The management of uveitic glaucoma that is refractory sity of opinions regarding the initial surgical manage-
to medical therapy is complex and challenging. Although ment of uveitic glaucoma, ranging from trabeculectomy
the reported success rate for trabeculectomy in uveitic without antimetabolites5,6 to trabeculectomy with 5-flu-
glaucoma is highly variable, it is historically lower than orouracil or mitomycin C712 to aqueous shunt proce-
the success rate for trabeculectomy in nonuveitic pa- dures.13,14,28,29 Trabeculectomy with 5-fluorouracil or
tients.16 The variable success rates have led to a diver- mitomycin C might have enhanced the success rate of
trabeculectomy for uveitic glaucoma in small series of
Received July 17, 2001; sent for revision October 18, 2001; accepted patients with relatively short follow-up period, and one
January 10, 2002. study noted a 67% success rate at 5 years using 5-fluo-
This work was supported in part by an unrestricted grant from Re-
search to Prevent Blindness, New York, NY, and a departmental core rouracil.712 Trabeculectomy failure in black patients
grant from the NEI (P30 EY06360) was significantly more common in the 5-fluorouracil
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Allen D. Beck, MD, study by Towler et al.,12 though only six black patients
Emory University School of Medicine, Department of Ophthalmology,
1365B Clifton Road NE, Atlanta, GA 30322; e-mail: abeck@emory. were enrolled in this study. The intermediate and long-
edu term success rate of trabeculectomy with mitomycin C in
uveitic patients and the possible risk factors for failure a vitrectomy, one was a penetrating keratoplasty, and one
remain largely undetermined. was a removal of a depot corticosteroid injection (total of
In this study, we report the intermediate-term results 20 incisional procedures). The patient demographics are
of trabeculectomy with antiproliferative agents (pre- summarized in Table 1.
dominantly mitomycin C) in a population with a majority
of black patients, and explore the effects of race, sex,
type of uveitis, previous incisional surgery, and subse- Surgical Procedures
quent cataract surgery on intraocular pressure (IOP) con-
Forty-four eyes of 44 patients underwent trabeculec-
trol.
tomy with antiproliferative agents. The trabeculectomies
were performed superiorly using a limbus-based con-
PATIENTS AND METHODS junctival flap and a modified Cairns technique. Intraop-
erative mitomycin C (Mutamycin; Bristol-Myers Squibb,
Patients Princeton, NJ) in a concentration of 0.20 or 0.25 mg/mL
was applied using a 7.5-mm diameter corneal light shield
The Emory University Human Investigations Commit-
(Merocel; Zomed Surgical, Jacksonville, FL) for a mean
tee (Institutional Review Board) approved the study pro-
of 3.4 minutes (range, 15 minutes). 5-Fluorouracil
tocol. Patients who received a diagnosis of glaucoma
(Adrucil; Pharmacia, Peapack, NJ) was administered in-
associated with inflammation using ICD-9 code 365.62
traoperatively (50-mg/mL concentration soaked in a cor-
between September 1995 and January 1999 were identi-
neal light shield for 14 minutes; mean, 2.3 minutes)
fied using a computerized search of the diagnostic data-
and/or postoperatively as subconjunctival injections of
base at the Emory Eye Center. Using this search method,
undiluted 50-mg/mL solution (range, 215 injections;
159 patients with glaucoma associated with inflamma-
mean, 5.9 injections). Of the 44 cases of initial trabecu-
tion were identified. Forty-four eyes of 44 patients who
lectomy at our institution, 32 received mitomycin C, 9
underwent one or more trabeculectomies for the manage-
received 5-fluorouracil alone, and 3 received both intra-
ment of uncontrolled IOP despite maximally tolerated
operative mitomycin C and postoperative 5-fluorouracil
medical therapy were included in the study. In patients
injections. Repeat trabeculectomy was performed on 10
who underwent bilateral filtration surgery, only the first
eyes of the 44 patients in the study, and mitomycin C was
eye to undergo surgery was included in the study. Pa-
used in all 10 eyes. Uveitis was noted to be controlled
tients who did not undergo surgery or those with con-
comitant neovascular glaucoma due to proliferative dia-
betic retinopathy, secondary inflammation after intraoc- TABLE 1. Patient demographic data summary
ular surgery, or inadequate records to ensure at least 6 Patients (%)
months of follow-up were excluded from the study.
