Adi Maryono
Porphyry Deposit Workshop
Lombok-Sumbawa, 2012
th
Discussion Outline
50% Witwatersrand
12% Epithermal
10% Porphyry (+ intrusion hosted)
12% Sediment hosted (incl. 4% Carlin)
9% Greenstone lode (orogenic)
7% Other (Fe Fm, VHMS, etc.)
Arribas, 2000
Ore Deposit Styles: Giant Gold Deposits
(31 >20 Moz deposits)
1 (7) Witwatersrand
7 Porphyry (+ 1 intrusion hosted)
8 Epithermal (3 HS, 2 IS, 1 LS, 2 LSa)
6 Sediment hosted (incl. 2 Carlin)
5 Greenstone lode (orogenic)
4 Other (Fe ox, Fe Fm, Archean diss.)
Sillitoe, 2000
Porph-Cu Metal Endowment
(Einaudi, 2010)
Pebble West
Behemothian
Super-giant
Cooke et al., 2008
El Salvador
Cu-Mo deposits
Cu-Au deposits
Reko Diq
Aktogay-Aide
Cuajone
Giant porphyry copper deposits
Pima
La Granja
Radomiro Tom
Resolution
Cerro Colorad
Pebble East
Morenci - Me
Lone Star
Escondida
Los Pelambre
Grasberg
Cananea
Bingham
Butte
Oyu Tolgoi
Collahuasi
Chuquicamat
Rio Blanco
El Teniente
80
60
90
70
50
40
30
20
10
0
Contained copper metal (Mt)
Sipilay
Cu-Au-Mo deposits
Chuquicama
Cooke et al., 2008
Cu-Mo deposits
Cu-Au deposits
Sar Cheshm
Atlas
Giant gold-rich porphyry deposits
Frieda River
Alumbrera
Galore Cree
El Teniente
Escondida
Tampakan
Minas Cong
Batu Hijau
Reko Diq
Ok Tedi
Panguna
Cerro Casale
FSE/Lepant
Dalneye
Cadia
Kal'makyr
Pebble Wes
Pebble East
Oyu Tolgoi
Bingham
Grasberg
1600
2800
2400
2000
1200
800
400
0
Gold (tonnes)
Our Region, SEA-PNG
Tectonic
Arc Distribution
Major Framework
Gold Deposits
Source: Mitchell & Leach, 1991; Carlile & Mitchell, 1994; Newmont Compilation, 2005; PaRFS, 2008
Our Region, SEA-PNG
Tectonic
Arc Distribution
Major Framework
Gold Deposits
Source: Mitchell & Leach, 1991; Carlile & Mitchell, 1994; Newmont Compilation, 2005; PaRFS, 2008
Taiwan-Japan,
2060, 9%
PNG, 3250, 15%
Neogene, 15689,
72%
Our Region, SEA-PNG
Tectonic
Arc Distribution
Major Framework
Gold Deposits
Source: Mitchell & Leach, 1991; Carlile & Mitchell, 1994; Newmont Compilation, 2005; PaRFS, 2008
Orogenic, 12, 2%
Placer, 2, 0%
Porphyry, 406, 57%
Skarn, 57, 8%
VMS, 2, 0%
Our Region, SEA-PNG
Tectonic
Arc Distribution
Major Framework
Gold Deposits
Source: Mitchell & Leach, 1991; Carlile & Mitchell, 1994; Newmont Compilation, 2005; PaRFS, 2008
Laos, 6.4, 1%
Philippines, 190.9,
27%
Malaysia, 11.8, 2%
PNG, 197.5, 28%
Myanmar, 1.5, 0%
Taiwan, 6.4, 1%
Thailand, 4.8, 1%
Indonesia, 284.4,
39% Vietnam, 8.1, 1%
Paleogene, 49.5, 7%
Mesozoic, 31.2, 4%
Paleozoic, 7.9, 1%
Volcanic arc
Typical calc-alkaline magmas contain sufficient
Sea level copper, chlorine, and water to produce economic
Upper crustal Continentalporphyry copper mineralization (Bodnar ,sufficient
Oceanic crust batholith crust flux of magma (>100km3) for metal concentration
Oceanic mantle
lithosphere Lower crustal
MASH zone Arc Magmas: Hi-S, H2O, Cl, LILE (K, Rb, Cs, Ba,
o
600 C 600o C Sr), enrichment in Li, B, Pb, As, Sb and depletion i
Basaltic
underplating SubcontinentalTi, Nb,Ta
o mantle lithosphere
1000 C 1000o C
Slab melts: Hi-alumina, Hi-Sr, low-Y. low HREE,
Asthenosphere
Partial melting of (Al2O3>15wt %, MgO <3 wt%, Y<18ppm,
hydrated mantle o Yb<1.9ppm, Sr>400ppm, SiO2>56wt%).
