Table

Sample Absolute Depth (Meter)

Point Landsat 8 Sentinel-2A Insitu
1 12,338 10,669 12,700
2 12,534 11,010 7,200
3 12,298 11,177 15,300
4 9,510 10,612 9,800
5 10,062 10,701 8,700
6 10,560 10,403 10,200
7 10,443 11,436 11,800
8 10,573 11,226 8,400
9 11,440 11,474 6,100
10 10,930 11,478 8,200
11 9,199 11,381 8,700
12 10,269 11,477 9,800
13 11,453 11,413 16,400
14 11,058 11,210 13,700
15 11,323 11,202 11,300
16 11,305 11,367 11,200
17 11,972 11,389 10,700
18 11,587 11,122 10,200
19 10,657 10,824 9,900
20 11,205 11,343 9,900
21 10,717 10,735 9,800
22 9,624 11,372 9,800
23 9,017 10,573 9,100
24 10,172 10,982 8,900
25 10,459 11,293 7,700
26 10,396 11,319 7,000
27 12,180 10,977 10,700
28 11,137 11,437 7,200
29 11,680 11,164 16,100
30 12,432 11,366 14,000
31 11,660 11,478 5,866
32 10,637 11,476 11,446
33 12,503 11,384 14,838
34 11,360 11,412 12,351
35 10,595 11,243 10,723
36 11,708 11,200 12,115
37 7,780 11,425 11,197
38 10,111 11,478 12,553
39 10,531 11,441 10,286
40 12,006 11,478 7,050
41 12,240 11,202 15,278
42 12,534 11,385 14,695
43 12,417 11,430 13,233
44 11,927 11,360 18,825
45 12,436 11,284 15,424
46 11,627 11,394 10,180
47 12,163 11,476 14,143
48 11,433 11,320 10,025
49 12,177 11,105 10,969
50 12,046 11,343 9,338
51 9,889 11,304 15,174
52 11,252 11,458 14,731
53 11,951 11,451 8,183
54 11,832 11,456 8,771
55 12,355 11,058 15,748
56 11,755 11,232 11,440
57 12,270 11,463 15,774
58 12,460 11,394 10,435
59 12,245 11,412 14,706
60 10,577 11,364 9,025

Sample NMAE (%)

Point
Landsat 8 Sentinel-2A
1 2,848 15,994
2 74,087 52,911
3 19,620 26,949
4 2,962 8,288
5 15,658 22,997
6 3,530 1,987
7 11,496 3,082
8 25,871 33,640
9 87,549 88,092
10 33,290 39,971
11 5,734 30,813
12 4,787 17,115
13 30,164 30,410
14 19,284 18,178
15 0,204 0,868
16 0,941 1,488
17 11,892 6,435
18 13,602 9,035
19 7,645 9,336
20 13,184 14,574
21 9,359 9,540
22 1,799 16,038
23 0,917 16,182
24 14,291 23,388
25 35,829 46,663
26 48,514 61,703
27 13,834 2,588
28 54,682 58,850
29 27,454 30,661
30 11,203 18,815
31 98,764 95,662
32 7,066 0,266
33 15,738 23,282
34 8,028 7,603
35 1,190 4,848
36 3,359 7,552
37 30,517 2,036
38 19,453 8,567
39 2,378 11,234
40 70,306 62,808
41 19,885 26,682
42 14,705 22,527
43 6,168 13,624
44 36,643 39,654
45 19,368 26,841
 46 14,221 11,931
47 13,998 18,858
48 14,043 12,911
49 11,015 1,240
50 29,005 21,472
51 34,829 25,504
52 23,614 22,216
53 46,060 39,949
54 34,903 30,610
55 21,547 29,781
56 2,755 1,814
57 22,215 27,326
58 19,397 9,188
59 16,732 22,399
60 17,197 25,913
Average 21,289 22,848
 Table 1.
Absolute Estimated Depth from Landsat 8 and Sentine-2A image

Sample Absolute Depth (Meter) Absolute Depth (Meter)

