Bioresource Technology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/biortech
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Electricity production and modeling of microbial fuel cell (MFC) from continuous beer brewery wastewa-
Received 16 December 2008 ter was studied in this paper. A single air-cathode MFC was constructed, carbon ber was used as anode
Received in revised form 24 February 2009 and diluted brewery wastewater (COD = 626.58 mg/L) as substrate. The MFC displayed an open-circuit
Accepted 27 February 2009
voltage of 0.578 V and a maximum power density of 9.52 W/m3 (264 mW/m2). Using the model based
Available online 29 April 2009
on polarization curve, various voltage losses were quantied. At current density of 1.79 A/m2, reaction
kinetic loss and mass transport loss both achieved to 0.248 V; while ohmic loss was 0.046 V. Results dem-
Keywords:
onstrated that it was feasible and stable for producing bioelectricity from brewery wastewater; while the
Beer brewery wastewater
Microbial fuel cell
most important factors which inuenced the performance of the MFC are reaction kinetic loss and mass
Continuous operation transport loss.
Model 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0960-8524/$ - see front matter 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.biortech.2009.02.058
4172 Q. Wen et al. / Bioresource Technology 100 (2009) 41714175
and parameters of the models are complicated, the process of mod- on the unit change; 0.1 denotes the volume of anolyte (L). To mea-
eling is also complex. A basic simple model, which can provide sure electrode potentials, a digital voltmeter was used against a
important predictions and optimization about inuence of activa- saturated Ag/AgCl reference electrode. The Coulombic efciency
tion loss, charge transport and mass transport on the performance (CE) was calculated using the ratio of total Coulombs obtained in
of MFC, is more applicable. Therefore, establishing of simple model the experiment (CP) to the theoretical amount (CT) available from
for MFC should be given attention. complete substrate oxidation (Liu et al., 2004):
In this paper, the feasibility of electricity production from con-
CP It
tinuous brewery wastewater using air-cathode MFC was demon- CE 100% M 1
CT F n DS V
strated. The inuences of external resistance on voltage, power
density, COD removal efciency and Coulombic efciency (CE) on where I represents the current (A); t is the time interval (s); F is the
performance of MFC were investigated. A basic electrochemical Faraday constant = 96,485 C/mol; n is the number of moles of elec-
model of MFC was established based on polarization curve; a de- trons produced per mol of substrate (n = 4 for oxygen reduction on
tailed analysis of various voltage losses was carried out to obtain cathode); DS is the absolute removal amount of COD (mg/L); V is
the net fuel cell jV behavior. the volume of anolyte (L); M is molecular weight of the substrate
(32 g/mol for oxygen).
Polarization curves were obtained by plotting potential and
2. Methods power density against current density. Potential were measured
at variable resistance points (900020 X) during stabilized fuel cell
2.1. Microbial fuel cell conguration operation. COD was determined by standard method (Wei, 2002).
2.2. Culture and operation Polarization curves are useful for determining dependence on
resistance of fuel cell performance. To obtain the polarization
Anaerobic mixed consortia from Harbin beer brewery (China) curve, the current density was calculated and plotted against volt-
was used as inoculums in the anode chamber of MFC for electricity
generation. Diluted beer brewery wastewater, supplemented with
phosphate buffer solution (PBS) and other trace elements required
by microorganism growth (Lovley and Phillips, 1988), was used as 1.0
0.07
substrate. The characteristics of raw brewery wastewater are: pH,
-2
current density / A m
0.06
0.9
6.6 0.2; COD, 1680 400 mg/L; NH3-N, 19 10 mg/L; TN,
0.05 current density
27 12 mg/L; SS, 600700 mg/L.
0.8 0.04
Fuel cell was operated in continuous ow at room temperature
(24 4 C). Brewery wastewater, which was diluted by PBS (4.97 g/ 0.03
0.7
voltage / V
0.6 12 Table 1
voltage(V) Substrate degradation at different external resistance.
activation -3
0.5 polarization power density(W m ) External resistance (X) 9000 500 100 70 60 20
10
Inuent COD (mg/L) 604 636 652 657 626 654
0.4 Efuent COD (mg/L) 344 372 387 391 358 380
power density / W m
8
COD removal amount (mg/L) 260 264 265 266 268 273
COD removal efciency (%) 43.0 41.5 40.6 40.5 42.8 41.7
voltage / V
0.3
6
ohmic loss that the reactor has a well ability and stability in wastewater treat-
0.2
4 ment in various conditions.
