A) MAIN REPORT
Section Subject Page
B) DESIGN REPORT
ANNEXURES
Annexure A : Report on traffic survey
Annexure B : Report on topographic survey
Annexure C : Report on subsoil investigation
Annexure D : Report on seismicity of site
Annexure E : Computer Modelling
Annexure F : Influence lines
Section A-1: Background of the Project.
A two-lane high level road bridge had been constructed across Zuari river in April 1983 at km 16 on
Panaji Mangalore section of NH-17. This is a prestressed concrete box girder balance cantilever type bridge with
627m length on river portion and a total length of 807m including viaducts. The super structure of the main bridge
comprises of 4 spans of 122m PSC box girder of varying depth, two end spans of 69.5m each and 5 viaduct spans
of 36m each. All foundations are of deep well type.
Since 1983, the traffic density on the corridor has increased substantially for which the 2-lane carriageway
is inadequate. Also, due to high salinity and severe aggressive coastal environment, the existing road bridge had
shown signs of distress and consequently a load restriction of 12 tonne was imposed. The bridge girders have been
strengthened by external prestressing in the year 2001 followed by load testing. However, due to very high traffic
growth in this region, decision has been taken to construct a new 4-lane bridge alongside the existing one on BOT
basis.
One of the important feature of the Zuari river is that it carries large number of high capacity barges laden
with iron ore which passes underneath the bridge and move to Mormngao Harbour and back. This necessitates
provision of navigational passage in the existing and proposed crossing. In the existing road bridge, two
navigational spans of 122m each have been provided. For the proposed bridge, decision has been taken by the
department to construct a 4-lane cable stayed bridge with central span exceeding 350m. The decision for a cable
stayed bridge has been primarily dictated by tourists attraction as tourism is of prime importance to the state and
also to have a landmark structure in the state. In addition to the main cable stayed bridge, consultants scope of
work also includes design of a 6km long Velha bypass to with a toll plaza in continuation to the Panaji side
approach to the bridge.
Accordingly, tenders were invited by PWD, Goa for the consultancy services for the proposed cable
stayed bridge and terms of reference was issued in August 2001. This TOR was originally made for 2-lane bridge
and subsequently modified in favor of a 4-lane bridge crossing. The consultancy work has been awarded to M/s
Span consultants Pvt. Ltd. On 9th August, 2002 refer PWD Goa letter no. PWD/SE.IX (NH)/F.5260-T/2002-03/290
dated 9th August, 2002 followed by signing of agreement on 5 th September, 2002. The consultancy work has been
accordingly started, all the related site survey and investigation work completed preliminary design engineering
carried out and the draft feasibility report is now submitted as per terms of agreement.
Relevant extracts of the above data are enclosed for reference. These have been made use of in the present work.
Section A-3: Traffic Survey and Analysis
Section A-4: Field survey and investigation
Following field survey have been carried out as per provision of TOR and in discussion with the department.
i) Topographic survey
Topographic survey has been completed on the entire project stretch using computerised Total Station and
Autolevel equipments. Reference co-ordinates have been established with Global Positioning system (GPS).
Details of the GPS instrument is enclosed. A survey corridor width of 250m i.e. 125m on either side of centre line
has been adopted. All existing physical features within the corridor width have been identified. The survey has
covered the entire proposed alignment including 1000m beyond end of approaches on either ends plus the proposed
6km long 4-lane Goa-Velha bypass alignment on Panaji side. Here also a survey corridor width of 250m has been
adopted.
The survey covered two alternative alignments for the proposed bridge and approach.
Survey of river bed profile has been made with steel chains from boat at the proposed centre line of
bridge and on u/s and d/s side of the same. Bed level in navigational channel varies between 8m-11m below HTL.
The proposed alternative alignment plans for the bridge and bypass has been developed based on the
results of above survey and in discussion with the department.
The existing GTS bench mark reference point is located on the south end of the existing road bridge and
identified by PWD engineer at Goa. Based on the GTS value, the temporary bench marks are fixed along the
survey corridor by double run leveling method. Temporary BMs have been established using Autolevel
equipments of make Sokkia, Japan.
The control points for the traverse have been conducted by using Global Positioning System of Leica
Swiss make. Based on the GPS control points, open traverse has been conducted by using computerized Total
Station equipment. These 3-D survey data have been down loaded in the consultants design office computer system
to prepare the survey drawings on digital terrain mapping system. The proposed alignment plan has been plotted on
the survey drawings.
