iePhysics
HeatEngines&Entropy
thermodynamics
byWilliamDietsch2006
HeatEnergy(Q)
Theenergy,whichflows,fromonebodytoanotherbecauseoftheirtemperaturedifference.Iftwo
bodieshavethesametemperatureasathird,theywillbeinthermalequilibriumwitheachotherandno
heatwillflow.Thisfactisoftenrefereedtoasthezerothlawofthermodynamics.+Qreferstoheat
whichflowsfromasystemandQindicatesheatflowintoasystem.
InternalEnergy(U)
Referstothetotalenergycontentofasystem.Itisthesumofallthekinetic,potential,electrical,nuclear
andallotherformsofenergypossessedbythemoleculesofasystem.Theinternalenergyofanideal
gasispurelykineticanddependsonlyonthetemperatureofthegas.
WorkDoneByASystem(W)
Whenasystemdoesworktoitssurroundings,Whasapositivesign.Ifthesurroundingsdoworkona
system,Whasanegativesign.
TheFirstLawOfThermodynamics
Thefirstlawisastatementoftheprincipleofconservationofenergy.Itstatesthatifanamountof
heatenergy(Q)flowsintosystem,thenthisenergymustappearasanincreaseintheinternalenergy
(U)andorwork(W)donebythesystemonitssurroundings.(preferableunitsareJoules)
Q=U+W
IsobaricProcess
Aprocesscarriedoutataconstantpressure.Seebelow.
Isochoric(Isovolumetric)Process
http://d1068036.site.myhosting.com/ePhysics.f/WDHeatEngines.html 1/6
3/7/2017 HeatEngines,Entropy
Aprocesscarriedoutataconstantvolume.Whenagasundergoessuchaprocess,anyheat,whichflows
intothesystem,appearsasanincreaseintheinternalenergyofthesystem,i.e.,Q=U.Seebelow.
IsothermalProcess
Aconstanttemperatureprocess.Inthecaseofanidealgas,U=0.Thisinnottrueforallsystems.
Forexample,whenicemeltsthechangeininternalenergyisnotequaltozerobecausethechangeof
staterequiresenergyinputtotheicetochangeitsstate(latentheatoffusion).Foranidealgasunder
isothermalconditions,(i.e.,U=0)allworkinputisequaltoanincreaseinthethermalenergy.(Q=
W).Seebelow.
AdiabaticProcess
Oneinwhichnoheatenergyistransferredtoorfromasystem.Q=0).Anyworkdonebythesystem
isdoneattheexpenseoftheinternalenergy(0=Q=U+W).
TheEfficiencyOfAHeatEngine
Theidealefficiencyofaheatengineisdefinedas:=workoutput/workinput.
TheCarnotcyclebyNicolasLonardSadiCarnot(b1796inParis,d1832)isthemostefficientcycle
possibleforaheatengine.Anengineinaccordancetothiscycleoperatesbetweenahotreservoir(at
temperatureTh)andacoldreservoir(attemperatureTc).(Thetemperaturesareabsolute,preferably
expressedinKelvin.)Theefficiency,=1Tc/Th.
TheCarnotCycle:
ABThegasisfirst(thisisacycle,soourstartisarbitrary)
expandedisothermallybytheadditionofheatQh.
BCThegasthenexpandsadiabatically.Noheatentersor
leavesthesystembutthetemperaturedropsfromThtoTc.
CDThegasiscompressedisothermally(constant
temperatureTc)andheatflowsoutQc.
DAThegasiscompressedadiabatically.Noheatentersorleavesthesystem,butthetemperature
increasestotheoriginalmeasure.
Theareaencompassedbytheenclosedcurvesonthegraphrepresentstheworkdonebytheengine.
Ifthefirstandthirdstepsaredoneinfinitelyslowlytheprocessistheoreticallyreversible.
Arealprocessontheotherhandisnotcompletedslowlyandthereforeresultsinanirreversibleprocess.
Inpracticalapplications,heatcanbesuppliedbyafuelandexternalworkperformed.Orthecyclecan
bereversedusinganexternalsourceofwork,pumpingheatoutintothewarmerenvironmentasina
refrigerator.
SecondLawOfThermodynamics
http://d1068036.site.myhosting.com/ePhysics.f/WDHeatEngines.html 2/6
3/7/2017 HeatEngines,Entropy
Heatflowsspontaneouslyfromahottertoacolderobject,butnotviceversa.ThisistheClausius
statementofthesecondlaw.
Nodeviceispossiblewhosesoleeffectistotransformagivenamountofheatcompletelyintowork.
ThisistheKelvinPlanckstatementofthesecondlaw.
Ifasystemundergoesspontaneouschange,itwillchangeinsuchawaythatitsdisorderwillincrease,or
atbestremainthesame.
Ifasystemundergoesspontaneouschange,itwillchangeinsuchawaythatitsentropywillincrease,or
atbestremainthesame.
