N C H R P 17-28
Summary Page 5
6 NCHRP Project 17-28 Proposal
2. TABLE OF CONTENTS
3. RESEARCH PLAN.............................................................................7
3.1. Introduction...............................................................................7
3.2. Statement of the Problem.........................................................8
3.3. Proposal Overview....................................................................8
3.3.1. Identification of Key Issues................................................8
3.3.2. Description of the Work Plan...........................................11
3.3.3. Technical Approach.........................................................14
3.3.4. Management Approach....................................................15
3.4. Research Team within the Task Context:................................16
3.4.1. Task A (no corresponding NCHRP task number)............18
3.4.2. Task B (RFP Task 1).........................................................20
3.4.3. Task C (RFP Task 2).........................................................21
3.4.4. Task D (RFP Task 3).........................................................22
3.4.5. Task E (RFP Task 4).........................................................23
3.4.6. Task F (RFP Task 5).........................................................24
3.4.7. Task G (RFP Task 6).........................................................24
3.4.8. Task H (RFP Task 7).........................................................25
3.4.9. Task I (RFP Task 8)..........................................................26
3.4.10.Task J (RFP Task 9).........................................................27
3.4.11.Task K (RFP Task 10).....................................................27
3.4.12.Task L (RFP Task 11)......................................................27
3.5. Anticipated Research Results.................................................28
3.5.1. Implementation Plan........................................................28
3.6. Applicability of Results to Practice.........................................29
6. OTHER COMMITMENTS................................................................37
Table of Contents 7
6.3. Pieter Poolman, Researcher....................................................37
6.4. Frank Schmidt, Researcher....................................................38
6.5. James Stoner, Researcher.......................................................38
6.6. David Forkenbrock, Researcher..............................................38
8. TIME REQUIREMENTS..................................................................47
9. ITEMIZED BUDGET........................................................................49
11. APPENDIX.......................................................................................55
Pavement markings are by far the most widely used traffic control devices
on the roadways. They convey essential information to the motorists in a
continuous fashion, without any need to look away from the roadway.
Pavement markings appear to play a role in reducing the number of
accidents especially in location with high crash rates [1]. They convey
information on alignment, information on permission to pass other vehicles,
and information on the direction of traffic. Pavement markings convey this
information by virtue of configuration (dashed vs. solid), and color (white,
yellow). Thus, it is essential that pavement markings and their
configurations be identifiable to the drivers without ambiguities. It is often
argued that improved nighttime visibility of pavement markings will
improve driver safety. Improving and maintaining pavement marking and
marker visibility is usually associated with an infrastructure cost. Benefits
of improved visibility may come in the form of fewer crashes, fewer injuries,
and fewer fatalities, thus possibly reducing the cost to society. It is the goal
of this research to establish the link between pavement marking visibility
and their safety impact and cost-effectiveness.
Research Plan 9
markings/RPMs, seemed to pose new questions in terms of the cost
effectiveness of these traffic control materials. Contrary to the expectations,
in some of the cases, brighter materials seemed to cause safety drawbacks.
Although the direct and variable costs for material purchase and
maintenance are relatively easy to assess, the calculation of the benefit
potential requires expertise on topics such as human factors (visibility),
public policy, traffic engineering, and statistics. In addition, a
comprehensive knowledgebase is required to relate the visibility aspects of
pavement markings and markers with crashes, and eventually to translate
these figures into costs to the society. This is why we brought together an
excellent team of researchers, incorporating a wide spectrum of expertise in
human factors, traffic engineering, public policy, and statistical disciplines
with a particular emphasis on meta-analysis.
Research Plan 11
A more complex problem is to accurately identify the connection
between the visibility of pavement markings (and RPMs) and the rate of
crashes both during daytime and nighttime. Daytime pavement marking
visibility is not a function of retroreflectivity, and can constitute a baseline
for comparison with the nighttime visibility. Nighttime visibility of pavement
marking and RPMs depends on the retroreflectivity, headlamps,
driver/roadway/headlamp geometry, ambient lighting conditions, road
surface bidirectional reflectivity characteristics, and windshield
transmission, besides other uncontrollable factors. An in-depth review of
the literature and crash data is required to discover the link between
pavement marking (and RPM) visibility and crashes. We are confident that
our research plan, which will be further elaborated upon in following
sections, is an effective way to approach to this problem. Such an effort
requires expertise in the consolidation techniques of large and technically
unrelated research findings, and performing analysis thereupon, with
methodologies such as meta-analysis.
V* at f CTotal 0
Visibility
Crash Related
Costs f CCrash
Visibility
V* Daytime
Optimal Visibility
Visibility
The cost function shown in Figure 1 may depend on various factors such as
the climate, the traffic density and mixture, headlamps, pavement type, and
driver characteristics, besides many others, and is not purported to be a
ubiquitous representation. The actual cost function is a product of a set of
stochastic processes (i.e. the brighter the pavement marking/markers, the
great the possibility of driver complaisance and over-calibration of trust to
such guidance).
In the light of the above, key questions that should be answered include:
Research Plan 13
Program, Collision Database System, Traffic Safety Data Service, etc)
that contain the data from these sites, which are likely to be at
different states?
f. What was the initial visibility of pavement markings/RPMs at the time
they were implemented at these specific sites under dry, wet, rainy,
and foggy conditions?
g. What were the crash rates at the time the pavement markings/RPMs
were implemented?
h. What were the states of independent variables identified at point (d)
above, at these sites at the time the pavement markings/RPMs were
first implemented?
i. What were the traffic densities, volumes, and mixtures at the time the
pavement markings/RPMs were first implemented?
j. What is the visibility of the same pavement markings/RPMs now (or
at a point in the future) under different weather conditions?
k. What are the current crash rates? Are there more crashes due to
material degradation?
l. What were the states of independent variables identified at point (d),
at these sites at the current time?
m. What are the traffic densities, volumes, and mixtures at the current
time?
n. What is the degree of correlation between pavement marking/RPM
visibility and crash rates?
o. Is it possible to develop a cost function (similar to the one shown in
Figure 1), and optimize the cost with respect to the visibility,
specifically for dry, wet, rainy, and foggy conditions based on these
findings ?
1
The research plan described in this proposal addresses these issues and
many more by developing a series of coordinated tasks, strategies, and
techniques. The results of this project are intended to assist rule-making
agencies to identify the best selection practices for pavement
markings/RPMs applications that will provide an optimum level of service
with minimal overall cost.
2. Determine the independent variables that may affect the crash rates
other than the pavement markings/RPMs from a traffic engineering
point of view. These independent factors may include the roadway
geometry, weather conditions, time of day, ambient lighting, vehicle
mixture, driver age, traffic density and volume, traffic speeds,
pavement reflectivity, and roadway functional classification, among
others.
3. Implement data mining strategies to identify the cases and the rate of
crashes that can be at least in part attributed to pavement
marking/RPM visibility. To that end, we will draw on any and all
available crash databases and use data mining and clustering
algorithms to sort the crashes according to cause. The goal is to
extract those crash descriptions that are likely to be associated with
visibility issues. The granularity of our crash data filtering will
become gradually smaller until we can isolate those crashes that were
caused by factors solely driven by pavement marking and RPM
visibility.
Research Plan 15
compared to the time a crash occurred but we will use pavement
marking age to roughly estimate the likely retroreflectivity at the time
of the crash. It would obviously be great if crash reports provided that
data but it is highly unlikely that pavement marking retroreflectivities
are recorded after a crash.
8. Merge findings to link the gaps in the literature, and conduct meta-
analysis to determine the effect sizes of each independent variables
mentioned in point (2).
Research Plan 17
Based on the findings of the proposed research option spelled out in
the work plan and the meta analysis, develop cost models, and lookup
tables for the aforementioned independent factors.
Development of a plan, and organization of meetings to communicate
the findings of the study to the agencies, and provide
recommendations, tools, and related procedures in determining the
best pavement-management strategies.
Development of a model performance-based specification, and a web
based documentation or application to support agencies with issues
related to pavement-management strategies.
Heavy emphasis on communications between members of the
research team and the NCHRP panel (through the NCHRP staff
officer) through technical memorandums, reports, and availability of
information on the web.
The above listed key aspects of the work plan also parallels with another
research effort similar in nature. The OPL and the National Institute of
Standards and Technology (NIST) are currently in the process of developing
a work plan for field measurements of retroreflectance and color of
pavement markings under an ongoing NCHRP project (5-18, Color
Effectiveness of Yellow Pavement Markings). We are already receiving
invaluable information from various state agencies regarding the pavement
management and maintenance programs, and we believe that this
information provides us with a margin of advancement up-front. We have
developed state of the art electronic questionnaires using php scripting and
we could reuse much of the electronic automation that was developed for
those questionnaires. In the project NCHRP 5-18, we are specifying key
sites for field measurements of retroreflectance and color similar to what
we propose for the project 17-28. We believe that the measurements
obtained during the course of the former project may be significantly
The work plan for this research effort utilizes a five-pronged approach as
follows:
The activities associated with each of these tasks are described in the
Work Plan section of this proposal. This technical approach is intended to
fully conform to project requirements set forth by NCHRP in the RFP.
Research Plan 19
usable and implementable results. A strong link to practical
engineering.
Significant experience in researching many aspects of pavement
markings including:
- Pavement marking retroreflectivity, configuration, width, color,
wet vs. dry. Tom Schnell and Fuat Aktan conducted numerous
pavement marking research studies within the last 10 years [7]
[8] [9] [10] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25]
[26].
- Pavement marking fabrication process,
- Pavement marking materials,
- U.S. transportation agency practices,
- Vehicle headlight performance.
The contractual and administrative aspects of the study will be
handled through the UI Division of Sponsored Programs.
The Principal Investigator will be responsible for all technical
activities of the research study.
Monthly and quarterly progress reports will provide a means of
monitoring the status of research activities and the budget.
The PI will place emphasis on maintaining communication at all
levels of the project. This contact includes:
- Frequent use of email to maintain communication at all levels.
The PI can be reached by email at thomas-schnell@uiowa.edu.
- Informal presentations on the status of the research to various
professional audiences that might have an interest in the
research, subject to the approval of the NCHRP staff
representative. Table 1 lists professional meetings that might be
considered for interim presentations during the course of the
research.
Date of Meeting
Organization and Meeting
2004 2005 2006
Earlier than
ATSSA Convention and Traffic Expo estimated project February 6-8
start date
CIE 26th Session June 7-11
January
TRB Conferences January 11-15 January 9-13
22-26
September
HFES Annual Meetings September 20-24
26-30
ITE Conference and Exhibit March 23-26, August 7-10 August 6-9
Tom Schnell is the Principal Investigator (PI) of the research team, and
he assembled a team of experts with the necessary expertise, manpower,
and resources to effectively manage, conduct, and finalize the tasks
required for the successful conclusion of the proposed project. Dr. Thomas
Schnell is the Director of the Operator Performance Laboratory (OPL). He is
an expert in human factors and theoretical aspects of the human visual
system, pavement markings and retroreflectivity. Dr. Schnell has conducted
pavement marking research for more than a decade, and published many
papers related to pavement markings. He investigated virtually all aspects
of pavement marking visibility. He is also a renowned expert in the field of
driver visibility, driver eye scanning behavior, traffic sign legibility,
retroreflection and photometry. Over the years, he has lead the development
of the TarVIP model, and three Ohio University proprietary computer based
visibility models IRPE, LEGI, and PCVisi. Dr. Schnell has developed the
pavement marking visibility program CARVE [16][17][18][19]. He is the
chairman of the CIE (International Illumination Commission) Committee
TC4-38 (Road Signs) and he is a member of the Transportation Research
Board (TRB) Committee on Visibility. He is the author of over 30 journal
articles and more than 47 articles in conference proceedings.
Dr. Fuat Aktan, a research engineer and the head of the Ground
Transportation Research Branch of the Operator Performance Laboratory
(OPL). He is an expert on pavement marking/RPM visibility and modeling.
