BC Place Cable Snaps FOI

Steve Lingenfelter
F r o m : L a r r y L a M o n t a g n e p a r r y. l a m o n t a g n e @ s c m . c a ]
S e n t : M o n d a y, D e c e m b e r 0 6 , 2 0 1 0 9 : 2 3 A M
To : 'Ralph Herten'
Cc: 'Andy Tallentlre'; Chris Beaton; Roy Patzer; Robert Gagnon; pmanley@jltcanada.com;
shu@msexch.jltcanada.com; mjang@jltcanada.com; Dan Bock; 'Martijn Lunneker'; 'Lome
Ebenal'
Subject: RE: BC Place Crane - Dropped Cable Net Incident
Thanks Ralph,
Please let me know when more information is available. A preliminary rough estimate would also be
appreciated ASAP.
Cheers,
Larry LaMontagne, FCIP
Director-Commercial Claims
ClaimsPro (An SCM Company)
Tel. (604) 609-4116 Direct
Fax. (604) 662-8105
Original Message
From: Ralph Herten irmailto:RHerten@pcl.com1
Sent: 2010-12-06 9:18 AM
To: Larry Lamontagne
Cc: Andy Tallentire; CBeaton@bcpavco.com: RPatzer@bcpavco.com: RGagnon@bcpavco.com;
pmanlev@iltcanada.com; shu@msexch.iltcanada.com: mianq@iltcanada.com;
DBock@bcpavco.com: Martijn Lunneker; Lome Ebenal
Subject: RE: BC PLace Crane - Dropped Cable Net Incident
Larry,
Further to our discussion today, and as per your request, we are forwarding a plan and a photo of
typical cablenets. The photo shows one cablenet installed and another in the process of being
installed.
Our preliminary investigation is pointing towards a failure of the rigging during the installation of one
of the cablenets. There was some resultant damage to the components of the cablenet (cables and
castings) and also to the bleacher area below.
The incident is still under investigation and we expect to have more information in the next few days.
Regards,
Ralph Herten, P. Eng. | Senior Project Manager
PCL Constructors Westcoast Inc.

Page 16 of 96 1
BC Place - Phase 2 Roof, Project 2200906-1F3
Phone: (604) 673-4306 | Cell: (604) 786-3646
Original Message
From: miana@iltcanada.com fmailto:mianq@iltcanada.com1
Sent: Sunday, December 05, 2010 11:19 AM
To: DBock@bcpavco.com: mianq@iltcanada.com
Cc: Andy Tallentire; Ralph Herten; CBeaton@bcpavco.com: RPatzer@bcpavco.com:
RGaqnon@bcpavco.com: pmanlev@iltcanada.com: shu@msexch.iltcanada.com
Hi Dan,
Further to our conversation of just now, I will advise our claims department and Larry of the new
claims. It sounds to me like the majority of the damage is to the new COC materials with some minor
damage to the existing structure. We will report this into the insurers. In the meantime, please
continue to update us with any additional information that you receive on this.
Thanks,
Monica
Original Message
From: Dan Bock rmailto:DBock@bcpavco.com]
Sent: Sunday, December 05, 2010 10:12 AM

To: mianq@iltcanada.com
Cc: atallentire@pcl.com; Ralph Herten; Chris Beaton; Roy Patzer; Robert Gagnon; Peter Manley
(pmanlev@iltcanada.com)
Hi Monica i pass along this notification at PCL's suggestion. Pavco has very little information on the
event at the current time. Here is what we know at this time. During the erection process late friday
afternoon a cable net fell from a crane connection. I dont believe there was any personal injuries
There was some minor damage to existing stadium. I understand from PCL's attached email that the
cable net itself was damaged and some components will require replacement.
I will discuss claim notification protocol with PCL. I suggest JLT's claims department contact Ralph
Herten at PCL for details on this claim.
Ralphs phone number is 604 673-4306.
Pavco - Dan Bock

Page 17 of 96 ,
604818 5552
From: Andy Tallentire [ATaIlentire@pcl.com]

Sent: December 5,2010 5:07 AM
To: Dan Bock; Roy Patzer
Subject: Incident
Dan and Roy

its very likely that we will need to replace the cables and at least some of the castings.
You should advise your insurance company asap as this may be an insurable event.
Thanks
Andy Tallentire
Operations Manager
Direct (604) 241-5342
Mobile (604) 999-6964
The contents of this e-mail as received may not be a complete or accurate version of that sent. If you
consider that the contents are material to the formation of
a contract or you are otherwise relying upon its accuracy, you may wish to request a copy be sent by
facsimile or normal mail. The information in this e-mail is
confidential and may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, please
destroy this e-mail and notify the sender immediately - you should not retain, copy, distribute or use
this e-mail for any purpose, nor disclose any of its contents to
any other person.
Page 18 of 96
Steve Lingenfelter
From: mjang@jltcanada.com
S e n t : Tu e s d a y, D e c e m b e r 0 7 , 2 0 1 0 11 : 2 6 A M
To : Dan Bock
Cc: atallentire@pcl.com; RHerten@pcl.com; Chris Beaton; Roy Patzer; Robert Gagnon;
pmanley@jltcanada.com; shu@msexch.jltcanada.com; mmcwilliams@msexch.jltcanada.com;
lany.lamontagne@scm.ca; mjang@jltcanada.com
Subject: BC PLace Crane - Dropped Cable Net Incident - Insurer Notification.
Hi Dan,
Further to our telecon of yesterday, this is to confirm that all COC and Wrap Up insurers have been
notified of the loss and acknowledged receipt of the report. As you can see, Larry is already working
on this with Ralph.
Please let us know if you have any questions and keep JLT informed of any further updates.
Many Thanks,
Monica
The contents of this e-mail as received may not be a complete or accurate version of that sent. If you
consider that the contents are material to the formation of
a contract or you are otherwise relying upon its accuracy, you may wish to request a copy be sent by
facsimile or normal mail. The information in this e-mail is
confidential and may be privileged, if you are not the intended recipient, please
destroy this e-mail and notify the sender immediately - you should not retain, copy, distribute or use
this e-mail for any purpose, nor disclose any of its contents to
any other person.
Page 19 of 96
Steve Lingenfelter
From: Martijn Lunneker [Lunneker@pcl.com]

S e n t : W e d n e s d a y, D e c e m b e r 0 8 , 2 0 1 0 8 : 0 1 A M
To : d m c @ g e l g e r e n g i n e e r s . c o m ; C h r i s t o p h P a e c h
Cc: Dan Bock; Andy Tallentire; Lome Ebenal; Michael Halajian; James Outerbridge; Karen Lynch;
Kevin Lindsey
Subject: BC Place - Cable Net R31 Inspection report proposal
Attachments: BCP_FREY_IRP_3006_A - Inspection plan for Net R31 .pdf
Importance: High
David and Christoph,
We have requested Freyssinet to outline their plan for inspection of the elements on cable net R31 that was involved in
the incident last Friday.
Please review and provide any comments or concerns you may have.
We are currently focusing on the installation of R14 and are trying to get confirmation to install R15 after this. This will
hopefully buy us the necessary time to deal with R31.
The next cable net that needs to be installed after R14 and R15 will be R31. We cannot skip this one and continue with
R32 since we will not be able to make the pin connections at the node side at R31 at a later date.
Pins at the node can only be made in a pre-determined sequence because of space restrictions.
First priority would therefore be to get confirmation and approval to use elements from R06 and R24 to re-built cable
net R31.
As noted by Freyssinet the only elements that currently cannot be substituted are the A and B clamps.
Pending your comments on this proposal Freyssinet has therefore started inspection of these clamps.
Don't hesitate to ask for any information that you require in addition.
Regards,
Martijn Lunneker | Project Manager
PCL CONSTRUCTORS WESTCOAST INC.

BC Place - Phase 2 Roof, Project 2200906
BC Place - 777 Pacific Blvd, Vancouver
Tel: (604) 673-4300 (Direct 4323) | Fax: (604) 673-4301
A member of the PCL family of companies
Watch us build at www.pcl.com
This e-mail (including any attachments) is for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential information which may be protected by
legal privilege. If you are not the intended recipient, please immediately notify us by reply e-mail or by telephone 604-241-5200, delete this e-mail and
destroy any copies. Thank you.
File: 2200906-4:051000
Page 20 of 96
INSPECTION PROGRAM AND REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31
Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010

By: BCN
Document ref: BCP FREY IRP_3006 Rev: A Checked: MDN
The purpose of this document is to present our inspection plan for the cable net R31 elements after
the lifting accident (Dec, 3rd 2010). It is organized in three parts.
1. Facts
In this first part we will present the position of the elements after the
accident and the elements available to get an understanding of the
situation
2. Analyze
This part details the possible damages we indentified and the inspections
that will be carried in order to control them.
3. Inspection documents
This will give a sample of each type of inspection record and the
instructions required to perform the inspections.
Pjyu21 uf90
96 p gg a6ed
1N3CH33V U3dV S1DVJ
96ot an
0X03 Jaqujaoaa pj uo 6uaj!| 6uunp ||ej 6u|mo||oj :uoseay
IE* #13N
xauissxaud
aovid oa T3N
NVld NOULDHdSNI
INSPECTION PLAN
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssmeT
NET# R31
Part 1. Status after fall/before lowering operation

Part Description
Hanging to grizzly on mast side

Upper cables Pinned in central node
Open female sockets (mast side) on the ground

Lower cables Cable resting on ground and intermediate trolleys until position H05
Pinned in node
Hangers 1 to 13 connected both side

As usual (refer to ITP 3910) hanger 14 was only connected and the top and tension rod 15 was|
Hangers not connected.
Hanger 5 tensioned, stuck on 2 trolleys below lower suspension cables
Hanger 6 tensioned
Lower damps Lower 1 and 2 on ground, 3,4 and 5 on or near trolleys, not touching ground
Other damps hanging in the air
Upper damps Upper damps on position in the air
Page 23 of 96
BCP_FREYJRP_3006_A - Inspection plan for Net R31 jds
spc%eMieN-KyuB|duoipedsu|-v 900C ddl A3dd d09
96 jo ^ a6ed
juappu/ ajqjBg
(/TJ (sdjnjDid ujea uadMjddq Dds nj) dsde/-3iui j i/ej
OIOZ Jaqiusoaa DJ uo Duryii 6uunp ||bj 6u|MO||cy :uosea>j
ley #JL3N
aUISSAdU=J
aovid oa TC13N
NVld NOLLDHdSNI
spr \.u jbn joj uejd uo(joedsu| - v 900e~dUrA3Hd~dO8
96 JO gg a6ed
ludppuijayv
(/Z) (sdjnjjid i/jea uddMâaq dbs ot) 9sde/-dLui -j jjed
0I07J Jaquuaoaa PJ uo 6uny!| Buunp ||B^ Bujaaoiioj :uoseo^
lH #3N
auissxad=j
aovid oa TE13N
N\Hd NOLLD3dSNI
spci.eW9N-'tyu8Kluo?Podsul-V 900 ddl A3dd~d08 96 JO 92 oBed
j u ff p p u / j ff y y
(/) (sdJn)Did uDed uddM)ddq -dbs ot) dsdei-diui -j j./ej
OTOZ Jsqujaoaa pj uo Bupjn 6uunp ||bj Buimohoj ruoseay

xeci #hn
xauissxadd
aovid oa TEJL3N
NVId NOUOadSNI
spriea J6N Jo; uejd uoipedsui - V~900~dyrABUd~dOa
96 jo LZ 96ed
(/T) ludppoe jayv - uo/jenj/sjo ajnjjij *j /</

0103 Jaqujaosa pj uo 6uaj!| Buunp ||ej 6u!MO||cy -.uoseay
TCy #3N
auissAau=i
aovid oa TEJL3N
NVld NOUOadSNI
sprj,caieNJOju8|duo|ped8U|-v""900e""dai A3dd d09 96 jo 82 o6ed
(/Z) iUdpiDDe Jdyv - uotfenysjo ajn^Did i ven
0101* jaqtuaoaa pJ uo 6uryn 6uunp ||ej 6u!/v\0||aj :uosea>|
IZH #JL3N
xauissxadd
3DVld oa T13N
NVld NOIX33dSNI
spaea 8n jj ueid "oipodsui - v 90oe dai a3wj doa 96 JO 62 oBed
(/) juappje jojjv - uo/jenjfsjo ajnjj/d 'j jJ&d
0103 Jaqujaoaa pj uo Butyl.! Buunp ||ej BU|N\0||OJ :uosea
TEH #13N
xauissxadd
aovid oa TEJL3N
modern NOiioadSNi
96 jo 0 o6Bd
S3DVWVCJ JO S33nOS C1NV 3SA1VNV
Bra am
OTOc* J3quJ9oaa pj uo Bujjjjj Buunp ||Bj 6u!mo||oj :uoseay
TEy #13N
xauissAadd
aovid oa TE13N
NVId NOLLDSdSNX
INSPECTION PLAN
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31
Reason: Following fail during lifting on 3rd December 2010
Part 2. Potential sources and damages (1/3)

Part Source Potential damage
On mast side, the upper cables have hit the
handrail and bleachers, the lower cables Opening of wires due to twisting or
Full locked cable (socket) have hit the ground and trolley. bending below minimum radius
(upper and lower) On node side, cables may have been damaged Damage to coating (pins, cables and
in scorpion. sockets)
There was no contact with the tower.
Substitution:
Upper cables 090: use R6
Lower cable 070: use R6
Substitution possible for R31 and
Replacement:
replacement Limited stock on Geobrugg's plant (1 cable 090
- none 070) - Delivery time: pending
information
Visual inspection (straightness of cable, pin,
socket, conical socket, special socket)
Inspections Checking galvanisation (impact area)
(see IRP 3005 Al) Inspection and re-certification by Geobrugg
Estimation of the dynamic load
Coating: touch up (cold spray galvanizing or
ZRC paint)
Repair Further repair to be defined following
inspection (pending information from
Geobrugg for" undiped " wires)
Cable tensioned between 2 damps or under Opening of wires due to twisting or