Thesecondlawtellsusthedirectionaspontaneouschangewillfollow,whilethefirstlawtellswhether
ornotthechangeispossibleaccordingtoenergyconservation.Sometimesthesecondlawisusedto
determinetimesarrow.Thatis,theincreaseofentropyanddecreaseofavailableenergyinasystemis
anindicatorofthespontaneousprocessesthatweusetomeasurethepassageoftime.
Entropy(S)
Entropyisastatevariableforasystematequilibrium.Thismeansthattheentropy(S)isalwaysthe
sameforasystematequilibrium.Whenheat(Q)entersasystematabsolutetemperatureT,thenthe
changeinentropyis:S=Q/T.Areversiblechangeisoneinwhichthevaluesofp,V,T,andUare
welldefinedduringthechange.Iftheprocessisreversedthenthevaluesofp,V,T,andUwillfollow
thesamevaluesbutinreverseorderthoroughthechange.
EntropyIsAMeasureOfDisorder
Anotherfullyequivalentdefinitionofentropycanbegivenfromadetailedmolecularanalysisofthe
system.Ifasystemcanachievethesamestateindifferentways(differentarrangementofthe
moleculesetc.)thentheentropyofthesystemcanbeexpressed:S=kln.WherekisBoltzmanns
constant(1.38X1023J/K)andlnislogarithmtothebasee.
Asystemthatcanoccurinonlyonestate(onlyonearrangementofthemoleculesforexample)hasa
highstateoforderandalowstateofentropy.Toassociateanumberwithdisorder,thedisorderofthe
systemisproportionalto(thenumberofpossiblewaysthatstatecanoccur).Spontaneousprocessesin
systemscontainingmanymoleculesalwaysproceedfromastateofordertoastateofdisorder.
Entropyneverdecreasesinaspontaneousprocessitalwaysincreasesorstaysthesame.
MostProbableState
Isthatstateofasystem,inwhichtheentropyhasamaximumvalue.Itisthestatewiththemaximum
disorderandthestatethatcanoccurinthelargestnumberofways.
LudwigBoltzmann(b1844,d1906)madeacleardistinctionbetweenthegrosspropertiesofasystem
suchaspressure,temperature,andvolume(macrostate),andthemicrostateofthesubstance.The
microstateofthesubstancewouldbeascertainedbydeterminingthepositionandvelocityofallofthe
moleculesmakingupthatsystem.Therearelotsofmicrostates,whichcanyieldthesame
macrostate.Considerthepossiblemicrostatesinwhichonlyfourcoinsaretossedasshowninthe
followingtable.
http://d1068036.site.myhosting.com/ePhysics.f/WDHeatEngines.html 3/6
3/7/2017 HeatEngines,Entropy
4heads HHHH 1
3heads,1tail HHHT,HHTH,HTHH,THHH 4
2heads,2tails HHTT,HTHT,THHT,HTTH,THTH,TTHH 6
1head,3tails TTTH,TTHT,THTT,HTTT 4
4tails TTTT 1
Belowisatablefor102tossedcoins.Afternotingthenumberofmicrostatesforahundredcoins,
considerthevastnumbersofmicrostatestothelocationsofmoleculesinaballoonofgas(recallamoleof
gascontains6x1023 molecules).Thissuggeststhatthesecondlawisessentiallyastatisticalone.Itis
theoreticallypossibletotoss100coinsandhavethemallcomingoutheads,buttheprobabilityofthis
happeningisextremelylow.Intermsofprobability,thesecondlawclaimsthatentropyalways
increases.Moreprecisely,itstatesthatthisisthemostprobableoutcomeofanyphysicalchange.Itis
theoreticallypossibleforentropytospontaneouslydecrease,butforanysystemwithalargenumberof
entities,itishighlyimprobable.
Numberofmicrostates
Macrostate
(notemanyrowshavebeenomitted)
Heads Tails
100 0 1
99 1 1.0x102
90 10 1.7x1013
80 20 5.4x1020
60 40 1.4x1028
55 45 6.1x1028
50 50 1.0x1029
http://d1068036.site.myhosting.com/ePhysics.f/WDHeatEngines.html 4/6
3/7/2017 HeatEngines,Entropy
45 55 6.1x1028
40 60 1.4x1028
20 80 5.4x1020
10 90 1.7x1013
1 99 1.0x102
100 0 1
EntropyAsAMeasureOfInformation
PierreSimon,marquisdeLaPlace(b1749d1827)inthenineteenthcenturyproposedaformof
scientificdeterminism.Brieflystated,hesurmisedthatasufficientlyadvancedsciencewouldbeableto
determinetheexactvelocityandpositionofalloftheparticlesintheuniverse.Usingthisinformationa
person,intheorycouldpredictallfutureevents.WernerHeisenberg's(b1901d1976)uncertainty
theorymadethisformofdeterminismimpossible.Quantumdeterminismissimilarinthatitcanpredict
thefuturebehaviorofquantizedmatter.Extrapolatingthistoasuperadvancedcivilization,itisonce
againpossibletopredictthefuturemathematically.
