Case Assignment

IV JUDICIAL DEPARTMENT
Case Under the Topic of SCRA/GR Date Reporter Back-ups
1 Diaz v CA Dec. 5, 1994 Omar Minda/Roa
Jurisdiction October 7,
2 First Lepanto Ceramics v CA 1994 Melvin Yanne/Tito
3 De Castro v JBC appointments of judiciary Rosalyn Thelma/Mark
4 Zanduela v de la Costa 66 Phil 615 Thelma Shy/Jerry
Meralco v Pasay
5 Transportation justices/judges may not 57 Phil 600 Roa Melvin/Mazo
be...
6 Lopez v Roxas 17 SCRA 756 Yanne Omar/Junalyn
7 Garcia v Macaraig 39 SCRA 106 Mazo Roa/Rylah
8 CSC v DBM Fiscal Autonomy GR 158791 20-Feb-06 Tito Earnswell/Yanne
Re: request of Judge AM no. 00-3-
9 Ernesto Acosta 01-CTA Sept. 29, 200 Minda Mark/Thelma
10 Fortich v Corona en banc & Div. Cases GR 131457 19-Aug-99 Jerry Maryjane/Rosalyn
Dolalas v Office of the
11 Ombudsman Powers: Adm. Supervision GR 118808 Dec. 24,1996 Junalyn Melvin/Jerry
12 Maniago v CA Rule -making powers 253 SCRA 674 Mark Shy/Omar
13 People v Esparas mandatory review.... GR 120034 Aug. 20, 1996 Shy Junalyn/Mazo
14 Nicos Ind. Corporation v CA 206 SCRA 127 Omar Minda/Roa
Decision of the court
15 Prudential bank v Castro L-69907 31-May-85 Melvin Yanne/Tito
16 Echegaray v Sec of Justice Power to control... GR 132601 Jan. 19, 1999 Rosalyn Thelma/Mark
112 SCRA 294
17 De la Llana v Alba Tenure of Justice supra Thelma Mazo/Agapito
18 Maceda v Ombudsman GR 102781 22-Apr-93 Roa Melvin/Shy
Removal and discipline
19 People v Gacott 246 SCRA 52 Yanne Omar/Junalyn
20 Perfecto v Meer 85 Phil 552 Mazo Roa/Minda
21 Endencia v David Salaries 93 Phil 696 Tito Jesson/Rosalyn
Nitafan v Com. Of Internal
22 Rev. 152 SCRA 284 Minda Mark/Thelma

V. Legislative Department
Ang bagong Bayani v
1 COMELEC GR 147589 26-Jun-01 Jerry Agapito/Rosalyn
2 BANAT v COMELEC HR Composition GR 179271 Jul. 8, 2009 Junalyn Thelma/Mark
Ang Ladlad LGBT v
3 COMELEC GR 190582 8-Apr-10 Mark Anne/Jerry
4 Macias v COMELEC 3 SCRA 1 Shy Melvin/Shy
5 Felwa v Salas 18 SCRA 606 Omar Shy/Junalyn
6 Gonzales v COMELEC 21 SCRA 774 Melvin Roa/Minda
7 Baker v Carr Apportionment 369 v 186 Rosalyn Mazo/Yanne
8 Mariano v COMELEC 242 SCRA 211 Thelma Mark/Thelma
9 Montejo v COMELEC GR 118702 19-Mar-95 Roa Tito/Rosalyn
Sen. Benigno Simeon
10 Aquino v COMELEC GR 189795 7-Apr-10 Yanne Melvin/Jerry
11 Marcos v COMELEC 248 SCRA 300 Mazo Shy/Omar
12 Aquino v COMELEC Qualifications Sept. 18, 1995 Tito Earnswell/Mazo
13 Bengson v HRET supra Minda Melvin/Roa
14 Jimenez v Cabangbang 17 SCRA 876 Jerry Jesson/Junalyn
15 Antonio v Valencia 57 SCRA 70 Junalyn Thelma/Mark
Eastland v US Servicemen's
16 Fund Parliamentary Immunity 421 v 491 Mark Yanne/Tito
17 Hutchinson v Proxmire 443 US 111 Shy Thelma/Mark
Pobre v Sen. Miriam
18 Defensor -Santiago A.C. No. 7399 25-Aug-09 Omar Shy/Jerry
19 People v Jalosjos Disqualification/Disabilities Gr 132875-76 Feb. 3, 2000 Melvin Minda/Shy
20 Osmena v Pendatun 109 Phil 863 Rosalyn Omar/Junalyn
Discipline
21 Santiago v Sandiganbayan GR 128055 18-Apr-01 Thelma Roa/Minda
GR 147589
22 Santiago v Guingona Session, Adjournment... supra 26-Jun-01 Roa Mazo/Yanne
23 Avelino v Cuenco Quorum 83 Phil 17 Yanne Mark/Thelma
24 Pacete v Secretary of CA 40 SCRA 58 Mazo Melvin/Jerry
Internal Rules
25 Arroyo v De venecia GR 127255 Aug. 14, 2007 Tito Maryjane/Rosalyn
26 US v Pons Journals/Enrolled Bill 34 Phil 729 Minda Mark/Omar
27 Mabanag v Lopez Vito 78 Phil 1 Jerry Junalyn/Agapito
