Plato in his Phaedo has Socrates make one of the most
cryptic statements in all of Philosophy, The purpose of
Life is to prepare for Death. Often interpreted as a ode to glorified pessimism, it verily contains the essence of the whole of Platonic Philosophy and the nature of the philosophical endeavour itself. The Greek age was one of the last cultures where Philosophy reflected the esoteric structures of reality and concerns of human life in its most far reaching aspirations, much like the Upanishads with its mystic Mahavakyas and deep springs of wisdom. So when Plato links life and death in one sweep of rhetoric, it behooves us to look closely at what he is trying to teach Mankind. Ever since Man has evolved to the consciousness of a thinking self-aware human being, Death has been the one constant which has terrified him throughout his existence. He may have invented ways to evade his confrontation with this enemy until late in his life, but he has not defeated him. Our myths, epics and legends are full of Death, sometimes as a friend, sometimes as a fair or unfair Judge, mostly as an enemy who robs innocent lives of their chance to enjoy mortal life. The greatest artistic depiction of death undoubtedly remains Ingmar Bergmans The Seventh Seal but haunted by a distorted Christian version of death, Bergman could only paint him as a dark, hooded foe. Art might entertain us but its not for Art to enlighten us, not anymore. Today, death occupies an even more prominent place in the consciousness of mankind since man is now using his latest toy, Science to defeat Him. But He remains undaunted and undefeated. And so shall He be until we take the next evolutionary step in consciousness to understand what Death has been trying to say for many millions of years. Our wise men knew it and spoke to us, sometimes in riddles and sometimes in plain speech. But we were not ready. With Science behaving like a toddler trying to scrape together something to placate the deep despair and agony of its denizens, it is time to speak more clearly about what really Death is so we can finally rest our souls and stop trying to win an impossible war. For this is not a War in the first place.
Plato was an initiate, a Siddha in Indian terms who had
access to knowledge forbidden to the layman. This restriction upon knowledge might offend our modern democratic sensibilities but this was not done to exclude anyone. Knowledge as Man has always known is like a knife which can be used to kill as well to redeem. Since the advent of materialistic Science, we have been taught this lesson in umpteen ways but drugged by a false ideal of equality, we have still not learnt these truths. One is given knowledge not because he wishes for it but because he has proven himself deserving of it. These tests of endurance and deservedness were called initiations in the Greek Mysteries only after which, one was allowed entry into the hallowed portals of wisdom. There are frightening accounts of such tests in the ancient literatures and Proclus, the Neo-platonist disciple of Plato, wrote that the Odyssey is itself the allegorical depiction of a profound Initiation ritual. To describe them is not the objective of this essay so we come back to Death. When Plato mentions Philosophy as a way to prepare for Death, he is making a very crucial assumption that Death is a milestone in a journey, a signpost that something significant has been achieved in a long itinerary of the soul. Phaedo in itself is a wonderful dialogue on the existence of an afterlife and is highly recommended. The question is, what is the nature of this journey and what meaning can then be ascribed to Life given the certainty of Death ? For Plato, life only has meaning because we will die. If there was no Death, would this life have any meaning ? If we could be assured to living for ever, would there be any imperative in us to create meaning in life ? The great psychoanalyst, Ernest Becker in his pathbreaking work, Denial of Death, made the striking claim that all human endeavor and civilization is built as a defense mechanism against Death. As true as it is, it must be remarked that this is largely true of the Western Civilization for in the east, Death has been always taken as a friend, until lately when it got drugged by its fascination for the glamour of the west. Our stories of course have a Dark Deva, Yama who rides a bull and comes to take us from our mortal bodies but he takes us to YamaLoka, which is in truth, a state of consciousness and not a location. But Death as such has never been hated and feared by the virtuous and the wise. Its only the spiritually corrupt and sinners who fear death. And Plato makes the same point in Phaedo through Socrates when he says that he is looking forward to meet the Gods after Death. Our modern consciousness has become so cut off from the truth of our existences that what was common exoteric knowledge of our ancestor has become esoteric and hidden in our times.
