNP levels less Presentation
Doppler echocardiogram or MUGA than100 pg/ml continue to be useful
usually provide adequate diagnostic in excluding heart failure in these A 54-year-old male presented to
criteria. Pulmonary artery catheteriza- patients. BNP levels are also elevated the dialysis unit of an acute care hos-
tion can also be done and has an in patients with chronic kidney dis- pital due to inadvertent dislodgement
adverse event rate of 4.5% - 9.5%, but ease, such that a cut off level below of his tunneled venous catheter. He
it is much more precise in defining 200 pg/mL has been suggested to had been receiving chronic hemodial-
the presence of diastolic heart failure exclude heart failure when the esti- ysis for 3 years at the time of presen-
than MUGA or Doppler echocardio- mated glomerular filtration rate is tation and was oliguric. Arrange-
gram alone. If the pulmonary artery below 60 mL per minute. Chronic ele- ments were made with the interven-
occlusion pressure is greater than 18 vations in BNP may also be a hall- tional radiology department to have
mm Hg then cardiogenic pulmonary mark of patients with or at risk for this catheter removed and a new
edema exists (Harvey et al., 2005). diastolic heart failure among subjects catheter placed. He had undergone
Laboratory testing in flash pul- with preserved systolic function, inde- hemodialysis at the community dialy-
monary edema typically may include pendent of the degree of left ventricu- sis center 48 hours prior to his pre-
measurement of plasma levels of tro- lar hypertrophy (Yamaguchi et al., sentation.
ponins and brain natriuretic peptide 2004). There was no evidence of car-
(BNP). Troponin I elevation in the diopulmonary compromise on admis-
presence of kidney failure has Symptoms of Flash Pulmonary sion and he was able to ambulate to
demonstrated high prognostic value Edema the unit without difficulty. His blood
for acute coronary syndrome pressure was noticeably elevated and
(myocardial ischemia). Troponin T Complaints of severe cough and he reported holding his antihyperten-
elevation has not been recommended dyspnea are usually the primary sives that day in anticipation of
for detecting acute myocardial symptoms on presentation of flash undergoing hemodialysis. Holding
ischemia, but has been associated pulmonary edema with or without his antihypertensives on the day of
with increased mortality risk (Freda, chest discomfort. Common findings dialysis was a common practice. A
Tang, Van Lente, Peacock, & Francis, on physical examination include: chest radiograph was obtained prior
2002). In a recent study of 258 Tachypnea with use of acces- to sending the patient to intervention-
hemodialysis patients, elevations in sory muscles of breathing. al radiology to evaluate for any evi-
Troponin T (0.10 ng/mL or greater) Lung fields auscultation of dence of volume expansion since he
correlated significantly with the pres- crackles in bases and scattered would most likely miss his dialysis
ence of left ventricular hypertrophy throughout the lung fields, treatment that day (see Figure 5).
