4 Plaintiff,
9 _______________________________________________
25 therein).
1 A P P E A R A N C E S:
15
16
17
REPORTED BY: GINA R. HORNBECK, CCR-RPR
18 NM CCR #43, TX CCR #2987
GINA GRUBEN, INC.
19 COURT REPORTING SERVICE
2200 W. PIERCE ST.
20 8A
CARLSBAD, NM 88220
21 575-623-4462
gina@courtreportersite.com
22
23
24
25
1 I N D E X
2 PAGE
6
Reporter's Certificate.............. 211
7
Witness's Signature Page............ 214
8
9
E X H I B I T S
10
Exhibit # Description Page Marked
11
1 E-mail 29
12 2 Documents Notebook 35
3 E-mail 39
13 4 E-mail 41
5 E-mail 42
14 6 E-mail 43
7 E-mail 47
15 8 E-mail 69
9 E-mail 75
16 10 Water Board Report 78
11 Letter 79
17 12 E-mail 83
13 Handwritten Note 91
18 14 E-mail 174
15 Letter 179
19 16 Letter 183
17 Letter 200
20
21
22
23
24
25
6 you say.
8 investigator.
12 or Bob Gallagher.
16 the witness.
17 ROBERT GALLAGHER,
20 EXAMINATION
21 BY MR. FALLICK:
2 A Yes.
4 A K.
6 A 12-5-1955.
17 A I do.
21 A Yes.
1 A Yes.
8 A Yes.
13 A Yes.
21 A Yes.
24 right?
25 A Yes.
4 A Yes.
11 A Yes.
15 A Yes.
18 A Yes.
23 A Yes.
3 A Yes.
6 penalty of perjury?
7 A Yes.
10 deposition?
11 A Yes.
15 A No.
19 A No.
22 questions today?
23 A No.
25 before?
1 A Yes.
8 A Yes.
12 today, right?
13 A Yes.
15 case?
17 in this case.
7 A Yes.
10 A Yes.
13 file them?
14 A Yes.
18 the complaint.
5 the documents?
12 this, no.
14 that?
15 A No.
20 it.
6 A No.
8 A I would be.
11 A Yes.
16 communication.
20 is a confidential communication.
24 communication.
20 particular pleading.
12 communication.
14 hair.
16 step at a time.
21 A Yes.
23 Mr. Newell to --
5 not to answer.
13 2017.
15 A Yes.
17 hearing.
19 A No.
24 to Judge Clingman?
25 A Yes.
4 attorney-client communication.
10 confidential.
17 a position.
4 that.
9 record.
10 Is that okay.
21 attorney-client instruction.
3 to my IPRA letter?
10 production?
11 A Yes.
21 talking about.
2 A Yes.
5 Jal?
17 request, right?
18 A Yes.
21 Q Yes.
22 A Yes.
3 public records.
6 understand that?
10 request.
12 company documents?
22 wouldn't be complete.
1 Jenny Edwards?
4 respond to it.
12 to that question?
18 correct?
19 A Correct.
4 question.
8 require.
10 Mr. Newell?
2 refer to 'em.
6 city manager?
7 A Yes.
10 obligations?
11 A Absolutely.
16 A No.
22 A No.
25 negative in there.
3 over.
10 again. Okay?
19 A No.
22 A No.
25 requester?
1 A No.
4 A Yes.
6 well, correct?
9 name of Crutchfield?
10 A Yes.
12 Melody Beckham?
13 A Yes.
16 differently?
21 one differently.
25 A To who?
2 A I don't recall.
15 employees.
22 and employees."
24 A Yes.
1 A Absolutely.
5 A Yes.
10 A I believe so.
16 absolutely ridiculous?
21 A That's correct.
16 my hands on something.
25 identification.)
3 recognize that.
13 council members?
21 people?
19 Q Understood.
2 A No.
6 numbers.
8 as 1 through 3000.
12 cumbersome.
3 agreeable to you?
4 A Absolutely.
7 that right?
10 that up.
14 that.
17 that up?
4 from 2014?
8 of 'em.
12 system?
20 A Yes.
4 councilors.
14 2/26/16.
18 that stipulation?
2 identification.)
