BAB III

HASIL DAN PEMBAHASAN

A. HASIL
1. GRAFIK DATA PLOTING AWAL DI EXCEL
A. PRODUK 1

Data Produk 1 (data Konstan)

270
265
Penjualan (unit)

260
255
250
Produk 1
245
240
235
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35
Periode (bulan)

B. PRODUK 2

Data Produk 2 (data Trend)

450
400
350
Penjualan (unit)

300
250
200
150 Produk 2
100
50
0
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35
Periode (bulan)
C. PRODUK 3

Data Produk 3 (data Musiman)

350

Penjualan (unit) 300

250
200
150
Produk 3
100
50
0
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35
Periode (bulan)
2. HASIL FORECAST PRAKTIKUM
A. PRODUK 1 METODE SA

09-23- Forecast R-square

Actual Forecast MAPE Tracking
2017 by CFE MAD MSE
Data Error (%) Signal
Month SA
1 250
2 250 250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
3 265 250 15 15 7,5 112,5 2,830189 2 1
4 245 255 -10 5 8,333333 108,3333 3,247337 0,6 0,115384
5 255 252,5 2,5 7,5 6,875 82,8125 2,680601 1,090909 0,142857
6 250 253 -3 4,5 6,1 68,05 2,38448 0,737705 9,67E-02
7 260 252,5 7,5 12 6,333333 66,08334 2,467836 1,894737 0,156308
8 250 253,5714 -3,57143 8,428574 5,938775 58,46501 2,31937 1,419244 0,105607
9 260 253,125 6,875 15,30357 6,055803 57,06509 2,359977 2,527092 0,154725
10 255 253,8889 1,111115 16,41469 5,506393 50,8617 2,146172 2,981024 0,162232
11 250 254 -4 12,41469 5,355754 47,37553 2,091555 2,318009 0,116064
12 260 253,6364 6,363632 18,77832 5,44738 46,7501 2,123918 3,447221 0,152408
13 245 254,1667 -9,16667 9,611649 5,75732 49,85658 2,258717 1,669466 7,47E-02
14 255 253,4615 1,538467 11,15012 5,432793 46,20353 2,131379 2,052373 7,90E-02
15 260 253,5714 6,428574 17,57869 5,503921 45,85517 2,155746 3,193849 9,94E-02
16 265 254 11 28,57869 5,870326 50,86483 2,28876 4,868331 0,137088
17 255 254,6875 0,3125 28,89119 5,522962 47,69188 2,153371 5,231104 0,137251
18 250 254,7059 -4,70589 24,1853 5,474898 46,18914 2,137429 4,417489 0,107036
19 250 254,4444 -4,44444 19,74086 5,417651 44,72047 2,117449 3,643805 8,57E-02
20 255 254,2105 0,789475 20,53033 5,174063 42,39957 2,022299 3,967933 8,76E-02
21 260 254,25 5,75 26,28033 5,202859 41,93271 2,031761 5,051133 0,103215
22 255 254,5238 0,476196 26,75653 4,97778 39,94672 1,943903 5,375193 0,104223
23 245 254,5455 -9,54546 17,21107 5,185402 42,27258 2,032639 3,31914 6,63E-02
24 250 254,1304 -4,13043 13,08064 5,139534 41,1764 2,016097 2,545103 0,057475
25 250 253,9583 -3,95833 9,122314 5,090317 40,11357 1,998065 1,792092 5,15E-02
26 265 253,8 11,2 20,32231 5,334704 43,52662 2,087199 3,809454 5,92E-02
27 250 254,2308 -4,23077 16,09154 5,292245 42,54096 2,072011 3,040588 5,15E-02
28 248 254,0741 -6,07408 10,01746 5,321202 42,33183 2,085982 1,882555 4,33E-02
29 255 253,8571 1,142853 11,16031 5,171975 40,86663 2,027489 2,157843 4,40E-02
30 250 253,8965 -3,89655 7,263763 5,127995 39,98099 2,011321 1,416492 4,07E-02
31 255 253,7667 1,233337 8,497101 4,998173 38,69899 1,960399 1,700041 4,13E-02
-6,04E-
32 245 253,8065 -8,80646 -0,30936 5,121021 39,95237 2,013111 3,61E-02
02
33 255 253,5313 1,46875 1,159393 5,006887 38,77127 1,968201 0,23156 3,61E-02
34 260 253,5758 6,42424 7,583633 5,049838 38,84702 1,983433 1,501758 3,64E-02
35 250 253,7647 -3,76471 3,818924 5,01204 38,12131 1,969387 0,76195 3,47E-02
36 260 253,6572 6,34285 10,16177 5,050063 38,18161 1,982821 2,012208 3,58E-02
37 253,8333
38 253,8333
39 253,8333
40 253,8333
41 253,8333
42 253,8333
 CFE 10,16177
MAD 5,050063
MSE 38,18161
MAPE 1,982821
Trk,Signal 2,012208
R-square 3,58E-02