(Iliou et al., 2001). The rise and fall of rales or even decreased breath Physical examination on presenta-
Troponin I (trend) may be required to sounds. tion:
make a definitive diagnosis of acute Cardiac exam possible pres- Temperature: 97.8 F;
coronary syndrome since 1% -6% ence of an S3 indicating an Weight: 71 Kg (less than 2 kg
have been shown to have elevations increase in left ventricular end above present dry weight esti-
without symptoms (Freda et al., diastolic volume or an S4 gal- mate);
2002). lop coinciding with an increase Blood pressure: 165/116 HR
Elevations in brain natriuretic pep- in left atrial pressure, and a 89 (sitting); blood pressure
tide (BNP) have been routinely used new or changed murmur. 151/88 HR 86 (standing);
in the diagnosis of heart failure. When Jugular venous distension indi- No evidence of jugular venous
the ventricular wall stretches or there cating increased filling pres- distension;
is increased ventricular pressure, BNP sures. Cardiovascular exam: Regular
is secreted. A recent consensus panel Systolic Blood pressure may rhythm, rate 89/minute, I/VI
concluded that BNP levels below 100 be markedly elevated. Hypo- systolic murmur, - no pericar-
pg/mL indicate that heart failure is tension suggests left ventricular dial rub, no gallops;
unlikely (negative predictive value, systolic dysfunction and Lungs: Respirations were regu-
greater than 90%); while a BNP level impending cardiogenic shock. lar and unlabored, no tachyp-
greater than 500 pg/ml indicates that Peripheral edema usually nea noted, few scattered crack-
heart failure is likely (positive predic- without signs of edema, if pre- les in lung bases, otherwise
clear to auscultation; and The following findings were noted jugular vein with the tip in the
No peripheral edema present. upon his return to the dialysis unit. superior vena cava. The previ-
Past medical history was signifi- Temperature: 97.6 F; ously placed catheter had been
cant for: Blood pressure: 247/142 HR removed. There was diffuse
Coronary artery disease and 127 (sitting); bilateral pulmonary interstitial
myocardial infarction with Pulse oxygenation: 67 78% edema (see Figure 6);
coronary artery stent place- (room air); Serial Troponin I: 0.0 1.0
ment 8 months prior, Respiratory rate: 30/minute ng/mL over 24 hours (Range:
Long-standing hypertension, with use of accessory muscles; 0 0.6 no cardiac damage,
and Productive cough of frothy 0.7 1.5 non-diagnostic,
Hyperlipidemia. white sputum; greater than 1.5 Evidence of a
A 2-D Echocardiogram obtained 3 Jugular venous distention was myocardial infarction)
months earlier demonstrated: present; Other lab results included:
Diffuse hypokinesia of the left Cardiovascular exam- tachy- Platelets: 374 K/uL
ventricle, with an approximate cardia, II/VI systolic murmur, Na: 140 meq/dL
ejection fraction of 29%; loud S2, positive gallop Potassium: 4.4 meq/dL
Left ventricular diastolic dys- rhythm , no pericardial rub; HCO3: 39 meq/L
function; Lungs - decreased breath sounds BUN: 40 mg/dL
Mild eccentric left ventricular in lung bases; Creatinine: 9.8 mg/dL
hypertrophy; No peripheral edema noted; Glucose: 84 mg/dL
Trace tricuspid regurgitation; 12 Lead EKG Sinus tachy- Calcium: 10.8 mg/dL
and cardia with rate 127/minute, The treatment included:
No pericardial effusion. occasional premature ventricu- Oxygen by non-rebreather
The patient returned from the lar complexes, left atrial facemask at 60%;
interventional radiology department enlargement, left ventricular Nitroglycerin paste: 1 to
following catheter removal and place- hypertrophy and non-specific chest;
ment of a new cuffed hemodialysis ST segment changes; Labetalol: 20 mg IV over 2
catheter on a stretcher. He was noted Portable chest x-ray demon- minutes; and
to be in acute respiratory distress with strated a new dialysis catheter Acute hemodialysis with vol-
the head of the stretcher at 90. in place in the left internal ume removal.
Hemodialysis was initiated with during episodes of volume expansion. pressure and pulmonary edema
ultrafiltration of 3.5 liters over a 4- The routine practice of holding anti- through venous dilatation, but mor-
hour period. The patients blood pres- hypertensives prior to undergoing phine may also cause respiratory
sure improved, and he did not require hemodialysis in certain circumstances depression (Beattie, 2000). Lowering
endotrachial intubation. The oxygen may need to be reconsidered. The the blood pressure is a priority with
by non-rebreather facemask was practice of holding antihypertensives severely elevated blood pressures.
