Anda di halaman 1dari 69

Management Engagement Training

2017 Survey
Reviewing Your Q12 Survey Results
Creating Action/Impact Plans with Your Team
Integrating Engagement into Your Everyday Work Life
Encouraging Peer Engagement
Next Steps for Managers
Appendices

Presented by UCSF Learning & Organization Development Department


1 UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Copyright Standards

Parts of this document contain proprietary research, copyrighted materials, and


literary property of Gallup, Inc. It is for the guidance of your company only and
is not to be copied, quoted, published, or divulged to others outside of your
organization. Gallup, Q12 Impact, SF34, CE11 Impact, Clifton
StrengthsFinder, SRI, The Gallup Path, StrengthsCoach, Gallup
University, Gallup Consulting, StrengthsFinder, The Gallup Poll, and
Business Impact Analysis are trademarks of Gallup, Inc. All other trademarks
are the property of their respective owners.

This document is of great value to both your organization and Gallup, Inc.
Accordingly, international and domestic laws and penalties guaranteeing
patent, copyright, trademark, and trade secret protection protect the ideas,
concepts, and recommendations related within this document.

2 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


UCSF Learning & Development Resources
Learning.ucsf.edu

3 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


What is Engagement and
Why Does it Matter?

4 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


What is Engagement?
Different for everyone

Engagement > Satisfaction

Engagement is based on an emotional connection


between the employee and organization.

Involvement, Enthusiasm, Discretionary Effort.

5 Copyright 2017 Gallup, Inc. All rights reserved.


Why Engagement Matters

Dedication
More loyal to the organization

Engaged employees share


More willing to put forth discretionary effort
certain characteristics that
help them to drive
performance outcomes.
More willing to trust and cooperate with
It is these attributes that others
the organization should
foster through the
engagement effort. More willing to work through challenges
(rather than adopt a victim mentality)

More willing to speak out about problems


and offer suggestions/comments
Ownership

6 Copyright 2017 Gallup, Inc. All rights reserved.


Who Owns Engagement?

Research suggests that peers have a significant influence on


engagement:

Source: Corporate Leadership Council

7 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Your Role in Enhancing Engagement

Hire The Right Person


For the Job

Conduct
Encourage Peer
Action
Engagement
Planning

Integrate Leadership
Actions Into Work Life

8 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Available Survey Results

Gallup provides three types of results:


Direct data: the responses of individuals who report directly to the
department manager. Available if 5 or more individuals in the unit
complete the survey.

Rollup data: the responses of all individuals who report directly and
indirectly to the department manager/director.

Verbatim data: open-ended responses to the question What could UCSF


do to make this an even better place to work? Available when there are
comments from at least 30 respondents. If not, they are rolled up to next
level managers report.

See Quick Guide and answers to FAQs to access your results.

9 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Communicating and Creating
Action/Impact Plans with Your Team

10 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Why are Communication of Results
and Action Planning Important?

Workgroups that show the greatest gain in engagement from one


year to the next do three things well:
They share and discuss their engagement results with one another.

As a team, they create an action plan to build engagement.

They work together throughout the year to make progress on the


action plan.

11 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Explore Engagement With Your Team

When?
Results were to be reviewed with your team by May 30, 2017.
Complete action plans with your team and post by August 30, 2017.

How Long?
Schedule 30-60 minutes to review the results with your team.
Schedule 60-90 minutes for action planning.

12 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Communicating the Teams Results

Share the results with your team.

Start a dialogue with mostly open-ended questions:


What do you think about our results? Does anything surprise you?
What is our highest-scoring Q12 item?
What are the most important things an outsider might learn about our
team from our results?
What are the headlines of our results?

