a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This study investigated the optimal calcining temperatures of Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4 (x 00.12) phosphors
Received 20 November 2015 prepared by a new coprecipitation method using potassium carbonate as the precipitant. The results
Received in revised form show that the potassium carbonate coprecipitation method was useful and successful, and avoids the
26 January 2016
problems of residual precipitant presence and the elution of small metal ions. The optimal calcining
Accepted 29 January 2016
temperatures of the phosphors ranged from 920 to 950 C, which were lower than those obtained using
Available online 1 February 2016
other methods. An empirical model was established to examine the calcining temperatures of prepared
precursors. The average absolute relative error between the starting temperatures obtained from ther-
Keywords:
Luminescence
mogravimetric analysis and temperatures estimated by the empirical model was 0.23%. The emission
Optical materials intensity increment rate of the phosphors produced using the potassium carbonate coprecipitation
Chemical synthesis method between the doping amounts x of 0.01 and 0.06 is approximately 10-fold higher than that
Calcium aluminates produced using the solidestate reaction method. Emission intensities of the prepared phosphors were
increased approximately 23.5-fold when the doping amount was increased from 0.01 to 0.06.
Sr0.64Eu0.12Dy0.24Al2O4 phosphor has moderate surface characteristics and the highest surface Dy/Eu ratio
of all phosphors; therefore, its emission intensity is greater than those of other prepared phosphors.
2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.01.227
0925-8388/ 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
C.-J. Liang, H.-Y. Siao / Journal of Alloys and Compounds 669 (2016) 38e45 39
different temperatures from 1000 to 1300 C. at an optimal concentration for synthesizing Eu and Dy codoping
As mentioned, the nal calcining temperatures of most prepa- SrO,Al2O3 phosphors. Theoretically, the precursor mainly consists
ration methods are extremely high, thus resulting in high energy of SrCO3 and M(III)(OH)3 (M(III) Al, Eu, Dy), according to the
expenditure. Although the nal calcining temperatures of the following chemical reaction equations [24]:
coprecipitation methods are lower than those of other methods,
two problems must be avoided: residual precipitant inuences the Sr(NO3)2 K2CO3 / SrCO3)2 K2(NO3)2 (2)
chemical homogeneity of mixed metal oxides when the precursors
are calcined, and small metal ions elute from the precursors when 2M(III)(NO3)3 3K2CO3 3H2O / 2M(III)(OH 3C 6N (3)
washed with distilled water. Additionally, the crystal structure of
phosphors depends on the calcining temperature, as observed in The calcination proceeds according to the following equation:
calcining
1 3xSrCO3s xEuOH3s 2xDyOH3s 2AlOH3s !Sr13x Eux Dy2x Al2 O3s 3 4:5xH2 O 1 3xCO2 0:75xO2
(4)
rare-earth-doped strontium aluminate systems [21]. However, Infrared spectra of the precipitates were obtained using Fourier
reducing energy use for industrial production and environmental transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy (Perkin Elmer, FT-IR Spec-
protection is crucial. This work introduces a new coprecipitation trometer Frontier). The crystalline phases of the prepared phos-
method that involves using K2CO3 solution as the precipitant to phors were identied using X-ray diffraction analysis (Bruker, D8
prepare phosphors that are efcient, have low-energy re- SSS) with Cu Ka radiation of 1.54 between 10 and 70 at a scan
quirements, have high purity, and demonstrate favorable homo- rate of 0.5 min1. The morphologies and surface atomic percent-
geneity. The results show a direct relationship between the optimal ages of the phosphors were observed using a variable vacuum
calcining temperature and the composition of the starting scanning electron microscope and an energy dispersive spec-
materials. trometer (Hitachi, S3000eN VVSEM). The BrunauereEmmette-
Teller (BET) surface properties were acquired using a high-
2. Experimental resolution surface area and porosimetry analyzer (Micromeritics,
ASAP 2020). The photoluminescent properties between wave-
Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4 (x 00.12) phosphors were prepared using lengths of 200 and 1500 nm were obtained by employing a cryo-
the potassium carbonate coprecipitation method with 800 mL of genic cathodoluminescence system (JEOL, JSM7001F) at an
0.18 M K2CO3 solution (pH 10.98) as the precipitant and a stirring accelerating voltage (VII) of 20 kV. Afterglow properties were
rate of 500 rpm. Subsequently, 100 mL of metal nitrate solution, collected using uorescence spectrometry (Agilent, Cary Eclipse
contained 0.1280.20 M Sr(NO3)2, 00.048 M Eu(NO3)3, FLR) after the samples were fully activated under a select excitation
