Anda di halaman 1dari 15

Akello et al.

Reintegration of former child soldiers


in northern Uganda: coming to terms
with childrens agency
and accountability
Grace Akello, Annemiek Richters & Ria Reis

Reintegration processesofformerlyabducted children behavioural problems, or a habitual recourse


have yielded limited success in northern Uganda. to violence as a survival strategy. Other
The article seeks answers to the question why explanations are sought on a community
reintegration processes in the area have failed. level ^ such as the communitys diculties
The approach of one Christian non-governmental in accepting the innocence of a child who
organization towards reintegration is compared was forced to kill, or who has children by a
with the ideas and strategies of formerly abducted rebel father that in turn lead to stigmatiza-
child soldiers and people in their communities on tion and rejection of the child (Omona &
how best to deal with their violent past. Matheson,1998; Unicef, 2004; Singer, 2005).
This article seeks answers to the questionwhy
Keywords: cen, child soldiers, psycho- reintegration processes in northern Uganda
trauma, reintegration, Uganda,WorldVision have failed, by critically analyzing the
perspectives and strategies of one Christian
non-governmental organization (NGO) in
Introduction particular, regarding reintegration. It also
Reintegration processes of formerly compares the perspectives and strategies of
abducted children have yielded limited suc- formerly abducted child soldiers and their
cess in northern Uganda. For example, three communities with regard to how to best deal
months after the rescue of 300 such children with their violent past. Special attention will
in 2004^2005, none were found residing in be given to conicting ideas on:
the community in which they were supposed 1. Who is responsible; and
to have been reintegrated.1 Other data 2. A culture-specic idiom ofdistress (the way
show that over 70% of prisoners in the in which distress is experienced and
juvenile crime unit in the Gulu District, expressed) among childrenwho are being
Uganda are former child soldiers, incarcer- rejected by their communities (these chil-
ated on charges of rape, assault and theft dren feel that they are being harassed by
(among other crimes, information supplied cen, the revenging spirits of those they
by a regional psychiatrist).2 killed. Community and childrens strat-
In the literature, explanations for failed egies for healing cen will be discussed in
reintegration of former child soldiers are relation to the aim of reintegration).
often sought on an individual level ^ such as We will argue that for successful reinte-
a childs psycho-trauma that in turn lead to gration to take place, children and their

229
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

communities have to come to terms with the termswithaccountability, andfeelingsofguilt


unavoidable change in the status of such and revenge.
children, and to deal with issues of account-
ability in away that answers the needs of both The reintegration process
the community and the anxieties of the In the Gulu District many national and inter-
children involved. national organizations are active in the eld
This article is based on ethnographic eld- of refugee relief. Since 1995 two NGOs have
work of the rst author that took place over been responsible for the reintegrationprocess
a 1-year period. In the pilot phase of the of formerly abducted children in northern
study (July ^ December, 2004) she spent Uganda. One is the Gulu Support the Chil-
5 weeks at the World Vision Centre for dren Organization (GUSCO), a local NGO
Formerly Abducted Children. (WVCFAC) facilitated by Save the Children in Uganda
in the Gulu District, Uganda,3 among the (SciU) that bases its rehabilitation and
approximately 400 ex-combatants living at reintegration process on traditional Acholi
the centre at the time. Insight was gained ways, such as involving clan leaders and a
through participatory observation during traditional cleansing ceremony in the pro-
group and individual counselling sessions cess. The other is World Vision (WV), an
and morning devotions, and by in-depth international Christian relief and develop-
interviews with 80 ex-combatants. In-depth ment organization. Its format for counselling
interviews were also carried out with six and reintegration has its roots in Christian
child mothers. A group counselling session ideas aboutconfession and repentance of sins,
on HIV/AIDS was conducted with 150 for- and healing by forgiveness and seeking
mer child soldiers. Additional data were refuge with God. Since there was a strict
gathered through: informal discussions, ban on researchers by GUSCO, the rst
observation and diagrammatic illustrations author worked withWorld Vision only.5
of common illnesses and medicines used by
ex-combatants, and interviews with the Rescue and handing over Immediately after
centre counsellors, a centre nurse, and the abducted children are rescued through a
centre coordinator. Finally the rst author state army attack on the Lords Resistance
participated in a so-called hand over Army (LRA), an announcement is made
ceremony of a child to the community at over local FM radio stations. In addition,
the barracks close to the Gulu District air- radio calls are made directly toboth GUSCO
strip, and in the reintegration of one ex- and World Vision, so that they will come
combatant in October 2004 at Bungatiravil- and collect the children for rehabilitation
lage. Inthe secondphase of the ethnographic and reintegration within their communities.
eldwork (July 2004 ^ January 2005) an ex- This process takes place in a series of distinct
combatant child (Apiyo) was selected for steps. First, the childrens general health is
extensive follow-up.4 The history of Apiyos checked and any problems are then taken
life (See Box 1) is a good starting point for an care of then. Some of the children are found
analysis of the problematic discrepancy with severe gunshot wounds. Usually a
between the well-meant eorts of NGOs to substantial proportion of them are also
reintegrate child soldiers with their commu- severely malnourished. Often, there are
nities, and the compelling need of these pregnant girls or child mothers amongst
children and their communities to come to them. For treatment, the two NGOs use the

