Design Task # 2: Rubric

EKC 453 Plant Design & Economics

Reviewer:
Group:

PO5: Ability to design and evaluate the performance of complex chemical engineering activities using modern engineering and IT tools
CLO1: Design/Draw a piping and instrumentation diagram (P&ID) of a typical Chemical Process Plant.

Indicator Poor Fair Good Excellent Final

(0-10) (11-20) (21-30) (31-40) marks
(i3) The piping and Copied Genuine report from the Genuine report from the Genuine report from the
instrumentation information/report from student. student student
diagram of the someone or Able to select the Able to select the sensor Able to select the sensor
process somewhere else appropriate control valve for measurementation with for measurementation with
Able to provide control with justification justification justification
valve selection and Provide the basic Able to select the Able to select the
justification. maintenance/calibration of appropriate control valve appropriate control valve
Summary of the the control valve with justification with justification
control loops including Summary of the control Provide the basic Provide the basic
the objectives of each loops including the maintenance/calibration of maintenance/calibration of
loop is explained. objectives of each loop is the sensor. the sensor and control
explained. Summary of the control valve.
Able to state any possible loops including the Summary of the control
disturbances for each objectives of each loops is loops including the
loops well explain. objectives of each loops is
Able to state any possible well explain.
disturbances for each loops Able to state any possible
disturbances for each
loops
Summary of the control
loops in tabular form were
provided.
Dynamics Aspen
simulation for at least one
major equipment is
provided (distillation
column or reactor).

Gp # 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Marks 30 32 38 36 36 32 36 30 31 30 36 32 34 35 30 28 20
 (i1) Draw the P&ID Most of the symbol is Some of the symbol is Most of the symbol is The symbol for each
incorrect incorrect correct equipments is correct
Most of the control Control loops for major Control loops for major Control loops for major
loops is missing for equipment is available equipment is available equipment is available.
the major equipment The format is correct The format is correct Control loops for auxiliary
The format is Not in A3 size A3 size equipment is available
incorrect The format is correct
Not in the A3 size Using any software for
P&ID drawing like vision
or AUTOCADE
A3 size

Plant layout at the The arrangement of The arrangement of the The arrangement of the All symbol use is
whole complex the building and building and process building and process appropriate.
(ISBC/OSBC). process equipment is equipment is equipment is appropriate. The arrangement of the
inappropriate. inappropriate. Recommendation for building and process
Recommendation for evacuation procedure equipment is appropriate.
evacuation procedure (road map) is available Recommendation for
(road map) is missing The format is correct. evacuation procedure
The format is incorrect A3 size (road map) is available
The format is correct
A3 size

Gp # 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

Marks 37 32 34 32 35 30 32 30 30 34 38 32 16 31 28 16 20