METODE MA

09-23- Forecast R-square

Actual Forecast MAPE Tracking
2017 by CFE MAD MSE
Data Error (%) Signal
Month 3-MA
1 250
2 250
3 265
4 245 255 -10 -10 10 100 4,081633 -1
5 255 253,3333 1,666672 -8,33333 5,833336 51,3889 2,367615 -1,42857 0,722222
6 250 255 -5 -13,3333 5,555557 42,5926 2,245076 -2,4
7 260 250 10 -3,33333 6,666668 56,94445 2,645346 -0,5 0,155556
8 250 255 -5 -8,33333 6,333334 50,55556 2,516277 -1,31579 0,252137
9 260 253,3333 6,666672 -1,66666 6,388891 49,53705 2,524248 -0,26087 0,106061
10 255 256,6667 -1,66666 -3,33331 5,714286 42,85715 2,257011 -0,58333 0,153846
11 250 255 -5 -8,33331 5,625 40,62501 2,224885 -1,48148 0,185185
12 260 255 5 -3,33331 5,555555 38,88889 2,191351 -0,6 0,124031
13 245 255 -10 -13,3333 6 45 2,380379 -2,22222 0,150537
14 255 251,6667 3,333328 -9,99999 5,757576 41,91919 2,282816 -1,73684 0,141706
15 260 253,3333 6,666672 -3,33331 5,833333 42,12963 2,306257 -0,57143 0,103314
16 265 253,3333 11,66667 8,333359 6,282052 49,35899 2,467508 1,326535 8,81E-02
17 255 260 -5 3,333359 6,190476 47,61906 2,431313 0,538466 0,149685
18 250 260 -10 -6,66664 6,444445 51,11113 2,535892 -1,03448 0,207207
19 250 256,6667 -6,66666 -13,3333 6,458333 50,69445 2,544065 -2,06451 0,222562
20 255 251,6667 3,333328 -9,99997 6,274509 48,36602 2,471308 -1,59375 0,231162
21 260 251,6667 8,333328 -1,66664 6,388888 49,53703 2,512076 -0,26087 0,222789
22 255 255 0 -1,66664 6,052631 46,92982 2,379861 -0,27536 0,223027
23 245 256,6667 -11,6667 -13,3333 6,333332 51,38887 2,498963 -2,10526 0,213404
24 250 253,3333 -3,33333 -16,6666 6,190475 49,47088 2,443457 -2,6923 0,217712
25 250 250 0 -16,6666 5,90909 47,22221 2,332391 -2,82051 0,242911
26 265 248,3333 16,66667 4,58E-05 6,376811 57,24637 2,504431 7,18E-06 0,233333
27 250 255 -5 -4,99995 6,319443 55,90277 2,483413 -0,7912 0,230769
28 248 255 -7 -12 6,346666 55,62666 2,496979 -1,89075 0,227792
29 255 254,3333 0,666672 -11,3333 6,128204 53,50427 2,410997 -1,84936 0,2264
30 250 251 -1 -12,3333 5,938271 51,55967 2,336516 -2,07692 0,235228
31 255 251 4 -8,33328 5,869047 50,28968 2,309091 -1,41987 0,241823
32 245 253,3333 -8,33333 -16,6666 5,954022 50,95018 2,346756 -2,79922 0,230891
33 255 250 5 -11,6666 5,922221 50,08518 2,33389 -1,96997 0,241141
34 260 251,6667 8,333328 -3,33328 5,999999 50,70967 2,361994 -0,55555 0,231065
35 250 253,3333 -3,33333 -6,66661 5,916666 49,47221 2,329849 -1,12675 0,229255
36 260 255 5 -1,66661 5,888888 48,73063 2,317522 -0,28301 0,220371
37 256,6667
38 256,6667
 39 256,6667
40 256,6667
41 256,6667
42 256,6667