Asthenosphere 1400 C
o
Structure and processes in a subduction zone and continental arc 1000 C
Cu content 60ppm to make 10 Mt
Cu=10Mt/60ppm/2.7g/cm3=63km3. <100%
Richards, 2005 extraction, ~ 100km3
Deposit Setting and Styles
The end of protacted tectono-
Advanced argillic Central
alteration (AA) volcano magmatic events (culmination of
AA AA
deformation).
Ph
0 km
K
Ph Relaxation of compressional stress
K
Ph K K K
K
permits the voluminous rise of
Potassic alteration (K) K K
K Ph Pr Pr Pr buoyant, evolved magmas to upper
Pr overprinted by phyllic (Ph) K K
K
K
K crustal levels
Pr
Supracrustal Pr
K
K Sub-volcanic Propylitic alteration (Pr)
Pr K K
K
plutons Buoyant magmas raising from depth
sequence K
K K Pr
Pr
Pr
(5km) to form a cupola zone (~2km)
Pr
Pr Pr K
K
Pr
along pre-existing fractures.
K K
K
K K
5 km K K
K K K Upper-crustal
K batholith at LNB This fluid dynamic mechanism enables
K K
K efficient partitioning of metals from
large volume of magmas into the
exsolving hydrothermal fluid
Crystalline Focused delivery into the carapace
basement zones following ground preparation
(fracturing due to volatile rich
Feeder dyke carapace)
Structure and processes in a subductioncomplex
zone and continental arc Efficient precipitation of metals by
cooling and wall rock reactions.
Richards, 2005
A. Neutral stress to midly extensional arc (e.g
Deposit Setting and Styles
Yanacocha)
B. Compressive back arc during arc volcanism
(e.g. Potosi Bolivia)
C. Compressive arc with subdued volcanism
(e.g. El Indio)
D. Extensional arc ( El Penon Chile)
E. Extensional back arc during volcanism
(Cerro Vanguardia, Argentina)
F. Extensional back arc during transition from
subduction to rift-related magmatism
G. Extensional continental margin following
cessation of subduction-advent of transform
faulting (Bullfrog Nevada)
H. Compresive tectonism linked to transform
fault boundary (McLauglin California)
I. Restricted post-collisional magmatism during
collision-induced slab break off (Porgera, PNG)
J. Extension due to tectonic collapse following
continent collision (Baley, Russia)
Sillitoe and Hedenquist, 2003
th
H2S + 2O2 H2SO4 Steam-heated
Origin of acid-
sulfate alteration
Porgera
Ertzberg+ Lepanto
Batu Hijau Wafi, Nena
Kucing Liar Tujuh Bukit
OkTedi
Golpu
Grasberg
Acid-Alkaline
Enargite-gold CENTRAL OYU TOLGOI
Vuggy quartz ore-qz-enargite ore
Typical altered QMD
LEPANTO MINE, PHILIPPINES
Low and high sulphur
Hot spring
Transitional Porphyry-Epithermal
Penasquito
Wall rock porphyry, failed porphyry
Vein in Honko deposit
LS to HS
Porphyry Cu-Au,
Hishikari Mine, Japan Cu-Mo, Au etc Porphyry
Epithermal
Nomenclature
NOMENCLATURE AUTHORS-INVENTORS
Acid Alkaline
Mesothermal-Epithermal Lindgren, 1933
High sulfidation High-sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Low sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Sillitoe, 1989, 1993
on Mesothermal-Epithermal
the basis of a single perspective or parameter Lindgren, 1933
High sulfidation High-sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Low sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Sillitoe, 1989, 1993
High sulfidation High-sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Low sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Sillitoe, 1989, 1993
Acid Alkaline
Mesothermal-Epithermal Lindgren, 1933
High sulfidation High-sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Low sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Sillitoe, 1989, 1993
Acid Alkaline
Mesothermal-Epithermal Lindgren, 1933
fieldwork applicability
High-sulfidation in exploration?
