April- J u n e 1996 I
The Q~v'anicHorizons:
Marliazi Anjumm I<huddnm-ul-Qur'iu~
36-I<,Model Town, 1,ahorc-54700, I'nltist,~~
Phone: ,5869501-3 F;u: 5834000
Vol. 1:No. 2
April-June 1996
Contents
The Spirit of Revolution
Dr. Ahmed Afzaal
In Search of Knowledge
Farhan Onfar Shatnsi
The Spirit of Revolution
n our first editorial (The Qur'anic Horizons 1:1), we pointed out
thz significance of Pakistan in the context of the contemporary
global movement for Islamic revival and renaissance. There are,
indeed, a number of indications 'that Pakistan is destined to play a
pivotal role concerning the hture of Islam, and that Pakistan will have
the honor of leading the Muslim Ummah into an age characterized by
the domination of Islam. For instance, unlike the more or less
simultaneous movements launched against the yoke of Western
imperialism throughout the Muslim world, it was only in the Indian
subcontinent that the name of Islam was invoked. Furthermore, any
keen student of history can appreciate the veracity of the assertion
that, in view of the extremely unfavorable situation prevailing at the
time, the establishment of a separate homeland for Muslims in 1947
was nothing short of a miracle.
On a deeper level, it should be obvious to all believers that the
creation of Pakistan was in direct response to our firm and solemn
pledge to Almighty Allah (SWT) - the pledge that, in case we
succeed in gaining our much coveted freedom, we will establish the
Islamic System of Social Justice in this country. During the movement
for independence, we made public claims that we are going to create a
model Islamic state, that we are going to show the entire world the
true picture of Islam, and that we are going to demonstrate how the
Islamic ideals of human freedom, equality, and fraternity work in real
life.
This means that, like all other prophets and messengers of God,
Prophet Muhammad (SAW) was also a preacher, a moral and spiritual
mentor, a teacher, a warner, a bearer of glad tidings and a witness of
Truth. Even though each prophet of Almighty AUah (SWT) had his own
Muhammad's Prophethood (SAW) - I1 9
Sindhi (1872-1944) has taken this verse as the key for understanding the
global revolutionary manifesto of Islam.
A careful study of the verse reveals that Prophet Muhammad
(SAW) has been sent by Almighty God along with two items: (1) "Al-
Huda" or The Guidance, and (2) "Deen al-Haq" or the True Way of
Life (sometimes translated as "the religion of truth"). Let us study these
expressions more closely one by one:
Al- Huda
We would not be wrong to take the word in its wider literal
sense, but if we are to try and understand the term "Al-Huda" in the
light of numerous Qur'anic precedents, then it can only signify the Holy
Qur'an itself. This is because only this very Divine Book is "hudal lil-
muttaqeen" (guidance for the God-fearing; Al-Baqarah 2:2), as well as
"hudal lin-izaas" (guidance for the ordinary run of people; Al-Baqarah
2: 185). The meaning of "Al-Huda " is thus elucidated in the following
verses:
We have caused this (message) to be a light, whereby We
guide whom We will of Our servants. (Al-Shura 42:52)
Verily, this Qur'an guides to the path that is most right.
(Al-Isra 17:9)
(0 Prophet) Say: It has been revealed to me that a group of
jinn listened, then (returning to their folks) they said, "we
have indeedd heard a wonderful Qur'an, which guides to the
right way..," (Al-Jinn 72: 1,2)
has been used in place of the expression "al-Huda" used in the versc
under discussion. This proves the truth without an. iota of doubt that in
the context of Muhammad's Prophethood (SAW), "al-Huda" signifies
nothing else but Al-Qur'an.
Deen al-Hag
Whether we take the complex locution as a relational con~pound
and translate it as "Deen of Truth", or take it as a qualitative compound
and translate it as "True Deen" (as has been done by the majority of the
translators of the Holy Qur'an), its connol,ition and meaning remaill
essentially unchanged. "Deen al-Haq" means "Deen of Allah", because
the true faith and the true way of life can be none else but that which
comes from Almighty Allah (SWT). Similarly, the personilication of
"Haq" can be none other than Allah Himsell', its the Qur'an says:
This is because Allah is the Truth. (Al-Hqjj Z2:6)
On that Day (of Judgement) Allah will pay them in full their just due,
and they will come to know that Allah alone is the Ultimate Truth,
manifest and manifesting. (Al-Nur 24:25)
This clearly shows that "Deen al-Hag" is, in real import and
meaning, equivalent to "Deerz of Allah."
If we concentrate on the word "Deen", we come to know that in
Arabic language it connotes exactly what it means in Surah Al-Fatiha,
viz., recompense, which is, of course, rewards of the Paradise in case of
good deeds and torments ul' Hell-fire in case of bad ones. That explains
the fact why in the early surahs of the Makkan period the word "Deen." is
used in its core meaning of recompense; for instance:
Have you seen him who belies the rewards and punishments
of the Hereafter? (Al-Ma'un 107:1)
Therefore (0 Prophet!) who can belie you after this
concerning the rewards and punishments of the Hereafter?
