Investigation of droplet breakup in liquid-liquid dispersions by CFD - PBM
simulations: The influence of the surfactant type

Dongyue Li, Antonio Buffo, Wioletta Podgorska, Daniele L. Marchisio,

Zhengming Gao

PII: S1004-9541(16)30897-7
DOI: doi:10.1016/j.cjche.2017.01.014
Reference: CJCHE 821

To appear in:

Received date: 19 September 2016

Revised date: 30 November 2016
Accepted date: 20 January 2017

Please cite this article as: Dongyue Li, Antonio Buo, Wioletta Podgorska, Daniele
L. Marchisio, Zhengming Gao, Investigation of droplet breakup in liquid-liquid dis-
persions by CFD - PBM simulations: The inuence of the surfactant type, (2017),
doi:10.1016/j.cjche.2017.01.014

This is a PDF le of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication.
As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript.
The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof
before it is published in its nal form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could aect the content, and all legal disclaimers that
apply to the journal pertain.
 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
$%% ,% , 22

P
$,$$ 8 $%$ %

RI
% $,%% %

SC
+ ++ 1345 45

!! )!) 2) )

NU
) )2!
! )2! )!! ! 2

! B)22 ) )2 )2!
MA
)2 B
2!!! ) )!!
B! ) ) !
ED
PT
CE
AC

""$ ," , ,

B))! 2!! ! 2 ) ) !)
 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
$%% ,% , 22

P
$,$$ 8 $%$ %

RI
% $,%% %

SC
NU
"#$#
&' &' ' &' / /'&' 6
6 '&' /&// / ' &' /
MA
'& '/ ' &6&/ /' &/ ' '
/&'' / 66 /&// ' &'
& & / ' ' &' ' '&
'/ && / ' '& '/ &' '
ED

&/' ' ' /'' ' ' ' '' ' /&'' / /
& & ' &' /& &' ' /&' /'&///
'/ & ' && & &/ & ' '&'& / /
PT

/// ' /'' '& ' ' &' ' ' ' '
' '& '& &' /&''/ &
'/ & && ' ' 6&'& ' '/ & '
CE

/' ' ' ' ' '

' ' $&&,&$ /& '
/& '' /
AC

' ' ' '& '& &' '/ &/ /

' /' &' ' & / '/' // &&& ' /'&& '
' &' '/ /&''/ M ' &'
'&'/ &' & &' /'&&& &' & &/'/ / ''
& ' /&/ ' ' /'&// / &' '
'&' & & && &'/ ' ' &/
' '& &/ &' ' /' & &'/ & /&
M &/ & & & / '
%' & '&& 66 /&// '&
/ M

!!& '&& & ' ! ! &!

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
$%$

P
# (( ##-# / -# -/- -

RI
-/ /- #-/# # - - /#
-- / - --

SC
# - /- # #-/- /
- - - E
-# - # - E # # - ###
- - - / - - /-/

NU
- -# - /- /-/ -
-# - - /- /-/ - -#
/#/# # - -#
MA
- - /-/ - -
# -# -# - #-- /-
#-/ /###
/ / - - E - # -
ED

- / ## / #/ - /-
- - /# / # / /#
- /#- / / # / ((
PT

#/## #-// -# ## -- - / /(
/-# /## # - /- - /# / -
- /- - -- / / /-# -
CE

#- - / /## -/ #/ -# / -
- -/ - /-- -/ /- #/ -
/ / - - # # - /# - #-/
-/ - -/ - #-/ -/ #
AC

/# -/- / - / /( # -
- # -/ # # - / /
/-/ / -# # - ##- - -/-
-# /- - - -/--- /-/
-/ #/- /- /### # # / # /
/ -# - # -/ - -/-
/ /# E`/# /-ab -
#-- - / / # -/ - #-- --
- /- - / /- -/ / /- # /
/- - - / - - /- - /#
/ # / - -/ - #
/ #-/- ## -- / / - #

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
# # ) )# ) )# .# #. # )
) #..# ) # #..#

P
. ) . ) #)# )# #) #

RI
) . . )) ) )# . .)#) .
# #) ) .) #)#. # )# . )#

SC
)# ) #.) # ) . )## )) .
. # . ) # #) ) ) )
)# )# )# ) # #)## ) )
#) ##. .) . ) )# ) #)

NU
#. .# #. #.##. . . ) #
.)# .)#) #) # .) # #
)#) ) )) #
MA
) # # )## N)## #. .
) )#. .)# )# .) ##.
# # )#. ) # #
.)# ) # ## ) ) ) .. ) )
ED