230
Akello et al.

Box 1: An uneasy homecoming

Apiyo is a 14-year-old girl who was abducted by the Lord Resistance Army (LRA) rebel group in
northern Uganda when 7 years old. During a military offensive of the Ugandan state forces, 4 years
later, she was rescued and taken to theWVCFAC for rehabilitation and reintegration. During her stay
in this Christian centre, she received counselling that had the specific aims of processing her traumatic
memories, encouraging her to confess and repent the violence she had committed and absolve her from
feelings of guilt. In the meantime Apiyos family was notified that she was found and that she would be
reunited with them. After a few weeks in the centre, counsellors finally brought Apiyo, (then 11 years
old), to the camp where her family was living.To ease the familys acceptance of the child she was given
some money and household items as starting capital. Apiyo used the money to forge friendly relations
with people by lending it to them, but when the money wasgone, it was never paid back and the relation-
ships collapsed. Other challenges arose as a result of having confessed that she had killed various people
in her village, including close kin. As a result, the community harassed her, referred to her as a killer and
a person whose head is sick. In school, children frequently laughed at every mistake she made and
constantly involved her in fights.They also openly resented the special attention Apiyo received from
her counsellors, which in turn made the girl decide to bar any follow-up activities by theWorld Vision
(WV) counsellors.
In the meantime, Apiyo also started to develop symptoms of ill health, the most prominent being sleep-
lessness and nightmares in which the spirits of people killed by her (cen) appeared and threatened
revenge. Following her familys advice she took medicines for sleep and regularly burned leaves of the
plant atika, which is thought to chase away evil spirits. However, the spirits chasing her were too strong.
After 1 yearApiyo, again followed her familys advice, and at the age of 12 she asked to be allowed into
the army, knowing that the environment of the army would chase away the spirits. However, even
though the state was indiscriminately recruiting boys at this time, regardless of their age, Apiyo was
not accepted into the army.This left Apiyo and her family with no other options. At 12, Apiyo rejoined
the rebel group, but not for long. She was taken captive again by the state army and sent back to the
WVCFAC. At the time of the interview, the now 14-year-old girl had been reintegrated again, but not
with her family. She was placed and accepted as the caretaker of a sickly friend with HIV/AIDS
registered in a WVantiretroviral treatment programme. In that situation she still has to confront the
spirits of the dead, but they are not as vengeful as they were during the first reintegration.
Currently, Apiyo goes to a school within the municipality where she was not introduced by any of the
NGOs dealing with former child soldiers, so none of the children know her history. She has, however,
discovered that one of her close kin has recently moved near this school and is intending to take their
children to herschool.The good thing is, within the municipality, there were so many schools that she
could easily change to another school where no one knows her very well.

Lacor hospital, or their own clinics where The ceremonyof handingoverex-combatants


some of the sick ex-combatants are also taken to the rehabilitation centres is adult oriented.
for medical care.Those who have been medi- The children, for whomthese ceremoniestake
cally examined and declared healthy are place, play a passive role. The main players
taken from any of the two centres for rehabi- involved are state security representatives at
litation, and subsequent reintegration back district level, high-ranking army comman-
into their own communities. ders, coordinators of the two NGOs and some

231
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

spectators. This is especially common in to each other during the sessions, or join
ceremonies with wide publicity, and on others who played in the compound.
occasions when ex-combatants are own into In individual counselling, a counsellor and
the district by light aircraft. Dierent high- ex-combatant interact in a private setting.6
ranking ocials make speeches about the Such counselling serves several explicit pur-
ex-combatants, largely portraying them as poses. On the one hand, the counsellor needs
vulnerable innocent victims who need all the to document the former child soldiers bio-
support, encouragement and help they can graphic data to allow the tracing of their
get to become part of the community again. kin. On the other hand, it is also thought that
We will come back to this below. counselling will help the child to process his
or her memory, and cope with the violence
The counselling process at World Vision After they have survived, witnessed or committed.
the handing over ceremony, GUSCO and Success in counselling is measured by the
WV will take the children to their own extent to which children can freely discuss
centres where the rehabilitation occurs. their experiences. Memories are accessed
The World Vision centre for formerly through story telling or drawing. Special
abducted children is an institution occu- attention is given to childrens active
pying about 1km2 of space enclosed by a participation in violence (such as murder,
fence wall. In 2004, it had two oce rape, looting property, and amputating the
blocks, a central isolated building forchurch limbs of people). However, counsellors delib-
activities, and two big blocks serving as erately, or following instructions, will not
dormitories for boys and girls, respectively. inquire directly about the childs participa-
There is also a small room at the boys tion in this violence at their own initiative.
block, which serves as a centre clinic, and Talking about the crimes committed, by the
numerous smaller huts for child mothers child him/herself, often amounts to a climax
and their children. in the counselling process. The counsellor
The daily procedures in the centre are will explain to the child that it was not their
similar throughout the week. At 7 oclock a fault that they were abducted and sub-
bell wakes sta and children. They prepare sequently forced to carry out such atrocities.
for prayers, also called morning devotion, The child is then advised to forget those acts,
which is scheduled for 8 ^ 10 oclock. This and forgive those who made them do
devotion takes the Pentecostal format, with such things.
an hour of singing, dancing and giving testi- One of the explicit aims of theWVcentre is to
monies, followed by the teaching of a instill Christian values in the children,7
preacher or pastor on topics such as forgive- before they are reintegrated back into their
ness, the Ten Commandments, and peace. communities. Counsellors believe that if
Sessions will then be adjourned for sta and they do not succeed in converting the child
children to have breakfast. After the break, and making them confess and repent their
individual or group counselling sessions will involvement in violence, the reintegration
occasionally take place. Often, group coun- process will be delayed. In theory, therefore,
selling sessions involve teaching by invited the time spent at the centre depends on the
Pentecostal preachers. During the sessions readiness of a childto openupabout the atro-
observed by the rst author, few children cities they have committed. Children who
stayed until the end. Most preferred to talk prefer not to share their experiences are

