Make 'em Work for It

A student makes a mistake, and what do you do?

Blurt out the right answer? You could do that. But you could also help students
see their mistake and guide them towards figuring out the correct answer by
themselves.

Try this simple strategy:

1. write the sentence containing the mistake on the board,

2. ask your student what's wrong with it, and
3. have them correct it.

How to Correct Mistakes

Throughout their studies, students will make lots of mistakes. It is an important part of the
learning process. If they are not making mistakes then they are not being given difficult
enough topics and structures to work with. You have to choose material that is challenging
but manageable for your class and correct mistakes in positive ways. Singling out students
who make errors will make students feel self conscious and shy so some tact when correcting
mistakes is important.

How To Proceed

1. 1

Practice
When introducing new vocabulary, emphasize correct pronunciation and during the
drilling exercises have students practice using choral repetition. This means students
are not immediately singled out to pronounce new and unfamiliar words and they can
become accustomed to the sound of the words together. The next step is generally to
call on students or have students volunteer to pronounce words or phrases. It is an
important step to check pronunciation on an individual basis however it means that a
student is being singled out to perform independently in front of the entire class.
Correcting mistakes at this level is the most challenging but you can use the same
process to correct errors in any situation.

2. 2
 Self- Correction
The best way to correct mistakes is to have students correct themselves. Ideally a
student will realize a mistake has been made and fix it automatically but that is not
always the case. If a student answers a question incorrectly you can gently prompt
them to revisit their answer. One of the ways to do this is to repeat what the student
said placing emphasis on the incorrect portion, for instance I have play baseball.
and saying it in a questioning way. At this point the student has an opportunity to
think about and revise his initial response. You may have your own method of
prompting students with a facial expression or phrase which they associate with being
incorrect but avoid saying words such as wrong, incorrect, or no in response to
mistakes. They are negative and will have ill effects on your students confidence in
the classroom.

3. 3

Peer Correction
When a student is unable to self correct, peer correction might be appropriate. If a
student raises his hand while you are waiting for a student to self correct, you may
want to call on that student for the correct answer or, after waiting a short time for a
student to self correct, you could ask the whole class the same question and encourage
a choral response. Especially with challenging questions, this is a good method
because then it is unknown who in the class has the right answer and who does not.
Just repeat and emphasize the correct answer by writing it on the board and explaining
why it is correct. This is a good method of correcting mistakes because it shifts focus
away from the student that provided the original incorrect answer.

4. 4

Providing the Answer: Last Resort

Sometimes individual students as well as entire classes have no idea what the answer
to your question is. If providing hints and examples does not lead them to the correct
answer, you will have to provide it. Generally this is a last resort and means that a lot
of review activities may be in order but keeping a positive attitude and explaining the
answer good-naturedly will do a lot to keep your students positive about learning
English. Asking similar questions in a simpler form will build student confidence
again so that the lesson can continue smoothly.

At every stage of an activity, praise should be given. If a student volunteers to answer a

question, you can thank him immediately for volunteering which will boost his self
confidence. At that point if the student provides an incorrect answer you can correct in an
encouraging way by saying Almost. If the student gives the correct answer, be sure to say
Good job! or Excellent work! As long as you are positive in your method of correcting
errors, reassure your students that they are doing well, and do not get upset with them for
making mistakes, they will continue to volunteer and try their best because making mistakes
is OK. That is how learning should be. If students never take risks, they will not improve.

5 Non-Verbal Ways to Do Error

Correction
Effective error correction is one of the things ESL teachers struggle with the
most.

If you correct them too much, you might make them feel discouraged and compromise their
fluency for the sake of accuracy. If you correct them too little, theyll continue making the
same mistakes. Achieving the right balance is a daunting task, although not an impossible
one. And when doing on the spot correcting, do you simply supply the right answer?
Although it is certainly an option, you should sometimes give your students the chance to
correct themselves. There are several verbal strategies you may use, like asking them to
repeat what theyve just said, or repeating the sentence yourself but pausing to let the student
fill in the blank correctly.

However, here are the 5 best non-verbal ways to do error correction.

How To Proceed

1. 1

Use a grammar flag

Once you have your students actively engaged in some drilling exercises, use a little
red flag to flag their mistakes. The flag goes up if they make a mistake and students
instantly know they should go back and say it again. You may also use the flag in
others types of activities, or whenever you wish to work on accuracy.

