Anda di halaman 1dari 7

See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232216978

Comparative LCA of the use of biodiesel, diesel


and gasoline for transportation

Article in Journal of Cleaner Production January 2012


Impact Factor: 3.84 DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.07.026

CITATIONS READS

53 469

2 authors:

Evanthia A. Nanaki Christopher J. Koroneos


University of Western Macedonia National Technical University of Athens
35 PUBLICATIONS 276 CITATIONS 138 PUBLICATIONS 1,684 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

All in-text references underlined in blue are linked to publications on ResearchGate, Available from: Christopher J. Koroneos
letting you access and read them immediately. Retrieved on: 14 June 2016
Journal of Cleaner Production 20 (2012) 14e19

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Cleaner Production


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jclepro

Comparative LCA of the use of biodiesel, diesel and gasoline for transportation
Evanthia A. Nanaki*, Christopher J. Koroneos 1
Interdisciplinary Postgraduate Program, Environment and Development, School of Rural and Surveying Engineering, National Technical University of Athens,
Iroon Polytecniou 9, Zografou 157 80, Athens, Greece

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: The energy fuels used for in the Greek transport sector are made up of gasoline consumed by auto-
Received 4 October 2010 mobiles, diesel oil consumed by taxis, trucks, maritime transport and railroads, and jet fuel used in the
Received in revised form aircrafts. All these fuels are hydrocarbons that emit great amounts of CO2 which has a major impact in
7 February 2011
the global warming phenomenon. The issues relating to climate change, the soaring energy prices, and
Accepted 20 July 2011
Available online 11 August 2011
the uncertainty of future oil supplies, have created a strong interest in alternative transportation fuels.
During the past decade biofuels in the form of blended gasoline and biodiesel have begun to nd place in
energy economy. The Greek car market shows a remarkably low rate in the penetration of biodiesel
Keywords:
Life cycle assessments
compared to the average European Union market. This work compares the environmental impacts of the
Greece use of gasoline, diesel and biodiesel in Greece using as a tool for the comparison the Life Cycle
Biodiesel Assessment (LCA) methodology. The environmental impacts taken into consideration include: organic
Fossil fuels respiratory effects, inorganic respiratory effects, fossil fuels, acidication e eutrophication, greenhouse
effect, ecotoxicity and carginogenic effects. From the environmental point of view, biodiesel appears
attractive since its use results in signicant reductions of GHG emissions in comparison to gasoline and
diesel. It also has lower well-to-wheel emissions of methane. However, the use of biodiesel as trans-
portation fuel increases emissions of PM10, nitrous oxide, nitrogen oxides (NOx) as well as nutrients such
as nitrogen and phosphorous; the latter are the main agents for eutrophication.
This study can be considered as an opportunity for further research and evaluate the available options
for a sustainable transportation system planning in Greece.
2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction similar attributes to fossil fuels e can be used, using existing


infrastructures and being utilized by the current engines not only in
In Europe the transportation sector is responsible for 27.4% of all a mixed mode but also in pure state (especially for biodiesel).
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions which have a great contribution Nevertheless, a social opposition has risen during the past years
to climate change (Eurostat, 2007). In addition, the forecasted EU- against biofuels, raising concerns about environmental sustain-
25 energy use demands in 2010, are estimated to be around 390 ability, energy utilization concerning the energy performance,
Mtoe (European Union, 2006). According to Kyoto Protocol, for the feedstock availability and production cost.
year 2020, the target of reducing GHG of the transportation sector is The development of the biofuels industry in Europe has led to
set to 20% below 1990 levels for all EU-27 Member States of EU. the performance of many environmental studies, which led to
Actions such as reducing energy use, increasing energy efciency a very thorough knowledge of energy and greenhouse gases
and carbon sequestration, the decarbonization of energy supply by balance over their whole life cycles (De Calvedo Macedo et al.,
expansion of renewable energies, are considered a viable solution 2004; Ecobilan, 2002; Joint Research Center, 2006; UFOP, 2008).
for a sustainable transport future. An increased usage of biofuels In addition, a lot of comparative studies concerning biodiesel and
can contribute towards the reduction of CO2 emissions in road fossil diesel fuel have been made (Ceuterick and Spirinckx, 1997;
trafc. In addition, biofuels produced from waste residues e having Gover et al., 1996; Coulon et al., 1996; Kaltschmitt and Reinhardt,
1997; Sheehan et al., 1998; Lechon et al., 2006; De Nocker et al.,
1998; Van Gerpen, 2000), reecting the ongoing interest in the
environmental assessment of biofuels.
* Corresponding author. Tel.: 30 6945555002.
The United States, Brazil and China are the worlds largest
E-mail addresses: evananaki@gmail.com (E.A. Nanaki), koroneos@aix.meng.
auth.gr (C.J. Koroneos). ethanol producers, producing 4.8, 4.5 and 1 billion gallons
1
Tel.: 30 2310995968. respectively in 2006 (Ethanolfra, 2006). In Europe, more biodiesel is

