Break it in the pit and save haulage costs. John Chadwick No ancillary equipment required: the MMD Mobile
Sizer and shovel combination can efficiently mine the
looks at some of the latest thinking and applications making entire length of the face, and then turn around for a
L
et us start with a miner’s view of in-pit required.” He said installing the system would production ‘guarantee’ unless they can
crushing and conveying (IPCC), and in this save Clermont more than 35% of its haul synchronise the performance of the shovel
case one of the world’s most truck running costs, and will remove, crush with the IPCC System.”
technologically advanced mining companies, and convey almost 50% of the mine's P&H feels that as a shovel supplier it is in a
Rio Tinto. Rio Tinto Coal Australia’s first use of overburden per year. unique position to optimise the performance
this technology is Clermont mine's in-pit Scot Szalanski, Product Manager for the of the shovel-IPCC system. “P&H has
crusher/conveyor system that was put to work P&H IPCC notes “the IPCC ‘concept’ has been developed a new process called 4D
late in 2009. The mine said last August “this around for at least 40 years. One of the main Visualisation of an IPCC System Analysis. We
innovative system will make mining at problems with the ‘concept’ was that not only can now take 3D models of our shovel and
Clermont more efficient and sustainable.” did it have a high initial capital cost but just as IPCC system and incorporate them into a
General Manager Construction, Dave Lamb significant, the hydraulic excavator or electric customer’s 3D topography of the mine site. In
said then: “When we were investigating the shovel operated independently with the IPCC addition, as a supplier of the complete shovel-
feasibility of the Clermont mine we knew that System. As a result, it was nearly impossible for IPCC system we have developed new
we had a great coal reserve, however this was any supplier to be positioned with sufficient technology which can add ‘movement’ to the
buried under a large amount of overburden. control over an integrated system in order to individual IPCC components in ‘real time’. As a
This is where the in-pit crusher/conveyor deliver sustained production volume. With shovel manufacturer we have been able to
system works best, as it provides a cost small tonnage IPCC systems, such as 2,000- develop ‘digging algorithms’ to simulate
effective solution for mines with deeper coal 4,000 t/h, the equipment for the system was material removal by our shovel. Just as
seams. We are able to mine in areas that generally oversized enough so that production important we have developed ‘spreading
previously would have been too cost- was not a factor. algorithms’ to simulate how the material will
prohibitive if we had based our mining solely “However, considering today's need to be spread in the waste area of the mine. A 4D
on a traditional truck and shovel method. supply plus 8,000 t/h IPCC systems it can be a visualisation of both the loading and spreading
“Not only does this system make Clermont lot harder to make production requirements are critical in optimising a mine plan.
mine more feasible to mine from a cost when the equipment is operating near its “In effect what we can do is create a
perspective, but we can also reduce our maximum-rated limits. At these high ‘virtual’ mine plan analysis that can cover any
carbon footprint as we will be using less diesel production levels there is no longer any margin time period, from one day to 10 years or more.
fuel due to the reductions in truck hours for error. Suppliers cannot consider any type of This visualisation clearly shows the proper
FLSmidth RAHCO's Dual Truck conjunction with a shiftable face conveyor, the
Mobile Sizer (DTMS) offers an entire system provides complete mobility.”
innovative technical solution Its operation is very similar to some of the
to the civil cost and operating large shovel fed mobile sizing stations currently
drawbacks associated with a on the market, such as FLS’s RAHCO Triple
traditional crushing system Truck Mobile Sizer, but with added flexibility
since they include trucks in the equation. This
opens up access areas on the bench that are
fleet operation – are often needed for maintenance and operation
taken into account.” purposes. Additionally, the use of the smallest
Like other IPCC possible haul truck fleet eliminates the need
manufacturers the focus is for large and expensive belt wagon machines
on reducing these costs, that are commonly used to feed a centralised
with mining companies mobile crushing station where multiple
installing mobile and benches are involved.
