Anda di halaman 1dari 10

Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Food Packaging and Shelf Life


journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/fpsl

Nanoscale, zero valent iron particles for application as oxygen


scavenger in food packaging
Zenon Foltynowicza,* ,1, Alexander Bardenshteinb,1, Sven Sngerlaubc,d,1,
Helle Antvorskovb,1, Wojciech Kozaka,1
a
Faculty of Commodity Science, Poznan University of Economics & Business, al. Niepodleglosci 10, 61-875 Poznan, Poland
b
Danish Technological Institute, Materials, Packaging and Logistics, Gregersensvej 5, 2630 Taastrup, Denmark
c
Fraunhofer Institute for Process Engineering and Packaging IVV, Giggenhauser Strae 35, 85354 Freising, Germany
d
Chair of Food Packaging Technology, Technische Universitt Mnchen, Weihenstephaner Steig 22, 85354 Freising, Germany

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Article history:
Received 17 May 2016 Oxygen scavengers which are based on oxidation of iron powder dispersed in a polymer matrix are
Received in revised form 2 January 2017 established in the packaging industry. They protect foods from oxygen. The iron particles have a diameter
Accepted 16 January 2017 of several micrometers, which is too high to allow thin layers in multilayer lm structures. A promising
Available online xxx alternative is a developed nanoscale oxygen scavenger which is subject of this study. The aim of this study
was to evaluate the oxygen absorption rate and the oxygen absorption capacity of nanoscale iron at 100%
Keywords: relative humidity and at dry conditions.
Nanoparticle Nanoscale oxygen scavengers (zero valent iron particles) were synthesized. Their reactivity was tested.
Oxidation
Furthermore, they were blended with a silicone matrix. The nanoscale oxygen scavenger absorbed
Coreshell nanoparticle
oxygen in wet (100% relative humidity) and dry conditions. At 100% relative humidity the reaction rate of
Active packaging
the powder was two to three times higher compared to non-nanoscale iron powder. The absorption rate
of the nanoscale iron dispersed in a silicon carrier was at least ten times higher at 100% relative humidity
compared to a commercially available iron based oxygen scavenger in a polyethylene or polypropylene
polymer matrix.
2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction headspace, it can permeate from the environment into the


packaging or it is gotten into packagings as solved oxygen in food
Oxygen causes quality loss at many food products such as cured (Chaix, Guillaume, & Guillard, 2014; Hintze, Becker, & Heiss, 1965).
boiled sausage, salami, milk, peanuts, beer, edible oils and wine A strategy to reduce the oxygen permeability of plastic packagings
(Bhner, Hsl, Rieblinger, & Danzl, 2014; Giovanelli, & Brenna, and to absorb oxygen from packaged food and from packaging
2007; Jensen & Risbo, 2007; Kozak & Samotyja, 2013; Lisin  ska- headspace is the application of oxygen scavengers. Oxygen
Kusnierz, 2001; Kuchel, Brody, & Wicker, 2006; Roman, Heyd, scavengers (Brody, Strupinsky, & Pruskin, 1995) remove oxygen
Broyart, Castillo, & Maillard, 2013; Rizzo, Torri, Licciardello, from the inner package environment and thus, in turn, from the
Piergiovanni, & Muratore, 2013; Sngerlaub et al., 2012; Saffert, food product itself through partial pressure actions.
Pieper, & Jetten, 2008; Saffert, Pieper, & Jetten, 2006; Zardin et al., Many studies showed the effectiveness of oxygen scavengers for
2016). Deterioration processes involved are autoxidation, light different foods such as salami, milk powder, milk, juice, tortilla,
induced oxidation and aerobic microbial growth (Buchner, 1999). olive oil, wine, almonds, beer, catsh and probiotic yoghurts
To reduce the access of oxygen, foods are packaged with barrier (Antunez, Omary, Rosentrater, Pascall, & Winstone, 2012; Cecchi,
materials and the headspace of packagings is ushed with nitrogen Passamonti, & Cecchi, 2010; Giovanelli & Brenna, 2007; Gibis &
or nitrogen/carbon dioxide mixtures (Buchner, 1999; Lange & Rieblinger, 2011; Mannon, 2007; Mueller, 2003; Mohan, Ravish-
Wyser, 2003). However, residual oxygen can remain in the ankar, & Srinivasagopal, 2008; Miller, Nguyen, Rooney, & Kailasa-
pathy, 2003; Perkins, Zerdin, Rooney, DArcy, & Deeth, 2007; Mexis
& Kontominas, 2010; Realini & Marcos, 2014; Sngerlaub et al.,
2012; Zerdin, Rooney, & Vermu, 2003)
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: zenon.foltynowicz@ue.poznan.pl (Z. Foltynowicz). A multitude of oxygen scavengers were developed and tested.
1
These authors contributed equally to this work. They are subsumed into organic (e.g. polymers with double

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fpsl.2017.01.003
2214-2894/ 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483 75