(Al-Teen 95:7)
Nay, but they deny the rewards and punsihments of' the
Hereafter. (Al-Intitar 82:9)
12 The Qur'anic Horizons 1:2
as the Supreme and Absolute Sovereign and people entered into this
faith in great numbers, it was referred to by the Holy Qur'an as "Deen
Allah. " From this perspective, it would not be inapproopriate to call the
modern political set-up of Democracy (in which, at least theoretically,
the people of a country are themselves the sovereign) as "deen a1
jamhoor. "
However, the Holy Qur'an also employs expressions in which
"Deen" is attributed to somebody other than God, and this should be
described as a metaphorical usage of the possessive pronoun/adjective,
e.g., "deeni " (my "Deen "), "dinukum" (your "Deen"), or "dinuhum"
(their "Deen"). This is obviousIy in the sense of the system or way of
life which one has accepted and adopted. This system of life and socio-
political governance, so to say, is a person's "Deen." In this very sense,
Islam is sometimes called "Deen of Muhammad"; e.g., in one of the
popular prayers we supplicate thus: "0 Lord, succour all those who
support and promote the Deen of Muhammad." Of course, Islam is
actually "Deen of Allah", but it is also Muhammad's Deen as it has been
revealed and given to mankind through Prophet Muhammad (SAW).
To sum up, "Deen Allah" is that system of belief and action
which is based on the basic premise of total, absolute and unconditional
subnlission to the commands of Almighty Allah (SWT). And this, in
fact, is the "al-meezan" - the Balance - which is the final and ultimate
form of Divine guidance for mankind. After progressing gradually
through the vicissitudes of history, Divine guidance finally culminated in
the most comprehensive and balanced system of life as revealed to
Prophet Muhammad (SAW). The Islamic way of life represents the ideal
system of social justice and equity wherein the duties and rights of all
are clearly laid down, "in order that the humanity may stick to, and
behave with, Justice."(Al-Hadeed 57:25)
The Wisdom in the Timing of the Last Prophet's Advent
A deeper consideration will reveal the truth that the point and
wisdom in the temporal location of the culmination of Prophethood and
imparting perfection to the revealed system of Life can also be
14 The Qur'anic Horizons 1:2
And, time and again, it offered the whole mankind a challenge in these
words:
And if you are in doubt as to what We have revealed to Our
servant, then produce a surah like thereunto. (Al-Baqarah
2:23)
It is a pity that so far Qur'anic scholars have mainly focused on
the literary and stylistic beauties of the Holy Book and its linguistic and
rhymic excellences. Whatever scant attention was paid to the meanfig-
content of the Book was too, by and large, misguided and misconceived
in so far as either Aristotelian logic or half-baked scientiiic theories were
made paradigm of truth in the light of which attempts were made to
understand the Qur'an. Little did they realize that the Qur'an could not
possibly accept these ever-changng strait-jackets. The truth should be
clearly borne in mind that the Holy Qur'an is essentially "al-Hudu" and
its real magnificence lies in its guidance for thought and practical life;
and that it was given to man at a time when his independent thought, as
such, had reached its zenith and he had, so to say, attained mental
adulthood and maturity.
The second point of wisdom in the timing of the last Prophet's
advent seems to be the fact that the social consciouness of mankind had
also reached maturity in the 7th century CE, in that human polity had
experienced all the major evolutionary stages. After passing through the
social polities of tribal organization and city state, human life had
entered the phase of great kingdonls and empires. This, in fact, meant
that the hold and domination of socio-political system on huinan Life had
reached its lull intensity for the lirst time, and that man had begun to
face the vexed and multi-dimensional problems of human society and
collective life. Moreover, the time was about to usher in which humanity
had to encounter such unsolvable issues - as those of the Individual
versus Group, Man versus Woman, Capital versus Labour - and in the
solution of which human thought moved from one extreme to another,
dways adding to human travail and misery.
of human history, Almighty Allah (SWT) bestowed upon man the most
balanced system of social justice and equity that was really "al-meezan"
and offered the best and the most excellent solutions for all the intricate
issues and problems of social existence. In all spheres of collective life -
social, economic, and political - the God-given system of life guided
humanity to the straight path and the most balanced middle way, putting
an end to social perversions or discrimination, economic exploitation
and political repression. And thus the sole purpose of sending prophets
and revelation of Books - which was to guide the people to live with
equity and justice - was fully realized in the advent of the Last Prophet
and a concrete example was set for all times to come through the
completion of the true faith, as the Qur'an says:
This day I have perfected your Deen for you, completed My
favour upon you and have chosen for you Islam as your
Deen. (Al-Mai'dah 5:3)
Now, let us take another step forward and try to understand the
meaning of the Arabic expression "le-yuzhira-hu" used in the Qur'anic
verse under discudsion. The literal meaning and connotation of the verb
"izhar" - to make dominant - is accepted by all scholars and experts of
Qur'anic sciences. However, there are more than one opinion in respect
of the subject and object of the verb "izhar", though these differences of
opinion cause no real change in the essential meaning of the verse.