Hangers other cables bending below minimum radius
Cable hitting ground/damp/trolleys Domage to coating
Substitution:
Substitution possible for R31 and Hangers: use R6
replacement ReDlacement: limited stock on Geobrugg's
plant - Delivery time: pending information
Visual inspection (straightness of cable, pin,
Inspections socket)
(see IRP 3006 A2) Checking galvanisation (impact area)
Inspection and re-certification by Geobrugg
Coating: touch up (cold spray galvanizing or
ZRC paint)
Repair Further repair to be defined following
inspection J
Page 31 of 96
BCP_FREYJRP_3006_A- Inspection plan for Net R31.xls
INSPECTION PLAN
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31
Part 2. Potential sources and damages (2/3) \

Part Source Potential damage
Lower damps position 1,2 and 3 hit the Bending of plates

Lower clamps ground, 4 and 5 probably hit trolleys. Damages to surface or coating
Other lower damps didn't hit anything Damage In welds
Substitution:
Substitution possible for R31 and
Damps A & B : none
replacement
Clamps C: use R6
Oamrjs A - Pos 1 to 5 :
Visual inspection AND SANDBLASTING
Casting : UT & MPT (according SCA 1010 B)
Welds :UT
Inspections Plates: geometrical survey
(see IRP 3006 A3 and IRP 3006 M)
Clamps A - Pos 6 to 9. damps B & C :
Visual Inspection
If marks of Impact, same process than damps
A pos 1 to 5
Protection : re-metallisation for damps A pos 1
to 5
Repairs Touch up for the other damps
Further repair to be defined following
inspections
Clamps Dl Position 1 may have hit bleachers

Bending of link plates
Upper damps (probably not thank to the spacer on the cable)
Other upper clamps have not hiot anything Shocks/damages to surface or coating
Substitution possible for R31 and Substitution:

replacement Clamps D : use R24
Clamps D - Pos 1 to 15 :
Visual inspection of the assembly and of the
Inspections individual parts (casting, connection plates,
(see IRP 3006 A5) pins)
If marks of impact, same process than clamps
A pos 1 to 5
Protection : touch-up
Repairs Further repair to be defined following
inspections
All bolts used on CN 31 are rejected and
Bolts
replaced
Nota : Each component will be keep together and put aside for inspection.
Report of site inspection will be issued for each component (except bolts). It indudes pictures before and after
disassembling.
In case of further inspections, an NCR will be opened.
Page 32 of 96
BCP_FREY_|RP_3006_A - Inspection plan for Net R31.xte
spc%ea ion JOJ UB|d uofpedsui - v 900E~dbfABdrfdOa 96 jo oBBd
A8||OJi/punoj6 Aenoj} fo||OJ}

jsiueq BuiijiL) punoiB Ouijjim punojB 6ui)i!n punojS 6u!iiim BuWIM punoje Bui arm punojB BU|ABM
o;qeo joddn lesposjoMon l diuep jeMo~| Z durep jeMon E diuep jewon V diuep jbmoi 9 duiBp jeMon
(/) sabeiuep pue sajjnos /eyudjod 'Z &Bd

OTOZ Jaqtuaosa pj uo bupjn Buunp ||ej. 6u!MO||Oj :uose3
OTOZ Jaqujaosa S-fr uorpadsuj JO 9)60 IE* #13N
lauissxaud
aovid oa TE13N
NVTd NOULD3dSNI
96 jo f oBBd
SNOLLDfUllSNI ONV SlN3WnDOQ NOI133dSNI

:WBd
sbbt 381
OTOc* JaquJ9D9a PJ uo 6uuj!| 6uunp ||bj 6u!MO||oj :uoseay

ley #i3N
xauissAaud
aovid oa T3N
NVld NOLLHdSNI
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssiner
NET# R31 Date of inspection
INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - Al: Full Locked Cable inspection
Lower cable FC31-L-2
Defect type Defects Ref picture

Details;
Coating damage NO YES
Details;
Undiped wires NO YES
Details:
Residual
NO YES
Deformations
Details;
Other observations
Conclusion on Lower cable FC31-L-2
Sample
Note: Inspection by Geobrugg required for all the cables CHECKED BY:
Page 35 of 96
96 jo Q a6Bd
ajdiues
soinpfd Z1TDJ 9/qej jbmoj

uogttXKtn 8RB5 popsi ||HJ! TV - dodfi 3HI dUttaU HOTB33SWI
OIOZ J3qui9Daa pj uo 6ui:y!| 6uunp ||bj 6u!MO||cy :uoseay

uoppodsui jo 9)ea fey # 13N
xauissAddd
aovid oa TCJL3N
luodara NOuoadSNi
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31 Date of inspection 6 December 2010
INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - A2 : Hanger Cables inspection
Hangers dismantled
Sockets
and pins Rope Ref picture Conclusion
(coating and (wires, straightness)
shape)
Cable bent and

OK opened on male FR31H01-001/002 To be replaced
Hanger FR31H01
socket side
Use as is
Hanger FR31H02 OK OK after Geobrugg's assesment
Use as is
Hanger FR31H03 OK OK
after Geobrugg's assesment
Use as is
Hanger FR31H04 OK Minor coating damage after Geobrugg's assesment
OK Cable opened FR31H05-001/002 To be replaced

Hanger FR31H05
Hanger FR31H06 not inspected yet/pending lowering of net
not inspected yet/pending lowering of net

Hanger FR31H07
Hanger FR31H13 Sam pie not inspected yet/pending lowering of net
General Minor coating damage can be repaired per usual process (cold spray galvanised or ZRC rich paint)
Paytj 37 uf 90
96 jo 9C oBBd
(djnp/d sd6eujep) pa/jueuisip sjabuen
0102 JaquraJdci p->e uo bucyn BGjJnp [jlj BQJMOJjol :uosea^
OJOZ jaquiaoaa 9 uogoddsu; jo ajerj IC* # UN
xauissxaud
aovnd oa TEJL3N
modau NOiioadSNi
96 jo 6 96Bd
rofl =A9 Q3>D3HD sajeid pue sdeo 'bupseo uoperapisuco 0}uj sa>je} uorpadsui :sjon
loquco Aj}3Ui036 -
g~0T0T"VDS"A3yd"dDa uooejupads jad se 6upsac| iw pue in -
OXOZ Jaqujaaaa VM. uo 6uRse|qpues joj juas -
:(0S0O^DN~A=&fcTcD8 *DN P) ucfleoijipaoaj jo ssaaoid japun si dujeo -
uoppadsui lensjA jaye asn jo uoppiqsai on -

papapp spajap jofeiu ou :uorpadsui lensjA -
1T0HTDJ diuep J3MO/ uo uo/snpuoj
J9M10
spjsg
a|dtues S3A ON S9A00JD
'.S|lelarj
ejnpjd jag spajaa adAipajaa
paaueiustp 1T0HTDJ diuep JdMOj
punoj6 uo uopjsod diuep oj

anp papaqp aq iou p|noD (speui paj) }uaiuu6!|e |ejuozuoH - ajqeo uo uopjsod
(s>ueiu ypefO 5jo iuaiuu6||e |eu!proj.6ucq -
S3A ON UOflBUlJOpQ
Isjlejad
Z00-1I0HIEH (eaie peiuco) 6upseo pue aje|d 53^ ON spoqs

T00-1I0HXOJ aiqeAoui qaie pap cq abeiuep jow w
S3A ON a6eiuep fkigeoo

aaajd aqa uo sarjeujep lepyjadns
ejnpjd ley spajao adAjpajaa
a/qej uo U0HTDJ diuep JdMOj
aoTpsanq sanrep wwai; e? - sure 381 aaosra woTBaaswi

010c" Jaqtusoaa pJe uo 6upj}| Buunp ||6j 6u|MO|pj ruoseay
OIOZ jaqujaoaa 9-S-fr uoipodsui jo aea xey #13N
xauissxaud
aovid oa TE13N
lUOdsRI NOUL33dSNI
96 jo Of oBBd
(sajnpid/ejauab) 1T0HTDJ diuep JdMOj
OoTPHBD] saimp jomoi 2 v - grjoe SHI 98533S RoIDaaSRI
0T03 J8qui9Daa pJC uo fJupjH Buunp ||ej 6u!MO||oj :uoseay

OTOZ Jaqujsoaa 9-S-fc uojpadsuj jjo bjbq ley #13N
xauissAadd
aovid oa TC13N
IHOd3H NOLDHdSNI
96 jo |,f 96Bd
aidtue
(sajnpid sadeiuep ) 1T0HTDJ diuep ja/woj
(sajnpidlejauad) 1J0HTDJ diuep Jd/noj

ooipRHro] sanrep jshoti: gv - 99BE 381035333 RoTBaaSNI
0103 J9qui8D8a pje uo 6ucy{| 6u|jnp ||ej 6u!mo||oj :uoseou
0103 Jaqujaoaa g-s-t, uocpadsui jjo ejea IZH #13N
xauissAadd
aovid oa TC13N
JHOdSlf NOLiOSdSNI
INSPECTION PLAN
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssmeT
NET# R31
j,r,p 300$ - A4; NPT Terts on lower damps i to 5
Lower damps position 1 to 5 shall be inspected according to the fabrication

specification (Ref: SCA_1010 - rev B), as follow:
- UT Inspection of the body of the casting as per ASTM A609M for quality level 1
- MPT eamlnation of the surface of the casting as per ASTM A903M.
Quality levels of acceptance are accodlng to the following sketch:

h Red: level 1 (can not be controlled as the plates are now welded)
Green (cable grooves): level 2
White (rest of the surface): level 3
- UT inspection of the two welds as per W59 - level 11
- Geometrical control of the assembly, specially the flatness and coplanarity of the welded elements
damps to be controlled have the following marking numbers:

- FC31H01L
- FC31H02L
- FC31H03L
- FC31H04L
- FC31H05L
Page 42 of 96
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31 Date of inspection
INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - A5 : Upper damps inspection
Upper clamp FC31H01U on cable

Details:
Coating damage NO YES
Details:
Shocks NO YES
Details:
Deformation of the
NO YES
assembled damp
Sanjiple
Alignment on cable
Upper clamp FC31H01U dismantled

Part Defects Ref picture
Details:
Groves NO YES
Details;
Deformation of YES
NO
individual elements
Perils:
Other
observations
Conclusion on Upper clamp FC31H01U \
Note: Inspection take in consideration the 4 casting parts, the connection plates, and the pins.
CHECKED BY:
Page 43 of 96
96 jo frfr sBBd
(sajnpid sabeiuep ) niOHTDJ diuep jaddp
ajdaies
(sajn&id lejaudb) nTOHTDJ diuep jaddp

uiSR35aiO] saurep ssaan s 5V - 30o aai 0HS538 RoTBaaSNX
0T03 Jsqujaoaa pje uo 6ucy!| Buunp ||b; 6u!mo||oj ruosesy
OTOZ Jaqujsoaa S-fr uoppadsui jo &\eq raj #3N
xauissAadd
aovid oa T3N
iaOd3 NOLLD3dSNI
Steve Lingenfelter
From: David Campbell [dmc@geigerengineers.com]
S e n t : W e d n e s d a y, D e c e m b e r 0 8 , 2 0 1 0 3 : 0 6 P M
To : Dan Bock
Cc: Karen Lynch
Subject: Re: Cable net Incident - Damage to Building or Cable net
Dan:
We have not been requested by PCL to review anything regarding cablenet incident as of yet. My
understanding is that Christoph was contemplating a site visit this week in any event. Geiger did not ask him to
make the trip to review the R31 net components nor did SBP inform us of any such intent.
When and if we are asked to perform inspections otj 8n. _____ we

would consider such effort as additional services. We will not provide such services without PavCo's prior
explicit approval. For reference, as the issue will likely arise, per diem would be, g ^ (If
they want to reuse the cables and they need close inspection, we would probably Save jyaiii Udssett oi ouTomce
look them over. His per diem would bj|^ ~~]More than likely there would be some time in the office
reviewing documentation, which is better billed on an hourly basis, in addition to on site work.
Thanks and Best Regards,
David M. Campbell P.Eng.
Geiger Engineers
2 Executive Blvd. Suite 410
Suffern, NY 10901
t 845.368.3330x11
f 845. 368.3366
m 845. 729.1063
dmc@qeiQerenqineers.com
On Dec 8,2010, at 4:28 PM, Dan Bock wrote:
We've asked you all to not work for PCL and Subcontractors directly. I appreciate this is a bit of emergency but no one
has approached Pavco for additional services so I can only assume you are performing activity on the Cable Net Incident
as part of your base fees. Alternatively if you are planning on submitting an additional services claim, please confirm
asap with a per diem proposal so we can put PCL on notice.
David I believe Christophe has made a special trip here to view the damaged cable net so these disbursements as a
minimum should be tracked separately. I gather there will be some effort involved on assessing the damage to the net.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 661 3648
Cell 604 818 5552
Page 45 of 96
Steve Lingenfelter

S e n t : T h u r s d a y, D e c e m b e r 0 9 , 2 0 1 0 1 : 4 0 P M
To : Martijn Lunneker
Cc: Christoph Paech; Dan Bock; Andy Tallentire; Lome Ebenal; Michael Halajian; James
Outerbridge; Karen Lynch; Kevin Lindsey; SBP; Laurenz Kosichek; rajinder.warraich@stant
Warraich
Subject: Re: BC Place - Cable Net R31 Inspection report proposal
Importance: High
Martijn:
We have reviewed the inspection program for the R31 cablenet components. We have not yet had the
opportunity to review this with SBP. We may have specific comments pending our review with SBP.
That said, in our view the checklist is and inspection plan is good as far as it goes. We see the key being the
review of the cables and the assessment of those which have been damaged as to whether can be employed in
the work or are to be replaced. We assume Geobrugg's representative will be making an assessment for
Structal/ Freyssinet. Note there is no reason to involve us should you and your subs decide to replace the
damaged cables with new assemblies. If the affected cables are proposed to employed in the Work, we note the
following:
1. We will want to see a written assessment from Geobrugg indicating any repairs required and an unqualified
certification that the repaired cable assemblies meet the specified requirements.
2. We will perform our own review and assessment, Please note this is not a service covered in the scope of
our agreement with PavCo and we will request additional fees for the time and expenses involved.
3. We reserve the right to make the final determination of the acceptability of use of any damaged (repaired or
otherwise) components in the structure. Our standard is that the (repaired) cables employed in the Work
perform as specified, essentially as new.
Anticipate the same approach to the castings and hardware. However, we note that the testing proposed should
be reasonably definitive. Key is the absence of cracks or permanent deformation, We suggest that all clamp
bolts of the castings subjected to impact should be replaced. Similarly the D clamp link pins should be replaced
where they were subject to impact.
Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions.

