Anda di halaman 1dari 16

Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering

Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction for micro
hydropower schemes: A review
--Manuscript Draft--

Manuscript Number: CJME-D-17-00329

Full Title: Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction for micro
hydropower schemes: A review

Article Type: Review articles

Funding Information: National Natural Science Foundation of NA Wen-Tao Su


China
(51606050)

Abstract: Energy is unarguably the key factor for today's economic and social development
within nations. Electricity as one of many energy forms is a critical input to developing
countries in the struggle to the national self-satisfaction in all domains. Rural electricity
supply involved institutions have recently recommended the pump as turbine (PAT)-
based micro hydropower plant (MHP) schemes for remote off-grid electrification,
mostly from their economic advantages. However, from different published research
findings, PAT-based MHP is not only simple and economically feasible, but has
presented bottlenecks in the move to its full understanding. Moreover, compared to
other clean energy technologies, PAT technology has not found much literature in
academic published researches, thus contributing to its limited understanding within
the community. Therefore, the PAT literature availability is one way to level up its
understanding, which can be helpful to academic and professional communities. In the
present study, a literature review on the two most challenging PAT aspects, namely
pump-turbine selection and performance prediction, is presented; where a summary
about energy sources history leading to the actual MHP global adoption was first
presented.

Keywords: Renewable energy, Micro-hydropower, Pump as turbine, Pump selection,


Performance prediction.

Corresponding Author: Maxime Binama


Harbin Institute of Technology
Harbin, Heilongjiang CHINA

Corresponding Author Secondary


Information:

Corresponding Author's Institution: Harbin Institute of Technology

Corresponding Author's Secondary


Institution:

First Author: Feng-Chen Li, PhD

First Author Secondary Information:

Order of Authors: Feng-Chen Li, PhD

Maxime Binama

Wen-Tao Su, PhD

Xiao-Bin Li, PhD

Yue Zhao, Bsc.

Order of Authors Secondary Information:

Author Comments: Dear Editor,

The here submitted paper has been successfully presented at the 2nd International
Conference on Cavitation and Multiphase Flow (2016ISCM) Held in Jiangsu University
on October 22, 2016.

Powered by Editorial Manager and ProduXion Manager from Aries Systems Corporation
After presentation, it has been submitted to the Chinese Journal of Mechanical
Engineering for publication. After it was accepted for publication(check down the
received mail), the authors were asked to submit the present article manuscript
through the journal online submission system, which is being processed right now.
Please feel free to contact us for any other inquiry.

Thank You !

:"" <zhangjinfeng@ujs.edu.cn>
:2017-04-06 16:22:45 ()
: suwentao@hit.edu.cn
:
: 2016ISCM

ISCM
""

Suggested Reviewers: Jin-Tao Liu


liujintao86@hotmail.com
He is an renown expert in the field of the present article's research focus.

Bin Ji
jibin@whu.edu.cn

He is an expert in the field of the presented article's research focus.

Da-Zhuan Wu
wudazhuan@zju.edu.cn

He is a renown expert in the field of the present article's research focus.

Bao-Shan Zhu
bszhu@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn
He is an expert in the field of the present article's research focus.

Powered by Editorial Manager and ProduXion Manager from Aries Systems Corporation
Manuscript Click here to download Manuscript SCI-maxime-ISCM-076.docx

Click here to view linked References


1 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
2 Vol. xx, No. xx, 2016
3
4 www.springerlink.com; www.cjmenet.com
5
6
7
Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction for micro
8 hydropower schemes: A review
9
10
11
12 LI Fengchen1, BINAMA Maxime1, SU Wentao1,*, LI Xiaobin1,*, and ZHAO Yue2
13 1
School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, China
14 2
State key laboratory of hydropower equipment, Harbin Institute of Large Electric Machinery, Harbin 150040, China
15
16 Abstract: Energy is unarguably the key factor for todays economic and social development within nations. Electricity as one of many energy
17 forms is a critical input to developing countries in the struggle to the national self-satisfaction in all domains. Rural electricity supply involved
18 institutions have recently recommended the pump as turbine (PAT)-based micro hydropower plant (MHP) schemes for remote off-grid
19 electrification, mostly from their economic advantages. However, from different published research findings, PAT-based MHP is not only simple
20 and economically feasible, but has presented bottlenecks in the move to its full understanding. Moreover, compared to other clean energy
21 technologies, PAT technology has not found much literature in academic published researches, thus contributing to its limited understanding within
22 the community. Therefore, the PAT literature availability is one way to level up its understanding, which can be helpful to academic and
23 professional communities. In the present study, a literature review on the two most challenging PAT aspects, namely pump-turbine selection and
24 performance prediction, is presented; where a summary about energy sources history leading to the actual MHP global adoption was first presented.
25 Keywords: Renewable energy, Micro-hydropower, Pump as turbine, Pump selection, Performance prediction.
26
27
28 According to the International Energy Agency, 1.4 billion
29
people worldwide have no access to electricity[6], Sub-Sahara
30 1. Introduction
31 African region being the worst hit, yet the region is endowed
32 Energy is unarguably the key factor for todays economic and with several resources from which modern forms of energy can
33 social development within nations. The provision of reliable, be generated, for example hydropower [7]. Nevertheless, as far
34 secure and affordable energy services is central to addressing as electricity is concerned, hydropower is the most important
35 many of todays global development challenges[1]. Electricity renewable contribution to the primary energy supply mix. It
36 as one of many energy forms is a critical input to developing represents more than 92% of all worldwide renewable energy
37 countries in the struggle to the national self-satisfaction in all generated, and it continues to stand as the most important
38 domains. Being a secondary source of energy, electricity can be renewable energy source [8]. Hydropower is a renewable energy
39 source based on the natural water cycle, and actually the most
obtained through the conversion of primary sources of energy,
40
mature, reliable and cost-effective renewable power generation
41 such as fossil fuels, nuclear energy or green energy [2]. From the
technology available[9]. It contributes to around 16% of the
42 early age, mankind require electrical energy to fulfil their needs
43 such as lighting their houses, running industrial processes, World electricity supply generated from about 20,053 TWh of
44 heating and cooling for comfort, communication and numerous installed capacity [10]. While large hydropower plants feed the
45 others [3]. However, both the demographic growth and the national grid, typical off-grid micro hydropower plant (MHP) is
46 socio-economic development that took place during the last the most popular solution for electrification among rural
47 century have led to a continuous increase in electricity demand. communities which supplies power in the range of 5100 kW,
48 These two events caused an augmentation of the yearly total usually using a run-of-the-river to divert some of the water from
49 world electricity generation in the period 1973-2008, which the river before dropping into a pressurized penstock [11]. The
50
increased from 6116 TWh/year to 20181 TWh/year [4]. main components that comprise typical MHP schemes are
51 electromechanical equipment, civil structures, and energy
52 Despite this demonstrable increase in world electrical energy
distribution systems [12], the turbine being one of the critical
53 production, there is still shortage of electricity supply and other
54 forms of modern energy in most of the developing countries [5]. technological components of the MHP project [5]. Small and
55
56 *
Corresponding author: email: suwentao@hit.edu.cn, lixb@hit.edu.cn.
57 Supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China
58 (51606050, 51506037, 71390522), Foundation for Innovative Research
Groups of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51421063),
59
and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (HIT.NSRIF.2017047)
60
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4
micro hydropower installations have, historically, been cheap to schooled engineers, scientists or policy makers. He also added
5
run but expensive to build. This is now changing, with smaller, that one of the easily confused things is equating small to
6
7 lighter and more efficient higher-speed turbine equipment [13]. simple, as it mostly results in a backfire.
8 The mostly met problem in micro turbines is their higher price
compared to full scale ones with respect to the whole project Table 1. PAT installations
9
10 budget, owing to their expensive manufacturing price. For Location Capacity Year
11 instance, its very difficult, time-consuming, and costly to Sainyabuli Province, Laos [27] 2 KW 2008
12 develop such site-specific turbines in accordance with the local Thima Kenya [30] 2.2 KW 2001
13 Mae Wei village, Thailand [31] 3 KW 2008
ecology [14]. The cost of electro-mechanical components in West Java, Indonesia [32] 4.5 KW 1992
14 large hydro-power plants is around 20% but in MHPs it is Kinko village, Tanzania [33] 10 KW 2006
15 relatively high and varies from 35% to 40% of the total project Fazenda Boa Esperanca, Brazil[34] 45 KW 2007
16 Ambotia Micro-hydro project, India[29] 50 KW 2004
cost which may rise even up to 60% to 70% of the total project British Columbia, Canada [35] 200 KW -
17
cost in some typical cases [15]. Therefore, a better solution to Vysni Lhoty, Czech Republic [36] 332 KW 2008
18
19 this issue would be finding cheaper electro-mechanical
20 equipment but considering three fundamental conditions, viz. Taking from these grounds, the present paper, through a big
21 simplicity, efficiency, and reliability. One way to reduce the number of published literatures survey, seeks to serve as
22 equipment cost has been the use of a standard pump unit as an awareness about the mostly met techno-scientific problems in
23 alternative to a conventional turbine [16-19]. Pumps are mass- pump turbines daily operations; namely pump selection and
24 produced, and as a result, have different advantages for MHP performance prediction. This is done in the sense of scaling up
25 compared to purpose-made turbines, viz. availability in large the knowledge and know-how in the same field, which may be
26 number of standard sizes for a wide range of heads and flows[16- helpful to different institutions; be it academic or professional.
27
18], short delivery time [18-22], long life span [19-23] and easy
28
installation and availability of spare parts such as seals and
2. Pump-turbine selection
29
30 bearings [16-18]. The first pump turbine had been set at a remote Typical micro hydropower plants convert the falling water-
31 farm in the Yorkshire Dales of the North England in 1930. This contained energy to mechanical energy by turning the pump
32 scheme has been working for a five year testing time, after which turbine, which converts the water pressure into mechanical shaft
33 its reliability was confirmed before being transferred to other power to drive an electricity generator. The power available (P)
34 countries [16]. From then on, pump turbine has become a hot is proportional to the product of head (H) and volume flow rate
35 topic amongst researchers and field engineers, where indeed, it (Q) as the general formula for hydropower systems shows [37]
36 has been used at so many sites, mainly for electricity provision (equation 1). It can then be seen that the turbine selection process
37 in remote hilly regions away from central grid reach (Table 1). for a MHP of interest, should be based on the head and flowrate
38 Different researchers; Williams[16], Orchard and Sander[24], available at the site. Nevertheless, the power output may also be
39
Ramos and Borga [25], Derakhshan and Ahmad [26], and related to the head to express the turbine specific speed (NS).
40
41 Arriaga [27] among others, have provided information about the
42 applications and advantages of pump working as turbine, mainly P gQH
43 basing their arguments on its two most important features: cost-
nP1/2 (1)
44 effectiveness and simplicity. Adding on the third one, NS
45 smallness, which is also true in a way; PATs simple structural H 5/4
46 design would reflect its easily understandable operations.
This parameter characterizes the turbine runner, spiral casing,
47 However, owing to the philosophy behind the pumps
48 blade shape and other geometric design features, thus doesnt
functioning difference between conventional and reverse modes,
49 depend on the size but the shape of the machine of concern [14].
pump turbines flow dynamics and characteristics have not been
50 For instance two machines of similar shape and different size
fully understood, thus requiring more research efforts in the
51 may have same specific speed. One of the biggest difficulties in
same. As a matter of fact, many researchers have tried different
52 micro hydropower technology is to adapt the equipment to the
53 PAT efficiency prediction methods but in vain, as the predicted
specificity of the plant [38]. For instance, as much the PAT can
54 results never got validated through experimentation, with errors
be having many advantages compared to purpose-made turbines,
55 of the order of 20% [28], and couldnt cover a wide range of
the main drawback in its usage is generally the difficulty of
56 pump operating conditions in reverse mode. Though the reasons
finding the turbine characteristics that are needed to select the
57 for these failures are somewhat controversial, Singh[29] through
correct pump for a particular site [16]. The adequate selection of
58 his theory Small is beautiful but not simple, emphasized that
59 the PAT has been a big challenge in the past decades, where
one of the foremost causes is that these technologies are
60 different aspects need a close attention, viz. available head range,
considered easy and simple which do not need competence of
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 Maxime B. et Al. Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction
3 for micro hydropower schemes: A review
4
5 capacity range, back pressure at the turbine outlet, desired speed, The main weaknesses of simple PATs are generally the inability
6
etc. [14, 39]. For the PAT based MHP cost effectiveness goal to to control the flow as they are not provided with flow control
7
8 be achieved, an optimum operational design, smart selection of facilities (guide vanes), and the poor performance at off-design
9 the equipment and reduced professional consultation must be operating conditions, viz. part and over flow conditions.
10 implemented to lower the overall cost [40-42]. Nevertheless, for Therefore, they only can work efficiently at a short range of
11 the optimum PAT selection at a particular site, there is a discharges close to the full load (80% to 100%).
12 fundamental need of basic information about the head and
13 discharge available at the site, but most importantly, the
14 expected PAT performance characteristics, which in fact, are
15 two key-factors to the PAT selection validity. However, the lack
16 of PAT performance data is always stated as one of the
17
significant challenges in the design of PAT for MHP sites [43].
18
Different researchers; Orchard and Sander [24], Franc et al. [44],
19
20 Chapallaz et al. [45], Fraenkel et al. [46] and Paish [37] among
21 others, have so far provided head-flow charts depicting the range
22 of application for different PATs (Fig. 1.a). It was generally
23 concluded that multistage radial flow PATs fit sites with high
24 heads-low flow rates, whereas axial flow ones perform well at
25 low head-high flow rates sites. However, the use of single stage (a) Head-flowrate selection chart [40]
26 end suction centrifugal PATs from low to medium heads, has
27 also been recommended by many of researchers [26, 39, 47-53].
28 PAT selection can also be carried out through a head-specific
29
Head (m)

