Auriah Cao
Whitney Gilchrist
ENC2135
Research Paper
8 April 2017
The world is filled with many unique individuals; each with their own beliefs,
likes/dislikes, ideas, and perspectives. These specific traits are based on a persons particular
upbringing and culture. Although there are many differences that divide most people,we are the
same; we are all human. Everyone enters the World the same way and everyone dies. Nothing
Throughout history there have been many instances of struggle for power. According to
information gathered from the website of Jim Crow Museum of Racist Memorabilia at Ferris
State University, Jim Crow laws were created as a means to ensure that African Americans in the
United States would remain segregated and unequal to whites, making them second class
citizens. These laws divided white and black Americans. Some examples illustrating this
oppression during that era included not allowing African Americans to show public affection,
give handshakes with white individuals, or even eat within the same vicinity (Jim Crow).
The implementation of the Jim Crow laws were a way to assert white superiority. W.E.B.
Du Bois, a prominent civil rights activist and socialist, suggested that many white Americans felt
intimidated by the working black mans ability (Wilson 234). We all have traits and
characteristics that make us unique, but it also identifies us with particular social groups. These
Cao 2
social groups separate people into various categories. When others are different from us and have
traits that we cant relate to or understand, it can result in stereotyping and prejudice towards
them (Heine 92). And, when stereotyping and prejudice occur, it can result in bullying, threats,
While African Americans were the primary target of hate and prejudice during the Civil
Rights Era, there are different marginalized groups that bear the burden now. Hate and
discrimination against African Americans are still prevalent in todays society, but there are
other groups who are being targeted as well. Since 9/11 Muslim Americans have been the target
of hate and discrimination ( Moore 85) . More recently, hate towards Muslim Americans have
increased because of the election of President Donald J. Trump. The president's views toward
this population can be perceived as condemning and hateful. In an article published by the
Washington Times, Trump stated, We will eradicate radical Islamic terrorism from the
face of the Earth (Sherfinski). This quote demonstrates how president Trump associates Muslim
people with terrorism. Today many people believe correlation implies causation. Just because a
persons upbringing mirrors one of anothers many assume they share the same beliefs and
ideals. According to Donald M. Taylor, a professor at McGill University who has done research
relating to cultural diversity and intergroup relations, and Lana E. Porter, a graduate student of
social science at McGill University, the media is guilty of depicting films and ideas implying
that correlation and causation relate. People who are not a part of that group being depicted will
categorize them as different and bad. By using a persons group membership to generalize
about that persons character, we engage in stereotyping (Taylor & Porter, 87). Because of this,
many people have correlated terrorism with the Islamic religion. The official FBI website
Cao 3
released this year's hate crime statistics report last November which shows that 19.7% of hate
It is evident that discrimination and hate still exists in many areas. One group has
privilege at the expense of another. Within the recent year we have seen an increase in hate
crimes against the LGBT and African American community as well. Fifty nine point two percent
of hate crime are race related and 17.7 are based on sexual orientation (Victims). How can we
stop unequal treatment and discrimination? How do we stop the struggle for power that results in
one group dominating another? To answer this question, we have to look closely at human
Once we examine human behavior on a social level, we may be able to find a solution.
discrimination. The Social Identity Theory states that humans have a yearning to feel good about
themselves and tend to discriminate against opposing groups to achieve this (Lilienfeld 534). It
is because each of us, essentially, want to feel good that we resort to these kinds of behavior to
achieve this state of being. We achieve this feeling by putting others down and. When we judge
and put others down, we are categorizing them in a way that makes them seem different and less
actually share more similarities than differences (Lilienfield 531). However, belief perseverance
remain strong within a person when something challenges their views; they rebut and refuse to
accept any truth that questions their own belief, even if its backed up by evidence (Lilienfield
10). How do we help people realize that there are multiple ways of viewing and experiencing the
world and, at the same time, reassure that good feeling they so much want to achieve?