Low-sulfidation Hedenquist, 1987
High sulfidation High-sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Low sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Sillitoe, 1989, 1993
on Mesothermal-Epithermal
theAcidbasis of a single perspective or Alkaline
parameter Lindgren, 1933
productEpithermal
vs process based Buchanan, 1981
an overlapping field,
Acid sulfate an overprinting and complex system?
Adularia-sericite Hayba et al., 1985, Heald et al.,1987
fieldwork
High sulfidation applicability in exploration?
High-sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Low sulfide+base metal, low sulfidation Sillitoe, 1989, 1993
NEUTRAL
ACID
CENTRAL
OYU TOLGOI
Typical altered
QMD
O Tolgoi Akeshi El Indio El Indio Golden Cross
Key parameters to observe
Low Sulfidation High Sulfidation Porphyry
Metals As, Sb, Zn, Pb, Hg, Se As, Sb, Bi, Pb, Hg, Te, Sn Bi, Pb, Zn, Te, As
Sulfides py, asp, po en, tet, ten, cpy, cov cpy, bo, dig, cc, cov
Mineral stability
Mineral 100 200 300
pH Alunite
Jarosite
Halloysite
Kaolinite
Dickite
Acidic Pyrophyllite
Diaspore
Zunyite, topaz
Anatase
Rutile
Cristobalite
Quartz
Pyrite
Marcasite
Neutral
Smectite
Illite/smectite
Chlorite/smectite
Illite
Chlorite
Epidote
Biotite
Adularia
Alkaline
Calcite
Mordenite
Laumontite
Wairakite
1200
Sulfide-oxide mineral assemblages
2
(high KCA-porphyry to epithermal) ~
0
Rs
=-
3
py po
Lazy L-shaped field
=-2 andesitic
Rs
magma
t+ p
n
O
m +c
+b
Mo
state~ fS2 and T
bn
py cp
-4
hm
Au-
E ens
atio
n
ry Cu- =0
AT r cond T phy r" Rs
ST Sulfu por ffe
Cu
bu
ON
Active system, the oxidation-sulfidation
-6 k
TI cv oc
DA "r =1
al
dg Rs
FI g
cp
y
n-A
S
+p
UL
erm
GH
IS
Logf S2
t
hm
Pb-Z
m
S HI state ~ function of their magmatic sulfur
o
u
p
-8
+p
Cu
as
Zn C
lo
RY
pith
,fm N H
ins
en
VE ,t
t nt
l ve
tn asa
gas composition
HS e
Ple o
eta
cv -M
nt W orph
-10
e-m
dg Mou
Au
p
bas
ns
uv
n-C
-Zn zoned
Sn-Z
GHn
-A
-12 HI
cc dg
+b
Pb
p y cp ite
e
r
tit
py
ho
E
AT al
e.g. boiling, fluid mixing
rr
py
DI m
W
-14 Isl
an
d
M E er
LO
i te
Wh end R ith y
+p p
TE ep tn p+c
n te
RY
tr
iro oti
N as