slowly weaned during dialysis to a is to avoid low blood pressures at the Labetalol is an effective antihyperten-
nasal cannula oxygen by the end of end of dialysis following volume sive to use in hypertensive crisis since
the dialysis treatment. He was admit- removal (Coomer, Schulman, Breyer, it can be given intravenously without
ted for observation and serial tro- & Shyr 1997). Blood pressures tend to renal adjustment (NHLBI, 2003). It
ponins to rule out myocardial infarc- normalize with the removal of can be given as a slow intravenous
tion, all of which were negative. He intravascular volume during the ultra- push starting at 20 mg over 2 min-
returned home after 24 hours with filtration process. It may be better to utes: additional 2 mg dosages can be
instructions to take his antihyperten- reduce rather than hold antihyperten- given every minute up to 300 mg
sive medications the night before dial- sives prior to dialysis to avoid such maximum dose to obtain a gradual
ysis to avoid the surge in blood pres- extremes in blood pressure (Sulkova reduction in blood pressure (NKF,
sure the morning prior to his & Valek, 1988). 2005). Lowering of the blood pres-
hemodialysis treatments. The immediate treatment of sure reduces cardiac filling pressures
patients with flash pulmonary edema and allows cardiac output to improve,
Nursing Implications is essentially the same as with any thus reducing fluid accumulation in
other type of pulmonary edema. the lungs. Additionally slowing of the
Pulmonary edema is a common Initial assessment should include heart rate will improve diastolic fill-
complication of patients with ESRD monitoring of hemodynamic parame- ing, thus improving stroke volume
(Evans, Reddan, & Szczech, 2004; ters and pulse oxymetry or arterial and cardiac output.
Shapiro, Deshetler, & Stockard, blood gases. Patients should be given Treatment of flash pulmonary
1994). Fluid and salt abuse has been oxygen. This oxygen support should edema is aimed at resolving the
reported to be the most common be provided by a non-rebreather face- immediate threat of respiratory dis-
cause of pulmonary edema in patients mask or by positive pressure ventila- tress and hypoxemia and eliminat-
receiving renal replacement therapy. tion. If the work of breathing (respira- ing/treating the underlying cause (i.e.,
How does one differentiate between tory rate greater than 30) and hypox- hypertensive crisis). Nurses assess
pulmonary edema that is associated ia is excessive (PaO2:FiO2 less than patients blood pressures pre-dialysis
with excessive fluid intake and car- 200) endotrachial intubation may be and post-dialysis, thus they are the
diogenic mediated flash (acute) pul- required (Antonelli et al., 2001). first to note changes that may place
monary edema? Pulmonary edema When hypertension is felt to be con- that patient at risk. If blood pressures
that occurs without significant interdi- tributory, obtaining immediate reduc- are assessed as above the recom-
alytic weight gain or evidence of tion in blood pressure is paramount. mended pre-dialysis reading of
peripheral edema on physical exami- Arrangement for acute dialysis with 140/90, then changes in the treatment
nation, particularly in association with ultrafiltration if the patient has regimen can be instituted. It may be
an elevation in blood pressure, already been receiving dialysis is necessary to reduce the estimated dry
strongly supports the diagnosis of most beneficial. weight to achieve a normalized pre-
flash pulmonary edema. Medications commonly used in dialysis pressure or additional antihy-
A history of ischemic heart dis- the treatment of flash pulmonary pertensives may be required. When
ease, poorly controlled hypertension, edema include a) nitroglycerin, b) hemodialysis is postponed or can-
and identification of left ventricular furosemide, and c) morphine sulfate. celed, then nurses need to remind
hypertrophy by Doppler echocardio- Nitroglycerin is a potent vasodilating patients to resume their antihyperten-
graphy may signify an increased risk drug which increases cardiac output sives in order to avoid blood pressure
for development of flash pulmonary while decreasing preload and after- extremes and risk of flash pulmonary
edema. Anemia and hypertension load. Nitroglycerin reduces pul- edema.
have been primarily associated with monary edema mainly through
the development of left ventricular venous dilatation. Patients receiving Conclusion
hypertrophy and are found in the dialysis who are oliguric or anuric
majority of patients beginning dialy- may have a mild venodilatory Patients with CKD are at risk for
sis. Poorly controlled hypertension in response to furosemide, but will not developing flash pulmonary edema.