Coulombic efciency (CE) is shown in Fig. 3. As current density
-3
0.1
2 increased, CE increased linearly. According to formula (1)
CE CC PT 100% FnItDSV M (Liu et al., 2004) and data in Table
0.0 concentation polarization
1, it can be seen that DS is nearly independent of R, thus the theo-
0
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 retical electricity production (CT) had a little change. But as current
current density / A m
-2 increased, total electrons obtained (CP) in the experiment in-
creased, which resulted in an increasing CE. According to linear
Fig. 2. Voltage and power density generation as a function of current density. t of this curve, it was found that the relationship between CE
and j is CE = 0.1298 + 8.3624 j, with a correlation coefcient of
0.9998.
A maximum CE of 19.75% was obtained at external resistance of
age and power density at different external resistances (20 20 X, which is quite lower than CE of synthetic wastewater (Liu
9000 X) (Fig. 2). Results showed a maximum power density of and Logan, 2004; Venkata-Mohan et al., 2008b). There are many
9.52 W/m3 (264 mW/m2) at external resistance of 60 10 X. Cur- possible reasons for such a low Coulombic efciency, such as the
rent decreased consistently with the increase in the resistance, complicated component of brewery wastewater (probably includ-
which is accordance with literatures reported earlier (Liu and Lo- ing some other electron donors), oxygen diffusion to the wastewa-
gan, 2004; You et al., 2006; Venkata-Mohan et al., 2008b). ter, etc.
It is evident from the experimental data that the voltagecur-
rent density curve can be roughly divided into three stages: activa- 3.4. MFC modeling
tion polarization, ohmic loss and concentration polarization. At the
rst stage, current was relatively low, activation resistance caused 3.4.1. Establishment of a model of MFC
by reaction kinetics played a dominant role, which caused a rapid For a fuel cell, the real voltage output could be written by start-
voltage decrease. As current increased, polarization curve showed ing with the thermodynamically predicted voltage and then sub-
a linear relationship between voltage and current, which is called tracting the various overvoltage losses (Ryan et al., 2007):
ohmic polarization, resulted from ionic resistance and electronic
resistance. In this phase, there was also non-ohmic polarization; V Ethermo gact gohmic gconc 2
when external resistance was equal to internal resistance where V is operating voltage of fuel cell; Ethermo is thermody-
(60 10 X), power density reached the maximum of 9.52 W/m3 namically predicted voltage of fuel cell; gact, gohmic and gconc are
(264 mW/m2). With continued increase of current density, concen- voltage losses due to reaction kinetics, ohmic polarization and
tration diffusion became obvious. mass transport, respectively. Mathematically, the net fuel cell jV
behavior can be written as:
3.3. The inuence of external resistance on MFC
V Ethermo aA bA ln j aC bC ln j
3.3.1. Voltages at different external resistance jL
j S Rohmic c ln 3
The voltages at different external resistance (1000, 500, 100, 70, jL j
60 and 20 X) were recorded when MFC was controlled under sta-
ble phase for 6.05 h at each resistance (data not show). It was con-
cluded that voltage showed a consistent decreasing trend with
decrease in the external resistance. But the cell voltage is relatively 20
voltage / V
0.3 ohmic loss
Formula (3) shows the theoretical equation of fuel cell, but in
reality, it is found that one additional term is usually needed to re-
0.2 concentration loss
ect the true behavior of most fuel cell systems. This additional
term, jleak, is associated with the parasitic loss due to current leak-
age, gas crossover and unwanted side reaction. jgross is used to ex- 0.1
press gross current density produced at the fuel cell electrodes; j is
the measured current density of the fuel cell. The relationship of 0.0 -2
j=1.79A m
jgross, jleak and j can be expressed as:
0.0 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0
J gross j jleak 4 -2
current density / A m
where U is the open-circuit voltage of MFC, which can be re- a. Increase the reactant concentration. For anode, increasing the
garded as the voltage that without the loss of this system itself concentration of brewery wastewater is effective; while for
and the effect of jleak. Hence, formula (6) is the nal model that cathode, making MFC worked at a high pressure can increase
established for the MFC with brewery wastewater. the gas concentration. But in real fuel cells, kinetic reactant
concentration effects generally work against this rule for
3.4.2. Non-linear t and analysis of polarization curve several reasons, which need deep research.
According to the measurement, the open-circuit voltage U was b. Decrease the activation barrier. A catalytic electrode can sig-
0.578 V, the cross-sectional area of electrode S was 0.0036 m2. So nicantly lower the activation barrier for the reaction.
the nal model became to: Because activation barrier appears as an exponent, even
small decreases in it can cause large effects. Using a highly
V 0:578 aA bA ln j aC bC ln j
catalytic electrode therefore provides a way to quite signi-
jL cant increase of kinetic performance.
