BMJ 2003;326;1444-1448
doi:10.1136/bmj.326.7404.1444
These include:
References This article cites 17 articles, 3 of which can be accessed free at:
http://bmj.com/cgi/content/full/326/7404/1444#BIBL
Email alerting Receive free email alerts when new articles cite this article - sign up in the
service box at the top right corner of the article
Topic collections Articles on similar topics can be found in the following collections
Notes
Clinical review
Chagas disease is a parasitic infection that has far reaching consequences for public health and
national economies in Latin America. The latest molecular typing methods may help in developing
targeted, effective control programmes
which implies that in some localities the local domestic groups IId and IIe.1 11 Phylogenetics analysis based on
triatomine vector (Rhodnius prolixus) might be moving DNA sequence data has recently confirmed that strains
between infested palm trees and houses. This formed T cruzi IId and IIe are probably derived by
the basis of the important concept that typing of T hybridisation of strains similar to IIb with IIc or IIa.12
cruzi strains can act as an indicator of whether a link Does T cruzi have an active capacity for genetic
exists between domestic and silvatic transmission exchange? With the aid of genetic transformation and
cycles. drug resistant markers to select recombinants, T cruzi I
A plethora of molecular methods has since been hybrids have recently been produced experimentally,9
applied to genotyping T cruzi strains by analysing DNA proving that T cruzi is still capable of genetic exchange.
polymorphisms. Methods include genetic fingerprint- Hybrids, recovered from the mammalian stage of the
ing by random amplification of polymorphic DNA life cycle, seem to result from fusion, followed by loss of
(RAPD), comparing the sequences of mini-exon genes genetic material (genome erosion), probably in
and intergenic ribosomal spacers or other DNA conjunction with some homologous recombination. In
targets, and comparing the sizes of microsatellites. the malaria parasite (Plasmodium) genetic exchange is
Based on all these methods two principal subdivisions an obligatory part of its life cycle, whereas in T cruzi it
of T cruzi have been designated by international is not. Neither does T cruzi have quite the same genetic
consensus.9 These subdivisions are named T cruzi I, exchange as African trypanosomes, which is thought
corresponding with zymodeme I, and T cruzi II, incor- to occur in the salivary glands of tsetse flies.13
porating zymodeme II. Up to five subgroups of T cruzi Nevertheless, the implications of genetic hybridisation
II have been recognised, named T cruzi IIa to IIe.10 in T cruzi are profound, allowing recombination across
The question arises whether the great diversity of T greater genetic distances than mendelian inheritance
cruzi is in part due to genetic recombination between and potentially facilitating rapid speciation and evolu-
isolates. This is an important question because a capac- tion, possibly with adaptation to new hosts.
ity for genetic exchange could facilitate the spread of The associations of the subdivisions of T cruzi
virulent strains and drug resistant genotypes. Popula- strains with natural hosts and vectors are not yet fully
tion genetics has been used to search for recombina- defined; in particular the hosts of some T cruzi II sub-
tion by examining allele frequencies in natural groups are unresolved. However, separate evolutionary
populations of T cruzi. Random mating (panmixia) can histories have been proposed for T cruzi I (associated
be looked for by using the Hardy-Weinberg test, or with the vector tribe Rhodniini, the marsupial opossum
conversely departure from panmixia can be detected Didelphis, and the palm tree habitat) and T cruzi II
by using linkage disequilibrium tests. These methods (associated with the vector tribe Triatomini and
