In this study, mechanical and physical properties of concretes incorporating acidic and basaltic pumice,
barite and limonite were investigated. Acidic pumice (AP), Basaltic Pumice (BP), Barite (B) and
Limonite (L) were substitute for fine aggregate by mass. Compressive strength, wear resistance,
capillary water absorption and ultrasonic sound velocity tests were performed at 7th and 28th days on
concrete samples. Besides 28 day samples exposed to 600 C and 800 C for one hour and cooled with
2 different (air and water cooling) method. As a result; both 600 C and 800 C heated samples which
are produced with acidic pumice showed lower compressive strength loss than other samples at both air
and water cooling process. These results showed similarity with ultrasonic sound test results. Water
absorption values of the samples produced with lightweight aggregates are higher and wear resistance
values are lower than other samples. Compressive strength losses of the barite samples are lower than
reference sample but higher than other lightweight aggregate samples. However, wear resistance of
barite incorporating samples are the highest and water absorption values are the lowest ones. When the
cooling methods compared in itself, it is determined that air cooled samples have lower compressive
strength loss than water cooled samples.
Keywords: Barite, Pumice, Limonite, Rapid Cooling, High Temperature, Normal Cooling.
Introduction
The two most important properties of hardened concrete are its strength and durability. Concrete must
provide the necessary strength for the structure and besides needs to preserve its function during service
life. Concrete durability is the ability of maintaining all its properties during the service life according to
the construction type [1]. With the advances of technology in the concrete industry, some kind of
concretes with different properties take part in the literature as special concretes such as heavyweight
concretes, load bearing lightweight concretes, high strength concretes and insulating concretes. For giving
concrete different properties, surely its needed to change the conventional mixture of concrete and add
different qualified building materials. The most popular kinds of special concretes which are produced
with modified mixtures are lightweight and heavyweight concretes. Heavyweight concretes generally
used for preventing dangerous effects of radiation emitting structures [2]. Lead is a very effective
289
290 Investigating Some Durability Properties of ...
radiation shielding material; on the other hand it is very expensive and harmful for human health with
toxic constituents. For this reason, researchers have turned to different materials which are not harmful
for health and have shielding properties. Barite (BaSO4) contains high amount of barium minerals which
have radiation absorbing properties [3, 4]. Its unit weight is very high because of the barium element in its
components. Heavyweight concretes with barite aggregates are used for minimizing the radiation effect
and protecting from deadly neutron and gamma rays [4 6]. Lightweight concretes which are light,
insulating, enough strong and non-flammable are very important materials for the future of architecture.
Differences from conventional concrete is being lighter and having great number of voids which provides
insulation. These voids are generated by using porous aggregates (zeolite, pumice, slag and perlite etc.),
forming a porous microstructure or constituting gas bubbles with the fine slurry. In this scope, pumice is
an ideal material for producing lightweight concretes with its millions of small air voids, low density, fire
resistance, good sound and heat insulation properties [7, 8].
Wear resistance is one of the properties which effecting concrete durability. Forces affecting the
surface of concrete as fractioning and striking occurs surface wear such like rasping. Wearing is a
physical and mechanical event which happens slowly. Wear resistance of concrete can be strengthened
with different admixtures and this caused more interest on concrete for the constructions which needed
high wear resistance [9 11]. Advantages of concrete than other building materials are forming easily in
desired shape and size, high compressive strength, good adherence with steel rebar, resistant to high
temperature and fire [12]. Concrete has high fire resistance due to being non-flammable, non-toxic
fuming and resisting against fire for quite a long time. But this resistance is valid temporarily and for
certain temperatures [13, 14]. Effect of high temperature on mechanical properties of concrete has been
investigated since 1940s. In these researches, cement pastes, mortars, concrete samples and reinforced
concrete elements exposed to high temperatures and their behavior has been studied. Fire resistance of
concrete is changing with the used aggregate and cement type [15]. Aggregates have a volume of 60
80% in concrete. Effect of fire on concrete changes with temperature and time of exposure, besides
aggregate type and cement paste phase is also important and this ends up with a significant strength loss.