Geiger Engineers
Suffern, NY 10901
t 845. 368.3330 x 11
f 845. 368.3366
m 845. 729.1063
dmc(5)qeiqerenqineers.com
Page 46 of 96
On Dec 8,2010, at 11:00 AM, Martijn Lunneker wrote:
David and Christoph,
We have requested Freyssinet to outline their plan for inspection of the elements on cable net R31 that was involved in
the incident last Friday.
Please review and provide any comments or concerns you may have.
We are currently focusing on the installation of R14 and are trying to get confirmation to install R15 after this. This will
hopefully buy us the necessary time to deal with R31.
The next cable net that needs to be installed after R14 and R15 will be R31. We cannot skip this one and continue with
R32 since we will not be able to make the pin connections at the node side at R31 at a later date.
Pins at the node can only be made in a pre-determined sequence because of space restrictions.
First priority would therefore be to get confirmation and approval to use elements from R06 and R24 to re-built cable
net R31.
As noted by Freyssinet the only elements that currently cannot be substituted are the A and B clamps.
Pending your comments on this proposal Freyssinet has therefore started inspection of these clamps.
Don't hesitate to ask for any information that you require in addition.
Regards,

BC Place - 777 Pacific Blvd, Vancouver
Tel: (604) 673-4300 (Direct 4323) | Fax: (604) 673-4301
A member of the PCL family of companies
Watch us build at www.pcl.com
This e-mail (including any attachments) is for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential Information which may be protected by
legal privilege. If you are not the intended recipient, please immediately notify us by reply e-mail or by telephone 604-241-5200, delete this e-maH and
destroy any copies. Thank you.
File: 2200906- 4:051000
<BCP_FREYJRP_3006_A - Inspection plan for Net R31 .pdf>
Page 47 of 96
Steve Lingenfelter
From: Martijn Lunneker [Lunneker@pcl.com]

S e n t : M o n d a y, D e c e m b e r 2 0 , 2 0 1 0 3 : 5 0 P M
To : D a n B o c k ; ' D a v i d C a m p b e l l '
Cc: 'Karen Lynch'; 'Hillary Oliver'; 'Laurenz Kosichek"; James Outerbridge; Jane O'Flaherty
Subject: BC Place - Submittal: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger
cables, and end sockets
Dan,
PCL/Structal will be putting forward and insurance claim for this incident.
Consultant cost would be part of this claim.
We appreciate your instruction to Geiger to advance their review.
We can review whether PavCo would invoice PCL directly or whether PCL would add this to the claim on PavCo's behalf.
For the record PCL will put Structal on notice that these cost are forthcoming.
Regards,

Tel: (604) 673-4300 (Direct 4323) | Fax: (604) 673-4301
File: 2200906-
From: Dan Bock [mailto:DBock@bcpavco.com1

Sent: Monday, December 20, 2010 1:18 PM
To: 'David Campbell'; Martijn Lunneker
Cc: 'Karen Lynch'; 'Hillary Oliver"; Michael Halajian; Marc Narduzzi; 'Laurenz Kosichek'; Martijn Lunneker; James
Outerbridge; Jane O'Flaherty
Subject: RE: FYI - BC Place - Submittal: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and
end sockets
David thank you adhering to the protocol that Pavco requested. We would like Geiger to review this, if you can estimate
your time and cost involved that would be preferable. We would be prepared to have Geiger do this on a per diem basis
as well. You are authorized to proceed.
Martijn - Pavco will be approaching PCL or the insurers for cost of this review by Geiger. I'm not sure if you will
confirming an insurance claim or not.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 661 3648
Cell 604 818 5552
From: David Campbell rmailto:dmc(aqeigerenqineers.com1

Sent: December 20, 2010 1:13 PM
To: Martijn Lunneker
Cc: Karen Lynch; Hillary Oliver; Michael Halajian; Marc Narduzzi; Laurenz Kosichek; Martijn Lunneker; Dan Bock;
2200906 - James Outerbridge
Page 48 of 96 1
Subject: Re: FYI - BC Place - Submittal: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and
end sockets
Martijn:
Per previous email correspondence, review of the the R31 cablenet is outside the scope of our agreement with
PavCo for the project. This "submittal" will not be reviewed pending authorization to proceed with the services
associated with such review and evaluation.

Geiger Engineers
Suffern, NY 10901
t 845.368.3330x11
f 845. 368.3366
m845. 729.1063
dmc@qeiqerenqineers.com
On Dec 16,2010, at 8:08 PM, 2200906 - James Outerbridge wrote:
22009Q6
Submittals Received: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and
Click HERE to view CS 215 - Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and end sockets.pdf Click HERE to take
Content Type Submittal Item
Name CS 215 - Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and end sockets.pdf
Submittal # CS215
Spec Section 05191
Revision #
Description CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and end sockets
Media Type Electronic
Contributor Structal, Heavy Cons (D. Renaud)
Review Stage Submitted for Review
Assigned To Geiger Engineers (K. Lynch)
Send Alerts To Geiger Engineers (K. Lyndi);New Cable Submittal Group;PCL Const Westcoast (J. Outerbridge);PO. Const Westcoast (M. Lunnek
Contributor Due
From Contributor 12/16/2010
To Reviewer 12/16/2010
Page 49 of 96
96 jo OS 96ed
(teuia ssifl cq Appaiip Ajdaj jou oq
a6puqja^no saiuer. Aq wd 80:S 0X02/9I/2I payipow 3sei
s|U3uiUMo srqe)S
IN Wd
leAOJddy
opfcUL
eseifd
siepwso UO|S|A|a
uado sraets
N aiqeoxy sja^pos pua pue 'sajqeD jacueu. 'sajqea jsmoi 3 jaddn sift jo vodai uojpadsui laups/teJd paipene am MajAaj aseaid S)U9UIUI03
sdmtieM
psuuqou
J8W9tAeb UIOJJ
ITOZ/fr/l end J9M9JA9U

Steve Lingenfelter

S e n t : Tu e s d a y, D e c e m b e r 2 8 , 2 0 1 0 9 : 5 8 A M
To : Dan Bock
Cc: Martijn Lunneker; Karen Lynch; Michael Halajian; Marc Narduzzi; Laurenz Kosichek; Jane
O'Flaherty
Subject: Re: FYI - BC Place - Submittal: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables,
hanger cables, and end sockets, 208054-19
Dan:
We anticipate our fee for review of this matter will not exceed $3k. We anticipate completing this service this
week.

Geiger Engineers
Suffern, NY 10901
t 845.368.3330x11
f 845. 368.3366
m845. 729.1063
dmc(a>qeiqerenqineers.com
On Dec 20,2010, at 4:18 PM, Dan Bock wrote:
David thank you adhering to the protocol that Pavco requested. We would like Geiger to review this, if you can estimate
your time and cost involved that would be preferable. We would be prepared to have Geiger do this on a per diem basis
as well. You are authorized to proceed.
Martijn - Pavco will be approaching PCL or the insurers for cost of this review by Geiger. I'm not sure if you will
confirming an insurance claim or not.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 6613648
Cell 604 818 5552
From: David Campbell [mailto:dmc@geiQerenQineers.coml

Cc: Karen Lynch; Hillary Oliver; Michael Halajian; Marc Narduzzi; Laurenz Kosichek; Martijn Lunneker; Dan Bock;
2200906 - James Outerbridge
Subject: Re: FYI - BC Place - Submittal: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and
end sockets
Martijn:
Page 51 of 96
Per previous email correspondence, review of the the R31 cablenet is outside the scope of our agreement with
PavCo for the project. This "submittal" will not be reviewed pending authorization to proceed with the services
associated with such review and evaluation.

Geiger Engineers
Suffern, NY 10901
t 845. 368.3330 x 11
f 845. 368.3366
m 845. 729.1063
dmc(5)qeiqerenqineers.com
On Dec 16,2010, at 8:08 PM, 2200906 - James Outerbridge wrote:
22009.06
Submittals Received: CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and
Click HERE to view CS 215 - Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and end sockets.pdf Click HERE to take
Content Type Submittal Item
Name CS 215 - Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and end sockets.pdf
Submittal # CS215
Spec Section 05191
Revision #
Description CS 215 -Inspection of cable net R31 upper and lower cables, hanger cables, and end sockets
Media Type Electronic
Contributor Structal, Heavy Cons (D. Renaud)
Review Stage Submitted for Review
Assigned To Geiger Engineers (K. Lynch)
Send Alerts To Geiger Engineers (K. Lynch);New Cable Submittal Group;PCL Const Westcoast (J. Outerbridge);PCL Const Westcoast (M. Lunnek
Contributor Due
From Contributor 12/16/2010
To Reviewer 12/16/2010
Reviewer Due 1/4/2011
From Reviewer
Page 52 of 96
96 jo S e6ed
'lieuia sup oj Appaiip A|dai y>u oa
36pijqj9}no sauief Aq wd 80-S 0T02/9I/ZT psyipow }sei
siu8uiuio3 srqets
1W Nd
IBAOiddv
apeix
asetfd
S|E13W SO uopiAia
uado snms
N siqeD joj sppos pua pue 'safqea jaBueij 'sajqea j3M0| 9 -Bddn em P vodai uofpadsui jaujssAay paupene aifl m9|a3j aseaid S)uauiui03
sdnHjeM
pauiiqou
Steve Lingenfelter
From: Dan Bock
S e n t : M o n d a y, J a n u a r y 0 3 , 2 0 11 1 : 1 9 P M
T o : R o y P a t z e r ; B r i a n G r i f fi n
Subject: FW: BC Place Phase 2 Roof Cablenet R31 Cable Damage Assessment - Geiger Review
Attachments: R31 Damage - Cable Evaluation-10.12.28.pdf; ATT00001 ..htm
FYI re damaged cables at R31 after the dropping incident. Note that Geiger have OK'd their reuse. Separate emails to
follow on upper clamp and lower clamp condition after the incident.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 661 3648
Cell 604 818 5552
From: David Campbell [mailto:dmc(aqeiaerengineers.com]

Sent: December 29, 2010 7:34 AM
Cc: martin.duroyon(a)freyssinet.com; brice.letreut(5)freyssinet.com; Michel Lafrance; Dan Bock; Laurenz Kosichek; Lome
Ebenal; Kevin Lindsey; Karen Lynch; Paul Gossen; Hillary Oliver
Subject: BC Place Phase 2 Roof Cablenet R31 Cable Damage Assessment - Geiger Review
Martijn
Please see the attached review of the R31 cable damage assessment report.
Please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any questions. This will posted on the PDC site as well.

Geiger Engineers
Suffem, NY 10901
t 845. 368.3330 x 11
f 845. 368.3366
m 845. 729.1063
dmc(3>qeiqerenqineers.com
Page 54 of 96
G e i g e r G o s s e n H a m i l t o n C a m p b e l l E n g i n e e r s P. C . N e w Yo r k / B e l l i n g h a m
28 December 2010
PCL BC Place Stadium Site Office

777 Pacific Blvd.
Vancouver, BC
Canada (via. email)
Attention: Martijn Lunneker - Project Manger
RE: BC Place, Phase 2 Roof, Division 5 Cables and Castings, Specification Section 05191
R31 Cablenet Damage, Cable Assessment, Submittal No. CS 215
Geiger Engineers* File No. 208054.19
Dear Martijn:
We have reviewed the attached report, "Inspection Report Net 31", prepared by Freyssinet
documenting the damage to the cables in the Grid R31 cable net assembly that fell during lifting
operations on 3 December 2010. We find the re-use of and repairs to the cables and endfittings
proposed to be acceptable. We note that the cold galvanizing of the damage to the cables zinc
wire coating will not offer quite the same service as the wires' zinc coating. That said, the areas
requiring coating repairs are quite limited.
Please do not hesitate to call me should you have any questions or desire more information.
Very truly yours,
Geiger Gossen Hamilton Campbell Engineers, PC

Principal
cc. Laurenz Kosichek - Stantec (email)
Dan Bock - Pavco (email)
Michel Lafrance - Structal (email)
Brice Letreut - Freyssinet (email)
Christoph Paech - SBP (email)
Lome Ebenal, Kevin Lindsey - PCL (email)
Karen Lynch, Paul Gossen - Geiger Engineers
2 Executive Blvd. Suite 410. Suffern, New York. 10901 -4164. tel: 845. 36B. 3330 fax: 845. 368. 3366. www.geigerengineers.com
Page 55 of 96
INSPECTION PLAN
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31
Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010 By: BCN
Checked: MDN
Document ref: BCP_FREY_IRP_3006 Rev: A Approved: BLT
The purpose of this document is to present the inspections performed on the cable net R31 (FLC and
OSS) after the lifting accident (Dec, 3rd 2010). It is organized in four parts.
1. Estimation of the maximum tension on the cables during the accident