0:0036 j Rohmic c ln 7
jL j c. Increase the temperature. By increasing the reaction temper-
ature, the thermal energy available in the system is
Formula (7) was used to make a non-linear curve t of the
increased, which makes reactants obtain enough energy to
polarization curve by Origin 7.5. The nal values of parameters
reach activated state. Temperature increase is also propi-
are given by the software directly: aA, 0.1090; bA, 0.0229; aC,
tious to anaerobic organisms, which has a better electricity
0.1148; bC, 0.0232; Rohmic (X), 7.3049; c (V), 0.1271; jL (A/m2),
production environment.
2.0805.
d. Increase the number of possible reaction sites (i.e., increase the
In order to validate the creditability of the model and these
reaction interface roughness). A rough electrode has quite lar-
parameters, a test of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy
ger surface area than smooth surface; it provides more sites
(EIS) of the MFC was carried out. Result showed that the ohmic
for reaction. Therefore, a rough electrode surface will be
resistance was 7.160 X, which is close to that from the model, sug-
more effective than a smooth one.
gesting that the model established for the MFC is reasonable.
Fig. 4 shows the results of the tting and analysis of various
Besides reaction kinetics, concentration loss also is an impor-
voltage losses. The line down most is the tted curve; the one on
tant issue of the MFC. The reactant depletion (and product accu-
the top is the open-circuit voltage. The activation loss (including
mulation) affects fuel cell performance in two ways: Nerstian
anodic activation and cathodic activation), ohmic loss and concen-
losses and reaction losses. Increasing limiting current density jL
Q. Wen et al. / Bioresource Technology 100 (2009) 41714175 4175
can greatly extend a fuel cells potential operating range. jL can be Larminie, J., Dicks, A., 2000. Fuel Cell Systems Explained. John Wiley, Chichester.
Liu, H., Logan, B.E., 2004. Electricity generation using an aircathode single chamber
improved by two ways: one is increasing reactant concentration,
microbial fuel cell in the presence and absence of a proton exchange membrane.
especially the pressure of oxygen; the other is to improve the ow Environmental Science and Technology 38, 40404046.
structure of MFC, scilicet, it is possible to improve MFC congura- Liu, H., Ramnarayanan, R., Logan, B.E., 2004. Production of electricity during
tion to decrease mass transport losses. In real fuel cells, mass trans- wastewater treatment using a single chamber microbial fuel cell.
Environmental Science and Technology 38, 22812285.
port losses are minimized by employing intricate ow structures Liu, Z.D., Li, H.R., 2007. Effects of bio- and abio-factors on electricity production in a
containing many small ow channels, which mean corridor struc- mediatorless microbial fuel cell. Biochemical Engineering Journal 36, 209214.
ture, can be applied in MFC. The ow structure often provides the Lovley, D.R., Phillips, E.J.P., 1988. Novel mode of microbial energy metabolism:
organism carbon oxidation coupled to dissimilatory reduction of iron and
best opportunities for mass transport optimization, which need manganese. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 54, 14721480.
deep research. Menicucci, J., Beyenal, H., Marsili, E., Veluchamy, R.A., Demir, G., Lewandowski, Z.,
2006. Procedure for determining maximum sustainable power generated by
microbial fuel cells. Environmental Science and Technology 40, 10621068.
4. Conclusions Min, B., Angelidaki, I., 2008. Innovative microbial fuel cell for electricity production
from anaerobic reactors. Journal of Power Sources 180, 641647.
OHayre, R., Cha, S.-W., Colella, W., Prinz, F.B., 2007. Fuel Cell Fundamental. Wang,
The feasibility of MFC in bioelectricity generation from brewery
X.H., Beijing.
wastewater was demonstrated. The open-circuit voltage and the Picioreanua, C., Head, I.M., Katuri, K.P., Van Loosdrecht, M.C.M., Scott, K., 2007. A
maximum power density reached 0.578 V and 9.52 W/m3 computational model for biolm-based microbial fuel cells. Water Research 41,
(264 mW/m2). COD removal efciency was always kept at 40 29212940.