Informationisdeemedbysometobeameasureofentropy.Asingleletterorbitofbinarycarriesvery
littleinformationandassuchhasverylowentropy.Asmoreinformationiscontainedwithinabody
(suchasmass,velocity,quantumwavefunctionsetc.),theentropycontainedwithinthatbodyalso
increases.Complexsystemscontainagreatdealofinformationandassuchhavelargeamountsof
entropy.Somephysicistslookatallmatterandenergyasmerelyinformationcarriedbythewave
functionsoftheconstituentpartsofthebody.
EntropyInBlackHoles
Blackholesarelocationsinwhichthegravitationofacollapsedstarissogreatitwarpsspacetothe
pointwhereitcreatesasingularityofinfinitedensity.Theblackholehasonlymass,charge,angular
momentumandentropy.Allofthecomplexityandattendantinformation(entropy)containedinthe
uncollapsedstarisreducedtotheabovesimpleproperties.AccordingtoStephenHawking(b1942)
andJacobD.Bekenstein(b1947),theentropyoftheblackholeonlydeterminestheareaoftheevent
horizon,nothingelse.ThisisthenohairtheoremproposedbyRogerPenrose(b1931).Wherehasall
oftheinformationoriginallycontainedwithinthestargone?Hasthesecondlawofthermodynamics
beenviolatedinthatentropyislostforever,causingtheentropyoftheuniversetodecrease?
Hawkinghasproposedthatblackholesarentsoblackastheyradiateenergyattheeventhorizondue
toquantumfluctuations.Doesthisradiationcontaintheinformationcarriedbythecollapsingstarand
anythingelse,whichhasfallenintotheblackhole?Iftheinformationisonlythermalthentheansweris
no.TheHawkingradiationcausedtheblackholetoeventuallyevaporate(overanunbelievablylong
periodoftime).IftheHawkingradiationdoesnotcarrytheinformationitislostforeverandthesecond
lawisviolated.
http://d1068036.site.myhosting.com/ePhysics.f/WDHeatEngines.html 5/6
3/7/2017 HeatEngines,Entropy
Supposeyoutossedabookintoablackhole?Thebookwouldbelostforeverandaddtotheareaofthe
eventhorizon,howevertheinformationcontainedwithinthebookisirretrievable.Thispresentsabig
problemtothosewhobelievethesecondlawofthermodynamicsisinviolate.It'scertainlypossiblethat
theentropyofmatterfallingintoablackholecanbetracedasthemattercrossesthehorizonopinionson
thisdiffer.But,firstofall,youarenotgoingtogetenoughentropytoaccountforthe(enormous!)
BekensteinHawkingentropyoftheblackholeaveryhighentropyblackholecanbeformedfrom
verylowentropymatter.Ifyouwanttoaccountforblackholeentropythisway,there'sasensethatyou
can,buttodothatyouhavetocountupallofthedifferentpossiblewaystheblackholecouldhave
formed,notjusttheparticularwayitdid.Theinformationlossparadoxisaquantummechanicalone:
youcan,itseems,formablackholefromapurequantumstate,andthenhaveitevaporatebyHawking
radiationintoamixedstate.Suchatransitionfromapurestatetoamixedstateviolatesthestandard
rulesofquantummechanics.It'scalled``informationloss''because,basically,youloseinformationabout
thequantumstateoftheuniverse.
TheComplexityCompromise*
Theconceptofcomplexityismoredifficulttopindown.Aphysicalsystemthatweconsidertobe
'complex'representsadelicatecompromisebetweenmindlesssimplicityandpurerandomness.Thisidea
canbestbeillustratedgraphically.Intheleftbox,thepointsarearrangedinaregularlyspacedgrid
(likeacrystal).Thissimplearrangementcarrieswithitlittleinformationandcanbedescribedbya
singlenumberspecifyinggridspacing.Ifnewpointsweretobeadded,oneknowsexactlywheretoput
them.
Theoppositeextremeisthemiddlepattern,whichdepictsarandomcollectionofpoints.This
arrangementofpointsrequiresagreatdealofinformationtodescribe.Becausethelocationofeach
pointisrandomandunrelatedtoanyother,thexandycoordinatesofeachandeverypointmustbe
specifiedtodefinethepattern.Sucharandompatterncarriesthemaximumamountofinformation.If
apointistobeaddedtothepattern,onehasnoideawherethepointshouldbeplaced.
Thepatternontherightillustratesamoreinterestingpattern,onethatissimultaneouslymorestructured
thanrandompointsandencodesmoreinformationthanthesimplegridatthetop.Ifanewpointistobe
addedonewouldhavesomeideawhereitmightfall,andyetitisnotcompletelyspecifiedinadvanceas
inthesimplegrid.Complexandinterestingpatternsnegotiatethepropercompromisebetween
simplicityandrandomness.
*ByphysicistFredAdams,withthehelpofillustratorIanSchoenherr,OurLivingMultiverse2004,
PiPress(NewYork)andOriginsofExistence2006
tonextexperiment
toePhysicsmenu
tositemenu
createdand2006byWilliamDietsch
posted&edited4February2008byDTrapp
http://d1068036.site.myhosting.com/ePhysics.f/WDHeatEngines.html 6/6