have been applied to field isolates from dispersed geo- terrestrial mammals).14
graphical regions. The results indicate that T cruzi is From an epidemiological viewpoint it is striking
predominantly propagated clonally, without genetic that T cruzi II is the agent of Chagas disease in the
exchange.10 Nevertheless, isoenzyme profiles typical of southern cone countries of South America, where
hybrid strains were noted long ago for the T cruzi sub- megasyndromes occur, whereas T cruzi I is endemic in
northern South America and Central America, where
chronic Chagas disease is said to be more benign. Fur-
Initial acute phase
thermore, the hybrid strains T cruzi IId and IIe are par-
(infection and seropositivity are subsequently
usually life long) ticularly prevalent among communities in some
endemic regions of the southern cone countries of
Asymptomatic
Symptomatic South America.11
(Chagoma, parasitaemia)
Chronic phase
Identifying cryptic vector species and
intraspecific variation
Indeterminate Symptomatic Designing control campaigns for triatomine bugs
depends on understanding whether recurrent infesta-
Immunocompromised patients: tions are due to residual domestic populations that
reactivation of acute phase survive spraying with insecticides or to reinvasion of
bugs from silvatic habitats (see below). It is essential
therefore to be able to identify domestic and silvatic
Cardiomyopathy
triatomine species and populations accurately. Mor-
(ECG abnormalities, megacardia, phology, including dimensions and colour, has been
apical aneurysm) used for classic triatomine taxonomy.5 Unfortunately,
the size and colour of triatomines seem to evolve rap-
idly, giving smaller domestic populations or camou-
flaged colour morphs of the same species. Conversely,
Megaoesophagus Megacolon
some valid species are very similar and are often
confused, notably those in the genus Rhodnius. Two
new approaches have been developed to identify cryp-
and/or
tic triatomine species. The first entails size free
comparisons of morphological landmark configura-
tions, known as geometric morphometrics or pro-
crustes analysis (Procrustes of Greek mythology either
Fig 2 Chagas disease: clinical phases (reproduced with permission from James Patterson) stretched or surgically trimmed guests to fit his bed
precisely).15 The second approach is to analyse genetic entire geographical range. The southern cone pro-
diversity directly by sequencing both mitochondrial gramme was born from this idea.3
(maternally inherited) and nuclear genes.16 The control methods used in the programme are
Rhodnius prolixus, the most notorious domestic simple3: spraying houses and domestic animal shelters
vector in Venezuela,17 Colombia, and Central America, with residual pyrethroid insecticide to kill triatomines
illustrates the application of the molecular approach. and serological screening of blood donors to stop
R prolixus is virtually indistinguishable from the transmission by blood transfusion. Spraying pro-
species R robustus. DNA sequencing has now shown grammes are carefully designed, with preparatory,
that R robustus, formerly of controversial status, is not attack, and surveillance or consolidation stages. Health
only a valid species but probably encompasses several education and participation of communities are vital to
cryptic species with different geographical distribu- surveillance for persistent bug infestations. Serological
tions.16 18 So far colonies of R robustus have been surveys of children born after the control programme
reported only from silvatic habitats, although adult started track down pockets where vectors remain and
bugs occasionally fly into houses. None of the silvatic detect cases of congenital transmission. Long term
populations of R robustus are yet proved to replenish planning and commitment to the programme have
the domestic transmission cycle. In contrast, the same helped to prevent diversion of resources.
