Review
New perspectives on radicular cysts: do they heal?
P. N . R . N A I R
Department of Oral Structural Biology, Centre of Dental and Oral Medicine, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Table 1 The incidence of radicular cysts amongst periapical lesions ture of a radicular cyst in relation to the root canal of the
Reference Cysts Granuloma Others Total affected teeth has not been taken into account. The
% % % lesions n major reason for this has been the nature of the biopsy
(Sommer 1966) 6 84 10 170 itself. Apical specimens removed by curettage do not
(Block et al. 1976) 6 94 230 contain the root-tips of the diseased teeth. Obviously,
(Sonnabend & Oh 1966) 7 93 237 structural reference to the root canals of the affected
(Winstock 1980) 8 83 9 9804*
teeth is not possible. Simon (1980) pointed out that
(Linenberg et al. 1964) 9 80 11 110
(Wais 1958) 14 84 2 50 there are two distinct categories of radicular cysts
(Patterson et al. 1964) 14 84 2 510 namely, those containing cavities completely enclosed in
(Nair et al. 1996) 15 50 35 256 epithelial lining, and those containing epithelium-lined
(Simon 1980) 17 54 23 35
cavities that are open to the root canals. Simon (1980)
(Stockdale &
Chandler 1988) 17 77 6 1108 designated the latter bay cysts. It seems that he
(Lin et al. 1991) 19 81 150 observed only the large type of such lesions with volumi-
(Nobuhara & nous cavities into which the root apices of the affected
Del Rio 1993) 22 59 19 150
teeth appeared to protrude. The photomicrographs in
(Baumann &
Rossman 1956) 26 74 121 the publication reveal severe damage of the
(Mortensen et al. 1970) 41 59 396 microanatomical relationship between the root apices
(Bhaskar 1966) 42 48 10 2308 and the cyst-epithelia. Furthermore, they do not repre-
(Spatafore et al. 1990) 42 52 6 1659
sent axial sections passing through the root canal. These
(Lalonde & Luebke 1968) 44 45 11 800
(Seltzer et al. 1967) 51 45 4 87 factors might have influenced critics to wonder whether
(Priebe et al. 1954) 55 46 101 the bay cysts (Simon 1980) are histological artefacts.
Table adapted from (Nair et al. 1996) * Number of operations
More recently, (Nair et al. 1996) analyzed 256 periapical
performed. The author does not explicitly say whether all the 9804 lesions obtained with extracted teeth. The specimens
biopsies were subjected to histopathological diagnosis. were processed by modern plastic-embedding technique
and meticulous serial or step-serial sections were
epithelialized lesions, part of the specimens can give the prepared and evaluated based on predefined histopatho-
appearance of epithelium-lined cavities that do not exist logical criteria. Out of the 256 specimens 35% were
in reality. Seltzer et al. (1967) defined a typical radicular found to be periapical abscess, 50% were periapical
cyst as one in which a real or imagined lumen was lined granulomas and only 15% were periapical cysts. Equally
with stratified squamous epithelium. It should be significant was the finding that two distinct classes of
pointed out that the photomicrographic illustrations in radicular cysts the apical true cysts, with cavities
many studies (Bhaskar 1966, Lalonde & Luebke 1968) completely enclosed in epithelial linings and the apical
represent only magnified views of selected small pocket cysts, with cyst-lumina open to the root canals
segments of epithelialized lesions. They are not sup- occur at the periapex when the lesions were analyzed in
ported by overview pictures of lesser magnifications of relation to the root canals. An overall 9% of the 256
sequential sections derived from different axial planes of lesions were apical true cysts and 6% were periapical
the lesions in question. The discrepancy in the reported pocket cysts.
incidence of periapical cysts is most probably due to the
difference in the histopathological interpretation of the Periapical true cyst
sections. When the histopathological diagnosis is based
on random or limited number of serial sections, most The periapical true cyst may be defined as a chronic
epithelialized periapical lesions would be wrongly inflammatory lesion at the periapex that contains an
classified as radicular cysts. This assumption is strongly epithelium lined, closed pathological cavity (Fig. 1). The
supported by the results of a most recent study (Nair pathogenesis of radicular cysts, presumably the true
et al. 1996) in which an overall 52% of the lesions (n = cysts, has been discussed by various authors (Thoma
256) were found to be epithelialized but only 15% were 1917, Rohrer 1927, Gardner 1962, Shear 1963, Main
actually periapical cysts. 1970, Ten Cate 1972, Torabinejad 1983). An apical
cyst is considered to be a direct sequel to apical granu-
loma, although a granuloma need not always develop
There are cysts and cysts
into a cyst. Due to still unexplainable reasons only a
In routine histopathological diagnostic work the struc- small fraction (< 10%) of the periapical lesions advance
Fig. 1 (a) Periapical true cyst. Two sequential sections derived from
different axial planes (b, c) from the same lesion. Note the lumen (LU)
is completely enclosed in epithelium (EP). The rectangular demarcated
area in (b) is magnified in (a). D dentine; IC infiltrate cells.