bounds) and inorganic (e.g. metal powders) systems. Organic powder is already active in conditions of dehydrated and dry foods.
systems include Nylon MXD6 (a mainly aliphatic polyamide resin Crane assumed a passivating layer thickness of 3 nm (Crane, &
which contains meta-xylylene groups) blended with Poly(ethylene Scott, 2012). In this case a sphere is fully oxidised when the
terephthalate) (PET), ethylene methylacrylate cyclohexenylmethyl, diameter is 6 nm or less. At 20 nm diameter around 65 vol-% of the
cyclo-olen bonded chemically to a silicate backbone, low-density sphere is oxidised. The passivating layer consists of iron oxides or
polyethylene lled with oxygen scavengers made of powdered oxyhydroxides (Liu & Zhang, 2014). Also in humid conditions and
activated carbon impregnated with sodium erythorbate, polybu- in contact with electrolytes the reaction rate of nanoscale iron
tadiene, gallic acid and others (Amberg-Schwab, Weber, Burger, would be much faster than at iron powders with a diameter of
Nique, & Xalter, 2006; Dombre, Guillard, & Chalier, 2015; Goldhan several micrometres.
et al., 2007; Joven, Garcia, Arias, & Medina, 2014; Li, Tung, Paul, & Nanoscale iron powder is available as zero valent iron (ZV). In
Freeman, 2011; Mller, Sngerlaub, Kramer, Huber, & Fritsch, 2011; recent years it gained prominence in research because it catalyses
Mller, Welle, Rieblinger, & Sngerlaub, 2010 Piton & Rivaton, and/or oxidises the decomposition of contaminants such as
1996; Singh, Sngerlaub, Wani, & Langowski, 2012; Singh, Wani, & antibiotics, biocides, hexachlorobenzene, azo dyes and it can be
Sngerlaub, 2011; Schneider, Orzinski, Embs, Fritsch, & Weber, therefore applied for water treatments and decontamination (Crane
2006; Solis & Rodgers, 2001). Their oxidation is often catalysed, e.g. & Scott, 2012; Fang et al., 2011; Homem & Santos, 2011; Moon, Park, &
by cobalt compounds. Inorganic systems include polymers blended Park, 2011; Shih, Hsu, & Su, 2011; Zha et al., 2014; Xu & Wang, 2011).
with iron powder, different iron compounds and sodium sulphite Additionally it inactivates microbes (Diao & Yao, 2009). Several
(Cruz, Camilloto, & Pires, 2012; Foltynowicz, Kozak, & Fiedorow, groups measured the diameters of zero valent iron particles. The
2002; Gibis & Rieblinger, 2011; Galotto, Anfossi, & Guarda, 2009; smallest diameters were between 3 nm and 5 nm (Machado, Grosso,
Mller et al., 2010; Mller, 2013; Rooney, 1995; Singh et al., 2012, Nouws, Albergaria, & Delerue-Matos, 2014; Oropeza, Corea, Gmez-
2011). Oxygen scavengers differ in their absorption kinetics, Yez, Cruz-Rivera, & Navarro-Clemente, 2012).
absorption capacity, time-temperature behavior, reactivity at For food packaging related applications Mu and Busolo did
different relative humidities and costs. experiments with nanoscale iron. Mu prepared nanoscale iron
One of the most important systems for packaging materials is from borohydride resulting in 110 nm particle size (Busolo &
the group of oxygen scavengers that contain iron powder (Chiang Lagaron, 2012; Mu et al., 2013). The nanoscale iron and iron with a
et al., 1997; Gibis & Rieblinger, 2011; Lehner, Schlemmer, & particle size of around 20 mm was mixed with activated carbon,
Sngerlaub, 2015; Mller et al., 2010; Singh et al., 2012; Singh et al., NaCl and calcium chloride in a weight ratio of 1:1:1:0.2. At 75%
2011; Sngerlaub et al., 2012). They are a mixture of a carrier relative humidity and 25  C nanoscale iron absorbed oxygen circa 9
polymer, iron powder with a particle diameter in the range of 10 to times faster than conventional iron. The compound absorbed circa
30 micrometres and a catalyst such as sodium chloride (NaCl) 220 cm3 oxygen per one gram of iron, which is circa 280 mg per one
(Chiang et al., 1997; Klein & Knorr, 1990; Lpez-Cervantes, gram of iron (density of oxygen at 25  C, 1013 mbar: 1.3093 mg
Snchez-Machado, Pastorelli, Rijk, & Paseiro-Losada., 2003; cm3). The oxygen absorption capacity was lower than the
Sngerlaub et al., 2012; Galotto et al., 2009). In dry conditions stoichiometric capacity of 430 mg oxygen per one gram iron.
metallic iron is inert even though it is a non-nobel metal. The Busolo used an iron containing kaolinite (Busolo & Lagaron, 2012).
reason for this property is that metallic iron forms on its surface a The average iron particle diameter was 115 nm. The iron containing
passivating layer in the thickness of several nanometres (Ohtsuka, kaolinite and a HDPE-powder compound with the iron containing
2012; McCafferty, 2010). At high relative humidity or in contact kaolinite were analysed. At 100% relative humidity the reaction
with liquid water the passivating layer reacts with water and rate was higher than at 50% relative humidity. Interestingly, zero
becomes porous, which makes this layer permeable for water valent iron modied bentonite and kaolinite are approved by the
vapour and oxygen. Therefore, metallic iron below this porous European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) as non-nanoform species
layer is accessible for water vapour and oxygen and can react then (EFSA 2013a, 2013b).
with both. The oxidation is catalysed be electrolytes, e.g. NaCl.
Galotto and Saengerlaub reported that oxygen scavengers with 1.1. Intention of the present study
iron powder start to react with oxygen at a relative humidity of 75%
or higher (Galotto et al., 2009; Sngerlaub et al., 2012). Results from For this study an oxygen scavenger based on nanoscale iron
Schindelholz indicate that reaction starts already at a lower (nano iron) was synthesised. The intention of this study was to
relative humidity (Schindelholz, Risteen, & Kelly, 2014). He showed measure and to evaluate its oxygen absorption rate and its oxygen
that steel in direct contact with NaCl had a low but detectable absorption capacity.
corrosion rate at 33% relative humidity. The corrosion rate
increased at higher relative humidity (>53%) by factor 300 to 2. Materials and methods
2500. In polymers with dispersed iron powder and NaCl the
property of non-nanoscale NaCl is used to absorb water vapour 2.1. Experimental plan
above 75% relative humidity (deliquescence point) and to solve in
the absorbed water (Ewing, 2005). The salt solution can then wet Table 1 shows the samples of this study. Samples were analysed
the surface of the metallic iron particles and catalyse the oxidation in measuring cells with dened headspace. The weight of iron
of iron by oxygen there. This behaviour explains the higher reaction powder was similar or in the same range at all samples as well as
rate of iron powder when the relative humidity is higher than 75% the headspace-sample ratio. Nanoscale iron was analysed in cells
(Galotto et al., 2009; Klein & Knorr, 1990; Sngerlaub et al., 2012). with and without a petri dish of water with the aim to evaluate the
An important property of oxygen scavengers is their reaction inuence of relative humidity on the reaction rate. Iron powder
rate. A strategy to increase the reaction rate is the reduction of was mixed with NaCl because this electrolyte catalyses the
particle diameters. The area of spheres increases by factor 10 when oxidation and because it is applied at oxygen scavengers with
the particle diameter decreases be factor 10. For example iron iron powder. The concentration of NaCl was varied to 1 and 10% w/
powder with a particle diameter of 10 nm instead of 10 mm will w to study the inuence of its concentration on the reaction rate.
have a 1000 times bigger surface area. Due to the fact that the For comparison oxygen scavenger lms containing the commer-
passivating layer of metallic iron is several micrometres thick and cially available oxygen scavenger SHELFPLUS1 O2 were provided by
forms in dry conditions or at very low relative humidity such iron Fraunhofer IVV. The system SHELFPLUS1 O2 is an oxygen scavenger
76 Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483

Table 1
Experimental plan of samples for testing oxygen absorption kinetics and oxygen absorption capacity, all experiments were done at 23  C; initial oxygen concentration: 20.95
vol.-%.