???
13 UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Strong Correlation Between Action/Impact
Planning and Engagement
Average GrandMean Change in 2015-17 vs
UCSF Internal Accountability Index Quartile

0.30
Average GrandMean

0.20
0.20
Change

0.10

0.07
0.00
-0.05
-0.10
-0.10

-0.20
Bottom Middle Middle Top
<25 25<50 50<75 75+
(<3.20) (3.20 to (3.71 to (4.23+)
<3.71) <4.23)
(n=82) (n=80) (n=74) (n=83)

2017 UCSF Internal


Accountability Index Quartile

Note: UCSF Overall 319 Workgroups represented in this analysis;


14 UCSF Learning and Organization Development Quartile designation based on UCSF Internal Accountability Index Benchmarks
Copyright 2017 Gallup, Inc. All rights reserved.
Action/Impact Planning Process To Increase
Team Engagement

Strengths Progress
Action Connect to
Purpose Priorities and and
Plans Survey
Challenges Review

15 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Revisit Your Teams Purpose Purpose

Highlight the departments purpose to make the Action Plan meaningful


to your team. Link it directly to the teams and UCSFs purpose and
priorities.
Purpose - A brief statement that highlights the main purpose that a
department serves in terms of the value it adds to UCSF and its customers.

Example statement for our department:


Enhance UCSFs success by providing resources to enhance the growth and
development of its people.

16 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Revisit Your Teams Purpose Contd. Purpose

The following questions may help clarify the departments


purpose:
Who relies on our key services and how do we benefit them?

What services do we provide and what value do they provide to


customers?

What else makes our work meaningful?

17 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Identify Team Priorities Priorities

Brainstorm to teams current/near future priorities that help


fulfill the departments purpose.

Consider ongoing priorities and major initiatives/projects.


E.g. Excellent Patient Care, Accurate and Timely Financial Reporting, Cost
Management, New System Implementation, Billing.

Select the top two or three priorities on the teams


brainstormed list

18 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Identify Key Team Strengths
and
Strengths And Challenges Challenges

Brainstorm the key strengths and challenges that impact the teams
ability to meet the top priorities just identified.

Begin with brainstorming the strengths, then focus on the challenges.

What key strengths do we already have as a team that help us meet


our priorities at peak performance?

What key challenges do we face as a team that make it difficult to


meet our priorities at peak performance?

Preface the brainstorming of each of the above with a focus on how


the team operates and its needs (meaning more on what they can
influence). However, no need to censor the ideas as they are
generated.

19 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Identify Key Team Strengths
and
Strengths And Challenges Challenges

At the end of the brainstorming, select:

The main strength that would have the most impact on


maintaining the teams success in meeting their top priorities.

The main challenge that, once addressed, would have the most
impact on increasing the teams success in meeting their top
priorities.

20 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Generate Ideas For Action- Select
Improvement Action Plan Actions

Develop a plan to improve on the selected challenge. Focus on


challenges that the team can impact.

Brainstorm actions that would remove or address the


challenge.

Select two to three actions that would have the most impact on
the teams ability to meet the top challenge.

21 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Generate Ideas for Action: Select
Strengths Actions

Strengths Action Plan


Develop a plan to sustain or improve on each selected strength.

Brainstorm actions that the team would continue to sustain


the strength identified earlier.

Select two to three actions that would have the most impact
on maintaining their identified strength.

22 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Additional Tips For Action Plans Select
Actions

Focus on actions that have high impact compared to expended


effort:
For each plan, identify 3-4 actions with the most impact.
State your actions as specifically as possible.
Assign dates to review and to accomplish each action.

Use the Action Prioritization Grid to select the most effective


actions for your plans.

23 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Select
Action Prioritization Grid Actions

Low
II I
TIME/EFFORT

III IV
High
IMPACT
Low High
24 UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Connect Back To Q12 Connect
Questions to Survey

Determine which survey questions would most likely be


impacted by the Improvement Action Plan.
When we succeed, what areas of engagement will we improve?
The action plan may relate to multiple areas of engagement.

Complete the Summary Action Plan template.

Post the Action Plans on a visible board in your department and


enter it into Galluponline.com by August 30, 2017.