In this first part we will evaluate the upper bound of the dynamic forces
on the cables during the incident
2. Freyssinet's inspection reports

This part details the inspections led by Freyssinet
3. Geobrugg's inspection report

This part details the inspection led by Geobrugg.
4. Bander's inspection report

This part shows the result of the MPT performed by Elander on the
sockets
Conclusion:
The inspections performed by Freyssinet, Geobrugg and Elander show that no defects on the cables
and sockets.
Touch-up will be performed as per usual procedure.
The cables are good for use as they are.
On his report, the cable manufacturer confirms his warranty.
Bags 56 af 06
96 P /g aBed
S8|qe3 B\\\ uo uoisua) uinuiixeiu e jo uoiêuiiisg
5QSE an
0X03 Jaqtu9D9a pj uo 6u^!| 6uunp ||ej dujmohoj :uosea>]
IE* #3N
iaUISSA8Ud
30Vld OQ TEJL3N
"'^SSSm^^' NVTd NOLLHdSNI
96 jo 89 96Bd
NDS =A8 Q35D3H3
tusip a6eiuep jou pinoo sajqeo am uo aaioj D|iueuAp aifl }eifl saajuejen6 uoneujflsa s>m :U6|$npUo3
wp|B wp oa ugpuBH romnpreni g^p qohbutto
OTOc" JaqmaDSQ pjg uo Budjji fjuunp [je] 6u!MO(|Od :uosesy

0103 JaquiaDaa IT pue oi '9 uoipedsui jo aqea IZti #J3N
xauissAaud
3DVld OQ TE13N
HOd3H NOXJLD3dSNI
96 jo 69 oBed
syoctej uoipedsui sjauissAajj
:3UBd
900E dm
OIOZ Jaqui93aa PJ uo 6ucy!| Buunp ||ey dujmohoj :uoseay

xey #3N
laUISSABUd
aovid oa Tc i 3 N
"^^^^5^ MVTd NOI133dSNI
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31 Date of inspection 6,10 and 11 December 2010

INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - A2 : Hanoer Cables inspection
Hangers dismantled j
Sockets and
Rope Ref picture Conclusion
pins (wires, straightness)
(coating and shape)
Cable bent and

Hanger FR31H01 OK opened on male FR31H01-001/002 Rope to be replaced
socket side
Use as is
Use as is
Use as is
Hanger FR31H04 OK Minor coating damage
Hanger FR31H05 OK Cable opened FR31H05-001/002 Rope to be replaced
Use as is
Use as is
Use as is
Minor bending near New rope is produced

Hanger FR31H09 OK FR31H09-001/002
fitting at male side Old one can be kept as spare.
Use as is
OK Use as is
Hanger FR31H11 OK
New rope is produced

Hanger FR31H12 OK Minor bending FR31H12-001/002 Old one can be kept as spare.
Major bending/opening
Hanger FR31H13 OK FR31H13-001/002 Rope to be replaced
on female side
OK Use as is
Hanger FR31H14 OK
Hanger FR31H15 N/A N/A Use as is (tension rod is assembled after lifting)
Hangers inspected with Geobrugg's representative on 11 December 2010.

General Minor coating damage can be repaired per usual process (cold spray galvanised or ZRC rich paint)
Socket and pin on rejected ropes to be used on new ropes.
CHECKED BY: ECU
Page 60 of 96
96 jo 1,9 aBed
(t) (dJnpid sabeiuep) pa/jueius/p sjabuen

OTOc" Jaqtuaoaa PJ uo 6uruj| 6uunp ||ej 6u!M0||Oj :uoseay
OTOZ Jaqiuaoaa 01 pue 9 uoppadsu] jo ajea XZH ~#3N
lauissxadd
aovid oa T3N
*iOd3U NOLLD3dSNI
96 JO Z9 96Bd
fDfl =A3 Q3)03HD
(Z) (ajnioid) (ajeds joj) pa/juews/p sjabue/J
0T0Z JaquiSDaa PJ uo f3ucy!| 6uunp ||ej 6uiMO||cy :uoseaa
OIOZ Jaqiuaoaa 01 pue 9 uocpadsuj jo aaerj !* #13N
xauissAddd
3DVld OQ TE13N
JL)IOd3tt NOIlDadSNI
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssmeT
NET# R31 Date off inspection 10,13 and 14 December 2010

Lower cable FR31-L-1

Details:
Minor surface coating damages. Cable
Coating damage NQ YES still presents galfanisation protection. #5 to 18
Details:
All undiped wires observed after the
Undiped wires NO YES fell went back in position with
straightening of cable.
Details:
Residual
Deformations NO YES
Details;
Minor surface coating damages.
Sockets NO YES MPT was performed by Elander on # 1, 2, 3,4
these areas. No indication found
Details;
Other observations
Conclusion on Lower cable FR31-L-1

Cable visually inspected with Geobrugg's representative on 13th and 14th December 2010.
Sockets and threaded rod do not present any major damage.
Special socket does not present any major damage.
Minor coating damage can be repaired per usual process (cold spray galvanised or ZRC rich paint)
Use as is.
Note: Validation letter by Geobrugg endosed CHECKED BY: BCU /BCN / MDN
Page 63 of 96
96 jo PQ a6Bd
jrainpid Eainpid
spsqs itrensg Boppsqs - osfpsasai dw
Z ainpid i ainpu
PSSPSIP BS3B alft J6 Uot)jUU&d - UdtpadsUj. JJR
sojnpid sjayjos - T-l-lVJ a/qeaja/uioj

(rappsasni sppQ pwpî pa: ?v - sots an oassas nonsaasRi
0103 J9qiU9D9rj pj uo Bupjn Buunp ||bj DUJMO|jdj :uosesy
010c* Jaquiaoaa t uoppadsui |o eiea Iel #JL3N
xauissAaud
aovid oa TEJJN
lUOd3U NOUOadSNI
96 JO 99 3BBd
8 ajnpjd L ainpy
nuBBBiOTOB m&m nns - gn gwp raflPPa tt isrerop bohbb3
9 ainpid S ainpu
OSPpRpqifll HU55SR] HffS - TO BBP uOft|sod - fa# 5BW0BP bUt|eoD
SDinpij siJVd DU - r-7IMJ 9/qeD JdMOj
PSlFWgoi gp|g pwpgl TO! tV - 966 m 085538 nTOBSBSnI
0102 J9quia3aa PJ uo 6upj!| Buunp ||e.| 6u!MO||cy :uoseay

Oioz jaquKoarj pue et '01 uoipadsu| jo 3)ea TOl #13N
xauissAaud
aovid oa T3N
UOd3H NOLLD3dSNI
96 JO 99 aBBd
Z\ ainpld Tl ainpid
U6ftK|Uej|eb SHRBSRI ||R - bti BSSp 09RPB3 - fra SOTTOTCp buqeo^
OT ajnpid 6 ainpid
ngmpraw qassgra fffig - ero pro ZCH osgnqsq nggpsa - cd# sbwbbp wpwa
soinpid sved DU - I-l-IEVJ 9/qeD ja/uoj
ooTPsasm gppg pBfWri iinj a Tv - ggge aai agcaaE ngcoaasHi
OTOZ JaquiaDarj pj uo 6upj|| 6uunp |jej 6u|MO||cy :uoseay
OTOZ Jaqurasaa H pue T 'OT UORDOdsU| JO Djerj X>1 #13N
xauissAaud
BOVld OQ TEJL3N
lUOdaU NOLLD3dSNI
96 jo 19 a6Bd
ST ajrrpid H ainpjd
OoHSfOKOVB WfOSSSm ||S - FH WH DSflPSa - 9d #abeude<p B0RS55
Et ajnpid
ussBinraBB spmsni nBS - 591 swromp bdrrq
so.injD/d sjJedDU - T1THJ a/qea ja/v\oj
TORSSasul5RS5 r*^1 ||hj i tV - 406 <M dVIOdÛ NbLLD3d^Nl
0103 JaqiuaDarj pj uo 6u(y!| 6uunp ||bj 6u!MO|joj :uoseau
OTOZ Jaquiaoaa h pue et 'ot uoppedsui jo eqea TOl #3N
XaUISSAddd
BOVld OQ TE13N
UOd3U NOXJL33dSNX
96 jo 89 36Bd
8T ainpid
UOB!UeJ|eb SfOSBSRI ||r4S - PW UdjdJoos
l\ ainpy 9T ainpid
UotWWBJ|eb SpiSma |Rg - SOU J&UV - 999 5BBDJBP BOpBQ
so.iniDid sJjedDU - T-l-ThJ ziaeJ J9moi
osisssaiRii epTO papai ima s w - 90SE asi 989398 Ronsaasni
OTOZ Jaquiaaaa PJ uo BupjH Buunp ||ej Buj/wonaj zuoseau

OTOZ Jaqiuaoaapue et 'OT UOfpodsui jo jeQ I>l # 3N
xauissAadd
BOVHd OQ TEJL3N
lUOdlU NOLLD3dSNI
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31 Date of Inspection 10,13 and 14 December 2010
INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - Al; Full Locked Cable inspection
Lower cable FR31-L-2

Details;
Coating damage NO YES son presents galfanlsation protection. #6 to 11
Details;
All undiped wires observed after the
Undiped wires UQ YES fe|| went back in position with
straightening of cable.
Details:
Residual
Deformations NO YES
Details;
Sockets NO YES MPT was performed by Elander on #1,2,3,4,5
Details;
Other observations
Conclusion on Lower cable FR31-L-2

Sockets and threaded rod do not present any major damage.
Use as is.
^P"69 of 96
96 JO Ol eBBd
O tâinpid campy
SPSQS |DS0B5 Boppaqs - osfpBRai dw
Z 3Jnpid lajnpy
P3>j09ip e^Je" Bin J uotjIUyQd - uotpadsui id W
siayjDos - z-l-IVJ Biqej ja/uoj

uorA^dsui 5R65 pespRH P31 TV - SrJoT S8I aaoDaa NOiiMdSNi
0103 Jaqujaoaa PJ uo 6uLyi| Buunp ||ej Bu!MO||Oj :uoseay
OTOZ JsqujaDaa tf pue ET 'OT uoppadsui jo ajerj Ty #13N
auissAaud
aovid oq TE13N
!UOd3*J NOLLD3dSNI
96 jo tzeBed
6 ainpid 8 ainpkl
orcBHprensB nasm ims nsimn nsraasfl hbbto - Z9i bbrdbp burrs
L ampid 9 ainpid
uo.qKjuejiHb mnnaii m - en tt zh Dsramq QBfflssa - fro BBBurep bdrbss
soinioid siJedDU - Z-l-lUJ aiqei J9moj
33550101BRQ pnp7| ||hd : tV - 59SS 381981038 KI6LL33dSrJl
OTOZ Jaquiaoaa pj uo 6upj!| 6uunp ||ej 6u!mo||oj :uoseau

OTOZ Jsqiuaoarj pue et 'otuocpadsui jo eqeci TO! #13N
XaUISSABcJd
aovid oq TE13N
l*90d3ti NOLLD3dSNI
96 JO ZL 96Bd
H ainpid OT ainpy
UOn|U^|eb SSDBSSRI Hrs - Ffl 3S0B OoUPol - 91 dbeltiep bupeoD
SDinp/d siJed DU - Z-7-TiU îq^ JdMOj
DBBSsaso! S|qB5 psspoi P311V - dobfc 381989S3S 890333581
OTOZ Jaquiaoaa pj uo Bucyn 6uunp ||ej 6u!MO||oj :uosea>j
OTOZ JaquKoarj W pue et 'OT uojpadsui jo sjerj T^ # 13N
XaUISSAdUd
aovid oq TE13N
luodau NOLioadSNi
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssmeT
NET* R31 Date of inspection 10,13 and 14 December 2010
Upper cable FR31-UT

Details:
Coating damage NO YES still presents galfenisation protection. #1 to 17
Details:
DejaJlSi
Residual
Deformations NO YES
Cfitalls:
Sockets NO YES MPT was performed by Elander on #ltol0
Details;
Other observations
Conclusion on Upper cable FR31-UT

Sockets do not present any major damage.
Use as is.
3 of 96
96 jo u a6Bd
gajnpid Sainpid
frampid
Z aJnpi.d T
11 n ainpjd
BOPPBip pile B93B M**o U6ft|Ul^d - uob>adSiIl JJJR
so/rip/d sjayjDOS - Iri-TtiU d/qea jaddp
DSffSBOBul a|o.eo pÔI ||nd : TV - 900 381989938 NOilMdSNI
OTOZ Jaqujaoaa PJ uo 6ury!| 6uunp ||e\j 6u!mo||oj ruoseoy
OTOZ JaquraDaa \,\ pue et 'OT uoppadsu] jo ajBQ TO) #JL3N
xauissAaud
aovid oq TEJJN
lUOd3U NOLL33dSNI
96 jo 91 eBBd
OTSunpid 6ainPkJ
SpSip IBSOBg
Sajnpid âjnpu
PSDUTJB Z DODBol - uonfcDadsUj. idW
sojnjj/d sjayaos - n-IUJ ^/qeD jaddp
aorpOTU] spre PP1 B"3! tV - $do 381989338 NOLLD3dSNi
0T03 JaqtuaDaa pJ uo 6ujy!| 6uunp ||ej 6u!MO||oj :uoseay
OTOZ JaqujaDsa H pue T 'OT uorpadsui JO ajBQ T* #3N
XaUISSAddd
BOVld OQ TEJL3N
lUOd3H NOLL33dSNI
96 jo 9Z sBBd
^ f fl l l
H ajnpid ET ainpid
O
1 ubiij^Siuêb sûaSfeiti ||B$ - ZH TH Uaawqaq u6tjiS6d - a# abeuiep bu.qt^D
73
ZI ainpid TT ainpid
ooifnqinmBB >uasajd w& - th 9 jwpw osszeqsq nsspss -191 bbbuibp burrs
sojnjD/d siJed DU - Ifl-lVJ 9/qea Jaddp
OTjpsasoi S|qB5 pnpoi pi! tV - 90SS 38198(5538 8913333581
0T03 JaqtuaDaa pj uo Buoj| Buunp ||ej Bujmohoj :uoseay
OTOZ -laquiaoaa h pue et 'OT uoppedsui jo ajerj TO! #13N
XaUISSAdUd
aovnd oq TE13N
l*!Od3ti NOLL33dSNI
96 jo LL 3BBd
L\ ajnpid 9T ainpid
oasopraBB 5)uas9Jd hrs - apBa ooibhbs - abeuiep borrepj
ST ajnpid
Uoftesjuejjeb qOBSSRI IRES - 38 5 3SP&B UaoMjaa; uOgBOd - ed# obeiUBp BU|)b63
s*/fitf J7z/ - M-TiU 9/qea jaddp
DSRSSBTO] BpfBS PWPOl HnJ! tV - 9BBE 381982038 89EI3333RI
OTOZ JaqLU939Q pj uo 6ucyj| Buunp ||ej 6u!aao||oj :uoseay
OTOZ -laqujaoao H pue ET 'OT uorpsdsui jo 9JBQ TQI #3N
xauissAaud
aovid oq TE13N
JLUOdaU NOLDHdSNI
INSPECTION REPORT
NET 31 BC PLACE
FReyssineT
NET# R31 Date of inspection 10,13 and 14 December 2010
INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - Al; Full Locked Cable inspection
Upper cable FR31-UB