He developed the comprehensive modeling software TarVIP, a multi-purpose
tool that can predict the visibility distance of pavement markings and
markers and diffusing targets such as pedestrians as well as the legibility
distance of retroreflective signs . Fuat Aktan is a member of TRB
2
2Tarvip was in part implemented with FHWA funding under a subcontract to UI from
Virginia Tech. The model is being enhanced under another FHWA contract to evaluate the
roadway luminance induced by overhead luminaries. The TarVIP model is used by our
peers and practitioners for various studies with a particular focus on roadway object
visibility. TarVIP can be obtained free of charge upon request.
Research Plan 21
A3B02 (Committee on Vehicle User Characteristics). He has extensive
knowledge and modeling experience on retroreflectivitity of pavement
markings, road signs, diffusing targets, and headlamps. He is also a
member of HFES and CIE Committee TC 4-38 on road signs. The TarVIP
model will be an indispensable tool to convert the retroreflectivity measures
of the markings and RPMs into visibility performance. Dr. Aktan has 14
articles in journals and conference proceedings.
Dr. James Stoner is another key member of the team with his traffic
engineering expertise. He is currently a professor in the Civil and
Environmental Engineering Department of the UI. He conducted several
studies with a focus on advanced simulation technologies, traffic control
procedures, driver information systems, automated highway systems, and
driving simulation, and travel demand modeling. Dr. Stoners expertise will
assist the team all traffic engineering related components of the project.
Research Plan 23
Table 3. Overview of Tasks as Proposed and Relationship to Tasks
The above list is not all-inclusive. In the review process, we will perform
a multi-faceted approach to identify the key literature components. Each
factor will be weighted according to subjective importance, as well as
experimental validity, applicability, and date of each literature source
will be evaluated. Concurrently, we will design and develop an online
survey to determine the current selection processes and related
specifications for pavement marking/RPM applications. As stated before,
we will re-use the electronic php scripts and automated data analysis
tools that we have developed for online questionnaires under earlier
projects for Iowa DOT [22] and under NCHRP 5-18. We will be very
mindful of the content of the earlier surveys to avoid duplication and
possible questionnaire burnout effects in the pool of respondents. The
survey will be deployed to obtain data from highway agencies (OPL
already maintains a state DOT contact database for pavement marking
applications), and other sources such as public/private-sector materials
Research Plan 25
testing laboratories, materials manufacturers and suppliers, and the
National Transportation Product Evaluation Program (NTPEP) for the
purpose of:
i. Understanding the current practices of pavement marking
purchase and application policies, guidelines, specifications, and
procedures.
ii. Determining the extent, to which the agencies incorporate
relevant research studies (internally or external) in their
policies, procedures, and selection criteria when determining
pavement marking/RPM application to promote safety.
iii. Whether agencies have specific sites where they implement
safety programs through the use of pavement markings/RPMs.
iv. Investigating the long term performance based specifications
in agency practices, and associated specifications and
guidelines.
v. Investigating the manufacturer practices and existing studies
in the direction of increasing the pavement marking or RPM
visibility.
vi. Investigating the manufacturer practices, studies, efforts,
measurement techniques, and criteria in determining the long
term performance of pavement markings and RPMs.
vii. Understanding the relationship between generic material
types and their respective dry and wet performance, as well as
degradation characteristics.
Research Plan 27
identify the directions where further information is required. The
research team will analyze the findings in the literature, and determine
whether the current pool of studies contain the following items:
This task will involve developing a work plan upon the approval of the
option proposed by the research team. We envision the work plan to
include the following tasks:
i. Determination of all independent factors that may influence driver
safety alongside the pavement marking/RPM reflectivity from a
traffic engineering point of view (The effect sizes each of these
factors will be established through the meta-analysis techniques
performed on the extensive literature review).
ii. Perform meta-analysis on the existing data to provide a holistic
analysis of the extensive literature findings. We think that meta-
analysis is an excellent tool to integrate findings from different
studies.
iii. Identify effect sizes for each independent factor, and the
shortcomings of the outcome of the meta-analysis.
iv. Perform retroreflectivity measurements with a portable
retroreflectometer according to ASTM standard practices E-1710
(dry condition), E-2177 (standard condition of wetness), and E-
2176 (standard condition of continuous wetting) at each of the key
sites determined in proposal Task 1, and document the levels of
each independent factor at each site.
v. Utilize TarVIP to obtain the visibility of pavement markings/RPMs
for the current and past state of the sites based on the
retroreflectivity data.
vi. Access the crash databases and implement the filtering strategies
established in Task 1 for each of these sites to determine the
current state of the safety impact for the calculated visibility.
vii. Obtain retroreflectivity figures for the same materials when they
were initially applied. We will try the following alternative
strategies to obtain this data (in the given order of preference):
a. Through the state agency records (there is a greater chance of
agencies having this information, because the sites will be
selected among specific safety program locations),
b. Through manufacturer/supplier data,
c. By requesting the state agency to measure the same material
next time it is applied according to the site-specific pavement
management programs,
d. Through new material data in TarVIP database.
viii. Utilize TarVIP to obtain the visibility of pavement markings/RPMs
at the initial state of the sites based on the initial retroreflectivity
data.
ix. Obtain pavement marking degradation factors as a function of time
(in the given order of preference):
Research Plan 29
a. Through agency records if such routine measurements had
been performed,
b. Through NTPEP data,
c. Literature,
d. Engineering estimates.
x. Determine the visibility of pavement markings/RPMs at different
points in time based on the material degradation functions for each
site.
xi. Correlate visibility and crash rates as they relate to the pavement
marking/RPM applications.
xii. Access the crash databases and determine the rate of crashes per
vehicle miles driven specifically due to pavement marking/RPM
visibility problems for current condition, initial condition, and the
conditions in between.
xiii. Determine the costs of these crashes to society via public policy
data.
xiv. Update the literature knowledgebase with this information, and
reiterate the meta-analysis.
xv. Obtain direct and indirect cost information from the state agencies
for the selected site pavement management programs (for
installation, maintenance, etc).
xvi. Develop cost functions for pavement marking/RPM visibility for
cost to the society and the costs obtained through agency cost
information from (xv).
xvii. Generate overall cost functions based on (xvi) as a function of
material retroreflectivity (which changes with the weather
conditions).
The research team will conduct the subtasks in the approved work plan
as outlined in Task E (RFP Task 4) so as to:
i. Determine the correlation between the pavement marking/RPM
visibility and driver safety. The correlations will be determined for
various weather conditions and pavement marking/RPM and
roadway/pavement configurations.
ii. Translate the pavement marking/RPM visibility performance
shortfalls into the terms of crashes through the correlation
functions established in (i), and eventually to cost terms to the
society to generate cost functions.
iii. Optimize the visibility levels for different weather conditions and
generalize the functions for different climates (based on yearly
rainfall distributions) to achieve maximum cost effectiveness.
iv. Initialize lookup tables (in the form of matrices) and an electronic
database to utilize the findings of this task. We will seek panel
input, as well as the input from our contacts who will be the actual
stakeholders to further improve the lookup tables and the
electronic database to make them adaptable and functional for
practitioners to assist them in their pavement management
strategy policy decisions.
Research Plan 31
3.4.8. Task H (RFP Task 7)
Identification of the effect sizes of primary variables and the development of
a database and lookup matrices to assist practitioners in their decision
making process:
The independent factors, similar to those listed in Task D (RFP Task 3),
will be ranked based on the meta-analysis effect size suggestions for
each of the independent factors. We feel that the list given in Task D
(RFP Task 3) is rather extensive, but still far from being all inclusive.
The list will be updated during the in-depth literature review. Each
factor is not expected to affect the driver safety in a similar nature.
Therefore, we will establish criteria for including each independent
factor based on the effect sizes they impose on the safety
characteristics, and eventually to the cost figures. The research team is
fully aware of the fact that the findings of this research effort must be in
a simple yet effective form to assist the agencies in their policy making
decisions. To that end, we will have our communication lines open
throughout the project effort, and seek constant interaction and
feedback. The research team will therefore arrange a meeting with
practitioners at all levels (NCHRP Panel member(s) will also be asked to
participate). We propose to conduct this meeting at one of the venues
listed in Table 1 on page 20. The purpose of the meeting will be to
communicate our findings to the practitioners and stakeholders, and to
seek their inputs regarding implementation. We do not intend to develop
recommendations that would be infeasible. A 30 meter geometry
retroreflectometer may not be affordable for all practitioners to
3
3 One of the students at the OPL has developed a low-cost retroreflectometer for the Iowa
DOT. This retroreflectometer may hold some promise for DOT districts that cannot afford
expensive meters.
Determine current
Determine Independent
practices in selecting
Factors that affect Select 20 Key sites where
visibility (AADT, pavement marking/ RPM
roadway/ vehicle/ driver Determine the gaps in the safety programs are being Investigate pavement
geometries, weather implemented through the use management strategies,
conditions, pavement knowledgebase guidelines, specifications
marking type, etc) of PM/ RPMs
INVESTIGATE INITIAL AND
CURRENT STATE OF THE KEY SITES
findings
Existing body through key Obtain current crash data
of Literature sites to link
Obtain initial standard retroreflectance
the gap and the levels of all independent
factors at the key sites, when program
was first implemented
Timeline
Meta-Analysis
Research Plan 33
will be enhanced and modified to allow practitioners and agencies to
efficiently identify the cases of interest based on the reduced set of
independent factors in Task H (RFP Task 7), most likely through
illustrative examples (or via wizards to facilitate an electronic database
query), and determine the suggested material performance in the form
of standard retroreflectance (and possibly the configuration such as
spacing of RPMs). The guidelines will not specify a material by
manufacturer in particular, but will recommend in the lines of generic
material types with certain retroreflective performance. These
guidelines may ultimately lead to updates in relevant AASHTO, ITE,
TRB, and FHWA handbooks.
If the panel agrees, the research team will also develop a web page
to communicate the findings, recommendations, and procedures to the
public. Emphasis will be given to convey this information in very simple
terms. After the NCHRP panel review, we will implement suggestions
and revisions as needed, and submit the deliverables to the NCHRP.
This task will focus on the completion of the final report and the
associated executive summary outlining the research. The final report
will incorporate the interim report explaining how the research was
conducted in detail, including the guidelines, model performance-based
specifications, lookup matrices, the electronic database, and the
developed tools for the practitioners to effectively utilize the findings of
the project in the form of appendices, and via the internet and/or CDs.
We will submit the final report for panel review, obtain the panel input,
and update the final report as suggested by the panel, prior to
resubmitting the updated version of the final report.
3.5. Anticipated Research Results
Research Plan 35
3.5.1. Implementation Plan
4.2. Co-PI
Dr. Fuat Aktan, University of Iowa: Dr. Aktan recently received his Ph.D.
degree from the University of Iowa in Industrial Engineering with a focus on
human factors field. He received his masters degree from the same
department in December 2000. His dissertation study investigated the
effects of headlamp glare induced by tungsten-halogen and high-intensity
gas discharge headlamps.
Dr. Aktan also has substantial experience in online survey design and
implementation, database protocols and management, and software
development. He has 14 articles in journals and conference proceedings.
4.4. Disclosure
Other Commitments 43
conducted and numerous human factors experiments at the OPL. His
published papers and conference proceedings are available upon request.
6. OTHER COMMITMENTS
Other Commitments 45
6.3. Pieter Poolman, Researcher
10% Minnesota DOT
15% NCHRP 5-18
Time Requirements 47
Surface Transportation Research, Fuat Aktan, Research Engineer
Simulators:
One share in a KQ Corp. fixed base, one channel driving simulator
operated by the Cognitive Systems Laboratory (CSL) under leadership
of Dr. John D. Lee.
Vehicles:
One half share in a 1996 Ford Taurus Instrumented car, operated by
the OPL under leadership of Tom Schnell and Fuat Aktan
1994 Dodge Minivan for crew transport
Other Equipment:
Simulators:
Generic fixed-base wide-body (PC based 777 mockup) with functional
HDD and 140 photo-realistic forward field of view.
Fixed-base F15-E with functional HUD and infinity focus visual system
using collimated displays.
Fixed-base 737-800, with complete set of controls and displays.