CFE -1,66661
MAD 5,888888
MSE 48,73063
MAPE 2,317522
Trk,Signal -0,28301
R-square 0,220371
m=3

B. PRODUK 2 METODE SEST

09-23- Forecast R-square

Actual Forecast MAPE Tracking
2017 by CFE MAD MSE
Data Error (%) Signal
Month SEST
1 260
2 260 260 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
3 255 260 -5 -5 2,5 12,5 0,980392 -2 1
4 265 254,158 10,842 5,841995 5,280665 47,51629 2,017368 1,106299 0,682578
5 265 265,5838 -0,58377 5,258224 4,106441 35,72241 1,568098 1,280482
6 270 266,3528 3,647186 8,905411 4,01459 31,23832 1,524641 2,218261 0,877678
7 275 271,9203 3,079681 11,98509 3,858772 27,61268 1,457181 3,105934 0,870442
8 280 277,7307 2,269287 14,25438 3,631703 24,40367 1,364793 3,924985 0,92271
9 286 283,3592 2,640778 16,89516 3,507837 22,22493 1,309612 4,816402 0,937399
10 295 289,9855 5,014526 21,90968 3,675247 22,54943 1,352971 5,961418 0,884654
11 300 300,0412 -4,12E-02 21,86848 3,311842 20,29466 1,219047 6,603117 0,98498
12 295 305,4354 -10,4354 11,43306 3,959441 28,34952 1,429809 2,887544
13 290 298,6748 -8,67481 2,758255 4,352388 32,25808 1,559934 0,633734
14 289 291,3792 -2,37915 0,379105 4,2006 30,2121 1,503265 0,09025
15 300 289,2845 10,71548 11,09459 4,665949 36,25563 1,65102 2,377778
16 310 301,8987 8,101349 19,19594 4,894976 38,21405 1,715174 3,92156
17 305 314,1202 -9,12018 10,07576 5,159051 41,02427 1,794865 1,953026
18 315 308,2324 6,767578 16,84334 5,25367 41,30521 1,815663 3,206014
19 325 318,6425 6,357544 23,20088 5,314997 41,25594 1,823469 4,365173
20 350 330,2545 19,74551 42,9464 6,074497 59,60485 2,024422 7,069951 0,839099
21 355 359,0882 -4,08823 38,85817 5,975184 57,46029 1,980781 6,503259 0,937879
22 365 364,9794 2,06E-02 38,87874 5,691631 54,72411 1,886727 6,830861 0,966989
23 350 374,6558 -24,6558 14,22292 6,553639 79,8689 2,121172 2,170232
24 350 355,5054 -5,50543 8,717484 6,508065 77,71416 2,097337 1,339489
25 360 352,6058 7,394165 16,11165 6,544986 76,75414 2,095529 2,461678
26 355 363,4106 -8,41061 7,701035 6,619611 76,5135 2,106475 1,163367
27 350 357,5858 -7,58579 0,11525 6,656772 75,78391 2,108817 1,73E-02
28 368 350,6355 17,3645 17,47975 7,053354 84,14473 2,205477 2,478218
29 370 370,9528 -0,95282 16,52693 6,835478 81,17199 2,135907 2,417816
30 375 374,1815 0,818481 17,34541 6,627995 78,39605 2,069781 2,616992
31 380 379,2431 0,756897 18,10231 6,432292 75,80195 2,007428 2,814286
32 384 384,4361 -0,43607 17,66624 6,238865 73,36285 1,946335 2,831644
33 390 388,4232 1,576813 19,24306 6,093176 71,14796 1,898147 3,158132
 34 400 394,6538 5,346191 24,58925 6,07054 69,85808 1,881129 4,050586
35 410 405,6803 4,319733 28,90898 6,019046 68,35226 1,85679 4,802917
36 425 416,8354 8,164581 37,07356 6,080347 68,30392 1,858626 6,097277
37 433,5559
38 442,765
39 451,9741
40 461,1831
41 470,3922
42 479,6013

CFE 37,07356
MAD 6,080347
MSE 68,30392
MAPE 1,858626
Trk,Signal 6,097277
R-square
Alpha=0,92
Beta=0,27
F(0)=260
T(0)=0
METODE DEST