28 Casco Chemical v Gimenez 7 SCRA 347 Junalyn Minda/Roa
29 Morales v Subido 27 SCRA 131 Mark Yanne/Tito
30 Astorga v Villegas 56 SCRA 714 Shy Thelma/Mark
31 Bondoc v Pineda 201 SCRA 792 Omar Yanne/Tito
Abbas v Senate Electoral
32 Tribunal Composition 166 SCRA 651 Melvin Thelma/Mark
Pimental v Comm. On
33 Appntmnts GR 141490 Nov. 29, 2002 Rosalyn Mazo/Jerry
34 Aquino v COMELEC Sept. 1995 Thelma Melvin/Shy
35 Sampayan v Daza 213 SCRA 807 Roa Omar/Junalyn
36 Daryl Grace Abayon V HRET Electoral Tribunals powers GR 189466 Feb. 11, 2010 Yanne Roa/Minda
37 Waledn F. Bello v COMELEC GR 191998 Dec. 7, 2010 Mazo Mazo/Yanne
38 Henry Duenas, jr v HRET GR 191550 4-May-10 Tito Shyla/Thelma
39 Caruncho v Comelec Jurisdiction over GR 135996 Sept. 30, 1999 Minda Tito/Rosalyn
40 Aggabao v COMELEC proclamation GR 163756 Jan. 26, 2005 Jerry Melvin/Maryjane
41 Guingona v Gonzales Comm. On appointments 214 SCRA 789 Junalyn Shy/Omar
42 Sarmiento v Mison 156 SCRA 549 Mark Junalyn/Mazo
Ma. J. A. matibag v A. Powers of CA
43 Benipayo GR 149036 April 2 2002 Shy Minda/Roa
44 Ocampo v Cabangis Gen. Legislative Power 15 Phil 626 Omar Yanne/Tito
E. Quarto v Simeon
45 Marcelo police power GR 169042 5-Oct-11 Melvin Thelma/Mark
Datu Michael Abas kida v
46 Senate Implied limitations GR 196271 Feb. 28, 2012 Rosalyn Yanne/Tito
47 Guzman v COMELEC One Bill One Subject GR 129118 July 19, 200 Thelma Thelma/Mark
48 PJA v Prado GR 105371 Nov. 11, 1993 Roa Rosalyn/Jerry
Sufficiency of Title
49 Chiongbian v Orbos 245 SCRA 253 Yanne Melvin/Shy
50 Tolentino v Sec'y of Finance GR 115455 Aug. 25, 1994 Mazo Omar/Junalyn
Decision of motion for Bill originate excl. Frm. HR
51 Reconsideration 30-Oct-95 Tito Roa/Earnswell
52 Bengson v Drilon Item veto 208 SCRA 133 Minda Mazo/Yanne
Immigration Service v 462 US 919, 77
53 Chadha L.Ed.2d 317 Jerry Mark/Jesson
Legislative veto
Phil. Constitution Asso. V
54 Enriquez 235 v 506 Junalyn Tito/Rosalyn
55 Guingona v Carague Implied limitation on... 196 SCRA 221 Mark Melvin/Jerry
Phil. Constitution Asso. V Prohibition against
56 Enriquez transfer.. supra Shy Mark/Omar
Pascual v Sec'y of public
57 works 110 Phil 331 Omar Junalyn/Mazo
purpose
58 City of Manila v Posadas 48 Phil 300 Melvin Minda/Roa
59 Aglipay v Ruiz 64 Phil 201 Rosalyn Yanne/Tito
60 Churchill v Concepcion 34 Phil 969 Thelma Thelma/Mark
Bishop of Nueva Segovia v
61 Prov. Brd Power of taxation 51 Phil 352 Roa Yanne/Tito
Republic v Phil. Rabbit
62 Busline 32 SCRA 211 Yanne Thelma/Mark
63 Senate v Ermita GR 169777 20-Apr-06 Mazo Rosalyn/Jerry
Bengzon v Senate Blue
64 Ribbon Comm. 203 SCRA 767 Tito Melvin/Agapito
65 Arnault v Nazareno 87 Phil 29 Minda Omar/Junalyn
power of Legislative Inves.
66 Arnault v Balagtas 97 Phil 358 Jerry Roa/Maryjane
67 In re: Camilo Sabio GR 174340 Oct. 17, 2006 Junalyn Mazo/Yanne
Romulo L. Neri v Senate
68 Comm. GR 180643 25-Mar-08 Mark Mark/Thelma
67 US 635 17
69 The Prize cases L.Ed 459 Shy Omar/Rosalyn
Power to dec. State of war 389 US
934,19L.Ed.2d
70 Mora v Mc Namara 287 Omar Melvin/Shyla
Defensor-Santiago v
71 COMELEC Initiative... GR 127325 19-Mar-97 Melvin Shy/Omar
72 SBMA v COMELEC Indirect Initiative GR 125416 Sept. 26, 1996 Rosalyn Junalyn/Mazo
73 Garcia v COMELEC Recall GR 111511 Oct. 5, 1993 Thelma Minda/Roa
204 SCRA 464,
74 Evardone v COMELEC loss of confidence... 472 Roa Yanne/Tito