Survey drawings have captured all major existing physical featured viz. buildings, drainage, electric posts
major trees. Telephone posts, existing roads etc.
Regarding the bypass, about 75%of the alignment passes through agricultural lands. The right-of-way (ROW) of
the bypass boundary (land acquired by the department) has been shown to the consultants team by the concerned
PWD engineer.
Entire centerline of the proposed alignment on land has been staked out at site and marked on ground at
50m intervals. The same has been checked by concerned PWD engineer.
For future reference of the proposed bypass centerline alignment and bridge, a no. of reference points
have been marked at site. Details of these reference stations, list of bench marks, layer details for Autocad
drawings, details of blocks and field data checked by PWD engineer are enclosed to this report.
Shipping and
Good Good Good Heavy Heavy
handling
Installation and
Small, light Small, light Small, light Heavy bulky Heavy bulky
stressing gear
Grouting on site Yes Optional Optional Yes No
Preferable cable size:
u.t.s (kN) < 25,000 < 25,000 < 25,000 < 25,000 < 25,000
-length (m) < 100 > 100 > 150 <150 < 200
Availability India/Import India
1) According to the French Code NF A 35-035, u.t.s cab be upto 1860 N/mm2
2) According to the French code NF A 35-0.35, u.t.s cab be upto 1770 N/mm2
Completion work.
Following the actual work on the cables, various completion operations must usually be carried out. These include:
Dewatering: the cavity between the anchorage sleeve and the cylindrical cable passage must be dewatered or
filled with grease, to prevent accumulation of condensate and assure corrosion protection. Apart from the
corrosion preventing effect of the grease, requirements are also imposed in regard to dripping point and
composition.
The transition between the polyethylene or steel tubing and anchorage is sealed with shrink tubing.
Permanent corrosion protection of anchor head, bearing plate and grout cap.
Fig: Sequence of operations for restressing or distressing a stay cable at site
Quality Control
Quality is the most important aspect for stay cables particularly for such aggressive environment. It must therefore
be assured during all stages of protection application. During in-service of the structure, surveillance and
monitoring the forces of selected stay cables must be implemented.
The quality assurance includes the following measures:
Careful selection of all components including selective sampling and testing. The checks comprise
destructive and non-destructive tests of the relevant properties for all the tendon components including h.t
steel, anchor materials including steel socket, heads, lock-nuts, shims, wedges, filler material,
polyethylene pipe and corrosion inhibiting compound.
Precise and detailed method statements for all actions and works in connection with cable fabrication,
installation, stressing and final corrosion application.
Minutes and detailed checks on and reporting of the various stages of cable fabrication in the factory or
cable assembly on site.
Minutes and detailed checks reporting on the various steps of cable installation.
Stressing reports indicating cable loads and extensions for each tensioning operation and characteristics
of the equipment used, including calibration charts.
Static tensile and fatigue tests on full size stay cables with a length depending on testing facilities
(normally approxi. 5 m).
Monitoring of the tendon loads using specially developed load cells will provide interesting information
on the fluctuation of the tendon force due to service loads, as permanent printing out of data is possible.
DESCRIPTION OF CONSTRUCTION STAGES (For cable stayed portion only)
1.1 Starting position.
Following structural element have already been erected.
Two pylon upto level 114.00 (temporary guys if required)
Abutments PP1 and PM1.
1.2 Construction stages.
i) Approx. 25m of the bridge deck at each pylon location are built by means of scaffold from well
cap and cantilevering supporting brackets.
Erect cable 19 and 20 and stress to predefined level.
ii) The main span and side span erection will start simultaneously from each pylon in a cantilevering
construction procedure. Each stage consists of in-situ segments of approx. 10m each.
Cantilevering Form Travellers (CFT)shall be assembled on above deck already built.
iii) progressively proceed from pylon side towards both midspan and anchor pier, erecting
corresponding cables on each side simultaneously viz. Cables 18-21, 1-22,16-23, etc. till approx.
cable 12-31.
During these operations. The CFT to work as a cantilevering unit for its won dead weight only.
Weight of in-situ concrete in 10m segment shall be carried by stay cables attachment to deck.
The anchorage details shall cater to this requirements.
vii) Finish deck with footpath, crash barrier railing, WC etc. and then fine tune all cables to finished
vertical profile.