speed chart. Avelan [54] has presented a head-specific speed


30
31 chart for Francis-type reversible pump turbines, where the PAT
32 geometric design plays the key role in the classification process.
33 PATs with narrow impeller channels at the runner inlet are
34 characterized by high heads-low specific speeds, while PATs
35 with wider impeller channels at the runner inlet are characterized
Specific speed (-)
36 by low heads-high specific speeds (Fig. 1.b). Kaunda et al. [5]
37 has presented the systematic process of selecting the optimum (b) Head-specific speed selection chart [41]
38 turbine according to the site conditions, where both the
39 Fig. 1. Head-flow charts for hydro turbines
importance of head-volumetric flowrate chart and the turbine
40 However, MHPs are often required to work at off design
specific speed were recognized (Fig. 2), and different factors
41 conditions, mainly from seasonal flow variations. In this case,
which can assist in pump selection decision making, viz.
42
investment cost of the turbine, turbine design complexity, unit the site flow rate can pass or go below the maximum plant
43
power generation cost, and the turbine performance, were capacity in rainy or dry seasons respectively. To take care of this
44
45 discussed as well. The field applications of multistage, single issue, the site flow should be recorded on the whole year, so that
46 impeller centrifugal and axial flow pumps can be compared with PAT selection can be performed based on the lowest annual flow
47 Pelton, Francis and Kaplan turbines respectively [55]. record. Another alternative would be running many PATs in
48 According to Lueneburg and Nelson [39] and Sharma[56], all parallel to take care of the off design flow conditions. This
49 centrifugal pumps from low to high specific speed, single or method would be more profitable as PATs can be switched on
50 multistage, radially or axially split, horizontal or vertical and off depending on the site available flow [57], however,
51 installations, in-line and double suction can be used in reverse needing more attention so that the MHP cost-effectiveness goal
52 remains uncompromised. In this respect, different researchers,
mode. However, some pump types cant find their use in this
53 such as Singh [29], Spangler [58], Fraser et al. [59],
54 field because of, for some their operating characteristics, others
their design features. For instance, self-priming and wet-motor Nicholas[60], and Hochreutiner [61], have come out with a
55
56 submersible bore hole pumps cant be reversed because of the range of number of PATs ranging from 3 to 7, which when
57 presence of a non-return valve. Dry-motor submersible pumps operated in parallel would be more efficient than a single
58 also cant be used mainly because of their over-heating issue.
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18 Fig. 2. Turbine selection flow chart for micro hydropower schemes [5]
19
20 conventional turbine of a comparable capacity. The last completely reliable solution to the problem as their results were
21
technic to be presented in this paper is the siphon intake way erroneous as compared to field test results.
22
23 method as presented by Williams [28]. This method is used in Therefore they may only be used to get a rough picture of the
24 low flow cases, where the flow is accumulated and stored in a required PAT characteristics, which need validation adjustment
25 reservoir in order to release the full flow to the PAT by experimental methods. Selected PAT performance researches
26 intermittently, thus producing an intermittent power. This and findings have been chronologically presented by Jain et al.
27 method is not convenient to engineering applications requiring [14] as shown in Table 2. To some authors, e.g., Fraser [59],
28 continuous energy supply, but it can serve for different basic Garay [69], and Sharma [65] among others, pump mode-based
29 operations like heating and battery charging. prediction methods are reliable, but may need some corrections
30 in particular cases. To some others, e.g., Burton and Mulugeta
31 3. Pump-turbine performance prediction [70], Chaudry [71], and Ventrone and Navarro [72] to mention
32
about, these methods are solely unreliable, but recognize the
33 PAT is an economical alternative for small and micro-hydro
34 pump geometry as the most fundamental parameter to base on
schemes in remote areas. A pump in reverse can generally handle PAT performance predictions, as pump manufacturers dont
35 comparatively higher flow rates, which in turn may implicate
36 necessarily provide universally standardized pumps. It is said
higher output energy ranges [62]. However, due to the fact that that two pumps of same BEP may sometimes have different
37
38 the pump manufacturers do not offer performance curves of their performance in their turbine-mode operations.
39 pumps in turbine mode; the selection of a suitable pump turbine As a matter of fact, a comparatively small number of
40 to run under site-specific operation conditions has become a big researchers have rather opted on using the pump geometrical
41 challenge [14]. design and other hydraulic phenomena to end up with more
42 A large number of theoretical and experimental studies have accurate technics. However, due to their complexity, these
43 been done for performance prediction of reverse running methods were generally not preferred. Away from the researches
44 centrifugal pumps[48]. The pump mode-based prediction which was carried out in the early age of PAT discovery, PAT
45 technic is the easiest way as it only requires the user to have
46 has remained a hot research topic among professional and
access to the pump performance basic information such as the academic communities, where intensive theoretical,
47
flow rate , head and the efficiency , which in turn make experimental and computational studies have eventually resulted
48
it easy to find correspondent turbine mode performance in a big literature about PAT performance prediction, as
49
50 parameters through simple calculations. Therefore, theoretical described in the following section.
51 researches were mainly based on pump mode performance
52 parameters where the head and flow correction factors play a key
3.1. Theoretical studies
53 role in PAT performance prediction. Many researchers, e.g.,
54 Stepanoff [63], Childs [64], Sharma [65], among others, have
55 Pump turbines are a cost-effective alternative for micro-hydro
developed PAT performance prediction relations based on pump
56 schemes at remote areas. Different researchers have
best efficiency point (BEP) whereas others such as
57 continuously carried out theoretical, numerical, and
Gopalakrishnan [66], Diederich [67], and Grover [68] have
58 experimental studies or sometimes a combination of some of
developed their relations basing on the pump specific speed.
59 these methods, to come out with a universal PAT performance
However, theoretical prediction methods have not provided a
60 prediction method.
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 Maxime B. et Al. Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction
3 for micro hydropower schemes: A review
4
5
6 Table 2. Performance prediction methods for pump-turbines
7
8 Year Researcher Criteria Head correction(h) Discharge correction factor (q) Remarks
9
1 1
10 1957 Stepanoff [63] BEP Accurate for Ns: 40-60
11
1 1
12 1962 Childs [64] BEP -