support of their respective positions, but the question that clinches the
matter is this: What real difference does either position make in the over-
all purported intent of the verse? As Muslims, we all believe that the
final and real agent for all actions is none other than Almighty Allah
(SWT). Despite this basic metaphysical belief, all imperatives in the
Qur'an are directed and addressed to human beings living in the world of
facts, and it is incumbent upon them to leave no stone unturned in
performing their religious obligations. That is why we see that the Holy
Prophet (SAW) struggled very hard all through his prophetic career for
making Islam triumphant and dominant. That is to say, in the world of
objective facts, the Prophet had to carry out an extremely arduous
struggle for Islam at a purely human level, although we believe that the
ultimate and real causal agent of all actions is always Almighty Allah
(SWT). The Qur'an categorically asserts thus:
So the fact is that (0 Believers) you did not slay them but
Allah slew them, and (0 Prophet) you did not throw (the
sand) but Allah threw it. (Al-Anfal8:17)
Would those who are, through minor difference of interpretation
based on feeble arguments, trying to distort the whole concept of
religious obligations think about the far-reaching implications of their
standpoint! The truth of the matter is that, on the basis of a trivial point,
they have wrongly absolved themselves of the Qur'anic obligation of
making Islam dominant as a politico-socio-economic order in the world.
They should try to honestly consider as what would have happened if the
Holy Prophet and his Companions had taken the above quoted verse in
its apparent literal sense. Obviously, they would have forthwith given up
their struggle for the cause of Islam and the subsequent world history
would have been radically different from what it is. Moreover, would it
be possible for anyone of us to have embraced Islam, the true Divine
faith?
Indeed, we should always try to be on guard against the
seductive trappings of Satan, in particular his master deception that
causes us to see as superfluous, burdensome, or frightening that which is
really one of the basic obligations of all faithful. Is not the attitude of
18 The Qur'anic Horizons 1 :2
in the meaning and import; the victory of the Prophet is not to be taken
as his personal or his clan's or tribe's victory. Rather, it means the
dominance and triumph of the Faith which he preached tirelessly, and
established, in letter and spirit, throughout the whole of the Arabian
peninsula.
Alad-deeni Kulli-hi
This expression of the Qur'anic verse has been variously
translated as "over all false religions" and "over all Deen." It is quite
significant that the plural form of the noun "Deen" - which is
"Adiyyan" - has not appeared in the whole of Qur'an even once.
Moreover, the emphasis connoted by the expression "kulli-hi", in
addition to the verse already noted, appears at only one other place in the
Holy Qur'an, as follows:
And fight against them until there is no more oppression and
all Deen belongs to Allah alone. (Al-Anfal 8:39)
I11 respect of the difference between religion and "Deen ", two
points should be clearly borne in nlind: (1) the Arabic word for religion
is "mndhnb", whlch has not been used at all in the Qur'an, nor has it
been used in the whole corpus of Haditlz in its present commonly
understood meaning. It came to be used much later quite rightly to
connote various schools of juristic thinking, e.g., Hanbali rnadlznb,
Maleki i?~adhab,Ha~zafirnadlzab, etc, which are in reality branches or
developmental variants of that part of the faith of Islam that deals with
22 The Qur'anic Horizons 1:2
law or Shari'ah. (2) Though, in matters of details, the revealed law or
the Shari'ah given to Prophet Musa (AS) and Prophet Muhammad
(SAW) shows numerous points of divergence, yet the essentials of
"Deen" have remained identical right from Prophet Adam (AS) down to
Prophet Muhammad (SAW). This point is elucidated by the following
Qur'anic verse:
The same Deen has been ordained for you as that which He
enjoined on Noah, the one which We have sent by inspiration
to you (0Prophet), and that which We enjoined on Abraham,
Moses, and Jesus: namely, that they should establish this
Deen and make no divinsion therein. (Al-Shura 42: 13)
zenith means that there will be no more prophets, and, therefore, the
responsiblity for the task executed by the chain of prophets has now been
placed on to the shoulders of the Muslim Ummah. In respect of both
types of duties - those pertaining to the basic purpose of Prophethood,
which is preaching, and those related to the consummatory nature of
Muhammad's Prophethood, which is establishing the Deen of Allah in
its totality - the responibility lies with those who take pride in
belonging to the Muslim Ummah and who adore and eulogize the Holy
Prophet.