semi-mobile crushing When multiple DTMSs are used in
stations to reduce haulage conjunction with an FLSmidth designed movable
distances. Though passover – bridge, trucks can seamlessly access
companies realise face shovels located at upper and lower benches
operational savings to feed each DTMS station improving overall
through these systems, production and adding the needed
they lead to other hurdles, manoeuvrability to service multiple dig locations.
i.e., significant Looking at the system operation from an
realise the enormous economic and geotechnical preparation for the semi-mobile individual bench level, once the face
environmental benefits available with an IPCC stations and expensive retaining walls to allow excavation has reached a mine-determined
system. trucks to drive to an elevation sufficient to point, the shiftable face conveyor is moved
“The basic requirements for successfully dump material into the receiving hopper. “The using a common track shifting head closer to
implementing an IPCC system are: associated costs can truly be staggering. the face and the DTMS is relocated to the
■ Knowledge of mine requirements Retaining wall structures and site preparation conveyor’s new location. The DTMS can be
■ Mine planning analysis capabilities of this magnitude end up costing millions of placed at any point along the shiftable conveyor
■ Analysis of the IPCC interfaces dollars as well as a significant amount of to reduce and optimise truck haulage distances.
■ Flexibility in crusher selection invested time required for their construction. With the addition of an out-of-pit conveyor,
■ Expertise in designing IPCC systems.” These considerations can lead to less than truck haulage distance, as well as the truck
optimum station relocation, and therefore, fleet numbers, can be reduced even more.
Dual truck systems longer haul distances,” he says. In short, the introduction of a single DTMS
Dennis Medina, Manager of Sales and FLSmidth’s RAHCO Technology Centre in or a DTMS system into a mine site offers the
Marketing at FLSmidth RAHCO notes that in Spokane, approached this challenge and operational cost advantages of a conveyor
“large-scale open-pit mining, the majority of a engineered a unique and innovative machine, system with the operational flexibility of truck
mine’s operating cost is frequently tied to the the Dual Truck Mobile Sizer. The DTMS offers haulage.
removal and transportation of the overburden an innovative technical solution to the civil cost CO2 reduction is becoming an important
waste material via truck fleets, an extremely and operating drawbacks associated with a factor and the use of IPCC systems offers
costly operation when operators, road traditional crushing system. The company potential to substantially reduce a mine’s
construction and maintenance, vehicle claims the DTMS “is the only fully mobile overall emissions, as discussed in last year’s
maintenance and facilities, fuel, tyres and crushing station that interfaces directly with article (IM, June 2009, pp8-14).
spare parts – that are the costs of the truck rear dump haul trucks. When used in The blending of a traditional truck and
INVICTA
VIBRATORS
See
us at… Harlaxton Road, Grantham, Lincolnshire NG31 7SF, England
Tel: +44 (0)1476 566301 • Fax: +44 (0)1476 590145
HILLHEAD E-mail: sales@invictavibrators.co.uk
Stand B31 www.invictavibrators.co.uk
shovel plan with an IPCC plan requires special so that critical mine operating data is with single pieces weighing many tonnes.
sensitivities to where the two operations developed which allows the vendor to create a Armesy says that with the crusher dump
interface, or where there are shared corridors 3D IPCC mining plan. There are a number of hopper “located some distance from the
of operation. Other factors that affect both surface mine software packages that can be crawler structure support point(s), the shovel
mine planning and IPCC equipment selection used for this purpose including Surpac™ Vision load weight can result in substantial dynamic
include: by Gemcom, MineSight® products by Mintec, loads for the carrying structure. If proper care
■ Upstream mine operational availability Vulcan by Maptek, and others. is taken during the development of the
requirements (drill and blast, shovel “Software modules within these programs structural model and during the FEA
operations, etc.) that can be used include: calculations, the hopper does not need to be
■ Projected mine life ■ Pit design (volume calculations, production ground supported.
■ Selective mining requirements plans and mine development) “It is important to choose an appropriate
■ IPCC availability targets ■ Block modelling (grade or tonnage reports, sized shovel for system operating efficiency.