Fixed base General Aviation
Other Equipment:
Collimated Infinity-Focus Display Systems including a HUD
Biopac Physiological Assessment Equipment (for airborne workload
assessment)
A test road has been made available to the OPL by the Iowa Department
of Transportation. The test road (see Figure 5) is open to public traffic but
has an extremely small traffic volume. The road is 10 miles long, includes
Itemized Budget 51
horizontal and vertical curves, and long tangent level sections. The road can
be used to evaluate the effectiveness of traffic control devices. Removable
sign posts are an integral part of the test road to evaluate traffic signs
during daytime and at night.
a. Panel Mounted Mini Pan-Tilt Unit may be used b. Close-up Look at the
Mini Pan-Tilt Unit
instead of Ball Cap Mounted Optics
Itemized Budget 53
c. Experimenter Workstation on Rear Passenger Side d. Overall View of the
Instrumented Vehicle
Itemized Budget 55
8. TIME REQUIREMENTS
We are prepared to meet this time frame following the timeline presented
below.
Table 4. Gantt Chart of the Proposed Project NCHRP 17-28.
Itemized Budget 57
9. ITEMIZED BUDGET
Itemized Budget 59
Table 6. Itemized Budget, University of Iowa, Phase II
Itemized
60 Budget
Table 7. Level of Effort by Task (Phase I)
Itemized Budget 61
Table 8. Level of Effort by Task (Phase II)
We have a very good working relationship with Tom Welch from the Iowa
DOT. He is the State Transportation Safety Engineer and is heavily involved
in work aimed at improving the traffic environment. We have made Tom
Welch aware of the fact that we are proposing on NCHRP 17-28 and we
have obtained a letter of collaboration from him. Through Tom Welch, we
will be able to gain access to practitioners in the field, not just in the State
of Iowa, but in other states as well through his network of connections. Tom
will also be instrumental in providing support in terms of crash data and
engineering data.
All letters of support are found in the Support Letters section of the
Appendix at the very end of this proposal, starting on page 139.
Cooperative Features 63
64 NCHRP Project 17-28 Proposal
11.APPENDIX
Appendix 65
11.1.2. Pavement Marking Retroreflectivity
Incoming Light
Beam C
Diffused Light
a. Diffuse Reflection
Reflected Light
Incoming Light Beam
Beam
b. Specular Reflection
R e tr o r e fle c te d C
L ig h t
c. Retroreflection
Figure 10. The Three Types of Light Reflection
Appendix 69
Zwahlen and Schnell [30] investigated the visibility of new pavement
markings at night under low beam illumination. Three independent field
studies were conducted. First study was conducted to obtain exploratory
pavement marking nighttime visibility field data for detecting the begin and
end of a continuous pavement marking line as a function of line width,
material color, and lateral position of the line. The results of the first study
was used primarily in the development of the pavement marking visibility
model CARVE for continuous lines. Study two was conducted to obtain
exploratory pavement marking nighttime visibility data under low-beam
conditions to determine the visibility distance to detect the onset of a left or
a right curve with a 244 meter (800-ft) radius along a tangent section
marked with a continuous white edge line placed at approximately 1.83
meter (6-ft) to the right of the car as a function of the line width. The
objective of the third study was to obtain the nighttime average detection
distances under low-beam illumination conditions for the begin and end of
various yellow centerline pavement marking tape configurations using
various widths.
30%
20%
10%
0%
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
2
RL [mcd/m /lx] at Mirolux 30m Geometry
Appendix 71
performance module to assess the pavement marking detection distances
under various conditions.
D r i v e r 's e y e l o c a t i o n r e l a t i v e
Y to c a r o r ig i n Z
Headlamp Z
E ye
p o s it io n
H e a d la m p Y D r i v e r 's e y e l o c a ti o n r e l a tiv e to c a r o r i g in Y
C ar
Z X
O r ig in
Appendix 73
O b s e r v a ti o n
A x is
E n tr a n c e
A n g le ( E A )
Ill u m i n a t i o n
A x is
O b s e r v a ti o n
A n g le ( O A ) P O I
Figure 16. Entrance and Observation Angles for the Passenger Side
Headlamp.
For each of the 100 surface colors, they obtained the probability that
a color was categorized into a given color category. For each of the thirteen
color categories, iso-percentage distribution curves (generated with Table
Curve 3D 3.0 by SPSS Science Software) were generated, showing the
percentage correctly identified. They indicate that the present US color
boxes appear to be too large to appropriately account for the absolute
human color classification performance. They mention the need for
additional research to establish more appropriate color boxes that are
based on human performance rather than on available sign sheeting
materials.
All of the aforementioned resources are available from the OPL upon
request of the NCHRP panel members.
Appendix 75
illumination is provided with a xenon arc, which provides light in higher
color temperatures compared to TH headlamps.
In the past, the number of headlamp types on the market was fairly
small. The majority of the cars in the US used some form of sealed beam
headlamps including the famous H6054. This lowbeam headlamp is actually
fairly bright and provides considerable illumination above the horizon.
Concerns about glaring oncoming vehicles with the H6054 and similar
broad lowbeam headlamps were voiced by some. The strongest push for
cutting off light above the horizon seemed to come from Europe, where
many of the disadvantaged traffic signs are internally or externally
illuminated.
a. 1999 BMW 525i HID Left Headlamp Low Beam Iso-Candela Plot.
Appendix 77
Figure 18. Spectral Power Distribution of 2000 Mercedes S-Class HID Low
Beam Headlamp.
Optronics
Spectro- Fluorescent Visible Light Handheld Photometer
Pavement Filtered Radiation towards Photometer (Pritchard 1980 A) used
radiometer
Optic Head Marking for cross-checking
Sample
Photoreceptor
on a sliding
surface in the
Xenon
same horizontal
plane with the
IL 1700 light source
Luxmeter
Photoreceptor Oriel Bandpass Photoreceptor
Head Filter Unit reading
measurements
(in Picoamps)
Radiometer, OL and sending it
IL 1700 to the Main
754 41.4
8
Luxmeter Computer
Monochromator
Measurements for Computer Main computer
each 2nm interval equipped with OL controlling the
Spectroradiometer goniometer and
Software the
photoreceptor,
collecting data
Appendix 79
1.5 1.5
Coefficient of Retroreflection
Coefficient of Retroreflection
1.25 1.25
1 1
0.75 0.75
0.5 0.5
0.25 0.25
0 0
0.5 85
1 86
1.5 87
Ob 2 les
s er
vat 2.5 88 Ang
ion 3 ce
Ang 89 ran
les 3.5 Ent
4 90
1.5
1.7 1.4
1.6 1.3
1.5 1.2
1.4 1.1
1.3 1
1.2 0.9
1.1 0.8
1 0.7
0.9 0.6
0.8 0.5
0.7 0.4
0.6 0.3
0.2
0.5 0.1
0.4 0
0.3 0.5 g]
0.2
1.5
1
s [de
0.1
0 2 g le
2.5 An
89 n
88 3 tio
87 3.5 rva
Entrance 86 4 s e
Angles [d 85 Ob
eg] 84
Appendix 81
the accident potential and proneness, usually in case of that controlled
field experiments. Simulators are widely used for such purposes, however,
the differences between the risks associated with simulator experiments
and the risks in the real world driving conditions make actual accident
measures hard to assess. Common measures mentioned in the literature
other than actual crash rates are the driver alertness and behavior changes
such as speed reduction, vehicle lateral placement, potentially hazardous
actions that may lead to crashes, conflicts, and erratic maneuvers.
Al-Masaeid [1] and Persaud [38] argued that the utilization of average
accident reduction factor might not be a proper measure for the
effectiveness of traffic control devices. Al-Masaeid defined accident
reduction factor as the percent reduction in number of accidents or
accident rates due to implementation of a specific countermeasure.
Similarly, it is defined as the proportion of change in the number of
accidents or accident rates from the before period to the after period when
a safety measure is implemented. One problem that may be recognized in
this approach is that the number of crashes cannot be analyzed independent
of the crash risks, which grow in parallel with the traffic volumes and AADT.
Therefore, we believe that number of crashes is not a meaningful measure
without an indication a relative risk measure, such as vehicle miles driven.
Persaud [38] further argued that the measure of safety effectiveness was
a function of the expected number of accident reduction factor, because the
accident reduction factor is a random variable. The accident reduction
factor for a given traffic control device improvement varies from one site to
another even if the improved sites have similar situations such as crash
experience, physical factors, and operational characteristics.
Al-Masaeid [1] used a Bayesian stochastic probabilistic model to
estimate the expected accident rate, expected accident reduction rate and
its ranges (confidence interval). The expected accident rate was normalized
so that a -distribution could be used to model the distribution of the
transformed accident reduction factor.
By analyzing the data collected from all the selected sites, the expected
accident reduction rate was found to be 3.4% (a negative accident
reduction rate means an increase in the after period), on average, yet the
difference was not statistically significant between the before and after
conditions The 80% confidence interval was found to be [-0.369. 0.304]). A
follow-up work was carried out to analyze the hazardous sites included in
the study, which had expected accident rates higher than the average
accident rates in the before period. The analysis for the hazardous sites
revealed that there was a 13.5% reduction in the accident rate at the
hazardous sites after the pavement markings were improved (The 80%
confidence interval for the accident reduction rates was found to be [0.065,
0.215]).
Appendix 83
markings on reducing traffic crashes. 55 sites were selected with 65% on
freeways, 15% on non-freeways with speeds of 45mph or more, and 18% on
non-freeways with speeds of 40 mph or less. Before the installation of the
experimental pavement markings, 48 sites had conventional solvent paint,
and 7 had epoxy. A total of 10,312 crashes were observed during the study.
The crashes that occurred between intersections under dry and wet
pavement conditions during daytime and nighttime were analyzed. One
statistically conclusive result from Migletzs study was that crash rate
achieved a significant decrease by 11% under nighttime dry pavement
condition due to the longer lasting and more retroreflective pavement
markings.
The large paint contract was the most cost-effective for two-lane
roads under most volume conditions and for four- and six-lane low-volume
roads. Polyurea and paint installed under a large-scale contract were the
most cost-effective for high-volume four-lane roads, and polyurea and waffle
tape were the most cost-effective for high-volume six-lane roads. For
durable markings, the ordering from most to least cost-effective was found
to be polyurea, thermoplastic, epoxy, and waffle tape for the low-volume
roads. For higher volume roads, the order of materials from most to least
cost-effective was found to be polyurea, waffle tape, thermoplastic, and
epoxy. When only the annualized installation costs are considered for a
study period of 6 years, the ordering from most to least cost effective
materials was thermoplastic, epoxy, polyurea, and waffle tape.
Glennon [39] integrated and analyzed the data in a FHWA report edited
by Lee [40] and additional data from the states of Ohio and Missouri. When
centerline and no-passing zone markings were added on previously
unmarked roads, in general, the accident rate reduction effect was not
significant. At a further step, when data from each state were analyzed
independently, the results suggested mixed signals in terms of accident rate
reduction. Data from the state of Montana showed a significant increase in
accident rate after centerline and no-passing zone markings were
implemented on previously unmarked roads. In the state of Ohio, the results
were the total opposite of that seen in Montana, in that the accident rate
Appendix 85
was significantly reduced after the implementation of centerline and no-
passing zone markings. Data from other states yielded inconclusive results
(Missouri, North Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia), in that the rate of
change in accidents was not statistically significant. The effect of adding
only dashed centerline markings to previously unmarked roads was
evaluated based on the date from the state of Missouri. The result showed a
statistically non-significant increase of 22% in accident rate. The effect of
adding no-passing zone markings on roads with dashed centerline markings
from Missouri data found significant accident rate decreases for roads with
traffic volumes greater than 500 vehicles per day (VPD). The study
concluded that dashed centerline pavement markings might be beneficial
with respect to traffic safety for roadway widths of 20 or more feet, and for
a traffic volume of 500 or more VPD.
Two FHWA studies [41] [42] reported accident reduction rates varying
from negative 13% to +30% due to the implementation of pavement
markings, for various average daily traffic volumes on rural roads and for
various lane widths.