Sample Point
Point Landsat 8 Sentinel-2A Insitu Landsat 8 Sentinel-2A Insitu
1 12,338 10,669 12,700 31 11,660 11,478 5,866
2 12,534 11,010 7,200 32 10,637 11,476 11,446
3 12,298 11,177 15,300 33 12,503 11,384 14,838
4 9,510 10,612 9,800 34 11,360 11,412 12,351
5 10,062 10,701 8,700 35 10,595 11,243 10,723
6 10,560 10,403 10,200 36 11,708 11,200 12,115
7 10,443 11,436 11,800 37 7,780 11,425 11,197
8 10,573 11,226 8,400 38 10,111 11,478 12,553
9 11,440 11,474 6,100 39 10,531 11,441 10,286
10 10,930 11,478 8,200 40 12,006 11,478 7,050
11 9,199 11,381 8,700 41 12,240 11,202 15,278
12 10,269 11,477 9,800 42 12,534 11,385 14,695
13 11,453 11,413 16,400 43 12,417 11,430 13,233
14 11,058 11,210 13,700 44 11,927 11,360 18,825
15 11,323 11,202 11,300 45 12,436 11,284 15,424
16 11,305 11,367 11,200 46 11,627 11,394 10,180
17 11,972 11,389 10,700 47 12,163 11,476 14,143
18 11,587 11,122 10,200 48 11,433 11,320 10,025
19 10,657 10,824 9,900 49 12,177 11,105 10,969
20 11,205 11,343 9,900 50 12,046 11,343 9,338
21 10,717 10,735 9,800 51 9,889 11,304 15,174
22 9,624 11,372 9,800 52 11,252 11,458 14,731
23 9,017 10,573 9,100 53 11,951 11,451 8,183
24 10,172 10,982 8,900 54 11,832 11,456 8,771
25 10,459 11,293 7,700 55 12,355 11,058 15,748
26 10,396 11,319 7,000 56 11,755 11,232 11,440
27 12,180 10,977 10,700 57 12,270 11,463 15,774
28 11,137 11,437 7,200 58 12,460 11,394 10,435
29 11,680 11,164 16,100 59 12,245 11,412 14,706
30 12,432 11,366 14,000 60 10,577 11,364 9,025
 Table 2
NMAE Sample Data

Sample NMAE (%) Sample NMAE (%)

Point Point
Landsat 8 Sentinel-2A Landsat 8 Sentinel-2A
1 2,848 15,994 31 98,764 95,662
2 74,087 52,911 32 7,066 0,266
3 19,620 26,949 33 15,738 23,282
4 2,962 8,288 34 8,028 7,603
5 15,658 22,997 35 1,190 4,848
6 3,530 1,987 36 3,359 7,552
7 11,496 3,082 37 30,517 2,036
8 25,871 33,640 38 19,453 8,567
9 87,549 88,092 39 2,378 11,234
10 33,290 39,971 40 70,306 62,808
11 5,734 30,813 41 19,885 26,682
12 4,787 17,115 42 14,705 22,527
13 30,164 30,410 43 6,168 13,624
14 19,284 18,178 44 36,643 39,654
15 0,204 0,868 45 19,368 26,841
16 0,941 1,488 46 14,221 11,931
17 11,892 6,435 47 13,998 18,858
18 13,602 9,035 48 14,043 12,911
19 7,645 9,336 49 11,015 1,240
20 13,184 14,574 50 29,005 21,472
21 9,359 9,540 51 34,829 25,504
22 1,799 16,038 52 23,614 22,216
23 0,917 16,182 53 46,060 39,949
24 14,291 23,388 54 34,903 30,610
25 35,829 46,663 55 21,547 29,781
26 48,514 61,703 56 2,755 1,814
27 13,834 2,588 57 22,215 27,326
28 54,682 58,850 58 19,397 9,188
29 27,454 30,661 59 16,732 22,399
30 11,203 18,815 60 17,197 25,913
Average 21,289 % 22,848 %