TIME FRAME
Total time frame is closely related to the extent of resources mobilised by the contractor. Based
on the construction stages described above, i.e. simultaneous mobilisation of 4nos CFTs 2nos tower
cranes, barge mounted cranes, sets of hydraulically operated jump form shatters for pylons etc, a
preliminary construction program has been made, as enclosed.
For deck erection, a cycle time of days for each 10m segment has been considered viz. 4 segment
to be built simultaneously.
Overall time frame is envisaged as follows:
Construction of Pylon
Construction form well cap +3.800m upto +19.100m can be made by conventional method with
steel shutters. This portion is having a steep inclination. Above +19.100m level, jumpform conreting
method can be adopted to +114.000m (top). Cable inserts of steel, are to be installed from +74m to
+112m. Also the top tie beam is to be constructed at +74m level. In this 38m portion, jump form shutter
on two opposite sides need to be tailor-made due to these inserts. Else fixed form shutters may be used. It
is of utmost importance to install these cable inserts to very degree of accuracy to avoid permanent
damage to the stay cable in these anchorage zones.
One dimension of the pylon leg is constant while the other dimension is gradually varying.
Each lift of the jump form shutter shall depend upon various factors e.g. jack capacities etc. however a lift
of 2.5m to 3.0m is considered reasonable. All the 4 legs of the 2 pylons shall be constructed
simultaneously.
One no. tower crane shall be erected at each pylon location with boom of adequate length to cover both
legs.
In addition to the cable inserts, a no. of other inserts are to be left on pylon viz. access lifts, restaurants at
top (optional), aviation beacons, illumination, emergency access ladder, lightening arrestors etc.
AESTHETICS ASPECTS.
The aesthetic attraction of cable stayed bridges lies in the extreme slenderness of the deck which
in combination with thin stays, provide an aesthetic impression of lofty lightness. In our case the
depth/span ratio of the deck is 470/2 i.e. 235. Individual size of the stays, due to this close spacing, is also
thin e.g. for the longest cable of 247m, duct dia. is 200mm, length /dia. ratio of 1235. For the shortest
cable of 65m length, this ratio is 406. As such the finished deck would appear to float over the large
expanse of Zuari river close to the mouth of sea.
There are a number of possibilities for the stay arrangement. The most natural and technically
most efficient arrangement is the fan shape with all stays starting theoretically from the pylon top. The
other extreme is the harp shape with all stays parallel and equally distributed over the height of the
tower. However, technically this arrangement is the leas efficient.
Since stay cables must be replaceable in future, the joining of all the cables at the top becomes
structurally difficult. Therefore, the upper range stay anchorages are normally distributed over a suitable
length of the tower head leading to a compromise between fan and harp types i.e. modified fan type. This
is adopted in this bridge.
For a pleasing appearance of such cable-stayed bridges, it is aesthetically important that the
fascia runs undisturbed throughout the length on the outside on cable anchorages. For this bridge the
fascia is the integration of the wind fairing and the low height protection wall on the edged of the deck
which runs uninterrupted throughout the length. Care has been taken in the cable anchorage details so that
the anchors do not protrude below the soffit line. However in deck alternative 2, the anchorheads only
would protrude underneath the corner of soffit, but again in the backdrop of the main girder depth, this
will have insignificant visual impact.
For large spans and taller heights, A-shaped towers normally provide the appropriate solution. Here again,
two alternative shapes have been worked out. In the first alternative the lower legs have been inclined
towards inside under the deck in order to concentrate the force on to a relatively smaller foundation.
Careful proportioning has been made in order to obtain harmony.
It is also aesthetically and structurally important to have proper proportioning between the central and side
spans. The side spans which end with the backstay cables should be less than half of the main span which
in our project is 0.404. This is required to keep the stress changes in the backstays within allowable limits.
In order to avoid a drab aesthetic situation by providing all the exposed HDPE ducts as black tubes, it is
now possible to have brightly coloured HDPE ducts which are co-extruded with UV resistance. Large
number of recent cable-stayed bridges have been built internationally with such coloured ducts which
provides a contrast against the backdrop of the blue sky.
Illumination of such long span cable stayed bridge plays a very important role in highlighting the structure
and providing a location of tourist interest. A major part of the energy required can be obtained by
installing permanent solar panels as has been done in a number of major bridge projects in Japan. Also it
is possible to have different illumination scheme during different seasons (rainbow effect). These shall be
worked out during the DPR stage.