Picioreanua, C., Katuri, K.P., Head, I.M., Van Loosdrecht, M.C.M., Scott, K., 2008.
43% with a hydraulic residence time (HRT) of 2.13 h, which indi- Mathematical model for microbial fuel cells with anodic biolms and anaerobic
cated the stability of wastewater treatment in different conditions digestion. Water Science and Technology 57 (7), 965971.
of the MFC. The maximum Coulombic efciency of 19.75% was doc- Rabaey, K., Lissens, G., Siciliano, S.D., Verstraete, W., 2003. A microbial biofuel cell
capable of converting glucose to electricity at high rate and efciency. Journal of
umented at external resistance of 20 X. Moreover, using the model Biotechnology 25, 15311535.
established based on polarization curve for the MFC, it was found Rozendal, R.A., Hamelers, H.V.M., Buisman, C.J.N., 2006. Effects of membrane cation
that the most important factors which inuenced the performance transport on pH and microbial fuel cell performance. Environmental Science
and Technology 40, 52065211.
of the MFC were reaction kinetic loss and mass transport loss (both Torres, C.I., Marcus, A.K., Parameswaran, P., Rittmann, B.E., 2008. Kinetic
were 0.248 V when current density was 1.79 A/m2). There are experiments for evaluating the Nernst-monod model for anode-respiring
many effective methods to decrease these losses, for example, bacteria (ARB) in a biolm anode. Environmental Science and Technology 42
(17), 65936597.
increasing reactant concentration; employing more effective and
Venkata-Mohan, S., Mohanakrishna, G., Srikanth, S., 2008a. Harnessing of
cheaper electrode catalysts; increasing reaction temperature; bioelectricity in microbial fuel cell (MFC) employing aerated cathode through
employing rough electrode and improving the ow structure, etc. anaerobic treatment of chemical wastewater using selectively enriched
hydrogen producing mixed consortia. Fuel 87, 26672676.
Venkata-Mohan, S., Saravanan, R., Veer-Raghuvulu, S., Mohanakrishna, G., Sarma,
Acknowledgements P.N., 2008b. Bioelectricity production from wastewater treatment in dual
chambered microbial fuel cell (MFC) using selectively enriched mixed
The authors would like to thank Group of Heilongjiang Science microora: effect of catholyte. Bioresource Technology 99, 596603.
Wang, X., Feng, Y.J., Lee, H., 2008. Electricity production from beer brewery
and Technology, Heilongjiang, China for funding the research and wastewater using single chamber microbial fuel cell. Water Science and
Harbin Beer Brewery, Harbin, China for providing the sludge. Technology 57, 11171121.
Wei, F.S., 2002. Water and Wastewater Monitoring Analysis Method, fourth ed.
Publishing House of Environmental Science of China, Beijing.
References Yoshitake, M., Tamura, M., Yoshida, N., 1996. Studies of peruorinated ion exchange
membrane for polymer electrolyte fuel cells. Denki Kagaku 64, 727.
Feng, Y.J., Wang, X., Logan, B.E., Lee, H., 2008. Brewery wastewater treatment using You, S.J., Zhao, Q.L., Jiang, J.Q., 2006. Treatment of domestic wastewater with
air-cathode microbial fuel cells. Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 78, simultaneous electricity generation in microbial fuel cell under continuous
873880. operation. Chemical and Biochemical Engineering Quarterly 20, 407412.
Freguia, S., Rabaey, K., Yuan, Z., Keller, J., 2007. Non-catalyzed cathodic oxygen You, S.J., Zhao, Q.L., Zhang, J.N., Liu, H., Jiang, J.Q., Zhao, S.Q., 2008. Increased
reduction at graphite granules in microbial fuel cells. Electrochimica Acta 53, sustainable electricity generation in up-ow air-cathode microbial fuel cells.
598603. Biosensors and Bioelectronics 23, 11571160.
Huang, L.P., Logan, B.E., 2008. Electricity generation and treatment of paper Zhan, Y.L., Zhang, P.P., Yan, G.X., Guo, S.H., 2008. Constructing and operating of
recycling wastewater using a microbial fuel cell. Applied Microbiology and mediator- and membrane-less microbial fuel cell. Journal of Chemical
Biotechnology 80, 349355. Engineering of Chinese Universities 22, 177181.
Kargi, F., Eker, S., 2007. Electricity generation with simultaneous wastewater
treatment by a microbial fuel cell (MFC) with Cu and CuAu electrodes. Journal
of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology 82, 658662.