Industrial Accidents:
Types and Causes of Accidents :
The ever increasing mechanisation, electrification, chemicalisation and
sophistication have made industrial jobs more and more complex and
intricate. This has led to increased dangers to human life in industries through
accidents and injuries. In fact, the same underlines the need for and
importance of industrial safety. Let us first understand what industrial
accident actually means.
Industrial Accident:
An accident (industrial) is a sudden and unexpected occurrence in the
industry which interrupts the orderly progress of the work. According to the
Factories Act, 1948: It is an occurrence in an industrial establishment
causing bodily injury to a person who makes him unfit to resume his duties in
the next 48 hours.
Types of Accidents:
Accidents may be of different types depending upon the severity, durability
and degree of the injury. An accident causing death or permanent or
1
prolonged disability to the injured employee is called major accident. A cut
that does not render the employee disabled is termed as minor accident.
When an employee gets injury with external signs of it, it is external injury.
Causes of Accidents:
2
2. Unsafe Acts:
Industrial accidents occur due to certain acts on the part of workers. These
acts may be the result of lack of knowledge or skill on the part of the worker,
certain bodily defects and wrong attitude.
3. Other Causes:
These causes arise out of unsafe situational and climatic conditions and
variations. These may include excessive noise, very high temperature, humid
conditions, bad working conditions, unhealthy environment, slippery floors,
excessive glare, dust and fume, arrogant behaviour of domineering
supervisors, etc. Of late, industrial accidents have become common
happening in our country.
3
Accident during Process :
The old removal tank of plant was taken for modification (nozzle
preparation). During gas cutting it caught fire because of tank not clean
properly.
Shift Officer was on plant round and when he was on 2nd floor at that
time he observed that from scrubber area one HDPE drum was
damaged and POCl3 + Toluene spillage hence heavy fumes and vapor
of POCl3 generating, it seems due to generation of high pressure inside
drum may be cause of damage the drum. He informed to HOD and
Executive and then to HOD of EHS. Immediately HOD activated his
team for emergency. Officer reached at site with SCBA and tilted the
leaking drum to avoid more spillage from drum. Mr. Rakesh had
opened ammonia cylinder for ammonium chloride vapour generation.
Mr. Partik , Mr. Gohil , Mr. Solanki (Security Officer), Mr. Rakesh ,
Mr. Patil along with all Plant 8 person and emergency team controlled
the incident by neutralized the spilled material with sodium carbonate
by wearing SCBA. After 02 hrs all spill liquid and vapors are
neutralized. And affected person are send to Dr.A.K.Patel for medical
check up. Remaining material of drum was sucked by vacuum and
charged into the near by reactor and dropped down in drum.
4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
As the workman shaken the bag with jurk cause static charge is
generated and already present of Vapors cloud of THF inside of reactor
cause a flash of fire is occurred. Immediately Shift-officer
Extinguished the fire by using CO2-22.5lit and DCP-10 kg fire
Extinguisher.
5
Mr. Amit who is Jr. Officer at Plant was carried out unloading
activity (Unloading of Trospium Chloride) with casual worker in his
presence from VTD . During this period he exposed from Trospium
chloride. With immediate exposure of this material he felt giddiness
and bitter taste in mouth and lips. Mr. Sharma (Officer of same
module) observes this incident and immediately took him to OHC.
Mr. Nikunj Ramani who is Jr. Officer at Plant 01. During work he
was going to meet with Mr. Suresh Sharma (Incharge of plant) on CF-
108. When he was go down step with out observed proper path, hence
get injury on head with bottom nipple of Reactor GLR 144.
Immediate took him to OHC.
6
During solution preparation Mr. Tejas bare left hand finger & gets in
contact with glecial acetic acid and irritation felt by him. Leg injury
during his movement at plant 5 due to tripping his leg palm in gutter
chamber he slipped and leg inury occurred.
The person was going to drink the water and during picking of fallen
glas on land his head strucked into table edge and head injury
occurred.
During line opening by fitter in plant first floor, during taking out the
line remaining holdup MDC splashed on his shoulder - back side.
DMS was charged by vacuum to glass flask (100 litre capacity). Casual
worker observed that material is leaking from the botoom nozzle of the
glass valve so while fixing the clamp DMS spilled on the handgloves
and spread on uncoverd part of the hand (Fore arm).