#) .# )# . . )
. ) # #. # ) # .)# .)#
)# ) #) #) ..) .#.
PT

# ## # )# . . #. ) ).) .
# #. # #. # .) # ) # ..
.)# )# # .))
CE

. .#) # .. )) )# ) # #
#. #) # #. # .)
) .). #) # .)## ). # ) ) # N
N ..). # ) .#)) . .. ) ).
AC

. ) #. ) )# ). # .)) .
. ) ) # )#. ) # )
.#)) ). . #) # .#))
#) # )##) )# ) #. )#
). )## ) #. .#.)# .)#.. . )
) ) )) ) .) # . .) #
#) .# )) #). ..). #)# ) .
)# ). # ) )# ) ) .#)) #
. Z#) .# #). ) . . . ))#) )
.#)) # # ) .# ) . .)) )) ) #
) # t = 0 .)) )# ). ) )#
) .)#.. ) # ) #). . . ) . #

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
&)*+ 2 2 22 * 2 +2 2+
+ 2 * * + * 2 *2

P
2* *2 2 2* +*2

RI
2+ +2 *2 * *+ * 2 2*2*
*+ * * &)*+
2*2 * * 2+ 2 &)*+

SC
+ 2 * * *2SU 2
* * * 2 * * * 2 2*
+ +2+ 2 +22 2* 2 2 *2 2 2

NU
2 2 2* 2* *2 +*22+ *
2 2 YY +*+ 2 2 +*22 2 *
+ 2 +22 * *+ * + * Y
MA
Y +*++ 2 2 2*+22 *+ +
2 2 + + & + 2+ *
+ 2 * 22 2 $&&,&$
+* *2+ * 2
ED

+2 *2 2 * + *2 2+2 ++ 2 *+
+2** 2 2 *2 +*22+ 2 *2 2*2
* 2 *2 +2*** ++ 2 *+2 2+2 * 2 +*22 +
+ +*22 +* * *
PT

*2 *+ 2 2 +*2 +2*++ 2+ + 2
2* 2+ + +* 2 + 2+2 *
2 +*22 + 2 * *++ Y 2
CE

& * 2 * + +2*
*2 2 2 +* 2** 2 2 +2*++ + 2 *2
AC

& *-. -

2 2 ++ * +* 2*+ 2* *2+
* 2+ 2*2 + 2 2*2*2 ++
* 22 Y2 * 2 *2 2 +*+
+
(d d )
t
+ (d d Ud ) = 0,
* d + 2 *2 2 +*+ + d + 2+ +2
Ud + 2+ * 2 *2 2 2+ +
c + * 2 22 *2+ + 2 2

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
d + c = 1 ( . . 2(2 2 Ud 2 .

P
2 . ((2 . 8.

RI
(d d Ud )
+ (d d (Ud Ud )) +
t

SC
(d d ) + (d Rd ) = d p + d d g + Md ,

( p 2 . (22( 2( . . 22 d 2 .
222.(22 .2(2 Rd 2 . 22.(22 .2(2 g 2 . (..

NU
(. .( Md 2 . .( ( .( 2(2 .
. . . . 22 ( . ( ( 2
. . . . ( . ((. (
MA
2 .2 ( 2( 8. 2 2 2 ( .
.2 2 . ((. ( ( . 2 (. 2
2.(22 .2(2 ( . 2(2 2 2( ( . .2 2
2 . 2228 (.
ED

(. .(. 2 . . . .(.
.( . . 8.2 .( k 2 . 2.
( .(. 2 .2 2. ( .2 .(
PT

. ( (2 .. 2.
( . 2.( k 2 .. . .( 22.
(. 2 . (2.. 2 (2.. 22
CE

2(2 ( . ( (2 ( . .(.
22. (. ( .2 (2.. ( 2
((. ( . .(. 22. (. . 2
( (2 (2( 2.( k . .(. .
AC

( k . .(. ( 22. (. ( . 2
. . 2(. 8.2 2 2
 
(c k) t
+ (c kUc ) = c k + c Gk c
t k
 
(c ) t
+ (c Uc ) = c + c (Ck1 Gk Ck2 )
t k
( t = C k 2 / 2 . .(. 22. C k C1 C2 (
2..2 ( Gk ((2.2 . (. . .(. .
(

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
"(
# ( ) -)) 22 --) - -)))

P
) 2) # ) ( ) () )

RI
()- ) ( ) ) () ) -(-
- ( ) )-) -- ) ) (- -())
- - ) )- ( ( - -( -

SC
)( -( (- # )) (- ) )
) (- - - )) - ) -

NU
Z
n(d)
t
+ (n(d)Ud ) = (d, d )g (d ) n (d ) dd g (d) n (d) ,
d
MA
( n(d) - ) d - ) () - g - ) ( ( (
(2 ( (d, d) - ) )( - -)() )
-)) ) - -)() )( ()- () ( )(
() - d ( )- ) 2 )
ED

(-
- ) - ) # (
- ) () ) n(d) -) ( )
)- )( ) - 2()( ()
PT

N

X
n(d) w (d d ),
CE

=1

( w d ( ) N )- - ( ---- ) 2(
)( () (( N N - )- ( )
AC

( ) (-) 2N )- )
Z N

X
k
mk = n(d)d dd w dk ,
0 =1

) k 0, . . . , 2N 1 - ) - ) (- ()-
- - ( ) #()( ( ( ()- - -
)() ) (- )
)(-() 2) ( ) ) (( k -
+
N
mk
Z

X
+ (Ud mk ) = w g(d ) (d, d ) dk dd dk ,
t =1 0

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
# $ $# # $ #$ . . $ . $
$ $ # . $

P
. $ . # ; $ $ $ #;#.