Zador et al. [44] conducted a study investigating the effects three types
of roadway delineation devices: chevrons, post-mounted delineators, and
raised pavement markers (RPM), on driver behavior change in terms of
Appendix 87
were designed to give the drivers an illusion of acceleration up to certain
deceleration rates. At the aimed safe speed, the markings appear equally
wide to the driver as the vehicle proceeds. The objective of applying
transverse pavement markings is to induce the drivers to decelerate to a
safe speed and negotiate a dangerous roadway segment. The slowing-down
distance was calculated as given below.
V 2 - V22
D 1
2d
where, D is the distance traveled in slowing down from V1 to V2, d is the
deceleration, V1 denotes the speed at beginning of markings, and V2 denotes
the speed at ending of markings (beginning of curve).
11.1.7. Surveys
Zwahlen and Schnell [49] conducted a large field evaluation study for
the Ohio Rail Commission and the Ohio Department of Transportation. Two
new crossbuck designs for use at passive railroad-highway grade crossings
were evaluated. The Standard Improved and the Buckeye crossbuck were
evaluated in Ohio with respect to their potential to alter driver risk taking
behavior (part I), their accident reduction potential (part II), user
acceptance (part III), and with respect to their photometric performance at
night (part IV). A user acceptance survey indicated an overwhelming
preference of the Buckeye crossbuck among of the surveyed user groups.
Photometric crossbuck luminance measurements conducted under
automobile low-beam illumination at night indicate that thanks to their
increased reflectorization, both new designs provide superior visual stimuli
to an approaching driver at night. The Buckeye crossbuck provides by far
the strongest visual signal among the measured crossbucks at night.
Amendments to the National Standard for crossbucks at passive RRX in the
MUTCD are recommended. Post reflectorization (four-sided) is
recommended and the additional use of a striped, angled shield is
recommended in situations that require a maximum visual stimulus,
Appendix 89
assuring shortest possible perception reaction times, and in situations that
involve visual obstructions, frequent fog, or blinding snow.
Driver eye scanning behavior has been found to reveal the true driver
needs in terms of visual information acquisition in curve driving. Schnell
and Zwahlen [23] determined driver needs when driving at night in terms of
driver preview behavior as a function of the pavement marking retro-
reflectivity. The study indicated, that drivers do in fact make use of the
A p p lic a tio n
Level
U s e r fr ie n d lin e s s
-N u m b e r o f
v a r ia b le s
(fa c to rs )
- D e g r e e o f d e ta il
R e s e a rc h
Level
Appendix 91
11.2. References
[1] Al Maseid, H. R., Sinha, K. C., Analysis of Accident Reduction Potentials
of Pavement Markings, Journal of Transportation Engineering, Vol. 120,
Sept/Oct 1994, p. 723-36.
[2] Migletz, J., J.L. Graham, D.W. Harwood, K.M. Bauer, and P.L. Sterner,
Evaluation of All-Weather Pavement Markings, Federal Highway
Administration, McLean, Va., October 2000.
[3] Cotrell, B. H., Hanson, R. A., Determining the Effects of Pavement
Marking Materials, Final Report, Virginia Transportation Research
Council, VTRC 09-R1, Charlottesville, VA, February 2001.
[4] Safety and congestion Management Research and Advanced
Technology Applications; Research Work Order Number 1, Technical
Assistance to the RPM Task Force, Final Report to the PADOT, Orth-
Rodgers Associates, Inc., Research, August 1998.
[5] Fish, J. K., Evaluation of All-Weather Pavement Markings: Report on
Two Years of Progress, Paper presented in 1996 Semisesquicentennial
Transportation Conference Proceedings, Ames, IA, May 1996.
[6] Hills, B.L., Vision, Visibility and Driving Perception, 9, 183-216, 1980.
[7] Aktan, F., The Development of a Nighttime Driver Visibility Model,
Master Thesis, Thomas Schnell, Advisor, Operator Performance
Laboratory, Department of Industrial Engineering, The University of
Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa 52242-1527, Dec 2000.
[8] Aktan, F., Schnell, T., An Interactive Computer Model to determine the
Nighttime Visibility of Normal and UV Activated Pavement Markings
Under Normal and UV Headlamp Illumination, CIE Istanbul 2001
International Lighting Congress Vol. 1., p. 105-112, 12-14 September,
Istanbul, Turkey, 2001.
[9] Aktan, F., Schnell, T., TarVIP, A PC-Based Visibility Model for Normal
and Ultra-Violet Activated Pavement Markings, HFES 45th Annual
Meeting Proceedings, Minneapolis, Minnesota, October 8-12, 2001.
[10] Aktan, Fuat., Schnell, Thomas., The Development of a Nighttime Driver
Visibility Model for Ultra-Violet Activated Pavement Markings, PAL
2001 Conference Proceedings, Darmstadt University of Technology,
September 25/26, Darmstadt, Germany.
[11] NCHRP 4-29, Selection of Materials to Optimize Sign Performance,
working project, PI, Thomas Schnell, Expected Completion Date:
September 15, 2003.
[12] Schnell, T., Ohme, P. J., Evaluation of Various Strategies to Increase
Pavement Marking Visibility for Older Drivers, Proceedings of 81st
Annual Meeting of TRB, 13-17 January, 2002, Washington, D.C.
[13] Gates, T., Chrysler, S. T., Hawkins, H. G., Innovative Visibility-Based
Measures of Effectiveness for Wider Longitudinal Pavement Markings,
Proceedings of TRB Biennial Symposium on Visibility, Iowa City, IA, June
2-4, 2002.
Appendix 93
[26] Aktan, F., Schnell, T., Performance Evaluation of Pavement Markings
under Dry, Wet, and Rainy Conditions in the Field, Paper submitted for
Presentation at the 83rd Annual TRB Meeting, January 2004,
Washington, D.C.
[27] Goodrich, E.P., Traffic Engineering Reminiscences, Annual Meeting
Proceedings, ITE, Washington, D.C, 1971.
[28] Hawkins, H. Gene, Evolution of the US pavement Marking System,
Part of the Interim Report for the NCHRP 4-28: Feasibility Study for an
All-White Pavement Marking System, October 2000.
[29] Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Lee, Y. C., Wet-Weather Visibility of Pavement
Markings, Third Interim Report to the FHWA, March 2002.
[30] Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., Visibility of New Centerline and Edge
Line Pavement Markings, Transportation Research Record 1605,
Transportation Research Board, National Academy of Sciences,
Washington, DC., 1997.
[31] Schnell, T., Bentley, K., Hayes, E., and Rick, M., Legibility Distances of
Fluorescent Traffic Signs and Their Normal Color Counterparts,
Transportation Research Record 1754, Transportation Research Board,
National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2001.
[32] Blackwell, H.R., Contrast Thresholds of the Human Eye, Journal of the
Optical Society of America, 36(11): pg. 624-43, 1973.
[33] Blackwell, H.R., Blackwell, O.M., Individual Responses to Lighting
Parameters for a Population of 235 Observers of Varying Ages,
Illumination Engineering, 75, 1980.
[34] The International Commission on Illumination (CIE) Publication No. 95,
Technical Report Contrast and Visibility, 1992.
[35] The International Association of Lighthouse Authorities (IALA),
Recommendation for a Definition of the Nominal Daytime Range of
Maritime Signal Lights Intended for the Guidance of Shipping by Day,
April 1974.
[36] Schnell T., Merchant, S., Classification of Uniformly Spaced Surface
Colors into Thirteen US Traffic Sign Color Categories Under D65 and
Illuminant A Conditions, Paper Presented at the DfwG-Jahrestagung
2000, October 20, 2000, Technische Hochschule Darmstadt, Fachgebiet
Lichttechnik.
[37] Miller, T., J. Viner, S. Rossman, N. Pindus. W. Gellert, J. Douglass, A
Dillingham, and G. Blomquist, The Cost of Highway Crashes. Report
prepared by the Urban Institute for the Federal Highway
Administration, US DOT, Washington, DC, 1991.
[38] Persaud, B. N., Safety Migration, the Influence of Traffic Volumes, and
Other Issues in Evaluating Safety EffectivenessSome Findings on
Conversion of Intersection to Multiway Stop Control, Transportation
Research Record, 1068, pp. 108-114, 1986.
[39] Glennon, J. C., Accident Effects on Centerline Markings on Low-Volume
Rural Roads, Transportation Research Record, 1027, pp. 7-13, 1985.
Appendix 95
[53] ASTM Standard Specification D6628-01 Standard Specification for
Color of Pavement Marking Materials, ASTM, West Conshohocken, PA,
January 2001.
[54] Schnell, T.,"Legibility Optimization of Uppercase Alphanumeric Text
for Displaying Messages in Traffic Applications", 1998, Ph.D.
Dissertation, Department of Industrial and Manufacturing Systems
Engineering, Ohio University, Athens, Ohio 45701-2979, 471 pages.
[55] Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., Visual Detection and Recognition of
Fluorescent Color Targets Versus Non-fluorescent Color Targets as a
Function of Peripheral Viewing Angle and Target Size, Transportation
Research Record 1605, Transportation Research Board, National
Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC., 1997.
[56] Poynter D., Contrast Sensitivity and English Letter Recognition,
Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting,
September 2-6, San Francisco, CA, 1991
EDUCATION
B.S. Electrical Engineering, Institute of Technology of the State of Bern, Bern,
Switzerland, 1992
M.S. Industrial and Systems Engineering, Ohio University, 1994
Ph.D. Integrated Engineering, Ohio University, 1998
CURRENT POSITION
Assistant Professor, Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA
Director, Operator Performance Laboratory (OPL)
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Assistant Professor, Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Iowa, 1998
Present
Human Factors Consultant, Rockwell Collins, 6/01-Present
Research Engineer, Human Factors and Ergonomics Laboratory, Ohio University, 1994
1998
Research Associate, Human Factors and Ergonomics Laboratory, Ohio University, 1992
1993
Software consultant, APP Informatik AG, Bern, Switzerland, 19901992
Appendix 97
Software designer, ASCOM AG, Bern, Switzerland, 19881990
PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS
Chairman of the Roadsign Technical Committee (TC 4-38) of the International
Committee on Illumination (CIE) Division 4, Lighting and Signaling for Transport, 2/99
current
Member of the International Committee on Illumination (CIE) Division 1, Vision and
Color 12/98 - current
Member of the International Committee on Illumination (CIE) Division 4 Lighting and
Signaling for Transport, 12/98 current
Member of the Transportation Research Board Simulation and Measurement
Committee A3B06, 1997 present
Member of the Transportation Research Board Simulation and Measurement
Committee A3B06, 1997 present
Member of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 1992 present
Member of Iowa Traffic Control and Safety Association
AWARDS
1992 Ascom Prize, Award for the highest GPA and the best of class on 1992 in the
Department of Electrical Engineering of the Institute of Technology, Bern,
Switzerland, 1992
1999 Old Gold Summer Fellowship, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA
1999 3M Traffic Control Materials Division, Faculty Award
2001 Old Gold Summer Fellowship, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA
2002 Best paper of session and of Track, Authors: Sohel Merchant , Yongjin Kwon, Tom
Schnell, Tim Etherington, Tom Vogl, Evaluation Of Synthetic Vision Information
System (SVIS) Displays Based On Pilot Performance, In Proceedings of the 20th
Digital Avionics Systems Conference, October 14-18, Daytona Beach, 2001
CONSULTING
Airborne Human Factors Principal Investigator (PI) for Rockwell Collins during
NASA Test Flights in Boeing 757 Research Laboratory in Eagle Vail, Colorado, 2001
Design of an instrumented vehicle for Ohio University, Athens, Ohio 45701, 2000
Photometric Evaluation of a Tennis Court Lighting Installation in Iowa City, Dunlap
Court Residents, Iowa City, Iowa, 1999
Evaluation of the Influence of Car Following Glare on Driver Nighttime Visual
Performance with and without Night Driving Glasses, Prepared for SOLA
International Holdings Ltd., 1997
RESEARCH CONTRACTS
Appendix 99
Start End
Total
Sponsor Name Long Title Comments
Date Date
Costs
Oct- Sep-
$25,000 Rockwell Collins, Basic Human Factors In 100% PI
99 00 Inc. Aviation Research
Feb- Jan-
$10,000 Iowa State Synthetic Vision 100% PI
00 01 University,
Isgc/Nasa
Jul- Jun- $49,833 Ohio Department Of Evaluation Of Traffic Flow 100% PI
00 01 Transportation Analysis Tools Applied To
Workzones Based On Flow
Data Collected In The Field
Nov- Feb- $30,000 Rockwell Collins, Assessing Pilot Performance 100% PI
00 01 Inc. In Flightdecks Equipped
With Synthetic Vision
Information Systems
Jan- Dec- $49,950 Honda Research & Fun And Stress In Driving 50% PI with
01 01 Development John Lee
Americas, Inc.