232
Akello et al.

considered dicult cases. In practice, an A view on trauma, repentance


individuals duration of stay at the centre is and innocence
determined by the demand on the facilities. The course of the rehabilitation and reinte-
In 2005 for instance, some children spent gration process of former child soldiers is
over a year at theWVCFAC, mainly because based on a view in which Christian values
there were few child soldiers being rescued. are blended with psychotherapeutic con-
Reintegrating children as soon as possible cepts. This view is constructed around two
would mean that the centre ran out of related but distinct themes. One theme
business. When the state armed forces fre- centres on the necessity of repentance and
quently attack the rebel ghters and more being forgiven. Post-traumatic therapeutic
children were freed, the maximum time an counselling should bring about repentance
individual might spend at the centre is and forgiveness. Another theme centres
3 weeks. around issues of vulnerability, innocence
and victim hood, issues closely related to core
Reintegration back into the community Reinte- western ideas that children are essentially
gration is at its peak when the child is vulnerable (Christensen,1997).
taken to their community of origin, or to This view is often expressed during the hand-
their family. It is a prerequisite that the coun- ing over ceremony of the former child soldiers
sellor goes to the homestead where reinte- by the army to the NGOs. In the speeches
gration will take place a week in advance to delivered at the ceremony, frequently the
counsel the parents aboutbringing back their term trauma is used, always followed by
child. On the day itself, the coordinator the recommendation that counselling be car-
brings with him 300 000 shillings (approxi- ried out for theseinnocent victims. Counsel-
mately 136 euros), a mattress, basin, hoe and ling, it is explicitly asserted, will help the
other household utensils to give to the child.8 children to come to terms with their trau-
The child, accompanied by two or three matic events, rework through their memory
counsellors, is then transported to his or her of witnessing and being forced to carry out
parents. Often, on arrival, the community extraordinary events, and will ensure rehabi-
insist on an ancient cleansing ritual whereby litation of the formerly abducted children.
people make the child step on eggs or In the speeches, the violent acts of the
sprinkle water on his or her feet using the children are explained by emphasizing that
branches of the Olwedo tree.9 We will come they have been forced to do such horrendous
back to this ritual later. Depending on how things. Since they have witnessed and experi-
busy the counsellors are, often the process of enced such extraordinary events, they are
reintegration takes less than 1hour.The child traumatized and need community support
isthen left with hisorherpeople. Occasionally and sympathy.
counsellors do a follow-up on their clients. Inthe reintegration process as it is carried out
Distance of the homes for the centres, the by the NGO World Vision these ideas are
disappearance of the child and, as in the applied in dierent ways. When entering
case study of Apiyo, the childrens reluctance the fenced complex of theWVCFAC one sees
to be visited by counsellors again, were all the writings on the wall; biblical excerpts
given as contributing factors for the low concerning forgiveness, love, peace and
intensity of contact with the centre after extorting the children not to fear.The centre
reintegration. coordinator disclosed that these writings

233
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

are meant to help re-shape the rescued chil- atrocities they have been involved in,
drens thinking since they are powerful experience of such children point to wide-
messages which they need. spread community resistance to their reinte-
As we have seen, Christian devotions form an gration. Apiyo explained in relation to the
important element in the counselling process 300 000 shillings donated to her by the
at WVCFAC. Testimonies given during the NGO: A s long as the money is still there and you
morning rituals focus on the miraculous are lending it to people around, they pretend to be
work of God, and forgiveness is a recurring your friend. When the money we were given is
and important topic in everyday preaching. nally over, everyone in the camp changes. Even
Visiting preachers often admonish the chil- those who borrowed the money from you become
dren to turn away from their sins and give so cruel; you do not know where to begin to ask for
their lives to Christ. This desired outcome your money back.
also is the focus of individual counselling. In numerous focus group discussions, dis-
Conversion and repentance of the evil done placed children described how in the com-
during combat is seen as a necessary step for munity or in camps where the latin lum
the child to be redeemed and healed. Being (child from the bush) is reintegrated, there
led to Christ in practice means that the ex- is frequent harassment, verbal abuse and bolo
combatant, after confessing his or her sins, dogekum dano mooo Ilum (wherever that person
is advised to forgive those who forced him to passes and whatever he or she is doing, people
do such horrendous acts and told to say a keep on criticizing and talking against him
prayer in which he becomes saved. Dicult orher). S/he is called names such as murderer,
cases were according to one counsellor those killer, and thief.
ex-combatants who did not readily talk about their There is a clear stigma attached to being
experiences in the bush. Giving an example of labelled a formerly abducted child. This
one male former child soldier she argued, if stigma is rooted in dierent notions of what
only he would open up, talk about all evil things he having been a child soldier means. Firstly, it
had done, he would be led to repent them and then is widely known that, motivated by poverty,
be reintegrated in his community. misery, seeking revenge or curiosity, or by
In short, right from the hand over ceremony seeking healing from evil spirits, some freed
to the actual reintegration, key persons ex-combatants voluntarily joined the armed
addressing issues of reintegration of former struggle. This obviously undermines the
child soldiers portray them as vulnerable ocial talk on innocence. The fact that a
people in need of special attention. However, substantial proportion of ex-combatants,
the notion of the need for repentance of for- particularly boys, nd it dicult to live a life
mer child soldiers is ambiguous. By stressing outside armed struggle and become involved
the fact that the children were abducted, in looting and harassing people does not help
and thus forced to commit their horrendous the image of innocence of formerly abducted
acts, their essential innocence is emphasized children either.
throughout the reintegration process. Another source of stigma lies in ideas about
the eects of traumatization, which in itself
Community perspectives on are accurate. That people know about these
rehabilitated child soldiers eects is especially problematic for ex-
In spite of the counsellors insistence on for- combatants who are of school-going age.
mer child soldiers innocence regarding the They nd the schoolteachers, administration