RI
$ . $ #$. $$ # # # $ # #..
$ $ . $# .$#$ $ (d, d) .
# $# .$#$ $ .. .

SC
.$$.$ E . # . . $ .#
# $# .$#$. . $ $ $ #.$
#$ .. (d, d) . . .

NU
.$$.$ . $ . .. $$ $ . $# #$
. # # $. #$ .$#$ .$.. . ;
$. $ ... $ #$ $# .$#$ $.
MA
#. .#. $ . .
.$$.$ .$#$ #. $#
.$#$ $ . .
2  2
ED

d2 d3 d3
 
(d, d ) = 180

d3 d3
1 3 .
d

$ ... $$ $ #$. #$ .. # # $ # #
PT

.. $$ .$# # . $ .$ $ . ..$$
$ #. $ $ #$ #.$#$
. . $ $# .$#... . .# $ #
CE

.. #.. $. # $ $# .$#$ $
##$ ; . $ . $ . # $.
$ # .# #.$. $ $# #.
AC

; . ..$$$ $ ; $ .$ .$. #
$ $# $ .;# #$. # k 0
Z+
3240d k
(d, d ) dk dd =
(k + 9) (k + 12) (k + 15)
.
0

# #+
# #$. $#$ .#.. . $
$. . #. $# $#$. # $
# . #.. . $ $# .$#...
# $ $. . $$$ $ .$# $ #$. $

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
"$ ") ) " )) )"$)) " ) " $)"$)

P
") $ ) ) " )" $" "$ $

$ " $ $" ) "$ " $ ")

RI
" )$$ < ") $"$)") $" $ $)

$) " )$ $" $ ") $

SC
" $ $) $) ) "

) $"KN " $ " $

RS$) $ )"" ) "$

NU
") $ $) $ ))) " )

& &
$ $ )
MA
$) $ << )$)) "$" ))

"" $" )") $) " $))$ "") $

$ " ) )) "" " )" $" $ " "$)""

" $ ) $ " " )$ $ $ $

ED

$) ) )

1/3
 

g(d) = C1 2/3 exp C2 2/3 5/3 ,
PT

d c d

$ ) " "$" $ ))" $" d ) " $" "$

c ) " )" " ") ) ) " "$ ")
CE

C1 C2 $ ))) )"") "" $ " " ""

" $" " " " )$) ) )

$" $$ " "$" "$ )

AC

" $ $ ) $$" " $))

1/3 (1 + d )2
 
g(d) = C1 2/3 exp C2 .
d (1 + d ) c 2/3 d5/3

" "$"$ C1 C2 $ ))" " 0.00481 0.08 ")

) $ ) $ $ $) $ $ " )

1 & &
) $ $ ) ) " $ $

$) " $ )")" $ " $" "

$ $< ) $) " )" ))" " )$)

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
# % #% ) )# ) )# # )% % %
## % ## ) % 7## %## # %)

P
)% ) ) # %#

RI
r 
C2
g(d) = C1 erfc ,

SC
c 1/3 d5/6

% C1 = 0.883 # ) % ) %%) ##) )) )

%# #% % # ) %) %) # % )

NU
) @# )% %)# # ) %# )) C1
# #% ) %% ) %
) % # %@ ) ) ) )) %
MA
)% ) #% %# ) # ## # % %
% )# ) %
s !
C2 C3
g(d) = C1 1/3 erfc + ,
ED

2/3
c d 5/3 c d 1/3 d4/3

% C2 C3 % ### #))# C1 # #
) ) ) %# # ) )# ) )%
PT

)# ) ##) ) #%# #
) # % % %) # C1 C2 C3
# ) # % ) 7 #
CE

# ) # C1 = 0.986 C2 = 0.000892 C3 = 0.2

) ) C1 = 3.68 C2 = 0.000775 C3 = 0.2
) % )% )%)% #%# )) %) #
AC

# % )# #))# ) ##)
)# % ) % C1 = 3.68 C3 = 0.2 % # ) %
) C2 # #) )) ) ) %) ) )
# ) @ )

% %
%)RS ) % % # % % %)#
% % # )%# ) )
)%) )% % % )% % ##) %)
% %# %## % % %) % )# # )
% % ) ### )) ) % %@ # %%) )

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
& & - &--- & &

P
- - -& - - &&
& - -

RI
q
C2 (d)2/3 12 c d

SC
g(d) = C1
d
& C1 = 0.25 C2 = 8.2 C1 - & &- C2
- & & & - & & && -

NU
& G && - & &
& dc = 1.26(/c )3/5 2/5 - & & & - -&
& & - -- &
MA
& & &
& & & & & -
- & & - -& - -
ED