Details;
Coating damage NO YES still presents galfanisation protection. #7 to 11
Detail?;
Details;
Residual
NQ YES
Deformations
Details;
Sockets NO YES MPT was performed by Elander on #lto6
Details;
Other observations
Conclusion on Upper cable FR31-UB

Cable visually inspected with Geobrugg's representative on 13 December 2010.
Sockets do not present any major damage.
Use as is.
Page 78 of 96
96 jo 61 96ed
gainpid sainpid
vajrtpid Eajnpu
Z aunpid i ajnpu
BDPfSBip pue esan sons o&ppgsg - BoTpsasni dW
sojnp/d siayjos - gn -ThJ zjqea jaddp
QBffSStBui SRB5 p>oi ||ry: tv - dfldfe 381989538 NbUb3d$Ni
0T03 J9qui9D9Q pj uo 6ujy!| 6ujjnp ||Bj 6u!MO||oj :uoseay
OTOZ Jaqiuaoaa w pue ET 'OT uoppodsui jo ajBQ IOJ #13N
XdUISSAdUd
aovid oq TE13N
mod=ra NOiioadSNi
96 jo 08 oBBd
II ainpid
osppBpqpB igasnaa ims - 558 * 38 BBBmsq Qoup&a - 95 BBnmp BOgBSS
Oi ajnpjd 6 3Jnp!d
i^l
^^5181
* ^
i / -4^
8 ainpy Z ainpid
u6j)&idejjeb sÛa^BJd [|B - 5PeH UoldJcog - BbBUiep B0RBB5
soinjDjd svedDU- ffll-TiUîqeajaddn

OoTOBWl BWP PWPÎ Hnj! tv - gfldfe 381989538 890333381
OTOZ JaqiuaDaa pj uo Buryu Bujjnp ||ej Bujaaouoj :uoseay
OTOZ J3qUJ3D3a K PUB T 'OT UOtpodSUI |Q OJBQ TD1 #13N
aUISSA3dd
aovid oq TCJL3N
Od3H NOLLD3dSNI
96 jo L8*0Bd
jjodaj uoipadsui s.BBmqoa^
3)
9Q9E 381
OTOZ Jaqiuauaa pj uo 6upj|| 6uunp ||bj 6u|mo||oj :uoseau
Ty #13N
xauissAaud
BOVld OQ TE13N
NVld NOLLDSdSNI
A\
Te s t r e p o r t
P09-500803 - Stadium Vancouver (BC Place)
Visual rope tests
Customer: Freyssinet International & Cie

1 bis rue du Petit Clamart
BatimentC-BP135
78148 Velizy-Villacoublay Cedex
France
Test reason: Incident during the erection of Grid 31

o
Test object:
Date of issue: 15. December 2010

m
Geobrugg AG Rope architecture Aachstrasse 11 CH-8590 Romanshom

Telephone: +41 (0)71 466 81 55 Fax: +41 (0)71 466 81 50 info@geobrugg.com www.geobrugg.com
A company of the BRUGG group
Page 82 of 96
96 JO 68 aBBd
1 INTRODUCTION
In order to determine the effects of the falling down of Grid 31 during erection we
did a visual test of the cables and of the fittings. Additionally we measured the
thickness of the remaining Galfan coating at the position where scratches were
found. At the end fittings we did magnetic particle inspection carried out by
Elander Inspection.
Page 84 of 96
P09-500803 - STADIUM VANCOUVER
2 PICTURES DIRECT AFTER THE INCIDENT
Z-wires out of position
Scratches on the ropes
The pictures above where made by Freyssinet right after the incident was happen. Af
ter the cables where moved out of the stadium the wires jump into the right position.

=
in
GEOBRUGG A\
Page 85 of 96
96 jo 98 e6ed
punoj uoiieojpu; ou gjom ojaiji
I
o-p
a\
Q
punoj uoijeoipui ou aie/w ojaiji
uo;padsu| japue|3 Aq
poLjjaui 5jU| >pe|q auj ljjim sjsa; 6uunrj
suorjisod esaifl pajsa}

uoipsdsuj JspuBig pue uoijisod pedum
oiq;ssod ei|) po>ueuj o/w sOui^y, ||e w
s)S9) (uoipadsu; epj+jed oijauBeiu) n/\j
S1S31 - w t
96 jo Z8 96Bd
\r DDnuaoaD
PUU6 9M 9J9UM UOjJISOd 91",

1
O
\e uoflBOjpu; Aue punoj ;,u9J9m 9j9uj_
PUU6 9M 9J9UM UOIJlSOd 9L)(

]euojjeo!pu!_Aue punoj j,u9J9m 9J9lji
PUU6 9M 9J9LJ/W UOglSOd 91",

\e uoi;eojpu! Aue punoj },U9J9m ajeuj.
pgpuuB 6u;uy
U!e6e jsgj pue
owz 9t|) $0 puu6 oj pgpj09p 9/v\ ped
-uij jsjom 9u,j 9)jj| s)jooi z *on osneogg
âAQODNVA PVOIOVIS - 0800C-60d

4 CABLES VISUAL AND GALVANIZATION TEST
Following some of the indicated scratches or little damages at the surface. On

every cable we marked a defect number.
For example upper cable top, defect 1 (UTD1)
Thickness still 60 micro meter. Nominal

about 80. At some spots the thickness
came down to 30 micros.
03
Such scratches are placed on several

places on the cable surface. If they didn't
had a smaller zinc layer we did not count
them.
Page 88 of 96
A
96 jo 68 oBBd
oonuao3D
V
A||npjBo padsui
9M p9U0!J|S0d SBM SdUJB|0 9U.J 9J9Uj\A
tf 3AHCONVA WnidVlS - 080OS-60d

96 jo 06 e6Bd
ti*
punoj6 oqj paipnoj 9|qeo J9M0|

eifl 9J9U.M uorjjsod au,} punojB papg^
-ap 9JB S9j|/y\ aqi uo saBewBp qons
8 P09-500803 - STADIUM VANCOUVER
5 CONCLUSION
Freyssinet International & Cie asked us to check the suspension cables of the
Grid 31. Our conclusions are the following:
- The minor damages found on the cables do not have negative influence
on the cables breaking loads, service loads and lifetime.
- At the indicated locations where the thickness of Galfan was measured
lower as nominal, cold zinc spray shall be applied. The surface will serf-
heal from the cathode/anode effect.
- The fittings were MPT tested and no defects were found.
So the R31 suspension cables and fitting still reach the required mechanical
characteristic (MBL) and the required corrosion protection for the project. As a
consequence, the observed elements have no influence on the warranty on our
products.
CH-8590 Romanshom on 15th of December 2010
S
s
Head of department
Ir--
Markus ZOrcher
A\
Page 91 of 96
96 jo 26 36ed
jjodai uoipadsui s,iapue|3
M6 aSI
OTOZ Jaqujaoaa PJ uo 6upj|| 6uunp ubj 6uimo||oj :uosesy

TO! #13N
18UISSA8Ud
aovid oa TEX3N
^5â^"' NVld NOIOadSNI
Suite 128-11800 River Road,
Elander Inspection LTD. Richmond, B.C. Canada V8X1Z7

Phone: (604)214-1318 Fax: (604)214-1349
E-mail: ElanderiSMnteroBtB.ea
Nondestructive Testing and Marine Inspection ^& Web Page: Elanderlnspectlon.ca
C Llc_
I E N^T : REPORT
f ^ f c OF
Y S SNONDESTRUCTIVE
f^CT P R O J E C EXAMINATION
T NO:
REPORT DATE: tSi-i
Attention: Al frft "0 A/ Û&PYOrS
T E S T D AT E : \ O t C
P.O. NO:
H ,2010
CLIENT'S NO:
REPORT NO:
LOCATION: BC Place CODE: see below
PROJECT: BC Place. New Roof Erection PAGE: 1of
EXAMINATION METHOD
MAGNETIC PARTICLE & LIQUID PENETRANT Q EDDY CURRENT D ULTRASONIC D VISUAL Q
ITEM TESTED: EQUIPMENT: MT: Model; DS300 W Y6S/N:.atJBi44_.ia.1l5_Bl8ckLBht:

^ ^ 1595500*
OPT;Ardrox Visible Red Penetrant, Afdrox Developer
HMT: Parker Probe AC Yoke. DWFMPi, Black light, JSCotor Contest System, Dry Red Powder 3
P(fÔ Ce^HAF ComfitA'&tsTs U uTi___ , )ff Dlamele/ 2,2 5 Mhz Probe; Couplant
C3 Other M^tNxtt r
INSPECTION TECHNIQUE:
Q PT- ASTM E165. Method B, Type 1 INSPECTION CODE:
8 MT-ASTM E709-01 D WFMPI g Black Ink Method Ory Powdor CSAW59-03,Sec.11Ol2| AWS DM Section
D UT-ASTM E114 UfrMomci'uttcraSm^<OTT^ DASME EfOther: S3
MATERIAL: co
FORMING PROCESS: SURFACE CONDITION: 0 Clean; D Machined Surfaces:
OCarbon Steel; QStalntess DForged Shaft: gCasi, J} Wolds; OOlherf 1>
Steel;Q Olher DOther 2
Area Tested DMasi ; Field welds as detailed below:
P e s c r f p t l o n o f Te s t ; "**** *Y A> nftfttfj ZWcH&L7k B)ai/^T/^ J>MY*fl>
Srf^!!ilP!Sr!,nl exaj"S,ton "^ *?ducte,d m !!* J?rt* as described- above; Penetrant was applied to the areas after the component
tiand
SSdried,
*%??*Devetoper
deane(1 S6 waspen?8ntwas altowed
applied and t0 dwe"for15
the parts minu,fes ^ for
visually examined P3*5 were orwaterwashed
cracks to remove
other significant the excessSant
problems, penetrant.
Siwtef<Ji2SSOrtfc ta"aânai ^P^100 was conducted on the areas described above to determine If any cracks or otherobwious reflectors
Test Results
1
IN Attendance N.R J. * No cracks or retevant indicai'ons tound using referenced Inspection technique and acceptance criteria.
TECHNICIAN: Peter D. Gabor ELANDER INSPECTION LTD,

CGSB Level II, MT PTlEJ.UTQ
Cert No. 3845
SNT-TG-1A Level II MT.PT R Allan Elander, Manager, NOT
V
'>
C E RT I F I E D W E L D I N G I N S P E C T I O N O R G A N I Z AT I O N - C S A W 1 7 8 . 1
Page 93 of 96
Suite 128- 11800 River Road,
Richmond, B.C. Canada V6X1Z7
Elander InspectionLm Phone: (604)214-1318 Fax: (604)214-1349
> E-mail: ElandanS>Jnêraa1a,ca
Nondestructive Testing and Marine Inspection qfp Web Page: Etahdertnapectlon.ca
REPORT OF NONDESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION
C U E N T: fftEYSS/MgT TEST D ATEST