13 1 1
14 1963 Hanckock [73] BEP -

15 1980 Grover [68] Specific speed 2.693 0.0229 2.379 0.0264 Applied for Ns: 10-50
16 6 1.6
17 1982 Hergt (in [74]) Specific speed 1.3 1.3 -
3 5
18 1 1
19 1985 Sharma [65] BEP Accurate for Ns: 40-60
1.2 0.8
20 2.5 2.4
1988 Schmiedl [75] BEP 1.4 + 1.5 + 2 -
21
22 1 0.855 + 0.385
1994 Alatorre-Frenk [57] BEP -
23 0.855 + 0.385 29.5 + 0.205
24 2 1.1 1.1
1998 Sharma [56] BEP [ ] 1.2 = 240
25 0.8
26
27
28 A considerable number of published theoretical methods were experimental test-rig was constructed as in[55], and
29 based either on pump mode performance parameters or pump experimental results were compared to both theoretical and
30 geometric design. This subsection comprises pure theoretical numerical predictions. Theoretical methods predicted values
31
researches and their combination with other methods. Hossain et were found slightly lower than experimental data with 1.1%,
32
33 al. [76] carried out a comparative study between two mostly used 4.7%, 5.25%, and 2.1% deviation for discharge (), Head (),
34 theoretical PAT performance prediction methods (Chapallaz et Power (), and efficiency () numbers respectively. CFD results
35 al. [45] and Sharma [65] methods) to get an idea which is better were in good agreement with experimental results in pump mode,
36 than the others. Pump hydraulic characteristics were first found but much lower in turbine mode. Yang et al. [79] carried out a
37 through an experiment session on a 4hp DC powered motor PAT performance prediction study in which three methods, viz.
38 pump at a 2900 rpm rotational speed. The experimental results theoretical, numerical, and experimental methods, were used. A
39 were used to get PAT performance characteristics, power, and pump mode-based theoretical prediction method was developed,
40 output electrical energy, through the two above mentioned the results of which got compared with other theoretical,
41 methods. The study, through a comparative scheme, concluded numerical and experimental methods. Numerical simulations on
42 that Sharma method could only predict the PAT BEP and power both modes (reverse and direct operating modes) were
43
whereas Chapallaz et al. method gave a wide range of operating performed by ANSYS-CFX which is a commercial 3D Navier-
44
45 points from minimum to maximum deviation, thus providing the stokes CFD software. The selected turbulence model was k-,
46 access to the information about PAT operation at and away from where the flow domain was subdivided into four parts, viz. inlet
47 BEP. Chapallaz et al. method was found to provide more clear pipe, volute, impeller, front and back chambers to facilitate the
48 understanding of the PAT performance characteristics. gridding process by ANSYS ICEM. Comparing experimental
49 Derakhshan et al. [26] have compared three PAT performance results as tested by a Jiangsu University-based test rig, with
50 prediction methods, viz. Area ratio a theoretical method numerical, theoretical and other prediction methods results; CFD
51 developed by Gantar [77] and Anderson [78], numerical, and results were found in good agreement with its two modes
52 experimental methods. Theoretical and numerical prediction experimental data, whereas a slight difference between
53 results were compared to experimental ones to get an idea which experimental and numerical results was noticed. The theoretical
54
one predicts well the PAT performance characteristics (at BEP). and CFD methods were more accurate than the other two
55
56 The pump two operational modes (direct and reverse modes) methods (Sharma [65] and Stepanoff [63] methods), as shown in
57 numerical simulation was performed through FineTurbo V.7 Fig. 3 and Table 3. Williams [50] carried out a comparative
58 flow solver, where 3D full Navier-Stokes equations were solved; study of eight different prediction methods on 35 pumps with
59 the results of which, helped on the pump complete specific speeds ranging from 12.7 to 183.3, where the main
60 characteristics curve construction for both modes. An research focus was the impact of performance prediction
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4 Table 3. BEP predictions by various methods
methods errors (deviation between predicted and actual BEP
5
values) on PAT operations. Every methods credibility was
6 Exp. Num. Theor. Sharma Stepanoff
7 evaluated through a British standard-based prediction
h 1.89 2.00 1.99 1.74 1.58
8 coefficient C, for which acceptable errors were supposed to be
q 1.66 1.70 1.55 1.45 1.26
9 equal or inferior to a unity. Error h (%) - +5.3 +5.3 -7.9 -16.4
10 Error q (%) - -2.4 -6.6 -12.7 -24.1
2 2
2 a b
11
12 C
0.3 0.1 Carravetta et al. [80] proposed the turbomachinery affinity
13
1 laws modification scheme to eliminate the big discrepancy
14
With : a q h (2) between PAT performance theoretical and experimental
15 2


16 1 prediction methods. In order to obtain the PAT BEP
17 b q 2 h 2 2hq characteristics at a speed ( ), the usual
18 2
turbomachinery affinity laws were transformed to functions of
19 the ratio ( ) as follows:
20 The C value was calculated from an H-Q curve, for which the
21 center coincided with the manufacturer-provided BEP. It was
Q N H B N
22 found that none of all evaluated methods was reliable; however, q f 1 MAX h f 2 MAX
23 Q MAX N HBMAX
N
Sharma method presented better performance than others, thus B
(3)