0959-6526/$ e see front matter 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2011.07.026
E.A. Nanaki, C.J. Koroneos / Journal of Cleaner Production 20 (2012) 14e19 15

Table 1 comparable to the production of fossil fuels, from an environmental


Biodiesel production plants (Hellenic Department Ministry of Development, 2004, point of view, taking into account all stages of the life cycle of these
2006).
products.
Facility Annual capacity Location Start
(ton/year)
2. Legislation e Greek experience
Hellenic Biopetroleum Industrial 40,000 Kilkis 2005
and Commercial S.A
VERT OIL S.A. 25,000 Thessaloniki 2006 The Directive 2003/30/EC (European Parliament, 2003) on the
Pettas Industrial and Commercial S.A. 60,000 Patra 2006 promotion of the use of biofuels and other renewable fuels for
Agroinvest S.A. 200,000 Fthiotida 2006 transport, urges all Member States to ensure that a minimum
Elinoil S.A. 80,000 Volos 2006
Biodiesel LTD 20,000 Thessaloniki 2005
proportion, 2% for biofuels, and 5.75% for other renewable fuels, be
part of markets. Following this Directive, the Greek government has
Total 425,000
launched late in 2005 a new law L3423/05 (FEK 304/A 13.12.2005)
for the introduction of biofuels in the existing Greek fuel market.
The First National Report estimates that 148,000 ton of biodiesel
produced than ethanol, with rapeseed used as the primary feed- would be needed to fulll the 5.75% target by the end of 2010
stock. The total EU-27 biodiesel production for 2007 was over 5.7 (Hellenic Department Ministry of Development, 2004).
million metric tones, an increase of 16.8% from the 2006 gures The distribution of biodiesel in Greece started in December 2005
(European Biodiesel Board, 2009). Germany with a production of when the rst batches were distributed to reneries by Hellenic
2890 thousand metric tones was the leader in 2007. France and Biopetroleum S.A. The blend of 2% contentment of biodiesel, by
Italy followed with productions of 872 thousand metric tones and volume, in the automotive diesel, has been distributed to all
363 respectively. Biodiesel is mainly produced from oil crops (such consumers since February 2006. This percentage was raised to 3.5%
as rapeseed and sunower), waste cooking oils or animal fats. The by volume (71,851 ton) by about the end of 2006, and it reached the
extracted oils are converted by transesterication with an alcohol level of 5% (97,695 ton) in 2007 (Hellenic Department Ministry of
(usually methanol) to produce biodiesel. Biodiesel is generally Development, 2006). Table 1 presents the biodiesel production
accepted to be fully blendable with conventional diesel (blending plants that currently operate in Greece. According to the available
up to 5e10%), except for certain cases when using high percentage data, a further eight biodiesel production units are at the initial
biodiesel blends or neat biodiesel. In the case of Greece, the use of stages of design and construction: four with a capacity of 5000 ton,
biodiesel as an alternative diesel fuel, will improve the environ- two with capacity of 11,000 ton, one with a capacity of 22,000 ton
ment, reduce imports and increase the use of renewable fuels. and one with a capacity of 100,000 ton (Hellenic Department
Biodiesel can be produced from various vegetable and/or animal Ministry of Development, 2006). It should be mentioned that the
oils with methanol or ethanol yielding methyl or ethyl ester with raw materials used for the biodiesel production units in 2006,
glycerol as by-product. comprise of about 70% of imported seed oils e mostly rapeseed and
Nevertheless the production of biodiesel entails emissions to the soyabean oils e while the remaining 30% consist of domestically
environment coming from the use of fertilizers during plantation produced oils such as cottonseed, sunower and used cooking oils
phase, and emissions from fuel use during oil extraction, trans- (European Biodiesel Board, 2006). The cost of producing biodiesel
portation, etc. Thus, the environmental implications of biodiesel from sunower is 0.53V/lt, and its breakdown in distinct cost
production need to be addressed. LCA can be used for such an components is shown in Fig. 1.
evaluation. The objective of this study is to perform a comparative The total agricultural area of Greece is 3.8 billion hectars (ha)
analysis of biodiesel produced from rapeseed, and conventional mainly consisting of arable (56%) and tree crops (30%) (National
diesel as well as petrol with the implementation of the LCA Statistical Service of Greece (NSSG), 2004). The main vegetable
methodology. This comparison has been achieved using the Eco- oils produced in Greece consist of soy oil, sunower oil and
Indicator 99 method (Goedkoop and Priensma, 2001) and it has cottonseed oil with respective seeds being either domestically
addressed the question of whether the production of biodiesel is produced or imported e mostly in the case of soy. In 2005 most of