Cao 4
One way to achieve this is by helping people develop critical consciousness. Critical
consciousness is the ability to understand other worldly perspectives and be able to see social
injustices (Thomas et. al al. 487). It helps us see how we contribute to the injustice and
mistreatment of others. Critical consciousness is a way to help those who are victims of hate and
discrimination see their situation in a different perspective, so they can actively try to change it.
According to Matthew A. Diemer, a developmental psychologist who has done research on how
the youth challenges racial and socioeconomic stigmas, critical consciousness is a term coined by
In 1943, Freire studied law at the University of Recife and went on to become the
director of the Department of Education and Culture of the Social Service in 1961. During this
time Freire realized the injustices toward the uneducated and lower class population. In
particular, only those who were literate were allowed to vote at that time (Gerhart 499). Freire
began to educate the people who were illiterate and in the lower class. He wanted them to see
where they were positioned in society in order for them to realize their potential to help
themselves. He felt that as long as they remained uneducated about their situations, they
remained victims of the oppression they were in. Those who had higher social statuses were not
going to make a change to end the division because they lacked the understanding of the
stigmatized group. Since they could not relate to the situation of the poor, those in powerful
positions didnt feel the need to address something that did not affect them. Freires concept of
critical consciousness stemmed from his fathers authoritative style of discipline. Freires father
held high expectations for his children but, at the same time he was understanding (Gerhardt
Cao 5
493). Freire applied this same approach to those he worked with. He had high expectations for
them and realized their potential to help themselves if only they were aware of their situations.
learn to read and understand the world around them. Freire believed that illiteracy and and
lack of critical literacy blinded many to the injustice and division around them (445). Critical
consciousness is a form of thinking to aid in the fight against social dominance that revolve
around race, sexuality, women, social class, and those with disabilities (Thomas, et al. 487).
Acquiring critical consciousness influences people to learn about social situations around them,
question them and then to take action to change their situation (Diemer 216). By taking action,
people who are oppressed become empowered to do something about their circumstance rather
It was determined by Friere that the best way to expose people to critical consciousness
was through interventions. These interventions involve discussion with others of different
backgrounds that aims to promote reflection, motivation, and action (Diemer 217). Topics of
discussion may include common everyday subjects from politics to personal preference. If this
approach is facilitated correctly, these types of dialogue can show that there are peaceful means
As mentioned earlier, based on peoples characteristics and traits, they identify with
certain types of social groups that define who they are. However, it is not as easy to identify how
People who are privileged go through life blinded by social injustices and think that their
privilege exist without any reason (Kendall 4). As a result of them not being aware that their
privilege is at the expense of someone else, they may commit involuntary acts of prejudice,
stereotyping and discrimination. But, this does not mean every privileged person is racist or
self-entitled; it means they are uninformed and unaware of how their privilege exist. People tend
to avoid situations that do not affect them. Therefore, they do not see the negative effect their
The challenge is how do we help people see their privilege, so they may understand the
struggle those without privilege go through. In A Journey into Critical Consciousness by Yvette
P. Franklin, she describes her development of critical consciousness, while attending various
multicultural classes throughout college. Franklin states that her experiences in those courses
changed her perception. She asserts, In 2007 I took a class. But upon reflection, the class took
me (47). An epiphany in class made her realize how racist she was, and how she was the
embodiment of white privilege in society. Through exposure and learning about privilege and
oppression, she recognized her role in social situations that results in certain groups having
privilege over others. Franklins story is a prime example of someone who has gone through life
blinded from social injustices because those circumstances did not affect her directly.
It is unlikely that people will sit down together and have a productive dialogue about
their opinions, perspectives and experiences. And even then some may refute ideas challenging
their own beliefs. If people are willing to put themselves in a state of learning, change can
potentially take place. Critical consciousness is meant to create a chain of thought that is
intended to spread understanding of where one is located on the social hierarchy and how one
Cao 7
contributes to the social situations that may have negative effect on certain people (Diemer 218).
Influences of family, friends and peers help strengthen that chain of thought (Thomas et. al 486).
