EN BAN C
-versus-
CITYLAND, INC.,
Respondent.
x----------------------------------x
CITYLAND, INC., CTA EB No. 1439
Petitioner, (CTA AC No. 125)
Present:
DEL ROSARIO, P.J.,
CASTANEDA, JR.,
-versus- BAUTISTA,
UY,
CASANOVA,
FABON-VICTORINO,
MINDARO-GRULLA,
THE CITY OF MAKATI AND THE RINGPIS-LIBAN, and
CITY TREASURER OF MAKATI MANAHAN, JJ.
CITY,
Respondents. Promulgated:
JUN 2 8 2017 3.'Sj-(_~
x-------------------------------------------------------~:~-x
DECISION
1Minute Resolution dated September 5, 2016 consolidating cases CTA EB No . 1428 and CTA
EB No. 1439.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 2 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
SO ORDERED."
SO ORDERED."
('
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 5 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
RULE 15
RULE 15
Motions
5 City Of Dagupan, represented by the City Mayor Benjamin S. Lim vs. Ester F. Maramba,
represented by her Attorney-In-Fact, Johnny Ferrer, G.R. No. 174411, July 02, 2014, citing
the case of Jehan Shipping Corporation v. National Food Authority, G.R. No. 159750,
December 14, 2005.
6 Preysler, Jr. v. Manila Southcoast Development Corporation, G.R. No. 171872, June 28,
2010.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 9 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
('
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 10 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
7Eduardo 5. Baranda And Alfonso Hitalia vs. Honorable Judge Tito Gustilo, Acting Register Of
Deeds Avito Saclauso, Honorable Court Of Appeals, And Atty. Hector P. Teodosio, G.R. No.
81163, September 26, 1988.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 12 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
8 Cynthia S. Bolos vs. Danilo T. Bolos, G.R. No. 186400, October 20, 2010.
9 Luz R. Yamane, Capacity As The City Treasurer Of Makati City vs. BA Lepanto Condominum
Corporation, G.R. No. 154993, October 25, 2005
10 Supra Note 1, pp. 31-32.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 13 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
~ .
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 14 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
SO ORDERED.
~ N. M~J.M.- G_ ~
CIELITO N. MINDARO-GRULLA
Associate Justice
WE CONCUR:
Presiding Justice
~~ C!. ~o-.40{..
JtfANITO C. CASTANEDf(,.JR.
Associate Justice
9..
LOVELL~ BAUTISTA
Associate Justice
ERL~P.UY
(On Leave)
CAESAR A. CASANOVA
Associate Justice Associate Justice
R. FASON-VICTORINO
~~. ~ p'~'
MA. BELEN M. RINGPIS-LIBAN
Associate Justice
~7
CATHERINE T. MANAHAN
Associate Justice
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Page 16 of 16
Makati City vs. Cityland, Inc., /Cityland, Inc., vs.
The City of Makati and the City Treasurer of Makati City
CTA EB Nos. 1428 and 1439 (CTA AC Case No. 125)
DECISION
CERTIFICATION
ROMAN G. D L ROSARIO
Presiding Justice