7
While conducted MDC layer separation, hose pipe changed in another
drum that time material hold up and spilled on both leg.
At Mix solvent drum storage area near plant- 10 during drums shifting
in Tempo by Mr. Suresh and another casual that time his leg slipped
and got injury on his nose with sharp part of drum.
Mr. Suresh is suffered with injury on nose after getting First Aid
treatment from OHC and shifted him to Dr. A.K. Patel's hospital.
8
During the mutimilling of Colistimethate Sodium Stage- Final, at the
time of increasing nitrogen pressure at manifold suddenly nitrogen
filter got burst.
Route Cause:
1. Nitrogen line leading to module 2 was not isolated where the filter was
kept.
2. To increase the pressure for module 1 nitrogen regulator was operated
accordingly.
3. Since nitrogen regulators pressure gauges were not working, it was not
possible to find out actual pressure.
4. Since the pressure was increased drastically, it had a flow for module 2
which was not isolated the filter got burst.
Preliminary it is an operational mistake and non functioning of pressure
gauges.
9
Bhopal disaster
The Bhopal disaster, also referred to as the Bhopal gas tragedy, was a gas
leak incident in India, considered the world's worst industrial disaster.
Estimates vary on the death toll. The official immediate death toll was 2,259.
The government of Madhya Pradesh confirmed a total of 3,787 deaths related
to the gas release. A government affidavit in 2006 stated the leak caused
558,125 injuries including 38,478 temporary partial injuries and
approximately 3,900 severely and permanently disabling injuries.
Others estimates 8,000 died within two weeks and another 8,000 or more
have since died from gas-related diseases. The cause of the disaster remains
under debate. The Indian government and local activists argue slack
management and deferred maintenance created a situation where routine pipe
maintenance caused a backflow of water into a MIC tank triggering the
disaster. Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) contends water entered the tank
through an act of sabotage.
The owner of the factory, UCIL, was majority owned by UCC, with Indian
Government-controlled banks and the Indian public holding a 49.1 percent
stake. In 1989, UCC paid $470m ($907m in 2014 dollars) to settle litigation
stemming from the disaster. In 1994, UCC sold its stake in UCIL to Evereday
Industries India Limited (EIIL).
10
Dow Chemical Company purchased UCC in 2001, seventeen years after the
disaster. Civil and criminal cases were filed in the District Court of Bhopal,
India, involving UCC and Warren Anderson, UCC CEO at the time of the
disaster. In June 2010, seven ex-employees, including the former UCIL.
An eighth former employee was also convicted, but died before the
judgement was passed. Anderson also passed away at a nursing home in
Vero Beach, Florida on September 29, 2014.
11
extinguished. Normal production of Ammonia could not be sustained on
account of fire. To take remedial actions, operation of Ammonia Synthesis
Unit has been stopped. Repair of Waste Heat Boiler (E-703) is being taken-
up. Disruption in operation of Ammonia Synthesis Unit has however, not
affected the operations of other major plants such as Methanol, Formic Acid,
Acetic Acid, WNA / CNA / ANP / CAN, Aniline and TDI plants of the
Company and presently, they continue to operate smoothly. There has beenno
incident of human injury.
Meghmani Organics:
Fatal accident at agrochemical Ankleshwar plant :
12
Fatal Accident at Waste Paper Factory :
Synopsis of Accident:
While the deceased was in the process of loading a paper block, the
forklift suddenly reversed out from the side of the ramp and toppled
off the ramp. The deceased was pinned onto the ground by the
forklift and was killed.
13
Fatal Accident at Warehouse Premise :
Synopsis of Accident:
The deceased worker was involved in tallying stock stored on metal racks
within yellow boxes.
Yellow box
The deceased worker was conducting checks in between two metal racks
just prior to the accident. To free up space for more cargo, a forklift operator
used his forklift to push
the adjacent metal racks. The deceased worker was trapped in between the
metal racks. Deceased worker was found dead an hour later.
14
Fatal Accident at Shipyard :
Synopsis of Accident:
Workplace Premise: Vehicle access road in shipyard.
Forklift: 7 ton (load capacity)
Activity: Deceased was sleeping near vehicle access road next to steel
fabrication block. The road is part of a T-junction. At around 11.55 pm, a 7-
ton forklift carrying a concrete block turned left at the T-junction into the
road and ran over the deceased.
