Clare DSouza
is a senior lecturer in the Business School at La Trobe University, Australia. Her key research interests include environmental marketing with special
interest in social implications of corporate marketing decisions, and green products marketing communication. She can be contacted at cdsouza@
latrobe.edu.au
Mehdi Taghian
is a senior lecturer in International Marketing at Deakin University, Australia. His key research interests include environmental marketing, marketing
audit and marketing strategy.
Rajiv Khosla
is an associate professor at the School of Business, La Trobe University, Australia. He has a multidisciplinary background in management, engineering and
computer science. His key research interests include management information systems and cognitive models. He can be contacted at R.Khosla@latrobe.edu.au
Abstract Research indicates that the environment has had a definite impact on consumer behaviour
whereby suggesting to target consumers according to their environmental beliefs. This study investigated
the consumers green purchase behaviour using price and quality attributes as contributors to the formation
of purchase intention. It attempts to construct a model that may facilitate the better understanding of
green consumers market segments through the use of an intelligent soft computing model. The model
is designed to incorporate knowledge, beliefs, demographic profiles and situational variables. This
potentially provides a more direct method for companies to gauge consumers intention to purchase
green products. The results showed strong preference for companies to place higher priority on reducing
pollution than on increasing profitability. It highlighted different clusters that demonstrate various levels
of the strength of intention to purchase and market segment profiles.
Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing (2007) 15, 6978. doi:10.1057/palgrave.jt.5750039
2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00 Vol. 15, 2, 6978 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 69
www.palgrave-journals.com/jt
DSouza, Taghian and Khosla
70 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 15, 2, 6978 2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00
Examination of environmental beliefs and its impact
2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00 Vol. 15, 2, 6978 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 71
DSouza, Taghian and Khosla
structured based on prior qualitative research and neighbourhoods or clusters that act as feature
the literature review. The instrument was pre- classifiers on the input data. The advantage of
tested and modified to include variables developing neighbourhoods is that vectors that
contributing to the customers formation of the are close spatially to the training values will still
overall perception about environmentally safe be classified correctly even though the network
products. All measurements were subjective has not seen them before, thus providing for
assessments by the respondents using a seven- generalisation.
point Likert-type scale.37 The sample was Since Kohonens network is an unsupervised
randomly drawn from the residential telephone self-organising learning paradigm, Kohonen also
directory of Victoria (Australia) including both introduced a supervised learning technique called
metropolitan and regional areas. The Learning Vector Quantisation (LVQ). LVQ
questionnaires were administered over a weekend method is very useful because it amounts to a
using Quantum Research data collection services. method for fine-tuning a trained feature map to
The respondents were the main buyers of food optimise its performance in altering circumstances.
from supermarkets irrespective of gender. A total The basic feature of LVQ method is that we can
of 155 questionnaires were completed and were add new training vectors at typical situations to
used for data analysis. improve the performance of individual
The sample selection method using a random neighbourhoods within the map. This can be
telephone dialling was expected to provide a achieved by selecting training vector (x) with
representative sample of the supermarket shoppers known classification, and presenting them to the
population. No nonresponse rate has been network to examine cases of misclassification.
reported as the automatic telephone dialling Again a best match comparison is performed at
would select the next call to replace the each node and the winner is noted (nw) (Beale
unsuccessful call. and Jackson,38 p. 122).
The selected samples main characteristics were The LVQ prediction model used in this work
female (79 per cent), 3554 years old (49 per is based on the need to develop an incremental
cent), married (65 per cent) with children (47 per learning model of green purchase based on price
cent), secondary school educated (60 per cent) and quality.
and employed (50 per cent). The data were In order to develop a predictive model, we
analysed using both descriptive measures and need to determine green consumer cluster groups
cluster analysis to identify and validate the items related to purchase intention. These cluster groups
contributing to each component in the model then will become the dependent variable to be
developed. The resulting instrument included predicted by the LVQ technique. In the rest of
items to measure customers product perception this section, we first describe the identification of
of quality and price by using Kohonens LVQ purchase intention cluster groups and then follow
behaviour prediction agent, which is discussed it up with the design and implementation of the
below. prediction model.