25 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


ENGAGMENT IMPROVEMENT ACTION PLAN SUMMARY
TEAM PURPOSE:

TEAM PRIORITIES:

KEY CHALLENGES:

ACTIONS: WHEN WE WILL REVIEW:

Q12 SURVEY ITEM(S):

26 Enter Action Plans at Galluponline.com by 8/30/17


UCSF Learning and Organization Development
ENGAGMENT STRENGTH ACTION PLAN SUMMARY
TEAM PURPOSE:

TEAM PRIORITIES:

KEY STRENGTHS:

ACTIONS: WHEN WE WILL REVIEW:

Q12 SURVEY ITEM(S):

27 Enter Action Plans at Galluponline.com by 8/30/17


UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Progress
Progress and Review and Review

Keep the plans in a visible place where your team can see them
regularly.

Hold regular discussions with your team to maintain focus on the


plan actions and acknowledge the progress made.

Periodically tie the action plan and its progress to the survey,
especially during plan review meetings.

28 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


How to Review Your Plan Progress
and Review

Are we achieving the action items


we said we would?

No Yes

Review relevance of action items


to your purpose, priorities, Does achieving them help us
& sense of team realize our purpose and priorities?
engagement and revise
Yes

Continue progress & determine whether


to add other actions to realize
teams purpose and priorities
& enhance engagement

29 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Integrate Leadership Actions Into
Everyday Work Life

30 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Your Role in Enhancing Engagement

Hire The Right Person


For The Job

Conduct
Encourage Peer
Action
Engagement
Planning

Integrate Leadership
Actions Into Work Life

31 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Start with Your Own Engagement

To sustain your own engagement level, try these actions:


Throughout the day, notice what you enjoy doing the most. Make a
note of it, and look for more ways to do what you enjoy again
tomorrow.

Spend some one-on-one time with your manager to learn where he


or she sees you doing your best work. Discuss opportunities for
devoting more time to those activities.

Include time in your day with the people or on tasks you enjoy.

32 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


What Keeps Your Team Members Engaged?

???
33 UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Examples of Best Practices To Build and
Sustain Staff Engagement
Holding team daily huddles with department leaders to review data on key
performance metrics and provide input/problem solve;

Reviewing progress of engagement plans every couple of


huddles/meetings;

Making goals, metrics and accomplishments visible to all and providing


greater amounts of decision-making authority to improve processes;

Helping employees feel safe to voice their opinions and to alert the team
to quality issues;

Encouraging and fostering peer recognition; and

Department and senior leader rounding with staff (go to gemba).

The above practices are intended to be integrated within Lean,


rounding or other proactive leadership practices.

34 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Rate Of Improvement is Better In Best Practice Units
vs. UCSF Health Overall

Change in Score from 2015-2017 for Unit Based Teams

Note: Comparisons are for those people in each group who took the survey in both 2015 and 2017.

35 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Copyright 1993-1998, 2017 Gallup, Inc. All rights reserved.
Self-Assessment: How Frequent are Your
Engagement Best Practices?
I do this regularly and consistently.
I try my best to focus on this, but
Assess your actions using the following checklist: sometimes things get in the way.
To be honest, I could really focus on this
more.

Item Green Yellow Red

I talk about key work responsibilities with every member on my team.


I encourage my team to learn about each others key work responsibilities.

I check whether my team has everything they need to do their best work.

I position my team members to make the best use of their strengths.


I give my team feedback on how we are meeting our goals.

I acknowledge and act upon my team members questions and comments.

I show the members of my team that I care about them and their success.

I promote/enable team members participation in activities beyond their roles.

I look for ways to expand team members skills, knowledge, and strengths.

I make a special effort to be visible to my team.

I frequently recognize my direct reports and others efforts &accomplishments.


I facilitate communication and collaboration within and outside our department.

36 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Follow-Up Actions On Your Self-Assessment

Continue demonstrating behaviors you rated Green.


Select 1 or 2 impactful ways to increase frequency of Yellow or Red
behaviors.
Select areas first that have the most impact on your teams needs.
Focus your effort where there is a connection with Q12 results.
All the leaders actions listed are closely aligned with Lean Daily
Management Practices. Integrate them into your daily work with your
team.
Consider the following Learning and Development programs as
engagement resources for you or your staff: Leading the Frontline,
Skillsoft, Professional Staff Development (for staff), and online
learning.