To understand the purpose of Death, we have to
understand the purpose of Birth. And the first important truth to understand is that Death is the opposite of Birth and not Life. Since we are born, we must die but in neither case are we ending the continuity of Life itself. We have simply changed its mode of operation, from a non- material one to a material one and back. For now, this has to be an assumption for most but I will come to more proofs later in the essay. India has always been the land of the seekers. Religion in its modern sense does not really belong to this country since we have never been a group of blind believers unlike the west where Faith held sway for well over a thousand years until its crumbled under its own weight. The greatest spiritual treatise, The Bhagwad Gita mentions in unambiguous terms, the illusory nature of Death when it says, Death is simply the discarding of a piece of cloth and the wearing of a new one. These are important words. To understand the meaning of these words, we have to take recourse to the science of Koshas or cloaks in Yoga. Man is composed of 5 koshas, Annamaya Kosha or Physical Body, Pranamaya Kosha or the Etheric Body, Manomaya Kosha or Astral Body, Vijnanamaya Kosha or Lower Mind body, Anandamaya Kosha or Higher Intuitive mind body. Death is essentially the severing of the first 2 bodies, Physical and the Etheric from the last three bodies. After death, one is simply retreating into his or her Manomaya Kosha along with the last 2 bodies, leaving behind the physical and etheric. One of the yogic principles on which the science of Ayurveda and Homoeopathy is based on, is that the physical body is not the realm of causes, but rather the one of effects. The physical body is the recipient of forces that originate in the etheric body which in turn, depend on the forces acting from the astral and mental bodies. Thus these medicinal disciplines affect this body and not the physical. All scientific tests designed to disprove these disciplines will end up in vain because these bodies are not detected by the modern scientific instruments. Science will bang its head for sometime and finally dismiss the whole field because of a misplaced idea of causation, ignorant of the esoteric nature of inner bodies. This interconnected nature of inner bodies is the reason why, Ayurveda and Homoeopathy always insists on clean living, good thinking and harmonious living. It is not that they are some die-hard moralists refusing to go modern. It is because the emotional or astral bodies are so connected to the physical through the effects on the Pranamaya Kosha that disturbances in emotional life invariably result in physical problems. Modern Science is not finally coming to terms with this truth. Death therefore, robs you of your physical and etheric cloaks and releases you in your emotional and mental bodies. To be sure, these are not locations in space one enters into. Space and Time are realities only in the Physical Plane. These are rather states of consciousness just that the physical life on earth is also just a state of consciousness. The defining feature of this state is the existence of sense-organs through which one is able to cognize the exterior world. Similarly the defining state of consciousness in after-death states is the existence of subtle organs of perception called tanmatras well known in Yoga. After death, one is not robbed of Life, he is released into a much more wider realm of consciousness whose laws are very different from the physical plane. I will come to this later. The more immediate problem to confront is the meaning of Death since it is Death that gives Meaning to Birth and Life as we know it. One of the great Spiritual classics of India is the Bhagawat Purana where a story is related of the King Chitraketu who had everything in life except a son. He requests Sage Angiras to bless him with a child which the sage accepts on a condition that this Son will be a cause of despair for the King. The King accepts it and within a few months upon birth, the child dies drowning the whole royal family in despair. When Sage Angiras comes to placate the King with some truths about the illusory nature of birth and death, the king is unmoved. Sage Narada then invokes the soul of the departed child in a trance who then speaks to the King about the true nature of birth and death. Illumined as to the truth, the King takes to Yoga and gets released from the cycle of births and deaths. As fable-like as they sound to us today, these are essentially Yogic truths encased in a story form. We must realize the great truth that all the Vedas, Puranas, Itihasas and ancient stories are the result of deep meditation of Yogis and Rishis. They were written for the benefit of ignorant humanity who did not yet have the capability to verify these truths by direct experience of Yoga. Hence the requirement of Faith in the Masters. Aside from being a source of great power, the result of Faith is best reflected in Life itself. I am not ignoring the dark side of Faith which has also led to great disasters. But as I shall show, this has its bright side too. Sage Narada while invoking the soul of the departed child was having a dialogue with the essential Man behind the physical child who died. The soul which appeared was a grown up man and not a child. In Yoga, this plane of reality is called the Karana Sharira, the causal body. It is the True Man behind the outer coverings of lower mind, emotions and physical body. These three bodies are just the accumulation of forces outside the True Man, the Thinker in esoteric terms. One incarnates on the physical plane to work off karma, or the result of forces one has set in motion in previous lifetimes. By forces, we are essentially talking of thought currents, emotional forces of jealousy, anger, hurt at others and of course, physical plane actions. We have forgotten today that thought is as much a force as physical forces. In truth, Thought is the real force which sometimes manifests as physical force. This is why we think of doing many things but dont. But for the universe, thinking is also doing, albeit in a different plane of consciousness. It is well known in Yoga that the thought currents directed outwards at external objects remain in the causal body as impressions to be worked off in a future or present incarnation. The true Man is not involved in any of these currents but remains independent in its own plane untouched by these. It gains experience of these lower planes but it is