Chapter 1
Over the last decade there have been some serious concerns among accounting
professional bodies concerning the status of accounting education which has exhibited
relationship between the individuals mathematical skills and the decision to major in
accounting and since more students performance in mathematics is just average, some
studies suggests that one of the factors that might impede some students from studying
to be nine or ten (Lombardi & Clayton 2006, and Rkein& Norris 2010) The Relationship
lack of literature on the factors that impede Indigenous Australians from studying and/or
joining the accounting profession, this study investigates the mathematics factor, and
national averages, this study suggests to be one of the factors that might impede
In the Philippines, Filipino students are having problems when it comes to math
proficiency (Malipot, 2009). A number of students are dropping mathematics aside from
2
science courses usually before and even after examination (E. Senajon et al; in 1286.).
This is an indication of an existing perennial problem because of math anxiety that has
been overlooked by concerned offices and department. In the study conducted in May
2014 by students in Maritime University in Molo, Iloilo City entitled Correlation Between
Algebra) and Accounting 1 (Principles of Accounting) during the academic year 2013-
2014. Results revealed that the academic achievement of the first year student was
fair in Math 1 and good in Accounting 1. The study found out that there is a very
think that a person has to be good with numbers in order to do accounting. It was
concluded in the study conducted by Eskew and Faley (1988) that university students
success in accounting was attributed to spending more study hours in mathematics and
statistics. Other students have suggested that student interest in mathematics plays an
conducted this study to determine if the mathematical skills really have a relationship for
This study aimed to determine the relationship between mathematical skills and
College. This study also wants to determine if the mathematical skills of accounting
1.1. arithmetic;
1.3. algebra?
of:
Hypothesis
Accounting Students), mathematical skills are influential over the accounting discipline
outperformance, i.e., the higher the mathematic knowledge, the better the accounting
performance. The authors also conclude that students previous academic caliber
strongly affect their performances in accounting courses and added that mathematic
and algebra skills had a strongly positive effect on minority accounting students. Their
model consists of variables which are related to students mathematic skills, college
grade point average, college admission test score, and gender. Among all the variables,
Principles of Accounting. They found that although each one of the math score
variables had a significant impact, the overall effect of mathematic skills and the
explanatory power of the regression equation did not grow, as a new math score was
added to the equation. They judged this finding and indicated that mathematics did play
5
not the only effective variable, there are some other influential variables, which can
independent variable is the mathematical skills of the students the indicators are:
Arithmetic which involves numbers and the basic arithmetical operations such as
which is the relationship that exists between the size, number, or amount of two things
and Algebra, that uses numbers and letters that represent numbers. The dependent
variable is the accounting proficiency of the students that notes their academic
performance in their accounting subject. Its indicator is mock board pre-test result. The
Moderator Variable
Gender
This study is of vital importance for this will provide benefits to the following
groups or individuals:
support to the institution with its mission to provide a quality instruction to its students as
it will provide significant information that is useful in order to assist and give their
students the knowledge they needed to continue their goals and to become proficient in
Students. Through this study, college students will be able to grasp appropriate
insights concerning their needed knowledge for them to become proficient of their
chosen field.
Parents and Family Members. The result of this study can help them
understand more how to prepare their children in becoming a college student in the
be conducted.
Definition of Terms
The following terms are defined for clarity and better understanding of the study.
study, it refers the ability of the students to answer the prepared questions correctly
Chambers (2014). In this study, it refers to the ability of the students to answer the
time.
9
Chapter 2
The researchers made a thorough exploration of the related literatures which are
connected to the concerns of this study. This section presents various articles and texts
from books, journals, internet and other information sources to provide a vivid picture
Because math is also about generalizations and abstractions, math skills during the
early years help children to connect ideas, develop logical and abstract thinking, and to
question, analyze, and understand the world around them (Copley, N. 2009).
(and also whole) numbers and fractions and the basic operations applied to these
numbers. As a matter of fact, as a noun in the above sense, the word is used quite
seldom. In the early grades, when numbers are the main object of study, the subject is
much later when it paradoxically becomes Algebra I. The latter is usually associated
with the use of letters as place holders for generic or unknown numbers (Sherman and
Tymon, 1997).
relations, utilizing letters and other symbols to represent specific sets of numbers,
10
values, vectors, etc., in the description of such relations. It is any of several algebraic
numbers (linear algebra) as well as by other elements of the ring. It is any special
compare income, expenses, profits and debts to other companies in similar industries.