Sample Relative Headspace Weight of iron powder or polymer with


humidity volume dispersed iron per cell
(%) (cm3) (g)
Nanoscale iron powder dry 124 0.78  0.09
Nanoscale iron powder 100 117 0.78  0.09
Iron powder + 1% w/w NaCl 100 117 0.75  0.01
Iron powder + 10% w/w NaCl 100 117 0.76  0.01
Nanoscale iron powder in silicon matrix dry 60 1.55  0.45
Nanoscale iron powder in silicon matrix 100 60 1.55  0.45
Oxygen scavenger lm with iron powder; 100% SHELFPLUS1 O2 2400 (Ciba Specialty Chemicals 100 96 1
Inc., Basel, Switzerland); 120 mm, in PE matrix,
100% RH, 23  C
Oxygen scavenger lm with iron powder; 100 220 5
20% w/w SHELFPLUS1 O2 2710 in PP lm; thickness: 70 mm;
100%, 23  C

with iron particles that is blended with polymer and extruded to and nanoscale iron were chosen after pre-trials. The aim was to
separate layers in multilayer lm structures. The technology and the cover maximum amount of nanoscale iron powder with a
intellectual property rights for the oxygen scavenger SHELFPLUS1 O2 minimum amount of silicone.
were formerly owned by BPAmoco and Ciba Specialty Chemicals and Then, the components were thoroughly mixed using a
are now owned by Albis Plastic GmbH (Hamburg, Germany) mechanical stirrer until a homogeneous mixture and afterwards
(Anonymous, 2001; Anonymous, 2009). 0.45 g of the Gumosil AD-1S B component (crosslinking catalyst)
(Sip Silikony, Poland) was added. The whole set-up was intensively
2.2. Iron powder and salt mixed another time to achieve a uniform catalyst distribution.
Stirring was carried out at room temperature.
The analysed iron powder was acquired from Riedel-de-Haen, The synthesized dense mass of rubber-like consistence was
Seelze, Germany. It has a particle size up to 212 mm. NaCl was from formed into the form of discs of various dimensions and
the European salt company GmbH & Co. KG, Hannover, Germany. It thicknesses, which were left for 2030 min for complete polymer-
was milled with a mortar prior of the experiments. ization. The crosslinking of rubbers was accelerated by heating up
to 50  C. All activities were performed in argon atmosphere in
2.3. Synthesis of nanoscale iron order to prevent reaction with oxygen during preparation.

Nanoscale iron was synthesised from iron chloride and sodium


borohydrate dissolved in water according to a method described by 2.5. Analysis of oxygen absorption capacity referring to DIN 6139-1
Foltynowicz et al. (2012). Eq. (1) shows the reaction.
The oxygen absorption capacity/scavenging capacity of the
FeCl3 + 3 NaBH4 + 9H2O ! Fe # + 3H3BO3 + 3 NaCl + 10.5H2" (1) samples was measured according to the method described in DIN
In the bulb with a volume of 3 dm3, 1 dm3 of 0.05 M solution of 6139-1 (Anonymous, 2011). The method was outlined prior by
hydrated iron (III) chloride has been poured. The set-up has been Rieblinger et al. (1996). For the analyses measuring cells with a
rinsed with argon during instilling of 1 dm3 of 0.15 M water dened volume were taken. The samples were exposed to air, i.e.
solution of sodium tetrahydridoborate has been initiated with a an initial oxygen concentration of 20.95 vol.-% oxygen. 100%
speed of 11 cm3/min. During instilling the black, occulent deposit, relative humidity was adjusted by adding a petri dish with water.
owing on the surface of orange solution was observed, as well as The storage temperature was 23  C. The headspace value was
an intense release of hydrogen. With increasing amount of instilled estimated from the density of the samples and the internal volume
NaBH4 the solution changed its colour from orange to black and the of the measuring cells. The oxygen partial pressure was measured
amount of precipitated iron deposit increased. After complete with an oxygen sensor spot from PreSens1 Precision Sensing
instilling of sodium tetrahydridoborate solution the whole set-up GmbH (Regensburg, Germany). The measurement principle is
was heated until the solution reached the temperature of 75  C. based on dynamic luminescence quenching by molecular oxygen
With the temperature rise a progressive colour change of the (Huber, Nguyen, Krause, Humele, & Stangelmayer, 2006; Klimant,
solution was observed, from black, through greyish, to a complete Ruckruh, Liebsch, Stangelmayer, & Wolfbeis, 1999; Lundquist,
colour vanishing. In the nal stage of heating the occulent Pelletier, & Wyser, 2004). The spots were measured regularly with
reaction product has dropped onto the bottom in form of a black a Fibox 4 trace by PreSens1 Precision Sensing GmbH (Regensburg,
deposit. After cooling, the deposit has been ltered on a Schlenk Germany) to follow absorption kinetics. OxySense 4000B Oxygen
set, for the whole time in argon atmosphere, and the deposit has Analyzer (OxySense, USA) was used as second measuring device to
been washed with deoxidized acetone. The synthesized nanoscale measure oxygen concentration and to log the data.
iron powder has been stored in a Schlenk ask in a protective argon After the oxygen partial pressure in the cell reached equilibri-
atmosphere. 3.5 g of product was synthesized, with an efciency of um, the absorption capacity was calculated by applying the gas
75% w/w of the theoretical value. equations for the calculation. Furthermore, empty cells were
measured as blank test to ensure that the reduction of the oxygen
2.4. Incorporation of nanoscale iron powder in silicon matrix partial pressure was only originating from the analysed lms. The
experiments were conducted as duplicates and triplicates. The
4.5 g of food grade silicone moulding rubber type GUMO- shown error bars are standard deviations at the triplicates or the
SIL1AD-1S (Sip Silikony, Poland), approved for food contact, was difference between the maximum and mean value at the
added to 3.45 g of nanoscale iron powder. The amount of silicone duplicates.
Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483 77

The nanoscale iron was embedded in a silicone matrix, which 2.8. Elemental analysis
had the task to reduce the access of oxygen during handling.
Directly before testing, the samples were cut in the middle in two Elemental analysis was performed using the EDS type detector
parts of equal size to increase access of oxygen during the Ultra Dry Silicon Drift X-ray Detector (SDD, Thermo Fisher
experiments. The sample is shown in Fig. 1. Scientic, USA).

2.9. X-ray diffraction method


2.6. Analysis of oxygen absorption rate referring to DIN 6139-2
(Anonymous, 2011)
The type of iron obtained were determined by powder X-ray
diffraction method (radiation Co Kalpha) in range of angle 2
Following simplied rst-order exponential decay equation
theta = 150 (Philips PW 1050 diffractometer).
(Atkins & de Paula, 2006) describes the reaction kinetics for a short
time interval when the number of oxygen molecules reacting with
2.10. Water content and equilibrium relative humidity of the samples
nanoscale iron is simply proportional to a number of oxygen
of nanoscale iron powder in silicon matrix
molecules available in the headspace (Eq. (2)).
k0 mt
pt p0  ekt p0  e V 2 The relative humidity in the cells with silicon was measured
with a humidity measurement device (Testo AG, Lenzkirch,
Here, p0 and pt are the initial partial pressure of oxygen and the Germany). The sensor was placed into the cell and the cell was
partial pressure at a time point t. The normalized reaction constant sealed by a laboratory cling lm. The water content of the samples
k was calculated according to Eq. (2) from the reaction constant k, was measured gravimetrically with a laboratory balance (Mettler
the weight of the oxygen scavenger m and the headspace volume V. Toledo, Gieen, Germany). The samples were cut into small pieces,
The introduction of the normalized reaction constant k allows the placed in petri dishes and the set-up was stored in a desiccator
simplied comparison of the reaction kinetics of different oxygen with silica, which adjusted a relative humidity of circa zero
scavengers which are analysed at different headspace volumes in percent. The weight of the petri dish with the sample was
measuring setups and at different weights of oxygen scavengers. measured regularly until weight constancy. The weight difference
However, Eq. (2) is only valid for a rst-order unimolecular was equivalent to the water content of the sample.
reaction (Atkins & de Paula, 2006) and its rigours validity for
analysis of kinetics of an iron oxidation reaction is questionable. 3. Results and discussions