2. 2

Use facial expressions

Students are sometimes self-conscious enough without having to endure constant

corrections. So, how can you effectively correct them and not stomp on their
confidence in the process? When a student makes a mistake, like saying a verb in the
past tense incorrectly, use an exaggerated facial expression to signal the mistake. Give
them an open-mouthed, wide-eyed stare. Or arch an eyebrow. The more
theatrical the facial expression is, the funnier it'll be. Youll be effectively signalling
that a mistake has been made, but students wont take it so seriously.

3. 3

Use gestures

Another very effective way to show students theyve made a mistake is through
gestures, some of which may be specific to the kind of mistake. Teachers typically
gesture backwards with their hands or point to the back to show students they
havent used the verb in the past. Students often use the wrong pronouns; its quite
common to hear a student say, She went to the movies with your boyfriend. To
which you simply reply by pointing to yourself with a look of shock or surprise. You
may also implement a gesture to indicate that students should repeat something, or say
 it again, and if they repeat the mistake, you can raise a finger to show them where in
the sentence the mistake is, though they have to figure out what they are doing wrong.

4. 4

Use visual reminders

Very often students forget the final -s in the simple present, third person singular.
You may have a big S stuck on a wall that you can point to on such occasions, or point
to something that will trigger the right response, like the picture of an S-shaped snake.
Visual reminders are also great for vocabulary-related mistakes. A student may say
childs instead of children. You point to a picture of a group of children to indicate
that something is wrong; the student has to figure out he or she used the wrong plural.

5. 5

Use finger counting

How can you correct mistakes in word order in a non-verbal way? Finger counting is
simply perfect for this! Say a student used the wrong word order to ask a question:
You are a teacher? Ask the student to repeat the question and then show him or her
how you count the words on your fingers. Show the student how the first two fingers
are in the wrong order, so that the student understands the question should start with
Are you

You can get as creative as you like with your facial expressions, gestures, and visual
reminders. Remember here that the ultimate goal is to help students learn from their
mistakes, and if you simply supply the right answer, they may not fully internalize it.
Some teachers have even been known to hum well-known songs to trigger the correct
response, like Depeche Modes People are People when students make the classic mistake,
people is.

Do you have any suggestions for non-verbal error correction? Please share them below!

The Upside of Errors

When and Why to Avoid Correcting Your Students
I teached math in my home country, a student shares on career day. The
teacher raises her eyebrows and waits for the student to continue.

I mean, I taught math in my home country. This is a perfect example of when not correcting
an ESL student is the best way to handle an error. By signaling her student with a small
gesture, the teacher helps the student understands that he made an error. He thinks back to
what he said, and then produces the correct structure. This is what in language studies is
called self-correction.

Self-correction is just what it sounds like when students correct their own mistakes rather
than depending on the teacher to correct them. Self-correction happens naturally in speech,
both with first and second language learners and in spoken and written language. And
students who are able to self-correct have many advantages over those who do not.

Self-correction Basics

1. 1

Students who self-correct show that they understand the language.

They are able to recognize mistakes, even in their own speaking and writing, and
know what the correct structure should look like. They are then able to produce
that correct language on their own even if it is on the second try.

2. 2

Students who self-correct are more prepared for the real world.

They depend less on their teacher and more on themselves, and they take more
responsibility for their own quality of language. When they do this, they can better
function in real life language situations and are able to better communicate with native
speakers, even when they make mistakes, because they are able to identify and correct
those mistakes without help from someone else.

3. 3

Self-correction begets increased awareness.

Students must have some level of self-awareness when it comes to their language
use if they are going to self-correct. But as students learn to self-correct, they
become more aware of their language use and therefore any mistakes they are making.
When students are more aware of mistakes, they make fewer. As a result, they become
better at self-correcting. Getting students to self-correct, then, begins a positive cycle
of awareness and correct language production.

Developing Self-Correcting Students

Self-correction can be developed. For students with little experience self-correcting, you can
give them sentences with errors that they need to correct. Spending a few minutes on this type
of activity each day will increase student awareness of language errors. Creating examples
inspired by actual student errors is a good way to make sure your sentence corrections will
make a real impact on how your students speak. You can also use examples depicting errors
common with speakers of your students first language. You may also create examples that
highlight grammatical concepts you have recently taught in class. Each of these may serve a
different purpose, but all of them will help your students become better self-correctors.