24 being the most recommended method. It was also suggested that P N B N
p B f 3 MAX f 4 MAX
25 theoretical prediction methods should be accompanied with P MAX
B N MAX
B N
26 experimental ones for their validity confirmation during PAT
27
installation. Functions 1 , 2 , 3 and 4 were obtained from experimental
28
29 results on several submersible pumps operated at different
30 speeds. Using Suter parameters in conjunction with the obtained
31 modified affinity laws, the decrease of scatter between the
32 calculated and measured values was achieved. Ramos and Borga
33 [25] carried out a Suter parameters-based steady and transient
34 flow regimes study aiming at proving the pump physical,
35 economical and technical reliability not only in industrial
36 processes but also in power generation sector. It was confirmed
37 that using PATs is a good alternative to dissipation of excess
38
flow energy that, normally would be lost. The study outcomes
39
40 also showed that, depending on runner characteristics, PATs
41 efficiency can attain 80%. Induced motors were recommended
42 for large electric grids, and synchronous motors for isolated
43 (a) operations. For whatever case, PAT was globally found to be the
44 best economic solution.
45
46 3.2. Experimental studies
47
48
Raman et al. [81] carried out an experimental study aiming at
49
50 a better understanding of PAT characteristics. A centrifugal
51 pump with 15.36, 22m, and 8.31 l/s as specific speed, head, and
52 flow rate respectively, was tested in a test rig as installed in the
53 Mechanical Engineering Laboratory of the Universiti Tenaga
54 Nasional. The pump selection process was performed following
55 a reconnaissance technic as presented by Raman and Hussein
56 [82]; thereafter, the experimental results were compared to other
57 (b) previously published researches. The experiment findings were
58 approximately similar to other methods; although, the specific
59 Fig. 3. Comparison between Pump (a) and PAT (b) experimental speed and efficiency values were slightly lower. The pump
60 and numerical results
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 Maxime B. et Al. Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction
3 for micro hydropower schemes: A review
4
5 operation in turbine mode was found to require high heads and results on many pumps of different shapes (20-80rpm), mainly
6
flows compared to the direct mode. It was confirmed that a targeting its parsimony on PAT performance prediction,
7
8 centrifugal pump can satisfactorily be operated as turbine selection , and evaluation, which are its three main segments; in
9 without any mechanical problems. Singh et al. [83] studied the order to find a lasting solution for PATs modelling and establish
10 effect of casing eye ribs on the pump turbine hydraulics and a new basis of evaluating uncertainties, based on fundamental
11 performance characteristics. Two pump models, casing rib theory of turbomachines. The prediction segment required the
12 absent (CRA) and casing rib present (CRP), were both pump shape and size to come out with complete PAT
13 numerically and experimentally studied; where commercially performance characteristics. The selection segment required
14 available software, CFX, for which the K- turbulence model only the site head and flow data to determine the suitable pumps
15 was selected, was used for simulations. The PAT flow for specific sites. And finally, the evaluation segment compared
16 experimental and numerical analysis was comparatively carried the selected pumps and their characteristics to decide the most
17
out for two operating modes, CRA and CRP, at six operating suitable PAT for specific operating conditions. The developed
18
points, namely, A (51%QBEP), B (70%QBEP), C (88%QBEP), D consolidated model, from obtained test results and related
19
20 (100%QBEP), and E (116%QBEP), constituting the part, full, and analysis, through many modelling acrobatics, contributed to the
21 over loads. The study results from both methods showed that economic feature, needing a small number of parameters to give
22 CRA had higher efficiency and greater performance for the part- the complete and accurate PAT predictions. Yang et al. [85]
23 load and overload operations as compared to CRP. A satisfactory studied the influence of rotational speed to the PAT performance.
24 similitude was noticed between experimental and numerical In this paper, a rotational speed-based theoretical PAT
25 results, where the PAT exhibited good performance with 82% as performance prediction method was first developed where new
26 the highest attained efficiency. Nautiyal et al. [48] carried out correlation equations for flow rate, head, and shaft power; were
27 an experimental study on PAT performance characteristics in the developed as shown:
28 hope to come out with a more accurate prediction method. The
29
test results on a pump of 18( , 3 ) as specific speed, Q1 n1 H 1 n1
2
P1 n1
3
30 (4)
31 running at 1500rpm, confirmed that, as it had been demonstrated Q2 n2 H 2 n2 P 2 n 2
32 by many other researchers, the centrifugal pump can surely be
33 used as turbine under various operating conditions, where the Where the subscripts 1 and 2 stand for first and next operating
34 turbine operating mode is always characterized by higher flow conditions in terms of speed. Experiments were carried out on a
35 rates and heads but with comparatively lower efficiencies. Jiangsu University based-test rig at different rotational speeds,
36 Together with four other pump models from different viz. 1000rpm, 1200rpm, 1500rpm, and 1800rpm. And finally,
37 researchers, the tested pump was farther analyzed to come up the PAT model was numerically analyzed. The numerical study
38 with a new prediction method based on both pump efficiency
39 was performed by a CFD commercial code Ansys CFX, where
and specific speed. Compared to other prediction methods, the the k- turbulence model was adopted, and static pressure inlet
40
developed method presented better performance, with and mass flow rate outlet were selected as inlet and outlet
41
42 comparatively reduced errors (as compared to test results), thus boundary conditions respectively. Test, numerical, and
43 making it the best. Derakhshan and Nourbakhsh [55], based on theoretical results were in a quite acceptable agreement.
44 experimental results as performed on a mini-hydropower test rig However numerically predicted efficiency, head, shaft power
45 at the University of Tehran, has developed new correlation values tended to be slightly higher than test ones by 4.85%,
46 equations for PAT BEP prediction. Four centrifugal pumps in 2.31%, 5.39% respectively. Nevertheless, theoretical results
47 specific speeds range from 14.6 to 55.6 (m,m3/s) were tested, were higher than the two first, where wider deviation was found
48 where centrifugal pumps were again found to fit the turbine in Shaft power predictions. The developed theoretical method
49 operating conditions with comparatively higher heads and flows
50 was found reliable but needing some perfections to get even
and approximately equal efficiencies. The newly developed better results.
51
specific speed-based prediction method was compared to many
52
53 others, to only find it exhibited better and acceptable estimates
3.3. Numerical studies
54 of flow rate and head for pumps with specific speeds higher than
55 60 (m,m3/s). It was also demonstrated that between two pumps
Many researchers have shown that CFD analysis is a reliable tool
56 with same specific speed, the one with bigger impeller diameter
to predict the behavior of a pump machine operating as a turbine
57 has higher efficiency. Also the higher the flow and head they
and to estimate the performance curves of the
58 exhibit, the more efficient they become. A better PAT selection
turbomachinery[86]. With CFD, complex fluid flow behaviors
59 procedure for a specific site was also proposed. Singh and Franz
60 inside the PAT can be virtually previewed, which can
[84] developed a new consolidated model from experimental
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4
substantially reduce both the design time and cost. A big number performance prediction. Rawal and Kshirsagar [90] carried out
5
of studies have been carried out aiming at PAT flow a study through both numerical and experimental methods on a
6
7 characteristics understanding and performance prediction. mixed flow pump with the objective of analyzing the accuracy
8 Ismail et al. [87] tested an end suction centrifugal pump by of computational tools for PAT studies. The PAT flow was first
9 means of CFD simulations to determine its performance numerically studied at five different flows, viz. 60%, 80%, 100%,
10 characteristics in both direct and reverse modes. The CFD 120%, and 140% of the BEP flow at a rotational speed of
11 modelling and simulations were performed by Ansys CFX14.0, 1450rpm. The k- turbulence model was adopted, where the
12 where the K- was selected for flow turbulence modelling in a chosen inlet and outlet boundary conditions were total pressure
13 pump of 70 units (Euroflo EU50-20) as specific speed and in and flow rate out, respectively. The experimental part was run
14 working at a rotational speed of 1450rpm. The computational at a test facility based at a major University in Karlsruhe,
15 domain was divided into three parts, viz. volute, impeller and German. The single stage mixed flow pump with four mixed
16
draft tube; where inlet and outlet boundary conditions were set flow vanes was tested at three different speeds, viz. 800rpm,
17
