doi: 10.4183/aeb.2012.67
DOES OBESITY PROTECT POSTMENOPAUSAL WOMEN
AGAINST OSTEOPOROSIS?
*Correspondence to: Sabina Oros, MD, C.I. Parhon National Institute of Endocrinology -
Research Dpt., Aviatorilor 34-36, Bucharest 011863, Romania, Email: sabinaoros@yahoo.com
Acta Endocrinologica (Buc), vol. VIII, no. 1, p. 67-76, 2012
67
S.Oros et al.
beneficial effects on the bone, while Adiponectin and its receptors are
contrasting studies (3) reported that expressed in primary human osteoblasts,
increased visceral fat is associated with suggesting a link between adiponectin and
reduced lumbar spine BMD (bone bone. In vivo and in vitro studies indicate
mineral density) in men and that that adiponectin actually increases bone
excessive fat mass may not protect mass by suppressing osteoclastogenesis
against osteoporosis or osteoporotic and by activating osteoblastogenesis (1),
fracture. while another study showed that
The relationship between body adiponectin increases osteoclast formation
weight and BMD is complex and not by stimulating the production of receptor
completely understood. Possible activator of nuclear factor- B ligand
explanations for the protective bone (RANKL) that stimulates osteoclast
effects of increased body weight include differentiation and activity and by
increased aromatization of androgens to inhibiting the production of
estrogen in adipose tissue, mechanical osteoprotegerin (OPG), an inhibitor of
loading, lower levels of sex hormone- osteoclastogenesis, in osteoblasts (1,6).
binding globulin, and increased bone The fact that leptin, a hormone
formation due to high circulating insulin released from fat tissue, can regulate bone
levels (4,5). In normal pre- and mass first came to prominence in 2000.
postmenopausal women, total body fat is Increased leptin during obesity (7,8) may
positively related to BMD throughout the represent a mechanism for enlarging bone
skeleton and that rapid bone losers have size and thus bone resistance to cope with
significantly lower fat mass than the slow increased body weight. The role of leptin
bone losers (1). in bone turnover and osteoporosis is not
Menopause has also been associated completely understood. In vitro data
with increased bone loss, increased fat suggest that leptin stimulates bone
mass and decreased lean mass. When the formation possibly by acting on human
mechanical loading effect of total body marrow stromal cells to enhance
weight is statistically removed, fat mass is osteoblast and inhibit adipocyte
negatively correlated with bone mass, differentiation. Leptin also inhibits
suggesting that fat mass has actually a osteoclastogenesis by decreasing the
detrimental effect on the bone (1). receptor activator of nuclear factor-B
Studies of adipocyte function have (RANK) and its ligand (RANKL) and
revealed that adipose tissue expresses and increasing the production of
secretes estrogen, resistin, leptin, osteoprotegerin. In a prospective study of
adiponectin, and interleukin-6 (IL-6) that postmenopausal women, plasma leptin
affect human energy homeostasis and was positively correlated with BMD at
may be involved in bone metabolism. the lumbar spine, femoral neck and total
In obese postmenopausal women, body (5).
increased extragonadal estrogen synthesis Resistin, another adipokine
caused by high fat mass has been discovered some years ago, was identified
suggested as one of the potential as an adipose tissue-specific secreted
protective mechanisms. factor, as a protein found in inflammatory
68
Obesity and osteoporosis
zone 3 (FIZZ3), and as a hormone that the morning after a 12 hours fasting
potentially linked obesity to diabetes. period, in order to evaluate their
Thommesen (9) showed that hematological, biochemical profile, bone
resistin may play a role in bone turnover markers (PTH, 25 OH vitamin
remodeling. Their study indicates that D, osteocalcin and crosslaps) and
resistin is expressed in mesenchymal adipocytokines (adiponectin, leptin,
bone marrow stem cells, osteoblasts, resistin, CRP, TNF and IL6). We used
and osteoclasts and that resistin R&D System ELISA commercial kits,
increases osteoblast proliferation and provided by Cybermed. Normal ranges
cytokine release, as well as osteoclast were for adiponectin: 8.65-214.24 ng/mL,
differentiation. for leptin:3.87-77.27 ng/mL, for resistin:
1.287-5.28ng/mL, for TNF alpha: <15.6
AIM pg/mL, for IL6: 3.12-12.5 pg/mL and for
To see if adipose tissue and the CRP: 0.0-0.5 mg/dL.
presence of metabolic syndrome have a Dual-emission X-ray absorptio-
protective effect on bone mass and if metry (DXA) of the spine and the hip
adipokines and cytokines can be (left) was performed on all the enrolled
involved in adipose-bone tissue women using the same DXA machine.
communication. Insulin resistance was appreciated using
the formula:
HOMA-IR= (Insulin x glucose x
SUBJECTS AND METHODS 0.05551) / 22.5.