Effect of aggregates under high temperatures is related to their mineral origins. Generally silica-free
aggregates, for example limestone and volcanic originated aggregates are more resistant to high
temperatures [16 20]. Under the effect of elevated temperatures, it is noticed that the strength increasing
up to 300 C. This increment is higher at concretes which are produced with siliceous aggregates and its
related to higher adherence between siliceous aggregates and cement paste [21]. A durable concrete is the
one which shows the expected performance without deforming under various intrinsic and external
effects. Therefore, concrete durability can be defined as resistance to chemical and physical effects
without deforming except the mechanical loads. In this study concrete samples produced with pumice,
barite and limonite aggregates and their high temperature resistance, compressive strengths, ultrasonic
sound velocities, wear resistances and capillary water absorption properties are investigated.
Materials
Barite
Barite is clean, soft, naturally unresponsive and non-expensive mineral. The world's total reserves of
barite in Turkey is 2,1%. These reserves contain beaten, crumble dorraw, good quality barite. Barite
which is used in the study, was obtained from Osmaniye-Bahe region [22].
Ahmet Hayrullah Sevin et al. 291
Figure 1. Barite
Pumice
Pumice (P) that occurs as a result of volcanic activity is a porous and lightweight material. Turkey has
extensive deposits of pumice. Since pores are generally detached from each other, pumice is a light
material, can float in water for a long time, and has low permeability and high insulation characteristics.
Silica content up to 75% can be found in the chemical composition of pumice. The SiO2 ratio contained in
the rock gives them their abrasive property, and the Al2O3 composition makes it become heat and fire
resistant [23].
Limonite
The chemical formula of limonite iron oxide is commonly found in nature 2Fe2O3.3H2O. Limonite is
found as yellow and brown colors in the earth. (Figure3)[24]. Limonite which is used in the study was
obtained from Kahramanmara-Trkolu region.
Figure 3. Limonite
292 Investigating Some Durability Properties of ...
In the study, acidic pumice (AP), basaltic pumice (BP), barite (B), limonite (L), chemical and
physical analysis are given Table1 and Table 2.
Aggregate
Aggregate from Ceyhan River were used in this study. In Table 3, the physical properties of the
aggregates were given and granulometry curve is given in Figure 4.
Mixture
Cement
In the study, CEM I 42.5 cement was used. The chemical and physical properties of cement are given in
Table 4.
SiO2 20.02
Al2O3 4.87
Fe2O3 3.44
CaO 62.49
MgO 2.81
Na2O+K2O 0.91
SO3 2.86
FreeCaO 0.48
Fineness
Methods
Preparation of Mixtures
In this table, mixture proportions and fresh concrete properties can be seen. Pumice, barite and limonite
were used as amount of 10 and 20 % by weight instead of fine aggregates in the reference mixture.
Sample Water Cement Fine Coarse Additive Slump Tempera Unit Weight
s (kg/m3) (kg/m3) aggregate aggregate (kg/m3) (mm) ture of (kg/m3)
(kg/m3) (kg/m3) concrete
(C)
R 165 300 760 1165 0 82 20 2312
7 and 28 days 10 cm size cube compressive strength tested according to TS EN 123903 standards [25].
For determining the surface wear 100x100x100 mm sized cubic samples produced and cure 28 days. Than
these samples are cut into 71x71x71 mm sizes tested according to DIN 52108 standards [26].
Ahmet Hayrullah Sevin et al. 295
Water can move upwards through the capillary voids in the concrete from the surface which contacts to
water. This event which is affecting the durability properties of concrete is called capillary water
absorption. Capillary water absorption test were performed on 28 days old concrete samples and capillary
water absorbing value is calculated with the equation (1).
(1)
Where;
Q: Change in sample weight (gr)
A: Water contacting area of sample (cm)
td: Passed time up to last read (min)
k: Capillarity Coefficient
Passing time of the ultrasound wave sent from one surface to other of the concrete sample was measured
and velocity of ultrasound calculated with the equation (2). Compressive strengths of concrete samples
were determined by ultrasound velocity according to ASTM C597 [27].