Revenues from glycerine

Revenues from meal

Depreciation

Variable cost

Labor cost

Raw material cost

-0.3 -0.2 -0.1 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
Fig. 1. Costs and revenues from biodiesel production (Agricultural University of Athens, 2000).
16 E.A. Nanaki, C.J. Koroneos / Journal of Cleaner Production 20 (2012) 14e19

Table 2 Table 3
Properties of fossil fuels and biodiesel (European Commission, 2004). Energy used for the production of oilseed rape (Hellenic Department
Ministry of Development, 2004; MEET Project, 1997; Jossart et al., 2005).
Fuel Energy content (MJ/I) Energy content ratio
Bioethanol (BE) 21.2 1.472 (BE/FG) Rapeseed (kg/ha)
Fossil gasoline (FG) 31.2 0.679 (FG/BE) Energy consumed (MJ/kg) 110,3
Biodiesel 32.8 1.088 (BD/FD) N fertilizer 144
Fossil diesel (FD) 35.7 0.919 (FD/BD) K2O 74
P2O5 74
Pesticides 2.2
Rapeseed produced 1,300
the oilseeds produced locally were cottonseeds (720,000 ton),
which produced 39,000 ton of cottonseed oil. About 26,000 ton of
sunower seeds were produced in 2005; the production increased Table 4
to 31,000 ton in 2006. Both soy oil and cottonseed oil have average Mass and energy balance of biodiesel production (Jossart et al., 2005).
prices around 600 V/tn, while sunower oil price is much higher,
Heat Electricity Chemicals By-products
reaching the level of 890 V/tn in 2004 (Hellenic Department (MJ/t RME) (kWh/t RME) (kg/t RME) (kg/t RME)
Ministry of Development, 2004). As far as the oil crops are con-
Drying 812 33 e e
cerned, the main existing options consist of cotton, sunower and Extraction 2317 106 Hexane:2.7 Meal: 1582
soy. Rening 162 11 e e
The consumption of automotive diesel fuel used in transport in Esterication 947 37 Methanol: 109 Glycerin: 100
Greece for year 2002 amounted to 1,925,000 tons (Hellenic
Department Ministry of Development, 2004). It is noted that the
biodiesel distributed in the Greek market meets the EN 14214  Impact assessment
specications. The end products under the specications of EN  Interpretation
14214 for bio-auto fuels have valuable energy content representing
a good degree of replacement relative to fossil fuels (Table 2). The goal of this study is to evaluate the environmental perfor-
Nevertheless, Greece has low Hydrocarbon Tax for fossil fuels mance of biodiesel, based on a life cycle perspective. The assess-
which makes the competitive position of biofuels more difcult: ment includes the extraction of primary raw materials as well as
Greece (30 V/l), Spain (40.3 V/l), Germany (66.5 V/l), UK (68 V/l), the combustion of the fuels in the car engine. The system bound-
France (59 V/l). aries do not include the production of capital goods, risks and
human labor. Final transportation to the fuel station is not
3. Methodology considered, since the average distance as well as the means of
transportation are assumed to be the same for all the fuels. Greece
Life Cycle Assessment has been chosen as the methodology to is considered to be the geographical reference area for the fuels life
qualitatively evaluate the environmental loads of the studied fuels. cycle. As far as the functional unit is concerned, this is dened in the
Analysis of a system under LCA encompasses the extraction of raw ISO standard as a quantied performance of a product system for
materials and energy resources, the conversion of these resources use as a reference unit in a life cycle assessment. In this study,
into the desired product, the utilization of the product by the 100 km e covered with a middle size and recent car e is chosen as
consumer, and nally the disposal, reuse or recycle of the product the functional unit. Life Cycle Assessment is conducted using the
after its service life. The Society of Environmental Toxicology and Eco-Indicator 99 method, in the hierchist perspective.
Chemistry and the International Organization for Standardization Biodiesel is assumed to be rapeseed methyl ester (RME), which
(ISO 14040, 1997; ISO 14041, 1998; ISO 14042, 2000a; ISO 14043, is produced by transesterication of rapeseed oil (Van Gerpen,
2000b) developed in the 1990s the LCA methodology. The meth- 2005). Based on Fig. 2, which presents the life cycle of biodiesel
odology used falls under the international standards series ISO and the fossil fuels, it is seen that the rst stage in the biodiesel
14040. The main stages in the aforementioned methodology chain concerns the cultivation of the rapeseed grains. After the
include: growth and harvest of plants, the grains are dried and then oil is
extracted in two steps, followed by an extraction with an organic
 Goal denition and scoping solvent (hexane). The solvent is separated and recycled, while
 Inventory analysis a small quantity is lost (emission to air). Oil and rapeseed meal are
generated. Transesterication of the oil produces methyl esters
(biodiesel) and glycerol, which is puried and then used in chem-
Biodiesel Fossil Fuels
ical industry.
Production of rapeseed The production of the fertilizers and pesticides, soils emissions
Extraction of crude oil
of N2O, the consumption and emissions of the tractors (fertilizing,
Drying, storage& transport
Transport of crude oil
Table 5
By-products
Rapeseed oil production Energetic consumption and exhaust emissions of vehicles (US Environmental
Refinery
Protection Agency, 2002; United States Environmental Protection Agency, 2005).
Biodiesel Distribution Petrol Diesel Biodiesel
Fossil fuels Distribution