09-23- Forecast R-square

Actual Forecast MAPE Tracking
2017 by CFE MAD MSE
Data Error (%) Signal
Month DEST
1 260
2 260 260 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
3 255 260 -5 -5 2,5 12,5 0,980392 -2 1
4 265 254 11,00003 6,000031 5,333344 48,66689 2,037246 1,125004 0,720007
5 265 265,4 -0,39999 5,600037 4,100006 36,54016 1,56567 1,365861
6 270 267,08 2,920013 8,52005 3,864007 30,93743 1,468833 2,204978 0,933899
7 275 272,6 2,399994 10,92004 3,620005 26,74119 1,369482 3,016582 0,932988
8 280 278,5472 1,45282 12,37286 3,310407 23,22254 1,247965 3,737565 0,988257
9 286 284,2218 1,778198 14,15106 3,118881 20,71497 1,169688 4,537224 0,996831
10 295 290,8098 4,190155 18,34122 3,237912 20,36413 1,197544 5,66452 0,928982
11 300 300,9324 -0,9324 17,40881 3,007361 18,41466 1,10887 5,788734
12 295 306,4163 -11,4163 5,992493 3,771812 28,58899 1,359876 1,588757
13 290 298,9839 -8,98386 -2,99136 4,206149 32,93238 1,50471 -0,71119
14 289 290,3605 -1,36047 -4,35184 3,987251 30,5415 1,425175 -1,09144
15 300 287,651 12,349 7,997162 4,584518 39,25266 1,6174 1,744384
16 310 300,9031 9,096863 17,09402 4,885341 42,15268 1,705205 3,499044
17 305 314,6983 -9,69827 7,395752 5,18615 45,39667 1,797365 1,426058
18 315 309,2142 5,785828 13,18158 5,221425 44,69544 1,799683 2,524518
19 325 318,8196 6,180359 19,36194 5,274699 44,33441 1,805347 3,670719
20 350 330,9815 19,01852 38,38046 5,998058 61,03808 1,996322 6,398815 0,848071
21 355 360,774 -5,77402 32,60645 5,986856 59,65314 1,97783 5,446339 0,957854
22 365 367,6622 -2,66217 29,94427 5,828538 57,15 1,918379 5,137527 0,999089
23 350 376,2059 -26,2059 3,738373 6,754782 85,76815 2,171517 0,553441
24 350 355,5388 -5,53876 -1,80039 6,701911 83,37292 2,145907 -0,26864
25 360 350,2381 9,761871 7,961487 6,829409 83,86964 2,169479 1,165765
26 355 361,3042 -6,30423 1,657257 6,808402 82,10458 2,153733 0,243414
27 350 356,6053 -6,60535 -4,94809 6,800592 80,62482 2,143484 -0,7276
28 368 349,2756 18,72437 13,77628 7,242214 90,62396 2,252545 1,902219
29 370 369,9636 3,64E-02 13,81268 6,984863 87,38744 2,172449 1,977517
30 375 374,9668 3,32E-02 13,84592 6,745152 84,37412 2,097842 2,052721
31 380 379,9792 2,08E-02 13,86673 6,521007 81,56166 2,028097 2,126471
32 384 384,9886 -0,98865 12,87808 6,342544 78,96217 1,970979 2,030428
33 390 388,7943 1,20575 14,08383 6,182019 76,54004 1,919048 2,278193
34 400 394,8772 5,122803 19,20663 6,149922 75,01588 1,899704 3,12307
35 410 406,0947 3,905334 23,11197 6,083904 73,25812 1,871846 3,798871
36 425 417,6954 7,304596 30,41656 6,118782 72,68951 1,867471 4,971016
37 434,7812
38 445,7311
39 456,681
40 467,631
41 478,5809
42 489,5308

CFE 30,41656
MAD 6,118782
MSE 72,68951
 MAPE 1,867471
Trk,Signal 4,971016
R-square
Alpha=0,6
F(0)=260
F'(0)=260