2.7. Microscopic analysis 3.1. Microscopic picture/chemical structure of nanoscale iron

Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) studies were carried out Peaks visible in Fig. 2 at angle 2 theta 52.5;77.3;99.7;124 come
using an apparatus SU3500 (Hitachi, Japan) equipped with from alpha iron phase, which conrms that synthesized nanoscale
detectors SE and BSE under given magnication. iron is in form of alpha iron. There are several allotropic forms of
pure iron: alfa, beta, gamma, epsilon. Each has a different crystal

Fig. 1. Nanoscale iron based oxygen scavenger embedded in silicon matrix.


78 Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483

Fig. 2. X-ray difractogram of synthesized nanoscale iron powder (radiation Co


Kalpha) in range of angle 2 theta = 150 .

Fig. 4. Oxygen partial pressure in measuring cells; 1: dry nanoscale iron powder; 2:
structure. a-iron, also known as ferrite, is the most stable form of nanoscale iron powder at 100% relative humidity.
iron at normal temperatures which has a body-centred cubic (bcc)
crystal structure. The number of atoms exposed on the crystal
surface determines the metal reactivity, for example with oxygen.
g-iron is able to bind six atoms of oxygen more than a-iron,
however it exists >1000  C. The X-ray difractogram furthermore
showed that there were no impurities in the sample, such as iron
oxides or iron hydroxides.
Fig. 3a presents SEM of pure nanoscale iron at a magnication of
2000. Regular grains of cluster-like structure of the size of less than
200 nm can be observed without any agglomerates. Under the
higher magnication, i.e. 300 k (Fig. 3b) it can be seen that this
agglomerates consist of nanoscale sized particles of less than
10 nm size with a very regular distribution, conrmed by
secondary electron image (SEI) analysis (SEI were taken on the
same region) of iron atom distribution presented on Fig. 3c.

3.2. Comparison of oxygen absorption of iron powder and nanoscale


Fig. 5. Oxygen partial pressure in measuring cells; 100% relative humidity, 23  C; 1:
iron nanoscale iron powder; 2: non-nanoscale iron powder mixed 1% w/w NaCl; 3: non-
nanoscale iron powder mixed 10% w/w NaCl.
The dry nanoscale iron powder did absorb oxygen (Fig. 4).
When the powder was exposed to 100% relative humidity the than expected. The possible reason for the lower than expected
reaction rate increased intensively. This result indicates that iron reaction rate of nanoscale iron lies in the NaCl inside the
oxidizes in dry conditions at a smaller rate than at wet conditions. compound. NaCl absorbs high amounts of water vapour (Cantrell,
At a high relative humidity iron forms iron hydrates that are porous McCrory, & Ewing, 2002; Sngerlaub & Stramm, 2012). The forming
and that allow access of oxygen to inner parts of iron particles. NaCl solution covered and embedded the iron particles and
Additionally, the fast reaction in 100% relative humidity was reduced the access of oxygen to the reaction sites of iron. Fig. 6
caused by the catalysis by residual NaCl in the compound, which is shows the samples of iron with 1% w/w NaCl and of nanoscale iron.
formed during the synthesis of nanoscale iron (Eq. (1)). Elemental Both samples were immersed by salt solution that formed during
analysis showed the presence of about 0.8 to 1.0% w/w NaCl in the water vapour absorption. Furthermore, the oxygen solubility in the
nanoscale iron. NaCl solution has an inuence on the reaction rate (Polyakov &
The reaction rate of nanoscale iron was 2- to 3-times higher at Miltz, 2016). By increasing salt concentration, there is a decrease in
100% relative humidity than the reaction rate of non-nanoscale the oxygen solubility in the salt solution (Geng & Duan, 2010) and
iron with 1% w/w NaCl (Fig. 5). The reaction rate was much lower thus less access of oxygen to the iron particle surface. This

Fig. 3. (a) SaEM picture of pure nanoscale iron under 2000 fold magnication. (b) SbEM picture of pure nanoscale iron under 300 000-fold magnication. (c) ScEI image of
nanoscale iron distribution in the same region of the sample as at Fig. 3b.
Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483 79

Fig. 6. Iron powder samples after 50 days, stored at 100% relative humidity, 23  C; left: non-nanoscale iron powder with 1% w/w NaCl; right: nanoscale iron powder of this
study.

hypothesis is backed by the results of experiments with 10% w/w


NaCl (Fig. 5). At 10% w/w NaCl iron powder reacted much slower
than the iron powder with 1% w/w NaCl.

3.3. Water content of a compound of nanoscale iron powder dispersed


in a silicon matrix

Table 2 shows the equilibrium humidity of the samples and


their water content. They contained water and the equilibrium
humidity was up to 100%. Therefore the samples were dried two
days in silica gel in a nitrogen atmosphere before the oxygen
absorption was tested.

3.4. Oxygen absorption of a compound of nanoscale iron powder in a


silicon matrix

The dry samples of nanoscale iron absorbed oxygen (Fig. 7).


After adding two grams of water the oxygen absorption rate of the
sample increased.
Fig. 7. Oxygen partial pressure in measuring cells; samples: nanoscale iron powder
For the sample of nanoscale iron powder in silicon matrix and in silicon matrix; 1: dried sample; 2: sample after adding two gram of water.
for two lms made of commercially available oxygen scavenger the
reaction rate constants were determined (Figs. 7 and 8). In the
observed interval the reaction could be described by a rst order
reaction.
From the reaction constants, the weight of the samples and the
headspace volume the normalized reaction constants were
calculated (Table 3,Fig. 8). The nanoscale iron in silicon matrix
absorbed more than ten-times faster oxygen than the other both
systems. The amount of oxygen absorbed in the intervals was in the
same magnitude of order, i.e. the sampling was comparable.

3.5. Oxygen absorption capacitycomparison with other systems

The nanoscale iron powder synthesized for this study absorbed


at least 68 mg of oxygen per one gram iron. The stoichiometric
capacity of iron powder of iron powder is 430 mg of oxygen per one
gram iron. This capacity was not measured for the nanoscale iron in Fig. 8. Oxygen partial pressure in measuring cells; 1: oxygen scavenger lm with
our analysis. Possible reasons are that the trials were stopped iron powder; 100% SHELFPLUS1 O2 2400, thickness: 120 mm, in PE matrix; 2:
before the nal capacity was reached and reaction with oxygen oxygen scavenger lm with iron powder; 20% w/w SHELFPLUS1 O2 2710 in PP lm,
thickness: 70 mm; 100%, 23  C.
during preparation. Nonetheless, the results show that nanoscale

Table 2
Water content and water activity/equilibrium humidity of the samples.