Consumption (MJ/100 km) 223.5 183.1 183.1


Biodiesel Vehicle Fossil Fuel Vehicle CO2 fossil (kg/100 km) 16.6 13.4 0.74
CH4 (mg/100 km) 2.4 7.6 7.6
N2O (mg/100 km) 0.129 0.0645 0.0645
Transportation Service NOx (mg/100 km) 10.2 25.6 28.2
Particulates (mg/100 km) 0.5 3.56 1.89
NMVOC (mg/100 km) 2.53 9.59 3.17
Fig. 2. Life cycle for biodiesel and fossil fuels.
E.A. Nanaki, C.J. Koroneos / Journal of Cleaner Production 20 (2012) 14e19 17

100
90
80

relative impact (%) 70


60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Organic Inorganic Fossil fuels Greenhouse Acidification- Ecotoxicity Carcinogenic
respiratory respiratory effect eutrophication effecs
effects effects

Petrol Diesel Biodiesel

Fig. 3. Comparison of the environmental impacts of the automotive fuels.

tillage, sowing, harvesting, and transport) as well as the valoriza- Protection Agency, 2005). Table 5 lists the exhaust emissions and
tion of by-products are taken into consideration. These data are fuel consumptions of the petrol and the diesel cars.
listed in Table 3 (Hellenic Department Ministry of Development,
2004; MEET Project, 1997; Jossart et al., 2005). All the trans-
portation steps are taken into consideration. Table 4 presents the 4. Environmental impacts
energetic and chemical consumptions of the rapeseed processes
(Jossart et al., 2005). As far as the nal use is concerned, it is noted The biofuels environmental impact depends on different factors.
that the exhaust emissions and fuel consumptions of the vehicles The raw materials used to obtain the biofuels, the different
were calculated on the basis of those of the fossil fuel vehicles. It is production processes and the nal use can determine the envi-
assumed that the efciencies of the motors (in MJ/km) and the ronmental balance of biofuels introduction. Biofuels supply chain
greenhouse gas emissions (g/km) e with the exception of fossil follows the typical approach of biomass production, biofuel pro-
carbon dioxide e to be the same for the biodiesel and the fossil fuels cessing, distribution and consumption. Several climatology factors
(Joint Research Center, 2006; Institute for Energy and (type of soil, weather etc.) have a strong inuence on environ-
Environmental Research (IFEU), 2004). According to EPA (US mental impact. Additionally, other signicant factors are the past
Environmental Protection Agency, 2002), the use of biodiesel land-use, the production or not of by-products, the technological
leads to a decrease of the emissions of particulates (47%) and VOC process path as well as the relative use of the end fuel either in
(67%), but also to an increase of NOx emissions (10%). Based on these a mixed or in a pure mode.
gures and the emissions of fossil fuels, the emissions of a middle Comparative LCA has been carried out for biodiesel, gasoline and
sized car running on biodiesel were calculated (Table 5). diesel. The results on fossil energy use and GHG emissions along
Finally, the life cycle of gasoline and diesel is established using the whole chain show the environmental benets of biodiesel use
the SimaPro 5.0 Pre: Simapro databases. Greenhouse gases emis- in Greece. Environmental impacts associated with air emissions
sions as well as fuel consumptions data came from the comparison and fossil fuel usage are shown in Fig. 3, where the environmental
of literature sources (Joint Research Center, 2006; Institute for proles of the three automotive fuels are compared for the different
Energy and Environmental Research (IFEU), 2004). Calculations impact categories taken into account in this study. The environ-
concerning NOx, VOC and particulate emissions from the car are mental impacts taken into consideration include: organic respira-
based on the Annual certication test results, 2005, of the US tory effects, inorganic respiratory effects, fossil fuels, acidication e
Environmental Protection Agency (United States Environmental

30
1,2
25
1
Eco-score

0,8 20

0,6 15

0,4 10

0,2
5
0
Petrol Diesel Biodiesel 0
CO CH4 NOx N2O PM10 PMunsp. SOx CO2

Health Ecosystem quality Resources BIODIESEL DIESEL