37 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Integrating Engagement with Daily Work:
Managers Touch Points

There are probably many situations throughout the day when you can
implement engagement best practices with your staff. What are
these touch points and when do they happen?

Weekly
Team
Daily Meetings
Huddle Daily
Employee
Rounding

38 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Encouraging Peer Engagement

39 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Your Role in Enhancing Engagement

Hire The Right Person


For the Job

Conduct
Encourage Peer
Action
Engagement
Planning

Integrate Leadership Action


Into Work Life

40 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Your Role In Supporting Peer Engagement

Encourage opportunities for teamwork and a sense of belonging:


Set group expectations in addition to individual ones.

Boost peers knowledge of each others work.

Build opportunities for peers to interact within workflows.

Encourage professional peer feedback.

Incorporate peer recognition and appreciation into regular meetings.

Engagement Ambassadors can play a key role in peer engagement.

41 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Source: 2010 CLC HR Engagement Research Survey
Your Staffs Role in Supporting Peer
Engagement

Helping Out

Approachability

Recognition

Positive Attitude

Providing Feedback

Source: Corporate Leadership Council; 2014 interviews with UCSF staff

42 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Encourage Engagement Champions

After the action/impact planning process, encourage your survey


ambassador or an informal leader (non-supervisor) to promote peer
engagement.

Ensure that they are introduced to the peer engagement training.

Together, discuss options for them to lead:


A meeting with their peers to agree on constructive practices to
increase each others engagement; or
An informal approach that entails connecting with individuals or
small groups to encourage peer engagement practices.

Refer to the Peer Engagement Activity Guide at


http://tinyurl.com/UCSFEngagementResources

43 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Next Steps For Managers

44 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Next Steps For Managers

1. Review survey results with your team by May 30.

If your GrandMean is 3.0 or less, please consult with Learning and Organization
Development before conducting impact planning. Email
learninganddevelopment@ucsf.edu.

2. Work with your team to develop action/impact plans that address


team priorities:
Maintain or build on the area of strength with greatest impact.
Improve on the area of challenge with greatest impact.

3. Complete and enter into Galluponline.com by August 30.

Action/Impact planning is recommended, even if your unit does not have survey
results. Check with your organization for specific expectations.

45 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Next Steps For Managers - Continued

4. Integrate engagement into your daily work.


5. Support peer engagement.
6. Follow up with your team on progress made on action plans.
7. Keep your next level manager informed of progress and needed
support.

For additional consultation regarding how to best communicate


results to your team, conduct action/impact planning, or follow up on
progress, contact LearningandDevelopment@ucsf.edu.

46 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Help With Accessing Your Survey Unit Report

Gallup sent emails, with links to access survey results, to each unit
manager who has results.
NOTE: survey access from Gallup must be activated within 48 hours of
receipt of personalized link.

If you did not activate the link for the first time within 48 hours,
contact the Gallup helpline to request another: q12help@gallup.com
or (877) 425-5871.

47 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Appendix I - Reviewing Your Q12
Survey Results

48 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Instructions For Accessing Reports From
GallupOnline
Go to learning.ucsf.edu.
Click on Engagement tab.
Instructions in both video and PDF formats.

49 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


How to Access Your Reports

Direct or Rollup Scorecard (5+ respondents), click on Q12 Reports


Verbatim Report (30+ respondents), click on Q12 Static Reports

50 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


First, Review Your Teams Results On Your
Own

Review your departments results on your own before exploring them


with your team.
Points to keep in mind:
The reports provide a snapshot in time of your teams engagement.

Be curious, dont jump to conclusions.

Consider the context of your teams recent history.

Look at the results which show the biggest increase in engagement.

Look for results that deserve recognition for the team.