18 to mass flow rate inlet and static pressure out respectively. 900rpm, and 1000rpm, under flows ranging from no load to
19 However, the reverse mode simulations had to be run at 1550 maximum load. The agreement between computational and test
20 rpm in accordance with the used induction generators speed. results has been satisfactory. The numerical approach served in
21 The flow simulations were then run at flows varying from 0.7 to the identification of losses in PATs different parts, and it was
22 1.3 QBEP. After comparing both modes CFD predicted results suggested that the use of finer mesh, better numerical methods
23 to pump manufacture-provided ones, it was observed that BEP and turbulence models, could improve on the numerical results
24 was attained at higher flows and heads in turbine than pump accuracy. Barrio et al. [91] presented a numerical study on a
25 mode. However efficiency was found higher in pump mode centrifugal pump with twisted backwards curved blades in both
26 (72.63% against 71.62%). Numerical simulation method was direct and reverse operating modes, aiming at the investigation
27
confirmed viable for PAT performance prediction. Pascoa et al. of global flow characteristics within the machine at different
28
29 [88] carried out a numerical study on a centrifugal pump to check flow rates. A CFD commercial code Ansys Fluent was used
30 the validity of three randomly selected theoretical correlation together with k- turbulence model to solve the full unsteady
31 methods, viz. stepanoff, Sharma, and Viana methods. In this RANS equations, with total pressure in variable static pressure
32 study, through a CFD commercial code Ansys Fluent, the flow out and constant total pressure in constant pressure out, as
33 in a NNJ125-250 pump was modelled, where Reynolds boundary conditions in pump and turbine mode respectively.
34 Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) equations were solved through After comparison between numerical and experimental results,
35 Spalart-Allmaras turbulence model. PISO algorithm was used an agreement between both was quite satisfactory with
36 for pressure-velocity coupling and stagnation pressure in and maximum errors less than 4%. However flow recirculation and
37 static pressure out were chosen for inlet and outlet boundary backflow regions were noticed at off-design flow rates in the
38 conditions respectively. Theoretical results were compared to reverse operating mode. Jovanovi et al. [92] presented a
39
computational ones, where an acceptable agreement was finally comparative study between numerical and experimental results
40
41 noticed between both. A new approach for PAT power plant on a centrifugal pump running in both reverse and direct modes.
42 design was also developed; where at each constant head, it was In this paper, different PAT usages and performance prediction
43 now possible and easy to know the most efficient PAT rotational methods were discussed. From its different advantages over
44 speed. All computational results in this paper were achieved other mostly used methods, namely theoretical and experimental
45 through a frozen rotor approach. Nautiyal et al. [89] presented a methods, CFD method was confirmed very effective for PAT
46 review of some already published works on PAT performance flow studies. An example computational case-study was run
47 prediction through CFD. It was shown that CFD usage in the through Ansys CFX commercial code, together with K-
48 area of turbomachines has seen extensive growth in recent turbulence model for both modes, where extracted results were
49 decades. Generally manufacturers dont provide performance compared to collected experimental ones. Different frequently
50
and flow characteristics of their pumps in turbine mode; so CFD met problems in computational method usage were pointed out
51
52 has been a recent attempt for PAT performance prediction. It was as well as their respective way outs. There was a good agreement
53 mentioned that CFD made it possible to identify losses in between test and numerical results with comparatively small
54 different parts of PAT. However, there have been discrepancies errors (less than4%). Milan et al. [93] simulated the flow in the
55 between numerical and experimental predictions mainly from middle stage of a radial-flow multistage PAT to get the flow
56 geometry simplification in computational studies, as reported in pattern information for efficiency improvement through
57 this paper. Nevertheless, it was pointed out that, numerical geometrical modifications if by any means needed. CFD
58 predictions accuracy would also depend on grid quality and commercial code Ansys CFX was used to solve the fully
59 numerical methods and used turbulence models. CFD was unsteady three dimensional RANS equations together with the
60 generally acknowledged as an effective design tool for PAT shear stress transport (SST) turbulence model. The studied flow
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 Maxime B. et Al. Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction
3 for micro hydropower schemes: A review
4
5 domain consisted of a six blades impeller with two different
6
diameters (full and reduced) and an eight channels stator, where
7
8 the selected boundary conditions were the flow rate and average
9 static pressure for inlet and outlet boundary conditions
10 respectively, for the turbine operational mode. Six interfaces,
11 three rotor-stator and three stator-rotor interfaces, were used
12 between rotor and stator, and the analysis was carried out at
13 different rotational speeds and flow rates. The numerical results
14 were in good agreement with experimental ones with an error of
15 about 13% from the neglected loss estimations in the numerical
16 study. Full diameter impeller version showed a comparatively
17
better performance, and it was found that the multistage pump
18
doesnt need any modification to become more efficient as it
19
20 could get sufficiently higher efficiencies, unmodified.
(a)
21
22
23
4. Performance improvement attempts
24
25 Patel et al. [94] experimentally studied the effect of impeller
26 modification on PAT performance. The main objective was to
27 compare the PAT efficiency as well as other performance
28 parameters before and after impeller modification. Different
29 modifications were made, viz. impeller edges rounding, hub and
30 shroud extremities rounding, and material removal at the
31 impeller exit areas; after which, the modified model was tested
32 at a constant speed of 1100rpm under continually varied loads.
33
After comparing the modified against unmodified model
34
35 performances, it was reported that the modified model exhibited
36 comparatively higher efficiency, where the BEP head and power
37 were attained at lower flow rates. It was then demonstrated that (b)
38 the rounded edges impeller would make a more efficient PAT.
39 Yang et al. [95] carried out a study on the influence of impeller
40 blade thickness on PAT performance. Three impellers with
41 different design parameters (Table 4) were experimentally and
42 numerically analyzed, and through a comparative scheme, their
43 performance characteristics were discussed. Owing to its
44
robustness and fast convergence, the CFD commercial code
45
46 Ansys CFX, was chosen to solve steady state Navier-Stokes
47 equations together with standard k- turbulence model. The
48 selected inlet and outlet boundary conditions were static pressure
49 in and mass flow out respectively, with continuously changed
50 flow to come up with the complete PAT performance curve.
51 Ansys ICEM was used for flow domain grid generation. The
52 PAT experimental tests were run at a Jiangsu University based
53 test rig, the results of which got compared to numerical ones. (c)
54 Both methods predictions were in an acceptably good agreement.
55
It was found that both pressure head and shaft power increased, Fig. 4. Performance curves of PATs with different blade thicknesses
56
whereas the efficiency decreased with the blade thickness a) Ns=57 b) Ns=119 c) Ns=168 [95]
57
58 increase (Fig. 4), therefore a small blade-thickness possible was
59 recommended as long as its strength is not compromised.
60
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4 Table 4. Design parameters of the PAT Sheng et al. [97] studied the influence of impeller trimming
5
on PAT performance through experimental and numerical
6 Q/ m3h-1 H/m n/r min-1 ns
7 100 40 1500 57
methods. Note that impeller trimming is generally aimed at
8 120 43 3000 119 pump performance improvement whenever there is pressure
125 28 3000 168 head or flow rate drop. Three PAT models with full, once-
9
10 trimmed, and twice-trimmed impellers, were tested at the same
11 Giosio et al. [96] presented an experimental study aiming at rotational speed of 1500rpm in both turbine and pump modes
12 improving the PAT operating conditions by flow regulation with 0.57%, 0.50%, 0.76%, 1.2%, 1.27% and 0.14%,
13 facility incorporation thus eliminating a widely known PAT 0.50%, 0.52%, 1.08%, 1.20%; as respective pressure head,
14 problem of inflexibility towards flow regime fluctuations. A flow rate, hydraulic power, generated shaft power, and
15 suitable pump was first selected using Sharma method and got efficiency measured uncertainties, at a Jiangsu University-based
16 installed inside the customized housing provided with flow test rig. The steady state numerical research was carried out
17 regulation facility, and guide vane assembly consisting of 13
18 through a CFD code Ansys CFX, where the k- turbulence