Feb- Jan- $30,000 Iowa State Assessing Pilot Performance 100% PI
01 02 University, In Flightdecks Equipped
Isgc/Nasa With Synthetic Vision
Information Systems
Feb- Jun- $105,94 Virginia Polytechnic Enhanced Nighttime 100% Pi
01 02 2 Institute Visibility
Dec- Jul- $34,498 Honda Research & Human Machine Interfaces 50% Pi With
01 02 Development In Automotive Applications John Lee
Americas, Inc.
Dec- Mar- $71,357 Minnesota How To More Safely 100% Pi
01 04 Department Of Accommodate Pedestrians
Transportation Through An Intersection
With Free Flow Legs
Feb- Dec- $30,000 Iowa State Terrain Sampling Density 100% Pi
02 02 University, And Texture Requirements
Isgc/Nasa Of Synthetic Vision Systems
(Svs)
Feb- Jan- $30,000 Iowa State Synthetic Vision 100% Pi
02 03 University,
Isgc/Nasa
1. Schnell T., Kwon J., Merchant S., Etherington, T., Vogl, T., Improved Flight
Technical Performance in Flight Decks Equipped with Synthetic Vision
Information System Displays, In Press, International Journal of Aviation
Psychology, 2003
2. Schnell T., Aktan F., Lee Y., Nighttime Visibility and Retroreflectance of
Pavement Markings under Dry, Wet, and Rainy Conditions, In Press,
Transportation Research Record 1824, Transportation Research Board,
National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2003
3. Zwahlen, H.T., Russ A., Schnell T., Driver Eye Scanning Behavior While
Viewing Ground-Mounted Diagrammatic Guide Signs before Entrance Ramps
at Night, In Press, Transportation Research Record 1843, Transportation
Research Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2003
4. Zwahlen, H.T., Russ A., Roth J., Schnell T., Evaluation of the Effectiveness of
Ground-Mounted Diagrammatic Advance Guide Signs For Freeway Entrance
Ramps, In Press, Transportation Research Record 1843, Transportation
Research Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2003
Appendix 101
5. Schnell T., Lee Y., Etherington, T., Synthetic Vision Information Systems,
NASA Flight Tests at Eagle County Regional Airport, Submitted for review to
the International Journal of Aviation Psychology, August 2003
6. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Lee, Y., "Driver Looking Behavior in, School Zones with
Fluorescent Yellow Green and Normal Yellow Signs", In review, Journal of
Safety Research, April, 2003.
7. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Ohme, P. J., and Yang, S., "Various Strategies to Increase
Pavement Marking Visibility for Older Drivers", in review, Journal of Safety
Research, April, 2003.
8. Aktan, F., Schnell, T., "Performance Evaluation of Pavement Markings under
Dry, Wet, and Rainy Conditions in the Field", Paper submitted for Presentation
at the 83rd Annual TRB Meeting, January 2004, and for review for publication
in Transportation Research Record, Washington, D.C., 2004
9. Aktan, F., Schnell, T., "Performance Evaluation of Pavement Markings under
Dry, Wet, and Rainy Conditions in the Field", Paper submitted for Presentation
at the 83rd Annual TRB Meeting, January 2004, and for review for publication
in Transportation Research Record, Washington, D.C., 2004
10. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Li, C., "Traffic Sign Luminance Requirements of
Nighttime Drivers for Symbolic Signs", Paper Submitted for Presentation at the
83rd Annual TRB Meeting, January 2004 and for review for publication in
Transportation Research Record, Washington, D.C.
11. Schnell T., Mohror, J., Aktan F., Evaluation Of Traffic Flow Analysis Tools
Applied To Work Zones Based On Flow Data Collected In The Field,
Transportation Research Record 1811, Transportation Research Board,
National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2002
12. Zwahlen, HT, Schnell, T, Donahue T, Hodson N, Johnson N, Influence of
Pavement Marking Angular Systems on Visibility Predictions Using Computer
Models, Transportation Research Record 1754, Transportation Research
Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2001
13. Schnell, T., Bentley, K., Hayes, E., and Rick, M., Legibility Distances of
Fluorescent Traffic Signs and Their Normal Color Counterparts,
Transportation Research Record 1754, Transportation Research Board,
National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2001
14. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., McGehee, D.V., Dvorak, M., Hunt, J., Reyes, A., Sorak, D.,
Pedestrian Visibility under Automobile Lowbeam Headlight Illumination, with
and without Headlight Covers, Transportation Research Record 1773,
Transportation Research Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington,
DC, 2001
15. Schnell, T., and Zwahlen, H.T., Computer Based Modeling to Determine the
Visibility and Retroreflectivity of Pavement Markings", 79th Annual Meeting of
the Transportation Research Board, Transportation Research Board, National
Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, Transportation Research Record 1708,
2000
16. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Minimum In-Service Retroreflectivity of
Pavement Markings", 79th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research
Board, Transportation Research Board, National Academy of Sciences,
Washington, DC, Preprint 001479, Transportation Research Record 1715, 2000
17. Allen, R.W., Francher, P.S., Levison, W.H.., Machey, J., Mourant, R.R., Schnell,
T., Srinivasan, R., Simulation and Measurement of Driver and Vehicle
Performance, Transportation in the new Millennium, Research Board,
National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC., 2000
18. Schnell, T., and Zwahlen, H.T., Driver Preview Distances at Night Based on
Driver Eye Scanning Recordings as a Function of Pavement Marking
Retroreflectivities, Transportation Research Record 1692, Transportation
Research Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC., 1999
Appendix 103
Nighttime Driving Conditions, Preprint 950994, Transportation Research
Record 1495, Transportation Research Board, National Academy of Sciences,
Washington, DC, 1995
33. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., Loss of Visibility Distance Due to Automobile
Windshields at Night, Transportation Research Record 1495, Transportation
Research Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 1995, pp.
128-139
34. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., Visibility of New Pavement Markings at Night
Under Low Beam Illumination, Preprint 940840, Transportation Research
Record 1495, Transportation Research Board, National Academy of Sciences,
Washington, DC, 1995
35. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., A Knowledge Based, PC Software Package for
the Application and Placement of Curve Delineation Devices, Preprint 940789,
Transportation Research Record 1495, Transportation Research Board,
National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 1995, pp. 107-116.
Appendix 105
23. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Nighttime Photometric Measurements of
Different Crossbuck Reflectorization Designs under Automobile Illumination at
Night", Proceedings of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering, 1998 Annual
Conference,2nd Transportation Specialty Conference, Operation and Safety, 4c,
1998 , pp. 149-163.
24. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Driver Risk Taking Behavior at Passive Railroad
Highway Grade Crossings as a Function of Different Crossbuck Designs",
Proceedings of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering, 1998 Annual
Conference,2nd Transportation Specialty Conference, Operation and Safety, 4c,
1998 , pp. 133-147.
25. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Advances in Passive Railroad-Highway Grade
Crossing Protection: The Photometric Performance of the Buckeye Crossbuck",
Proceedings of the Fifth International Symposium on Railroad-Highway Grade
Crossing Research and Safety, University of Tennessee Transportation Center
and Southeastern Transportation Center, 1998.
26. Wentz, C., and Schnell, T., "Human Factors Considerations of Aircraft Displays",
Proceedings of the Advances in Aviation Safety Conference, SAE Aerospace,
Society of Automotive Engineers, SAE Aerospace, 1, 1998.
27. Schnell, T., and Zwahlen, H. T., "Accident Trends at Railroad-Highway Grade
Crossings in Ohio", Proceedings of the Fifth International Symposium on
Railroad-Highway Grade Crossing Research and Safety, University of Tennessee
Transportation Center and Southeastern Transportation Center, 1998.
28. Schnell, T., and Zwahlen, H. T., "Driver Risk Taking Behavior Measurements at
Passive Railroad-Highway Grade Crossings Equipped With New Crossbuck
Designs", Proceedings of the Fifth International Symposium on Railroad-
Highway Grade Crossing Research and Safety, University of Tennessee
Transportation Center and Southeastern Transportation Center, In print, 1998.
29. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Field Evaluation of Crossbuck Designs for
Passive Railroad Crossings using Violations and Near Collisions Recorded with
a Train Borne Video Recording System", Proceedings of the Fourth
International Symposium on Railroad Highway Grade Crossing Research and
Safety, University of Tennessee Transportation Center and Southeastern
Transportation Center, Vol. 1, 1997, pp. 297-319.
30. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Target Visibility During Civil Twilight",
Proceedings of the Symposium on Vision at Low Light Levels, Photopic,
Mesopic, and Scotopic Vision, EPRI Lighting Research Office, Vol. 1, 1997 , pp.
171-196.
31. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Superior Traffic Sign, Pedestrian, Bicycle and
Construction Worker Conspicuity Through the Use of Retro-Reflective
Fluorescent Color Materials", Proceedings of the 13th Triennial Congress of the
International Ergonomics Association, International Ergonomics Association,
Vol. 6, 1997.
32. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Visibility of Pavement Markings at Night",
Proceedings of the 13th Triennial Congress of the International Ergonomics
Association, Vol. 6, 1997, pp. 445-447.
33. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Superior Traffic Sign, Pedestrian, Bicycle and
Construction Worker Conspicuity Through the Use of Retro-Reflective
Fluorescent Color Materials", Proceedings of the Triennial Congress of the
International Ergonomics Association, 1997.
34. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Visibility of Yellow Center Line Pavement
Markings as a Function of Line Configuration and Line Width", Proceedings of
the 40th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Human
Factors and Ergonomics Society, Vol. 2, 1996, pp. 919-922.
35. Zwahlen, H. T., Pracharktam, T., and Schnell, T., "A Method to Assign Weights of
Importance to Design Requirements in Human-Machine Systems Design",
Appendix 107
1. Schnell, T., Lemos, K., Keller, M., Yang, S., Synthetic Vision Systems, Optimum
Display Characteristics, Final Report, NASA Langley Research Center, Aviation
Safety Program, Hampton, VA, 2003
2. Schnell T., Aktan F., Lee Yi-Ching, Wet Weather Visibility of Pavement
Markings, Final Report, FHWA Number Assignment Pending, Federal Highway
Administration, Turner-Fairbank Highway Research Center, McLean, VA, 2003
3. Schnell, T., Lemos K., Terrain Sampling Density and Texture Requirements for
Synthetic Vision Systems, Final Report, Submitted to Rockwell Collins
Advanced Technology Center, 400 Collins Rd. NE, Cedar Rapids, IA 52498, 2003
4. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Ohme, P., Hogsett, J. Enhancing Pavement Marking
Visibility for Older Drivers, Final Report submitted to the Iowa Department of
Transportation, 800 Lincoln Way, Ames, Iowa 50010, 2003
5. Rockwell Collins SVIS Team, Synthetic Vision Information System Report of
Test at Eagle County Regional Airport, NASA SVS Phase II final Report,
January 31, 2002, Rockwell Collins, Cedar Rapids, Iowa
6. Zwahlen, HT, Schnell, T, Evaluation Of Ground Mounted Diagrammatic
Entrance Ramp Approach Signs, FHWA/OH-2000/018, Final Technical Report,
Ohio Department of Transportation
7. Schnell T., Aktan F., Mohror J., Evaluation Of Traffic Flow Analysis Tools Applied
To Work Zones Based On Flow Data Collected In The Field, Final Report
FHWA/HWA-2001/08, Ohio Department of Transportation
8. Schnell T., Merchant S., Kwon, Y., Assessing Pilot Performance in Flight Decks
Equipped with Synthetic Vision Information Systems, Rockwell Collins
Advanced Technology Center Final Report, Cedar Rapids, Iowa, 2001
9. Schnell, T., "Legibility Optimization of Uppercase Alphanumeric Text for
Displaying Messages in Traffic Applications", 1998, Ph.D. Dissertation,
Department of Industrial and Manufacturing Systems Engineering, Ohio
University, Athens, Ohio 45701-2979, 471 pages.