■ Power distribution requirements based on bench data) The shovel must be able to dig the proposed
■ Accurate overburden, coal, or ore interface ■ Solid modelling (geological, equipment block dimensions with the required capacity.
measurements at depth models) The shovel bucket capacity should not exceed
■ Geotechnical data (rock types, strata ■ Drill hole database the receiving hopper capacity.
conformities – or nonconformities, etc.) ■ Mine scheduling.” “Selection of a track mounted crushing
■ Overburden dump location requirements When choosing equipment, a shovel will be plant begins with a fundamental look at the
(inside or outside the pit) more effective when working with a crushing style of plant that matches the flexibility of the
■ Operating mine face lengths plant at the face because the shovel can load shovel, and meets the production requirements
■ Conveying distances to the next process into the hopper in a more or less continuous of the mining plan. Several basic questions to
facility or overburden dump area motion without the wait time that occurs be addressed when considering the design for
■ Bench configurations (initially, in five years, while trucks are positioning or travelling to the a fully mobile crushing plant are:
10 years, etc.) shovel location. This gives increased shovel ■ Whether a rigid superstructure or a slewing
■ Number of cuts per bench. capacity and greater availability of the structure should be selected?
complete mining system. Achieving the best ■ If a rigid structure is selected, should it be
Mine planning production efficiency depends on the shovel mounted parallel or perpendicular to the
Armesy notes the crucial mine planning step control system software employed and the crawler tracks?
“to establishing the basis for cost effective interface with the crushing plant operation. ■ Should the discharge boom be designed to
design of the IPCC system [is] understanding The shovel bucket size determines the rotate?
the geological situation, bench layouts, mine impact loads experienced by the crusher “These questions are critical to
access needs, the related mining methods, hopper. Large capacity buckets can deliver a understanding how the crushing plant will
material handling requirements, and the load exceeding 100 t into the crusher hopper, perform in terms of matching shovel
mining infrastructure to support an IPCC
operation.
“The IPCC system supplier should be
working with the mine planning department
the TAKRAF Mobile Crushing System (TMCS) between the crawlers and the crest or toe of crushers do not lend themselves to being
which is now offered as a modular system for the side slopes.” made mobile. This, says MMD, “has resulted in
a capacity range of about 4,000 to 12,000 t/h. No auxiliary hydraulic supports are needed all potential manufacturers/suppliers now
It may be combined with a belt wagon or a so ability to instantly move the loaded TMCS offering variations of the Sizer, a technology
mobile conveyor bridge which is capable of to a new position is really the main originally developed and patented by MMD.
spanning up to three benches of 15 m height improvement from this generation of mobile Realising Sizing is the only comminution
or more, from one face conveyor. If only one plants. It saves valuable operating time and system specifically designed for mobile
bench is to be operated the TMCS can even work improves the availability and utilisation of the operations; it held the key to IPCC and MMD
without any additional mobile link conveyor. entire conveying/spreading system. has proven its ability to handle high volumes of
The TMCS can be assembled in at least A rigid crusher discharge conveyor provides a wide range of material.”
three configurations, depending on the type of the following advantages: MMD over the intervening years has
link conveyor to be fed; a separate mobile ■ The actual crushing machine can be continued to develop and supply mobile units
conveyor, a belt wagon or a connected relatively low, which provides for better around the world and says it “is now in the
conveyor bridge. control of vibration generated by handling unique position of being able to offer proven
Having eliminated the main slewing and large ROM boulders within the crusher mobile units for a wide range of materials
slew gear function of the upper structure, the ■ Uneven material flow from the crushing including iron ore, copper, gold and even granite.”