Metsyn was defined using the
We designed a study enrolling International Diabetes Federations
postmenopausal women, aged over 60, criteria.
without diagnosed osteoporosis. Women Results were statistically analyzed
with secondary causes for osteoporosis using SPSS program, version 15; results
and women receiving already are expressed as means standard error.
osteoporosis treatment were excluded. We used t-test to compare
In order to see the influence of means between groups and Pearsons
adipose tissue on bone mass we formed coefficient for correlations and logistic
three groups: group 1- women with regressions to predict risk factors. They
osteoporosis and MetSyn; group 2- are considered statistically significant if
women with osteoporosis without p is 0.05.
MetSyn; group 3- women with MetSyn
without osteoporosis
The patients were informed about RESULTS
the study protocol (approved by the Ethic
Committee of the institute), number of Eighty-three postmenopausal
visits and the possibility to receive free women without known osteoporosis were
treatment for osteoporosis in The National enrolled after signing a written consent.
Osteoporosis Treatment Program. They were divided into 3 groups due to
Blood samples were taken early in DXA results and the presence of MetSyn-
69
S.Oros et al.
found higher left hip BMD in group 3 values in group 1 when compared to
when compared to group 1 and 2 group 2, but without statistical difference
(p<0.001)- see Table 1; 25 OH vitamin (Fig. 3).
D levels in the insufficiency domain for Leptin mean values were higher in
all three groups with lower vitamin D group 3 when compared to group 2
levels in group 1 when compared to (p=0.001), suggesting the protective
group 3 (p=0.045) and even lower effect of leptin on bone mass (Fig. 4).
vitamin D levels in group 1 when The highest CRP levels were in
compared with group 2 (p=0.003) (table group 3 when compared to group 1
2 and Fig. 1). 25 OH vitamin D mean (p=0.001), while crosslaps were the
values in groups 2 and 3 did not differ highest in group 1 when compared with
statistically significant. group3 (p=0.037, Table 2).
The lowest osteocalcin mean values In group 1, BMI correlated
were in group 3 (p=0.001- versus group 1; positively with spine BMD (p=0.031,
p<0.001- versus group 2- Table 2, Fig. 2), Fig. 5), leptin (p=0.022); insulinemia
with a tendency to higher osteocalcin correlated positively with osteocalcin
values in group 2 when compared to (p=0.004); crosslaps correlated positively
70
Obesity and osteoporosis
71
S.Oros et al.
72
Obesity and osteoporosis
Figure 3. Adiponectin mean values (p=0.001 Figure 4. Leptin mean values (p=0.018
group 3 vs 2, p=0.007 group 3 vs 1). group 2 vs 3).
HOMA- IR and insulinemia BMI (p=0.01) and with IL6 (p=0.008) in
correlated positively with leptin (p=0.004; group 3, positively with diastolic blood
p=0.012); HOMA-IR correlated pressure in group 1 (p=0.026) and
positively with TNF (p=0.048) and negatively with HDL-cholesterol
negatively with adiponectin (p=0.034). (p=0.023) in group 2, suggesting its
Logistic regressions showed a higher risk involvement more in inflammation and
for osteoporosis due to higher insulin cardiovascular risk, than in bone
resistance (p=0.004) when comparing metabolism.
group 2 with 3.
Resistin correlated positively with
73
S.Oros et al.
Adiponectin mean values were the values in the osteoporotic group. Leptin
lowest in the MetSyn group without deficiency may have a greater effect on
osteoporosis and the positive correlation hip BMD compared to spine BMD (1).
with hip BMD in group 2 provide a partial Data is similar with literature, presenting
explanation for the protective effects of fat reduced levels of leptin associated with
on bone (cortical bone). Some consider reduced bone formation and increased
that reducing levels of adiponectin, bone resorption (1). In a study of leptin-
associated with obesity in conjunction deficient mice, cortical thinning was
with inverse correlations between observed, while trabecular volume was
adiponectin levels and BMD, may be in increased compared to control mice. In
favor of the protective effects of fat on addition, adipocyte infiltration was seen in
bone (1,10). the femoral marrow, but not the vertebral
74
Obesity and osteoporosis
75
S.Oros et al.
76