V = (S / t) x 106 (2)
Where;
V = P wave velocity (meter/second),
S= Distance between two surfaces, ultrasound wave sent and taken (meter)
t = Time for ultrasound wave passed through the sample (microseconds)
Concrete is a non-flammable materials and it is resistant to fire more than other building materials. But
high temperatures cause some changes in concrete. Concrete contains water in the capillary voids and this
water leaves the structure at 100 C [28]. Previous studies showed that a temperature under 250 C does
not affect the strength [29]. When the temperature exceeds 400 C decompositions of Ca(OH)2 structure
begins. Yuzer et al. expresses that this decomposition completely happens at 530 C and the loss amount
is %33 [30]. Over 600 CC-S-H gels loses their binding ability and structure starts to dehydrate. After 800
C concrete loses all its properties [31, 32]. Concrete samples at 28 days, kept in oven at 100 C for 24
hours. After 24 hours, samples cooled at room temperature. Ultrasonic sound test were performed and put
into high temperature oven. Samples exposed to 600 C and 800 C respectively for one hour. After
exposing samples to high temperatures, samples cooled with two different processes. One is air cooling
and the other water cooling (Fig 5.) After cooling ultrasonic sound velocity and compressive strength tests
were performed.
296 Investigating Some Durability Properties of ...
Compressive Strength
The compressive strength results of concrete mixes cured in water for 7, and 28 days are graphically
plotted in Fig. 6.
The results indicated that, the compressive strength of concrete mix B10 is significantly higher than
the other concretes at the age of 7 and 28 days. This is the barite and normal aggregate can be explained
with almost same. The results indicated that, the compressive strength of concrete mix AP 20 is lower
than the other concretes at the age of 7 and 28 days.
This reduction in compressive strength is probably due to, the high water content consumed by
limonite fine aggregate this is 14.13 %. The high water content may causes internal bleeding under the
aggregate surface leading to the formation of voids in the vicinity of aggregate and thus porous interfacial
transition zone (ITZ) will be formed, which generates a weak bond between coarse aggregate and mortar
matrix [33].
Ahmet Hayrullah Sevin et al. 297
The abrasion resistance results of concrete mixes cured in water for 28 days are graphically plotted in Fig. 7.
The results indicated that, the abrasion value of concrete mix AP20 is lower than the other concretes.
This result is due to high porous structure of acidic pumice. This porous structure forms a weaker
skeleton in concrete. And this is also due to the porous structure of acidic pumice aggregate.
7.6
Abrasion Resistance (cm3/50 cm2)
7.4
7.2
6.8
28Days
6.6
6.4
6.2
R BP10 BP20 AP10 AP20 B10 B20 L10 L20
Samples
As the amount of lightweight aggregates and limonite, capillary water absorption values increased.
This is due to high water absorption of these aggregates.
Barite aggregate which has lower water absorption, make capillary water absorption values lower
than others.
The ultrasonic sound results of concrete mixes cured in water for 7, and 28 days are graphically plotted in
Fig. 9.
This method is a non-destructive testing method for obtaining the strength of materials. This results
expresses the compactness ratio of materials. So ultrasonic sound velocity results show similarity with the
compressive strength results.
For determining fire resistance of concrete samples, concretes exposed to 600 and 800 degrees high
temperature. For understanding the fire resistance clearly, ultrasonic sound tests performed before and
after fire resistance test. Two different cooling processes used for obtaining realistic results are likely a
real fire happened, which are air cooling and water cooling. The names of the samples, materials used and
mix proportions are given in Table 5.
After exposure to high temperatures of the various cooling regimes concrete subjected to
compressive strength and ultrasonic sound values are given Table 6 and Table 7.
Table 6. 600 C fire resistance values
600 C Ultrasound
Compressive Strength Ultrasound Velocity Compressive Strength
Temperature Velocity
x All aggregate substituted samples have given better results than reference sample.
x Minimum compressive strength loss happened at air cooling and water cooling occurred at AP20
sample.
x Water cooling caused more strength loss than air cooling at all samples
x At air cooling, strength loss happened between 22 and 36 % and at water cooling strength loss
happened between 37 and 52 %.
x Sudden cooling with water on highly hot materials occur multiple capillary cracks and voids.
This can be also presented with the ultrasonic sound test results.
300 Investigating Some Durability Properties of ...
Lightweight aggregates, such as pumice and perlite are formed by volcano eruption or incineration.