Fig. 4. Environmental impacts after weighting. Fig. 5. Emissions (gr/kg) of biodiesel and diesel (Sheehan et al., 1998).
18 E.A. Nanaki, C.J. Koroneos / Journal of Cleaner Production 20 (2012) 14e19

Table 6 concerning the vehicles per eet type in Greece in 2005 (National
Vehicles per eet type in Greece, 2005 (National Statistical Service Statistical Service of Greece (NSSG), 2007). Nevertheless, activities
of Greece (NSSG), 2007).
on such direction are still on a pilot scale. For this reason initiatives
Fleet type Number of vehicles should be taken in promoting and supporting the conversion of
Passenger cars 4,269,569 eets to alternative propulsion. Moreover, the development of
Taxi 33,560 biodiesel production in Greece is expected to reduce costs of raw
Buses materials for biodiesel production, thus further increasing their
Private use 11,760 competitiveness in the Hellenic fuel market.
Public use 15,069 A strategic and integrated transportation planning can evaluate
Light and heavy duty the results of a comparative fossil fuel and biofuel Life Cycle
Private use 1,149,988 Assessment in conjunction with a set of measures such as the
Public use 36,495
organization of training campaigns for eet owners and operators,
Motorbikes 1,124,172 based on dissemination of experiences from other countries/cities
Total 6,640,613 in relation to biodiesel; as well as the presentation of information
regarding fuel and investment costs, maintenance and operational
eutrophication, greenhouse effect, ecotoxicity and carginogenic safety issues. It should be also mentioned that a green public
effects. The fuel with the highest contribution to a particular transport eet can be an excellent example for motivating citizens
environmental effect is indicated with 100% bar. The use of bio- to switch to alternative energy.
diesel instead of fossil diesel fuel produces environmental advan- The use of biodiesel in a eet of diesel engine vehicles in the
tages as well as disadvantages. Biodiesel is benecial with respect region of Athens e or other urban areas e as well as the acceptance
to the saving of fossil energy and to the greenhouse effect; never- of using biodiesel by the purchasing public as its sale in some
theless, it is detrimental regarding acidication, inorganic respira- service stations of fuels is of great signicance. The challenge for
tory effects and ecotoxicity. The better environmental score for the future urban transport systems will be to meet the demand for
greenhouse effect can be attributed to the fact that rapeseed accessibility for people, while at the same time minimizing the
assimilates CO2 during its growth. It is estimated that every ton of impacts on the environment with safeguarding the quality of life.
fossil diesel adds about 2.8 tons of CO2 to the atmosphere. The This is particularly true, in the eld of public transport, where
specic carbon content of 1 ton biodiesel is slightly lower, about decisions affect the daily lives of millions of people and where the
2.4 tons of CO2. As far as the category of inorganic respiratory investment and operation costs of complex systems often amount
effects is concerned, it is noticed that biodiesel has a signicant to millions of euros. They also have a determinant impact on the
impact, mainly due to the increase of the exhaust emissions of NOx economic dynamism and environmental quality of urban areas. The
of the vehicle. It is obvious that the impacts of biodiesel are implementation of a sustainable transport strategy in the metro-
signicantly lower than those of gasoline and diesel, primarily due politan area of Athens is of great importance; nevertheless further
to sharp reductions in CO2. analysis and research is required, in order to nd the best solution
The results of global environmental impacts after weighting are in terms of sustainability.
presented in Fig. 4. Nevertheless, it should be interpreted with This study can be considered as an opportunity for further
caution, due to their subjective aspect. The benet of biodiesel in research to resolve these concerns and evaluate the available options.
comparison to other fossil fuels is obvious.