Number 44
The mean age of patients at the time of the initial Gender
surgery was 47.4 years (range, 580 years). Fourteen Male 14 (31.8)
patients (31.8%) were male and 30 (68.2%) were female. Female 30 (68.2)
Race
Twenty-five patients were black (56.8%), 16 (36.4%) White 16 (36.4)
were white, 1 was Hispanic, and 2 were of Black 25 (56.8)
other/undetermined race. The following uveitic diagnosis Hispanic 1 (2.3)
Other 2 (4.5)
were present: idiopathic inflammation (23 patients), sar- Age (years)
coidosis (9 patients), arthropathy-related uveitis (5 pa- Mean 47.4
tients; 3 with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, 1 with adult- Standard deviation 18.3
Range 580
onset rheumatoid arthritis, 1 with ankylosing spondyli- Previous incisional surgery 14 (31.8)
tis), herpetic uveitis (3 patients), Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada Failed trabeculectomies 3
syndrome (2 patients), Fuchs heterochromic iridocyclitis Uveitis syndrome/disease
Idiopathic inflammation 23
(1 patient), and multifocal choroiditis (1 patient). Best- Sarcoidosis 9
corrected visual acuities ranged from 20/20 to hand mo- Herpes (simplex or zoster) 3
tions before surgery. Fourteen patients (31.8%) had un- Juvenile rheumatoid arthritis 3
Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada 2
dergone incisional surgery (average, 1.4 procedures per Rheumatoid arthritis (adult-onset) 1
eye) before their first surgery at our institution. Thirteen Fuchs heterochromic iridocyclitis 1
of the previous surgeries were cataract extractions, three Multifocal choroiditis 1
Ankylosing spondylitis 1
were trabeculectomies, one was a scleral buckle, one was
Statistical Methods
complete or qualified success (Table 2). The cumulative Analyses were performed to compare the percentage
probability of success was 78% at 1 year and 62% at 2 of patients with trabeculectomy failure with the risk fac-
years (Fig. 1). The IOP was reduced from a preoperative tors of race, gender, uveitis type, and previous incisional
mean of 40.3 mm Hg (range, 1674 mm Hg) on an surgery. These analyses showed a similar result to the
average of 2.9 glaucoma medications (range, 15) to analyses of time to failure, and gender was the only
13.3 mm Hg (range, 427 mm Hg) postoperatively (in- statistically significant risk factor (P 0.04, 2 test,
cluding failures) on an average of 1.3 glaucoma medi- Table 4).
cations (range, 05) . Twenty-three of 29 (79%) patients Fifteen of the 44 initial trabeculectomies failed: 1 pa-
in whom initial trabeculectomy was successful required tient with hand-motions vision preoperatively lost light
no medications postoperatively for IOP control (Table perception, a repeat trabeculectomy was recommended
3). The mean SD reduction in IOP (27 11.5 mm Hg) in 1 patient and was pending at the last follow-up, 1
was clinically and statistically significant (P 0.0001). patient whose outcome was defined as a failure was be-
Two patients with uncontrolled and widely fluctuating ing treated medically at the last follow-up, and 12 pa-
IOPs had an IOP lower than 21mm Hg on their preop- tients received subsequent surgical intervention for un-
erative visit. controlled IOP. Two of these patients had placement of
In black patients, the cumulative probability of success an aqueous shunt device, and 10 patients underwent a
for initial trabeculectomy was 55% at 2 years. In white
patients, the cumulative probability of success was 74%
at 2 years (P 0.58, log-rank test, Fig. 2). In patients
with previous incisional surgery and without previous
incisional surgery, the cumulative probabilities of suc-
cess were 70% and 58% at 2 years, respectively (P
0.59, log-rank test) (Fig. 3). In patients with idiopathic
uveitis and with sarcoid-related uveitis (the only uveitis
categories considered for statistical analysis), the cumu-
lative probabilities of success were 45% and 74% at 2
years (P 0.17, log-rank test) (Fig. 4). In males and
females, the cumulative probabilities of success were
39% and 71% at 2 years (P 0.02, log-rank test) (
Fig. 5).