In our culture, the views of the majority is widely respected and accepted. So, if the notion of
open mindedness was popular and accepted, people would be more willing to listen. If people are
more open to each other and willing to understand, perhaps they would be less judgmental and
discriminatory towards those who are different. And as a result, change their perspective to be
The idea of getting people to have dialogue and to be open to each other is a positive
approach to ending oppressive situations. So how can critical consciousness help eradicate
discrimination and oppression? It can start with personal development. Effort should be made to
help people become aware of social situations to alleviate ignorance. According to Paulo Freire ,
ignorance is what perpetuates oppressive situations in our society. He believes that ignorance
also reflects that people do not have critical thinking ability. Therefore, his concept of critical
consciousness was developed to help people think critically about their situations in the social
context of an individual's situation (Thomas et. al 487). Because there are many variables in
psychology, it is very difficult to predict a certain individual's exact behavior (Lilienfield 11), but
people have potential to learn new ideas and ways of thinking about their situation if they are
The concept of critical consciousness has been around since the 1970s but there has been
no real way to assess for it or measure it (Diemer 217). Recently scholars have created several
types of scales to measure critical consciousness development. There are four scales that assess
Cao 8
individual critical consciousness development. These scales include critical conscious inventory,
critical consciousness. Within these scales are subscales that observe background and education
as well as scale foci which determines what a person needs to work on (Diemer 217).
Researchers observe behavior before and after the intervention to assess a change in
critical thinking ability. When researchers measure the critical consciousness of their subjects, it
has been difficult to assess changes in daily life. Additionally, it has been hard for researchers to
measure the mental change occurring in a person when exposed to the different mentality of
thinking.
Anita Thomas, associate dean of academic affairs and research at Loyola University of
Chicago, conducted a study that allowed her to analyze critical consciousness through a
observation of mental development. Thomas gathered 206 subjects from various universities;
each student was categorized based on age, race, and social income (Thomas et. al al. 488).
During this experiment, Thomas presented each student with items that represented social
equality and justice in society, as well as educational tools or information on diverse groups.
Each item presented reflected different severities of social injustices, and like a building block,
was meant to lead each student closer to seeing social injustices. There were four stages to the
development which Thomas described as precritical, instances where students wouldnt be able
to pick up injustices; beginning critical, where students would start to see social injustices; and
critical, where students would have a clear understanding of critical consciousness; and post
critical, where students would react with a personal or social response (488).
Cao 9
After the exposure of the variables, Thomas gave each student a multiple choice answer
sheet which was meant to give her a vague idea of social enlightenment gained, if any. Each
student was asked to circle one of eight responses based on their opinions about society. The
responses ranged from I believe the world is basically fair to When someone makes a
prejudiced comment, I tell them what they said is hurtful (Thomas et. al al. 489). The results
indicated that critical consciousness development remained higher in the younger groups. Most
students lie in between the beginning and critical stages of the four step development (Thomas
491). The younger a person is, the easier it is for them to comprehend information with an open
mind. An example that reflects this is the cognitive learning and comprehension of infants.When
a child turns one, their comprehension processing highly exceeds their ability to verbalize
(Lilienfield 274). This shows that the younger people are more open and receptive to learning
Unlike the intervention, the experiment did not force open discussion among the
participants. Instead it exposed each student to the reality around them, and based on the
persons upbringing, dictated whether or not the student saw the injustices in their reality
(Thomas et. al al. 488). Each person comes from a different upbringing. These familial
influences have shaped their frame of reference of which they view the world. It has a strong
effect on the decisions they make as well as how they cognitively process situations around
them. So regardless of what this experiment exposed them to, their way of thinking may not be
influenced or changed.