10. Zwahlen, H. T., and Schnell, T., "Evaluation of Temporary Pavement Marking
Systems for Resurfacing Zones", July 1996, Final Report FHWA/OH-96/015,
Prepared for Ohio Department of Transportation in Cooperation with US DOT,
Columbus, Ohio.
11. Schnell, T., "The Development of a PC Based Pavement Marking Visibility
Evaluation Model", 1994, Master Thesis, Department of Industrial Engineering,
Ohio University, Athens, Ohio 45701-2979, 189 pages.
12. Schnell, T., "Expertensystem fuer Serielle Kommunikation (Expert System for
Serial Communication)", 1992, Diploma Project, Department of Electrical
Engineering, Institute of Technology of the State of Bern, Bern, Switzerland,
225 pages.
EDUCATION
2000-2003 The University of Iowa Iowa City, IA
Ph.D., Industrial Engineering. (GPA: 3.90)
Dissertation Topic: Assessment of Modeling of the Glare Induced by Tungsten-Halogen
and High-Intensity Gas Discharge Headlamps.
1998-2000 The University of Iowa Iowa City, IA
M.S., Industrial Engineering. (GPA: 3.90)
Thesis Subject: A Nighttime Driver Visibility Model for Ultra-Violet Activated Pavement
Markings and Ultra-Violet Headlamps.
1997-1998 Ataturk University, Erzurum, Turkey
MBA, School of Business and Economics. - Suspended
1992-1997 Bogazici University Istanbul, Turkey
B.S., Industrial Engineering.
Honors Thesis: Image Processing and Object Recognition for Production Facility
Conveyor Belts using High Order Polynomial Approximations
1989-1992 Istanbul High School of Science Istanbul, Turkey
3-year high school education, emphasis on Mathematics and Physics.
RESEARCH CONTRACTS
Sept 02-May03, Pavement Marking Visibility Performance under Dry, Wet, and Rainy
Conditions in the Field, 3M, $15,000.
Sept 03-Feb 05, Development of a "Fixed Roadway Lighting Module" for the Target
Visibility Predictor (TarVIP) Computer Model $145,718, 50% PI with Thomas Schnell.
Appendix 109
SCIENTIFIC AND PROFESSIONAL SOCIETIES
Member of the Roadsigns Technical Committee (TC 4-38) of the International Committee on
Illumination (CIE) Division 4, Lighting and Signaling for Transport, 02/01
present.
Member of Transportation Research Board (TRB) Committee on Marking and Signing
Materials (A3C12), 01/02 present.
Member of Transportation Research Board (TRB) Committee on Vehicle User
Characteristics (A3B02), 2002 present.
Member of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 1999 present
1. Member of National Alpha-Pi-Mu Industrial Engineering Honor Society, 2000
present.
1. Schnell T., Aktan F., Lee Y., Nighttime Visibility and Retroreflectance of
Pavement Markings under Dry, Wet, and Rainy Conditions, In Press,
Transportation Research Record 1824, Transportation Research Board, National
Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2003
2. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Lee, Y., "Driver Looking Behavior in, School Zones with
Fluorescent Yellow Green and Normal Yellow Signs", In review, Journal of Safety
Research, April, 2003.
3. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Ohme, P. J., and Yang, S., "Various Strategies to Increase
Pavement Marking Visibility for Older Drivers", in review, Journal of Safety
Research, April, 2003.
4. Aktan, F., Schnell, T., "Performance Evaluation of Pavement Markings under Dry,
Wet, and Rainy Conditions in the Field", Paper submitted for Presentation at the
83rd Annual TRB Meeting, January 2004, and for review for publication in
Transportation Research Record, Washington, D.C., 2004
5. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., Li, C., "Traffic Sign Luminance Requirements of Nighttime
Drivers for Symbolic Signs", Paper Submitted for Presentation at the 83rd
Annual TRB Meeting, January 2004 and for review for publication in
Transportation Research Record, Washington, D.C.
6. Schnell T., Mohror, J., Aktan F., Evaluation Of Traffic Flow Analysis Tools
Applied To Work Zones Based On Flow Data Collected In The Field,
Transportation Research Record 1811, Transportation Research Board, National
Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 2002
7. Schnell, T., Aktan, F., McGehee, D.V., Dvorak, M., Hunt, J., Reyes, A., Sorak, D.,
Pedestrian Visibility under Automobile Lowbeam Headlight Illumination, with
and without Headlight Covers, Transportation Research Record 1773,
Transportation Research Board, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC,
2001
1. Aktan F., Schnell T., Li C., A Theoretical Approach For The Derivation Of
Legibility Threshold Luminance Contrast Data For Road Sign Applications, in
Proceedings of the 16th Biennial Symposium on Visibility and Simulation, June 2-4,
2002, Iowa City, Iowa
2. Aktan F., Schnell T., A Web-Based Legibility Threshold And Road Sign
Luminance Contrast Calculator For Nighttime Driving Conditions, in Proceedings
SELECTED PRESENTATIONS
1. Human Factors Research at the OPL, Driving Simulator Symposium,
SC, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, October 18, 2001.
2. Shedding Light on Visibility Models, TRB 81st Annual Meeting, W-8
Workshop, Washington DC, Jan 12, 2002.
3. Modeling the Visibility of Roadway Objects under Automobile Headlamp
Illumination and Glare, Graduate Seminar of Industrial and Mechanical
Engineering Department, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, March 14, 2002.
Appendix 111
PIETER POOLMAN, PH.D.
POST DOCTORAL RESEARCHER
Post Doctoral Researcher, Operator Performance Laboratory (OPL)
234 Engineering Research Facility
University of Iowa
Iowa City, IA 52242-1527
Office phone: (319) 384-0572; Office FAX (319) 335-5424
E-mail: ppoolman@ccad.uiowa.edu
EDUCATION
B.Eng Civil Engineering, University of Stellenbosch, South Africa, 1996
M.Eng Traffic Engineering, University of Stellenbosch, 1998
Ph.D. Traffic Engineering, University of Stellenbosch, 2003
CURRENT POSITION
Post Doctoral Researcher, Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Iowa
EXPERIENCE
Research Assistant, Institute of Transportation Technology, University of Stellenbosch ,
199706/1998
Research Engineer, Center of Transportation Research, University of Texas, 07/1998-1999
Research Engineer, Institute of Transportation Technology, University of Stellenbosch ,
20002002
AWARDS
1996 ECSA (Engineering Council of South Africa) Medal for Best B.Eng Graduand by
Merit at University of Stellenbosch
1996 ESCOM Prize for Best B.Eng Graduand by Merit in South Africa
1997 NRF (National Research Foundation South Africa) Fellowship for Master's studies
1998 H.L. Reitz Medal for Best Graduate Student in Civil Engineering at University of
Stellenbosch
1999 IRF (International Road Federation) Fellowship for Exchange Program at
University of Texas at Austin
1999 NRF (National Research Foundation South Africa) Fellowship for PhD studies
2003 NRF (National Research Foundation South Africa) Fellowship for Post Doctoral
studies
PUBLICATIONS
1. Poolman, P.; Bester, C.J. (2000). Towards a New Approach for the Design of the
Alignment of Highways and Railroads. Proceedings of the 2nd International
Symposium on Highway Geometric Design in Mainz, Germany.
2. Machemehl, R.B.; Rioux, T.W.; Tsyganov, A.; Poolman, P. (2001). Freeway
Operational Flexibility Concepts. Project Summary Report 1844-S, University of
Texas, Austin, TX.
3. Hugo, F.; Poolman, P. (2001). A Critical Analysis of WesTrack MMLS3 and Truck
Rut Data. Appendix A in FHWA/TX-01/2134-1, Texas Department of
Transportation, Austin, TX.
Appendix 113
Frank L. Schmidt
Professor, Department of Management and Organizations
College of Business-University of Iowa
Iowa City, Iowa 52242
Office phone: (319) 335 0949; Office FAX: 319:335-1956
E-mail: frank-schmidt@uiowa.edu
EDUCATION
SPECIAL INTERESTS
Personnel testing, selection, and placement; relation of selection and other personnel
programs to workforce productivity and output; abilities, aptitudes and personality traits;
integrity testing; performance testing; statistical issues in validation research; validity
generalization in employment testing; statistical and other methods for integrating
research findings across studies; meta-analysis; test theory; racial problems and
differences in the workplace; sex differences in occupationally relevant traits; computer
simulation of psychometric problems; application of learning principles in industrial
settings; role of experience in job performance; causal models and theories of job
performance.
Appendix 115
Member, Academy of Management, Heneman Career Award Committee, 2000-Present.
Member, American Psychological Association Awards Committee, 1997-1999; Chair 1999-
2000.
Science Liaison to the American Psychological Association for Division 5 of APA.
Member, Society for Multivariate Experimental Psychology. Elected to membership, 1995.
Member, James McKeen Cattell Fellow Award Committee, American Psychological Society,
1994-1995.
President, Division of Measurement, Statistics, and Evaluation (Division 5 of the American
Psychological Association), 1993-1994.
Secretary-Treasurer, Scientist-Practitioner Coalition of APA Council of
Representatives, 1984.
Division 14 Representative to APA Council of Representatives, 1983-1986.
Member, Division 14 ad hoc committee on Innovations in Methodology, 1979-1981.
Member, Division 14 Committee to revise Principles for Employee Selection,
1978-1980.
Member, Division 14 Executive Committee and Long Range Planning Committee, 1979-
1982.
Member, Division 14 Program Committee, 1977-1978 and 1978-1979.
Member, Division 14 Committee on Committees, 1976-1977.
Society for Organizational Behavior (1976-1983; 1986 to present); Member, Board of
Directors, 1992-1995.
President (1975), Midwestern Society of Multivariate Experimental Psychologists.
Academy of Management
American Psychological Association
Division 14 (Fellow)
Division 5 (Fellow)
American Psychological Society (Charter Fellow)
Sigma Xi
1. Ones, D.S., Viswesvaran, C., & Schmidt, F.L. (2003). Personality and absenteeism: A
meta-analysis. European Journal of Personality, 17, 19 38.
2. Schmidt, F.L., Le, H., & Ilies, R. (in press). Beyond Alpha: An empirical examination
Appendix 117
Publishers, 3-14.
21. Judiesch, M. K., & Schmidt, F. L. (2000). Between worker variability in output under
piece-rate versus hourly pay systems. Journal of Business and Psychology, 14, 529-
552.
22. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (2000). Racial and gender bias in ability and
achievement tests: Resolving the apparent paradox. Psychology, Public Policy, and
Law, 6, 151 158.
23. Gardner, S., Frantz, R. A., & Schmidt, F. L. (1999). The effect of electrical
stimulation on chronic wound healing: A meta-analysis. Nursing Research, 7, 495-
503.
24. Carlson, K. D., Scullen, S. E., Schmidt, F. L., Rothstein, H. R., & Erwin, F. (1999).
Generalizable biographical data validity: Is multi-organizational development and
keying necessary? Personnel Psychology, 52, 731-756.
25. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1999). Comparison of three meta-analysis methods
revisited: An analysis of Johnson, Mullen, and Salas (1995). Journal of Applied
Psychology, 84, 144-148.
26. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1999). Bias in standardized educational and
employment tests as justification for racial preferences in affirmative action
programs. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility, 17, 285-302.
27. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1999). Theory testing and measurement error.
Intelligence, 27, 183-198.
28. Schmidt, F. L., & Radar, M. (1999). Exploring the boundary conditions for interview
validity: Meta-analytic validity findings for a new interview type. Personnel
Psychology, 52, 445-464.
29. Carlson, K. D., & Schmidt, F. L. (1999). Impact of experimental design on effect size:
Findings from the research literature on training. Journal of Applied Psychology, 84,
851-862.