Nature of Accident: Ran over by forklift
Learing Point :
1. Proper management of forklift and human traffic in workplace, e.g.
Enforcement of designated resting area for workers
2. Importance of safety training and briefings to increase safety
awareness and manage workers behaviour.
3. Proper lighting for forklift operations at night.
4. Issue of fatigue -adequate hours of rest for workers
15
Fatal Accident at Construction Site :
Synopsis of Accident:
Workplace Premise: Circular vehicle ramp of a light industrial building under
construction.
Forklift: 3 ton (load capacity)
Work Activity: A worker (the deceased) was driving the forklift down a
circular vehicle ramp from the 4th level towards the 3 rd level. The forklift
suddenly swerved and overturned at the 3rd level. The deceased was pinned
by the forklift and he died on the spot. There was no load on the forklift.
Nature of Accident: Forklift overturned and crushed worker Forklift operator
had not undergone the mandatory Forklift Driver's Training Course.
The forklift was moving down the circular vehicle ramp when it suddenly
overturned and pinned down the deceased.
Learning Point :
16
Flixborough Disaster
On 1st June 1974 the Nypro (UK) site at Flixborough was severely damaged
by a large explosion. Twenty-eight workers were killed and a further 36
suffered injuries. Offsite consequences resulted in fifty-three reported
injuries. Property in the surrounding area was damaged to a varying degree.
A 20 inch bypass system ruptured, which may have been caused by a fire on a
nearby 8 inch pipe. This resulted in the escape of a large quantity of
cyclohexane. The cyclohexane formed a flammable mixture and subsequently
found a source of ignition. At about 16:53 hours there was a massive vapour
cloud explosion, which caused extensive damage and started numerous fires
on the site.
When reactor five developed a crack, a temporary 20 inch bypass pipe was
used to connect reactors four and six and remove reactor five from the chain
to allow repairs to take place.
A work engineer was yet to be replaced at the time that the modification was
performed, even though the designers of the piping had considerable
17
experience. The design of the piping was done in chalk on the workshop floor
by personnel unaware of the implications of the requirements on the piping to
withstand 150C and 10 bar. The plant was online again in a few days.
The bypass pipe was fixed at either end to the bellows, but the scaffolding
was used to support the bypass pipe proved to be inadequate, and the pipe
was free to squirm when the pressure increased.
On 1st June 1974 the pipe ruptured and allowed 40 tons of cyclohexane to be
released in approximately one minute. With cyclohexane having properties
somewhat similar to petrol, explosions occurred and an inferno took hold for
24 hours.
Had the explosion occurred on a weekday, more people may have been killed,
including many of the 550 who worked there.
29 people died and over 100 were injured. The plant was destroyed, and 100
nearby homes were destroyed or badly damaged.
Although most resources relating to this incident blame the modification,
some evidence to the contrary is raised in "Great Disasters" edited by John
Canning.
18
Mangalore Chemicals and Fertilizers Limited
19
The expert committee investigated made the following recommendations to
prevent any incident in future.
The pipeline, connected equipment and the accessories must be subjected to
hydrostatic test as required under the relevant provision of law.
Weldolet must be subjected to 100% examination to detect corrosion and the
soundness;
Maintenance/repair works shall not be undertaken on line, it shall be done
only as per standard maintenance procedure drawn up before hand;
Permit to work system shall be strictly adhered to along with suitable
personal protective equipment;
The on site emergency plan rehearsals shall be put to rigorous tests and
practiced by updating the weaknesses noticed from time to time;
The personnel including the contract workmen shall be put to rigorous
training in handling chemical emergencies particularly to bring a change in
their attitudinal behaviour of over confidence;
20
National Fertilisers Limited (NFL) at Panipat
Liquid ammonia hit workers Coughing and choking, with lungs bursting,
scrambled for fresh air.
It is a Freak accident? This was the first major incident in any of the NFL
plants. When working on the ammonia pipelines. It was admitted to down to
earth that for such work "Need to take extra precautions to ensure that
workers other than those doing the hazardous task, are not present in the
vicinity,"
21
The Chlorine Gas Leak at Jamshedpur
As we know Chlorine gas has strong oxidising properties. Its toxicity irritates
the respiratory system. Severe exposure to the gas may cause pulmonary
edema within 30 to 60 minutes and die. There is no available prophylactic or
post exposure therapy for chlorine.