Another way to encourage error awareness and self-correction is to signal your students when
they make an error. You can use verbal signals, asking them to repeat themselves for
example, or use simple physical clues like raising your eyebrows. If students still struggle
with identifying their mistakes, give a more obvious signal like raising you hand when they
make an error. The more natural your signals are, and the more subtle they are, the more
prepared your students will be for self-correcting on their own.

How Much is Too Much?

Making students aware of their mistakes is like walking a thin line too much and you will
end up discouraging your students rather than empowering them. For this reason, remember
what level your students are at. Dont expect perfect speech from beginning level students,
and dont expect them to correct every error they make. For any student, when errors occur in
many contexts, try focusing on one or two and let the rest slide (for now). Building a students
foundation in self-correction is often a slow process and one that should not be rushed. You
can always help them tackle more areas of error later, and you want them to feel good about
the language they are producing.

Creating a culture of self-correction can be challenging.

Sometimes students will realize their mistakes on their own. Other times the teacher will have
to offer a signal that self-correction is needed. She may make a physical signal or say
something like, What was that? Excuse me? Though establishing a classroom culture where
students self-correct may be challenging and time consuming at first, it is well worth it as
your students become more effective and more confident English users. They become more
independent and are ready to take their English skills out into the real world.

As ESL teachers, there are tons of activities we can plan.

There are several factors in the classroom setting that we can control. But we cant control the
number of mistakes our students make. And we all know that sometimes mistakes can really
hinder the flow of the lesson and even cause delays. Mistakes also affect students self-esteem
and their ability to communicate. So, how can we correct mistakes in a way that is less
threatening? Self-correction comes to the rescue!

Why Students Should Learn to Self-Correct

It trains them to listen to themselves. Too many students rush through answers without even
taking a few seconds to gather their thoughts.
It helps them take responsibility for their learning. The teacher is not there to correct them
all the time, and the teacher cant correct every single mistake.
It helps students gain a better awareness of the language. Theyre not just spewing things in
English. They really get it.
It makes students more autonomous in their learning. They become increasingly less
dependent on the teacher as they learn to self-correct.
It boosts confidence. When a teacher corrects a student, this mistake is singled out. The
more a teacher corrects someone, the more aware they are of their mistakes their
confidence suffers. But by self-correcting, the student is taking charge; corrections are less
obtrusive.
It allows students to gauge their own problem areas. Some might come to realize they
always make verb tense mistakes. Others might see they need to improve their vocabulary
and word choice.
Apply These 6 Ways to Encourage Self-Correction

1. 1

Playing Dumb

This is by far the easiest and my favorite way to get a student to self-correct (and
it might be your favorite too if you like acting for students). The technique goes
something like this. Say a student incorrectly uses a verb in the past tense and says,
Yesterday I leaved the school at 5 pm. All you need to do is say, Sorry? or What
was that? or Come again? Making a face that expresses your confusion is a great
help! The student will be forced to repeat what he/she said and in most cases they
correct their mistake the second time around. If the student fails to notice the problem,
try further encouragement: You said you did what at 5pm? You ..what?

2. 2

Write It Down

If the playing dumb strategy doesnt work write the sentence down on the
board. You can go about this in two ways:

o Write the sentence down as it was said by the student and ask him/her to find the
mistake.
o Write the sentence down and leave a blank where the mistake was made. Ask the
student to fill in the blank correctly.
3. 3

The Corrections Card

Most ESL teachers know that it is not convenient to interrupt and correct
students during a performance activity like a presentation or any kind of speech.
So how do we get them to self-correct their mistakes? The approach is similar to the
above, but for performance activities, well call it The Corrections Card (notice Im
not calling it The Mistakes Card corrections are positive, mistakes are negative).
While the student is giving his/her presentation, jot down the mistakes they make on a
little note pad. When theyre done, congratulate them on their presentation and
highlight any of the positive points (great use of vocabulary!) then tell the student
youre going to bring out The Corrections Card. Draw a big rectangle in the board and
write down the mistakes. You may ask them to find the mistake in a particular
sentence or have them fill in a blank with the correct word.