All convinced and committed Muslims must realize that, since
after Prophet Muhammad (SAW) there is going to be no prophet for the
guidance of mankind, Prophet Muhammad's mission has Iherrelvrc
acquired the following two-fold direction and significance. Firstly, hc is
the Messenger of Almighty Allah (SWT) to his contemporary Arab
people (in particular) and, secondly, he is also the Messenger to the
entire humanity till the end of the world (in general). It is stated quite
clearly in the Holy Qur'an (Al-Jum'ah 62:2,3) that the Prophet (SAW)
was sent unto both the unlettered people (urnmiyeen) and unto all the
people belonging to other lands and future times (akhereen). The latter
aspect of Muhammad's Prophethood stresses the universality and
timeless validity of all that was revealed to him. In a sermon already
referred to, the Holy Prophet (SAW) addressed his audience thus:
Concluded
The Qur'an and Riba
Sslyyid Tahir
he word riba occurs in the Qur'an in ayaat 275, 276 and 278
of Surah Al-Baqarah, 130 of Ad-eImran, 161 of Al-Nisa, and
39 of Al-Room. Traditionally, these ayaat are studied in their
textual order. Thus the analysis of riba starts with a tafseer of the ayaat
of 4-Baqarah. Two things are noteworthy in this regard: (a) there is an
enblock discussion of Al-Baqara 2:275-281, and (b) virtually all matters
relating to riba and interest are discussed at length and concluded here.
The issues arising out of the ahadith on riba are also covered. With the
iinal conclusions thus drawn, the ayaar of Aal-e-Imran, Al-Nisa, and Al-
Room get progressively less and less attention from the scholars.
This paper offers a break from the above tradition. It follows a
chronological approach to study the ayaat on n'ba. That is, the various
ayaat are studied in their order of revelation. Some obvious advantages
of this approach are as follows. First, it can improve our understanding
of the general background and the circumstances in which these ayaat
were revealed. Second, it may bring to the fore the various developments
in the process of the elimination of riba during the lifetime of Prophet
Muhammad (SAW). Third, it clarifies the total picture about the
injunctions of n'ba. As may be seen, all these points are essential for a
proper interpretation of the injunctions of riba in the Qur'an and Suiznah.
The Qur'an is the spoken Word of Alrnighty,Allah (SWT). It has
many chapters, sections, paragraphs and sub-paragraphs. Thus, it is
essential that every ayah should be read along with its companion ayaat
The author is Professor of Ecoilomics at the International Institute of Islamic
Economics, International Islamic Uni~~ersity, Islamabad.
The autl~oris gratell to ~ t i ~f a h e e dand Hakeemullal~Khan for their help in
the preparation of this paper.
Qur'an and Riba 31
thetime of Prophet Musa (AS), and then went to disobey Him (SWT)
time and again. After this, Allah (SWT) recounts the major crimes of the
Jews, which invited His wrath on them. In this perspective, the ayah 160
and its companion ayaat 161 and 162 are as follows.
P , 1 DO,, .5 * 1 .4 8 ' 5 r,
0 j X - i ; l&~$l,~-,J, 'dl Y!"jJJI,+,A,
(\?~-\YI : ? JT)
Some quarters take a lead from the phrase "eating riba on top of
riba" to conclude that only compound interest is prohibited, not simple
interest. Yet some others invoke the distinction between usury and
interest to limit the scope of the Qur'anic decree to exorbitant interest
rates. These points of views contradict both common sense and the
linguistic style of the Qur'an.
If Rs.100 are lent at a compound rate of 10% per annum for two
years, the borrower would be called upon to repay Rs. 121 at the end of
the contract. The same goal can be achieved by the lender by offering
38 The Qur'anic Horizons 1:2
Rs. 100 at the simple rate of 21%. What would be the grounds for
distinguishing between the two arrangements? Likewise, the term
"exorbitant rate of interest" is also arbitrary. A 10% rate of interest may
be exorbitant for one person while 21% may be normal for another
depending on their respective financial positions and prospective uses of
funds.
All mufassireen are of the view that "doubling and quadrupling"
(or "riba on top of riba") has only a linguistic significance in order to
highlight the despicable character of riba. This point is supported by the
text of Al-Baqarah 2:22. After drawing the attention of mankind to His
creation and blessings, AUah (SWT) says:
l2lLY A, P,'(
+
I- yi'
"
Literal meanings of this ayah are: "So, do not assign many partners to
Allah." It does not imply, by any stretch of imagination, that one can
ascribe a single partner to AUah (SWT). The interpretation "don't go
eve11 close to riba" is also supported by the text of Al-Baqarah 2:41. In
this ayah, Bani Israel are instructed as follows:
It means: "Don't seek a small price for My ayaat." Again, this does not
mean that there is room for charging a high price for violating the
in-junctions of Allah (SWT). To sum up, therefore, there is no room for
confusing the meaning of riba with -reference to Ad-eImran 3:130.
Whether simple or compound, nba is riba.
Let us now look at the other revelations on riba given in Surah
Al-Baqarah.