hydrofoil shaped vanes; at a micro-hydro test rig based at the model was used, and static pressure in and mass flow rate out
19
University of Tasmania. For the construction of the PAT were chosen as inlet and outlet boundary conditions. The
20
21 efficiency hill chart, the steady state flow test was performed at experimental results showed the PAT efficiency drop of about
22 different guide vane openings ranging from 20 to 35 4.11% from full to twice-trimmed impeller diameter. Numerical
23 corresponding to 53% to 92% of full stroke, and net specific predictions were in an acceptable agreement with experimental
24 energy values ranging from 34j/kg to 83.3kg/j with 5j/kg ones, yet comparatively higher, from the neglected losses in
25 repetitive increments. The prediction results for pump rated numerical analysis. The PAT performance variation was the
26 operation, Sharma prediction method, and presented combined effect of four driving parameters, viz. impeller
27 experimental test; as well as the experimental tests-resulted diameter, blade wrap angle, blade thickness, and inlet blade
28 efficiency hill chart are shown in Table 5 and Fig. 5 respectively.
29 angle. Sanjay et al. [98] carried out an experimental study to
The tested impeller exhibited a maximum overall efficiency of optimize the PAT geometrical and operational parameters, viz.
30
79% in good agreement with PAT theory, and it has been able to impeller diameter, blade tip rounding, and impeller rotational
31
32 operate within a big range of flow conditions. speed. Experiments were carried out on a selected centrifugal
33 Table 5 . Best efficiency values of the selected PAT operating as a
pump of 20m, 0.0292m3/s, 1400rpm, and 75% as rated head,
34 pump, turbine predicted, and turbine actual [96] discharge, speed, and efficiency, at a Nirma University-based
35 test rig. Tests were run at a wide range of rotational speeds from
36 H Q N P 900rpm to 1500rpm on PATs with original, 10%, and 20%
Values of BEP Nq [-]
37 [m] [m3/s] [rpm] [KW] [%] trimmed impellers (250mm, 225mm, and 200mm as respective
38 Pump as rated 104.3 12.25 0.222 1450 34.0 78.5
Turbine diameters), before and after blade edge curving. Every test was
39 92.4 4.38 0.139 750 4.68 78.5
predicted run three times and the parameter mean values were considered.
40 Turbine actual 71.9 5.98 0.133 754 6.20 79.0
41 From test findings, recommendations were given. However they
42 were more specific to this research case, thus requiring a
43 generalization process to a wide range of PAT geometrical and
44 operational conditions. The highest efficiency (76.93%) was
45 record at a 10% trimmed impeller running at 1100rpm. Finally
46 an empirical correlation was developed and gave the efficiency
47 predictions in the range of 10% compared to experimental ones.
48 Impeller trimming and blade rounding led to a better part load
49 performance and efficiency increase about 3-4% respectively.
50
Derakhshan et al. [99], using the gradient-based optimization as
51
52 presented in his previous publication [100], modified the
53 impeller blade geometric design to improve the PAT maximum
54 efficiency. The blade design was firstly optimized through a
55 gradient-based optimization technique, coupled with a 3D
56 Navier-Stokes flow solver, after which the optimized impeller
57 blades got rounded and experimentally tested for further analysis.
58 Fig. 5. Performance Hill chart of the micro-hydro turbine unit [96] FINE/TURBO was used for simulations and k- turbulence
59 model was selected to solve the flow RANS equations, where
60 mass flow rate in and static pressure out were the chosen inlet
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 Maxime B. et Al. Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction
3 for micro hydropower schemes: A review
4
5 and outlet boundary conditions respectively. The tested pump increase, volute pressure pulsation amplitudes decreased,
6
was a low specific speed centrifugal pump (23.5m, m3/s), with a whereas the impeller situation remained unchanged.
7
8 turbine mode rotational speed of 1500rpm. The test
9 measurement uncertainty analysis was carried out through
10 Moffat technique[101], where 5.5%, 3.4%, 5.1%, and 5.5% were
11 respective head, flow rate, power, and efficiency uncertainties.
12 The optimization process raised the PAT performance, but the
13 rounded PAT version exhibited even higher performance
14 compared to both initial and optimized versions. Both
15 modifications contributed to the efficiency improvement in the
16 range from 3% to 5%. Impeller modification was found a
17
reliable performance improvement method within PATs. Suarda
18
et al. [53] presented an experimental study on a small volute-
19
20 type centrifugal pump, aiming at pump reverse mode efficiency
21 improvement by modifying the shape of impeller blade tips into
22 bullet nose-like shape. A small volute-type centrifugal pump
23 having 0.13m3/sec, 13m, and 0.4Kw as maximum discharge, Fig. 6. Performance curves of the PAT with different radial gaps
24 head, and motor power respectively; has been tested under [102]
25 various flow rates, for both original and modified impellers, at
26 Yang et al. [103], through experimental, numerical, and
Huai Kra Thing village site. Experiment results showed an
27 theoretical methods, investigated the effect of impeller diameter
increase in both power and efficiency for the modified impeller.
28 on PAT performance. Experimental tests were performed on a
The maximum efficiency shifted from 34.34% (before
29 single stage centrifugal pump with a rotational speed of 1500rpm,
modification) to 37.5% (after modification) with a
30 with different impeller diameters namely 215mm, 235mm, and
31 comparatively lower BEP flow rate (0.00149m3/sec against
255mm respectively. Both power and efficiency increased after
32 0.002m3/s). Flow turbulences at the impeller inlet were also
BEP while the Head dropped with impeller diameter increase.
33 substantially decreased. This method was mostly recommended
However the PAT efficiency, shaft power, pressure head, and
34 for large capacity PATs, where remarkable improvements can
flow; all increased in the range from 10.26% to 89.39%, for an
35 be noticed; rather than in small pumps, as their performance
36 impeller diameter increase from 215mm to 255mm, at BEP.
improvement would be as small as ineffective. Yang et al. [102]
37 Simulation results were in a quite good agreement with
carried out a numerical study about the influence of the radial
38 experimental ones; yet small discrepancies were noticed, mainly
gap between the impeller and the stationary volute to both the
39 from some neglected losses. Also hydraulic losses were globally
PAT performance and PAT pressure fields characteristics. A
40 noticed to have been decreasing with the impeller diameter
CFD steady state simulation was first carried out on PATs with
41 increase. Theoretical method over-predicted the BEP
different radial gaps, viz. 0.062D2, 0.145D2, and 0.224D2
42 characteristics as compared to experimental findings, therefore,
43 (D2:impeller inlet diameter) at a rotational speed of 1500rpm.
they were only recommended for PAT BEP rough estimations.
44 Ansys CFX code was used, and k- turbulence model was
45 adopted; where static pressure in and mass flow out were chosen
46 for inlet and outlet boundary conditions respectively. By Conclusions
47 continually changing the flow rate, PAT performance curves
48 were achieved; where it was found that 0.145D2 was the This paper presented a literature review from previously
49 optimum radial gap as it exhibited the highest efficiency published works on pump-turbine technical aspects namely
50 (69.18%) at BEP (Fig. 6). For the next step, monitoring points pump-turbine selection and performance prediction, where the
51 following conclusions are drawn:
were set in the inlet pipe, volute, and blade flow passages and
52 (1) By inversing their fluid flow direction, pumps can work
the unsteady PAT flow simulation was performed, aiming at
53 effectively for power generation without any mechanical
54 analyzing the pressure fields in the PAT flow domain. The rotor-
stator interaction created both high and low frequency unsteady failures, and present many advantages over conventional
55 turbines, especially in off-grid energy systems.
56 pressure fluctuations in volute and impeller respectively.
(2) Pump-turbines operate poorly under part-load conditions
57 However, due to volute high frequency fluctuations propagation and their efficiency is usually lower or equal to
58 towards the impeller channels and inlet pipe; impeller pressure conventional turbines. However, their global adoption is
59 fields were a combination of both kinds. With the radial gap more about economic profits rather than performance
60 efficiency.
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4
(3) A great deal of studies have been carried out on pump- the remaining gaps; where more parameters, be it design or
5
turbine performance prediction but in vain as there is no operational, need to even deeply be checked; all leading to more
6
universal prediction method applicable to a wide range of ability to make the pump-turbine technology not only
7
specific speeds yet found. However, their performance can economically reliable but also technically efficient.
8
still be improved through impeller design modifications,
9
where blade rounding is so far the most promising technic References
10
Further research initiatives are still needed in the future for a
11
12 complete understanding, leading to the eventual elimination of