The formulas usually result in ratios or percentages that can be used to compare
companies with industry standards easily even though a large difference may exist
Sharlee (2008) stated that accounting is a very old subject and argued that the
word "account" comes from the Latin words ad and computer, which means to
reckon together. The word reckon means to count up, compute or calculate. It is
important to note here that although most accounting definitions do not specifically
accounting and mathematics cannot be denied (Jackling & Calero 2006; Hartwell et al.
2005; Mitchell 1985; Parker 2000; Wong & Chia 1996). Nonetheless, most accounting
definitions state that accounting requires numerical and analytical skills which are also
integral elements in mathematics. In their study, Cohen and Hanno (1993) suggested
that students who chose not to major in accounting did so based on recommendations
and advice from people important to them, but more significantly, they perceived it to be
too number-oriented and boring. Jackling and Calero (2006) cited that accountants have
been typically Rkein referred to as number crunchers given that bookkeeping and
auditing work has emphasized or been associated with an emphasis upon numerical
11
accuracy, routine recording and calculation methods, together with attention to detail
concepts. Researchers have also asserted that the negative views in accounting as a
profession are linked to poor numerical skills (Parker 2000). These numerical skills are
studies (Mitchell 1985) have also established a positive relationship between accounting
drives a better performance in accounting. Although they were more specific than
others, Wong and Chia (1996) indicated that a higher degree of proficiency in
accounting. For instance, it was concluded in the study conducted by Eskew and Faley
(1988) that university students success in accounting was attributed to spending more
study hours in mathematics and statistics. Other students have suggested that student
The relationship between mathematics and accounting was attributed to the heavy
al. 2009). This was demonstrated in Pritchard et al.s study (2004), which suggested
students who major in accounting and finance have better computational and algebraic
Chapter 3
METHOD
This chapter contains the different parts of the research method. These are the
research design, research instrument, research subject, data gathering procedure and
the statistical treatment which were used in the analysis of data that will be gathered.
Research Design
measure variables (without manipulating them) and then analyze the data to see
whether the variables are related. The statistical tools were used are those that
measure the strength and direction of the relationship (i.e. correlation coefficients). It is
much easier to establish a cause and effect relationships when you manipulate one of
the variables (i.e. the independent variable) but there are times when you cannot. If you
use a correlational design then you face the problems described in the previous lecture
This study provided information about the naturally occurring academic status of
Research Subject
respondents of this study were the accounting technology students preferably the
second year of UM Tagum College for the school year 2014- 2015.
13
There were eighty-two (82) female students and fifteen (15) male students. The
the questionnaire to the second year students who were currently enrolled for the
school year 2014-2015; the sampling method used was random sampling. These
Table 1
Gender
Population
Research Instrument
The study employed a patterned questionnaire from the previous researcher April
Diane Abella (2014, unpublished). Questionnaires sharpen the solving ability of the
respondents without relying into calculators. This would test their thinking skills in
The questionnaire had only one part of which it consisted of twenty four (24)
items. Each question is based on the three independent variables indicators of the study
namely: arithmetic, percentage and proportion, and algebra. Choices are given in each
question and calculators are not allowed to use during our survey.
questionnaire. The first part composed of thirty (30) theory question items and the
second part composed of sixty (60) problem solving items. It is also composed of two or
more subject course depending on the year level of the student. The data were
gathered from the result of the latest mock-board examination taken from the program
To determine the level of mathematical skills the following rating scale was used:
is average.
16
Data Gathering
Seeking permission to conduct the study. A written letter was given by the researchers
to the Dean of College to conduct the study and to distribute the questionnaires. With
the approved letter by the Dean, the researchers gave the letter to the registrar.
to the respondents. Data gathered were extracted from the questionnaires and were
The answers to the items of the questionnaires were tallied and recorded the
Mean. This was used to determine the level of mathematical skills and
Chapter 4
Presented in this chapter are the findings of the study. Presentation of findings is
based on the problems raised in the previous section of the study and the statistical
analysis of the gathered data. Presentations of findings are done both in tabular and
textual forms.
Presented in the Table 2 are the data on students mathematical skills in terms of
The posted indicators of mathematical skills are as follows: arithmetic got a mean
percentage and proportions got a mean percentage of correct answer of 73.88 with a
high descriptive equivalent and algebra got a mean percentage of correct answer of
The overall mean percentage of correct score is 65.81, this is described as high.
students in terms of grades of mock board examination result which consist of four
The overall mean is 70.06 with a high descriptive equivalent. It means that
Table 2
of Correct Deviation
Answer
and Proportions
61-80 High
41-60 Average
21-40 Low
Table 3
20 - 68.74 Low
21
proficiency when respondents are analyzed according to their gender. The posted
gender of the accounting students are as follows: the Male students obtained the mean
score of 69.76 and SD value of 8.32; the female students obtained a mean score of
Shown from the table is the computed t-value of 0.19 with the corresponding
p-value of 0.853. To test if there was a significant difference in the level of mathematical
skills and accounting proficiency when analyzed by gender the 0.05 level of significance
was used by researchers. Since that the p-value is greater than the 0.05 level of
significance, therefore, the null hypothesis which states that there is no significant
This means that the level of accounting proficiency of accounting students when
Thus, gender can never be a basis in determining the level of accounting proficiency of
an accounting student.