00.096 M Dy(NO3)3, and 0.40 M Al(NO3)3, was added to the po- spectrum.
tassium carbonate solution at an approximate rate of
10.0 mL min1. The precipitates were ltered out repeatedly, 3. Results and discussion
washed with distilled water, and then dried in a vacuum oven at
110 C for 2 h. Next, the precursor of the phosphors was calcined in 3.1. Preparation
a reducing environment of 10% H2 90% N2 with the calcination
process shown in Eq. (1): The precursors were prepared and calcined as mentioned.
1h 2h 6h cooling
room temp,! 400 C!max, calcined temperature!max, calcined temperature!room temp, (1)
The calcination process involved heating the coprecipitates from Fig. 1 shows the FTIR spectra of the precipitates obtained using the
room temperature to 400 C, which was maintained for 2 h for potassium carbonate coprecipitation method. The FTIR spectra of
maximum transformation of metal hydroxides to metal oxides. The the precipitates were characterized by a broad band between
temperature was then raised to the maximum calcining tempera- 2700 and 3700 cm1 (OeH stretching), and three shaper bands at
ture, which was maintained for an additional 6 h to complete the 2483 cm1 (OeH bending), 1646 cm1 (OeH bending),
transformation of metal oxides to phosphors. The maximum and1168 cm1 (OeH stretching), all of which correspond to
calcination temperature of each precursor was determined using structural M(III)(OH)3. The area of the broad band between 2700
Simultaneous DSC-TGA (TA Instrument, SDT2960) between 50 and and 3700 cm1 increases by increasing Eu and Dy doping
1200 C at a heating rate of 5 C min1. amounts. This demonstrates that the major precipitates of Eu and
An equilibrium pH of 9.16 was measured in the coprecipitates by Dy metals are Eu and Dy hydrates. SrCO3 presence was also
using 0.18 M K2CO3 solution as the precipitant. Between pH 4 and conrmed by the appearance of a shoulder on the two asymmetric
10, aluminum, Al(OH)3 is nearly insoluble. Hydroxide compounds stretching CO3 bands at 1470 (main band) and 855 cm1. In
of Sr are somewhat soluble at pH 9.16, but their carbonate com- addition, three shaper symmetric stretching bands were located
pounds are insoluble. Therefore, the loss of Sr ions in solution can at 1774, 1068, and 744 cm1. The main asymmetric stretching CO3
be minimized through this method. The 0.18 M K2CO3 solution was bands at 1470 cm1 separated into two bands, 1518 and
40 C.-J. Liang, H.-Y. Siao / Journal of Alloys and Compounds 669 (2016) 38e45
1401 cm1, when x 0.08. The results show that the potassium oxides at higher temperature without weight loss to form alkaline
carbonate coprecipitation method was useful and successful, and earth metals aluminates. The results show that the starting tem-
avoids the problems of residual precipitant presence and the perature of the recombination of metal oxides decreases linearly
elution of small metal ions. when the amount of Eu and Dy doping was increased (Fig. 2).
DSC and TG curves of the prepared precursors are shown in Table 1 presents the starting temperatures of the recombination of
Fig. 2a and b, respectively. The calcining process can be expressed the prepared precursors, which are shown in Fig. 2. The maximum
by three main reactions: the dehydration of M(III)(OH)3 to form calcining temperature of the precursors is equal to or greater than
M(III)2O3, the decomposition of SrCO3 to form SrO, and the this starting temperature. For each phosphor, a temperature was
recombination of metal oxides to form alkaline earth metal alu- selected as the maximum calcining temperature that was higher
minates. Three endothermic peaks are evident in the DSC curves than its starting temperature of 20 C. In this study, the maximum
of the sample precursors (Fig. 2a). Their TG curves also show calcining temperature ranged from 920 to 960 C to form efcient
favorable agreement with the DSC results. The two endothermic phosphors.
peaks lower than 500 C can be assigned to the dehydration of Because the starting temperature of the recombination of metal
M(III)(OH)3 to form M(III)2O3. Because the dehydration of oxides decreases linearly by increasing the doping amount of Eu
Eu(OH)3, Dy(OH)3, and Al(OH)3 simultaneously occurred before and Dy, a multiple regression analysis was performed using the
500 C, the patterns of DSC and TG varied considerably. The nal data of the prepared concentrations of metals in solution (Table 1).