IV. The Fourth Revelation on Riba
The fourth revelation on nba consists of Al-Baqarah 2:275-277.
In the text of the Qur'an, these ayaat are followed by four more ayaat on
riba, namely Al-Baqarah 2:278-28 1. And, as mentioned earlier,
generally mufassireen discuss a l l of them together. However, the
background and the tone of these ayaat confirm that in fact the passage
Al-Baqarah 2:275-281 consists of two sets of ayaat revealed on two
Qur'an and Riba 39
Those who spend their wealth for the sake of Allah day and
night, secretly and openly, have their reward with their Lord.
They have nothing to fear and nothing to be sorry about. (Al-
Baqarah 2:274)
Among other things, these ayaat mentally prepare the readers of the
Qur'an for the injunctions of riba in the ayaat 275-281. After this useful
digression, let us look at Al-Baqarah 2:275-277. The background of
these ayaat is as follows.
Riba was prohibited by the end of 3 A.H according to
Aal-e-Imran 3:130. This decree clearly affected both taking and giving
40 The Our'anic Horizons 1 :2
of riba on new loans. But it also had implications for riba on the then
existing debts. The Companions (RAA) never missed any opportunity
for immediate, unconditional and total obedience of Allah (SWT) and
His Prophet (SAW). Therefore, it is certain that soon after the decree of
Surah Ad-eImran, they beseeched additional guidance about riba on the
existing debts. And, given the level of their Allah-consciousness, it is
quite likely that some Companions (RAA) also approached the prophet
(SAW) with queries about the riba charged in the past.
Another significant factor at the time was the role of the Jews
who used to deal in riba (Al-Nisa 4:161). They were part and parcel
the Madani society when the Prophet (SAW) migrated to Madinah.
There were three Jewish tribes in Madinah: Banu Qainqa', Banu Nudair
and Banu Quraizah. They dominated the civic and economic life of
Madinah. The Ansuar were often indebted to them through riba-based
loans. The Jews had their reservations about Islam. First liiction and
then hostilities followed. This lead to the expulsion of Banu Qainqa'a
toward the Syrian territories in Shawwal 2 A.H. Banu Nudair were
exiled to Khyber, about 200 miles from Madinah, in Rabi al-Awwal 4
A.H. Banu Quraizah were penalized in Zi Qa'adah 5 A.H for their role in
the battle of Ahzaab (Shawwal 5 AM). This was followed by the battle
of Khyber in Muharram 7 A.H. This sequence of events implies that one
section of the society actively resisted the rise of Islam in Madinah at
least until 7 A.H. Of course, it had the sympathies of the munafiqeen, the
other group in Madinah with nefarious intentions towards Islam.
By the end of 3 A.H, Islam had taken a clear-cut stand against
riba. One can see that the vested interests went on a counter-offensive,
both because of the fear of losing their clientele and because of their
grudge against Islam. Issues like mixing up of ribu (on a sum lent) with
profits (on trading using the same money) can be seen as part of the
propaganda. Those who understand the nature of psychological warfare
would confirm that any propaganda campaign works while the issue is
still fresh in the minds of the people. Thus, the circumstantial evidence
suggests that as soon as Allah (SWT) forbade riba (as per Aal-eIrnran),
Jews and their sympathizers in Madinah launched a war of attrition
Qur'an and Riba 41
existing debts. The issue drawing the most attention of the people is
addressed first.
Both trading and loans carry risk - trading risk in one case, but
commercial credit risk (of borrowers) in the other. Time too is not
critical, because loans may also have a very short duration. Overnight
lending in international financial markets is an example. Nonetheless
trading involves a heterogeneous exchange: money versus some good,
for example. On the other hand, a loan represents a homogenous
exchange. That is, in this case the items given and taken back belong to
the same category. Furthermore, the transfer of ownership in a loan is
only for the pendency of the loan, and the lender is not a legal party to
the use of the object lent at the borrower's end. The nature of the
exchange and these legal dimensions distinguish loans from other
transactions. Thus the injunctions of riba prescribe the principles
according to which loan transactions are to be executed.
Allah (SWT) signifies two things. First, once the riba decree (Aal-e-
Irnran 3:130) was given, all riba calculations had to stop forthwith.
Secondly, those wilfully charging riba are promised an abode in the Hell
because of their denying the absolute and authorit~tivestatus of the
ayaat of the Qur'an - the Word of Allah (SWT) Himself.
After the above point, Allah (SWT), Who created man and Who
knows his psyche, emphasizes some negative dimensions of riba and
positive aspects of saduqaat. This is the focus of the ayah 276. How do
riba and spending for the sake of Allah affect the life at individual and
national levels? A detailed account of this issue requires a separate
study. However, one point may be just mentioned here in order to inspire
some thinking on the subject. From an economics point of view, riba
discourages investment and hence curtails economic development. On
the other hand, sadaqaat enhance aggregate demand and hence augment
economic activity.