&- -- & - &

& & -& &
& - -- -&
PT

&- & -& - & &

& & - && - -

7/5 9/5 !
CE

1 d5/3 19/15 c 2
g(d) = 7/5
exp 9/5
.
2 d d 6/5
3
AC

- - & & &- &

& &- - & & &G &-- &-
& & &- & & -- & &-
- - - &- & -

& &
& & UV&-
&--& - & -& &-- & & &
- -- - - & &
-&- & & &
- - - &- - & & &
& &- & & & - - & &

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
- - - -

P
4 - - - - 4 -- 4 4

RI
s   Zx   +23f ()
L 1/3 d 3
g(d) = Cg ln d,
d d2/3 L

SC
min

- Cg = 0.0035 L 4 - - 4 4
(2k/3)3/2
4 4 L = min = 0.12 -4 -

NU

- - -4 4 x 4
-44  
L0.4 0.6
2.5 ln c
MA
Cx 0.6
x = 1.5,
ln (L/d)
- Cx = 0.23 4 4-4 4 44 4
- x 4 - - 4 -
ED

- - KL-4
- -4 -4 4-
4 4 - 4 - 4 -
PT

-4 - - 4 4 4
4 - 4 -4 4- - -
- 4 - 4- - - - 4
CE

- 4 - - 4- 44 4-
4 4 - 4 -
- TT 4-44
- -4 - - T- -
AC

4 -4 - 4 4 -4
4- - t 0 t0 4 - 4 4
4- - 4 T - - 44 4
4- 0 - 4 -44 - - -
4 = 0 4 - 4-4 4 -44 --
4 - 4 -44 KL-4 -4
4 - - x - - 4 4
4-4 - -4 4 4 4- 4
- x 4
 
L0.4 0.6
2.5 ln C (2 )0.6
c
x 0
x = 1.5,
ln (L/d)

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
# 0 % & &# &% # & %%& && %#&&
&% %& 5 % % # & &#& & x &

P
# # # &%& # % & %#&&

RI
#% 5 % % # &%& # & %#&& %
H % % %& & %%& && & &
%#& %&#%% # # % & & &% &&#

SC
% & & & && H % # %&# %# #
& % # # & #& %#% &#& %&#
f () # 5 % #% # % #&

NU
& #%%
f () = a + b + c2 + d3 + e4 + f 5 + g6 + h7 + i8 ,
MA
& a = 3.51, b = 18.721, c = 55.918, d = 120.9, e = 162.54, f =
131.51, g = 62.572, h = 16.1, i = 1.7264 # 0.12
&% # & && & #& %&#
#%
ED

$% $$ , %$
PT

## & %&& & & & #& # #% &

#& & & & & &# &# 55 %
#%% %&## &% #& %#&&% #
CE

& 1 & &

# #%% 5 & H & # & #
% & %#&&% # & & &&# %%
AC

& & % %#% % &# % &% % #

#& & & # HY#%
%# $&&,&$ %
& & #& & 55 % # #% #%
& % &% &## &# % &# &% 5#&#
# # % & & % H & %&
%5 %%&% &% %# % & & & & %
& 55 %#%% & #& %%& & %#% % &
#& & & & & &# &# & & #
# & # # % &
&% & %& % # # 55 %#%%
%&## &% &% # & & %

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

P T
RI
SC
NU
MA
ED
PT

$ +$, + ,+$$ +, ,++ +, $ +, $

CE

& & &, & / / ,// /& &&

&/ ,&//, &
AC

&/, & && / / / / /& ,/

,&// & &// , /&/ /
,&// /& /, / / /& /& &
, & &&/ ?& & /,/ , ,
// ,, ,&/ / /& ,
& & /, & &/ / ,, /
&/ / / &/ // & /,
/ ,/& / ,/&& / , H / &
, , , & &&,/ , &/,, /, ,
&, , / /, , ,,/, & 5.5 104 ? ,
8.9 104 ? , &,/ ,/ / ,&, , /
/, , , 3 3 / ,&,

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
# +- # ++# - + -
-- #-# - #- - - - #-+++ #

P
# - - + + + + #

RI
- - -+ F # ++ - - ##+ +
- # # + - +# -

SC
-- #-# +

#- ## +-- N C 0 d32

NU


T
MA
T
T
ED

),, )),1 ), ,1 1,, ,1 ) N 1 ,

) ),, 1 ) C 1 , ,), ) ) >
, ), 0 ) , 1,, ) t 0 ,)
,1 , , , 11 1 d32 1 , , ,) ,)
PT

-+##+ # # - T +-
- + ## - +-# + ++ -
CE

+ - #+# # # F- - -
T - #+ + +# + #
- ++ - # - #- -# -+#+-
AC

F-# + - - ##- F-# - # - -

- - #+ -+# # - + -# #- -
-- - # - # T # - -
# + # +# - #-# + ++
- - - T - +# -+# +
+ - -# - - + - -
- #+ -+ - F - -+ F+-+ # + +
+ # + + # + + - +
# + + - - - + +
- # +- - -- -# # + - #- # -
# - - + #