equally true that for the man identified with these three lower bodies, reaching his Own True nature, means dis-identifying with the three bodies of physical, emotional and lower mental natures. All of Yoga, meditation and spirituality is in reality, this one striving to dis-identify. Death gives us release from the physical but not from the emotional and mental. There is a secondary process after death called the second death when the emotional body is broken down into its constituent elements and the mental body is the only one left. What most religions call Heaven is in truth, a residing in the pure mental body, also known as the plane of Meaning. Heaven has been mis-represented by most religions as some paradise of pleasure, but it is simply the reaping of the most meaningful and blissful acts in the last incarnation. It is selfish in the sense that you only reap the fruits of your own life. The nature of this reaping is a very complex business and i will discuss it in some future post but for now, the essential truth is that in heaven, one finally comes to understand the True Meaning behind the physical plane actions one did. This meaning is in essence, abstract as all true meaning is. Abstraction today, remains as the pursuit of only mathematicians and philosophical thinkers, but ideally, it should be the pursuit of all since that is what life essentially about. This urge to meaning which every human being realizes after death is manifested in earthly life as the Human search for meaning. One result of Philosophical pursuit which Plato wanted to instill in his students is that one can understand the true Purpose of Life here itself its its abstract Truth and thus prepare for Death. By Death, Plato did not the mean the usual laymans death just described earlier. Death for Plato is essentially a release from Life just like the old Indian goal of Mukti or Liberation. We come to birth due to karmas which are the result of our identifications with the three lower bodies. Philosophy, but educating us about the true reality behind the appearance of objects, releases us from this identification and lets us go beyond a personal or selfish obsession. This letting go of these false identifications is what is called Moksha or Liberation. When one has dis-identified with the three illusory planes of lower life, namely, physical, emotional and lower mental bodies, one has nothing selfish remaining. One has gone Universal. One is bound to nothing narrow. In Yogic terms, one has graduated from the earthly life, only to enter into a much wider canvas of activity. The Planet Earth only exists for human beings to learn this lesson of universality. This truth has been spoken by many masters over the millenia in sentences like, Life is a school, not a playground, The purpose of Life is God-realization. God realization is simply the identification of the personal with the universal consciousness. Death for the normal man, is a release from the fetters of the flesh so that one can learn the truths of the last earthly life he led, learn from the mistakes and come back to complete this lesson of universality. Until one learns this, one will keep on re- incarnating on earth. To be even more exact, there is a limit on how many chances one gets to learn these lessons. In the Bible, there is a mention of a certain Judgement Day. This has been mis-interpreted as usual by dogmatic theologians. The estoeric truth behind this is that after a certain period of time, Planet Earth will no more give uneducated souls a chance to keep reincarnating to learn the essential universal truths of existence. These failures will then be kept in cosmic cold storage so to say, until a new planet conducive to their evolution is found. What will be the parameter for such a separation is not known but the fact of separation is undoubtedly true. This truth gives a tremendous force to the individual striving for liberation which the Buddhists embody to the greatest level. Death is thus revealed to be a friend who shakes off the cloak when it sees that the individual is not carrying out the purpose of its incarnation anymore. Most lives are led without any idea as to the origin or the end of that life existence. He or she might be accumulating many things in outer life but these acquisitions most often do not serve either the individual or the society. Such lives are in need of the shocking wisdom that only Death can give sometimes because the earthly life has become so stagnant that nothing worthwhile will reach him. Beyond Death is not liberation. Beyond Death is a chance to come back to birth to pursue liberation. Beyond the selfish Heaven is Liberation which is to be sought for in earth itself. I shall give a beautiful illustration of this process through a small diagram in a book written by the American sage, Franklin Merrel Wolfe called Death and After.
In this figure, the innermost circle BCDEFG is the goal of
human evolution and the three outer circles are the region in which man keeps revolving for many incarnations until he is able to break through into the inner circles. Breaking through, in a true sense means raising the vibration and consciousness through Yoga and not reaching somewhere in space and time. The book Death and After is one of the most scientific explorations of the process of death I have ever come across and must be read by any seeker of Truth. Here is theLink :Merrell Wolfe Death and After
Death constitutes the most pressing problem of modern
life as we are faced with ever increasing problems of extinction driven by our own selfishness caused by a forgetting of the purposes of life itself. The divine created this Planet only so we could evolve spiritually and for no other reason. But this evolution is not something guaranteed and human have to earn it for themselves. The Masters can show the path just like Krishna showed the path to Arjuna but Arjuna and Mankind has to walk this path themselves. Truth brooks no barriers no matter what. At the end of all doubts as to the feasibility of such a quest, the only certainty we have is the search for our own Truth. As we find our own Truth inside, we will find the truth of everything outside. Death is a beneficent blessing and a friend who teaches us when we falter that we have to come back and walk the path to infinite Glory and sublime Truth.
Bacon's Man of Science Author(s) : Moody E. Prior Source: Journal of The History of Ideas, Vol. 15, No. 3 (Jun., 1954), Pp. 348-370 Published By: Stable URL: Accessed: 07/04/2014 11:57