30. Schmidt, F. L. (1998). Validity generalization. In C. L. Cooper, & C. Argyris (Eds.),
Encyclopedia of management. London: Blackwell Publishers, 677-678.
31. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1998). The validity and utility of selection methods in
personnel psychology: Practical and theoretical implications of 85 years of research
findings. Psychological Bulletin, 124, 262-274.
32. Collins, J. M., & Schmidt, F. L. (1997). Can suppressor variables enhance criterion-
related validity in the personality domain? Educational and Psychological
Measurement, 57, 924-936.
33. Schmidt, F.L., Viswesvaran, V., & Ones, D.S. (1997). Validity of integrity tests for
predicting drug and alcohol abuse. Research Monograph Series (National Institute
on Drug Abuse), 170, 69 96.
34. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J.E. (1997). Eight common but false objections to the
discontinuation of statistical significance testing. In L. Harlow, S. Mulaik, & J.
Steiger (Eds.), What if there were no signficance tests? Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence
Erlbaum Associates.
35. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1997). Measurable personnel characteristics:
Stability, variability, and validity for predicting future job performance and job
related learning. In M. Kleinmann, & Bernd Strauss (Eds.), Instruments for potential
assessment and personnel development. Gottingen, Germany: Hogrefe. (This
chapter is in German.)
36. Schmidt, F. L. (1997). Validity generalization. In L. Peters, L. Youngblood, & R. Greer
(Eds.), Dictionary of human resource management (pp. 381-382). Maldon, MA:
Blackwell Publishers.
37. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1996). Intelligence and job performance: Economic
and social implications. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2, 447-472.
38. Judiesch, M. K., Schmidt, F. L., & Mount, M. K. (1996). An improved method for
estimating selection utility. Journal of Human Resource Costing and Accounting, 1,
31-42.
Appendix 119
general mental ability, and job knowledge. Current Directions in Psychological
Science, 2, 8-9.
59. Collins, J. M., & Schmidt, F. L. (1993). Personality, integrity, and white collar
criminality. Personnel Psychology, 46, 295-311.
60. Ones, D. S., Viswesvaran, C., & Schmidt, F. L. (1993). Meta-analysis of integrity test
validities: Findings and implications for personnel selection and theories of job
performance. Journal of Applied Psychology Monograph, 78, 679-703.
61. Schmidt, F. L., Law, K., Hunter, J. E., Rothstein, H. R., Pearlman, K., & McDaniel, M.
(1993). Refinements in validity generalization methods: Implications for the
situational specificity hypothesis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 78, 3-13.
62. Judiesch, M. K., Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1993). The judgment problem in
utility analysis remains unsolved. Journal of Applied Psychology, 78, 903-911.
63. Schmidt, F. L. (1993). Personnel psychology at the cutting edge. Chapter in N.
Schmitt, & W. Borman (Eds.), Personnel selection. San Francisco: Jossey Bass, 497-
515.
64. Judiesch, M. K., Schmidt, F. L., & Mount, M. K. (1992). Estimates of the dollar value
of job performance in utility analysis: An empirical test of two theories. Journal of
Applied Psychology, 77, 234-250.
65. Viswesvaran, C., & Schmidt, F. L. (1992). Meta-analytic comparisons of the
effectiveness of smoking cessation methods. Journal of Applied Psychology, 77, 554-
561.
66. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1992). Development of causal models of processes
determining job performance. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 1, 89-92.
67. Schmidt, F. L. (1992). What do data really mean? Research findings, meta-analysis,
and cumulative knowledge in psychology. American Psychologist, 47, 1173-1181.
68. Schmidt, F. L., Ones, D., & Hunter, J. E. (1992). Personnel selection. Annual Review
of Psychology, 43, 627-670 (43 pages).
69. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1991). Employment testing: Old theories and new
research findings. In Cary L. Cooper (Ed.), Industrial and organizational psychology
- Volume I. Hants, England: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. (Reprinted from
earlier journal article.)
70. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1991). Development of a general solution to the
problem of validity generalization. In Cary L. Cooper (Ed.), Industrial and
organizational psychology - Volume I. Hants, England: Edward Elgar Publishing
Limited. (Reprinted from earlier journal article.)
71. Schmidt, F. L., Hunter, J. E., McKenzie, R. C., & Muldrow, T. W. (1991). Impact of
valid selection procedures on work force productivity. In Cary L. Cooper (Ed.),
Industrial and organizational psychology - Volume I. Hants, England: Edward Elgar
Publishing Limited. (Reprinted from earlier journal article.)
72. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1991). Fairness and bias in job testing. Issues in
Science and Technology, 7, 1, 27.
73. Schmidt, F. L. (1991). Why all banding procedures in personnel selection are
logically flawed. Human Performance, 4, 265-278.
74. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1991). Meta-analysis. In R. K. Hambleton, & J. N. Zaal
(Eds.), Advances in educational and psychological testing: Theory and applications.
Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
75. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1990). Meta-analysis: Facts and theories. In M.
Smith, & I. Robertson (Eds.), Advances in personnel selection and assessment.
Chichester, England: Wiley (pp. 203-216).
76. Rothstein, H. R., Schmidt, F. L., Erwin, F. W., Owens, W. A., & Sparks, C. P. (1990).
Biographical data in employment selection: Can validities be made generalizable?
Journal of Applied Psychology, 75, 175-184.
77. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1990). Dichotomization of continuous variables: The
implications for meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 75, 334-349.
78. Hunter, J. E., Schmidt, F. L., & Judiesch, M. K. (1990). Individual differences in
Appendix 121
98. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1984). A within-setting test of the situational
specificity hypothesis in personnel selection. Personnel Psychology, 37, 317-326.
99. Schmidt, F. L., Mack, M. J., & Hunter, J. E. (1984). Selection utility in the occupation
of U.S. Park Ranger for three modes of test use. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69,
490-497.
100. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (in press). The impact of job selection methods on
workforce productivity: The firm and the economy. Chapter to appear in R. H.
Franke (Ed.), The science of productivity. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, Inc.
101. Hunter, J. E., Schmidt, F. L., & Rauschenberger, J. (1984). Methodological and
statistical issues in the study of bias in mental testing. In C. R. Reynolds, & R. T.
Brown (Eds.), Perspectives on bias in mental testing, New York: Plenum Press.
102. Schmidt, F. L., Hunter, J. E., Croll, P. R., & McKenzie, R. C. (1983). Estimation of
employment test validities by expert judgment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 68,
590-601.
103. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1983). Individual differences in productivity: An
empirical test of estimates derived from studies of selection procedure utility.
Journal of Applied Psychology, 68, 407-415.
104. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1982). Quantifying the effects of psychological
interventions on employee job performance and work force productivity. American
Psychologist, 38, 473-478.
105. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt, F. L. (1982). Ability tests: Economic benefits versus the
issue of fairness. Industrial Relations, 21, (3), 293-308.
106. Hunter, J.E., Schmidt, F. L., & Pearlman, K. (1982). The history and accuracy of
validity generalization equations: A response to the Callender and Osburn reply.
Journal of Applied Psychology, 67, 853-858.
107. Hunter, J. E., & Schmidt F. L. (1982). Fitting people to jobs: Implications of
personnel selection for national productivity. In E. A. Fleishman and M. D. Dunnette
(Eds.) Human performance and productivity. Volume I: Human capability
assessment (233-284). Hillsdale, NJ: Earlbaum.
108. Schmidt, F. L., Hunter, J. E., & Pearlman, K. (1982). Progress in validity
generalization: Comments on Callender and Osburn and further development.
Journal of Applied Psychology, 67, 835-845.
109. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1982). Two pitfalls in assessing fairness of selection
tests using the regression model. Personnel Psychology, 35, 601-607.
110. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1982). The money test. Across the Board, The
Conference Board Magazine, 19, 7, 35-38. (Also in L. N. Jewell (Ed.), Industrial
organizational psychology for the eighties, West Publishing Co., in press.)
111. Schmidt, F. L., Hunter, J. E., & Pearlman, K. (1982). Assessing the economic impact
of personnel programs on workforce productivity. Personnel Psychology, 35, 333-
347. (Also in R. S. Schuler and S. A. Youngblood (Eds.), Personnel and human
resource management, New York: West Publishing Co., 1984).
112. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1981, Summer). New research findings in personnel
selection: Myths meet realities in the 1980's. Management Magazine, 23-27.
113. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1981). Employment testing: Old theories and new
research findings. American Psychologist, 36, 1128-1137. (Special Issue on Testing)
(Also in Readings in professional personnel assessment. Washington, D.C.: The
International Personnel Management Association, in press.; in Rynes & Milkovich
(Eds.), Readings in industrial relations, in press; and in C. E. Schneider, R. W. Beatty,
& G. M. McEvoy (Eds.), Personnel/human resource management today, 2nd Ed.
Addison-Wesley Co., in press).
114. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1981). New research findings in personnel selection:
Myths meet realities in the 1980's. Public personnel administration: Policies and
procedures for personnel (431-434). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. (Also in R.
S. Schuler and S. A. Youngblood (Eds.), Personnel and human resource
management, New York: West Publishing Co., 1984.)
Appendix 123
1071.
137. Hunter, J. E., Schmidt, F. L., & Raushenberger, J. (1977). Fairness of psychological
tests: Implications of three definitions for selection utility and minority hiring.
Journal of Applied Psychology, 62, 245-260.
138. Hansen, E. A., Schmidt, F. L., & Hansen, J. C. (1976). A model for the correction for
guessing on multiple choice tests. SIGSOC Bulletin, 7, 24-28.
139. Schmidt, F. L., Hunter, J. E., & Urry, V. W. (1976). Statistical power in criterion-
related validation studies. Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, 473-485.
140. Schmidt, F. L., & Wilson, T. (1975). Expectancy-value models of attitude
measurement: A problem. Journal of Marketing Research, 12, 366-368.
141. Forbes, T. W., Schmidt, F. L., Nolan, R. O., & Vanosdall, F. E. (1975). Driver
performance measurement based on dynamic driver behavior patterns in rural,
urban, suburban, and freeway traffic. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 7, 257-280.
142. Forbes, T. W., Schmidt, F. L., Nolan, R. O., & Vanosdall, F. E. (1974, Winter). Driver
performance measurement research. Transportation Research News, 57, 16-17.
143. Schmidt, F. L., Marshall, R. L., & Johnson, R. H. (1974). Policy capturing as an
approach to graduate admissions decision making: Gains in utility from
subgrouping, utility estimation, and an unexpected technical problem. Journal
Supplement Abstract Service, 4, 92. (Abstract only; full paper available from JSAS.)
144. Schmidt, F. L. (1974). Probability and utility assumptions underlying use of the
Strong Vocational Interest Blank. Journal of Applied Psychology, 59, 456-464.
145. Schmidt, F. L., & Hunter, J. E. (1974). Ethnic and racial bias in psychological tests:
Divergent implications of two definitions of test bias. American Psychologist, 29, 1-8.
146. Schmidt, F. L., & Crano, W. D. (1974). A test of the theory of fluid and crystallized
intelligence in middle and low SES school children. Journal of Educational
Psychology, 66, 255-261.
147. Schmidt, F. L. (1973). Implications of a measurement problem for expectancy theory
research. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 10, 243-251.
148. Schmidt, F. L., Berner, J. G., & Hunter, J. E. (1973). Racial differences in validity of
employment tests: Reality or illusion? Journal of Applied Psychology, 58, 5-9. (Also
in D. L. Ford (Ed.), Readings in minority group relations, University Associates,
1974.)
149. Schmidt, F. L., & Hoffman, B. (1973). An empirical comparison of three methods of
assessing the utility of a selection device. Journal of Industrial and Organizational
Psychology, 1, 14-23. (Also in W. C. Hamner & F. L. Schmidt (Eds.), Contemporary
problems in personnel, St. Clair Press, 1974.)
150. Schmidt, F. L., & Johnson, R. H. (1973). The effect of race on peer ratings in an
industrial situation. Journal of Applied Psychology, 57, 237-241. (Also in D. L. Ford
(Ed.), Readings in minority group relations, University Associates, 1974.)
