Abstract
The radical changes which have been taken place in the Chinese economy since the late
1970s have influenced the health sector and the health care financing system. A rapid
increase in medical care costs in the last decade has placed a heavy financial burden on the
government and enterprises and a vast majority of the rural population. The public service
medical scheme for government employees and labor insurance for enterprise workers are
facing a great challenge of cost containment through a series of reforms in the mechanisms
of fund collection and management. In the meanwhile, the collapse of the cooperative
medical care scheme in most rural areas has raised the issue of gaining access to basic
health care for the rural population and in particular the poor. This paper provides a
description, with some explanation, of how and why the health care financing system had
been changed and experienced such a sharp increase in expenditure. In conclusion, how to
develop and improve a financing system appropriate to the level of socio-economic develop-
ment in China is addressed.
*Corresponding author.
1. Introduction
The health care financing system mainly refers to the economic mechanism for
the collection, distribution and use of health resources. Health care is one of the
basic needs, and as such, the Constitution of the Peoples Republic of China
indicates that every person has a right to have access to health care. However,
provision of health services for everyone depends on their availability as well as on
the effective organization of health services. Organizational aspects of health
service provision include adjusting the relation between provision and demand, and
balancing the interests of consumers, providers, government, employers, and insti-
tutions in China.
Since 1978, socio-economic reforms in China have been implemented; in rural
areas the unit of responsibility changed from the agricultural collective to the
household. To facilitate the transition from a centrally-planned to a socialist
market economy, elements of competition have been introduced to Chinese
enterprises and institutions. The government administrative and financial systems
are also changing. The centralized administration is evolving into a system in which
local governments play a more important role. The system of financial responsibil-
ity, that was established in the 198Os, states that parts of government revenue
generated at the provincial, municipal and county levels should be managed by
those levels, with a fixed amount of revenue transferred to the central-level
government based on established contracts. These reforms promote socio-eco-
nomic development, and as such, have a significant impact on health care and
health care financing,
Three types of health care financing schemes exist in China. These are the labor
insurance medical care scheme, the public service medical care scheme, and the
cooperative medical care scheme. In addition, those not covered by the above
schemes have to pay out of pocket for medical care they seek on a basis of a
fee-for-service. The first two schemes were part of the social security system
established by the government, and the last relied on agricultural collectives. These
three schemes should be improved to meet the goals of the socio-economic
reforms.
The purpose of this article is to review and analyze the Chinese health care
financing systems and the recent socio-economic reforms in terms of their impact
on health care. More recent and specific health care financing reforms will also be
discussed. Having considered historical factors and the great differences in socio-
economic development between rural and urban areas in China, the financing of
health care in the two areas, in turn, is addressed.
Table 1
Chinese health financing systems, 1990
Coverage of Chinese
population (%) 17.8 2.4 7.0
medical care costs in particular [4]. This implied that most enterprises had to use
their profits to pay the excess. At the national level, total expenditure due to the
labor insurance medical care scheme was 5.3 billion yuan in 1980 and 22.2 billion
yuan (13.3 billion yuan in 1980 prices) in 1990. This indicates an annual growth rate
of 9.6% for total medical expenditure and 9.2% for medical expenditure per capita
during the 1980s.
The population coverage of labor insurance has increased gradually with
economic development during the 1980s. The total number of employees covered
was 117.79 million in 1980, and 203.16 million in 19901. This percentage is the
equivalent of 17.9% of the total Chinese population, of which state employees
accounted for 47%, collective employees 20% and dependents of employees
accounted for 33%.
The exchange rates of yuan to U.S. dollars in the years 1980 and 1990 were as follows: 1980, period
average .4984; 1990, period average $4.7832 (Source: International Financial Statistics Year Book, 1994,
International Monetary Fund).
X.-Y Gu. S.L. Tang /Health Policy 32 (1995) 181-l 91 185
Table 2
Medical expenditure and coverage of insurance schemes, 1980-1990
Source: The State Statistical Bureau and The Ministry of Public Health. Note: Figures in brackets are
1980 prices.
186 X.-Y. Gu, S.L. Tang /Health Policy 32 (1995) 181-191
expenses paid by the government and the enterprises are the main sources of
income for service providers. As a result, neither medical care providers, nor
consumers have any incentive to control medical care expenditure under these
insurance schemes. This is the real reason why utilization was higher, average
length of stay longer, and medical costs per visit and admission higher than those
of patients who pay out of pocket for medical care.