15 Number 2.
19 just described?
20 A Yes, sir.
18 correct.
1 2014.
6 the record.
11 mistake. So...
17 deposition.)
3 A To Jenny Edwards.
8 password.
11 servers?
12 A Absolutely.
24 identification.)
5 e-mail?
9 from there.
12 Q Right.
13 A I apologize.
17 Okay.
22 A Yes, sir.
3 documents?
4 A No.
9 A Yes, sir.
13 A No.
19 it, then.
21 identification.)
4 question.
6 Okay.
12 produced to me?
13 A No.
17 identification.)
25 Okay.
4 A I don't know.
11 past.
13 identification.)
3 Q Yeah.
12 Jenny meant.
16 A Yes, sir.
9 yes, true?
11 not yes.
19 members?
22 of the Council.
23 Q Now?
24 A Yes, sir.
1 A No.
5 not.
6 A Yes.
9 A No.
18 addresses?
22 can respond.
7 10:33 a.m.)
9 record.
11 identification.)
18 you, Mike.
25 IPRA letter?
2 Mr. Fallick.
11 servers?
21 business."
6 of Jal"?
17 going to be clean.
20 request?
21 A No.
25 A No.
8 7.
9 'em.
25 that sentence?
5 way"?
8 government entity.
23 Catholic temper.
12 it's filled.
1 gets in my way."
12 information?
14 process.
20 A Right.
4 for 1 through 4.
7 letter.
25 OCD?
1 A Yes, it is.
12 public domain."
15 something.
22 look at it.
2 A Councillor Ellison.
6 box.
10 A They did.
12 Jal?
13 A Yes, I was.
15 A I am.
18 manager, right?
19 A Yes.
24 specific.
5 water?
16 Division's job?
24 to be public records?
3 we do?"
11 A There was.
16 A Right.
17 Q On City property?
18 A Yes.
21 A Correct.
23 Councillor Ellison?
24 A It was.
1 A He did.
3 A Some of them.
8 do?"
12 documents?"
6 IPRA letter?
9 were produced.
14 matter."
22 want?
4 questions 1 through 4?
6 at all.
10 you?
16 Albuquerque."
12 them?
1 in blue packaging?
3 enough. I apologize.
9 or not?
10 A No.
13 say that.
16 be produced?
17 A No.
5 A No, sir.
9 Newell?
15 these documents?
11 A I don't know.
14 A I don't know.
20 A No.
22 identification.)
3 A I do.
4 Q What is that?
9 A It does.
11 A Yes.
13 deposition?
14 A Yes, it is.
22 from Chevron.
25 OCD.
2 A I do.
6 A I did not.
8 Chevron?
9 A I do.
10 people at all?
11 A No.
20 A No.
3 those people?
11 area."
13 A No.
18 A Not to me.
20 to you?
21 A About?
23 Chevron?
9 11:12 a.m.)
11 record.
16 OCD communications?
19 Q Correct.
24 testimony today?
4 Councilor Ellison?
20 A No.
22 identification.)
3 about it.
11 document.)
12 Okay.
18 A No.
22 over.
4 the answer.
11 2016?
14 Q If I showed you --
16 identification.)
25 Number 9.
1 Q Thank you.
3 identification.)
18 A I do.
23 deposition, correct?
25 of that meeting.
12 water, correct?
18 correct?
23 A Yes, sir.
2 freshwater aquifers"?
5 Q Anything else?
20 A Mr. Newell.
11 identification.)
13 hand you --
15 Mr. Newell --
2 A Yes, sir.
5 the complaint?
12 A Okay.
15 A Yes, sir.
22 Exhibit A --
23 A Yes, sir.
25 A Yes, sir.
7 A That's correct.
10 today, correct?
15 A Yes, sir.
19 wrote a memo.
1 involved in it.
4 retired --
5 A No.
6 Q -- or whatever.
7 A No.
9 A Yes.
15 correct?
16 A Yes.
22 A That's correct.
25 aware of?
16 A No.
25 on the record?
18 that way.
6 now.
11 to --
13 guys?
15 hour.
1 this plan.
3 12:41 p.m.)
5 record.
7 identification.)
15 to go forward.
17 you, Mike.