the presence of a remodeled heart have an effective diuresis. The benefit Cardiovascular disease is highly
(i.e., LVH) may result in diastolic dys- of morphine in treatment of pul- prevalent in the kidney disease popu-
function which predisposes to the monary edema has remained contro- lation. Diastolic heart failure is often
development of pulmonary edema versial. Morphine will reduce blood unsuspected without clinical suspi-
study. Nephrology, Dialysis & hemodialysis patients. American Safian, R.D., & Textor, S.C. (2001). Renal-
Transplantation, 16(7), 1452-1458. Journal of Kidney Disease, 41(4), 814- artery stenosis. New England Journal of
Jackson, G., Gibbs, C. R., Davies, M. K., 821. Medicine, 344(6), 431-442.
& Lip, G. Y. (2000). ABC of heart Mansoor, S. Shah, A., & Scoble, J.E. Shapiro, R.S., Deshetler, N., & Stockard,
failure pathophysiology. British (2001). Flash pulmonary edema: A H. E.(1994). Fluid overload again: A
Medical Journal, 320(7228), 167-170. diagnosis for both the cardiologist technique to enhance fluid compli-
Jaff, M. R. (2001). Management of athero- and the nephrologist? Nephrology ance. Dialysis & Transplantation, 23(6),
sclerotic renal artery stenosis: Dialysis Transplantation, 16(7), 1311- 303-306.
Interventional versus medical thera- 1313. Silver, M. A., Maisel, A., Yancy, C.W.,
py. Current Interventional Cardiology Mason, R.J., Broaddus, V.C., Murray, J.F., McCullough, P.A., Burnett, J.C. Jr.,
Reports, 3(2), 93-99. & Nadel, J.A., (2005). Textbook of Francis, G. et al., (2004). BNP
Kramer, K. Kirkman, P. Kitzman, D., & Respiratory Medicine In W. B. Consensus Panel 2004: A clinical
Little W. C. (2000). Flash pulmonary Saunders Company (Eds.), Textbook of approach for the diagnostic, prognos-
edema: Association with hyperten- respiratory medicine, (4th ed.). New tic, screening, treatment monitoring,
sion and reoccurrence despite coro- York: W.B. Saunders Company. and therapeutic roles of natriuretic
nary revascularization. American Missouris, C. G., Belli, A. M., & peptides in cardiovascular diseases.
Heart Journal, 140(3), 451-455. MacGregor, G. A. (2000). Apparent Congestive Heart Failure, 10(5 Suppl.
Lange, R.A., & Hillis, L.D. (2001). heart failure: A syndrome caused by 3), 1-30.
Cardiovascular complications of renal artery stenosis. Heart, 83(2), Staub, N.C.(1974). Pulmonary edema.
cocaine use. New England Journal of 152-155. Physiology Review, 54(3), 678-811.
Medicine, 345(5), 351-358. Murphy, S. (2003). Management of heart Sulkova, S. & Valek, A. (1988). Role of
Lee, F.A., Cabin, H.S., & Francis, C.K. failure and coronary artery disease in antihypertensive drugs in the therapy
(1988). The syndrome of flash pul- patients with chronic kidney disease. of patients on regular dialysis treat-
monary edema: Clinical definition Seminars in Dialysis, 16(2), 165-172. ment. Kidney International, 35, S198-
and angiographic findings. Journal of National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. 200.
the American College of Cardiology, (2003). Seventh Report of the Joint Torre-Amione, G. (2005). Immune activa-
11(2), 151- 153. National Committee on Prevention, tion in chronic heart failure. American
Levey A.S., Beto J.A,. Coronado B.E., Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of Journal of Cardiology, 95(11A), 3C-8C.
Eknoyan, G., Goley, R.N., Kasiske, High Blood Pressure, ( JNC VIII), Tozawa, M. Iseki, K., Iseki, C., &
B. L., et al., (1998). Controlling the Retrieved January 5, 2006 from Takishita, S. (2002). Pulse pressure
epidemic of cardiovascular disease in http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/guide- and risk of total mortality and cardio-
chronic renal disease: what do we lines/hypertension/. vascular events in patients on chron-
know? What do we need to learn? National Kidney Foundation. (2005). ic hemodialysis. Kidney International,
Where do we go from here? National K/DOQI Clinical practice guide- 61(2), 717-726.