I LS +As
h
W
Good understanding on principal
rr
Au
VE
py
-16
y p asp LO
te g
ni e ar er +p
o
v
tib rit sil qz lite
-18 r"
+s hie
py ert
b
ib
st imo
an
t
te
ni ny t+
m aya
f sulfides and oxides:
fe
uf
kb
"r
o c
4Fe3O4+O2=6Fe2O3
3.0 2.8 2.6 2.4 2.2 2.0 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 (magnetite>hematite)
1000/T ( K )
2FeS+S2=2FeS2 (pyrrhotite>pyrite)
used to define main line ore forming environments
0.67Cu12As4S13+S2=2.67Cu3AsS4
and to identify evolutionary trends
(tennantite>enargite)
Einaudi et al., 2003
T ( oC )
100 200 300 400 500 600 800 1000
Sulfidation State
2
1200
0 3
py po
=-
Rs
=-2 andesitic
Rs
magma
-2
flu x
SO2 gas
t+ p
n
O +b
m +c
Mo
bn
-4 py cp
hm
- Au-
atio
n C u
ATE r condens T p hyry r" Rs
=0
Cu
u
-6
TI
ON cv c kb
DA "ro Rs
=1
al
dg
FI
cp
y
n-A
S
+p
L
erm
GH
IS
Logf S2
hm
U m
Z
S HI
o
Pb-
u
p
-8
+p
Cu
as
Zn C
lo
RY
pith
,fm N H
ins
en
VE , tt nt
l ve
tn asa
Ple
HS e
o
eta
cv -M
nt W orph
-10
e-m
dg Mou
Au
p
bas
vns
Cu
Zn-
-Zn ned
Sn-
g
Pb zo
GHn
-A
-12 HI
cc dg
+b e
p y cp ri t
e
tit
py
ho
E
AT al rr
py
DI m
r
W
-14 Isl
an
d E e
RM pith
LO
y
hi te +p p
W nd E tn p+c
n te
tr e T e
RY
iro oti
s
IN LS +As
a
h
W
rr
u
VE
py
-16
y
p asp A LO
te g
ni e ar er +p
o
v
stib erit sil te + qz lite
+ h i ni ny t
m aya
py ert ib
st imo f
-18 r" b
an
t
fe
buf
ck
Pyrite
Asp
Hematite
Pyrrhotite
Magnetite
Fayalite Iron
Iron
Chemical environment
February 15Hedenquist
th , 2010 et al., 2001 Sillitoe & Hedenquist, 2003
Discussion Outline
Ertsberg
EESS
LEMBAH ERTSBERG
TEMBAGA INTRUSIVE
KUCING
LIAR
BIG DOM
GOSSAN
0 2000
PT FREEPORT INDONESIA
METERS
GEOLOGIC SERVICES GROUP
th
District Clusters
Equidimensional clusters reflect underlying batholith:
Grasberg-Ertzberg +4 deposits, Yerington 4, Globe-Miami 7 , Pima-
Mission 6, TB +4
Heavy
Sulphide
Zone Grasberg Block
Cave Reserve
Kucing Liar
Wafi Diatreme
Morobe Granodiorite
A short-span
++Ar?
++Ar?
Collapsed-caldera, short-lived
Lithology Error Age Comment 1Ma 0.5Ma 0
Volcanic, hydro bio, L11, K-Ar* 0.100 0.917 porphyry alt
Monzo, bio, L63, K-Ar* 0.036 0.342 porph?