peaks at 700e930 C can be assigned to the decomposition of The empirical equation resulting from the multiple regression
metal carbonates. The samples underwent dehydration and analysis is Eq. (5). The experimental results of the calcining tem-
decomposition reactions followed by a recombination of metal peratures of Sr1-xEuxDy2xAl2O4 (x 01.2) phosphors through this
C.-J. Liang, H.-Y. Siao / Journal of Alloys and Compounds 669 (2016) 38e45 41
empirical model are presented in Table 1. The average absolute phosphor in this study was higher than its starting temperature of
relative error between the starting temperatures obtained from 20 C. The X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4
Fig. 2 and the temperatures estimated using Eq. (5) was 0.23%. The (x 00.12) phosphors are shown in Fig. 3. In undoped strontium
results demonstrate that the empirical equation can provide a aluminates (x 0), SrAl2O4 is the main phase. The relative
quantication of the calcining temperature of Eu and Dy codoping amounts of each phase are in the following order: SrAl2O4 >
strontium aluminate phosphors, thereby enabling the synthesis SrAl4O7 >> Sr4Al14O25. Twenty-seven characteristic XRD peaks of
process to operate under optimal conditions for reducing energy the SrAl2O4 phase were observed in the Sr0.94Eu0.02Dy0.04Al2O4
use. phosphor curve, and four small peaks of the SrAl4O7 phase
occurred at 19.6 , 25.1, 32.1, and 32.6 2q. One shaper and two
Tcalcined temp. 2857.1 3040.7[Al] 3462.8[Sr] 3014.0[Eu] trace peaks of the Sr4Al14O25 phase appeared at 23.8 , 34.3 , and
4103.2[Dy] (5) 62.9 2q. The XRD patterns of Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4 phosphors with
a doping amount of x 0.04 were similar, and had amounts
similar to those of the SrAl4O7 and Sr4Al14O25 phases. However,
the amounts of the EuAlO3, EuAl12O19, and Dy2O3 phases slightly
increased by increasing the doping amount. The diffraction peaks
3.2. Structure of the EuAl12O19 and Dy2O3 phases began to appear at x 0.04,
and the diffraction peaks of the EuAlO3 phase began to appear at
As mentioned, the maximum calcining temperature of each
Table 1
Summary of data for multiple regression and the estimated results.
x 0.08. Nevertheless, the peaks of these phases were extremely lengths of several hundreds of nanometers. The differences
small. It can be concluded that the points at which Eu and Dy among the microstructures may be attributed to the effect of
begin to become liberated from the strontium aluminate crystal recombination of metal oxides. Europium and dysprosium hy-
are x 0.04 and x 0.08, respectively. Therefore, a doping amount droxides play a crucial role in the recombination of the calcining
that is too high does not enhance the formation of Eu emission process.
centers. Table 2 presents the surface properties of prepared phos-
phors. The surface properties and atomic percentage of each
phosphor were measured using a BET technique with N2
3.3. Surface characterization adsorption and SEM-EDS, respectively. The ranges of the specic
surface area, pore volume, and average diameter for prepared
The SEM images of Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4 (x 00.12) phosphors phosphors were 5.77e18.91 m2 g1, 0.0136e0.0364 cm3 g1, and
are shown in Fig. 4. The surface of undoped strontium aluminate 7.59e11.03 nm, respectively. The Sr0.82Eu0.06Dy0.12Al2O4 phos-
(Fig. 4a) was sparsely covered with a ne grain of approximately phor has a specic surface area, pore volume, and average
10 nm. These ne grains may be the nanocrystallites of the diameter close to the averages, which were 13.28 m2 g1,
SrAl4O7 phase compared with its XRD pattern (Fig. 3). Irregular 0.0299 cm3 g1, and 9.24 nm, respectively. Clearly, there is an
morphological grains of varying sizes were observed in the Eu effect of Eu and Dy codoping on surface properties of the phos-
and Dy codoped strontium aluminate phosphors (Fig. 4beh). The phors. The ratio of surface Sr, Al, and O atoms of the undoped
particle size is distributed over a wide range, and the grain strontium aluminate was 1:1.23:1.41. The amounts of surface Al
boundary is not clean. The average grain sizes of Sr1-3xEuxDy2x- and O atoms were lower than the stoichiometric molar ratio of
Al2O4 phosphors with the doping amounts of x 0.01, 0.02, 0.04, SrAl2O4. In may refer to SrAl4O7 and Sr4Al14O25 phases in the bulk
0.06, 0.08, 0.10, and 0.12 were approximately 200, 170, 140, 80, of the undoped strontium aluminate (Fig. 3). The Al/Sr atom ra-
120, 180, and 120 nm (Fig. 4beh), respectively. As shown in tios of the prepared phosphors when 0.02 x 0.10 ranged from
Fig. 4e, the morphologies of Sr0.82Eu0.06Dy0.12Al2O4 phosphors 1.66 to 2.35, which was lower than their stoichiometric molar
with a lower grain size show uniform 1D nanostructures with
C.-J. Liang, H.-Y. Siao / Journal of Alloys and Compounds 669 (2016) 38e45 43
Fig. 4. SEM photographs and EDX surface element compositions of Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4 (x 0 0.12) phosphors. The subgures from (a) to (h) in sequence are x 0, 0.01, 0.02, 0.04,
0.06, 0.08, 0.10, and 0.12, respectively.