4. 4

Gestures

The problem with teacher corrections is that we need to interrupt the student. A
much more unobtrusive way of bringing their attention to a mistake is to use a signal.
For example, when students speak but fail to use the verb in past, I simply wave my
hand backward or point to the back with my thumb. Students automatically switch to
 the past tense. You can develop different signals for different types of mistakes like
finger counting for word order.

5. 5

The Red Flag

Use a red flag (or any colored flag) to literally flag mistakes. This technique is
more useful for drilling or intensive grammar practice, but less so for performance
activities.

6. 6

In Writing

Have you ever stopped to consider how a student feels when you hand back their
creative writing assignment covered in red ink? Probably not very good. Try this
instead. Correct some of the mistakes yourself, but choose others for self-correction.
For example, if the goal of the writing assignment is to write about an event in the
past, correct all of the mistakes that are not related to the past tense, like spelling or
prepositions. Make a note on the margin that states the number of mistakes theyve
made, which they need to correct. See if they find them all.

Sometimes, we are too quick to correct.

We jump in the middle of the conversation and interrupt the student. We cut a discussion
short. By fostering self-correction, the student stands to gain a lot more than they stand to
lose.

9 Ways to Correct Students Without

Correcting Them
When we as teachers correct students, we discourage them from trying!

It is hard enough to get EFL students to practice speaking and writing without adding barriers.
Try correcting them in disguise with positive re-enforcers or a more passive style. It might not
come naturally to you at first, but with a little practice, you will never tell a student she is
wrong again!

Try These 9 Simple Ways to Correct Your Students Without Correcting

Them

1. 1
 The Stare

If a student answers a question incorrectly or grossly mispronounces a word, fail

to respond to him and rather stare blankly or with a raised eyebrow, like you
heard no words. You will convey there was a failure in communication without
correcting with your body language cues, and those cues are actually a more powerful
way of encouraging a second, third, and even fourth attempt for a right answer. The
student will naturally want to try harder to communicate with you.

2. 2

Is There Another Way to Say That?

Do not tell her she is wrong, but ask if maybe there is another way (with the
implication of better way) to answer your question or communicate. The question
will trigger a thought process in which she scans her mental thesaurus.

3. 3

What Word Did We Learn Yesterday?

This question inspires recall of lessons taught, and your student will not think
you are correcting her, only seeking a different answer based on your lesson
plans. It will trigger her brain to replace the incorrect word or usage with what you
taught as well.

4. 4

Does Anyone Else Have A Thought?

Do not correct your student, but immediately ask if anyone else has a different
answer. Keep asking until someone gives you the right response. Positively respond
to all of the participation, but very positively respond to the correct answer once you
find it and stop asking for more answers. The final answer will sit in their heads as the
best and the most correct.

5. 5

Who Else Thinks That Answer Is Correct?

Turn it around on your students! Poll who thinks the answer is correct. The correct
answer will emerge, but the student who was wrong will have commiseration from
classmates that voted for her answer, diffusing the culpability in a lighthearted way.

6. 6

I Do Not Quite Understand You

This phrase indicates that the student is on the right track, but is not quite
conveying what he wants to communicate. He will keep trying and rephrase his
 words or try another grammatical construction naturally to attempt to explain. This is
much more effective than That is not how you say that or other negative correction
tools.

7. 7

The Repeat

Nod in agreement with the student and then repeat what she is trying to say
correctly. This shows she said it well enough to be understood and that her
communication was relayed, but the correct pronunciation or grammar will stick in her
mind. For example, if she asks, I go to bathroom? say, Can I go to the bathroom?
Yes you can go to the bathroom.

8. 8

Ask Someone Else

If someone answers incorrectly, just ignore her and ask someone else until you
receive the right response!

9. 9

A Game with Rewards

Do not correct wrong answers, but reward the right answer. This is the oldest
teacher trick to inspire participation. Give candy, points, prizes, etc. if students answer
you correctly, but do not even acknowledge wrong answers.

With a little bit of practice, you can succeed at never correcting your students
but always finding the right answer! You will notice higher participation in
your activities as well as increased learning in your classroom by employing
these techniques and always making wrong right.