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
$'$

P
(( - -2
* , ,0 * ,* *, 5

RI
5 * * *,* * , 55* ,*
*, *5 , * , , , 5 *5

SC
, * , , ,*5 , ,* , ,*
,* 5 5 ,* 5 ,5 , *
* *, *5 5 * *,* 55* ,* 5

NU
* 5 * , ,* *, *55
, 5, * *,* * , 55* ,* 5
MA
101 100

100
10-1
g(d) (1/s)

g(d) (1/s)

-1
10
-2
10
-2
10
ED

-3
-3 10
10
-4 -4
10 10
0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002
d (m) d (m)
PT

$ (+ $ $3 $ $+ +$+ $ 99+ $+
+ +$ +9 + = 0.01 1 = 0.01 2 93 $ = 0.1 2 93
CE

$ = 1 2 93 = 10 2 93 $+ +$ +9 +
+$+ $ 99+ $+ ++ = 1 2 93 = 0.01 1 $
= 0.03 1 $ = 0.05 1 + + $+ 9 $ + $
$3
AC

, ,0 ,55 * ,* *, , * ,
, 5 5 *5 * * *, , 5 , *
5 * , ,0 * , = 0.01 2 53 5*,*5 *,
d 0.008 5*5 5 , * , 5 5 5 ,
* , * *5 ,5 * *,* * ,
55* ,* 5 d < dc * , ,0
* , , 5 55 * , * ,55 , ,
,*5 ,, * * ,* d > dc *, ,
* , ,0 ,55 * * * ,* 5 5
5 5 , * ,* 5 5 5, * dc

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
% ' )'% ) % ))' ) ' 3
3 %)% '%' %% '% %' % % )') ) )

P
')% %'% ))' ' ' %' )'

RI
') '% % ) %) ' ) )3 )%
' '% ' ) %' %%

SC
140 35
120 30
100 25

NU
g(d) (1/s)

g(d) (1/s)
80 20
60 15
40 10
20 5
MA
0 0
0 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008 0.01 0 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008 0.01
d (m) d (m)

$ (+ $ $3 $ $+ +$+ $ 99+ $+
ED

+ +$ +9 + = 0.01 1 = 0.01 2 93 $ = 0.1 2 93

$ = 1 2 93 = 10 2 93 $+ +$ +9 +
+$+ $ 99+ $+ ++ = 1 2 93 = 0.01 1 $
= 0.03 1 $ = 0.05 1
PT

' ' ) )3 )%% ' )' ') ) '

% ) ) % % ) ' '
CE

) )% ' % ) ) % ' )'

) )3 ) )3 )%% 3 ' %
' )' % ' ) ' ' ' )% )
AC

%' )' ') '% % ) %) ' )

)3 )% ' ' % )% ' ' )% )'
%
' ' ) )3 )%% )' ') ) ' )
) ) % % % ' % ' ) )'%
) ) )3% ' )) 106 ' ' ') )
)% ) = 10 2 %3 ) ' ' )'% ) )
)3% ) ')' ' ) %%' )'% ) )'
')% ' ) ' ')' '
) %%' )' % ' ) )3 % ) % '
)) 1020 %1 % % ) ' ' )' '
') ) )% ) % )'% '' ' ) )3

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
8 3.5
7

P
3
6 2.5
g(d) (1/s)

g(d) (1/s)
5

RI
2
4
1.5
3
2 1

SC
1 0.5
0 0
0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005
d (m) d (m)

NU
$ (+ 0 $ $3 $ $+ +$+ $ 00+
$+ + +$ +0 + = 0.01 1 = 0.01 2 03 $ = 0.1 2
03 $ = 1 2 03 = 10 2 03 $+ +$ +0
MA
+ +$+ $ 00+ $+ ++ = 1 2 03 = 0.01 1 $
= 0.03 1 $ = 0.05 1

#&& , , #& #, & #,& ,

ED

#, ,# ,& & # &#

14000 800
12000 700
PT

10000 600
g(d) (1/s)

g(d) (1/s)

500
8000
400
6000
300
CE

4000 200
2000 100
0 0
0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005 0 0.001 0.002 0.003 0.004 0.005
d (m) d (m)
AC

$ (+ $ $ $3 $ $+ +$+ $ 00+ $+
+ +$ +0 + = 0.01 1 = 0.01 2 03 $ = 0.1 2 03
$ = 1 2 03 = 10 2 03 $+ +$ +0 +
+$+ $ 00+ $+ ++ = 1 2 03 = 0.01 1 $
= 0.03 1 $ = 0.05 1

, # #; & ,, #&& , #, & # ,

# # ,#&, , #& # #& ,

# # & , ,# , & ,# L

& , &&, & #&,& # , , , ,#

,#,, , , , ,# , & ,# & ;

, &# &#, #& ,, , #

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
!& ' & ! ! ' '! & && & !
! ! & !' & ! !& ! ' !&' !

P
& & ! ' & ' '& ' & !& & !