Magnifications: a x130; b, c 325.
other hand, there is increasing evidence in support of a stratified squamous epithelium which grows and forms
molecular mechanism for cyst expansion (Nair 1997). an epithelial collar (Fig. 3c) around the root tip. The
The macrophages (Nair 1997) and T-lymphocytes epithelial collar forms an epithelial attachment (Nair &
(Torabinejad & Kettering 1985) in the cyst wall may Schroeder 1985) to the root surface so as to seal off the
provide a continuous source of bone resorptive metabo- infected root canal and the microcystic lumen from the
lites (Formigli et al. 1995) and cytokines. The presence of periapical milieu. The presence of micro-organisms in
effector molecules such as matrix metalloproteinase-1 the apical root canal attracts neutrophilic granulocytes
and 2 have also been reported in the cyst walls by chemotaxis into the microlumen. However, the
(Teronen et al. 1995). pouch-like lumen biologically outside the body milieu
acts as a death trap and garbage bag to the external-
ized and dying neutrophils. As the necrotic tissue and
Periapical pocket cyst
microbial products accumulate, the sac-like lumen
The periapical pocket cyst is a radicular cyst containing enlarges to accommodate the debris to form a volumi-
an epithelium-lined pathological cavity which is open to nous diverticulum of the root canal space into the
the root canal of the affected tooth (Fig. 3). As has been periapical area (Fig. 3c). It has been pointed out (Nair
mentioned previously such lesions were originally et al. 1996) that from the pathogenic, structural, tissue
described as bay cysts (Simon 1980) and has been dynamic and host-beneficial and protective stand points,
recently investigated in detail and renamed as the the epithelium-lined pouch-like extension of the root
periapical pocket cysts (Nair et al. 1996). It is postu- canal space of such lesions has much in common with a
lated that a pocket cyst is initiated by a small bubble-like marginal periodontal pocket so as to justify the termi-
extension of the infected root canal space into the nology of periapical pocket cyst as against a biologically
periapex. The microluminal space is enclosed in a meaningless nomenclature of bay cyst (Simon 1980).
On the other hand, many clinicians are of the opinion should also be considered. The aim of conventional root
that a great majority of cysts heal after conventional canal therapy has been the elimination of infectious
root-filling-therapy. A success rate of 8590% has been agents from the root canal and the prevention of reinfec-
recorded by many practitioners and endodontic investi- tion by obturation. A periapical pocket cyst is, likely
gators (Staub 1963, Kerekes & Tronstad 1979, therefore, to heal after conventional root canal therapy
Barbakow et al. 1981, Sjgren et al. 1990). However, the (Simon 1980). The tissue dynamic of a true cyst is self-
histological status of any apical radiolucent lesion at the sustaining however, as the lesion is no longer dependent
time of treatment is unknown to the clinician and on the presence or absence of irritants in the root canal.
he/she is unaware of the differential diagnostic status of Therefore, true cysts, particularly the large ones, are less
the successful and failed cases. However, most of the likely to be resolved by conventional root canal therapy
cystic lesions must heal in order to account for the high (Fig. 4). This has been clearly shown in a longitudinal
success rate after conventional root canal treatment follow-up of a case (Nair et al. 1993).
and the observed high incidence of radicular cysts. We The low incidence of periapical cysts and the existence
have already seen how several investigators listed in of two distinct classes of cystic lesions at the periapex call
Table 1 reached the erroneous conclusion of high cyst- for a rethinking of the rationale behind some of the
incidence based on incorrect diagnosis of epithelialized diagnostic and therapeutic procedures currently
periapical lesions. practised in oral surgery and clinical endodontics such
The clinical impact of the structural difference as: (i) routine histopathological examination of peri-
between the apical true cysts and the apical pocket cysts apical lesions removed by curettage, (ii) performing
disproportionately large numbers of apical surgery
based on radiographic diagnosis of a periapical lesion as
a radicular cyst, (iii) the widely held notion amongst
endodontists that a large majority of cysts heal after
conventional root filling therapy and (iv) the decision to
re-treat an asymptomatic, post-therapeutically persist-
ing periapical lesion instead of adopting apical surgery
as the treatment of choice under those clinical circum-
stances.
References
BA R B A K O W FH, CL E A T O N-JO N E S PE, FR I E D M A N D (1981) Endodontic
treatment of teeth with periapical radiolucent areas in general
dental practice. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine and Oral Pathology 51,
5529.
BA U M A N N L, RO S S M A N SR (1956) Clinical, roentgenologic and histo-
logic findings in teeth with apical radiolucent areas. Oral Surgery,
Oral Medicine and Oral Pathology 9, 13306.
BH A S K A R SN (1966) Periapical lesion types, incidence and clinical
features. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine and Oral Pathology 21, 65771.
BL O C K RM, BU S H E L L A, RO D R I G U E S H, LA N G E L A N D K (1976) A histo-
logic, histobacteriologic, and radiographic study of periapical
endodontic surgical specimens. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine and Oral
Pathology 42, 65678.
BO R G G, PE R S S O N G, TH I L A N D E R H (1974) A study of odontogenic cysts
with special reference to comparisons between keratinizing and
Fig. 4 Longitudinal radiographs of a periapically affected central nonkeratinizing cysts. Swedish Dental Journal 67, 31125.
maxillary incisor of a 37-year-old woman for a period of 4 years and FO R M I G L I L, OR L A N D I N I SZ, TO N E L L I P, et al. (1995) Osteolytic
9 months. Note the large radiolucent asymptomatic lesion before (a), processes in human radicular cysts: morphological and biochemical
44 months after root-filling (b), and immediately after periapical results. Journal of Oral Pathology and Medicine 24, 21620.
surgery (c). The periapical area shows distinct bone healing 1 year FR E E M A N N (1931) Histopathological investigation of dental granu-
post-operatively. Histopathological examination of the surgical loma. Journal of Dental Research 11, 176200.
specimen by modern tissue processing and step-serial sectioning GA R D N E R AF (1962) A survey of periapical pathology: part one. Dental
technique has confirmed that the lesion was a true radicular cyst. Digest 68, 1627.
(Selected radiographs from P.N.R. Nair et al. Int Endod J 1993, HI L L TJ (1930) The epithelium in dental granuloma. Journal of Dental
26:225233). Research 10, 32332.