References
5. Discussion
Agricultural University of Athens, 2000. Techno-Economic Feasibility Study of
Biofuels in Greece prepared for the Ministry of Transport, (in Greek).
The results of the present study can be used as an input to the Ceuterick D., Spirinckx, 1997. Comparative LCA of biodiesel and fossil diesel fuel,
strategic decision-making process for future transport energy VITO-report (1997/PPE/R/026).
Coulon, R., Camobreco, V., Sheenan J. and Dufeld J., 1996. Life cycle assessment of
policy and also to identify key areas of interest for further tech-
biodiesel versus petroleum biodiesel fuel, Abstract Book of SETAC 17 Annual
nology research and development of the Greek transport system. Meeting Partnerships for the Environment: Science, Education and Policy,
Biofuels Life Cycle Analysis can be considered as a valuable tool, published by Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC,
offering exibility to the system parameterization and to the inte- Washington, D.C.), November 17e21, 1996.
De Calvedo Macedo, I., Lima Verde Leal, R.R., Azevedo Ramos de Silva, J.E., 2004.
grated evaluation of their environmental impacts and their Assessement of Greenhouse Gas Emissions in the Production and Use of Fuel
performance in general. Furthermore, it can be a useful tool in the Ethanol in Brazil. Government of the State of Sao Paolo.
process of strategic and integrated transportation planning, since it De Nocker, L., Spirinckx, C., Torfs, R., 1998. Comparison of LCA and external ecost
analysis for biodiesel and diesel. VITO, available at. www.novem.nl.
takes into account environmental, technical and cost consider- Ecobilan, 2002. Bilans nergtiques et gaz effet de serre des lires de production
ations. It is obvious that the use of LCA can result in a shift of the des biocarburants en France. Ademe, Direm.
way planners make strategic and operational decisions, through Ethanolfra, 2006. http://www.ethanolfra.org/industry/statistics.
European Biodiesel Board, 2006 Biodiesel Chains: Promoting favourable conditions
being more effective in identifying improvement opportunities that to establish biodiesel market actions, WP2 Biodiesel market status, Deliver-
may not have been previously obvious. able 7: EU-27 Biodiesel Report.
Taken into consideration the fact that the biodiesel is suitable for European Biodiesel Board, 2009. http://www.ebb-eu.org/stats.php.
European Commission, 2004. Biofuels Potentials in the EU.
use in standard compression-ignition (diesel) engines designed to European Parliament and Council, 8 May 2003. Directive 2003/30 EC on the
operate on petroleum-based diesel fuel, it is obvious that it can be promotion of the use of biofuels or other renewable fuels for transport.
easily used in existing diesel engines either in its pure form (B100) European Union, 2006. European Energy and Transport e Trends to 2030 Summary
Energy Balances and Indicators, Appendix 2.
or in virtually any blend ratio with conventional diesel fuels.
Eurostat, 2007. Energy Pocket Book 2007, Part 4 Environment.
Furthermore, as presented in Fig. 5 the use of diesel is characterized Goedkoop, M., Priensma, R., 2001. The Eco-Indicator 99-A damage orientated
by a signicant increase of all types of emissions, in comparison with method for Life Cycle Assessment- Methodology Report, third ed. Pre Consul-
those associated with biodiesel. Additionally, biodiesel can be tants, BB Amersfoort.
Gover, M.P., Collings, S.A., Hitchcock, G.S., Moon, D.P., Wilkins, G.T., 1996. r92.
strongly promoted through captive and private eets (bus, taxi, car Alternative Road Transport Fuels- A preliminary Life-cycle Study for the UK, vol.
driver, municipal eets etc.). Table 6 gives the general picture 1. ETSU, Strategic Studies Department.
E.A. Nanaki, C.J. Koroneos / Journal of Cleaner Production 20 (2012) 14e19 19