22
SPIC ammonia unit shut due to leakage problem :
23
Defence Industries :
December 6, 1917:
Halifax, Canada . The Halifax explosion. A ship loaded with about 9000
tons of high explosives destined for France caught fire as a result of a
collision in Halifax harbour, and exploded. The explosion killed about
2000 and injured about 9000.
October 4, 1918:
T. A. Gillespie Company Shell Loading Plant explosion. An ammunition
plant in Sayreville, New Jersey exploded, killing approximately 100
people, destroying 300 buildings and causing $18 million in damages.
March 1, 1924:
1924 Nixon Nitration Works disaster. A plant for processing ammonium
nitrate in Edison, New Jersey exploded, killing 24 people, injuring 100 and
destroying several buildings.
August 9, 1965:
Little Rock AFB in Searcy, Arkansas. 53 contract workers were killed
during a fire at a Titan missile silo. The cause of the fire was determined to
be a welding rod damaging a hydraulic hose allowing hydraulic vapors to
leak and spread throughout the silo, which were then ignited by an open
flame.
24
July 11, 2011:
Evangelos Florakis Naval Base explosion, Cyprus. An explosion occurred
at a munitions dump; 13 people were killed, among them the captain of the
base, twin brothers who were serving there as marines, and four
firefighters.
25
Energy Industries :
October 1957:
The Windscale fire, the worst nuclear accident in Great Britain's history,
released substantial amounts of radioactive contamination into the
surrounding area at Windscale, Cumberland (now Sellafield, Cumbria).
May 1962:
The Centralia, Pennsylvania coal mine fire began, forcing the gradual
evacuation of the Centralia borough. The fire continues to burn in the
abandoned borough.
March 1967:
The Torrey Canyon supertanker was shipwrecked off the west coast of
Cornwall, England, causing an environmental disaster. This was the first
major oil spill at sea.
August, 1975:
The Banqiao Dam failed in the Henan Province of China due to
extraordinarily heavy rains and poor construction quality of the dam,
which was built during the Great Leap Forward. The flood immediately
killed over 100,000 people, and another 150,000 died of subsequent
epidemic diseases and famine, bringing the total death toll to around
250,000 and making it the worst technical disaster ever.
26
March 28, 1979:
Three Mile Island accident. Partial nuclear meltdown. Mechanical failures
in the non-nuclear secondary system, followed by a stuck-open pilot-
operated relief valve in the primary system, allowed large amounts of
reactor coolant to escape. Plant operators initially failed to recognize the
loss of coolant, resulting in a partial meltdown. The reactor was brought
under control but not before up to 481 PBq (13 million curies) of
radioactive gases were released into the atmosphere
June 3, 1979:
Ixtoc I oil spill. The Ixtoc I exploratory oil well suffered a blowout
resulting in the third-largest oil spill and the second-largest accidental spill
in history.
27
portions of Belarus and Ukraine surrounding Prypiat, remains
contaminated and mostly uninhabited. Prypiat itself was totally evacuated
and remains as a ghost town.
May 5, 1988:
Norco, Louisiana, Shell Oil refinery explosion. Hydrocarbon gas escaped
from a corroded pipe in a catalytic cracker and was ignited. Louisiana state
police evacuated 2,800 residents from nearby neighborhoods. Seven
workers were killed and 42 injured. The total cost arising from the Norco
blast is estimated at US$706 million.
July 6, 1988:
Piper Alpha disaster. An explosion and resulting fire on a North Sea oil
production platform killed 167 men. The total insured loss was about
US$3.4 billion. To date it is rated as the world's worst offshore oil disaster
in terms both of lives lost and impact to industry.
28
Jacobs, Fluor and BP. BP has since accepted that its employees contributed
to the accident. Several level indicators failed, leading to overfilling of a
knockout drum, and light hydrocarbons concentrated at ground level
throughout the area. A nearby running diesel truck set off the explosion.
February 7, 2010:
2010 Connecticut power plant explosion. A large explosion occurred at a
Kleen Energy Systems 620-megawatt, Siemens combined cycle gas- and
oil- fired power plant in Middletown, Connecticut, United States.