Bio-anh vein, hydro bio, L53, K-Ar* 0.027 0.336 porphyry alt
Alunite, L28, K-Ar* 0.015 0.151 epithermal
Bio-kspar alt, bio, K-Ar** 0.34 abstract only
Refrac ore, py breccia, K-Ar*** 0.52 abstract only
Qz-carb veins, K-Ar**** 0.15 abstract only
Reference:
* Luise Davies & Ballantyne, 1987
Harbour
Kapit ** Blackwell et al.,
zone ***Coastal Carman, 1994
zone
**** Molye et al., 1990
Lienetz
zone
rim
ra
lde
Minifie
Ca
LS Epithermal
overprint
Seaward-directed
sector collapse
Biotite
alteration
1 km
1 km
Instantaneous transition
e.g., sector collapse of an altered
volcanic edifice
Lihir, PNG (Sillitoe, 1994)
Block A Geology
GRASBERG
INTRUSIVE
GRASBERG
OPEN PIT
EESS
LEMBAH ERTSBERG
TEMBAGA INTRUSIVE
KUCING
LIAR
BIG DOM
GOSSAN
0 2000
METERS
Stratigraphic Section, Ertsberg District
MIOCENE
Kais Limestone
Woniwogi Fm
MESOZOIC
Kopai Fm
centered) W
S
E
Sulfide mineralogy
BATUHIJAU
0 1000m
< 500 ppm > 1000 ppm
Ore metals and association P R O J E CT
Gangue minerals
Texture of mineralization
Form of mineralization
BATUHIJAU
P R O J E CT
Discussion Outline
Multiple exploration targets with different styles but all are intrusion-
centered systems
Undercover Exploration
Thank you
Low-Sulfidation High-Sulfidation
Quartz ubiquitous (abundant) ubiquitous (abundant)
Chalcedony common (variable) uncommon (minor)
Calcite common (variable) absent (except overprint)
Adularia common (variable) absent
Illite common (abundant) uncommon (minor)
Kaolinite rare (except overprint) common (minor)
Pyrophyllite-Diaspore absent (except overprint) common (variable)
Alunite absent (except overprint) common (minor)
Barite common (very minor) common (minor)
Low-Sulfidation High-Sulfidation
zoned higher T
lower T
4
km
METEORIC Fluids: meteoric
Metal Associations:
Au-Ag (very minor Zn, Pb)
Alteration: hypogene neutral pH;
gas condensates acid
1 Examples:
McLaughlin, USA
Hishikari, Japan
2 Waihi, New Zealand
Gunung Pongkor, Indonesia
3
4
km
Petelovo
Porphyry environments
are characterised by
rapid uplift and erosion
hydraulic
discharge water table
low permeability
hydraulic head
high permeability
conduit zone
major ore
fluid source
th
SEA-PNG Gold and Copper-Gold Deposits
Source: Carlile and Mitchell, 1994, Newmont Compilation, 2005
Average Grade (g/t Au)
th Age (Ma)
MAGMATIC MAGMATIC-METEORIC METEORIC
4
4 4 4
km
km km km ?
H2O, CO2, SO2, H2S, HCl, metals H2O, CO2, SO2, H2S, HCl, metals
Chemical environment
Hedenquist
th et al., 2001 Sillitoe & Hedenquist, 2003
Intrusion-centered systems
Northern
Zone Feldspar porphyry
Augite-hornblende diorite
Diorite
C en t
N r n
Altered sediments
r al Z ste Deeps Black shale
on e Ea
D vein e
n
direction zo Calcareous sediments
A vein
direction Fault Ore zone
Roamana
t
ul
Fa UNDERGROUND
y
OPEN spla
PIT Hangin
g wall
t
us
Th
r
S
F
W
es
te
rn
lt
sh
u
Fa
ea
r
Diorite Breccia
Balatoc Diatreme
Virac Granodiorite
Modified from Cooke et al (1996) Ampucao Dacite Porphyry
Zig-Zag Formation
th
Antamok, Baguio, Philippines
Estimated production ~ 11 Moz
at an average grade of 5g/t Au
Similar mineralogy and fluid
chemistry to Acupan, but
hosted in volcano-sedimentary
rocks
NW veins dominant,
subordinate E-striking veins
320 vein up to 10 m wide and
rich in anhydrite
Wildcat Orebody: 0.471 Mt @
1.34% Cu; conglomerate
400 level plan - Sawkins et al (1979)
cemented by cp & py with
sericite-altered clasts
th
Penasquito, Alkalic system
Cayas Bulawan Nagtalay
th