234
Akello et al.

andpupilsequippedwithskillstointeractwith to their communities or places of origin. A


them. This is because various NGOs, includ- substantial proportion has migrated to a
ing Norwegian Refugee Council, SCiU and labora farm ^ a self-supporting institution
WV, organizedanumberof dierentteaching put in place by the state where former rebels
sessions and workshops for teachers and com- are settled and sometimes facilitated in
munity leaders.Therein, they are taught how their activities by the state. They engage in
to identify and counsel ex-combatants. One farm and other income-generating activi-
is taught characteristics of traumatized chil- ties. Reports from the SCiU ^ Gulu oce
dren, such as being aggressive,not-friendly, show that the former rebels, having been
hyper-alert,not respecting others. Teachers reintegrated and then rejected by their
interviewed often mentioned that trauma- communities, often relocate to this farm.
tized children are those from the bush or Others have gone back to the rebel group
formerly abducted children. to re-join the armed struggle or, in case of
A third source of stigmatization lies in the girls, as wives of the rebels.
idea of evil spirits. We will come back more It was reported in group, and individual,
extensively later to this issue, suce it to say narratives how child mothers face severe
that cen, who are thought to harass the former rejection in particular. They and their chil-
child soldiers are considered impure and dren are viewed as people with direct links
dangerous to the health of anyone coming to the killers. Some remain in touch with
into contact with them. Prior to the establish- their husbands10 and stories have been told
ment of WVCFAC and GUSCO, the state about rebel commanders who collected
army would line up all the rescued child sol- their wives and children after reinte-
diers in any of the streets of Gulu town and gration. The maintaining of links with the
instruct the spectators to identify and take rebels puts child mothers in a delicate
their kin with them. This was a problematic situation, especially when the husband is
approach since, as aWVcounsellor disclosed: thought to have committed atrocities
No one, not even parents of ex-combatants, would within the community.
selecttheirchildfrom the peoplelined up.Thesoldiers The unwillingness of communities to wel-
kept announcing the line-up over the radio and kept come formerly abducted child soldiers, is
parading the rescued child soldiers even in the market based on the refusal to accept the idea that
for over one month. People passing by would instead such children are not accountable for the
throw insults at them, and a substantial proportion crimes they have committed. The fact that
feared to use those streets lest they picked up cen communities will insist on traditional cleans-
brought back by ex-combatants. ing rituals for child returnees also points to
The new format for the reintegration pro- this issue. There is a story about the father of
cess where children are taken individually one ex-combatant who advised him to leave
to their communities, after having prepared the camp and nd somewhere else to stay
these communities for it, clearly tries to after he had disclosed that he had killed his
break with such stigmatizing procedures. paternal uncle. His father did not want to be
However, the hand over ceremony, as well associated with a criminal, let alone someone
as the formal reintegration within the com- who murdered his own brother. The reven-
munity does attract attention to the child ging spirit of close kin can be perceived to
as a child with a problematic past. Some be very dangerous, to both the ex-combatant
freed children request not to be taken back and those living with him.

235
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

A perspective from within: child So I went back to the bush till I was rescued
soldiers and their symptoms again.
Formerly abducted children are very con-
scious about the negative attitudes of the In focus group discussions and in-depth
people around them.When Apiyo was asked interviews with ex-combatants, it was
about her experience in the primary school commonly disclosed that they did not feel
where World Vision counsellors introduced like innocent victims. They even recog-
her, she replied as follows: nized that there were various incidents
where it had been possible to let a captive
At the school, no child wanted to interact with free, but that they chose nevertheless to kill
me at first. All the children, even the girls, in him or her. For instance Apiyo discussed
my class would run away each time I would the following:
want to interact or play with them. I was stay-
ing alone most of time. In class, they left a desk One night we went to a trading centre. We went
for me on my own, yet some children were sitting into one of the shops that had the highest number
on the floor since there were very few desks.They of commodities. After we had looted everything,
often laughed and joked that cen can get me at the commanders told us to start moving back into
any time and force me to kill them. Then the the bush again. I had talked to the shopkeeper
teachers started tellling them that it was not during the day to ask him to reduce the prices of
my problem that I was abducted. All the bad the clothes he was selling and he had just thrown
things I did, such as killing people, was simply insults at us. Since I had a gun, I shot him in the
because I was forced to. Then everybodys atten- head at a close range. He died instantly. It was my
tion would be on me. Children slowly started own choice to kill him.Till this day, the cen of
coming closer to me and asking me everything this man comes at night to disturb me. Sometimes
about the bush. I told them. Perhaps it was a he comes with a gun to shoot me as well. Some-
mistake that I told them about the people I killed times also, we came to capture some people, but
myself. They started to fear me again. They after some distance the commanders would not
started calling me dano ma wiye lit (some- decide on what to do with them. So they would
body whose head is sick), a mad person, and a leave the decision to any of the younger soldiers.
killer. During such times I would fight with the Often times, we enjoyed killing them ourselves.
other children. I would fight with boys older After some time in bush, you can do certain things
than me and they would sometimes over-power without fear.
me. I would then threaten to kill them if I found
a gun. The teachers would then call me aside In instances where the former child soldiers
and talk to me about how to behave in a school. had decided to commit horrendous acts
They told me that I should always forgive themselves, it was clear to them and to others,
others. And sometimes they would punish me what they had done.They would then discuss
for fighting. The children also reported me for among themselves the feeling of acting inde-
killing people they knew.11 On my way home, I pendently and how the cen of the people
would hear people talk and laugh about me. killed keeps disturbing them. Female ex-
People would call me names and abuse me combatants were sometimes harassed by cen
everywhere I went. I had to leave that place in the form of huge men wanting to rape
since, by then, I was not even able to sleep. them. Apiyo and three child mothers dis-
I wanted to join the army, but they refused me. cussed their experiences thus:

236
Akello et al.

Such cen can even come to attack you during the displaced children (not only ex-combatants)
day, but when you scream, it is instead a source of in interviews disclosed how they have often
happiness to the people around. People argue that seen deadbodies andeven mistakenly stepped
it is the only way you can pay for the bad things on them. They are advised to put branches
you did in the bush. (any type of branches but especially of the
olwedo tree) on such dead bodies in order to
Cultural leaders in the Gulu District have wardocen.Thiswasoftenasucienttherapy.
described cenasthe entrance ofanangryspirit Therefore, there is a measure of chance incon-
into the physical body of a person or persons tracting cen. If that is the case, the symptoms
that seeks appeasement, usually in the form can easily be warded o or removed. When
ofasacriceor,inthecaseofawrongfuldeath, they do not disappear, this indicates a persons
compensation and reconciliation between guilt in having committed a crime. One
the clan of the oended and oender. The 15-year-old ex-combatant who preferred to
spirit manifests as cen, which will haunt the settle within Gulu municipality and not with
wrongdoers by entering their mind or body close kin in the camps, often gossiped with his
in the form of visions and nightmares that friends in the neighbourhood, telling them
may result in mental illness and sickness until how wise he had been by regularly deceiving
the wrong is made right. Cen can also send the commanders by saying that he had shot
nightmares and sickness to the rest of the the captives dead, while in reality he had let
family of the individual involved, so threatens them escape. He had never been disturbed by
not only the individual, but the family and cen. He sympathizeswith otherex-combatants
community (Liu Institute for Global Issues who frequently carried out horrendous acts
& Gulu District NGO Forum, 2005). In by themselves. It is such ex-combatants who
essence, cen means evil spirits. Dimensions of are constantly disturbed by the cen of the cap-
the evilness take the form of revenge, ven- tives they had killed. According to this boy, in
geance, pollution, causing harm to the indi- cases where ex-combatants were simply
vidual and the community through illnesses, ordered to kill or killed jointly, not they but
misery and mysterious deaths. Children the commanders who were responsible for
describe the symptomatology of cen as night- ordering the killing would be disturbed
mares, sleeplessness, seeing images of men by cen.
whowanttoattackthem,anddisturbingrecol- Thecommunityalsoacknowledgesthatnotall
lections.Thepsychiatristwhowasinterviewed ex-combatants have the problem ofcen.There-
concerning such symptoms in former child fore, before the ex-combatant is accepted into
soldiers mentioned how they were usually thecommunityquestionsare oftenasked, such
diagnosed with severe forms of depression, as: Has the person complained of cen lately?
coupled with anxiety. The notion of cen can How severe is it? Has the person tried to use
thus refer to a multiplicity of symptoms, medicines to aid sleep and the atika plant to
including feelings of guilt, hearing voices, the extent of making incisions inthe forehead,
nightmares and feeling frightened or sad. andyetthereis still noimprovement? If so, this
In explanations ofcenthe one who suers from is an observable indicator that such a person
cen is not always held accountable for being is not an innocent victim, but a murderer.
attacked by the angry spirit. On the one hand, When the child has tried all available
one can pick up cen if one comes into contact approaches andthe cen is still disturbing them,
with a dead body. A substantial proportion of then the latter is explained in terms of guilt.