Okafor and Egbon (2011) examined two accounting courses grades of first year
university students in Nigeria and concluded that there was no significant difference
between academic performance of male and female. They however found that males
mean performance in both courses was higher than that of their female counterparts.
22
Table 4
= 0.05
Rejected
23
Table 5 reflects the relationship between the mathematical skills and accounting
proficiency of accounting students. Mathematical Skills got a mean score of 65.81 and
SD value of 25.01 while Accounting Proficiency got a mean score of 70.06 and SD
value of 8.89.
Shown from the table is the computed r-value of -0.003 with the corresponding p-
value of 0.979. Since that the p-value is greater than the 0.05 level of significance,
therefore, the null analysis which states that there is no significant relationship between
rejected.
Anent, mathematical skill is not the basis for a student to be proficient in the field
of accounting. Perhaps, Burdick and Schwartz (1982) did not consider mathematics and
Yunker et al. (2009) managed a pre-test of mathematics, which was divided into
different sections with each involving certain questions. They tested the effects of
found that although each one of the math score variables had a significant impact, the
overall effect of mathematic skills and the explanatory power of the regression equation
did not grow, as a new math score was added to the equation. They judged this finding
and indicated that mathematics did play an important role in undergraduate accounting
students better performance, but it was not the only effective variable. There are some
other influential variables, which can affect the academic ability of accounting students.
24
Table 5
= 0.05
Skills
Proficiency
rejected
25
Chapter 5
This chapter reveals the sum of the findings, conclusions and recommendation
Summary of Findings
The main purpose of the study was to find out if mathematical skills and
relationship. The respondents of the study were the second year students who took the
The study made use of patterned questionnaire to determine the students level
accounting proficiency.
followed by percentages and proportions that has a mean percentage of correct answer
of 73.88 with a high descriptive equivalent and algebra got a mean percentage of
correct answer of 56.70 with an average descriptive equivalent. The overall mean level
of the level of mathematical skills was 65.81, with a high descriptive equivalent.
On the other hand, the level of accounting proficiency in terms of mock board
The obtained mean of the male students was 69.76 and the female students
obtained 70.19. The computed t-value was 0.19 with the computed p-value of 0.853.
This resulted not to reject the hypothesis. Thus, the level of accounting proficiency when
Furthermore, the obtained mean of the mathematical skills was 65.81 with an SD
value of 25.01; while the accounting proficiency obtained a mean score of 70.06 with an
SD of 8.89. The computed r- value was -0.003. The p- value was 0.979 at 0.05 level of
significance. Hence, the yield results not to reject the null hypothesis. Thus, there is no
accounting students.
Conclusions
Based on the findings of the study, the following conclusions are drawn:
Recommendations
better improve their mathematical skills because it is useful and important to our lives
from the minds of students so that students who aspired to enroll in accountancy but are
afraid because of low mathematics performance will be given a chance to enroll in such
course.
28
REFERENCES
Burdick, R., and Schwartz, B. N. (1982). Predicting grade performance for intermediate
accounting. Delta Pi Epsilon Journal 24,( 3),117.
Chambers, R. (2014). The institute of internal Auditors and Author :Lessons Learned on
the Audit Trail. The Institute of Internal Auditors.
Cohen, J. and Hanno, D. (1993). An analysis of the underlying constructs affecting the
choice of accounting as a major. Issues in Accounting Education, 8(2), 219- 238.
Copley, N. (2009). Mathematics knowledge and skills. Math in the early years 2nd ed.
Washngton D.C. Retrieved on June 2015.
Senajon E.T et al (2010). Trends and pattern of Students performance in the science
and mathematics. SY 2004-2005: Towards EACs Policy Reforms. Emilio
Aguinaldo College Research Bulletin, 8(1),10-23.
Eskew, R.K. and Faley, R.H. (1988). Some determinants of student performance in the
first college-level financial accounting course. The Accounting Review, 63 (1),
137-47.
Gholamreza, Z., Pour, J., Alireza, S.,and Mojtabi, B. (2012). The relationship between
mathematics excellency and efficiency of accounting students. Journal of Modern
Accounting and Auditing 8 (10),pp.1419-1427. ISSN 1548-6583.