Slavery in the United States is deeply rooted in our history and has an enormous effect on
this culture. Slavery is also one of the first historical events shown to children in grade school
Cao 10
that reflects cruelty humans have inflicted among each other. Furthermore, slavery is an example
of how one group of people can exert dominance over another group because of difference and
perception of which race is better. Dominance results when one group of people deprive and
control another group of peoples basic rights and freedom. The dominance of one group over
another basically communicates that one group of people is inferior to another. Slavery showed
this. It showed that white people viewed themselves superior to Africans, which they believed
allowed them the natural right to control and dominate them. Even though slavery was
eventually abolished in the United States, there emerged another form of dominance referred to
as segregation of the races. Segregation divided black and white Americans. While African
Americans would live and pursue happiness, they were still controlled by the dominant White
America. They were not good enough to eat or live their lives among White people because
laws dictated how and where they could go. Through Jim crow laws, a modern day slavery
emerged. Black people were still controlled by White people who owned and wrote the laws that
affected them. African Americans, while able to live independently, had to abide by rules that
limited them. These rules were owned and controlled by the dominant White population. They
were completely divided from white America (SLAVERY). It was not until African
Americans recognized that equal but separate treatment was not freedom at all. It wasnt until
many activists in the civil rights movement began pointing out that to have equal rights, African
Americans should be able to live as White Americans could without laws restricting them from
how to live their lives. They gained an awareness about their circumstance and did something
about it.
Cao 11
Through awareness of their unequal treatment, African Americans brought light to the
injustices surrounding them since the establishment of the United States. Even after segregation
was abolished, African Americans were still being discriminated against. But as time went by,
perspectives changed.Through these adversities, they were able to pave a way to raising
awareness and understanding of their mis-treatment. Critical consciousness is a tool that can help
change the direction society is heading. However, through development of critical consciousness,
people may be able to see and experience the world with a little more compassion and
understanding of each other. Critical consciousness can help a majority of Americans realize
social issues around them and help them become active in preventing discrimination and
acceptance formed by critical consciousness may stop the spread of division, hate, and
dominance. To combat this very unfortunate uprising, it takes all but a simple open and
productive dialogue between people who are different in order to understand and see the world
Work Cited
Diemer, Matthew A., et al. "Challenging Racism, Sexism, and Social in Justice: Support for Urban
Marginalization and Oppression." Child Development Perspectives, vol. 10, no. 4, Dec. 2016, pp.
216-222.
Taylor, Donald M., and Lana E. Porter. "A Multicultural View of Stereotyping." (n.d.): 85-90. Web.
Freire P. Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York, NY: The Continuum Publishing Company; 2000:164
Franklin, Yvette P. "Ajourney into Critical Consciousness." Encounter, vol. 24, no. 4, Winter2011, pp.
46-49.
Gerhardt, Heinz-Peter. "Paulo Freire." Prospects: The Quarterly Review of Comparative Education. 3rd
Heine, S.J. (2015), Cultural Psychology, (3rd ed). New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc.
Lilienfeld, Scott O., Kenneth M. Cramer, Laura L. Namy, Steven Jay Lynn, Nancy Jean Woolf, and
Rodney Schmaltz. Psychology: from inquiry to understanding. Toronto: Pearson, 2017. Pp.
10-274 Print.
Moore, Ashley. "American Muslim Minorities: The New Human Rights Struggle." (n.d.): 85-90. Web.
Cao 13
Riedesel, Paul L. "Racial Discrimination and White Economic Benefits." Social Science Quarterly
(University of Texas Press), vol. 60, no. 1, June 1979, pp. 120-129.
Sherfinski, David. "Donald Trump: We Will Eradicate Radical Islamic Terrorism From The Face Of
The Earth". The Washington Times. N.p., 2017. Web. 7 Apr. 2017."
Thomas, Anita J., et al. "Assessing Critical Consciousness in Youth and Young Adults." Journal of
Research on Adolescence (Wiley-Blackwell), vol. 24, no. 3, Sept. 2014, pp. 485-496.
" What was Jim Crow." Jim Crow Museum: Origins of Jim Crow. N.p., n.d. Web. 02 Mar. 2017.
Wilson, Carter. "The Dominant Class and the Construction of Racial Oppression: A
Neo-Marxist/Gramscian Approach to Race in the United States." Socialism & Democracy, vol.