molecular approach indicates that R prolixus can be The success of the southern cone programme is
found in both domestic and silvatic habitats, at least in unequivocal. Uruguay was certified free of transmis-
parts of Venezuela, and therefore it may well reinvade sion in 1997, Chile in 1999, central and southern Brazil
houses from infested palm trees. in 2001, four provinces of Argentina in 2002, and one
Morphometrics and comparisons of DNA department of Paraguay in 2003. This success has been
sequences can also be used to explore wider relations dependent on the strength of the public health based
between triatomine species by phylogenetics analysis, and economic arguments for controlling transmission,
although morphometric phylogenetics has limited the availability of proved interventions, the shared
scope. Molecular clocks based on rates of change in public health problem, shared political will, adequate
DNA sequences can date when triatomine tribes political stability, unequivocal support by health minis-
diverged. A new molecular clock for the insects implies
tries, allocation of resources, and concurrent action
that the tribe Rhodniini diverged up to 90 million years
across national boundaries. The early stages of the ini-
ago, about the time when palm trees evolved.19
tiative were driven by a common purpose emerging
from research conferences, and by the vigour of key
individuals and networks of collaboration.3 Sustainabil-
Programmes to control Chagas disease ity will be dependent on: unimpeded resources; contin-
ued surveillance to consolidate control and avoid
The costs of coping with the public health burden of
resurgence, and on international monitoring and
chronic Chagas disease are enormous, as a result of
accurate public reporting of progress. The southern
the morbidity, mortality, hospitalisation, drug treat-
cone programme shows what can be achieved if
ment of arrhythmias, provision of pacemakers, and
disease control transcends national boundaries. It has
surgery. There is no vaccine, and none is likely because
been suggested that similar principles could be
the role of autoimmunity in pathogenesis is under dis-
adopted to combat African trypanosomiasis.20
pute. No prophylactic drugs exist, and treatment for
infection with benznidazole,2 although potentially life The southern cone initiative has spawned three
saving in the acute phase, entails prolonged adminis- others: an Andean Pact control programme
tration and side effects and is not guaranteed to elimi- (Venezuela, Colombia, Peru, Ecuador), a Central
nate T cruzi. However, the availability of comparatively American control programme, and a surveillance pro-
low cost and proved interventions to prevent transmis- gramme to protect the Amazon basin from incursion
sion, in the form of spraying houses infested with bugs by domestic triatomines.4 21 The simple southern cone
and screening blood and organ donors, provided principle of eliminating vectors may be directly
indisputable economic justification for establishing transposable to parts of the range of Triatoma dimidiata
control campaigns.3 Preventing transmission is there- (Ecuador, Peru) and Rhodnius ecuadoriensis (northern
fore an excellent investment for the governments of Peru), where these bugs seem to be confined to houses.
the countries of Latin America where T cruzi is Vector control is less straightforward for species
endemic. with both silvatic and domestic populations such as
Unlike the tsetse fly vectors of African trypano- R prolixus and T brasiliensis. In this context molecular
somiasis, triatomine bugs do not fly to hosts to take a methods, by determining the distribution of T cruzi
blood meal. The threat from triatomine bugs arises and triatomine genotypes, can define whether intera-
because some species colonise houses in large ction occurs between domestic and silvatic transmis-
numbers, feeding from humans, domestic mammals, sion cycles. In principle this molecular epidemiological
and chickens (although the latter are not susceptible to approach, in conjunction with ecological data, will
T cruzi, they are an important blood source). T infestans allow estimation of the risk that houses will be
is the domestic vector of Chagas disease in the vast reinvaded after spraying. In localities at risk of
southern cone region of South America. Surprisingly, reinvasion control strategies can then be modifiedfor
silvatic T infestans is known only from central Bolivia3 example, by repeating spraying or more frequent
and from parts of the Chaco region of South America. surveillance, or by devising some tacticsuch as spray-
This fact has prompted the idea that a united ing palm treesto attack triatomines in silvatic foci.
international campaign to spray houses infested with Where these modifications are not necessary the cost
T infestans could eliminate the species from almost its of control will be lower.
Take a holiday to Kenya and a fit and healthy 56 year old woman ulcer in the duodenum. Incidentally, she was also infected with
who had never taken non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs or Helicobacter pylori.
aspirin. Add advice from a friend to take aspirin to minimise the She made an uneventful recovery, had helicobacter eradication
risk of deep vein thrombosis. Take one aspirin on the outward therapy, and was warned not to take aspirin in the future.
bound journey and two within 36 hours of return. I suspect we are in for many more such patients and worry
Result? Well, predictably coffee ground vomiting and melaena about the consequences should the bleed occur in a remote area
stool five days after return, with a haemoglobin concentration of of the world during a holiday.
69 g/l when admitted to hospital five days later. The patient Tina Diggory locum consultant in gastroenterology, Hull Royal
required a 5 unit blood transfusion, and endoscopy confirmed an Infirmary