237
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

Therapeutic measures by the participants. After the ceremony, the


Childrens rst resort for dealing with symp- people who participated go back home with-
toms consists of medicines for sleep.12 They out talking or looking behind. The child for
are readily available in over-the-counter whom the therapy is being sought sits by the
pharmaceutical stores in the Gulu district. door of the house where it lives. Extract from
Other sources include grocery shops, the atika plant is applied to incisions on its
hawkers and market vendors. It is the buying forehead by the ajwaka. After that the child
of medicine by symptom, which makes it easy enters the house backwards. Also, the
for the children to get medicine for any ill- branches of atika are axed at the doorposts
health symptom. If an individual can buy and the windows, and sprinkled where the
medicines for headache,fever,desire to stay child is being frequently disturbed by cen
under the sun all the time, then hawkers while they sleep. That marks the end of
know that ex-combatants need medicines the ceremony.
for sleep. They stock dierent types of medi- It is expected that after such an elaborate
cation including: valium, pilitons, and some ceremony, the (ex-combatant) suerer of cen
tranquilizers.These are dispensed according will not be aected again. Some children
to the amount of money an individual can interviewed indicated that atika had been
raise. For instance, each tablet of valium is eective in chasing cen. However, for Apiyo
100 shillings. So a child is given the (See Box 1.) the plant did not work. This was
number of tablets according to the amount after its extract was applied into incisions
of money they can aord. on her forehead. Therefore, she felt that she
If the child has no money, the plant atika is had only one more option to try ^ namely
readily available. The plant is scrubby and to re-join the armed struggle. Indeed, when
has a characteristic smell.13 The most com- she was in possession of the gun again, she
mon use of the shrubs is to chase mosquitoes was rarely disturbed by cen.
from the house. However, they are also used
by many people in Gulu to chase cen away. A psychosocial view on cen
Children burn these plants on partially bro- Surprisingly no ex-combatant among those
ken pots as a therapy. Some have indicated interviewed indicated that s/he had ever
that they xed branches to the doorposts had such aproblemwith cenwhile incaptivity,
and windows, and on roofs, and at the time neither before nor after they were freed by
for sleep, smeared it on their heads and mats. the government, and they had decided to
However, when the disturbance by cen is return to the bush.Therefore it could be pos-
severe (occurring on a daily basis and with tulated that the symptoms of cen in formerly
a scary presentation, such as when the cen abducted, displaced children are a reaction
wants to kill the child aected), then a to the lack of acceptance of ex-combatants
ceremony is organizedby the childs kin.That by their own kin and their communities.
ceremony must involve an ajwaka.14 In brief, Or, in psychosocial terms: the systematic
the ceremony involves making animal sacri- exclusion of ex-combatants and communal
ces by the riverside. A goat or chicken is isolation are likely to form a second trauma-
slaughtered and its blood sprinkled on the tization accounting for the mental ill-health
person aected. The animal is then cooked symptoms exhibited by former child soldiers.
or roasted without salt and eaten. During When the community recommends armed
allthis time there must be no verbal exchange struggle as the best way to deal with cen,

238
Akello et al.

implicitly the ex-combatant is instructed to In Gulu, the rst authors initial encounter
nd a group where she or he can establish with the frequent use of the word counselling
relationships, build networks, and gain trust was where one of the WV counsellors often
and perhaps nd people who live according referred to group or individual counselling
to his or her norms. In short, in the context sessions, whereby these terms applied even to
of armed struggle, it is postulated here, cen gathering ex-combatants for announcements.
does not disturb the ex-combatants when Counselling was used also for teaching ses-
they are able to nd a sense of belonging, a sions. It was used for meetings where material
social support system and relationships support or basic necessities were distributed
within the armed struggle more easily than to ex-combatants. When the researcher
when they are reintegrated back into the civi- inquired if she could stay at the centre till the
lian community. The community of armed last session of the day, the centre coordinator
persons does not blame them, since people advised that it would be dangeroussince boys
involved in armed struggle can legitimately and girls involved in counselling sessions with
kill, loot and perform otherwise horrendous each other after dusk. In another context,
acts. When in armed struggle, former child counselling was used at Noahs Ark (a Chris-
soldiers can acknowledge that they carry tian-founded NGO with its headquarters in
out these acts in their own right as well.Thus, Kampala focusing on the wellbeing of dis-
in those circumstances the ambivalence of placedandvulnerablechildren) shelter where
being an innocent victim who has committed counsellorsgo for eldwork and research to
crimes does not apply to them. inquire about how much people know about
When ex-combatants re-join the armed Noahs Ark. If any negative comments were
struggle, they return to what they know how made about Noahs Ark or its sta, the com-
to do best ^ namely survive in adversity munity was counselled by being advised to
through militaristic ways. As already men- adopt a positive and self-reliant attitude.
tioned, a substantial proportion of these ex- Counselling was again used in churches for
combatants havebeen in armed struggle since people who go for prayers and at Caritas
their early childhood. Rejoining the armed (a Catholic-based NGO with headquarters
struggle by ex-combatants serves also to get at the district major cathedral) where people
out of the community where people see them go to see a lamiyi tamu (giver of advice).There,
asguiltyandyetcannoteasilytryandsentence they were counselled through various pro-
them. Therefore, sometimes rejoining the cedures includingdoingdream analyses with
armed struggle is perhaps best for both the theexperts.
healthof the community and the ex-comba- Clearly whatever procedure or format of
tants themselves. In the light of the need to counselling was used, the present strategy of
establish a peaceful society however, this last reintegration of formerly abducted children
resort of children to deal with their violent through counselling according to the Chris-
past ^ by returning to a context where tian ideals of repentance and forgiveness has
violence is seen as normal ^ is a direct failure. had limited success. The discourse on inno-
cence, trauma, repentance and forgiveness is
Coming to terms with neither shared with the community, nor with
accountability the children themselves. The communities
The words counselling and rehabilitation are diculties in forgiving perpetrators of vio-
usedby many people to mean dierent things. lence and their distrust of children whose