Preliminary reports attributed the cause of the explosion to a test of the
plant's energy systems.] The plant was still under construction and
scheduled to start supplying energy in June 2010. The number of injuries
was eventually established to be 27. Five people died in the explosion.
March 2011:
Fukushima I nuclear accidents in Japan. Regarded as the largest nuclear
disaster since the Chernobyl disaster, there were no direct deaths but a few
of the plant's workers were severely injured or killed by the disaster
conditions resulting from the earthquake.
29
October 29, 2012:
Hurricane Sandy caused a ConEdison power plant to explode, causing a
blackout in most of midtown Manhattan. The blue light emitted from the
arc made places as far as Brooklyn glow. No person was killed or injured.
July 6, 2013:
Lac-Mgantic, Quebec Canada. Lac-Mgantic derailment. Forty-seven
people were killed when there was a derailment of an oil shipment train.
The oil shipment caught fire and exploded, destroying more than thirty
buildings. It was the fourth-deadliest rail accident in Canadian history.
Food industry
May 2, 1878:
The Washburn "A" Mill in Minneapolis was destroyed by a flour dust
explosion, killing 18. The mill was rebuilt with updated technology. The
explosion led to new safety standards in the milling industry.
30
January 15, 1919:
The Boston Molasses Disaster. A large molasses tank burst and a wave of
molasses rushed through the streets at an estimated 35 mph (56 km/h),
killing 21 and injuring 150. The event has entered local folklore, and
residents claim that on a hot summer day, the area still smells of molasses.
February 6, 1979:
The (Roland Mill), located in Bremen, Germany, was destroyed by a flour
dust explosion, killing 14 and injuring 17.
September 3, 1991:
1991 Hamlet chicken processing plant fire in Hamlet, North Carolina,
where locked doors trapped workers in a burning processing plant, causing
25 deaths.
September 3, 1998:
1998 Haysville KN grain elevator explosion in Haysville, Kansas. A series
of dust explosions in a large grain storage facility resulted in the deaths of
seven people.
February 7, 2008:
The 2008 Georgia sugar refinery explosion in Port Wentworth, Georgia,
United States. Thirteen people were killed and 42 injured when a dust
explosion occurred at a sugar refinery owned by Imperial Sugar.
31
Manufacturing industry
May 4, 1988:
PEPCON disaster, Henderson, Nevada. A massive fire and explosions at a
chemical plant killed two people and injured over 300.
32
May 10, 1993:
Kader Toy Factory fire. A fire started in a poorly built factory in Thailand.
Exit doors were locked and the stairwell collapsed. 188 workers were
killed, mostly young women.
November 3, 2004:
Seest fireworks disaster. N. P. Johnsens Fyrvrkerifabrik fireworks
factory exploded in Seest, a suburb of Kolding, Denmark. One firefighter
died; seven from the rescue team as well as 17 locals were injured. In total
2,107 buildings were damaged by the explosion, with the cost of the
damage estimated at 100 million.
February 1, 2008:
Istanbul fireworks explosion. An unlicensed fireworks factory exploded
accidentally, leaving by some reports at least 22 people dead and at least
100 injured.
Mining industry
34
July 19, 1985:
Val di Stava dam collapse took place in the village of Stava, near Tesero,
Italy, when two tailings dams, used for sedimenting the mud from the
nearby Prestavel mine, failed. It resulted in one of Italy's worst disasters,
killing 268 people, destroying 63 buildings and demolishing eight bridges.
May 9, 1993:
Nambija mine disaster, Nambija, Ecuador. Approximately 300 people
were killed in a landslide
April 5, 2010:
Upper Big Branch Mine disaster, West Virginia, United States. An
explosion occurred in Massey Energy's Upper Big Branch coal mine.
Twenty-nine out of 31 miners at the site were killed.[18]
35
August 4, 2014:
Mount Polley mine disaster near Likely, British Columbia.
1927 - 1932:
Hawks Nest Tunnel Disaster, near Gauley Bridge, West Virginia, United
States. Over several years, 476 workers died from silicosis.
1932-1968:
The Minamata disaster was caused by the dumping of mercury compounds
in Minamata Bay, Japan. The Chisso Corporation, a fertilizer and later
petrochemical company, was found responsible for polluting the bay for 37
years. It is estimated that over 3,000 people suffered various deformities,
severe mercury poisoning symptoms or death from what became known as
Minamata disease.
