Please assess each item using the given scales. Fractional marks will be given for each category.
Subject : BKF2343 MATERIAL & ENERGY BALANCE
Section :
Evaluator :
Evaluation Date :
Matric No. ID
Manual Energy Balance Energy balance was reported Energy balance was reported Energy balance reported has
with some major errors, fully with no serious mistake considerably correct rigorous
Detail calculation and involving the major equipment and was made on the major calculations with less than
assumption involved in and process units in the plant. equipment and process units three small mistakes. X3
calculation must be clearly in the plant.
stated and mentioned.
Excel/Spreadsheet Material Excel calculations are not Excel calculations are All the data/calculation is
Balance complete. compete yet not flexible. connect properly and can be
X1
easily change to the desire
basis of calculation.
Excel/Spreadsheet Energy Excel calculations are not Excel calculations are All the data/calculation is
Balance complete. compete yet not flexible. connect properly and can be
X1
easily change to the desire
basis of calculation.
Auxiliary Equipment X2
Majority of auxiliary Auxiliary equipment was
Propose suitable of auxiliary Auxiliary equipment proposed
equipment proposed but still completely proposed with
equipment heat exchangers, not completed and no
contain some error on detail calculation of material
pump, compressor and calculation made related to
calculation made related to and energy balance
calculate the material & energy material and energy
material and energy requirement related to the
requirement requirement
requirement equipment.
References Ununiformed referencing A few citation not listed in test All citations in text are
system / not cited in the text / few citation available in text available and references are
X1
but not listed in the list of systematic
reference
Format/Layout/Arrangement So many format errors as to A few format errors Unique format aspects that
make report ineffective enhance report impact X2
Use the following criteria as the basis for evaluating yourself and your team members on a scale of 1 (low) to 4 (high) according to the rubrics in the table below.
Name
I Leadership skill
II Contribution and Quality of Work
III Team work
IV Dependability
V Knowledge Sharing
TOTAL
COMMENTS