239
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

violent past they know, led to rejection and Therefore, if the female ex-combatant with
open discrimination. Children themselves her children needs to settle in a community
acknowledge that they are not free from where she is accepted, she needs to go back to
responsibility for warcrimes inthe past, either the father of her children.This could be what
explicitly when they talk about it amongst child mothers would tell NGOs if they were
themselves, with the researcher or during asked. They are instead regarded as former
counselling. This is also true when exhibiting abducted girl children who need to be
symptoms of an aiction, cen, which clearly reunited with their parents. However, that
points to apersons responsibility inthe killing often fails, as they are viewed more as wives
of a human being and which may lead to re- or rebels than a child who was abducted. In
joining the armed struggle.The Liu Institute cases where it fails, the child mothers are then
forGlobalIssues & Gulu DistrictNGOForum required to rejoin or settle with the male
(2005) after numerous consultations with kin of her children; rebel commanders or
important actors in Acholi society came to returnee commanders who are sheltered at
the conclusion that traditional approaches to key rehabilitation centres, or those still active
justice and reintegration may make a signi- in the armed struggle.
cant contribution to restoring social relation- Another case that presents particular chal-
ships in Acholi lands. lenges are the ex-combatants who have been
Ex-combatant children are usually not asked in the armed struggle for a long period of
about their own perception of their past time. Some return as adults. However, they
and their wishes regarding reintegration. quickly nd out that to register as a former
Their answers couldalso refer tothe necessity child soldier is a safe option since they will
of a complete redesigning of the rehabilita- then automatically be presented to the com-
tion and reintegration project, which thus munity as an innocent victim who was forced
far has mainly been implemented in a top- to carry out horrendous acts. It is therefore
down manner. Surely key project planners likely that when the community feels an
anddistrictocials would nd it problematic urgent need for justice, and not compromise,
if former child soldiers would tell then that the ex-combatants will continue to face com-
they do not feel traumatized, and do not munity hostility and not acceptance. Then
see themselves as innocent victims but as there is still the option of re-joining armed
perpetrators of war crimes. struggle(s), an action that is justied asbeing
Female formerchild soldiers inparticular pre- in quest of therapy for cen.
sent a complex challenge. Their case makes Based on the eld data presented the existing
the gap between the approach of the NGO NGO attempts to cure bad habits by coun-
and the needs of their clients appear even big- selling and talk therapy for the duration of
ger. The most vulnerable were child mothers 3 weeks needs to be revised. These attempts
and those who were rescued pregnant and the neglect of traditional cleansing
mothers. They were retained at the centre till ceremonies by the Christian NGO World
they gave birth. In practice, the act of reinte- Vision may even be the reason that a
grating a child mother, some of them with as substantial proportion of rehabilitated ex-
many as ve children, back to their kin needs combatants end up as juvenile prisoners
rethinking. It is inappropriate, because in and not as a community member. Another
patrilineal societies, females do not own land. reason for the latter, could also be that the
Land is owned and controlled by male kin. community where the ex-combatants are

240
Akello et al.

reintegrated live in dire misery and abject boy has no problem of cen at all. In fact, on
poverty. These communities often have sur- his return, there is a man who recognized
vived in displaced persons camps for two him as the one who helped him escape. This
decades now. They rely on intermittent and boy wished all the combatants acted like
irregular distributions of aid from the this clever boy. This is because they could
numerous NGOs in the Gulu District.While avoid the idea that the community keeps on
some of the ex-combatants may thrive talking about them and perhaps even more
due to the armed conict and the support importantly, they would not have the
they have received after being rescued, problem of cen.
people in the camps rarely have signicant
skills needed for independent survival. Conclusion
The NGO strategy of presenting an innocent For the reintegration of former child soldiers
victim to the community is eectively being a multifaceted approach is needed in which
challenged through gossip and slander about at least the following factors are taken into
the supposedly innocent victims. This is account:
another factor explaining the failure of 1. The ex-combatants ideas concerning
reintegration processes. One of the recom- the entire process of rehabilitation and
mendations that displaced children give as reintegration;
a way to eectively deal with cen and help 2. The problem of cen;
the former child soldiers live with others in 3. The idea that a child is abducted, but a
the community is to stop saying negative rebel returns;
things about them. People around them 4. The limited community support of the
should also try to support them by telling ex-combatants; and
them that it was not their fault that they were 5. The poor general living conditions in
abducted and subsequently told to kill other the camps.
people. However, emotions running high It is often argued that the most impor-
can be recognized in group discussions when tant factor is that the war be stopped.
this issue is discussed. That may be so, but even then the chal-
For example, in one group a boy mentioned lenges presented regarding an eective
how one ex-combatant had disclosed in his reintegration of former child soldiers as
narratives that he had killed people of his victim/perpetrators remain.
own initiative. Sometimes he would order
the newly abducted people to kill, or he References
would do it himself. How then can people Christensen, H. P. (1997). Vulnerable bodies:
then consistently tell him that his problem Cultural meanings of child, body and illness.
of cen exists because he was just ordered to In: A. Prout (Ed.), Childhood and the body.
do such crimes? London: Macmillan.
One 12-year-old discussed extensively how
there was a clever ex-combatant renting a Singer, P. W. (2005). Children at war. New York:
hut in his neighbourhood in Cereleno ^ a Pantheon Books.
suburb east of the Gulu municipality. He told
them wise stories about how he always just Omona, G. & Matheson, K.E. (1998). Uganda: sto-
shot to miss, or in the air, and told all the len children, stolen lives, Lancet, February 7,
people that he was told to kill, to escape.This p. 442.