T E DATE:_
: ^^ ^ /lP
REPORT DATE:__
PROJECT NO:
PROJECT: BC Place. New Roof Erection PA G E : 1 o f
'
/N st\w n*i r J * & U I r. :; 1
-
A/ en >i
- iroe * t L4& /b
m*
&iP/ *rf ^ 6$. \ - 6 ? A f>e &
-*,u
rJS
L - < ^ A frto
-2. *f M*' 0 * isr G* fcV W^ z ^ - ^ \/ ^ftn-r ^rVj rC H> ft* >/?, A-3rt Vbe4s
j
g
1 ' *!/ < \tt> c$U3 -&& ^ i v t r i t j * \ ROi * / ^ l i ^
"" Hi. rtfr
!#Y" n* ^ 2 it ^ A5 O A *>vt ^ wV f e 6 - j 'S^ 'j . ~/ *L r,fi _J2 ^ ^->-a
i^cia^.
cn>J * ^ 9 z . V-
-*/r li/r* * . * f f ^ K <3> \ u Â- * 1 ^ r V rfr W TH i vs . f r - A - v (0
* * C( J r ^ T> s fl ^ r ef f t MT V / ^ & l .e?v >Ar ts~r l _ * > ^ k l . ^ ^Zsex=!L5: / . u 6 ^
F
f ^
VP- ^ f
m t >t>~i ""TftvK 2 * - 6 ( ^5 i-
> i - 0 > OR. S/ r 6 ! kr> *l& i>.
* 4 7?r <W J f f \ * P* { Z ? ft? <
\ / t 2 ,1 M > f ^ > ' > . t-c tf^ T l (-v r A J ? H r--7 v & S>.
) - 4 v/B rf ^ u e W hr^ 7 " It ^ 9-A T t 5HN fc? & ? & ' / ^ r
[>/ <
> F ^ 3l
Z- I < #H * c cr ( ^ ^
U - r f tf t " n - i W >./* r f t * & r^- 0 <* - V? * A - i xH>
^ 1 - p (s^ ? & ^
f. 2, ^ , H* "A"1 * 1 i tT l " 0 ' ^ A ; T i t - I * ' /
^. / u 9 ' & \ + ' y 5 V A - > j - ; ' Av>/ & \ T7 an- 5 ? ^ > t j**- b .
p <*' * i
J . 7. <5^V 3 c ^ i ; T** >5
U d T>f \ " i 7rf* -f< r"A \r* rV? ^ e-T < ^ f V ^ . ^ ^
/, 5L A-
!>% > ' | i ^P" rv* r-7 ? ^ ^ 5 J r >< ^ c " >& D
* i ~te f L(2T ^ i 5-v ' fi r r*/~ T - $ t - -A' '' dr, r^^ 2< *u - t .
//
1
Name of Ship/Item Tank No Aocatlcn:
LM.O.. Frame No.:
Class No.: Port/Starboard:
Attending Surveyor. Type of test: MT DWFMPI DDry DBIack/White
U T D We l d O U T t h i c k n e s s
PT DPT
T ^ ^ t r
Peter D. Gabor ELANDER INSPECTION LTD.
TECHNICIAN:
CGSB Level II, PT El MT El, UT D
Cert. No. 3845 Allan Elander, Manager, NDT
Consumables:
J
CERTIFIED WELDING INSPECTION ORGANIZATION - CSA W178.1
Page 94 of 96
Suite 128 - 11800 River Road,
Elander Inspection ltd. Richmond, B.C. Canada V6X1Z7

Phone: (604)214-1318 Fax: (604)214-1349
E-mail: Elander&lnteroate.ea
Nondestructive Testing and Marine Inspection 4/? Web Page: EJanderinspoction.ca
REPORT OF NONDESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION
CLIENT: fKeYS/Agr TEST D AT E : '']) Be ^/A-

REPORT DATE:
PROJECT NO:
PROJECT: BC Place. New Roof Erection PA G E : 3 PL-Jl
_^l m
J^*dj\^--lLLX-r
- ^fe-ûv^'iciê-f 6/v Is?* &-*va
- UotfA-r^r^ L_i:^:2E:l_ & fiMAz)*> ~~
~~ i_2 Lj:l\*Jz i-o-idir^t^: *A-&e /^^sc^rirf.h. or
"~ J^CLÂ&'Od^^ZLtez^L^ :Oe2 k:-&>lg___,Ba ***&.
yf 1 r ... ... .. _ _
^Tfc&c^ csi-QciJLj&g*ilrezx:^' de-G-c'- %&*>< j&-& /'^êJLaj/
lJ>L_:&iLZV ** f*eySS~i/*ri ', ^<^^~^^^rL^Lj^2cfe:
J2& A,&AAc?u^ ^LA^C fc^rYtg IpjW,^ t^nfij^ .:^llfllt& 5&
JL^'.-Pftr-rjL^j, I
r Te t * \ 10. A'<?$i't~7. |
H4%.- fvLr\ J
HII+ ,v IL 1
\
J S-4-1""
g r 3 T4.
^sl_jl_
*_Li_.
ztz zt
g _: > i t x z- ^ / L _ ^L r t r zr _^
g3'0- ^^_I_
JrTi'T^F ^V^J_
-R-LX- Z^&.J
tL_j;i3 Av^ ">^; TO*tf>5 ,
S
j
1 Zj
Name of Ship/Item Tank NoAocatton:
I.M.O.: Frame No.:
Class Na: Port/Starboard:
Attending Surveyor Type of test: MT QWFMPI QDry QBtack/White
UT QWeld DUT thickness
0. A/?/ PT DPT
TECHNICIAN: Peter D. Gabor ELANDER INSPECTION LTD.

CGSB Level II, PT El MT, UTD 8
"
Cert No. 3845 Allan Elander, Manager, NOT
Consumables:
;
CERTIFIED WELDING INSPECTION ORGANIZATION - CSA W 178.1

Page 95 of 96
Steve Lingenfelter
From: Dan Bock
S e n t : Tu e s d a y, J a n u a r y 11 , 2 0 11 3 : 1 0 P M
To : Roy Patzer
Cc: Brian G r i f fi n
Subject: Cable Net R26 - Lower radial 100mm too long- Outcome
They have used the components intended for R8 for Installing the net at R26. This shifted the problem from R26 to R8.
They had a spare lower radial on site that it is about 100mm too short for use at R8. To lengthen and use this cable, they
proposed to fabricate longer than normal threaded connector. Geiger and I approved this plan. They expect they can
have this new component on site in 2 weeks.
In the interim they have inventory to continue with CN fabrication and erection at R26,25, R24. They expect to have all
components soon for dropped radial R31 which would allow them to recommence clockwise installation direction.
We lost about a week due to the R26 problem component. Going forward they are working on checking all lengths to
ensure this doesn't surprise us in the future. This is the issue that concerns me most.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 6613648
Cell 604 818 5552
Page 96 of 96
Corporate Headquarter*
.HADE WORLDWIDE, Inc.
V/ett Coait Headquarters
8505A Chn<elloi Row, Dollai, ri 75747 350 Kalmui Drift, Coif a Mtia, (* 97626
P 5I4.905.9SOO f 214.905.9514 Tf 800.966.5005 P 714.427.6981 714.477.6982 It 800.50.SHADI
February 11, 2011
Mr. Martijn Lunneker

Project Manager
Suite 310
13911 Wireless Way
Richmond, BC V6V 3B9
Re: BC Place - Phase 2 - Roof Replacem ent

Subj: Cable Grease
Dear Martijn,
We received the information for the cable grease transmitted in your email of 11-23-10 as well as
the test results from NTB in your 1-17-11 email and forwarded all data to Saint Gobain. B oth Saint
Gobain and ourselves reviewed the information and have concluded the following to date
s17. s13
^
We applied some grease to both the SF I and Fabrasorb fabrics and have concluded that
the grease will most likely permanently stain the both the outer and liner fabrics.
o Photo 1 is of the sam pies with the grease applied for a period of 5 days, note you
can see the grease stain wlcking into the porous Fabrasorb fabric.
o Photos 2 and 3 are of the fabr ic after it was cleaned with water.
o Photo 4 is of the unbleached SF I fabric after it was cleaned with the recommended
cleaning soap (Murphy's Oil Soap). The dark stain indicates the fabric is
permanently stained. We are bleaching the fabric under UV exposure to get a better
sense of the darkening resultant of the staining.
(4
So
BRANDS YOU KNOW STRUCTURES Y O U T R U S T

w va vi . usa-shade.com
SHADE WORLDWIDE, Inc. We i l C u a i t H e a d q u a r t e r *
C o r p o ro i c H e a d q u a rte r-,
8505-A Chn.llor Row. Dailat, IX 75747 350 Kolmui Diiv, Coila Mto, CA 97676
P 714.905.9500 1 714.905.9514 If 800.966.5005 P 7)4.477.6981 I 714.477.6987 If 800.S0.SHADI
Thank you for your attention to this matter, we await your further instruction.
Sincerely,
tl
Bill Schmidt
Project Executive
Shade Worldwide, Inc. branded as FabriTec Structures
Cc: Lome Ebenal, PCL

Martin Brown, SWI
Chris Carraher, SWI
ûr*o'
BRANDS YOU KNOW. STRUCTURES YOU TRUST

v/ ww. u3a-shade.com
rftTTtr*
SAINT-GOBAIN
PERFORMANCE PLASTICS
January 26,2011
Bill Schmidt
USA Shade & Fabric Structures, Inc
8505 Chancellor Row
Dallas, TX 75247
Re: Oil Elaskon SK-A
Dear Bill:
Very truly yours,
Marcel Dery
Market Manager - Architectural
SHEERFILL and FABRASORB are registered trademarks of Saint-Gobain Performance

Plastics Corp.
BC STADIUM ROOF PROJECT
INSPECTION REPORT
LEAKING STATUS OF NET CABLES
REV
INSPECTION REPORT
Rev September 9th 2011
Page 1/14
INSPECTION REPORT
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION 3
1 CORRECTIVE ACTION PERFORMED 3
1.1 INITIAL S TAT U S 3
1.2 NODE / UPPER CABLE 4
13 UPPER CABLE 5
M LOWER CABLE / IET TO CLAMP 14 5
1.5 LOWER CABLE / MAST TO IET 5
2 FURTHER ACTIONS 6
2.1 GUTTERS 6
2.1.1 Lower cable at mast location 6
2.1.2 Cleaning frequency 7
3 MAINTENANCE 11
3.1 CABLE PICTURE MAP 11
3.2 MAINTENANCE PROGRAM 11
3.2.1 Lower cables from clamp 1 to node 11
3.2.2 Gutters and trays 12
3.2.3 Upper Gutters removal 13
4 INSPECTION AND CLEANING CREW 13
4.1 C O N TA C T PERSON 13
5 APPENDIX 14
Page2/14
INSPECTION REPORT
rcv
INTRODUCTION
The full locked cables supplied by our company tend to release some lubricant.
This lubricant is used to conserve the interior steel wires of the cable in order to
protect them against corrosion.
Since two months, the leaking rate tends to decrease, even if, some random
location are still releasing some lubricant
1 CORRECTIVE ACTION PERFORMED
1.1 INITIAL STATUS
Since the beginning of the leaking issue, the status of each cable and the date
of successive cleaning have been recorded.
Based on these data, each cable have been given a note reflecting their
tendency to leak.
The hypothesis was that if a cable is cleaned many times, it means that it is
leaking the most. It is not perfectly accurate as some radials (especially radials
8, 9 and 10) have been dealed with more often due to first installation of fixed
and retractable membranes to avoid drop hits on the first panels. However, due
to the extensive cleaning and number of data recorded, the note reflect correctly
the tendency.
The note has been ponderated, based on the cleaning/ protection method used.
For instance, the upper cables have an higher note as they had to be wrapped
in absorbent pad which was not the case for the lowers. Equivalent ponderation
have been applied to sockets area and lower points (mast, node).
The highest the note is, the more, the related cable was leaking.
Since the end of July most of the cable stop to leak and / or decreased their
leaking rate. Except at specific and isolated area, they are now quite
homogenous. Then the graph below shall be considered as a initial leaking
status illustration only and not current behaviour:
Page 3/14
GEOBRUGG* A\ INSPECTION REPORT
During the cleaning period, some corrective actions have been implemented in
order to contain the drops or to avoid that the accumulating drops fall off the
cable. These actions are described below.
1.2 NODE / UPPER CABLE
At the node area some trays have been installed below the socket to
collect lubricant.
On the upper top and upper bottom cables some gutters have been
installed to collect lubricant.
Those area are then secured and the retractable membrane is protected from
lubricant drop while folded in garage.
Page 4/14
GEOBRUGG* INSPECTION REPORT
13 UPPER CABLE
All the upper top and upper bottom cable have been equipped with
gutters
Those area are then secured. However some clamps (less than 0,1%) still need
some action. The caulking needs to be reinforced to ensure a 100% sealing.
This is monitored on a daily basis by our team, in order to identify any default.
The first heavy rains that occurred after gutter installation showed the good
behaviour and efficiency of drainage system.
1.4 LOWER CABLE / IET TO CLAMP 14
This area is, so far, the best in term of leaking. Very few spot has been noticed
during these last 50 days. It is noticeable that the summer months have been
quite warm (2113 average) and sunny (which bring the cable outer skin
temperature to 40*C) and didn't impact the overall leaking rate.
Furthermore, during the pouring of the Field of Play concrete slab, no drops
have been noticed on the whole area.
An overall cleaning is currently performed not as a necessity but as a part of a

maintenance program. The target being to keep all the cables dry and clean.
It is likely that these area, less loaded than the other part of the cables, will
remain dry in a short future.
IS LOWER CABLE / MAST TO IET
This area tends to improve significantly, in the last 2 months. Few cleaning
operation has been required even if some random location are still leaking.
Especially the socket area and the first meter of cable. Most of the extra
lubricant is accumulating by gravity at these lower points and then induce more
oozing.
Randomly, some other area may leak at a lower level up to significant level. It is
often where the cable is most loaded (i.e. catwalk) or during the tensioning of
fixed membrane connection point.
An overall cleaning is currently performed by our team before the closing of the
membrane.
We have the option in continuing a cleaning maintenance on those area, in

order to avoid punctual drops on the bleachers underneath.
Page 5/14
GEOBRUGG'JiK INSPECTION REPORT
This solution should be satisfactory based on last observation of average

leaking rate of the cables.
2 FURTHER ACTIONS
2.1 GUTTERS
2.1.1 Lower cable at mast location
As it has been observed that the lower cable continue to leak on the lower cable
connection to the mast, we will installed some gutters.
These gutters will run from the bottom of the sockets to the sealing clamp of
fixed membrane.
This gutters will avoid the lubricant to fall in the main drainage gutter.
They will be installed after completion of membrane trade activity, in order to

avoid any damage on them.
A mock-up have been performed to illustrate the shape of this gutter. The
material and principle is identical to initial lower gutter plan.
See below pictures of mock-up:
Page 6/14
2.1.2 Cleaning frequency
The cleaning frequency has been recorded since the beginning of the leaking
issue.
In average, all cables have been cleaned 10 times: minimum 5 times, maximum
16 times according to the behaviour of the cable. This extensive cleaning
allowed to remove most of the extra lubricant. However, some area, such as the
most loaded part of cables, the clamps and the lowest point, keep leaking at
lower rate. Some random area are also noticed and are the most difficult to
monitor.
The last months, even though the hottest in term of temperature, the cleaning
was not necessary for most of the cable.
Page 7/14
Below are some graphs showing the number of day spent since the last
cleaning. During this period, almost no drops have been noticed in the related
area:
Last cleaning from today on lower

damp 10 to 14
This area is located above the retractable membrane.