Kidney Foundation Task Force on lines for cardiovascular disease in United States Renal Data System.
Cardiovascular Disease. American dialysis patients. American Journal of (USRDS 2005), USRDS 2005 annu-
Journal of Kidney Diseases, 32(5), Kidney Disease, 4, 5(S1-S154), (suppl al data report Atlas of end-stage renal
853906. 3). disease in the United States.
Levin, A. (2003). Clinical epidemiology of Olin, R.W. (2004). Renal artery stenosis. Bethesda, MD: National Institute of
cardiovascular disease in chronic kid- The Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine, Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney
ney disease prior to dialysis. Seminars 71(2), 73-85. Diseases.
in Dialysis, 16(2), 101-105. Pickering, T.G., Herman, L., Devereus, Vasan, R.S., Benjamin, E J., & Levy, D.
Little, W.C. & Braunwald, E., Eds (1997). R.B., Sotelo, J E., James, G.D., Sos, (1995). Prevalence, clinical features
Assessment of cardiac function. Heart dis- T.A., et al.,. (1988). Recurrent pul- and prognosis of diastolic heart fail-
ease: A textbook of cardiovascular medi- monary edema in hypertension due ure: An epidemiologic perspective.
cine (5th ed., pp. 421-444). Phila- to Bilateral renal artery stenosis: Journal of the American College of
delphia: W.B. Saunders Company. Treatment by angioplasty or surgical Cardiology, 26(7), 1565-1574.
Logeart, D., Saudubray, C., Beyne, P., revascularization. Lancet, 2(8610). Vasan, R.S., & Levy, D. (1996). The role
Thabut, G., Ennezat, P. V., Chavelas, 551-552. of hypertension in the pathogenesis
C., et al., (2002). Comparative value Redfield, M. (2004). Understanding of heart disease: A clinical mechanis-
of Doppler echocardiography and B- Diastolic heart failure. New England tic overview. Archives of Internal
type natriuretic peptide assay in the Journal of Medicine, 350(19), 1930- Medicine, 156(16), 1789-1796.
etiologic diagnosis of acute dyspnea. 1931. Walker, F. Walker, D.A., & Nielsen, M.
Journal of the American College of Salem, M. M. (1995). Hypertension in the (2001). Flash pulmonary edema,
Cardiology, 40(10), 1794-1800. hemodialysis population: A survey of Lancet, 358(9281), 1646-1647.
Lorell, B.H. & Carabello, B.A., (2000). 649 patients. American Journal of Ware, L.B., & Matthay, M.A. (2005).
Left ventricular hypertrophy: Kidney Disease, 26(3), 461-468. Acute pulmonary edema. New
Pathogenesis, detection, and progno- Sarnak, M.J., Levey, A.S., Schoolwerth, England Journal of Medicine, 353(26),
sis. Circulation, 102(4), 470-479. A.C., Coresh, J., Culleton, B., 2788-2796.
Lucas, M.F., Quereda, C., Teruel, J.L., Hamm, L.L., et al.,.(2003). Kidney
Orte, L., Marcen, R., & Ortuno, J. disease as a risk factor for develop-
(2003). Effect of hypertension before ment of cardiovascular disease.
beginning dialysis on survival of Circulation, 108(17), 2154-2169.
Online submissions through a partnership with HDCN.com are accepted on this posttest at
$20 for ANNA members and $30 for nonmembers. CE certificates will be available immediately
upon successful completion of the posttest.
Posttest Answer Grid (Please circle your answer choice):
1. a b c d 4. a b c d 7. a b c d 10. a b c d 13. a b c d
2. a b c d 5. a b c d 8. a b c d 11. a b c d 14. a b c d
3. a b c d 6. a b c d 9. a b c d 12. a b c d