International Journal of Applied Research in Mechanical Engineering.
13 2013;3:71-6.
[1] Bazilian M, Nussbaumer P, Rogner H-H, Brew-Hammond A, Foster V,
14 Pachauri S, et al. Energy access scenarios to 2030 for the power sector in sub- [23] Ranjitkar G, Huang J, Tung T. Application of Micro-Hydropower
15 Saharan Africa. Utilities Policy. 2012;20:1-16. Technology for Remote Regions. EIC Climate Change Technology, 2006
16 [2] Hasmatuchi V. Hydrodynamics of a pump-turbine operating at off-design IEEE2006. p. 1-10.
conditions in generating mode [PhD Thesis]: Ecole Polytechnique de Lausanne [24] Orchard B, Klos S. Pumps as turbines for water industry. World Pumps.
17 2009;2009:22-3.
(EPFL); 2012.
18 [25] Ramos H, Borga A. Pumps as turbines: an unconventional solution to
[3] Hossain IM, Ferdous SM, Salehin S, Saleque AM, Jamal T. Pump-as-turbine
19 (PAT) for small scale power generation: A comparative analysis. Developments energy production. Urban Water. 1999;1:261-3.
20 in Renewable Energy Technology (ICDRET), 2014 3rd International [26] Derakhshan S, Nourbakhsh A. Theoretical, numerical and experimental
21 Conference on the2014. p. 1-5. investigation of centrifugal pumps in reverse operation. Experimental Thermal
[4] Birol F. World energy outlook 2010. International Energy Agency. Paris- and Fluid Science. 2008;32:1620-7.
22 [27] Arriaga M. Pump as turbinea pico-hydro alternative in Lao People's
France2010. p. 736.
23 [5] Kaunda CS, Kimambo CZ, Nielsen TK. A technical discussion on Democratic Republic. Renewable Energy. 2010;35:1109-15.
24 microhydropower technology and its turbines. Renewable and Sustainable [28] Williams A. Pumps as turbines: a user's guide: IntermediateTechnology
25 Energy Reviews. 2014;35:445-59. Publications, London; 1995.
[6] Ipcc. Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change [29] Singh P. Optimization of the internal hydraulic and of system design in
26 pumps as turbines with field implementation and evaluation [PhD Thesis]:
Mitigation. United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA: Cambridge University
27 Press; 2011. University of Karlsruhe, German; 2005.
28 [7] Kaunda CS, Kimambo CZ, Nielsen TK. Potential of small-scale hydropower [30] Maher P, Smith N, Williams A. Assessment of pico hydro as an option for
29 for electricity generation in Sub-Saharan Africa. ISRN Renewable Energy. off-grid electrification in Kenya. Renewable Energy. 2003;28:1357-69.
2012;2012. [31] 3kW pump as turbine mocro hydro at Mae Wei village, Tak provience.
30 <http://palangthai.blogspot.de/2008/02/3-kw-pump-as-turbine-microhydro-at-
[8] International Hydropower Association ICoLD, Implementing Agreement on
31 mae.html >. 2008.
Hydropower Technologies and Programmes/International Energy Agency,
32 Canadian Hydropower Association. Hydropower and the world's energy future. [32] GTZ N. Micro-hydropower factsheet, GTZ - MHP Project. Jakarta Pusat,
33 2000. Indonesia 1999.
34 [9] Brown A, Mller S, Dobrotkova Z. Renewable energy: Markets and [33] Singh P, Rao A, Ramasubramaniam V, Kumar A. Performance evaluation
prospects by technology. IEA information paper. 2011. of the pump as turbinebased micro hydro project in Kinko village, Tanzania.
35 Himalaya small hydropower summit. 2006:156-7.
[10] Electricity Generation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_generation.
36 2016. [34] Hydropower from pump as turbines, World pumps.
37 [11] Ismail MA, Othman AK, Islam S, Zen H. End Suction Centrifugal Pump <http://csmres.co.uk/cs.public.upd/article-downloads/Hydropower-from-
38 Operating in Turbine Mode for Microhydro Applications. Advances in pumps-asturbines.pdf>. 2012.
Mechanical Engineering. 2014;6:139868. [35] Using pumps as turbines. <http://www.smallhydropower.com/pumps.htm>.
39 [36] Pumps used as Turbines: Trend-setters in Energy Generation and Recovery.
[12] Mishra S, Singal SK, Khatod DK. Optimal installation of small hydropower
40 plantA review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2011;15:3862-9. <http://www.ksb.com/linkableblob/ksb-en/111086-
41 [13] Nwosu C, Madueme T. Recycled micro hydropower generation using 356644/data/Pumpe_als_Turbineendata.pdf>.
42 hydraulic ram pump\ n (HYDRAM). IMPACT Int J Res Eng Technol (IMPACT [37] Paish O. Micro-hydropower: status and prospects. Proceedings of the
IJRET). 2013;1:1-10. Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy.
43 2002;216:31-40.
[14] Jain SV, Patel RN. Investigations on pump running in turbine mode: A
44 review of the state-of-the-art. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. [38] Kueny J. PART I Objectives for small hydro technology. Institute National
45 2014;30:841-68. Polytechnique de Grenoble2003. p. 1-35.
46 [15] Prasad V, Shukla S, Joshi S. Performance characteristics of pump as turbine. [39] Lueneburg R, Nelson R. Hydraulic power recovery turbines. Centrifugal
47 Indian Pumps. 2006:5-9. PumpsDesign and Application, second ed, Gulf Publishing Company.
[16] Williams A. Pumps as turbines for low cost micro hydro power. Renewable 1992:246-82.
48 [40] Mishra S, Singal S, Khatod D. Optimal installation of small hydropower
Energy. 1996;9:1227-34.
49 [17] Teuteberg B. Design of a pump-as-turbine for an abalone farm. final report plantA review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2011;15:3862-9.
50 for mechanical project.878. [41] Mishra S, Singal S, Khatod D. Costing of a Small Hydropower Projects.
51 [18] Motwani K, Jain S, Patel R. Cost analysis of pump as turbine for pico International Journal of Engineering and Technology. 2012;4:239.
hydropower plantsa case study. Procedia Engineering. 2013;51:721-6. [42] Hosseini S, Forouzbakhsh F, Rahimpoor M. Determination of the optimal
52 installation capacity of small hydro-power plants through the use of technical,
[19] Kusakana K. A survey of innovative technologies increasing the viability of
53 micro-hydropower as a cost effective rural electrification option in South Africa. economic and reliability indices. Energy Policy. 2005;33:1948-56.
54 Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2014;37:370-9. [43] Tamm A, Brten A, Stoffel B, Ludwig G. Analysis of a standard pump in
55 [20] Giugni M, Fontana N, Portolano D. Energy saving policy in water reverse operation using CFD. 20th IAHR symposium. Charlotte, North Carolina
distribution networks. Renewable Energy Power Qual J. 2009;7:1-6. USA 2000.
56 [44] Franc J-P. La cavitation: mcanismes physiques et aspects industriels: EDP
[21] Daniela Popescu AD, Denisa Rusinaru. Study of Centrifugal Pump
57 Operating as Turbine in Small Hydropower Plants. wseas conference: Recent Sciences; 1995.
58 researches of electric power and energy systems 2013. p. 285-8. [45] Chapallaz J-M, Eichenberger P, Fischer G. Manual on pumps used as
59 [22] Singh R, Rishabh Gupta, Anuraag Singh, and PMV Subbarao. Guided turbines: Vieweg; 1992.
60 pump-as-turbine: design and development for pico-level energy generation.
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 Maxime B. et Al. Investigation on pump as turbine (PAT) selection and performance prediction
3 for micro hydropower schemes: A review
4
5 [46] Fraenkel P, Paish O, Bokalders V, Harvey A, Brown A, Edwards R. Micro- [73] Hanckock J. Centrifugal pump or water turbine. Pipe Line News. 1963:25-
6 hydro power, a guide for development workers. 1991. London: Intermediate 7.
7 Technology Publications Ltd. [74] Lewinsky-Kesslitz H. Pumpen als Turbinen fur Kleinkraftwerke.
8 [47] Fernandez J, Blanco E, Parrondo J, Stickland M, Scanlon T. Performance Wasserwirtschaft. 1987;77:531-7.
of a centrifugal pump running in inverse mode. Proceedings of the Institution of [75] Schmiedl E. Serien-Kreiselpumpen im Turbinenbetrieb. Pumpentagung:
9 Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy. 2004;218:265-71. Karlsruhe, Germany. 1988.
10 [48] Nautiyal H, Varun V, Kumar A, Yadav SYS. Experimental investigation of [76] Hossain IM, Ferdous S, Salehin S, Saleque AM, Jamal T. Pump-as-turbine
11 centrifugal pump working as turbine for small hydropower systems. Energy (PAT) for small scale power generation: A comparative analysis. Developments
12 Science and technology. 2011;1:79-86. in Renewable Energy Technology (ICDRET), 2014 3rd International
[49] Singh P, Nestmann F. An optimization routine on a prediction and selection Conference on the: IEEE; 2014. p. 1-5.
13 model for the turbine operation of centrifugal pumps. Experimental Thermal and [77] Gantar M. Propeller pumps running as turbines. Proceedings of the
14 Fluid Science. 2010;34:152-64. conference on hydraulic machinery. Ljubljana, Slovenia 1988. p. 23748.
15 [50] Williams A. The turbine performance of centrifugal pumps: a comparison [78] Anderson H. Modern developments in the use of large single-entry
16 of prediction methods. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, centrifugal pumps. Proceedings of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers.
Part A: Journal of Power and Energy. 1994;208:59-66. 1993;177.
17 [51] Ahmad RPSaN. Selection procedure of centrifugal pump to be used as [79] Yang S-S, Derakhshan S, Kong F-Y. Theoretical, numerical and
18 turbine for small hydro stations. National Seminar on Small HydroPower experimental prediction of pump as turbine performance. Renewable Energy.
19 Project-CIVSEM'93. Coimbatore, India1993. p. 64-71. 2012;48:507-13.
20 [52] Barrio R, Fernndez J, Parrondo J, Blanco E. Performance prediction of a [80] Carravetta A, Conte M, Fecarotta O, Ramos H. Evaluation of PAT
21 centrifugal pump working in direct and reverse mode using computational fluid Performances by Modified Affinity Law. Procedia Engineering. 2014;89:581-7.