ratios but higher than the ratio of undoped strontium aluminate. results demonstrate that the precursors and phosphors of uni-
The Al/Sr atom ratio of higher Eu and Dy codoped strontium form molar stoichiometry are easily formed when uses the po-
aluminates (x 0.12) was 7.30. The reason can be ascribed to the tassium carbonate coprecipitation method. However, the
formation of the EuAlO3, EuAl12O19, and Dy2O3 phases on the liberation of Eu and Dy from the strontium aluminate crystal
surface. The range of Dy/Eu atom ratios of the Eu and Dy codoped occurs when x 0.08.
phosphors was 1.42e1.87, with the minimum at x 0.06. These
44 C.-J. Liang, H.-Y. Siao / Journal of Alloys and Compounds 669 (2016) 38e45
Table 2
Surface characterizations for Sr1-3xEuxDy2xAl2O4 (x 0 0.12) phosphors.
Doping amount, x BET surface area (m2 g1)a Pore volume (cm3 g1)b Average pore diameter (nm)c Surface atomic percentage (%)d
Sr Al Eu Dy O
3.4. Luminescence 610.3 nm. Because the EuAlO3, EuAl12O19, and Dy2O3 phases occur
in the structure of Sr0.64Eu0.12Dy0.24Al2O4, the other types of
Fig. 5 shows the emission spectra of the phosphors prepared by emission centers emit two spectra of 425.0 and 481.3 nm. The
employing a cryogenic cathodoluminescence system at room peaks at 840.4 and 1037.6 nm are caused by wavelength doubling
temperature. The emission intensity of the prepared phosphors and scattering of peaks at 425.0 and 523.4 nm, respectively,
varies according to the following sequence: Sr0.82Eu0.06- because of the second harmonic. As mentioned, Sr0.64Eu0.12-
Dy0.12Al2O4 > Sr0.88Eu0.04Dy0.08Al2O4 > Sr0.76Eu0.08Dy0.16Al2O4 > Dy0.24Al2O4 phosphor has moderate surface characteristics and
Sr0.70Eu0.10Dy0.20Al2O4 > Sr0.96Eu0.02Dy0.04Al2O4 > Sr0.64Eu0.12- the highest surface Dy/Eu ratio; hence, its emission intensity is
Dy0.24Al2O4. In the emission spectra of the prepared phosphors, greater than those of others.
the main and minor emission bands are observed at 523.4 nm and The emission intensities of the prepared phosphors are
573.0 nm, respectively. This suggests that the emission of increased approximately 23.5-fold when the doping amount is
approximately 540 nm originates from the Eu2 4f65 d1 / 4f7(8S7/ increased from 0.01 to 0.06 (Figs. 5 and 6). Furthermore, it can be
2
2) transitions associated with the Eu ions, which are randomly observed that the emission intensities of the prepared phosphors
2
distributed at the three Sr sites. One weak emission band of the with doping amounts ranging from 0.01 to 0.06 increase linearly
prepared phosphors, with both x 0.01 and 0.02, is observed at and rapidly (Fig. 6). The emission intensity increment rate of the
phosphors produced using the potassium carbonate coprecipita-
tion method between doping amounts of 0.01 and 0.06 is approx-
imately 10-fold higher than that produced using the solidestate
reaction method [28] (Fig. 6).
4. Conclusions
Fig. 6. Emission intensities dependence of Eu2 concentration x for the present study (CL, VII 20 kV) and reported by Wang et al. (PL, lex 254 nm) [28].