The message is completed in the ayah 277 by drawing the
attention of the creation of Allah (SWT) to the road to ultimate success:
having Iman, doing good deeds in general, and establishing Salat and
Zakat in particular.
Zaid bin Aslam, Ibne Juraij, Muqatil bin Hayyan and Suddee
reported as follow^.'^ The ayah 278 and its related ayaat
were revealed in the context of a controversy between Bani
Amr bin Omair of Bani Thaqeef and Bani Al-Moghirah of
Bani Makhzoom. It so happened that Bani Amr and Bani Al-
Moghirah had some riba deal between them during the days
of Jahiliyyah (i.e., before embracing Islam). When Islam
dawned, b o d families became Muslim. However, when the
time of maturity of the said deal came, Bani Amr of the
Thaqeefs demanded nba. There was a h'eated argument. Bani
Al-Moghirah refused to pay nba on the ground that it was
abolished by Islam. The matter came before Sayyidena
Attaab bin Aseed (RAA), the Governor of Makkah. He sent a
written request to the Prophet (SAW), who was then in
Madinah, for a decision. Thereupon, the ayaat under
reference were revealed. The Prophet (SAW) wrote to him:
been other Companions in Makkah at that time, this point is not tenable.
The most likely explanation for Sayyidena Attaab's (RAA) action is that
the parties involved in the dispute were heavy-weights, and he deemed it
appropriate to seek a resolution of the matter by the Prophet (SAW)
himself in order not to spark any tribal conflict between the people of
Makkah and Bani Thaqeef.
Notwithstanding minor differences in the details, quite a few
sources leading to the same information and a general consensus among
many respected mufasserin on basic points confirm that the reported
incident did happen in late 9 A.H or early 10 A.H. The words in all
narrations imply that the Prophet (SAW) "wrote" to Attaab Ibn Aseed
(RAA). This must have happened before the 25th Zi Q'adah, 10 A.H,
when the Prophet (SAW) left Madinah for Hajj Al-Wida'.
On 9th Zil Hijjah, 10 A.H, the Prophet (SAW) decreed, in
person, the abolition of nba on all of the then existing debts. This was a
retrospective decree.l Thereafter, the Prophet (SAW) lived in this world
for only 81 days. The said announcement was made in the presence of
the Comanions (RAA) gathered in Arafat Erom all over Arabia. With the
status of riba on existing debts fairly recently coming into the
knowledge of virtually everybody, there was hardly any need for making
references of the above nature to the Prophet (SAW). Therefore, it is
quite unlikely that any need for intervention by Allah (SWT) arose after
the Hajj Al-Wida'a. One may, therefore, conclude that the time of
revelation of the ayaat under reference is after the conquest of Makkah
but before the last pilgrimage. The ayaat 278-281 are as follows.
48 The Qur'anic Horizons 1:2
2:279) - knowing full well the fate of the weak party: humiliation and
total destruction.
While the first part of the ayah 279 warns of the dire
consequences of not giving up riba, the second part is also significant.
The creditors are pointedly restricted to their principals while settling
any existing debts.
According to the ayah 280, if the, debtors face (genuine)
difficulties in meeting their payment obligations, the creditors are
ordered to give them grace period to meet their payment obligations to
the tune of the principal. This principle was already observed by the
veteran Companions (RAA) after the revelation of Al-Baqarah 2:275 in
late 3 A.H. But now the decree from Allah (SWT) formalized it. l b s
may be viewed as His special favor for this Ummah. More and more
people were going to enter the fold of Islam in the future. Settlenlent of
old contracts which involved riba by the new converts to Islam could
create social problems. This ayah forestalled such problems.
The ayah 280 also contains an additional guideline about the
treatment of the written-oft' loans. They are to be treated as sadaqah by
the lenders.
Whereas the ayah 279 restricts lenders to their principals, it also
closes on the following note: Neither the creditors do zulm on the
debtors nor the latter do zulm on the former. The link between charging
riba by creditors and zulm is often easy to understand. But how does
zulm arise on the debtors' side? The ahadith of Sayyidena Abu Hurairah
clarify that debtors commit zulm when they deliberately cause delays in
meeting their payment obligations.
(a) Riba is riba. Simple vs. compound interest or interest vs. usury
distinctions do not apply.
government.
..
11. In a transaction involving riba, a believer may either
charge riba or give riba. The Prophet (SAW) made it abundantly
clear that both taking and giving riba and even being a party to a
transaction that involves riba in any other capacity are
prohibited. Thus, there can be no question of the permissibility
of Muslims doing such transactions with non-Muslims either in
an Islamic state or in a non-Muslim country.
iii. Riba arises in the context of a loan or a comparable
transaction between two individuals (who must observe the
injunctions of Almighty Allah at their personal levels). Thus, if
such a transaction takes place between any two individuals,
irrespective of the relation between them, it has to be executed
on a one-to-one and equal basis. In other words, views like "no
riba between a master and his slave" need reconsideration.