Twenty of 32 (63%) patients who underwent trabec-
ulectomy with mitomycin C were successful compared
with 7 of 9 (78%) patients who received 5-fluorouracil
alone and 2 of 3 patients (67%) who received both 5-flu-
orouracil and mitomycin C. Mitomycin C and 5-fluoro- FIG. 2. The product-limit estimate for the cumulative probability
uracil were not analyzed statistically as mitomycin C was of success and months of follow-up after trabeculectomy in black
and white patients. The hash marks represent patients whose
used in cases deemed to be at higher risk for failure in trabeculectomies had not failed at the time of the last follow-up
this retrospective study. examination.
FIG. 3. The product-limit estimate for the cumulative probability FIG. 5. The product-limit estimate for the cumulative probability
success and months of follow-up after trabeculectomy in patients of success and months of follow-up after trabeculectomy in male
with and without a history of incisional surgery. The hash marks and female patients. The hash marks represent patients whose
represent patients whose trabeculectomies had not failed at the trabeculectomies had not failed at the time of the last follow-up
time of the last follow-up examination. examination.
* Initial trabeculectomy (n 44), percent failure without respect to time, P for 2 test.
glaucoma medications (range, 24). The mean postcata- sional surgery were paradoxical: patients without previ-
ract extraction time to trabeculectomy failure was 5.8 ous surgery had a lower success rate than those with
months (range, 015 months). previous surgery (58% vs. 70%), though the difference
was not statistically significant (Fig. 3). Repeat trabecu-
DISCUSSION lectomy on eyes that failed an initial trabeculectomy with
antiproliferative agents in our study showed a 71% cu-
Other studies of trabeculectomy with antiproliferative mulative probability of success at 1 year, similar to our
agents in uveitic patients have shown success rates rang- results at 1 year with initial trabeculectomy.
ing from 50% to 90%, with lower success rates noted A difference in outcome related to uveitis category
with longer follow-up periods.712,15 Our cumulative was noted, with a 74% success at 2 years for sarcoid-
probability of success of 78% at 1 year and 62% at 2 related uveitis and a 45% success rate for idiopathic uve-
years for trabeculectomy with antiproliferative agents itis (Fig. 4). Although the difference between these two
(Fig. 1) is less than the 78% success at 5 years for tra- groups was relatively large, a statistically significant dif-
beculectomy without antiproliferative agents reported by ference was not noted, likely because of an inadequate
Stavrou and Murray6 using identical success criteria. sample size despite an arbitrary grouping of uveitis type
However, the patient population studied by Stavrou and into four categories.
Murray was markedly different from ours, with a pre- A statistically significant difference in trabeculectomy
ponderance of white patients with no previous ocular outcome was noted in our study, with a 39% success at
surgery. The authors speculated that the additional risk 2 years in male patients compared with 71% in female
factors of previous incisional surgery and Afro- patients (P 0.02) (Fig. 5). Gender has not previously
Caribbean race might lead to worse outcomes with tra- been noted as a risk factor for trabeculectomy failure
beculectomy surgery in uveitic glaucoma. and, this finding may be due to unequal sample size (30
Previous incisional surgery and black race have been female patients vs. 14 male patients), and to the fact that
noted to be risk factors for failure of trabeculectomy a high percentage of male patients (8 of 14, 57%) had
surgery in patients with glaucoma not associated with idiopathic uveitis associated with a poor prognosis. Male
uveitis.1922 Towler et al.12 reported 82% success at 2 patients were also younger than female patients in our
years and 67% at 5 years with 5-fluorouracil trabeculec- study (42.0 vs. 49.9 years, P 0.19).