Another disadvantage of the labor insurance and public service medical care
scheme is, to some extent, their limited ability to spread risk. Since the manage-
ment of these schemes is largely at the enterprise or government institution level,
each enterprise or institution has a limited ability to bear great financial risks, such
as hospital payment for a cancer patient, for example. Under the market economic
system, the fiscal status of enterprises and institutions varies a great deal. Some are
financially unable to provide complete medical care for their employees. For
instance, they cannot pay an expensive medical bill for an employee with cancer,
heart disease, or renal failure. Therefore, people working at certain enterprises and
institutions are not guaranteed access to the medical care they may require.
However, there is overuse of medical care by the employees of enterprises and
institutions that can pay all their medical bills.
levels, had been weakened. In addition, there were problems in management of the
scheme. For instance, no clear guidelines were produced for the design and
management of the scheme. Many schemes were introduced without advice from
experts in health planning and financial management.
The percentage of villages covered by the scheme fell to 69% in 1980, and then
fell further to around 5% in 1985. However, some of the cooperative medical
schemes have still survived in the counties, townships and villages mostly located in
the relatively developed regions. Some counties and townships have developed
innovative schemes covering curative or/and preventive services for local people.
Government policy is to encourage the rebuilding and improvement of the cooper-
ative medical scheme, which is an important element for the implementation of the
global health strategy of Health For All by the year 2000. Under the circumstances,
there has been a tendency toward strengthening the cooperative medical care
schemes or developing rural health insurance schemes. For example, the health
sector in Jinshang county of the Shanghai municipality has worked with the county
insurance company since the late 1980s to develop a rural health insurance scheme
through a co-payment mechanism 181. Jintan county in Jiangsu province has
strengthened the cooperative medical care scheme which is financed jointly by the
rural enterprises, the village welfare funds and peasants [9].
A series of comparative studies indicate that the cooperative medical scheme can
provide basic health care for the majority of the peasants at reasonable cost (Table
3). It plays a key role in the implementation of rural primary health care in China,
In comparison with those who pay for medical care out of pocket, peasants covered
by cooperative medical schemes use more medical care with the same costs [lo].
The difficulties of the cooperative medical care scheme are that the funds
collected from village welfare funds and local governments have been reduced, or
in some cases disappeared. Because of changes in the structure and function of
local governance, funding and risk spreading are limited to the village level. The
cooperative medical scheme must be adapted to current socio-economic situations
and local circumstances.
Table 3
Comparison of rural health financing systems
Source: Gu X.Y. et al., Comparative Study On Health Financing System in Rural China, in Study of
Health Financing System in Rural China, 1991, pp. 54-66.
188 X.-Y Gu, S.L. Tang/Health Policy32 (1995) 181-191
China, which was the responsibility of the government and the collectives. Most
hospitals and health facilities were state-owned or collective-owed. There were no
private practices or private hospitals in China before 1980. The main sources of
financing for health services were the government, enterprises, and agricultural
collectives. Medical fees paid by individuals accounted for a small part of national
health expenditure. Health resources were allocated directly by the Ministry of
Public Health according to the distribution of the population, and the health care
network was established based on the administrative structure. Prices of medical
services were set below their costs. Health care development expenditure and part
of the recurrent expenditure were financed by the government. In general, re-
sources for health were limited, and demand for health care was also not high. The
health care supply and demand were balanced at a lower level.
The situation has changed dramatically. Presently, 14% of urban residents and
93% of rural residents have to pay for medical care out of their pockets. While the
socio-economic reforms of the 1980s promoted economic development and led to
an increase in peoples income, medical care expenditure paid directly by patients
grew more rapidly. As indicated in Table 2 the annual rate of growth of GNP per
capita during the 1980s was 7.6%. The national per capita income also rose during
the same period at an annual rate of 7.3%. The per capita income for peasants
grew at a rate of 6.4% annually between 1980 and 1990. The growth rate for total
health expenditure was much higher, being 10.0% in 1980s (in 1980 prices).
Medical care costs paid for by peasants were 1.5 yuan per person in 1980, and 21.3
yuan (12.7 yuan in 1980 prices) in 1990, with the annual growth rate being 23.8%.
Medical care costs became a heavy burden for those not covered by the schemes,
especially peasants. The ability to pay is a strong determinant of utilization of
medical care. Financial constraints were the main reason for peasants unmet
medical care needs. A national household health survey in 1988 showed that 20%
of rural patients did not seek outpatient services. Among those in poor counties,
half of the patients not treated were not treated due to the magnitude of costs
involved. Meanwhile, 25% of the rural population that was referred to hospital by
Table 4
Economic and medical care statistics for rural China (1988)
Source: Gu X.Y. et al., Medical Care in Rural China, in Study of Health Financing System In Rural
China, 1991, pp. 7-25.