151. Schmidt, F. L. (1972). The reliability of differences between linear regression
weights in applied differential psychology. Educational and Psychological
Measurement, 32, 879-886.
152. Schmidt, F. L. (1971). The relative efficiency of regression and simple unit predictor
weights in applied differential psychology. Educational and Psychological
Measurement, 31, 699-714.
153. Schmidt, F. L., & Kaplan, L. B. (1971, Fall). Composite vs. multiple criteria: A review
and resolution of the controversy. Personnel Psychology, 24, 419-434. (Also in A.
Bass & E. Fleishman (Eds.), Studies in industrial and organizational psychology,
Dorsey, 1974; and in K. M. Wexley & G. A. Yukl (Eds.), Readings in organizational
and industrial psychology, Oxford University Press, 1974.)
154. Schmidt, F. L., Owens, W. A., & Tiffin, J. (1971). Correlates of student attendance at
cultural events. Journal of College Student Personnel, 52, 41-43.
155. Schmidt, F. L., & Tiffin, J. (1969). Distortion of drivers' estimates of automobile
speed as a function of speed adaptation. Journal of Applied Psychology, 53, 536-539.
Appendix 125
40. Effectiveness of smoking cessation methods.
41. Effects of met expectations on newcomer attitudes.
42. Rater-ratee race effects on performance evaluation.
43. Comparison of different job satisfaction scales.
44. Impact of management by objectives on organizational productivity.
45. Job and life satisfaction.
46. Gender differences in occupational stress.
47. Work sample tests of trainability.
48. Employee age and job performance.
49. Unemployment, job satisfaction, and employee turnover.
50. The validity of assessment centers.
51. Task complexity as a moderator of goal effects.
52. The effects of goal setting on work performance.
53. Relation between personality traits and leadership perceptions.
54. Effectiveness of managerial training methods.
55. Turnover and communication networks.
56. Evaluation of realistic job previews.
57. Evaluation of methods of reducing job turnover.
58. Relation of job characteristics and turnover.
59. Relation between behavioral intentions and employee turnover.
60. Back pain and absence from work.
61. The value of corporate-wide training.
62. Predictors on organizational citizenship behavior.
63. Relation between objective and subjective measures of job performance.
64. Relation between work experience and job performance (3 studies).
65. Age and job turnover.
66. Validity of isometric strength tests.
67. Job satisfaction, organizational commitment, turnover intentions, and turnover.
68. Personality traits and job performance (4 studies).
69. Effects of OD interventions on job satisfaction.
70. Validity of evaluations of training and experience.
71. Relations among supervisory, peer, and self ratings of job performance (3 studies).
72. Evaluation of the Job Characteristics Model.
73. Effects of feedback on job performance.
74. Correlates of job involvement.
75. Equivalence of computerized and paper-and-pencil employment tests.
76. Correlates of organizational commitment.
77. Relation between negative mood and employee helping behavior.
78. Validity of alternative predictors of job performance.
EDUCATION
B.A. Architecture, University of Minnesota, 1965
M.U.P. Urban Planning, Wayne State University, 1973
Ph.D. Urban and Regional Planning, University of Michigan, 1977
CURRENT POSITION
Director, Public Policy Center, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, July 1987present
Professor, Graduate Program in Urban and Regional Planning, and Department of Civil
and Environmental Engineering, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, July 1986present
(University of Iowa faculty member since January 1978)
TRANSPORTATION ASSOCIATIONS
University of Iowa representative to the Transportation Research Board, National Research
Council, 1995present.
Chair, Transportation Research Board Committee on Transportation Economics, 19982004
(member, 19932004).
Member, Task Force on Environmental Justice in Transportation, 20012004.
Member, Task Force to Review the Highway Economic Requirements System (HERS)
Model, Federal Highway Administration, 1999.
Cochair, Steering Committee for Conference on Information Requirements for
Transportation Economic Analysis, Transportation Research Board and Federal
Highway Administration, 19981999.
Chair, Federal Highway Cost Allocation Study Review Committee, Transportation Research
Board, National Research Council, for the Federal Highway Administration, 199598.
Chair, Transportation Research Board Committee on Transportation and Economic
Development, 199495 (Committee member 19942002).
Member, Policy Analysis and System Monitoring Group, National Research and Technology
Partnership Forum. An on-going research collaboration sponsored by the American
Appendix 127
Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, the Federal Highway
Administration, and the Transportation Research Board, 2000present.
Chair, Transportation Research Board Committee on Local Transportation Finance, 1988
94 (Committee member 198294).
Member, Transportation Research Board Committee on Taxation and Finance, 19842006.
Member, Transportation Research Board Committee on Transportation Planning Needs and
Requirements in Small- and Medium-Sized Communities, 198190.
Member, National Cooperative Highway Research Program review panel for project on
Private Financing of Public Highway Improvements, Transportation Research Board,
198586.
Vice Chair, American Planning Association, Transportation Division, 198688.
Member, Transportation Research Board Committee on Public Transportation Planning and
Development, 198190.
Chair, American Institute of Certified Planners national competitions for student awards in
transportation research, 198083.
Member, Review Panel for Federal Highway Administration and Urban Mass Transportation
Administration study on Transportation Financial Forecasting, 198586.
Member, Advisory Committee for Federal Highway Administration staff study on Social and
Economic Concerns in Highway Development and Improvement, 1981.
Appendix 129
Forkenbrock, David J. and Norman S. J. Foster. The National Highway System as a Means
for Increasing Competitiveness. Iowa City, IA: University of Iowa, Public Policy Center,
for the Federal Highway Administration, 1993.
Forkenbrock, David J., Norman S. J. Foster, and Michael R. Crum. Transportation and
Iowas Economic Future. Iowa City, IA: University of Iowa, Public Policy Center, for the
U.S. Department of Transportation, Iowa Business Council, Iowa Department of
Transportation, and Northwest Area Foundation, 1993.
Foster, Norman S. J., David J. Forkenbrock, and Thomas F. Pogue. Evaluation of a State-
Level Road Program to Promote Local Economic Development. Transportation
Quarterly, Vol. 45, No. 4 (October 1991): 493515.
Forkenbrock, David J. Putting Transportation and Economic Development in Perspective.
Transportation Research Record 1274 (1991): 311.
Forkenbrock, David J. and Norman S. J. Foster. Economic Benefits of a Corridor Highway
Investment. Transportation Research, Vol. 24A, No. 4 (July 1990): 303312.
Forkenbrock, David J., Thomas F. Pogue, David J. Finnegan, and Norman S. J. Foster.
Transportation Investment to Promote Economic Development. In Infrastructure
Investment and Economic Development. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of
Agriculture, 1990: 1942.
Barnard, Jerald, David J. Forkenbrock, and Thomas F. Pogue (Equal authors). Directions for
Iowas Economic Future: Strategic Planning Recommendations for Economic
Development. Des Moines, IA: Iowa Department of Economic Development, 1987.
Forkenbrock, David J. and David J. Plazak. Economic Development and State-Level
Transportation Policy. Transportation Quarterly, Vol. 40, No. 2 (April l986): 143158.
Forkenbrock, David J. Highway Revenues and Expenditures: Some Emerging Policy
Directions at the State Level. Innovative Financing for Transportation: Practical
Solutions and Experiences. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Transportation, 1986:
87102.
Forkenbrock, David J. and David J. Plazak. State Transportation Programs to Foster
Economic Development. RISE Technical Report II. Ames, IA: Iowa Department of
Transportation, 1986.
Appendix 131
EDITORIAL BOARDS
Member, Editorial Board, Public Works Management & Policy, Sage Publications, Inc.,
1995present.
Member, Editorial Board, Journal of Public Transportation, 1995present.
Member, Editorial Board, Journal of the American Planning Association, 199498. Chair,
Committee to Select the Best Article for Volume 59 (1993).
Member, Editorial Board, Transportation Research, Pergamon Press, 1990present.
Member, Editorial Advisory Committee, Journal of Planning Education and Research,
Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning, 1981present.
Member, Editorial Board, Journal of Planning Literature, Sage Publication, Inc., 1996
present.
PERSONNEL INFORMATION
ACADEMIC BACKGROUND
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Academic
University Position Dates
Univ. of Iowa Director, Center for Urban Transportation 1977-1990
Studies
Assoc. Prof., Program in Urban and 1982-present
Regional Planning
Associate Prof. Civil & Environmental 1981-present
Engineering
Industrial
Company Position Dates
US. Navy Main Propulsion Asst. 1966-1967
Liquid Cargo Officer 1967-1968
Engineering Officer 1968-1969
Other
Company, Firm, Agency Position Dates
OTR Transportation Partner/Project 1973-1976
Planning Inc. Manager
Deleuw-Cather Consultant/Project Manager 1975-1976
Appendix 133
PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES
Consulting
RESEARCH ACTIVITIES
Appendix 135
or Grant Title Funding Rate Expiration Date
SELECTED PUBLICATIONS
Haug, E.J., Kim, S.S., and Stoner, J.W., "Conceptual Design of a National Advanced
Driving Simulator", Requested paper, Transportation Research Board, 1991.
Stoner, J.W., Romano, R., "Real Time Vehicle Dynamics Simulation: Enabling Tool
for Fundamental Human Factors Research", Vehicle Dynamics and Electronic
Controlled Suspensions, SAE SP-861, Society of Automotive Engineers, pp 71-83,
February 1991
Haug, E.J., J.G. Kuhl, and J.W. Stoner, Virtual Prototyping for Military Vehicle
Development, SAE Technical Paper Series, 930848, March, 1993
Bhatti, A and Stoner, J.W., Simulation of Dynamic Loads from Different Vehicle
Configurations, International Journal of Vehicle Design, Vol. I, No. 4, pp 396-416,
1994.
Bhatti, A., J.A. Barlow, and J.W. Stoner, Modeling Damage to Rigid Pavements
Caused by Sub-grade Pumping, Journal of Transportation Engineering, ASCE, Vol.
122, No. 1, pp 12 - 22, Jan/Feb 1996.
Bhatti, M.A. and Stoner, J.W. Nonlinear Pavement Distress Model Using Dynamic
Vehicle Loads, ASCE Journal of InfrastructureSystems, June 98.
Evans, D.E. and Stoner, J., Correlated Database Generation for Driving
Simulators,, IMAGE Conference Proceedings, July 15, 1992.
J.G. Kuhl, E.J. Haug, and J.W. Stoner, Operator in the Loop Simulation for Virtual
Prototyping of Ground Vehicles, Proceedings of the Summer Computer Simulation
Conference, Boston, MA, July, 1993.
Stoner, James W., Driving Human Factors Research Using High Fidelity
Simulation, Proceedings of the Driver Impairment, Fatigue, and Driving
Simulation Conference, Fremantle, Western Australia, 16-17 September, 1993, pp
1100 - 1150.
Stoner, James W., Ground vehicle Simulator fidelity and selection of appropriate
applications, Proceedings of the Real Time Systems Conference, Paris, France,
January 11-14, 1993.
Stoner, James W. and Richard Romano, Configurations for High Fidelity Driving
Simulation Research, Transportation Research Circular, National Academy of
Sciences, January 1994.
Stoner, James W. and D.F. Evans, Database Development for Real Time Driving
Simulation, IPC-8, Society of Automotive Engineers of Japan, pp 7-12, November
1995.
Stoner, James W. and D.F. Evans, Virtual Environments for Evaluating ITS Systems,
Proceedings of the Second World Congress on Intelligent Transportation Systems,
Yokohama, Japan, November 1995.
Stoner, James W., Specifying Simulation Requirements for Real Time Driver
Evaluation, Proceedings of the International Aerospace Symposium 96 Nagoya,
Nagoya, Japan, November 1996.
Keith Knapp, Welsh, T., and Stoner J., Statewide Engineering Information Series,
Mid Continent Transportation Symposium Proceedings, Nov. 1999
Appendix 137
13 NCHRP Project 17-28 Proposal
8
11.4. Support Letters
Appendix 139
14 NCHRP Project 17-28 Proposal
0
11.5. Certifications
Appendix 141