tomy in uveitic patients, noting significantly decreased Cataract formation or progression was a frequent
success in black patients compared with white and Asian event after trabeculectomy with antiproliferative agents
patients. We noted a cumulative probability of success of in our study, and 16 of 31 phakic patients (52%) required
74% at 2 years for white patients and 55% at 2 years for cataract extraction. Cataract formation is a common
black patients (Fig. 2). Our failure to document a statis- event in uveitic patients without glaucoma surgery due to
tically significant difference between white and black chronic inflammation or corticosteroid treatment.23 An
patients may have been because of our use of mitomycin increased risk of cataract formation has been noted after
C with trabeculectomy (24 of 26 black patients vs. 10 of trabeculectomy in patients with normal-tension glau-
16 white patients received mitomycin C), along with an coma,24 and one study of 5-fluorouracil trabeculectomy
inadequate sample size. Our results with previous inci- in uveitic patients reported cataract progression requiring
cataract surgery in 7 of 10 phakic cases.8 The cataract rence after trabeculectomy with antiproliferative agents,
formation or progression noted in more than half of our with relatively frequent loss of glaucoma control after
phakic patients was likely multifactorial due to the uve- cataract surgery. The use of mitomycin C appears to
itic process, chronic corticosteroid treatment, or glau- improve the chance of trabeculectomy success in black
coma surgery. Management of such cases poses a treat- patients with uveitis when compared with 5-fluoroura-
ment dilemma between improvement of visual acuity cil12. Further study is needed to clarify the role of anti-
and possible loss of IOP control. Four of the 16 eyes proliferative agents in trabeculectomy for uveitic glau-
(25%) that underwent cataract extraction in our study coma, the role of aqueous shunt devices, and surgical
required repeat glaucoma surgery due to failure of the strategies to avoid reoperation in patients with cataract
filtering bleb and loss of IOP control, despite reinstitu- and uveitic glaucoma.
tion of medical therapy. Cataract surgery after trabecu-
lectomy surgery is a risk factor for failure in uveitic REFERENCES
patients compared with patients with primary open-angle 1. Panek WC, Holland GN, Lee DA, et al. Glaucoma in patients with
glaucoma25. Cataract extraction combined with trabecu- uveitis. Br J Ophthalmol 1990;74:2237.
2. Krupin T, Dorfman NH, Spector SM, et al. Secondary glaucoma
lectomy usually does not lower IOP as effectively as associated with uveitis. Glaucoma 1988;10:8590.
trabeculectomy alone, though this procedure has not 3. Hoskins HD Jr, Hetherington J Jr, Shaffer RN. Surgical manage-
been well studied in uveitic patients26,27. Combined cata- ment of the inflammatory glaucomas. Perspect Ophthalmol 1977;
1:17381.
ract extraction with an Ahmed glaucoma valve (New 4. Hill RA, Nguyen QH, Baerveldt G, et al. Trabeculectomy and
World Medical, Rancho Cucamonga, CA) has been re- Molteno implantation for glaucomas associated with uveitis. Oph-
ported to be successful in small numbers of eyes.16 Mol- thalmology 1993;100:903908.
5. Stavrou P, Misson GP, Rowson NJ, et al. Trabeculectomy in uve-
teno reported on 40 eyes of 35 patients who received a itis: are antimetabolites necessary at the first procedure? Ocul Im-
single- or double-plate Molteno implant, and noted an munol Inflamm 1995;3:20916.
87% glaucoma control success rate at 5 years and a 77% 6. Stavrou P, Murray PI. Long-term follow-up of trabeculectomy
without antimetabolites in patients with uveitis. Am J Ophthalmol
success at 10 years.28 Ten of 20 (50%) phakic eyes in 1999;128:4349.
Moltenos study subsequently required cataract extrac- 7. Jampel HD, Jabs DA, Quigley HA. Trabeculectomy with 5-fluo-
tion, similar to the 52% noted in our study. Intraocular rouracil for adult inflammatory glaucoma. Am J Ophthalmol 1990;
109:16873.
pressure control was maintained in all 10 eyes after cata- 8. Patitsas CJ, Rockwood EJ, Meisler DM, et al. Glaucoma filtering
ract extraction28, similar to another study by Bhat- surgery with postoperative 5-fluorouracil in patients with intraoc-
tacharyya et al.29 addressing cataract extraction after ular inflammatory disease. Ophthalmology 1992;99:5949.
9. Prata JA Jr, Neves RA, Minckler DS, et al. Trabeculectomy with
aqueous shunt placement. However, the corneal decom- mitomycin c in glaucoma associated with uveitis. Opthalmic Surg
pensation rate of 27% (8 of 40 eyes) noted in Moltenos 1994:25:61620.
paper is a complication well known to aqueous shunt 10. Wright MM, McGehee RF, Pederson JE. Intraoperative mitomy-
cin-c for glaucoma associated with ocular inflammation. Ophthal-
devices.2830 We are unable to comment on the decision mic Surg Lasers 1997;28:3706.
to perform trabeculectomy instead of an aqueous shunt 11. Towler HMA, Bates AK, Broadway DC, et al. Primary trabecu-
procedure on the basis of this study, because we per- lectomy with 5-fluorouracil for glaucoma secondary to uveitis.