In average 47 days time frame virtually free of drops have been recorded.
At the end of this period, few area shows some oozing stains but with no risk to
accumulate in a drop.
The area is currently cleaned as per our maintenance program
Page 8/14
GEOBRUGG* AV INSPECTION REPORT
REV
T^>3
32/ I /\ A6
3 l / k X \ \ 7
30 /C/vN?S /7tC^
9
29/L7T^^
28 10
27 11
2 6 \ \ \ > S ^ ^ AVvA^X
2 5 \ X \ / / 0 / ~ "T \ J r V V / ^
24 \ \C^nT/ ~~X\^Ks\ /i4
4
AT >15
23^\/7^L
22\7 7 ^ 1 6
2*V19 H8
17
last cleaning from today on

lower from clamp 1 to 10
This area is located below the fixed membrane.

In average 34 days time frame virtually free of drops have been recorded
except at very specific location.
This area is more sensitive during construction period due to change in loading
of the cable: adding of punctual weight, anchor point fixed on the cables,
stressing of the fixed membrane with ratchet strap,...
The area is currently cleaned as per our maintenance program

t
Page 9/14
GEOBRUGG* A \ INSPECTION REPORT
This area is located from the socket fixed to the mast to the first clamp of
membrane edge fixation.
In average 14 days time frame virtually free of drops have been recorded
except at very specific location.
This area remain a significant leaking source. Indeed, being situated at the
lower point, all the extra lubricant within the cable tends to accumulate there.
The area will be equipped with lower gutters at completion of membrane trades
activity to avoid damage on them.
As a temporary measure, the end of the sockets is wrapped in an absorbent
pad.
Page 10/14
INSPECTION REPORT
REV
3 MAINTENANCE
3.1 CABLE PICTURE MAP
In order to illustrate the current status of lower cables during this month "free of
cleaning" a picture map has been made as follow:
All lower cable length from mast to IET pictures taken from the top
All lower cable length from IET to clamp 5 pictures taken from the bottom
It appeared to be not relevant to take picture from the bottom between mast to
clamp 5. Indeed the quality of pictures taken from the bleachers (extensive
zoom) and face to high fight exposure, is very poor. Furthermore, the status of
this area is totally similar to the other ones.
This map is located in appendix.
3.2 MAINTENANCE PROGRAM
Starting September 13th, 2011 up to September 27th, 2011, a daily inspection

will be conducted by a Geobrugg Inspector, in order to optimize the final
intensive cleaning before the completion of membrane installation.
The interest of these daily inspection is:
Identify accurately the potential leaking area to make easier the
scheduled maintenance program
Optimize the remaining period where access to lowers is easier
In a second step, we schedule an inspection and maintenance program for the

following months until the leaking issue definitely cease.
3.2.1 Lower cables from clamo 1 to node
Cycle I:
Inspection once every two weeks
* If no leaking issue noticed, schedule a new inspection 2 weeks
after
- If leaking issue is noticed, plan immediate cleaning and schedule
a new inspection 1 week after
The passage from cycle I to II will be based on 2 inspections without leaking

noticed.
Page 11/14
GEOBRUGG AX INSPECTION REPORT
Cycle II:
Inspection once every four weeks
after
> If leaking issue is noticed, plan immediate cleaning and return to
cycle I
The passage from cycle II to III will be based on 2 inspections without leaking
noticed.
In case of 2 successive inspections with leaking noticed, restart the cycle I.
Cycle III:
Inspection once every 2 months
> If no leaking issue noticed, schedule a new inspection 2 month
after
* If leaking issue is noticed, plan immediate cleaning and schedule
a new inspection 1 months after
-> After 2 inspections without leaking, end of the cycle III
In case of 2 successive inspections with leaking noticed, restart the cycle II.
3.2.2 Gutters and trays

Cycle I:
Inspection once every month
after
* If leaking issue is noticed, plan immediate reparation and
schedule a new inspection 2 weeks after
The passage from cycle I to II will be based on 2 inspections without reparation
required.
Cycle II:
* If no leaking issue noticed, schedule a new inspection 2 months
after
- If leaking issue is noticed, plan immediate reparation and return to
cycle II
The passage from cycle II to III will be based on 2 inspections without
reparation required.
In case of 2 successive inspections with reparation required, restart the cycle I.
Cycle III:
If no leaking issue noticed, schedule a new inspection 6 months
after
* If leaking issue is noticed, plan immediate reparation and
schedule a new inspection 3 months after
Page 12/14
GEOBRUGG A\ INSPECTION REPORT
REV
* After 2 inspections without leaking notice, end of the cycle III
3.2.3 Upper Gutters removal

At this stage, it is not possible to determine accurately the most relevant period
to remove the gutters.
However, a removal of gutters after a period of 2 years can be used as a
reference (end of the cycle Hi)
After removal of gutters a final extensive cleaning will be performed on the
concerned area to remove lubricant stains.
One month after completion of upper gutter removal a final inspection of upper
cables will be conducted to confirm that the cables remain dry.
4 INSPECTION AND CLEANING CREW
The inspection will be conducted by one person.

His role will be to fill up the inspection record sheet
On these record sheets will be indicated the leaking area. A short report will be
added to the record form to define the severity of the leaking, if any, and the
average behaviour of cables.
The cleaning team will be composed of rope access workers able to work on
the cables:
Access to lower cable from mast to clamp 1: from top facade beam with
fall arrest protection
Access to lower cables from clamp 1 to clamp 7: rope access while
walking on the liner from the catwalk
Access to lower cable from clamp 7 to 10: rope access from underneath
the cable
Access to lower cable from clamp 10 to node: rope access, walking on
the cable
Access to upper cables: from the node and then fall arrest protection
The amount of crew will be adapted according to volume of work to perform.

The cleaning intervention will be done on day shift basis during the standard
week working days.
The number of workers mobilized shall be sufficient to complete the cleaning on
maximum 3 days time.
The scheduled cleaning days shall be in accordance with Owner program.
4.1 CONTACT PERSON
A contact person is designated by Geobrugg to manage the coordination of the

maintenance and cleaning operation. He can be contacted by the Owner and
will organize necessary actions:
Page 13/14
GEOBRUGG* AV INSPECTION REPORT
Franz SPICHTIG
Rigging Specialties
A Division of E.V.A.S. Trading Co. Ltd.
P.O. Box 2705

Banff, AB T1L 1C4, Canada
E-mail: franzspichtig@hotmail.com
Phone: (403)762-2509
Fax: (403)762-3718
Cell: (403)763-8863
APPENDIX
Picture map of lower cables

Inspection record form
Daniel Schlesier Markus Zurcher

Manager Process&Production Business Unit Manager PCR
Engineering / QM
Geobrugg Architectural Rope
Fatzer AG, Wire Rope Division
Salmsacherstr. 9 Salmsacherstr. 9
CH-8590 Romanshom, Switzerland CH-8590 Romanshom, Switzerland
Page 14/14
E8JB amwejuew-"0^"^1
jpdaiwBuiuwpBpeP^11
K>J
6Ui IM
Bit)
ii OT
iZH
sza
oca
-..Aqpapodsui
S m :eW3
a fe|diQPPU
aoojjuoflowJsuj
CLEANING RECOMMENDATIONS
SEFAR* Architecture TENARA* Fabric is 100% fluoropolymer and is naturally dirt-repellent. However,
additional cleaning procedures can be employed to remove stubborn dirt or stains.
Overall Cleaning
In general, most contaminants such as dust and dirt can be deaned with water. If water proves insufficient to
clean the fabric, an ammonia or detergent solution can be used, along with a soft brush and a gentle cleaning
action. It should not be necessary to aggressively scrub" the fabric to remove dirt/ stains. If desired, chlorine
bleach solutions can also be used in any concentration without affecting the fabric. ..Pressure washers" should
not be used, as their extremely high pressure could damage the fabric.
Spot Cleaning
First wipe the discoloration off with a clean damp rag by rubbing gently. If this fails to remove the discoloration,
apply a liberal amount of cleaning solution (as recommended below) to a clean rag and rub the fabric gently.
Use a final water rinse, and allow the fabric to air dry. If desired, dry fabric with a clean rag. This should
remove most dirt spots.
Note: Ammonia and detergents are recommended cleaning agents to try BEFORE isopropyl alcohol, as alcohol
will tend to dissolve the contaminant and could cause it to be absorbed into the top fabric layer.
Cleaning Agents to Avoid

Solvents are NOT recommended and should not be used, as they may adversely affect the stain by helping
to set it" into the fabric. Examples include: Ketones, acetone and methylene chloride, paint removers, oven
cleaners, or dry cleaning solutions. Abrasive cleaning agents or implements should NOT be used as they could
damage the fabric surface.
Common Stains" and Recommended Cleaning Agents

- Amino Acids/Natural fats: Ammonia based products, detergents.
- Common dirt, grease, ink, etc.: Detergents, Isopropyl alcohol.
- Bleach solutions do not affect SEFAR* Architecture TENARA* Fabrics and can be safely used without affecting
the performance of the fabric.
Note: Cleaning agents should be used with care, and if possible tested on a hidden section for adverse
affects. Of course appropriate personal protective equipment should be used as recommended by the
cleaning manufacturer.
SefarAG Phone +41 (0)71 898 51 04

Architecture Solutions Fax +41 (0)71 898 58 71
Hinterbtssaustrasse 12 infoOsefararchitecture.com
9410 Heiden www.sefar.com
Switzerland www.tenarafabrics.com
Alexandra Wagner
From: Alexandra Wagner
Sent: Wednesday, February 01, 2012 3:25 PM
To: Graham Ramsay; Howard Crosley
Cc: Warren Buckley; JohnJHarding
Subject: FOIs 200 and BEING RELEASED TODAY Oul of Scope
Out of Scope
Attachments: lDocuments for FOI 200 REDACTED.pdf;
Out of Scope
Importance: High
Good afternoon,
We have a bundle of FOIs being released to an applicant from the media this afternoon as follows:
Oul of Scope
#200
"Correspondence and reports regarding concerns and problems (including, but not limited to, flaws, failure and malfunction)
encountered in the construction and installation of cable and steel components associated with the new roof and its support
mechanisms for the BC Place Stadium renovation. I am seeking records for the period of October 1, 2010 to September 30,
2011".
Thank you!
Ali
Alexandra Wagner
Assistant Corporate Secretary
PavCo
Suite 850 - 999 West Hastings Street
Vancouver, BC V6C 2W2
Direct: 604.484.5153
Cell: 604.730.4821
Confidential Fax: 604.484.5154
Email: awaqner(g)bcpavco.com
Please consider the environment before printing this email.

Alexandra Wagner
Sent: Wednesday, January 18, 2012 12:31 PM
To: 'Pearson, Barbera CSCD:EX'
Cc: 'Danine Leduc'
Subject: FOI BCPC 200
Attachments:
Follow Up Flag: Follow up

Flag Status: Flagged
Categories: FOI - in Victoria
Good afternoon,
PavCo received the following request from a member of the media:
"Correspondence and reports regarding concerns and problems (including, but not limited to, flaws, failure and malfunction)
encountered in the construction and installation of cable and steel components associated with the new roof and its support
mechanisms for the BC Place Stadium renovation. I am seeking records for the period of October 1, 2010 to September 30,
2011".
Out of Scope, s13
This request was due on November 23,2011.
Thank you for your time.
Regards,
Ali
Alexandra Wagner
PavCo
Direct: 604.484.5153
Cell: 604.730.4821
Email: awaqner(5)bcpavco.com

From: Steve Linaenfelter
To: Alexandra Waaner
Subject: FOI 200
Date: Monday, January 16, 2012 16:23:39
Hi Ali
In talking with Warren and John last night you can go ahead and send out the
previously released material (larger bundle of documents) to Mackin as a partial
reply.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216
Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail

From: Bob Mackin
To: Steve Lingenfelter
Subject: FOI request 111011a
Date: Tuesday, October 11, 2011 10:53:24
Steve Lingenfelter, CMA

Manager, Finance & Administration
BC Pavilion Corporation
604-482-2242
October 11, 2011
Dear Mr. Lingenfelter,
Please accept this letter as a formal request for the following:
Correspondence and reports regarding concerns and problems (including,

but not limited to, flaws, failure and malfunction) encountered in the
construction and installation of cable and steel components associated
with the new roof and its support mechanisms for the B.C. Place
Stadium renovation. I am seeking records for the period of Oct. 1,
2010 to Sept. 30, 2011.
I am making this request under the B.C. Freedom of Information and

Protection of Privacy Act, in the public interest as a member of the
media. My preferred method of routine communication is via e-mail and
I prefer to receive records via email or CD-ROM.
Sincerely,
Bob Mackin
18-1073 Lynn Valley Rd.
North Vancouver, B.C. V7J 1Z6
604-982-9130
Bob Mackin | North Vancouver, B.C., Canada 2010goldrush@gmail.com

columnist | Business in Vancouver | www.biv.com
2010goldrush.blogspot.com thesportmarketguestl.blogspot.com
follow me | twitter.com/bobmackin
From: Alexandra Waaner
To : D u n c a n B l o m fi e l d ; G r a h a m R a m s a v
Subject: Heads Up
Date: Wednesday, January 18, 2012 12:36:55
Attachments:
Graham / Duncan,
"Correspondence and reports regarding concerns and problems (including, but not limited to, flaws,
failure and malfunction) encountered in the construction and installation of cable and steel components
associated with the new roof and its support mechanisms for the BC Place Stadium renovation. I am
seeking records for the period of October 1, 2010 to September 30, 2011".
Attached are the documents we propose to release to the Applicant following a courtesy review by
Victoria 0u,0,Scope
Oul of Scope
/ill notify you before I send anything to the Applicant.
Cheers,
Ali
Alexandra Wagner
ZrBwCo
Direct: 604.484.5153
Cell: 604.730.4821
Email: awagneri@bcpavco.com