dynamics. International Conference on Renewable Energies and Power Quality, [81] Raman N, Hussein I, Palanisamy K, Foo B. An experimental investigation
22 Granada, Spain2010. of pump as turbine for micro hydro application. IOP Conference Series: Earth
23 [53] Suarda M, Suarnadwipa N, Adnyana WB. Experimental work on and Environmental Science: IOP Publishing; 2013. p. 012064.
24 modification of impeller tips of a centrifugal pump as a turbine. Proceedings of [82] Raman N, Hussein I. Reconnaissance study to identify micro hydro potential
25 the 2nd International Conference on Sustainable Energy and Environment sites in Malaysia. European journal of scientific research. 2010;41:354-72.
(SEE06)2006. p. 21-3. [83] Singh P, Kshirsagar J, Caglar S, Nestmann F. Experimental and
26 [54] Avellan F. Course of hydraulic turbomachines-2010. Ecole Polytechnique Computational Studies of the Effect of Casing Eye Ribon the Swirl Flow at the
27 federale de Lausanne, Switzerland.; 2010. Exit of a Pump as Turbine. ASME 2004 Heat Transfer/Fluids Engineering
28 [55] Derakhshan S, Nourbakhsh A. Experimental study of characteristic curves Summer Conference: American Society of Mechanical Engineers; 2004. p. 85-
29 of centrifugal pumps working as turbines in different specific speeds. 93.
Experimental thermal and fluid science. 2008;32:800-7. [84] Singh P, Nestmann F. A consolidated model for the turbine operation of
30 [56] Sharma RL. Pumps as turbines (PAT) for small hydro. Proceedings of the centrifugal pumps. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power.
31 international conference on hydro power development in Himalayas 1998. p. 2011;133:063002.
32 13746. [85] Yang S, Kong F, Jiang W, Qu X. Research on rotational speed to the
33 [57] Alatorre-Frenk C. Cost minimisation in micro-hydro systems using pumps- influence of pump as turbine. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental
34 as-turbines [PhD Thesis]: University of Warwick; 1994. Science: IOP Publishing; 2012. p. 042023.
[58] D S. Centrifugal pumps in reverse, an alternative to conventional turbines. [86] Carravetta A, Fecarotta O, Ramos H. Numerical simulation on Pump As
35 Waste Water International 1988;3:13-7. Turbine: mesh reliability and performance concerns. Clean Electrical Power
36 [59] Fraser. Modular small hydro configuration, Report Nyserda, Albany. 1981. (ICCEP), 2011 International Conference on: IEEE; 2011. p. 169-74.
37 [60] Nicholas WG. Using Pumps as Turbines. Selection and Application. Hydro [87] Ismail MA, Othman AK, Zen H. Numerical Simulation on End Suction
38 88 Third International Conference on Small Hydro1988. Centrifugal Pump Running in Inverse Flow for Microhydro Applications.
[61] Hochreutiner F. Centrale hydrolectrique de Tannuwald. Hidroenergia Applied Mechanics and Materials: Trans Tech Publ; 2015. p. 358-62.
39 International conference and exhibition1991. p. 98-104. [88] Pscoa J, Silva F, Pinheiro J, Martins D. A new approach for predicting
40 [62] Nautiyal H, Kumar A. Reverse running pumps analytical, experimental and PAT-pumps operating point from direct pumping mode characteristics. Journal
41 computational study: a review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. of Scientific and Industrial Research. 2012;71:144-8.
42 2010;14:2059-67. [89] Nautiyal H, Kumar V, Thakur A. CFD analysis on pumps working as
[63] Stepanoff AJ. Centrifugal and axial flow pumps, design and applications. turbines. Hydro Nepal: Journal of Water, Energy and Environment. 2010;6:35-
43 New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.; 1957. 7.
44 [64] Childs S. Convert pumps to turbines and recover HP. Hydrocarbon [90] Rawal S, Kshirsagar J. Numerical simulation on a pump operating in a
45 Processing and Petroleum Refiner. 1962;41:173-4. turbine mode. Proceedings of the 23rd International Pump Users Symposium:
46 [65] Sharma RK. Small hydroelectric projectsuse of centrifugal pumps as Texas A&M University; 2007. p. 21-7.
47 turbines. Kirloskar Electric Co, Bangalore, India. 1984. [91] Barrio R, Fernandez J, Blanco E, Parrondo J, Marcos A. Performance
[66] Gopalakrishnan S. Power recovery turbines for the process industry. characteristics and internal flow patterns in a reverse-running pumpturbine.
48 Proceedings of the Third International Pump Symposium(Houston). Texas Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of
49 A&M University 1986. p. 3-11. Mechanical Engineering Science. 2012;226:695-708.
50 [67] Diederich H. Verwendung von kreiselpumpen als turbinen. KSB Techn Ber [92] Bogdanovi-Jovanovi JB, Milenkovi DR, Svrkota DM, Bogdanovi B,
51 1967. p. 30-6. Spasi T. Pumps used as turbines power recovery, energy efficiency, CFD
[68] Grover K. Conversion of pumps to turbines. GSA Inter corp, Katonah, New analysis. Thermal Science. 2014;18:1029-40.
52 York1982. [93] Sedl M, oukal J, Komrek M. CFD analysis of middle stage of multistage
53 [69] Garay PN. Using pumps as hydro turbines. Hydro Rev. 1990;9:52-61. pump operating in turbine regime. Engineering Mechanics. 2009;16:413-21.
54 [70] Burton J, Muluget A. Running centrifugal pumps as micro-hydro turbines [94] Patel JB, Ajaypalsinh G. Barad, Rajesh V. Chaudhari, Manish D. Patel, and
55 performance prediction using the area ratio method. Renewable Energy, Harshad C. Patel. Experimental Investigation of Centrifugal Pump Regular and
Technology and The Environment. 1992:2839-47. Reverse Mode. International Journal for Scientific Research and Development.
56 [71] Hanif CM. Applied hydraulic transients. Van Nostrand Reinhold Company 2015;2.
57 New York; 1987. [95] Yang S-S, Wang C, Chen K, Yuan X. Research on Blade Thickness
58 [72] Ventrone G NG. Utilizzazione dellenergia idrica su piccola scala:Pompa Influencing Pump as Turbine. Advances in Mechanical Engineering.
59 come turbina. lenergia electrica. 1982;59:101-6. 2014;6:190530.
60
61
62
63
64
65
1
2 CHINESE JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
3
4 [96] Giosio D, Henderson A, Walker J, Brandner P, Sargison J, Gautam P. BINAMA Maxime, born in 1985, is currently following his PhD
5 Design and performance evaluation of a pump-as-turbine micro-hydro test
program in Power Engineering and Engineering Thermophysics
6 facility with incorporated inlet flow control. Renewable Energy. 2015;78:1-6.
[97] Yang S-S, Kong F-Y, Jiang W-M, Qu X-Y. Effects of impeller trimming at Harbin Institute of technology, China. His research interests
7
influencing pump as turbine. Computers & Fluids. 2012;67:72-8. include the optimization design and analysis of unstable flows in
8 [98] Jain SV, Swarnkar A, Motwani KH, Patel RN. Effects of impeller diameter reversible Pump turbines. He received his Masters degree of
9 and rotational speed on performance of pump running in turbine mode. Energy
Fluid Mechanics from Harbin Institute of Technology, China in
10 Conversion and Management. 2015;89:808-24.
[99] Derakhshan S, Mohammadi B, Nourbakhsh A. Efficiency Improvement of 2015.
11
Centrifugal Reverse Pumps. Journal of Fluids Engineering. 2009;131:021103-. Tel: +86-15846397463; E-mail: binamamaxime@hit.edu.cn
12 [100] Derakhshan S, Mohammadi B, Nourbakhsh A. Incomplete sensitivities for
13 3D radial turbomachinery blade optimization. Computers & Fluids.
14 SU Wentao, born in 1984, is currently a post-doc at Harbin
2008;37:1354-63.
15 [101] Moffat R. Contributions to the theory of single-sample uncertainty analysis. Institute of Technology, China. His research interests are in the
16 ASME, Transactions, Journal of Fluids Engineering. 1982;104:250-58. fields of fluid machinery and computational fluid dynamics. He
[102] Yang S-S, Liu H-L, Kong F-Y, Xia B, Tan L-W. Effects of the radial gap received his Ph.D. in Department of Nuclear Engineering, Kyoto
17 between impeller tips and volute tongue influencing the performance and
18 University, Japan.
pressure pulsations of pump as turbine. Journal of Fluids Engineering.
19 2014;136:054501. Tel: +86-451-86403740; E-mail: suwentao@hit.edu.cn
20 [103] Yang S-S, Liu H-L, Kong F-Y, Dai C, Dong L. Experimental, Numerical,
and Theoretical Research on Impeller Diameter Influencing Centrifugal Pump- LI Xiaobin, born in 1984, is currently a lecturer of School of
21 as-Turbine. Journal of Energy Engineering. 2013;139:299-307.
22 Energy Science and Engineering at Harbin Institute of
23 Technology, China. His research interests are in the fields of
24 fluid machinery, microscaled flow and heat transfer, and
25 experimental fluid mechanics. He received his Ph.D. in
Biographical notes Engineering Thermophysics from Harbin Institute of
26
27 Technology in 2012, and accomplished his post-doc research on
LI Fengchen, born in 1971, is currently a full professor at Harbin microscaled flow in the University of Tokyo in 2015.
28 Institute of Technology, China. His research interests include
29 Tel: +86-451-86403254; E-mail: lixb@hit.edu.cn
turbulent drag-reducing flow with additives and heat transfer,
30 micro-scaled flow and heat transfer, gas-liquid two-phase flows,
31 ZHAO Yue, born in 1967, is currently the director of Hydro-
and magnetohydrodynamics of liquid metal. He received his turbine lab at Harbin Institute of Large Electric Machinery,
32
Ph.D. in Engineering Thermophysics from Harbin Institute of China. His research interests are flow measurement, hydraulic
33
Technology in 2004. design in fluid machinery. He received his bachelor degree of
34
Tel: +86-451-86403254; E-mail: lifch@hit.edu.cn Mechanical Manufacturing at Jilin University of Technology,
35
36 China.
37 Tel: +86-13936624913; E-mail: zhaoyue1967@sina.com
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65