241
Reintegration of former child soldiers in northern Uganda: coming to terms with childrens agency and
accountability
Intervention 2006, Volume 4, Number 3, Page 229 ^ 243

Liu Institute for Global Issues & Gulu District more so since recently as these numbers were
NGOForum, withthe assistance of Ker Kwaro decreasing. After one radio announcement about
Acholi (2005). Roco Wat I Acoli. Restoring rescued child soldiers while the author was at
Relations in Acholi land: Traditional theWVCFAC centre, the coordinator of GUSCO
approaches to reintegration and justice. called to instruct the coordinator not to send any-
body to that district oce for clients, since
Unicef (2005). Child mothers face stigma of rejection, GUSCO would take in all the returnee children.
www.unicef.org/infobycountry/uganda_24566. This was becauseGUSCO was presently running
html. out of business since very few child soldiers from
Gulu were presently being rescued (female coun-
1 The Coordinator of Save the Children, Gulu sellor). Immediately following the phone call,
Uganda, provided this information. there were discussions among counsellors, support
2 This psychiatrist assesses all juvenile delin- sta and other workers at theWVCFAC concern-
quents for mitigating factors, such as post- ing why GUSCOthinks it isthe only NGOto carry
traumatic stress disorder. The psychiatrist often out counselling and reintegration. Presently it
does not nd concrete evidence for links between hadbroadened its scope to take in former child sol-
the crimes committed after reintegration and diers not from Gulu. Yet, its original mandate was
play-backs of extraordinary events which hap- to rehabilitate ex-combatants from Gulu district.
pened to these ex-combatants while in the bush. This did not happen when there were more former
3 This centre is popularly known as trauma child soldiers returning.TheWVCFAC coordina-
centreor simply trauma. tor expressed his determination to go and chal-
4 Interviews took place in the presence of her lenge GUSCO to adhere to its original
friend (also a former child soldier), at her primary objectives. Their constant shifting of goal posts
school or at the World Vision food distribution and changing of their focus will eventually con-
centre for people with HIV/AIDS registered in tribute to the WV trauma centre not having any
World Visions anti retroviral treatment program clients.
in Laroo division (one of the four geographic div- 6 Most information below comes from written

isions of the Gulu municipality). Other valuable records of the interactions with children.The rst
data derive from interviews with the northern author participated in one individual counselling
region coordinator of Save the Children in session.
Uganda (SCiU).This NGO is a key donor to Gulu 7 The WVCFAC also took in adult rebel comba-

Support the Children Organization (GUSCO), tants who surrendered to the state for rehabilita-
primary school teachers of displaced schools, tion. At the time of study, there was a separate
camp leaders in Unyama and Palenga displaced centre for adults but special cases such as a former
persons camps, healthcare providers (including rebel commander and his wives were hosted in a
the regional psychiatrist), nurses at the feeding separate apartment within the main centre of
unit of malnourished children at Lacor and Gulu WVCFAC described above.He would stay there
hospitals, and displaced children in some dis- as long as he wanted. It was a political decision
placed primary schools including St. Kizito Alero made by the ocials at the hand over ceremony.
Cuku and St. Peters Bwobomanam primary After the rescue the state and district ocials
schools hosted by Gulu Prison P.7 primary school. forgave the former commander and his wives.
5 In the pilot study, the two key NGOs turned out He could not be reintegrated immediately since
to be sti competitors over the numbers of rescued he feared the community would attack him,
children they were allowed to accommodate, even disclosed the WVCFAC coordinator when

242
Akello et al.

interviewed about the extraordinary scenario of the army, whether for the state army or the rebel armed
the presence of a former rebel commander and group.That is the only solution. Cen fears anybody with
his extended family. He was instructed to give a gun. Anybody who is armed cannot be attacked by cen.
him special treatment. Hence a separate apart- Sometimes, thegovernment doesnot wanttotake in children
ment was given to him and his family. WV pro- below eighteen years of age for their army (focus group
vided all the basic necessities. discussion with12^15 year olds in Gulu, Northern
8 Lists of items distributed to the children varied.
Uganda).
9 The specialists at Makerere University Botany 13 The shrubs belong to the class of Labiate and

Department could not identify the Olwedo tree. species commonly used include Ocimum basilicumL.,
We therefore refer to it by its local name in this Orthosiphon australisVatka and another similar plant
article. of class Chenopodiaceae and the species of
10 We usehusbandsandwivescautiouslybecause
ChenopodiumprocerumMoqwere referredto as Atika.
such relations involving rewarding commanders 14 An ajwaka is an indigenous healer. He or she

with abducted girls is not what constitutes a mari- evokes spirits in healing. These healers often have
tal union as between husbands and wives as adults more knowledge about the appropriate use of her-
consenting to the relationship. bal medicines than an average person does. They
11 In one focus group discussion with displaced
are also known to sometimes use their powers to
children selected for extensive follow-up, one of hurt other people. For example an aggrieved per-
the children whose brother was killed by rebels son can ask an ajwaka to send cen to make his or
confronted Apiyo. This was because Apiyo had her enemy insane.
decided to discuss her experiences and actions in
the bush. The girl accused Apiyo of having killed
GraceAkello is a PhDStudent aliated with the
a boy called Odokorach (her brother) from
Amsterdam School for Social Research and
Anaka. Apiyo deantly answered that the Odo-
Leiden University Medical Center. She lives in
korach she had killed was from Kitgum, and not
Uganda. E-mail: akellograce@hotmail.com.
Anaka. There was subsequently an exchange of
Annemiek Richters is Professor of Culture,
severe verbal insults. This focus group discussion
Health and Illness at Leiden University
was called o and it was decided to always meet
Medical Center, The Netherlands. E-mail:
with Apiyo individually, or with her friend.
12 When a formerly abducted child-soldierhas a problem
j.m.richters@lumc.nl
Ria Reis is Associate Professor at the University
of lack of sleep, when people are talking negative things
of Amsterdam, specialized in medical anthropol-
about him or her, and when he orshe is constantly disturbed
ogy, focusing in particular on children. Email:
bycen, thischild can use medicinesofsleep, and that plant
r.reis@uva.nl
atika. Ifthere isnoimprovement at all, thens/heshouldjoin

243

Anda mungkin juga menyukai