21 So Gallagher Number 13 is my
1 water wells.'"
4 says?
5 A Yes, sir.
17 A Yes, sir.
1 files, correct?
2 A Yes, sir.
8 question, Mike?
12 useful.
14 helpful, I believe.
19 order.
20 Yeah. Here's 2.
25 A Okay.
10 A Okay.
12 3.
1 So that is it.
6 files.
9 set, too.
3 not Chevron.
15 want to preclude --
17 to save time.
2 gotcha.
5 I want to try to --
6 MR. NEWELL: Do it --
11 with that.
7 plowing ahead.
17 deposition.)
2 you're done.
4 1:03 p.m.)
6 record.
12 A I do.
23 1 through 3492?
2 you.
12 A Yes, sir.
15 22, 2016.
2 not be.
20 oil company?
21 A I do.
22 Q What is that?
24 Q Yes.
9 were documents --
15 A That's correct.
20 myself.
23 school.
25 go to med school.
2 is?
13 A That's correct.
19 A I did not.
3 Okay?
7 other.
18 A Okay.
20 electronic search.
4 it looks --
21 well.
22 (End of recording.)
1 A That is.
6 A It is.
20 correct?
21 A Correct.
12 side.
19 A Yes, sir.
21 height.
25 (indicating).
2 well.
3 A I apologize.
5 A I gotcha.
9 this cover.
11 box of documents?
14 the --
15 A I do.
17 A Uh-huh.
24 that.
25 Q Okay.
9 qualities here.
11 boxes.
16 1:24 p.m.)
20 A Yes, sir.
23 correct?
24 A Correct.
5 measured.
8 observed it.
14 business.
17 a half inches.
21 A Yes, sir.
2 water wells.'"
5 that?
18 1:35 p.m.)
23 more time?
2 water wells.'"
5 A I did.
10 saying before.
18 in.
10 Jal.
10 past history.
4 et cetera.
18 told us.
2 going on.
7 Jal.
12 on?
18 produced to us.
20 do you?
21 A No.
3 to us?
4 A No.
15 you're saying.
20 I apologize.
24 freshwater aquifers."
16 Capitan Reef.
21 is it?
1 well, is it?
2 A No.
5 A I do.
7 drinkable?
22 cleanup, is there?
8 A Correct.
12 that it was.
24 to hide.
1 question.
20 water.
24 right?
25 A Absolutely.
2 for now.
5 Q Thank you.
9 A That's correct.
17 my prior e-mail?
18 A Yes, sir.
21 here?
10 was.
14 going to be here.
16 would be here?
2 right?
6 attorney-client privilege?
8 that.
11 documents --
16 my question.
19 find it?
24 produced to you-all.
11 Mr. Newell?"
14 A Yes, sir.
17 Mr. Ellison?
2 IPRA?
3 A No.
9 this.
5 A When?
17 A Absolutely.
25 admissible evidence.
23 Is that accurate?
1 subject matter.
22 that.
3 A The e-mails?
4 Q Correct.
16 thing.
7 e-mails, right?
11 you --
20 e-mails, right?
1 conversations.
7 A Yes.
11 A Okay.
13 A Sure.
18 A Sure.
3 A Okay.
16 A Oh, okay.
17 through.
25 didn't get.
16 about?
22 business day.
25 unreasonable guess?
2 correct.
7 request.
9 right?
10 A I do.
13 meetings?
14 A I do.
17 A No.
24 question.
4 oath?
10 there?
16 A Yes, sir.
20 termination?
10 question?
14 with it.
12 instruction.
15 question.
17 false.
22 termination?
1 instruction?
2 A Yes, I am.
7 does, yes.
16 objection --
3 meeting?
4 A I don't know.
8 request?
16 so e-mails.
6 thousands of e-mails?
16 A I would agree.
25 2:31 p.m.)
2 the record.
11 (Audio stopped.)
14 Mr. Gallagher?
15 A That is.
21 $1 per page.
4 (Audio stopped.)
7 22 seconds.
12 IPRA request?
18 Q Yes.
2 Council meeting.
3 (Audio playing.)
5 driver of --
6 (Audio stopped.)
9 Newell's voice?
10 A I do.
12 28 seconds.