7. After the revelation of Al-Baqarah 2:278-279, if a Muslim
wilfully defies the injunctions of riba and the matter reaches the
judicidstate level in a Muslim society, not only that the contract would
be treated as void, but it will also be the concerned authority's
responsibility as representative of Shari'ah to impose appropriate ta'zeer
(Shar'ee penalty) on him.
In this regard, it is also noteworthy that riba debts negotiated by
a person as a Muslim do not fall under the purview of Al-Baqarah 2:275.
That is, they will not automatically hold after deleting the riba clauses in
them. In fact they are uqood al-baatilah (contracts not recognized in
Shari'ah) which need to be replaced by genuine contracts in the process
of transition to a riba-free state. Of course, in addition to this, the
Muslims wilfully negotiating such contracts are also to be subjected to
appropriate ta'zeer (Shar'ee punishment) if matters are not cleared at the
personal level, i.e., before the start of judiciallofficial process.
9. The pattern and text of the ayaat on riba implies that in drawing
further conclusions, there is no point in looking at the rationale for the
prohibition of riba. The correct approach would be to develop a riba-free
economy, and to Cbmpare its performance with other ribabased
constructs in terms of a chosen criteria, such as level of economic
activity, investment, degree of inequalities in income and wealth, etc.
10. That "there is a declaration of war from Allah (SWT) and His
Prophet (SAW)" calls for paying attention to the following three points:
(b) "War" implies that if riba continues, the believers cannot look
forward to a pea~eful~living in this world, either at their personal or
national level.
ENDNOTES
1
According to Mufti Muhammad Shafie (Ma'arif-ul-Qur'an,Vo1.6, pp.739-
50), the passage of the 39th ayah starts with the 28th ayah. This ayah contains
arguments for Tauheed and, in light thereof, the 29th ayah is an invitation to
humanity to be rational. Thereafter, the message continues as above.
2
In this paper, the interpretation of Maulana Arnin Ahsan Islahi (Tadabbur-e-
Qur'an, V01.6, p.99) is followed. According to Mufti Muhammad Shafie
(Ma'arif-ul-Qur'an, V01.6, p.750), in this ayah the term riba applies to gifts.
Even if that were the case, the general conclusions noted above would hold.
3
The word zulm has both general and special meanings in the Qur'an. In the
special sense, it refers to (a) shirk (Luqmaan 31:13) and (b) denial of clear
signs from Almighty Allah (Al-Au'aam 6:144; Al-A'araaf 7:40-41). The Jews
did this kind of zulm because'they declared Prophet Uzair (AS) to be son of
Almighty Allah (Al-Taubah 9:30), and they went on to disobey Him soon after
experiencing the miraculous escape from the Pharoah and his army (Al-A'araaf
7:137-167).
4
Literal,translation of the first part of the ayah would be: "Don't 'feast on riba
- doubled and quadrupled." However, the message is the same: stay away from
riba. This point is further explained in the text.
5
The ayaat 135 and 136 are read here in continuation of the ayah 134.
Maulana Muhammad Idris Kandhalwi (Ma'arif-ul-Qur'an,Vol. 1, pp.577-81)
reads the ayaut 135 and 136 as a pair separate from the ayah 134. However,
this reading too does not affect conclusions about riba.
6
In this paper the details about the life and time of the Prophet (SAW) are
taken from Sirat-ul-Mustafa by Maulana Muhammad Idris Kandhalvi and
Sirat-un-Nabi by Maulana Shibli Nomani.
7
Mufti Muhammad Shafie (Ma'aurif-ul-Qur'an,Vol. 2, pp.175-91) interprets
the ayah 130 without its battl of Ohad background. The reasons for doing so
56 The Qur'anic Horizons 1:2
*
The contents appearing i n
this publication a r e indexed by
For further information, please contact:
Dr. Munawar A. Anees, Editor-in-Chief, Periodica Islamica
Berita Publishing, 22 Jalan Liku, Kuala Lumpur-59100, Malaysia
Tel (+60-3)282-5286 Fax (+60-3)282-1605
E-mail: America Online: dranees CompuServe: 72260,227
Delphi: drmanees InterNet: dranees@klcyber.pc.my
- -. -
Note to Contributors
Papers submitted for publication must conform to the following
guidelines :
All manuscripts must be typed on one side of the paper with double
spacing, with at least one inch margins on all sides, preferably on A4
paper.
Footnotes should be numbered consecutively and typed separately
following the main text.
Papers may also be submitted as computer diskettes provided they are
composed on Microsoft Word 6 for Windows, WordPerfect 6 for
DOS, or in a compatible format. A hard copy should also be
included.