As a result, they have low heat conductivity and exhibit a high resistance to heat. Therefore, the concrete
manufactured by using such aggregates should deliver improved mechanical properties at high
temperature in comparison to normal aggregates concrete [34] Results are parallel to the studies in the
literature.[35-39].
800 C fire resistance test, similar results obtained to 600 C fire resistance test. At air cooling,
strength loss happened between 43 and 52 % and at water cooling strength loss happened between 51 and
64 %.
Results
References
1. llstom, J.M. andDomone, P.L.J., 2001. Construction Materials their nature and behaviour, Spon Pres, USA and
Canada
2. Yazcolu, S., Bozkurt, N., 2006. Pomza Ve Mineral Katkl Tayc Hafif Betonun Mekanik
zelliklerinin Aratrlmas. Gazi niversitesi, Mh. Mim. Fak. Der. Cilt 21, No 4, 675-680.
Ahmet Hayrullah Sevin et al. 301
3. Akkurt, I.,Akyldrm, H., Mavi, B., Kilincarslan, S., Basyigit, C., Photon attenuationco efficients of
concreteincludes barite in different rate Ann. Nucl.Energy 37, 910914, 2010.
4. Bayiit, C.,Klnarslan, ., Akkurt, ., and Ertun, A., Research About Usage Of Barite are as Aggregate in
Shield Cocrete for Absorption of Radioactive Rays, International Symposium Industrial Minerals and
Building Stones, stanbul, ss:655-659, 2003.
5. Binici H, Aksoan O, Sevinc A.H, Kknder A.,Mechanical and radioactivity shielding performances of
mortars made with colemanite, barite, ground basaltic pumice and ground blast furnace slag, Construction and
Building Materials, 50 (2014) 177-183.
6. Klnarslan, ., Barit Agregal Ar Betonlarn Radyasyon Zrhlanmasndaki zellikleri ve Optimal
karmlarnn Aratrlmas SD Fen Bilimleri Enstits, Doktora Tezi, Isparta, 2004. 144
7. H. Kus, E. zkan, . Gcer, E. Edis, Hot box measurements of pumice aggregate concrete hollow block walls,
Constr. Build. Mater. 38 (2013) 837845.
8. A. Sariisik, G. Sariisik, New production process for insulation blocks composed of EPS and lightweight
concrete containing pumice aggregate, Mater. Struct. 45 (9) (2012) 13451357.
9. Erdoan T. Y., 2003, Beton, ODT Gelitirme Vakf Yaynclk ve letiim A. ., Ankara.
10. Do, M. T.,Chaal O. andAitcin P. C, FatigueBehavior of High-Performance Concrete, ASCE JM, 1(1993) 96-
111.
11. Can, O., Durmu, G., Suba, S., Yldz, K. ve Arslan, M., 2009, Lif Katkl Betonlarn Anma Direnci
zerindeki Etkileri, 5. Uluslar aras leri Teknolojiler Sempozyumu, Karabk.
12. Erdoan T.Y., (2003), Beton, ODT Gelitirme Vakf Yaynclk ve letiim A.. Yayn, Ankara.
13. Neville A.M., (2000), Properties of Concrete, Fourth Edition, Longman Scientific and Technical, New
York/USA.
14. Baradan B., Yazc H. ve n H., (2002), Betonarme Yaplarda Kalclk (Durabilite), Dokuz Eyll
niversitesi Mhendislik Fakltesi Yaynlar, yayn no 298, zmir.
15. Alpaslan, O.K., Bir Sanayi Yapsnn Yangn Dayanmnn Artrlmas ve Maliyete Etkisinin Aratrlmas,
Yksek Lisans Tezi, stanbul Teknik niversitesi, Fen Bilimleri Enstits, 1994.
16. Riley, M.A., (1991), Possible New Method for the Assessment of Fire Damaged Concrete, Magazine of
Concrete Research, say 43, say 87-92.
17. Akman M.S., (2000), Yap Hasarlar ve Onarm lkeleri TMMOB naat Mhendisleri Odas, stanbul.
18. Perkins P.H., (1986), Repair, Protection and Water proofing, of Concrete Structures, Elseveir Applied
Science Publishers Ltd., England.
19. Alonso C.,Andrade C. ve Castellote M. ve Khoury G.A., (2003b), Microstructure-Solid Phases,
International Centre for Mechanical Sciences, Course on Effect of Heat on Concrete, Udine/Italy.