X.-Y Gu, S.L. Tang /Health Policy 32 (I 995) 181-l 91 189
doctors were not admitted, largely because of financial difticulty (Table 4). As
Zhang reported [ll], of 60 poverty-stricken families in Yuhan county of Zhejiang
province, 47% of them stated that payment for expensive medical care for family
member(s) was the most important contributing factor in forcing them into poverty.
Hence, it is necessary to change the existing situation by expanding the coverage of
the cooperative medical scheme or developing innovative health financing schemes
in order to provide PHC for millions of Chinese peasants at a reasonable cost.
to basic health care to everyone. The emphases have been placed on improvement
of rural health, strengthening of preventive and promotive services and develop-
ment of traditional Chinese medicine. The following measures have been taken in
order for China to achieve the goals outlined:
Early in 1985, the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China suggested
that it was necessary to study and establish a new social security system that would
be compatible with the recent socio-economic reforms. Certain reforms of the
health care financing system have been conducted in the past decade.
In rural China, the rebuilding and improvement of the cooperative medical
scheme has been encouraged by the government for years. The scheme should bc
based on the level of local economic development and accepted by the vast
majority of the local population. The sources of finance for the scheme include
government subsidies, and collective and household contributions. To ensure that
the funds collected for the cooperative medical care scheme can be used in an
efficient way, the management of the scheme must be strengthened through use ot
some insurance mechanisms and monitoring of medical practice and consumer
behavior. The governments at various levels should play a leading role in develop-
ing the cooperative medical care scheme.
In urban areas, the main objective of reforming the public service medical
scheme and the labor insurance is to contain medical care costs, given that people
covered can get access to medical care when needed. To achieve the goal. several
issues have to be properly addressed in reforming the public service medical
scheme and the labor insurance. First, it is necessary for the government to
develop mechanisms of not only controlling the use of services, but also limiting
hospitals from over-providing services. Second, as shown in many studies. drug
expenditure accounts for a substantial percentage of medical cart costs. The
service providers, especially in urban areas of China, are more likely to use drugs
imported or made by joint ventures, which generate more revenue for them.
Therefore, it is very important to limit use of expensive drugs and tonics for cost
X.-Y Gu, XL. Tang /He&h Policy 32 (1995) 181-191 191
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to express their appreciation to Professor William Hsiao
of Harvard School of Public Health and some participants at the conference on
Health Sector Reform in Developing Countries: Issues for the 1990s who provided
insightful comments on an earlier draft of the paper. They would also like to thank
MS Anupa Bir for her editorial work.
References
Zhou, S.Q. and Zhang, B., Development of Health Care Financing System in Rural China, Study
of Health Care Financing System in Rural China, Shanghai Scientific & Technical Press, 1991, pp.
40-46.
121 Liu, C.Q. and Sun, K.D., Social Insurance and Employees Welfare, Labor Press, China, 1987.
131 Zhou, P., Reform of Employees Health Care Financing System, Huawen Press, China, 1993.
141 Institute of Sociology of Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences, Contemporary Social Security,
China, 1989.
151 Song, L.Z., Overview of Work-Related Insurance and its Reform in Mainland China. A Paper
Presented at the Mainland China-Taiwan Conference on Health Economics, Beijing, China,
October 1994.
b1 Gu, X.Y. et al., Financing health care in rural China: preliminary report of a nation-wide survey,
Social Science and Medicine, 3M4) (1993) 385-391.
[71 Feng, X.S. et al., Practice and perspective of rural health care financing schemes in China, Health
Economics Research, 5 (1994) 9-14.
181 Bao, J.T. et al., Rural Health Insurance Scheme in Tiing Township of Jinshan County, Study of
Health Care Financing System in Rural China, Shanghai Scientific & Technical Press, 1991, pp.
99-107.
191 Jiang, W.Z., Welfare and Welfare-Risk Types of the Cooperative Medical Care Schemes in
Jintan County, Study of Health Care Financing System in Rural China, Shanghai Scientific &
Technical Press, 1991, pp. 91-98.
1101 Gu, X.Y. et al., Utilization of health services in rural China, Health Econonomics Research, 5
(1994) 15-23.
t111 Zhang, C.M., The Cooperative Medical Care System in Yuhan County, Study of Health Care
Financing System in Rural China, Shanghai Scientific & Technical Press, 1991, pp. 83-90.