13 (Audio playing.)
7 (Audio stopped.)
12 my IPRA letter?
13 A Yes.
20 close.
21 (Audio playing.)
1 $1 per page.
16 2014.
21 for.
22 (Audio stopped.)
1 right?
4 Q Could be?
16 we talked about.
3 information?
8 public records.
2 had no clue.
14 What is that?
1 Mike?
4 MR. FALLICK: 7.
8 (Audio playing.)
21 (Audio stopped.)
5 it?
12 A Probably.
14 conversations?
17 of those conversations?
19 record conversations.
23 McCoys?
24 A On many occasions.
13 their feud?
16 don't recall?
22 anyone else?
24 sentence.
17 Fulfer?
23 A Never to me.
2 lawyer, right?
6 IPRA letter?
8 Q Is that a "no"?
19 uncooperative?
21 legally --
24 her, right?
25 A Right.
4 her, right?
19 A Right.
7 that"?
10 remember?
21 A I don't know.
23 services?
24 A Yes.
25 Q Who's that?
9 your head?
11 Q Who does?
14 A You did.
18 A No.
19 that way?
22 that.
25 admissible evidence.
18 response?"
1 for a murder?
2 A No.
12 to explain it.
14 analogy?
18 be analogizing.
3 doable.
7 councillors?
8 A No.
15 at my notes here.
21 know why.
25 Q Why?
20 everybody.
25 identification.)
7 number?
12 about that.
17 document.)
18 Okay.
10 A You did.
13 e-mail, to --
14 A Right.
16 Gallagher Exhibit 5?
7 Fairly easy.
10 Jal, right?
17 A Yes, sir.
19 Jal, right?
20 A Yes, sir.
23 A Right.
11 the City.
7 rest?
16 Council?
18 City Council.
2 identification.)
19 Q Third paragraph.
24 answer."
7 answer."
9 A You did.
12 A That's correct.
14 2016, right?
15 A Correct.
19 A Correct.
14 is a contractual agreement.
4 approval?
7 admissible evidence.
9 correct.
14 admissible evidence.
16 conclusion in paragraph 3.
19 correct?
22 admissible evidence.
1 identification.)
3 Gallagher 16.
5 you, Mike.
9 Okay.
12 engineer, correct?
13 A It is correct.
18 admissible evidence.
23 you to do this?
1 admissible evidence.
8 do this."
12 to reaffirm it.
14 what?
23 of that?
1 admissible evidence.
6 Council resolution?
9 admissible evidence.
15 file.
3 requested that.
8 two pieces.
22 A Absolutely.
24 A Right.
8 direction."
11 else?
16 city manager?
19 admissible evidence.
2 of Jal manager?
6 hide.
8 the Beckhams?
10 Q Correct.
17 water, right?
25 (indicating).
2 field.
7 right here.
10 again, Bob?
14 copy.
18 Let's look.
23 do we?
3 that.
14 to that letter.
17 what that --
20 the letter.
23 of it.
1 bottom of 441.
4 don't know what Page 442 is, but I'm sure that
11 to take it out.
17 together comprise --
18 That's 15?
21 document.
15 new wells.
23 out looking.
5 admissible evidence.
13 Basin, right?
14 A Yes, sir.
19 admissible evidence.
4 admissible evidence.
1 need of water?
6 evidence.
12 applying.
19 of admissible evidence.
12 A Correct.
2 wasn't running.
6 that.
10 theft of water?
4 admissible evidence.
7 sticker, please?
13 identification.)
20 Yeah.
25 A Yes.
2 This is your --
4 because --
13 3:53 p.m.)
1 profit."
3 that correctly?
15 evidence.
18 communications.
20 you --
3 that.
3 wanted to --
18 that?
22 for a deposition?
8 everything.
10 everything.
2 admissible evidence.
10 EXAMINATION
11 BY MR. NEWELL:
1 60 days of '16?"
21 computer crashed?
5 clerk.
16 witness.
17 FURTHER EXAMINATION
11 to the question?"
19 by the councillors?
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
4 Plaintiff,
11
25 by counsel.
25
1 _____________________
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
15
21 ______________________________
DATE
22
23
24
25