36
April 16, 1947:
Texas City disaster, Texas. At 9:15 am an explosion occurred aboard a
docked ship named the Grandcamp. The explosion, and subsequent fires
and explosions, is referred to as the worst industrial disaster in America. A
minimum of 578 people lost their lives and another 3,500 were injured as
the blast shattered windows from as far away as 25 mi (40 km). Large steel
pieces were thrown more than a mile from the dock. The origin of the
explosion was fire in the cargo on board the ship. Detonation of 3,200 tons
of ammonium nitrate fertilizer aboard the Grandcamp led to further
explosions and fires. The fertilizer shipment was to aid the struggling
farmers of Europe recovering from World War II.
1948:
A chemical tank wagon explosion within the BASF's Ludwigshafen,
Germany site caused 207 fatalities.
February 3, 1971:
The Thiokol-Woodbine Explosion at a Thiokol chemical plant in Georgia
killed 29 people and seriously injured 50.
June 1, 1974:
Flixborough disaster, England. An explosion at a chemical plant near the
village of Flixborough killed 28 people and seriously injured another 36.
37
poured concrete before it had cured sufficiently to withstand the loads. It is
thought to be the largest construction accident in United States history.
December 3, 1984:
The Bhopal disaster in India is one of the largest industrial disasters on
record. A runaway reaction in a tank containing poisonous methyl
isocyanate caused the pressure relief system to vent large amounts to the
atmosphere at a Union Carbide India Limited plant. Estimates of the death
toll range from 4,000 to 20,000. The disaster caused the region's human
and animal populations severe health problems to the present.
November 1, 1986:
The Sandoz disaster in Schweizerhalle, Switzerland released tons of toxic
agrochemicals into the Rhine.
July 5, 1990:
Arco Disaster. An explosion and fire occurred at the Arco Chemical
Company complex in Channelview, Texas. 17 people were killed. Five
were permanent employees of Arco Chemical Company and the remaining
12 were contract labor employees. An area approximately the size of a city
block was completely destroyed; no one in the area survived the explosion.
May 1, 1991:
Sterlington, Louisiana. An explosion at the IMC-operated Angus Chemical
nitro-paraffin plant in Sterlington, Louisiana killed eight workers and
injured 120 other people. There was severe damage to the surrounding
community. The blasts were heard more than eight miles away.
38
September 21, 2001:
Toulouse, France. An explosion at the AZF fertilizer factory killed 29,
injured 2,500, and caused extensive structural damage to nearby
neighbourhoods.
October 4, 2010:
Alumina plant accident. Ajka, Kolontr, Devecser and several other
settlements, Hungary. The dam of Magyar Aluminium Zrt.'s red mud
reservoir broke and the escaping highly toxic and alkaline (~pH 13) sludge
flooded several settlements. There were nine victims, including a young
girl and hundreds of injuries (mostly chemical burns).
November 8, 2012:
Sherbrooke, Quebec, Canada. Two people died and 19 were injured in an
industrial processing plant belonging to Neptune Technologies &
Bioressources, a manufacturer of health care products.
40
Bhopal (India 1984, chemical release 2,000 to 14,400 killed)
On December 3 1984, more than 40 tons of methyl isocyanate gas leaked
from a pesticide plant in Bhopal, India, immediately killing at least 3,800
people and causing significant morbidity and premature death for many
thousands more. The company involved in what became the worst
industrial accident in history immediately tried to dissociate itself from
legal responsibility. Eventually it reached a settlement with the Indian
Government through mediation of that country's Supreme Court and
accepted moral responsibility. It paid $470 million in compensation, a
relatively small amount of based on significant underestimations of the
long-term health consequences of exposure and the number of people
exposed. The disaster indicated a need for enforceable international
standards for environmental safety, preventative strategies to avoid similar
accidents and industrial disaster preparedness.
Since the disaster, India has experienced rapid industrialization. While
some positive changes in government policy and behavior of a few
industries have taken place, major threats to the environment from rapid
and poorly regulated industrial growth remain. Widespread environmental
degradation with significant adverse human health consequences continues
to occur throughout India.