Sample Water content Water activity


gwater gcompound1 % equilibrium humidity
Nanoscale iron compound embedded in silicon >0.013 98100
Nanoscale iron compound >0.026 98100
80 Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483

Table 3
Parameters for the calculation of normalized reaction constants.

Sample Weight Headspace Reactions Normalized reaction Oxygen absorption in interval/mg


(g) (cm3) constant constant O2 
(day1) cm3(g day)1 (g Absorber)1
Nanoscale iron in silicon matrix; 1.55 60 34.3 1300 10.6
100% RH, 23  C
Oxygen scavenger lm with iron powder; 1 96 1.37 130 12.5
100% SHELFPLUS1 O2 2400 (Ciba Specialty Chemicals Inc., Basel,
Switzerland)
120 mm, in PE matrix,
100% RH, 23  C
Oxygen scavenger lm with iron powder; 5 220 0.17 7 8.3
20% w/w SHELFPLUS1 O2 2710 in PP lm; thickness: 70 mm;

100%, 23 C

Table 4
Oxygen absorption capacities of different oxygen scavengers.

Oxygen scavenger Oxygen absorption capacity per weight/mg g1 Reference


Nanoscale iron powder >68  11 This study
Iron powder >117  4 This study
Nanoscale iron powder 280 Mu et al., 2013
Iron powder >370 Wanner, 2010
Stoichiometric capacity of iron powder (humid conditions) 430
Stoichiometric capacity of iron powder (dry conditions, eq. 3) 400
Nanoscale iron in silicon matrix >32  8 This study
Polymer with iron powder and additives (SHELFPLUS); masterbatch 2648 Lehner et al., 2015
Cyclo-olen bonded to a silicate backbone ORMOCER1; lacquer 90 Amberg-Schwab et al., 2006
O2Block1 (NanoBioMatters S.L., Paterna, Spain); masterbatch >1025 Lagaron and Busolo (2012)

iron powder of this study qualies as oxygen scavenger. The Theoretically, the above described two-step consecutive rate
absorption capacity was in the range of oxygen absorption capacity process should on the assumption of steady-state oxidation of
of other oxygen scavengers reported by other research groups nanoscale iron (i.e. when the amount of oxygen permeated in the
(Table 4). matrix is approximately equal to the amount of oxygen used up for
oxidation) be accounted as a double-exponential decay function
3.6. Elaboration of oxygen absorption kinetics for embedded nanoscale (Atkins & de Paula, 2006).
iron In order to prove, illustrate and quantify these statements, let us
analyse the relative oxygen concertation data shown in Fig. 9. The
As it has been discussed above, the present work aims in data were obtained from an experimental layout where nanoscale
generation of background for industrial application of oxygen iron powder was embedded in a casted silicon and the oxygen
scavenger systems based on nanoscale iron embedded in oxygen- concertation measurements were carried out in a hermetically
permeable matrices (e.g. packaging polymer plastic lms). This closed glass bottle where a piece of silicon with nanoscale iron was
application calls for a more detailed study of oxygen absorption placed. The initial oxygen concentration in the bottle was
kinetics in such systems. Indeed, Eq. (2) enables a very simplied approximately [O2]0  4.6%.
description of the oxygen absorption kinetics as a rst-order
unimolecular decay of oxygen during the time (Atkins & de Paula,
2006). This description is convenient for implementation of DIN
6139-2 standard measurements of oxygen absorption since it
enables straightforward comparison of scavenging performance of
different systems. However, the performance of systems where a
scavenging material (e.g. powder of nanoscale iron) is embedded in
a permeable matrix can only be optimized on the basis of a detailed
study. This must account the complexity of a two-step consecutive
rate process that comprises, rstly, oxygen permeation into a
matrix, and, secondly, its subsequent xation by nanoscale iron in
accordance with a generalized direct iron oxidation reaction:
5Fe + (7/2)O2 ! Fe2O3 + Fe3O4. (3)

As a matter of fact, this reaction is not at all unimolecular by


chemical nature. Hence, its kinetics cannot at all be rigorously
described by a rst-order decay of Eq. (2). Second, the rate of this
reaction depends on the rate of permeation of oxygen in the matrix
(for instance, in a silicon casting or in a packaging lm), and vice
versa the oxygen permeation rate depends on the rate of oxygen
xation since it maintains the driving force of oxygen diffusion into Fig. 9. Oxygen concentration history obtained from a layout with nanoscale iron
the matrix. powder embedded in a silicon matrix placed in a hermetically closed glass bottle.
Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483 81