TMCS concept now allows travel crawlers close process is more equalised (controlled MMD’s position is that while mining
to the head and tail extremities of the rigid downstream material flow and spillage) consultants and manufacturers around the
superstructure. This is most important and The TMCS can be equipped with either a world extol the virtues of IPCC, “much of what
advantageous for the support of the receiving double roll crusher or with a sizer. For has been claimed has yet to be accomplished,
hopper, which is located right above a pair of maintenance purposes there is enough space and proof of the capability to fulfil said claims
equalised crawlers. During loading of the provided ahead of the crushing unit itself, to is imperative if the industry is to avoid a repeat
receiving hopper and apron feeder by the roll it out towards the head of the crusher of the overt optimism followed by re-
shovel, the high impact loads are transferred discharge conveyor. evaluation which characterised its previous
directly into the ground via the two crawlers For both applications of the TMCS a series introduction. It is therefore essential that the
which form a two point support at this plant of machines has been developed. The design industry review the history/credentials of
location. Also full mobility is possible, which is rate and other parameters such as hopper potential suppliers prior to committing the
advantageous when cutting ramps or working volume etc. have been modified in line with future of an operation, to what could be no
away from a mining face. the various available shovel sizes. Below table more than an optimistic vision.
The opposing crawlers underneath the provides an overview of the main parameters. “Here MMD has a distinct advantage as its
conveyor are designed as a slewable two- involvement with IPCC has been
crawler undercarriage, which supports the Shovel capacity t 45 60 82.5 105 virtually synonymous with MMD
equipment. In conjunction with the two Rated capacity t/h 4,500 6,000 8,250 10,500 itself, with the company, shortly
crawlers underneath the receiving hopper this Hopper capacity t 125 165 225 290 after patenting the Sizer, actively
arrangement provides a clearly defined and addressing demand for mobile
strong three-point support, i.e. the crawlers are units, supplying them to a range
able to adjust themselves to the prevailing Wide experience of users.”
ground conditions. Even and equal load MMD provides its view of the development of MMD’s first major break in the mining
distribution is imperative in order to reduce IPCC, noting that continuous mining systems, industry came in the late 1980s when Lignitos
vibrations and fatigue on the plant, particularly epitomised by bucketwheel excavators (BWEs), de Meirama, which was using a semi mobile
on uneven ground. This concept has also been using conveyors to transport material out of gyratory rig and was aware of the advantages
pursued within the crawlers by using a system the mine, “have long been acknowledged as and issues surrounding IPCC, approached
of bogies and equalisers such that all the track the optimum method of handling large MMD for a sizing station to complement its
support rollers are equally loaded. volumes of material. However, their application existing unit. The existing operation’s capacity
Kueng and Hubrich continue: “The provision is limited to soft materials and their high was limited by the crusher and the time taken
of a ball point atop the two-crawler maintenance requirements are a major to reposition the unit. The conveyors, by
undercarriage allows rotation around the drawback. IPCC systems, which had been contrast, having been based on BWEs, were
vertical axis for steering purposes. Each of the successful in quarrying therefore came to be quick and simple to move.
steering crawlers can operate in opposite seen as the dream solution for the mining MMD designed and supplied a semi mobile
directions or at different speeds. There is no industry in the 1980s, but became a nightmare unit using a MMD 1250 series Sizer and MMD
need for a hydraulic steering cylinder because instead as it became obvious that for these D7 series plate feeder and this, the company
the crawlers are sufficiently spaced apart from systems to be viable more than simply making says, “was an immediate success. Not only due
one another. Slew angles up to 90° can be a standard crusher mobile was required, and to the Sizer’s ability to handle high throughput
achieved, which allows a minimum curve truck and shovels operations became the norm and its ground breaking in-ground hopper,
radius in the range of the distance between in spite of their environmental impact.” which allowed it to be moved as a single unit,
the two crawler pairs. Since all the crawlers Now it has become obvious that the root but also its ease of installation.” This allowed
have been arranged in longitudinal direction, cause of the problems encountered previously the mine to install the unit in the pit bottom
narrower than traditional ramps can be was not the IPCC concept but rather the with all truck haulage being either horizontal
negotiated between the individual benches. It shortcomings of the core technology i.e., or downgrade thereby allowing operations to
also provides maximum safety distances reducing the material to a conveyable size as expand to up to 4,000 t/h, resulting in the