51 UCSF Learning and Organization Development Copyright 2011 Gallup, Inc. All rights reserved.
Key Elements Of The Summary Card

52 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Key Elements On The Scorecard

Mean Percentile
Total N The total Rank The
number of people percentile rank in
who responded to Gallups overall
the Q12 item. database of the
Q12 items
Current Top Box Last Top Box The
The percentage of percentage of 5
5 (Strongly Agree) (Strongly Agree)
responses for the responses for the
most recent Q12 previous Q12
survey. survey.
Last Mean The
Current Mean The average response,
average response, on a 5-point scale,
on a 5-point scale, for the Q12 item on
for the Q12 item on the previous Q12
the most recent survey.
Q12 survey.
Frequency
Distribution A
visual scale with
Top Box color-coded
Percentile Rank response
The percentile rank distributions. Click
in Gallups overall to display a pop-up
database of the window with
Q12 items top box detailed information
score. about the response
distribution.

53 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Appendix II:
Q12 ENGAGEMENT RESOURCES

54 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Q12 Definition Summary, Q1-Q3

Q1: I Know What Is Expected Of Me At Work


This is more than simply knowing the tasks needed to complete your job; it is understanding the steps of
your work and how success will be measured in the context of the success of the unit or organization.
It is an awareness of how what one person is supposed to be doing fits in with what everyone else in the
unit or organization is supposed to be doing.
Being able to evaluate and address changes in expectations and priorities when circumstances change.

Q2: I Have The Materials I Need To Do My Work Right


Having access to the tools and resources that you need to correctly complete your tasks.
These can be the standard materials regularly needed, or specific to your needs.
The word materials can be defined very broadly: Tools, resources, training on new systems, processes
and work area layout/environment, no distractions that can affect productivity.

Q3: At Work, I Have The Opportunity To Do What I Do Best Every Day


Being able to use your innate abilities, as well as your skills and knowledge, in your work.
Your competencies and individual preferences are matched to the requirements for your job.
Maximizing the frequency of optimal experiences, of being in gear, or in the zone.

55 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Q12 Definition Summary, Q4-Q6

Q4: In the Last Seven Days, I Have Received Recognition or Praise for Doing Good Work
This refers to recognition from anyone, not just your supervisor or manager.
Appropriate recognition depends on the person receiving it. Recognition can be public or private, verbal
or written, material or non-material. But, however you prefer to receive recognition, it should be specific
and timely.

Q5: My Supervisor, or Someone at Work, Seems To Care About Me as a Person


In a work setting, care might appear as positive relationships or support for one another with teamwork,
commitment, and readily sharing knowledge and skills.
Someone is taking an interest in your personal life and activities.

Q6: Someone at Work Encourages My Development


Development means helping you improve your skills or get better at what you do.
Supporting your development can also mean helping you find roles or positions that fit your unique
combinations of skills, knowledge and talents. Development does not necessarily mean promotion.
This type of support is best when it is an informal, voluntary, mutually agreeable, and self-selected
interaction between two people.

56 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Q12 Definition Summary, Q7-Q9

Q7: At Work, My Opinions Seem to Count


You are frequently asked for your input and it is seriously taken into consideration when decisions are
made.
You feel that there is access to channels of communication across all levels of organization and that your
manager works to maintain those channels.

Q8: The Mission or Purpose of My Company Makes Me Feel My Job is Important


You identify with the organizations mission and purpose.
You know how your job fits into the grand scheme of things and that it contributes to the organizations
mission.

Q9: My Associates or Fellow Employees are Committed to Doing Quality Work


You believe your team is committed to quality.
You work in an environment of honest and complete communication about quality issues.
On your team, you understand each others work, and respect each others efforts and results.

57 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Q12 Definition Summary, Q10-Q12

Q10: I Have a Best Friend at Work


You have a strong sense of affiliation with someone on your team.
You have a relationship where you can share information and help othersespecially when support is
needed.
There is someone on your team that you watch out for, and who watches out for you.

Q11: In the Last Six Months, Someone at Work Has Talked to Me About My Progress
Someone has told you how youre doing, how you are perceived, and where your work is leading.
This refers to regular, insightful, personal feedback with active listening, not only formal performance
reviews.

Q12: This Last Year, I Have Had Opportunities at Work to Learn and Grow
Ive been given an opportunity for self-improvement; I have a chance to get better at what I do.
I feel that I am learning and am genuinely interested in improving my work.
I feel that I am making progress in my career.
Im given the chance to grow in a variety of ways, such as training and developmental assignments,
trying new things, finding more efficient ways to do my job.