The relative oxygen concentration [O2]/[O2]0 was then derived In following studies the nanoscale iron should be integrated in
and plotted versus time as shown in Fig. 9. Two data-tting polyethylene and polypropylene matrices which are commonly
procedures were then applied. used plastics in the packaging industry. The barrier improvement
Firstly, the rst-order exponential decay curve tting (dashed- by the active absorption of oxygen should be tested. Additionally,
dotted curve in the plot in Fig. 9) was used. This resulted in the the reaction rate at low relative humidity depending in the particle
Eq. (4) and the squared Pearsons correlation coefcient size should be determined.
R2 = 0.99804.
Acknowledgements
O2  1
ekt ; where the reaction rate k 0:1676  0:0025h : 4
O2 0
Authors would like to acknowledge the Danish Ministry of
It can be concluded that the results of the rst-order decay Higher Education and Science, the Agency for Science, Technology
approximation are reasonably good and it can be used for standard and Innovation for providing nancial support for this research in
calculations of the oxygen absorption rate. At the same time, it can the frame of the Performance Contract X4 Production in
be clearly seen that this approximation falls short of correct Denmark in 2014 and 2015. We also appreciate the support of
description of the scavenging kinetics at the beginning of the the Fraunhofer IVV for providing resources from which parts of the
process and after approximately 12 h from its initiation. This analysis were nanced. Furthermore we thank Veronika Florian for
obviously happens because at these stages the reaction rate is doing absorption experiments and the anonymous reviewers for
especially sensitive to the permeation of oxygen into silicon their valuable suggestions
matrix, and the process is far from quasi- stationarity.
Then, the second-order exponential decay curve tting (solid References
curve in the plot in Fig. 9) was applied. This resulted in the Eq. (5)
where the rates k1 = 0.5835  0.0214 h1and k2 = 0.1135  0.0023 h1 Amberg-Schwab, S., Weber, U., Burger, A., Nique, S., & Xalter, R. (2006). Development
of passive and active barrier coatings on the basis of inorganicorganic
and the squared Pearsons correlation coefcient R2 = 0.99995. polymers. Monatshefte fur Chemie/Chemical Monthly, 137(5), 657666.
Anonymous (2001). Ciba specialty chemicals buys inorganic oxygen absorbers from
O2 
0:2ek1 t 0:8ek2 t : 5 BP Amoco. Additives for Polymers, 2001(6), 45.
O2 0 Anonymous (2009). Albis Plastic invests in Ciba oxygen scavengers. Additives for
Polymers, 2009(5), 9.
This reveals a perfect, nearly deviation-less tting of the Anonymous (2011). DIN 6139-1 PackagingOxygen scavengers for packaging
experimental data and enables the conclusion that oxygen applicationsPart 1: 608 determination of capacity. Berlin: Beuth Verlag GmbH
[2011].
scavenging by nanoscale iron embedded in a permeable matrix Antunez, P. D., Omary, M. B., Rosentrater, K. A., Pascall, M., & Winstone, L. (2012).
is a double-exponential decay consecutive rate process. The rst Effect of an oxygen scavenger on the stability of preservative-fFree our
exponential decay has a higher rate that can be attributed to the tortillas. Journal of Food Science, 77(1), S1S9.
Atkins, P., & de Paula, J. (2006). Physical chemistry, 8th ed. NY: W. H. Freeman and
oxidation reaction, and the second exponential decay term with Company809818.
the ve times lower rate characterises oxygen permeation in the Axelson-Larsson, L. (1992). Oxygen permeability at high temperatures and relative
silicon matrix. humidities. Packaging Technology and Science, 5(6), 297306.
Bhner, N., Hsl, F., Rieblinger, K., & Danzl, W. (2014). Effect of retail display
Finally, the detailed accounting of the scavenging kinetics by
illumination and headspace oxygen concentration on cured boiled sausages.
embedded nanoscale iron can open up possibilities for implemen- Food Packaging and Shelf Life, 1(2), 131139.
tation of active control of the scavenging rate by the aid of Brody, A. L., Strupinsky, G. R., & Pruskin, L. R. (1995). The use of oxygen scavengers
and active packaging to reduce oxygen within internal package envmonments.
packaging barrier lms with variable oxygen permeabilities.
Technical report. . NATICK/TR-95/033. dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?
AD=ADA299164.
Buchner, N. S. (1999). Verpackung von Lebensmitteln: Lebensmitteltechnologische,
4. Conclusions verpackungstechnische und mikrobiologische Grundlagen. Berlin-Heidelberg:
Springer.
Busolo, M. A., & Lagaron, J. M. (2012). Oxygen scavenging polyolen nanocomposite
The present study shows that nanoscale iron can be an active lms containing an iron modied kaolinite of interest in active food packaging
component of oxygen scavenging composites. Nanoscale iron applications. Innovative Food Science & Emerging Technologies, 16, 211217.
Cantrell, W., McCrory, C., & Ewing, G. E. (2002). Nucleated deliquescence of salt. The
reacts in dry conditions with oxygen. However, the reaction rate
Journal of Chemical Physics, 116(5), 21162120.
was much higher at 100% relative humidity. For the application as Cecchi, T., Passamonti, P., & Cecchi, P. (2010). Study of the quality of extra virgin olive
oxygen scavenger for dry products the reaction rate at low relative oil stored in PET bottles with or without an oxygen scavenger. Food Chemistry,
humidity must be increased, i.e. by synthesizing a nanoscale iron 120(3), 730735.
Chaix, E., Guillaume, C., & Guillard, V. (2014). Oxygen and carbon dioxide solubility
with a lower particle size. Depending on the need and the and diffusivity in solid food matrices: A review of past and current knowledge.
predicted application in packaging, nanoscale iron can be Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 13(3), 261286.
dispersed in various polymers (Foltynowicz et al., 2012). Chiang W.L., Chokshi D., Tsai B.C., & Venkateshwaran L.N., (1997). Oxygen-
scavenging composition, Patent WO1996040412, Amoco Corporation.
Promising applications for the nanoscale iron are packagings Crane, R. A., & Scott, T. B. (2012). Nanoscale zero-valent iron: Future prospects for an
with ethylene vinyl alcohol (EVOH) as barrier layer. Such pack- emerging water treatment technology. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 211212,
agings are often sterilized in wet conditions. EVOH is hygroscopic 112125.
Cruz, R. S., Camilloto, G. P., & Pires, A. C. d. S. (2012). Oxygen scavengers: An approach
and it absorbs therefore water vapour during wet sterilisation on food preservation. structure and function of food engineering. In A. A. Eissa
(Axelson-Larsson, 1992; Tsai & Watchel, 1990; Mueller, Schoen- (Ed.), Structure and function of food engineering (pp. 2142).Rijeka, Croatia:
weitz, & Langowski, 2012). The absorbed water causes swelling in InTech.
Diao, M., & Yao, M. (2009). Use of zero-valent iron nanoparticles in inactivating
the EVOH polymer structure. The consequence is an increased the
microbes. Water Research, 43(20), 52435251.
oxygen permeability of EVOH (Axelson-Larsson, 1992; Kucukpinar Dombre, C., Guillard, V., & Chalier, P. (2015). Protection of methionol against
& Doruker, 2004; Muramatsu et al., 2003; Mller, 2013; Zhang, oxidation by oxygen scavenger: An experimental and modelling approach in
Britt, & Tung, 2001). This effect is called retort shock. Iron based wine model solution. Food Packaging and Shelf Life, 3, 7687.
EFSA CEF Panel (EFSA Panel on Food Contact Materials, E., Flavourings and
oxygen scavengers that are activated by humidity, reduce the Processing Aids), Scientic Opinion on safety assessment of the active
permeability of oxygen and prevent this retort shock. The results of substance, iron (0) modied bentonite as oxygen absorber, for use in active food
this study showed, that nanoscale iron can be an alternative to contact materials. EFSA Journal 2013. 11(10): 3400, p. 12.
EFSA CEF Panel (EFSA Panel on Food Contact Materials, E., Flavourings and
commercially available oxygen scavengers containing iron powder. Processing Aids), Scientic Opinion on safety assessment of the active
82 Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483