C. PRODUK 3 METODE HWA

09-23- R-square
Actual Forecast by Forecast MAPE Tracking
2017 CFE MAD MSE
Data HWA Error (%) Signal
Month
1 250
2 255 250 5 5 5 25 1,960784 1
3 265 257,308 7,691986 12,69199 6,345993 42,08332 2,43171 2
4 270 272,0466 -2,0466 10,64539 4,912862 29,45174 1,873807 2,16684
5 290 277,9295 12,07047 22,71585 6,702263 58,51284 2,445912 3,389281 0,966389
6 280 303,015 -23,015 -0,29913 9,964808 152,7482 3,600657 -3,00E-02
7 275 285,2592 -10,2592 -10,5584 10,01388 144,8321 3,622318 -1,05437
8 270 270,0552 -5,52E-02 -10,6136 8,591212 124,1422 3,107767 -1,2354
9 270 262,5921 7,407867 -3,20572 8,443295 115,484 3,062253 -0,37968
10 265 265,9985 -0,99847 -4,20419 7,616092 102,7632 2,763867 -0,55201
11 265 262,2977 2,702332 -1,50186 7,124716 93,21715 2,589455 -0,2108
12 260 263,3079 -3,30786 -4,80972 6,77773 85,73758 2,46971 -0,70964
13 270 257,423 12,577 7,767273 7,261002 91,77452 2,65208 1,069725
14 275 272,4426 2,557373 10,32465 6,899184 85,21803 2,519608 1,496502
15 280 281,6114 -1,61139 8,713257 6,521484 79,3165 2,380743 1,336085
16 285 286,4753 -1,47525 7,238007 6,185069 74,17382 2,256536 1,170239
17 290 290,4114 -0,41141 6,826599 5,824215 69,54854 2,124369 1,172106
18 298 294,871 3,129028 9,955627 5,665675 66,03338 2,061171 1,757183
19 285 304,2176 -19,2176 -9,26193 6,418557 82,88233 2,321273 -1,44299
20 290 283,0902 6,90979 -2,35214 6,444411 81,03301 2,324506 -0,36499
21 295 286,7137 8,286346 5,934204 6,536508 80,41454 2,348727 0,907855
22 280 297,1804 -17,1804 -11,2462 7,04336 90,64079 2,529066 -1,59671
23 280 276,2188 3,781189 -7,465 6,895079 87,17063 2,475492 -1,08266
24 270 273,8821 -3,88214 -11,3471 6,764082 84,03587 2,430376 -1,67756
25 265 262,9885 2,011475 -9,33566 6,566057 80,70296 2,360737 -1,42181
26 275 257,9946 17,0054 7,669739 6,98363 89,04218 2,513659 1,098245
27 285 276,3222 8,677795 16,34753 7,04879 88,5138 2,534089 2,319197
28 289 294,3684 -5,36838 10,97916 6,986553 86,3029 2,509033 1,57147
29 310 297,9522 12,04782 23,02698 7,167313 88,40458 2,558224 3,212777
30 320 323,2379 -3,23789 19,78909 7,031815 85,71766 2,5049 2,814223
31 315 334,6059 -19,6059 0,183228 7,45095 95,6734 2,628873 2,46E-02
32 310 319,7865 -9,7865 -9,60327 7,52629 95,6767 2,645907 -1,27596
33 305 305,6107 -0,61072 -10,214 7,310179 92,69846 2,56948 -1,39723
34 298 298,0035 -3,51E-03 -10,2175 7,088765 89,88941 2,491653 -1,44137
35 289 290,8568 -1,85678 -12,0743 6,934883 87,34701 2,437265 -1,74109
36 270 280,9989 -10,9989 -23,0732 7,050997 88,30782 2,48402 -3,27233
37 256,4806
38 240,3479
39 224,2152
 40 208,0825
41 191,9497
42 175,817

CFE -23,0732
MAD 7,050997
MSE 88,30782
MAPE 2,48402
Trk,Signal -3,27233
R-square
c=1
Alpha=0,76
Beta=0,92
Gamma=0,01
F(0)=250
T(0)=0
S(1)=0