Islamic Revolutionary Thought
and its Decline
Dr. Israr Ahmad
(Rendered into English by: Dr. Ahmed Afzaal)
earth. It's not that Islam cannot survive or support itself without political
authority, but, in fact, it is the political authority that grows more and
more corrupt unless it is subordinated to the commands of the Holy
Qur'an and the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad (SAW). .
exclusive interest of which lies in the minor details of worship and ritual
and not in the affairs of the government or of politics. Soon it was
accepted by all concerned, almost as if it were an axiomatic certainty,
that the state can function only on the basis of tribal loyalty and
allegiance to the clan - what is described by Allama Ibn Khaldun as
Asabiyyah - and that the only feasible and practicable principle in this
domain is that of "might is right."
As for the ulama or scholars of Islam, the order of the day was
that they should better not interfere in the affairs of the government. The
ulama were, of course, "free" to function in the Civil Service of the
monarchy as sermonizers in the mosques, as jurists, and as judges. The
more talented of them could try their intellectual prowess in the various
burgeoning Islamic sciences, like Qur'anic exegesis, Hadith,
jurisprudence, scholasticism, and theology. Or, if they were not gifted
enough, they could fulfill the religious obligations of sermonizing and
exhorting the masses in order to inculcate in them the love of Almighty
Allah (SWT), the motivation to follow Prophet Muhammad (SAW), and
the concern for the Hereafter. Or, if they were really capable and daring,
they could adopt the mysitc path of purification of the soul and establish
monasteries to help others purify their souls as well. But as far as the
affairs of government and politics was concerned, the idea was
implanted among the peole that these "profane" things belonged to the
"worldly" folks, and that to try and change the whole system by means
of any armed struggle is almost as prohibited as outright apostasy.
It may be pointed out here that the possiblity pf an armed
rebellion against an un-Islamic but ostensibly Muslim regime has been
rendered quite ineffective by the purely legalist mind. The dominant
view among the Muslims, made popular mainly by some of the Ah1 al-
Hadith scholars, is that such a rebellion is strictly forbidden by Islam no
matter how wicked, cruel, and corrupt the ruler may be. According to
these scholars, armed rebellion is allowed only when the ruler
commands a flagrant violation of the Shan'ah, or orders to commit
something identifiable with kufr. The most balanced opinion in this
regard, however, is that of Imam Abu Hanifa (RA). According to him,
Islamic Revolutionary Thought 65
One cannot help but come to the conclusion that Islam is the
most natural way of life. The goal comes into focus and the path
becomes clear, But learning is not enough; it must also lead to action.
After developing a basic understanding of the Qur'an, it now becomes
incumbent upon us to inform others of this reality and to struggle for the
establishment of al-Haqq, the Truth. Despite the great gains of
knowledge of the Qur'an, the Qur'an itself may become a witness
against us on the Day of Judgment if we fail to implement its
commandments in our lives.
These past few months have truly tested my patience, but the
fruits of my study are noticeable. Learning to depend on the Qur'an for
guidance revolutionizes one's life. It results in a deep-felt peace and
tr~nquillityeven in the face of difficulty and hardship. Al-Humdulillah,
in this short time the language of the Qur'an no longer seems completely
foreign to me. I've also come to learn and appreciate the importance of
the Qur'an in our everyday lives, and what it means to be a true Muslim
in the service of Allah.
Unfortunately, the pain of homesickness, a rude awakening to
the value given to Islam in Pakistan, and my own inability to read and
write fluently in Urdu have contributed to a decrease in my initial
enthusiasm. But the need for such an all-encompassing course is strongly
felt abroad among the younger generation of Muslims. The
establishment of the Institute of'Qurlanic Wisdom in New York is a step
in the right direction to fulfill this need. I would strongly, and without
hesitation, recommend the One-Year Course to all Muslims, as it is an
invaluable investment for one's present life and, Insha Allah, for the
Hereafter.
I would like to thank those of my classmates who contributed
their ideas and shared their thoughts which helped in producing this
article: I pray that we may come to appreciate Islam for the True Reality
that it is, that we may be blessed with the true understanding of the
Deen, and that Allah have mercy on us so that we may be able to enter
into Islam completely. Ameen.
One-Year
Ruju ' ilal Qur 'an
(Return Towards the Qur'an)
Course
For college and uiliversity graduates (men and
women), Markazi Anjuman IU~uddam-ul- Qur'an
Lahore offers a One-Ycar Course in:
Basic Arabic language,
Tajweed (the art of reciting the Qur'an),
M%ntahhabNisab (detailed study of Selections from
the Q~lr'an),
Introduction to Haditb, and
Study of selected Islamic literature.
The main objective of this course is that those
who have already colnpletcd their forinal education
can acquaint thcn~selveswit11 thc essentials of Islalnic
tc;~chings,so that the prevailing dichotomy between
"religious" and "secular" lcno\~rlcdgccan be removed.
Admissions will open in lntc September and
classcs i l l start in the first \~rcclc of October,
I n s l ~Allnh.
;~ Thc incdium of instruction is Urdu.