substance, iron (0) modied kaolinite as oxygen absorber, for use in active food Machado, S., Grosso, J. P., Nouws, H. P. A., Albergaria, J. T., & Delerue-Matos, C. (2014).
contact materials. EFSA Journal 2013, 11(10): 3401, p. 12. Utilization of food industry wastes for the production of zero-valent iron
Ewing, G. (2005). H2O on NaCl: From single molecule, to clusters, to monolayer, to nanoparticles. Science of the Total Environment, 496, 233240.
thin lm, to deliquescence. In D. J. Wales (Ed.), Intermolecular forces and clusters Mannon, A. G. (2007). Preventing oxidation of dairy powders using oxygen removal
II (pp. 125).Berlin Heidelberg, Germany: Springer. packaging. Virginia: Polytechnic Institute and State University.
Fang, Z., Chen, J., Qiu, X., Qiu, X., Cheng, W., & Zhu, L. (2011). Effective removal of McCafferty, E. (2010). Passivity. In E. McCafferty (Ed.), Introduction to corrosion
antibiotic metronidazole from water by nanoscale zero-valent iron particles. science (pp. 209262).New York, US: Springer.
Desalination, 268(13), 6067. Mexis, S. F., & Kontominas, M. G. (2010). Effect of oxygen absorber, nitrogen ushing,
Foltynowicz, Z., Kozak, W., & Fiedorow, R. (2002). Studies of oxygen uptake on O2 packaging material oxygen transmission rate and storage conditions on quality
scavengers prepared from different iron-containing parent substances. retention of raw whole unpeeled almond kernels (Prunus dulcis). LWTFood
Packaging Technology and Science, 15(2), 7581. Science and Technology, 43(1), 111.
Foltynowicz Z., Kozak W., Stoin  ska J., Urban
 ska M., Muc K., Dominiak A., & Kublicka Miller, C. W., Nguyen, M. H., Rooney, M., & Kailasapathy, K. (2003). The control of
K. (2012). Nanoiron-based oxygen scavengers. Patent WO2012091587A1, dissolved oxygen content in probiotic yoghurts by alternative packaging
Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny w Poznaniu. materials. Packaging Technology and Science, 16(2), 6167.
Galotto, M. J., Anfossi, S. A., & Guarda, A. (2009). Oxygen absorption kinetics of Mohan, C. O., Ravishankar, C. N., & Srinivasagopal, T. K. (2008). Effect of O2 scavenger
sheets and lms containing a commercial iron-based oxygen scavenger. Food on the shelf-life of catsh (Pangasius sutchi) steaks during chilled storage.
Science and Technology International, 15(2), 159168. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 88(3), 442448.
Geng, M., & Duan, Z. (2010). Prediction of oxygen solubility in pure water and brines Moon, B.-H., Park, Y.-B., & Park, K.-H. (2011). Fenton oxidation of Orange II by pre-
up to high temperatures and pressures. Geochimica Et Cosmochimica Acta, 74 reduction using nanoscale zero-valent iron. Desalination, 268(13), 249252.
(19), 56315640. Mu, H., Gao, H., Chen, H., Tao, F., Fang, X., & Ge, L. (2013). A nanosised oxygen
Gibis, D., & Rieblinger, K. (2011). Oxygen scavenging lms for food application. scavenger: Preparation and antioxidant application to roasted sunower seeds
Procedia Food Science, 1, 229234. and walnuts. Food Chemistry, 136(1), 245250.
Giovanelli, G., & Brenna, O. V. (2007). Oxidative stability of red wine stored in Mueller, K., Schoenweitz, C., & Langowski, H.-C. (2012). Thin laminate lms for
packages with different oxygen permeability. European Food Research and barrier packaging applicationinuence of down gauging and substrate surface
Technology, 226(1), 169179. properties on the permeation properties. Packaging Technology and Science, 25
Goldhan, G., Wanner, T., Sngerlaub, S., Amberg-Schwab, S., Weber, U., & Nique, S. (3), 137148.
(2007). Enhancement and indication of food quality by combinations of oxygen Mueller, K., (2003). Active packaging in breweriesoxygen scavenger for beer. Proc.
scavenger and indicator systems. Italian Journal of Food Science, 19, 157164. Congr. -Eur. Brew. Conv., 29th, 76/1-76/10.
Hintze, F., Becker, K., & Heiss, R. (1965). Lslichkeit und diffusion von sauerstoff in Muramatsu, M., Okura, M., Kuboyama, K., Ougizawa, T., Yamamoto, T., Nishihara, Y.,
lebensmitteln. Fette-Seifen-Anstrichmittel, 67(6), 12. et al. (2003). Oxygen permeability and free volume hole size in ethylenevinyl
Homem, V., & Santos, L. (2011). Degradation and removal methods of antibiotics alcohol copolymer lm: Temperature and humidity dependence. Radiation
from aqueous matricesA review. Journal of Environmental Management, 92(10), Physics and Chemistry, 68(3-4), 561564.
23042347. Ohtsuka, T. (2012). 2 Passive oxide lms on iron by in-situ detection of optical
Huber, C. H., Nguyen, T.-A., Krause, C. H., Humele, H., & Stangelmayer, A. (2006). techniques. In S.-I. Pyun, & J.-W. Lee (Eds.), Progress in corrosion science and
Oxygen ingress measurement into PET bottles using optical-chemical sensor engineering II (pp. 183241).New York, US: Springer.
technology. Monatsschrift fur Brauwissenschaft, 59(11), 515. Oropeza, S., Corea, M., Gmez-Yez, C., Cruz-Rivera, J. J., & Navarro-Clemente, M. E.
Jensen, P. N., & Risbo, J. (2007). Oxidative stability of snack and cereal products in (2012). Zero-valent iron nanoparticles preparation. Materials Research Bulletin,
relation to moisture sorption. Food Chemistry, 103(3), 717724. 47(6), 14781485.
Joven, R., Garcia, A., Arias, A., & Medina, J. (2014). Development of an active Perkins, M. L., Zerdin, K., Rooney, M. L., D'Arcy, B. R., & Deeth, H. C. (2007). Active
thermoplastic lm with oxygen scavengers made of activated carbon and packaging of UHT milk to prevent the development of stale avour during
sodium erythorbate. Packaging Technology and Science, 28(2), 113121. storage. Packaging Technology and Science, 20(2), 137146.
Klein, T., & Knorr, D. (1990). Oxygen absorption properties of powdered iron. Journal Piton, M., & Rivaton, A. (1996). Photooxidation of polybutadiene at long wavelengths
of Food Science, 55(3), 869870. ( >300 nm). Polymer Degradation and Stability, 53(3), 343359.
Klimant, I., Ruckruh, F., Liebsch, G., Stangelmayer, A., & Wolfbeis, O.& S. (1999). Fast Polyakov, V. A., & Miltz, J. (2016). Modeling of the temperature effect on oxygen
response oxygen micro-optodes based on novel soluble ormosil glasses. absorption by iron-based oxygen scavengers. Journal of Food Science, 81(1), E76
Mikrochimica Acta, 131(1), 3546. E85.
Kozak, W., & Samotyja, U. (2013). The use of oxygen content determination method Realini, C. E., & Marcos, B. (2014). Active and intelligent packaging systems for a
based on uorescence quenching for rapeseed oil shelf-life assessment. Food modern society. Meat Science, 98(3), 404419.
Control, 33(1), 162165. Rieblinger, K., Gottfried, Z., Berghammer, A., & Sandmeier, D. (1996). Verfahren und
Kuchel, L., Brody, A. L., & Wicker, L. (2006). Oxygen and its reactions in beer. Vorrichtung zur Bestimmung der Haltbarkeit von Lebensmitteln und dessen
Packaging Technology and Science, 19(1), 2532. Verwendung. Patent DE 19528400C1.
Kucukpinar, E., & Doruker, P. (2004). Effect of absorbed water on oxygen transport in Rizzo, V., Torri, L., Licciardello, F., Piergiovanni, L., & Muratore, G. (2013). Quality
EVOH matrices. A molecular dynamics study. Polymer, 45(10), 35553564. changes of extra virgin olive oil packaged in coloured polyethylene
Lpez-Cervantes, J., Snchez-Machado, D. I., Pastorelli, S., Rijk, R., & Paseiro-Losada, terephthalate bottles stored under different lighting conditions. Packaging
P. (2003). Evaluating the migration of ingredients from active packaging and Technology and Science, 27(6), 437448.
development of dedicated methods: A study of two iron-based oxygen Roman, O., Heyd, B., Broyart, B., Castillo, R., & Maillard, M. N. (2013). Oxidative
absorbers. Food Additives and Contaminants, 20(3), 291299. reactivity of unsaturated fatty acids from sunower, high oleic sunower and
Lagaron, J.-M., & Busolo, M. A. (2012). Active nanocomposites for food and beverage rapeseed oils subjected to heat treatment, under controlled conditions. LWT
packaging. In K. Yam, & D. S. Lee (Eds.), Emerging food packaging technologies: Food Science and Technology, 52(1), 4959.
Principles and practice (pp. 5565).Philadelphia, US: Woodhead Publishing. Rooney, M.L. (1995). Active food packaging. http://www.knovel.com/knovel2/Toc.
Lange, J., & Wyser, Y. (2003). Recent innovations in barrier technologies for plastic jsp?BookID=1540 Accessed 07.11.2007.
packaginga review. Packaging Technology and Science, 16(4), 149158. Sngerlaub, S., & Stramm, C. (2012). Humidity regulation. Kunststoffe International,
Lehner, M., Schlemmer, D., & Sngerlaub, S. (2015). Recycling of blends made of 102(9), 6668.
polypropylene and an iron-based oxygen scavengerinuence of multiple Sngerlaub, S., Gibis, D., Kirchhoff, E., Tittjung, M., Schmid, M., & Mller, M. (2012).
extrusions on the polymer stability and the oxygen absorption capacity. Polymer Compensation of pinhole defects in food packages by application of iron-based
Degradation and Stability, 122, 122132. oxygen scavenging multilayer lms. Packaging Technology and Science, 26(1), 17
Li, H., Tung, K. K., Paul, D. R., & Freeman, B. D. (2011). Effect of lm thickness on auto- 30.
oxidation in cobalt-catalyzed 1,4-polybutadiene lms. Polymer, 52(13), 2772 Saffert, A., Pieper, G., & Jetten, J. (2006). Effect of package light transmittance on the
2783. vitamin content of pasteurized whole milk. Packaging Technology and Science, 19
Lisinska-Kusnierz, M. (2001). The interrelation of charges in oxygen content and
 (4), 211218.
product quality in modied atmosphere packages of peanuts. Packaging Saffert, A., Pieper, G., & Jetten, J. (2008). Effect of package light transmittance on
Technology and Science, 14(6), 249252. vitamin content of milk. Part 2: UHT whole milk. Packaging Technology and
Liu, A., & Zhang, W.-X. (2014). Fine structural features of nanoscale zero-valent iron Science, 21(1), 4755.
characterized by spherical aberration corrected scanning transmission electron Schindelholz, E., Risteen, B. E., & Kelly, R. G. (2014). Effect of relative humidity on
microscopy (Cs-STEM). Analyst, 139(18), 45124518. corrosion of steel under sea salt aerosol proxies: I. NaCl. Journal of The
Lundquist, L., Pelletier, C., & Wyser, Y. (2004). Oxygen transmission rate Electrochemical Society, 161(10), C450C459.
measurement using oxygen sensitive uorescent tracers. 2004 TAPPI PLACE Schneider, J., Orzinski, M., Embs, F. W., Fritsch, K., & Weber, I. (2006). Monolayer-
Polymers, laminations, adhesives, coatings, and extrusions division conference, . Barriere-Blend-PET-Flaschen. Brauindustrie, 11, 5057.
Mller, K., Welle, F., Rieblinger, K., & Sngerlaub, S. (2010). Active packaging Shih, Y.-H., Hsu, C.-Y., & Su, Y.-F. (2011). Reduction of hexachlorobenzene by
functions: Oxygen absorbers. Kunststoffe International, 100(1), 5053. nanoscale zero-valent iron: Kinetics, pH effect, and degradation mechanism.
Mller, K., Sngerlaub, S., Kramer, A., Huber, C., & Fritsch, K. (2011). Temperature- Separation and Purification Technology, 76(3), 268274.
dependent oxygen permeation through PET/MXD6-barrier blend bottles with Singh, P., Wani, A. A., & Sngerlaub, S. (2011). Active packaging of food products:
and without oxygen absorber. BrewingScience, 64(11-12), 161167. Recent trends. Nutrition & Food Science, 41(4), 249260.
Mller, K. (2013). Multilayer lms for bag-in-container systems used in disposable Singh, P., Sngerlaub, S., Wani, A. A., & Langowski, H. C. (2012). Role of plastics
kegs: Basic principles of possible barrier concepts. BrewingScience, 66(34), 31 additives for food packaging. Pigment & Resin Technology, 41(6), 368379.
36.
Z. Foltynowicz et al. / Food Packaging and Shelf Life 11 (2017) 7483 83