58 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Further Reading On Engagement

12: The Elements of Great Managing Rodd Wagner and James


K. Harter

The 1001 Rewards and Recognition Fieldbook Bob Nelson, Dean


Spitzer

The Art of Engagement Jim Haudan

Engaged Leadership Clint Swindall

Engaging the Hearts and Minds of all your Employees Lee J.


Colan

Employee Engagement Macey, Schneider, Barbera and Young

Make their Day Cindy Ventrice


59 UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Development Resources for Managers and
Staff

Development workshops for managers.

Professional Staff Development series for staff (registration through


UC Learning Center: https://learningcenter.ucsfmedicalcenter.org/).

Learning portals for staff and managers (http://learning.ucsf.edu).

If you would like to request unit-specific planning or facilitation


support, please contact learninganddevelopment@ucsf.edu.

60 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


60
Online Learning - Skillsoft

Professional and leadership e-Courses - 1,100+

Continuing Education Units BRN (Nursing), PMI (Project


Management), and NASBA (Accountancy)

Prepare for additional certifications (HR, PM, etc.)

Desktop e-Courses- 500+ Microsoft Office, iPhone, and office


productivity software training

Short videos and live events

IT based e-Courses 18,000+

61 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


61
Skillsoft & CEs/Certifications

62 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


62
Other Engagement Tools And Resources

L&OD website: http://tinyurl.com/UCSFEngagementResources


Link to Gallup Website
Gallup Online Quick Reference Guide
How to Access Q12 Reports

Other engagement resources are also available on the site.

63 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Appendix III:

ACTION PLANNING
FACILITATION GUIDELINES

64 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Recommendations for Facilitation Challenges
During Action/Impact Planning

Prior to the action planning sessions, determine if it is best for you to


facilitate the action planning session or ask an informal leader from
your group to facilitate.

If during the meeting people are silent: Ask them to talk to each other in
clusters of 3-4, and after a few minutes, open the discussion to the whole
group.

If one or two people dominate the group discussion: Use brainstorming


rules on following slide to get input.

If people bring up unrelated topics: Write the topics in a parking lot for
future follow-up, and remind them of the original topic.

If people bring up problems that are outside the units ability to remedy:
Ask what they can do about the problem within their circle of influence.

65 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Sample Group Norms

Help make this a safe zone.

Keep an open mind.

Respect differences of opinions.

Avoid side conversationsspeak one at a time.

Presume good will.

Speak on your own behalf.

Share openly.

Listen actively.

Silence electronics.

66 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Brainstorming Rules

Take turns, in sequence.

One brief thought at a time.

Avoid critique or analyzing the ideas.

Build on the ideas of others.

It is OK to pass.

Record the ideas without changing the meaning.

67 UCSF Learning and Organization Development


Consensus Decision Steps

1. Define the desired outcome: a decision about which area the team
will focus its engagement efforts on.
2. Identify 3 - 5 evaluation criteria for the decision (i.e., whatever the
decision, it has to have a high impact on engagement; be within
the units sphere of influence; relate to current priorities; etc.).
3. Brainstorm solutions, using Brainstorming Rules (see slide 68).
Emphasize that no analysis or decision will be made during
brainstorming.
4. Apply evaluation criteria to the brainstorming list and remove ideas
that do not fit.

5. Examine remaining options to find out if clear decisions emerge.

Copyright 2003 APS


68 UCSF Learning and Organization Development
Consensus Decision Steps, Contd.

6. If no decision emerges, narrow remaining options by discussing


pros and cons of most viable ideas, utilizing the evaluation criteria.
7. If above steps do not result in a final decision and you have a few
viable decisions, use voting to select the best option that meets
evaluation criteria.
8. Check with all participants to ensure that they can commit to the
decision, support it and fully implement it.
9. Check again to find out if anyone cannot commit to, support, or
fully implement the solution. If so, find out their reasons and
address in a group discussion.

69 Copyright 2003 APS


UCSF Learning and Organization Development

Anda mungkin juga menyukai