F r o m : S t e v e U D fl S D f e i t B E
To : P a n B p g k ; C h r i g B e a t o n ; R o y P a t z e r
Cc: John Harding: Warren Buckley; Howard Crosley; Graham Ramsav; Duncan Blomfield: Alexandra Wagner
Subject: New FOI #200
D a t e : W e d n e s d a y, O c t o b e r 2 6 , 2 0 11 1 5 : 0 5 : 0 0
Good afternoon
I have received the following FOI request from a member of the media:
Correspondence and reports regarding concerns and problems (including, but

not limited to, flaws, failure and malfunction) encountered in the construction
and installation of cable and steel components associated with the new roof
and its support mechanisms for the B.C. Place Stadium renovation. I am
seeking records for the period of Oct. 1, 2010 to Sept. 30, 2011.
This is similar to request ** we received back in March of this year so I already

have the records from June 1, 2010 to March 11, 2011 so please just send me any
further records you may have between March 12 and Sept 30. 2011.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

A l e x a n d r a Wa g n e r
From: Elizabeth Darche [EDarche@oipc.bc.ca]

To: Alexandra Wagner Out of Scope
Subject: RE: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC 200
Sensitivity: Confidential
Oul of Scope, s3(1)(C)
From: Alexandra Wagner [mailto:AWagner@bcpavco.com]

Sent: February-01-12 3:59 PM
To : Elizabeth Darche ..
Oul of Scope
Subject: RE: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC|^ 200
From: Elizabeth Darche rmailto:EDarche(g)oiDc.bc.ca1

Sent: Thursday, January 26, 2012 14:25
To: Alexandra Wagner
Out of Scope
Subject: FW: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC 200
Importance: High
Elizabeth Darche
Intake Officer
Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of B.C.
Phone: (250) 387-0354 Toll Free: (800) 663-7867 FAX: (250)387-1696
Email: edarche@oipc.bc.ca Website: www.oipc.bc.ca
PO Box 9038 STN PROV GOVT, Victoria, BC V8W 9A4
Please consider the environment before printing this email
This email and any attachments are only for the use of the intended recipient only and must not be distributed, disclosed, used or copied by or to
anyone else. This email and any attachments may be confidential, privileged and/or subject to the provisions of the Freedom of Information and
Protection of Privacy Act. If you receive this in error please contact the sender by return email and delete all copies of this email and any
attachments. You can also call us at (250) 387-5629 Thank you.. Email can be intercepted in transit or sent to the wrong address, so use secure
means to communicate with us if you are concerned about confidentiality.
From: Elizabeth Darche

Sent: January-26-12 1:19 PM
To: 'slingenfelter@bcpavco.com' Oul of Scope
Subject: Re: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC "

Importance: High

To: slinqenfelter@bcpavco.com Out of Si
Oul of Scope
Subject: Alleged Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC] 200
Out of Scope, s3(1j(C)
Out of Scope, s3(1)(C)
Elizabeth Darche
Intake Officer
Email: edarche(5)oipc.bc.ca Website: www.oipc.bc.ca
Alexandra Wagner
To: 'Elizabeth Darche'
Subject: RE: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC 200 Oul of Scope
Out of Scope
Attachments: Response Letter200.pdf
From: Elizabeth Darche rmailto:EDarche@oipc.bc.ca1

Sent: Thursday, January 26, 2012 14:25
To : Alexandra Wagner Oul of Scope
Subject: FW: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPq 200
Importance: High
Elizabeth Darche
Intake Officer
Email: edarche(a)oipc.bc.ca Website: www.oipc.bc.ca
Sent: January-26-12 1:19 PM
To: 'slingenfelter@bcpavco.com'
Out of Scope
Subject: Re: Alleded Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC 200
Importance: High

To: slinqenfelter@bcpavco.com Out of
Oul of Scope
Subject: Alleged Deemed Refusal Your Files BCPC 200
Oul of Scope. s3(1)(C)
Elizabeth Darche
Intake Officer
Email: edarche(5)oipc.bc.ca Website: www.oipc.bc.ca
AiifDiwapiJuoD jnoqo paujaouoa djo noAfi sn qijM ajoojunujujoD 01 suodui
amoas dsn os 'ssajppo Buojm aqi 03 juas jo iisudji uj paidajjawi aq uoo 110013 ' 'noA yuoq 6Z9S-L8E (OSZ) W sn hod os/d uoo no^ sjuaujqoojjo
Auo puo 11u1.ua siqj fo saidoo //o aia/ap puo ijouia ujnjaj Aq japuas aqi 10031100 asoa/d jojja ui siqi a/\iaoaj noA f\ jo\/ Aootujd fo uojioaiojrf
From: Pearson. Barbera CSCD:EX
To: Alexandra Waaner
Cc: Pearson. Barbera CSCD:EX: ):EX: Smerechinskiv. Kathrvn I ITTrFX
Subject: RE: PavCo FOI - Courtesy Consultation - BCPC-200 (Construction issues)
Date: Wednesday, February 01, 2012 15:15:33
Attachments:
Importance: High
Hi Ali:
We have completed our courtesy review and have made some additional
severing recommendations (refer to the attached) for the updated package.
Please process accordingly.
Thank you for your assistance, please contact our office if you have any
questions.
Cheers,
Barb
"Correspondence and reports regarding concerns and problems (including, but not limited to, flaws,
failure and malfunction) encountered in the construction and installation of cable and steel components
associated with the new roof and its support mechanisms for the BC Place Stadium renovation. I am
seeking records for the period of October 1,2010 to September 30, 2011".
PavCo would like to release these records today. The remaining 96 pages of records in this package have already
been released in a previous FOI request, so we are not recommending any changes to this package:
Danine Leduc
Manager, Crowns & Strategic Initiatives
Ministry of Community, Sport and Cultural Development

Ministry of Jobs, Tourism and Innovation
Tel: (250) 387-8728 Fax: (250) 387-8038

E-mail: Danine.Leduc@gov.bc.ca
To: Dan Bock
Subject: RE: New FOI #200
Date: Thursday, November 17, 2011 13:39:00
Hi Dan
Where are you on this one or did I miss your response?
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216
From: Dan Bock

Sent: Thursday, November 03, 2011 12:57
Cc: Roy Patzer
I will be responding to this tomorrow.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 661 3648
Cell 604 818 5552
From: Steve Lingenfelter

Sent: November 3, 2011 8:45 AM
To: Dan Bock; Chris Beaton; Roy Patzer
Cc: John Harding; Howard Crosley; Graham Ramsay; Duncan Blomfield
Good morning
Please see the information below.
Are there any further records for the period Mar 12/11 - Sept 30/11 ?
Thank you.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

Sent: Wednesday, October 26, 2011 15:06
Cc: John Harding; Warren Buckley; Howard Crosley; Graham Ramsay; Duncan Blomfield; Alexandra
Wagner
Good afternoon

seeking records for the period of Oct 1, 2010 to Sept 30, 2011.
This is similar to request #167 we received back in March of this year so I already
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

From: Chris Beaton
To: Steve Linaenfelter
Date: Thursday, November 03, 2011 08:52:27
Steve,
This is Dan's issue as well, so I will bow out.
Thanks,
Chris "Beaton
Project Manager
BC Place Revitalization
Direct: 604-661-3632
Cell: 604-307-0123

Sent: Thursday, November 03, 2011 8:45 AM
Good morning
Thank you.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

Wagner
Good afternoon

seeking records for the period of Oct. 1, 2010 to Sept 30, 2011.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

To : D a n B o c k : C h r i s B e a t o n : R o v P a t z e r
C c : J o h n H a r d i n g : H o w a r d C r o s l e v : G r a h a m R a m s a v : D u n c a n B l o m fi e l d
D a t e : T h u r s d a y, N o v e m b e r 0 3 , 2 0 11 0 8 : 4 5 : 0 0
Good morning
Thank you.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

Wagner
Good afternoon

further records you may have between March 12 and Sept 30r 2011.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

From: Dan Bock
To : S t e v e L i n a e n f e l t e r
Cc: Rpy Patzer
Date: Monday, November 21, 2011 13:58:56
Attachments:
Steve I have attached the documents I feel are appropriate to the response to this FOI request,
have limited the response to currently unresolved "problems or concerns" on the basis that
resolved issues are neither problems nor concerns.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 661 3648
Cell 604 818 5552

Sent: November 17, 2011 1:39 PM
To: Dan Bock
Hi Dan
Where are you on this one or did I miss your response?
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216
From: Dan Bock

Sent: Thursday, November 03, 2011 12:57
Cc: Roy Patzer
I will be responding to this tomorrow.
PavCo
Dan Bock
Project Manager
Phone 604 661 3648
Cell 604 818 5552

Sent: November 3, 2011 8:45 AM
Good morning
Thank you.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

Wagner
Good afternoon

further records you may have between March 12 and Sept 30T 2011.
Steve Lingenfelter
604.484.5216

VANCOUVER PaulSkeath
centre Manager, Event Operations
1055 Canada Place, Vancouver pskeath@vancouverconventioncentre.com
British Columbia, V6C 0C3, Canada Direct line 604 647 7321
www.vancouverconventioncentre.com Toll-free (North America) 866 785 8232
Fax 604 647 7325
Please consider ihe environment
before printing this email. Follow us on: twitter | facebook | Linkedln | YouTube | flickr
This e-mail is Hie property of Terasen Inc. and/or its affiliates and may contain confidential material for the sole use of the intended reciptent(s). Any review, use,
distribution or disclosure by others is strictly prohibited. Terasen Inc. and its affiliates do not accept liability for any errors or omissions which arise as a result of e-
mail transmission, if you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender immediately and delete all copies of the message including removal from your
harrldnve. Thank you.

BC Place Cable Snaps FOI

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

BC Place Cable Snaps FOI

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

Steve Lingenfelter

Ralph Herten, P. Eng. | Senior Project Manager

PCL Constructors Westcoast Inc.

Sent: Sunday, December 05, 2010 10:12 AM

Pavco - Dan Bock

From: Andy Tallentire [ATaIlentire@pcl.com]

Dan and Roy

any other person.

any other person.

From: Martijn Lunneker [Lunneker@pcl.com]

David and Christoph,

Martijn Lunneker | Project Manager

PCL CONSTRUCTORS WESTCOAST INC.

Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010

1N3CH33V U3dV S1DVJ

0X03 Jaqujaoaa pj uo 6uaj!| 6uunp ||ej 6u|mo||oj :uoseay

Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010

Part 1. Status after fall/before lowering operation

Hanging to grizzly on mast side

Open female sockets (mast side) on the ground

Hangers 1 to 13 connected both side

Upper damps Upper damps on position in the air

(/TJ (sdjnjDid ujea uadMjddq Dds nj) dsde/-3iui j i/ej

OIOZ Jaqiusoaa DJ uo Duryii 6uunp ||bj 6u|MO||cy :uosea>j

(/Z) (sdjnjjid i/jea uddM^aaq dbs ot) 9sde/-dLui -j jjed

0I07J Jaquuaoaa PJ uo 6uny!| Buunp ||B^ Bujaaoiioj :uoseo^

(/) (sdJn)Did uDed uddM)ddq -dbs ot) dsdei-diui -j j./ej

OTOZ Jsqujaoaa pj uo Bupjn 6uunp ||bj Buimohoj ruoseay

(/T) ludppoe jayv - uo/jenj/sjo ajnjjij *j /</

(/Z) iUdpiDDe Jdyv - uotfenysjo ajn^Did i ven

0101* jaqtuaoaa pJ uo 6uryn 6uunp ||ej 6u!/v\0||aj :uosea>|

(/) juappje jojjv - uo/jenjfsjo ajnjj/d 'j jJ&d

0103 Jaqujaoaa pj uo Butyl.! Buunp ||ej BU|N\0||OJ :uosea

S3DVWVCJ JO S33nOS C1NV 3SA1VNV

Reason: Following fail during lifting on 3rd December 2010

Part 2. Potential sources and damages (1/3)

Cable tensioned between 2 damps or under Opening of wires due to twisting or

Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010

Part 2. Potential sources and damages (2/3) \

Lower damps position 1,2 and 3 hit the Bending of plates

Clamps Dl Position 1 may have hit bleachers

Substitution possible for R31 and Substitution:

A8||OJi/punoj6 Aenoj} fo||OJ}

(/) sabeiuep pue sajjnos /eyudjod 'Z &Bd

OTOZ Jaqujaosa S-fr uorpadsuj JO 9)60 IE* #13N

SNOLLDfUllSNI ONV SlN3WnDOQ NOI133dSNI

OTOc* JaquJ9D9a PJ uo 6uuj!| 6uunp ||bj 6u!MO||oj :uoseay

NET# R31 Date of inspection

Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010

INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - Al: Full Locked Cable inspection

Lower cable FC31-L-2

Defect type Defects Ref picture

Coating damage NO YES

Undiped wires NO YES

Conclusion on Lower cable FC31-L-2

soinpfd Z1TDJ 9/qej jbmoj

OIOZ J3qui9Daa pj uo 6ui:y!| 6uunp ||bj 6u!MO||cy :uoseay

NET# R31 Date of inspection 6 December 2010

Reason: Following fall during lifting on 3rd December 2010

INSPECTION RECORD IRP 3006 - A2 : Hanger Cables inspection

Cable bent and

OK Cable opened FR31H05-001/002 To be replaced

Hanger FR31H06 not inspected yet/pending lowering of net

not inspected yet/pending lowering of net