20. Postacolu B., (1987), Beton, Cilt 2, Teknik Kitaplar Yaynevi, stanbul.
21. Savva A., Manita P. ve Sideris K.K., (2005), Influence of ElevatedTemperatures on the Mechanical Properties
of Blended Cement Concretes Prepared with Limestone and Siliceous Aggregates, Cement & Concrete
Composites, say 27, sayfa 239-248.
22. Sevinc, A. H., 2011. Barit, bazaltik pomza, kolemanit ve yuksek frn curufu katkl harclarn ve betonlarn
muhendislik ozellikleri, Y.Lisans Tezi,Kahramanmara Sutcu mam Universitesi, Fen Bilimleri Enstitusu,
nsaat Mhendislii Anabilim Dal, 176 s. (In Turkish).
23. Binici, H., Kaplan, H. and Yaarer, F. Durability of the coated paint additivepumice concretes, Journals by
Engineering Faculty, 13(9), pp. 4047Sleyman Demirel University (in Turkish) (2009).
24. Karasu, B., M. ak ve A. Kl, "Limonitin Yumuak Porselen Transparant ve inko Kristal Srlarnda
Kullanm", Denizli Malzeme Sempozyumu, 459-464, Denizli, 2000.
25. Trk Standartlar Enstits (TSE), Beton - Sertlemi beton deneyleri - Blm 3: Deney numunelerinin basn
dayanmnn tayini, TS EN 12390-3, Ankara, 2003.
26. DIN 52108, Testing of Inorganic Non-Metallic Materials: Wear Test with the Grinding Wheel According to
Boehme, 2002.
27. Astm C597, Standart test method for pulse velocity through concrete, American Society Fortesting
Materials, USA, 2009.
302 Investigating Some Durability Properties of ...
28. Savva, A., Manita, P. ve Sideris, K.K. Influence of Elevated Temperatures on the Mechanical Properties of
Blended Cement Concretes Prepared with Limestone and Siliceous Aggregates, Cement and Concrete
Composites, Cilt 27, 239248, 2005.
29. Baradan, B., Yazc, H. ve n, H. 2002. Betonarme Yaplarda Kalclk (Durabilite), DE., Mhendislik Fak.
Yaynlar, zmir.
30. Yzer, N., Akz, F. ve Dokuzer ztrk L., Compressive StrengthColor Change Relation in Mortars at High
Temperature, Cementand Concrete Research, Cilt 34, 18031807, 2004.
31. Castillo C. ve Durrani AJ., Effect of Transient High Temperature on High Strength Concrete, ACI Materials
Journal, Cilt 87, No 1, 4753, 1990.
32. Xu, Y. ve Chung, D.D.L., Effect of Sand Addition on the Specific Heat and Thermal Conductivity of
Cement, Cement and Concrete Research, Cilt 30, 59-61, 2000.
33. Ahmed S. O., Development of high-performance heavy density concrete using different aggregates for
gamma-ray shielding, Progress in Nuclear Energy,Vol. 79, March 2015, Pages 4855.
34. QianminMa, RongxinGuo, ZhimanZhao, Zhiwei Lin, Kecheng He Mechanical properties of concrete at high
temperatureA review Construction and Building Materials 93 (2015) 371383
35. Sancak E, Sari YD, Simsek O. Effects of elevated temperature on compressive strength and weightloss of the
light-weight concrete with silicafume and superplasticizer. Cem Concr Compos 2008;30:71521.
36. Tanyildizi H, Coskun A. Performance of lightweight concrete with silica fme after high temperature. Constr
Build Mater 2008;22:21249.
37. Cao W, Sun Q, Zhou M, Yang Y. Study on effectrule of cementing material and aggregate varieties upon
concrete resistance to high temperature. New Build Mater 2009;3:1720 [in Chinese].
38. Turkmen I, Findik SB. Several properties of mineral admixtured lightweight mortars at elevated temperatures.
Fire Mater 2013;37:33749.
39. Sancak E, Sari YD, Simsek O. Effects of elevated temperature on compressive strength and weightloss of the
light-weight concrete with silicafume and superplasticizer. Cem Concr Compos 2008;30:71521.