Ocul Immunol Inflamm 1995;3:16370.
formed trabeculectomy with 5-fluorouracil or mitomycin 12. Towler HMA, McCluskey P, Shaer B, et al. Long-term follow-up
C as the initial glaucoma surgical therapy in all cases. of trabeculectomy with intraoperative 5-fluorouracil for uveitis-
However, all of our patients had controlled uveitis. Hill related glaucoma. Ophthalmology 2000;107:18228.
13. Valimaki J, Airaksinen PJ, Tunlonen A. Molteno implantation for
et al.31 noted that aqueous shunt devices were more secondary glaucoma in juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. Arch Oph-
likely to control IOP than trabeculectomy when signifi- thalmol 1997;115:12536.
cant postoperative inflammation was likely. 14. DeMata A, Burk S, Netland PA, et al. Management of uveitic
glaucoma with Ahmed glaucoma valve implantation. Ophthalmol-
We report the results of a retrospective study of tra- ogy 1999;106:216872.
beculectomy surgery with antiproliferative agents, pri- 15. Heuer DK, Parrish II RK, Gressel MG, et al. 5-Fluorouracil and
marily mitomycin C, in uveitic patients with medically glaucoma filtering surgery: a pilot study. Ophthalmology 1984;91:
38493.
uncontrolled glaucoma. Our study suffers from limita- 16. Kaplan EL, Meier P. Nonparametric estimation from incomplete
tions that are common with retrospective studies, includ- observations. J Am Stat Assoc 1958;53:45781.
ing different surgeons and evolving antiproliferative 17. Kalbfleisch JD, Prentice RL. The Statistical Analysis of Failure
Time Data. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1980.
agent use in a nonrandomized fashion. Different concen- 18. Fisher LD, Van Belle G. Biostatistics: A Methodology for the
trations or duration of mitomycin C application might Health Sciences. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1993.
have led to different outcomes. We noted a statistically 19. Heuer DK, Gressel MG, Parrish II RK, et al. Trabeculectomy in
aphakic eyes. Ophthalmology 1984;91:104551.
significant decrease in the success rates of male patients. 20. Tomey KF, Traverso CE. The glaucomas in aphakia and pseudo-
Cataract formation or progression was a common occur- phakia. Surv Ophthalmol 1991;36:79112.
21. Freedman J, Shen E, Abrens M. Trabeculectomy in a black Ameri- sification combined with superior trabeculectomy. Arch Ophthal-
can glaucoma population. Br J Ophthalmol 1976;60:5734. mol 1997;115:31823.
22. David R, Freedman J, Luntz MH. Comparative studies of Watsons 28. Molteno ACB, Sayawat N, Herbison P. Otago glaucoma surgery
and Cairns trabeculectomies in a black population with open angle outcome study: Long-term results of uveitis with secondary glau-
glaucoma. Br J Ophthalmol 1977;61:1179. coma drained by Molteno implants. Ophthalmology 2001;108:
23. Belfort R, Nusenblatt RB. Surgical approaches to uveitis. Int Oph- 60513.
thalmol Clin 1990;30:3147.
29. Bhattacharyya CA, WuDunn D, Lakhani V, et al. Cataract surgery
24. Collaborative Normal-Tension Glaucoma Study Group. The effec-
after tube shunts. J Glaucoma 2000;9:4537.
tiveness of intraocular pressure reduction in the treatment of nor-
mal-tension glaucoma. Am J Ophthalmol 1998;126:498505. 30. Topouzis F, Coleman AL, Choplin N, et al. Follow-up of the
25. Chen PP, Weaver YK, Budenz DL, et al. Trabeculectomy function original cohort with the Ahmed Glaucoma Valve Implant. Am J
after cataract extraction. Ophthalmology 1998;105:192835. Ophthalmol 1999;128:198204.
26. Shields MB. Another reevaluation of combined cataract and glau- 31. Hill RA, Nguyen QH, Baerveldt G, et al. Trabeculectomy and
coma surgery. Am J Ophthalmol 1993;115:80611. Molteno implantation for glaucomas associated with uveitis. Oph-
27. Park HJ, Weitzman M, Caprioli J. Temporal corneal phacoemul- thalmology 1993;100:9038.