Hartwell, C.L., Lightle, S.S. and Maxwell B. (2005). High school students perceptions
of accounting. The CPA Journal, 75(1), 62, New York.
Lombardi, L. and Clayton, B.M. (2009). The path less travelled: Indigenous Australians
and the accounting profession. Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Accounting
Conference, Innsbruck, Austria.
Lowe, D.R. and Simons, K. (1997). Factors influencing choice of business majors
some additional evidence: a research note. Accounting Education: 6(1), 39-45.
Mauldin, S, Crain, J.L. and Mounce, P.H. (2000). The accounting principles instructors
influence on students decision to major in accounting. Journal of Education for
Business, 75(3), 142148.
Okafor, C.A. and Egbon, O. (2011). Academic performance of male versus female
undergraduate accounting student: Evidence from Nigeria. Higher Education
Studies,1(1),9.
Parker, L.D. ( 2000). Goodbye, Number Cruncher. Australian CPA, 70(2), 5052.
Pritchard, R.E., Potter, C.G. and Saccucci, S.M . (2004). The Selection of a business
major: Elements Influencing Student Choice and Implications for Outcomes
Assessment, Journal of education for Business, 79 (3), 152-156. 4
Rkein, H. and Norris G. (2010). Indigenous students study choice: Why Not
Accounting? BAA accounting Education SIG annual conference, Dublin.
Sherman, W.R. and Tymon, W.G. (1997). Empowering accountants. National Public
Accountant (March/April): 40-43.
Wong, D.S.N and Chia, Y. (1996). English language, mathematics and first-year
financial accounting performance: a research note. Accounting Education, 5 (2),
183-189.
Yunker, P.J., Yunker, J.A., and Krull, G.W. (2009). The influence of Mathematics Ability
on Performance in Principle of Accounting. The Accounting Educators Journal
19 (2009).
30
Appendix A
Dear Maam,
Greetings!
The undersigned are BSAT Students, who were currently working on their research
entitled Mathematical Skills and Accounting Proficiency of Accounting Students in UM
Tagum College.
Anent, they would like to seek assistance from your good office to request a copy of the
total population of Second Year Students of the S.Y 2014-2015 2nd Semester.
Noted by:
Questionnaire
Instructions. Circle the correct response for each question. Calculators may not be used. Do all
scratch work on the test sheet.
c. 1,757.7 d. 1.7577
11. Last year Jakes salary was $58,000. At the end of the year he received a 10 percent
increase in salary. What is his salary this year?
a. $638,000 c. $116,000
b. $58,580 d. $63,800
12. If x = 2, then 3x2 5x 6 = _____
a. 16 b. -10 c. -8 d. 8
13. 1575 25 = _____
a. 75 b. 60 c. 63 d. 73
14. XYZ companys profits this year are $2,500,000. Its profit rate on sales (in ratio terms) is
0.10. What are its s0ales this year?
a. 250,000 c. 2,500,000
b. 25,000,00 d. 250,000,000
15. If x = 2, then (x + 3)(x 3)
=?
5
a. 1 b. -1 c. 1/5 d. -1/5
16. (350-200/15) 6 = ______
a. 2,020 b. 342.67 c. 20 d. 60
17. If 50 is 20 percent of x, then x = _____
a. 250 b. 10 c. 1000 d. 40
18. If 2x + 3y =14 and x y = 2 , then x = ? and y = ?
a. x = 2, y = 0 c. x = 4, y = 2
b. x = 0, y = 2 d. x = 2, y = 4
19. If Janice has 12 quarters, 3 dimes, 6 nickels and 7 pennies, how much money does she
have?
a. $4.56 c. $3.67
b. $45.6 d. $36.7
20. Take 62 percent of $12,000. The result is: _____
a. 4,560 c. 74,400
b. 7,440 d. 45,600
21. What are the two roots of x 2- 5x + 6 = 0?
(i.e., factor this expression) x1 = _____ x2 = _____
a. x1= 2 , x2 = 3 c. x1= -2 , x2 = -3
b. x1= 3 , x2 = 2 d. x1= -2 , x2 = -3
22. On the first of January the local bank agrees to lend you $20,000 for college tuition, room,
and board. They charge you 6% interest per year payable on a monthly basis. How much
interest must you pay at the end of January?
a. 12,000
b. 1,200
c. 2,400
d. 240
23. A fruit basket contains x apples and y oranges. There are 6 more oranges than there are
apples. Jack and Jill decide to split the fruit equally. Each of them gets 13 pieces of fruit.
How many apples and oranges were there in the fruit basket?
a. 16 oranges, 10 apples
b. 10 apples, 16 oranges
c. 14 oranges, 12 apples
d. 12 oranges, 14 apples