RI
& ! & ?? ''& & '!&& '
& &! '&!'' !'& ! & &! &' ! '

SC
& & ! ! ' !'&' &' & ! !? !
& '!' & !& &' ! ' ! &
&& !& ! ! & '!&
'&!'' & ! !& ' !'& !&' &

NU
! !' ! !
MA
ED
PT
CE
AC

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
101

P
100

RI
g(d) (1/s)

10-1

SC
10-2

10-3

10-4
0 0.0005
NU
0.001
d (m)
0.0015 0.002
MA
100

10-1
ED
g(d) (1/s)

10-2
PT

10-3

10-4
CE

0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002

d (m)

100
AC

10-1
g(d) (1/s)

10-2

10-3
0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002
d (m)

$ (+ $ $2 $ $+ +$+ $ 88+ $+
+ +$ +8 + = 0.01 1 = 0.01 2 83 $ = 0.1 2
83 $ = 1 2 83 = 10 8 $+ +$ +8
2 3

+ +$+ $ 88+ $+ = 1 2 83 = 0.01 1

$ = 0.03 1 $ = 0.05 1 +$ +8
+$+ $ 88+ $+ ++ = 0.0268 1 = 1 2 83 +
$ $ ++ $ + 8$+ 8+$88 $8+ $ + +$ +8
$ 0 $ 0 = 0.037 1 + + $+ 8 $ + $
$2
 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
) 2 26
&( &+ & &(& & ( ++& (& &

P
&(& & ( & &( &( ( & &+& +

RI
& ( ( ( ((& +& & &(&
& ( + ++& ( & ( ( & ( (?
+ & & ( + & ++& + & & +(+

SC
+ + +&(& (&( + & &( &( +
( & ++ + ++&& & ( (+ (
& + + &(+& & ( & ( (? (& &

NU
(& (+ ( &(+ +&+ & ( ((&
& + && & ( (? + (&( &
& & + ( & + ( (+ (
MA
(+ ( + ((& & &(&( &+ ( & (&
(+ +&( +( ( & + (& +( && & (
(? (& & ( + (( & & +
( (+ ( (? ( & ( ( (
ED

+ ( +( (+&& + + ++&& & & (+&+ ((&

( & +& &(& & ( ++
& (& & & ( & ( (? (&
( &+& + & ( ( (+ + (& ? &
PT

(
CE

2; ) 2);
(+ & & & & &( &( (
& &+ ( (+ & (& & ( + + (
(& + + & ( ( (+ &
AC

(+& (+ (&+ + & ( &+

( ( ( + ( & (& + +&(
&+ + & +( + & &
+ & + ( & ( ( &+& ++
& ( & &( &( & (&+ + (
+ ( +( & & + & ( ( +
&( + && (&( & & + && & (
( ( + & & +& ( ?? +(++
& &( &( + ( + ( &
( ( + ( & (& & ( (?
( ( + & & ( & + 1 &
&(& &( & &( &+& ++ & &(& &

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

P T
RI
SC
NU
MA
ED
PT
CE
AC

$ +$ +. + +$+ + $ ..+ $+ 2 .3
+$+ + $ k 2 .2 +$ +$ d $ . +
$ $
 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

P T
RI
SC
NU
MA
ED
PT
CE
AC

$ +$ +. $ $3 g(d) . $ + + + d = 60.10
+ + d = 85.76 $+ + + d = 258.4
. + + ++ d = 69.97 $ $+ + ++ d = 258.4
$ $ $ . $ .. $

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
" ''* "* "' " * 2 '3 ' "

P
* * ' "*" " *'* '' hi 0.15 2 '3
* * ' ** "*" ' * " "* *'

RI
* *' ' ' * " "? ' " d < dc
* *'* '' * "'*' * * " "

SC
"' " * ""*

400

NU
350
Mean Sauter diameter (m)

300
MA
250

200

150
ED

100

50
PT

0
0 700 1400 2100 2800 3500
Time (s)
CE

$ $- $ 0 0 0 0 0$ 0$ $0
$ $ - $ 0 $- 0
$0 0 -- $ -
AC

"' * * * * *" *" *

"* * " '' ' ""* ' '
* * * * *" *" "* "
" " *' *'* '' " * * "* * "
* ' * * *" *" * '*'**
"* * ' " "' ' '* " * *
" "
* ' ''' * * * * *" *" "
* ' " "' * * * * *"
*" * "* * " '' ' ""*
*' " * '"** ' ' ''' *'

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

P T
RI
SC
400
Mean Sauter diameter (m)

350
300

NU
250
200
150
MA
100
50
0
0 700 1400 2100 2800 3500
ED

Time (s)
300
Mean Sauter diameter (m)

250
PT

200

150
CE

100

50
AC

0
0 700 1400 2100 2800 3500
Time (s)

$ $. $ 1 1 1 1 1$ 1$ $1
$ $ . $. 1 $1 1 .. $ .
1 . 11

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
"&& " " & " " " & "&

P
" & & &" & & &" & "
" & " " "7 & & & &

RI
& " & " ""
"& & & & & "& "

SC
" "&& & " " & "
" "& & "& " & "& &&
" & "& &

NU
MA
ED
PT
CE
AC

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
250

Mean Sauter diameter (m)