72 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 15, 2, 6978 2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00
Examination of environmental beliefs and its impact
2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00 Vol. 15, 2, 6978 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 73
DSouza, Taghian and Khosla
resistance to lower quality and relatively more based clusters are distinct green customer groups
relaxed in terms of higher prices. whose purchase intentions are influenced by
Figure 2 shows the clusters based on different beliefs, attitudes and demographic
cognitive, affective, customer characteristics and characteristics.
price/quality variables. Thus, Figure 1 shows 11 Eight of the 11 clusters shown in Figure 2 are
price/quality-based clusters. Of these ten price- plotted on a two-dimensional price and quality
PRICE
C1 (High)
C9
C5
C6
C11
C7
QUALTIY QUALITY
(High) (Low)
C8
C2
PRICE
(Low)
74 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 15, 2, 6978 2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00
Examination of environmental beliefs and its impact
2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00 Vol. 15, 2, 6978 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 75
DSouza, Taghian and Khosla
76 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 15, 2, 6978 2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00
Examination of environmental beliefs and its impact
In both these quadrants, the research indicated green demographic profile. Further research could
that all clusters showed strong preference for investigate this issue more fully.
companies to place higher priority on reducing For those companies that intend to use the
pollution than on increasing their own green product offering as a competitive advantage,
profitability. it appears to be fundamental to segment their
markets based on the three combined dimensions
of price/quality/demographic characteristics and
MANAGERIAL IMPLICATIONS be able to quantify each segment for their
Peattie10 indicated that if the majority of attractiveness and purchase readiness.
consumers were offered credible green products Keller40 has identified ten top traits for the
with similar prices and technical performance to worlds strongest brands. In order to build up a
conventional products, consumers would strong green brand, there appears to be a need
discriminate in favour of the green products. for consideration of a pricing strategy in line with
Thus, for marketers of green products, the consumers perception and strength of attitude
challenge lies in how to identify environmental toward value and specifically about green values.
beliefs and values consumers hold about green Therefore, for environmental marketers pricing
products in order to target them. For those may involve a three-way balance between price,
consumers who do not currently purchase green eco-performance and primary performance to
products, the question is whether and how they create a green value strategy.10
can be motivated to become potential green A fundamental issue is whether green
consumers. consumers can be targeted. This study suggests
The present study has found evidence to that those consumers whose beliefs extend
suggest that there appears to be a fundamental positively towards the environment, potentially,
expectation existing on the part of the customer demonstrate a relatively consistent response
about all products to be green and friendly format and commonality of intention to
to the environment. From the cluster analysis, purchase. Therefore, this target market may
it can be explained that consumer attitude be attractive and could, potentially, be served
appears to be that they are less likely to using a well-structured and formulated
compromise on product quality than on environmental marketing strategy and consistent
somewhat higher prices of green products. Thus implementation.
with respect to business strategy, arguably, this
may mean two things: (1) manufacturers may
produce higher quality green products and use CONCLUSIONS
the premium pricing strategy commensurate In summary, the understanding of the
with the higher costs of production or (2) green products perception formation, potentially,
they may compete in the marketplace offering has a number of applications. The analysis
comparable product quality standards at the provides the motivations for management (1)
competitive price categories in the market. The to build a strong competitive advantage for the
second option may require investment in refining product, in terms of quality and price, (2) to
production processes and employing technology develop and project a profile of green
more effectively to create lower cost-based consumer based on demographics and (3) to
production processes. meet customers expectations by genuinely
It can be seen that buying intent for green being as well as effectively being recognised
products is also associated with customers by consumers as being demonstrably socially
personal characteristics. Consumer demographics responsible. This strategy may offer the
play a role in cluster analysis. In essence, to target potential benefits of improvement in market
these markets effectively, managers may benefit share and assist to achieve sustainable longer
from segmenting the market based on consumers term profitability.
2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00 Vol. 15, 2, 6978 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 77
DSouza, Taghian and Khosla
78 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 15, 2, 6978 2007 Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 0967-3237 $30.00