Solis, J. A., & Rodgers, B. D. (2001). Factors affecting the performance of new oxygen Zardin, E., et al. (2016). Dynamic changes in the volatiles and sensory properties of
scavenging polymer for packaging applications. Journal of Plastic Film and chilled milk during exposure to light. International Dairy Journal, 62, 3538.
Sheeting, 17(4), 339349. Zerdin, K., Rooney, M. L., & Vermu, J. (2003). The vitamin C content of orange juice
Tsai, B. C., & Watchel, J. A. (1990). Barrier properties of ethylene? Vinyl alcohol packed in an oxygen scavenger material. Food Chemistry, 82(3), 387395.
copolymer in retorted plastic food containers. In W. J. Koros (Ed.), Barrier Zha, S., Cheng, Y., Gao, Y., Chen, Z., Megharaj, M., & Naidu, R. (2014). Nanoscale zero-
polymers and structures (pp. 192202).American Chemical Society. valent iron as a catalyst for heterogeneous Fenton oxidation of amoxicillin.
Wanner G. T. (2010). O2-zehrende und -anzeigende Packstoffe fr Chemical Engineering Journal, 255, 141148.
Lebensmittelverpackungen: Technische Universitt Mnchen. https:// Zhang, Z., Britt, I. J., & Tung, M. A. (2001). Permeation of oxygen and water vapor
mediatum.ub.tum.de/doc/972162/document.pdf. through EVOH lms as inuenced by relative humidity. Journal of Applied
Xu, L., & Wang, J. (2011). A heterogeneous Fenton-like system with nanoparticulate Polymer Science, 82(8), 18661872.
zero-valent iron for removal of 4-chloro-3-methyl phenol. Journal of Hazardous
Materials, 186(1), 256264.

Anda mungkin juga menyukai