P
200

RI
150

SC
100

50

NU
0
0 700 1400 2100 2800 3500
Time (s)
MA
250
Mean Sauter diameter (m)

200

150
ED

100

50
PT

0
0 700 1400 2100 2800 3500
CE

Time (s)
250
Mean Sauter diameter (m)

200
AC

150

100

50

0
0 700 1400 2100 2800 3500
Time (s)

$ $- $ 0 0 0 0 0$ 0$ $0
$ $ - $- 0 $0 0 -- $ -
0 00

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

&&

P T
"% ( " , % " % " "

RI
" %" "(" << %(%% " (" %(""%
%"(( "% (" ( % " % (

SC
" (% ( "%" ( %"% " "
%( (" "%" %% ( %"
%"(( " < " %" ( ( ( ("
%"(( (" " (" %"% (%" (" "(

NU
"% % " " " " " "(
"( (" "% ( (% % ( " (" "
( ( %"% " " %%( "
MA
( (%"% % "" " <" ("( ( " ( (
" ( ( << %(%% ( (
( % " " %" ("( % " ("
( ("% % " %" ( "
ED

" " ( " ( (% ( (

( % % " % " %" ( ( <<
%(%% ( " << %(%% " , % %(""
PT

" ( ( (" (" " " "

"( "( % (% %" (%"" "
"( "( "" " (" ( (< % "
CE

( " << %(%% " % %(""

" %"(%%% ( (" " ( ( ("%
(" (%"% " % ( ( "" " "% "
%"(%%% " " % " "( ("( " " (
AC

"" " %"% ( (( " " ( (

"(% "(%" " (%"% (" " %
( (% ( % %"% % " " " "" "
( (" " %" ( " %"" "( %"%
" %(" %"(%%% "" ( " " " " "( ("%
" ("%

+ +.&+& +++
"(% ( "" " "% "(%" " "% (

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

P T
C1 #$$ ' ' '

RI
C2 #$$ ' ' '
C3 #$$ ' ' '

SC
CD ' $
Cg #$$ ' ' '
Ck1 k '$'#

NU
Ck2 k '$'#
Cx #$$ ' ' '
C k '$'#
d '$ #
MA
d32 $' $'
dc '$ '$ #
d $' '$ #
d #### $ 9'$' '$ 3
ED

g '$$ '$ $' 2

Gk '$ $ $'$ $ '
k $'$ $ ' 2 #2
PT

L $' $'$ $ #
Md $' '
mk k $ $ ' #$ $ k3
CE

N ' '$$ # '

p ' '##' @
Rd ##$'## $#' 2
AC

t $ #
Uc $ $# # #
Ud $ #'# # #
Ur # $ #

$'$ $
c '$ $# #
d '$ #'# #
min $'$ $
x ' $'$ $ ' '# #
$'$ ' ##$ '$ 2 #3
c ##$ $# # @#
d ##$ #'# # @#

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
t " )) .)

P
c ) ) ) 3
d ) )") ) 3

RI
) " )
0 " )

SC
k " " " k
" " "
d )) ) ")) )" 2
) ;" " " 3

NU
w MA
ED
PT
CE
AC

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

#&

P T
4 > A

RI
> >D A > A> A> A>AD 4A

>

SC
44 >A>

A > DD D A> A>AD

NU
4 D>

DD AD D\D A>A

4>A
MA
D D AD>A 4 A D

> >A D D DA> 4A

ED

A AD > D> > \

>D DA>> > >\ A

PT

>DD > > > \

> D D>>A > A A

CE

AD >A> \A>A
AC

D >D >D A >A> DAD D\ DD>D

>A> A >D

A A > A> A> A

D D >D A> > A

>D 4A

DD A D>DD A> >D

DA A> A AD A>D 4A

A DA> AD D > \A>A >

>D AD

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
'+ 4 4 :4+ +

P
4 '4 :'4' 4 4+ ' '+

RI
4 '4 :'4'

SC
4 4 ' 4 :4+ '

4 4 ' + 4

NU
4 :4 ' '4+ ' 4 '+

'4 4 :'4' 4
MA
4+ ' 4 :4+ ' '+

4
ED

'4 '4 ' 4+ '44 '

+4 +4'' 4 +4' ' +4' +'

PT

] 4 ''+44 + 4'+

4 :'4' 4 ' 4+ 4

'+ '
CE

] +4 ' 4

+ '44 ''4 4 '4 '4

AC

+4'' 4 4 4++ 4 ' +

] ' ] 4 ' +4 '

4 4 + 4 '4 :'4' 4 4+

' +

4 4 + 4 + '4 4 4

:'4' 4 4+ ' +4 '+ + '

'+

'+ c 4 '++ + 4

'4 '4 '4 :'4' 4 4+

'

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
2 >?> ?A

P
> A >A> ?A ?A ?A A A

A A A> 2?

RI
AA? A> ? ?A

SC
A >A ?