41
Piper Alpha (North Sea 1988, Hydrocarbon gas ignition, 167
killed)
The Piper Alpha platform was destroyed in 1988 by a series of explosions.
The North Sea oil rig accident cost more lives than any other offshore
disaster.
The Piper Alpha oil rig disaster, which occurred in 1988, remains the worst
ever oil rig accident. Of the 226 mean on board the platform at the time
only 61 survived. Two crewmen on a rescue boat also perished and 30
bodies were never recovered.
42
Bharuch- GNFC
BHARUCH: Four persons were killed and several injured in a major blast that
took place in the nitro-phosphorus plant of the Gujarat Narmada Valley
Fertilizers Company Ltd (GNFC) here on Tuesday night.
Some portions of the plant collapsed due to the impact of the explosion and four
persons who were buried under it are reported to have succumbed. Two persons
are said to be still trapped in the debris according to reports received well past
midnight.
Eyewitness account said that the fire was brought under control after midnight
even as fire tenders were rushed from Vadodara and Ahmedabad. The factory
has been completely sealed off even as huge crowds gathered around and at the
GNFC hospital where some of the injured were rushed for treatment.
Five injured persons were sent to the SSG Hospital in Vadodara. According to
Devendra Sinh Solanki, past president of Bharatiya Janata Party in Bharuch,
who was allowed inside the factory premises, the main control room has totally
collapsed apart from certain other sections.
He informed that there were five officials, 28 other employees and 19 casual
labourers in the factory at the time of the blast. Meanwhile, state home secretary
K Nityanandam confirmed the death of four persons in the blast and the
subsequent collapsing of some sections of the plant.
State chief secretary PK Laheri told TNN that the plant has been shut down to
allow rescue operations in the plant. He said it has to be carried out with
extreme precaution in view of the presence of highly toxic materials in the
factory.
The incident took place at about 9.05 p.m and shook almost the entire city. The
explosion could be heard several kilometres away from the plant. The impact of
the blast was such that walls in some houses of the nearby Vadadala village
developed cracks.
Major panic spread in the area with people initially fearing that the city had
been hit by an earthquake.
Local residents were scared due to the explosion and rushed out of their houses.
The explosion could be heard as far as Ankleshwar and Dahej. The blast was so
strong that windowpanes rattled due to its impact. "The initial fears of an
earthquake, however, vanished on hearing of the blast in GNFC," said K B
Dave, a local resident.
43
The district collector, superintendent of police, senior GNFC officials and other
personnel concerned rushed to the spot in wake of the blast. District collector
Rajiv Topno said, "The fire-fighters are already in action. There is likelihood of
more casualties but can't be determined as of now. We are trying to take the
head count only then can we give a true picture of the casualties."
DSP Amarsinh Vasava said "We are at the spot and will take some time in
ascertaining the extent of the damage." Bharuch nagarpalika president
Navinchandra Vanza said that municipal fire brigade was not called for dealing
with the situation. "The GNFC is managing the situation with their own fire
personnel," he said.Ambulances of the nagarpalika were pressed into service to
take the injured to hospitals.
44
MAJOR CHEMICAL DISASTERS IN INDIA
Number of
Origin of accident Year Date Location Products involved
Death Evacuat
Injured
s ed
New
Explosion (warehouse) 1992 29.04 Chemicals 43 20
Delhi
New
Fire at a chemical store 1994 13.11 Toxiccloud (chemicals) 500
Delhi
Leakage 1984 03.12 Bhopal* Methyl isocyanate 2800 50 000 200 000
Britannia
Leakage 1989 05.05 Chlorine - 200 ..
Chowk
leakage (transport
1997 21.01 Bhopal Ammonia 400
accident)
Leakage in an Ice
1990 00.07 Lucknow Ammonia gas 200
Factory
Thane
Transport accident 1994 00.01 Chlorine gas 4 298
District
New
Transport accident 1991 00.01 Ammonia gas 1 150
Bombay
Maharas
Transport accident 1995 00.12 Ammonia gas 2 000
htra
45
CONCLUSIONS
We learn best through our own experiences in different phases of our life.
Mistakes could be catastrophic in a chemical plant, but it is a great
opportunity to learn and design a safer plant in the future.
These incidents have much learning which reveal many hidden facts about
safety and provide efficient tools for prevention of similar incidents in the
future.
46