METODE HWM

09-23- R-square
Actual Forecast by Forecast MAPE Tracking
2017 CFE MAD MSE
Data HWM Error (%) Signal
Month
1 250
2 255 250 5 5 5 25 1,960784 1
3 265 257,3082 7,691833 12,69183 6,345917 42,08215 2,431681 2
4 270 272,0473 -2,0473 10,64453 4,913045 29,45192 1,873874 2,166585
5 290 277,9297 12,07025 22,71478 6,702347 58,51168 2,445945 3,389079 0,966392
6 280 303,0165 -23,0165 -0,3017 9,965174 152,761 3,60079 -3,03E-02
7 275 285,2601 -10,2601 -10,5618 10,01432 144,8457 3,622481 -1,05467
8 270 270,056 -5,60E-02 -10,6177 8,591701 124,1539 3,107945 -1,23581
9 270 262,5923 7,407684 -3,21005 8,443699 115,4939 3,0624 -0,38017
10 265 265,9983 -0,99826 -4,20831 7,616428 102,7719 2,763989 -0,55253
11 265 262,2975 2,702454 -1,50586 7,125031 93,22508 2,58957 -0,21135
12 260 263,3078 -3,30777 -4,81363 6,778007 85,74474 2,46981 -0,71018
13 270 257,4231 12,57687 7,763245 7,261246 91,78082 2,652168 1,069134
14 275 272,4432 2,556763 10,32001 6,899363 85,22361 2,519673 1,495791
15 280 281,6119 -1,61194 8,708069 6,521689 79,32181 2,380817 1,335247
16 285 286,4753 -1,47525 7,232819 6,18526 74,17878 2,256605 1,169364
17 290 290,4112 -0,41122 6,821594 5,824383 69,55317 2,124429 1,171213
18 298 294,8708 3,12915 9,950745 5,66584 66,03778 2,061231 1,75627
19 285 304,2178 -19,2178 -9,26703 6,418725 82,88696 2,321333 -1,44375
20 290 283,0914 6,90863 -2,3584 6,44451 81,03654 2,324541 -0,36595
21 295 286,7141 8,285858 5,92746 6,536577 80,41749 2,348752 0,906814
22 280 297,1807 -17,1807 -11,2532 7,043438 90,64404 2,529095 -1,59769
23 280 276,22 3,780029 -7,47318 6,895102 87,17335 2,475501 -1,08384
24 270 273,8825 -3,88251 -11,3557 6,764119 84,03858 2,43039 -1,67881
25 265 262,9887 2,011261 -9,34442 6,566083 80,70553 2,360748 -1,42314
26 275 257,9945 17,00546 7,661041 6,983658 89,04474 2,51367 1,096995
27 285 276,3229 8,677063 16,3381 7,04879 88,51576 2,53409 2,31786
28 289 294,3696 -5,3696 10,96851 6,986597 86,30527 2,509049 1,569935
 29 310 297,9523 12,04767 23,01617 7,16735 88,40674 2,558238 3,211253
30 320 323,2392 -3,2392 19,77698 7,031896 85,72004 2,504928 2,812467
31 315 334,6062 -19,6062 0,170776 7,45104 95,67614 2,628903 0,02292
32 310 319,7863 -9,78635 -9,61557 7,526372 95,67925 2,645935 -1,27758
33 305 305,6111 -0,61105 -10,2266 7,310268 92,70094 2,56951 -1,39894
34 298 298,0038 -3,81E-03 -10,2304 7,088861 89,89182 2,491685 -1,44317
35 289 290,8569 -1,85687 -12,0873 6,934978 87,34936 2,437298 -1,74295
36 270 280,999 -10,999 -23,0863 7,051093 88,31015 2,484052 -3,27414
37 256,4822
38 240,3511
39 224,22
40 208,0888
41 191,9577
42 175,8266

CFE -23,0863
MAD 7,051093
MSE 88,31015
MAPE 2,484052
Trk,Signal -3,27414
R-square
c=1
Alpha=0,76
Beta=0,92
Gamma=0,01
 F(0)=250
T(0)=0
S(1)=1

3. GRAFIK HASIL VERIFIKASI

A. Produk 1 Metode SA

Hasil Verifikasi Produk 1 (metode SA)

6
5
4
3
Tracking Signal

2 CL
1 TS
0 UCL
-1 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35
LCL
-2
-3
-4
Periode (bulan)
B. Produk 2 Metode SEST

Hasil Verifikasi Produk 2 (metode

SEST)
8
Tracking Signal 6

4 CL
2 TS

0 UCL
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 LCL
-2

-4
Periode (bulan)

C. Produk 3 Metode HWA

Hasil Verifikasi Produk 3 (metode HWA)

4
3
2
Tracking Signal

1 CL
0 TS
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 UCL
-1
-2 LCL

-3
-4
Periode (bulan)