Hellenic Department Ministry of Development, 2004. 1st National Report, Lechon Y., Cabal H., Lago C., de la Rua C., Saez R., Fernndez M., 2006, Comparative
regarding the promotion of the use of biofuels or other renewable fuels for life-cycle analysis of ethanol from cereals and gasoline. Results (in Spanish).
transport in Greece for the period 2005e2010. Internal Report CIEMAT.
Hellenic Department Ministry of Development, 2006. 3rd National Report, MEET Project: Methodologies for Estimating Air Pollutant Emissions from Trans-
regarding the promotion of the use of biofuels or other renewable fuels for port, 1997. Fuel and Energy Production Emission Factors, Lewis, C.A., Task No.
transport in Greece for the period 2005e2010. 3.4, Deliverable No.20, Contract No. ST-96-SC.204.
Institute for Energy and Environmental Research (IFEU), 2004. CO2 Mitigation National Statistical Service of Greece (NSSG), 2004. Agricultural statistics. www.
Through Biofuels in The Transport Sector Heidelberg, Germany. statistics.gr.
ISO 14040, 1997. Environmental Management- Life Cycle Assessment- Principles National Statistical Service of Greece (NSSG), 2007. Personal Communications.
and Framework. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva. www.statistics.gr.
ISO 14041, 1998. Environmental Management- Life Cycle Assessment- Goal and Pre: Simapro 5.0. Pre Consultants B.V. Plotterweg 12, 3821 BB Amersfoort, The
Scope Denition and Inventory Analysis. International Organization for Stan- Netherlands.
dardization, Geneva. Sheehan, et al., 1998. Life Cycle Inventory of Biodiesel and Petroleum Diesel for use
ISO 14042, 2000a. Environmental Management- Life Cycle Assessment- Life Cycle in Urban Bus N.R.E.L. Final Report.
Impact Assessment. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva. UFOP, 2008. Cost and life- cycle analysis of biofuels. Long version. http://www.ufop.de.
ISO 14043, 2000b. Environmental Management- Life Cycle Assessment- Life Cycle United States Environmental Protection Agency, 2005. Annual Certication Test
Intepretation. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva. Results and Data. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Washington
Joint Research Center, Concawe e Eucar, version 2b, May 2006: Well to wheel DC, USA.
analysis of future automotive fuels and powertrains in the European context. US Environmental Protection Agency, 2002. A Comprehensive Analysis on Biodiesel
Jossart, J., Nijskens, P., Remacle, M., 2005. Les biocarburants en Wallonie, second ed. Impacts on Exhaust Emissions Draft Technical Report.
ValBiom, UCL. Van Gerpen, J., 2000. Analysis of comparative LCA of biodiesel and fossil diesel fuel by
Kaltschmitt, M., Reinhardt, G.A., 1997. Nachwachsende Energietrger: Grunglagen, Ceuterick and Spirinckx. Iowa State University. Available at. www.biodiesel.org.
}
Verfahren, Okologische Bilzanzierung Ifeu. Institute for Energy and Environ- Van Gerpen, J., 2005. Biodiesel processing and production. Fuel Processing
mental Research, Vieweg Verlag. Technology 86, 1097e1107.

Anda mungkin juga menyukai