> >> A?>? V A?A > A

NU
> ? >

? > A A VA ?>

MA
2 2 ? A

? ? A >V

? >? >
ED

2 >A> >

V> ?A?> ? 2?

PT

?> >?A A?A ?>>>

AA VV >?>> ?

CE

A A ? ?>> V

V AA A> ? ?

AC

> ?A ? ? ?

A?A >?>> ?

A?A ? ? A

? >?A> A?A ?

? A??AA A?A > ?A>

A?A> ?

2g?> ? ? A?AAA A?

>A A?>A >> ?> ?

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
()*0 )456 6(6 ) ( (

P
) ) )() H() (

(J ( 6

RI
6(6 6) ()*0 )456 (

SC
6))6) 6 ( ) ( 6

(6 ) )() )() (

)6

NU
( 6 )(6() J) ( ) )( ( 6)

)6 ( (66 (

)( (
MA
( 6 )(6() J) ( ) )( (

6) ) 6 (

ED

( 6 6 6)()6 6

6 (

) ( () ( b
PT

)() ( ( ) () )(

) b (
CE

6( (66 (66 (6)( (

6) )() ()6 ) )( ( 6)( (

AC

)()

( () )( 6 6)() ( ()

)() 6 (

) (

6)( 6)() ( ( )() 6

6 6 ) () (

6 6( 6 ( ) ) ( 6)( 6)(

)( 6)( ( 6)( 6(

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
+/01 177 0 0 1

P
7 ?? 117 7 10771

RI
+/01 0 0 1 7

SC
770 1011 7 11 10 7 01 +

0 10 1

NU
1 1 0 7 10771 0 0

707 ? 1011 0

MA
1 1 1 0 7 7

7 1 0 ?? 1171 1700 7

+07 +070 77 7 1 7 7 0 1

1011 0
ED

+/01 01 7

07 0 707 ?? 1011 7
PT

+ 01 0 01 0

+/01 01 07 0
CE

1 ?? 1011 01 07

01 7 77 7 0
AC

+/01 01 707 0 1

7 01 70177 01 0 10

01

0 1 0 ?? 1011 007 07

01 7 70 01 0

011

01 771 1

11 7010 1 101 ?? 1011

0 0

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
.2 5 < 2.2

P
<2 22<2 2 < 2 <

< 2 . 2. 2

RI

SC
.2 < << <

<.2.< R<2 < .2. 2.< 22

.< <.< . <2 2

2<. 5<2 2<. < <.

NU
. << <2

2
MA
. 522 . << 2

..

2 5<2 22 <2
ED

<.< <2 2 2<.. 222 .

. . < ..< <

PT

22 2 2.2
CE

.< < 2 .<2 .

AC

5<<< 2< .2

5 2 2<.< 2<.. 2R

.<.2 < < ..< .<

<< .< 22 . 2<2

< <<. . . 2<.. 222

5 < .2< 2<.

.< 2

<. . <.< 2<..

<2 < < < . <.

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

( + (1 1( +

P
(+ ( ( 1(1 +1((1

RI
11(+ I(1 1 ++1 1( 1+
(

SC
T( ( I+ ( 1
(1 +1 (+1+ 1(+1 ( + +1(
1+ +1(( [[ +(++ (

NU
] I ( 1 +(+ + (1
MA
(1 (1 ( + +1(1+ (
1 +1(( ++1+ (
(+ I1 + ( 1+ 1 (
11 ++1+ ( (++
ED

(+ (1( 1 1+ (
(1( (+++ ( 1(
PT

(+ 11 + ( +(+ (11
1+ ++1+ ( (+1 I(++
CE

(1df 1gh+ +(+ 1 (

( 1 1 1(1 I(1
AC

I 1 (+1 1( + ( +

+(+ (+ ( + + ( (+
1(1 +(++ (
+ 1(1( ( 1(1 + ( (
( 1(1 +(++ (

+ 11 1 (
+ ++ 1(+( + ( +[ +(+
11 ++ (

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

T
*++ *++ 0 * *0+ 0*

P
0 + *

RI
K 0 * Q*0 * ++ *

RR ++0+ +0** + *0*+Q*0 +0

SC
*+ * *

*+ 0 *+ * 0*+0

* *0 *0+ 00 RR +*

NU
++ *

+ Q0

RR +*++ + 0+ +0**
MA
0 +0* * +0* +*

K * 0*0 * *0+ + + *
ED

*0+ *

0* 0* + 0* *

*+0 *++
PT

*+ 0*0 0* 0*0

* ++0 * +
CE

++ + Q*0 *

+++ + 0 *+ ** 0 * *
AC

++ + 0+ 00 *++

*++ **0 + 0*0 0 +

* 00 Q++

+ *0*0 RR +*++ 0

* ++0 00 +

0 + *

 ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT

Highlights

l Five different breakage kernels are implemented in OpenFOAM-2.2.x

l Droplet breakage in liquid-liquid dispersions with surfactants are simulated
l The predictions obtained with five breakage kernels are compared with experiments

T
l The multifractal kernel describes well when surfactants effect was included

P
RI
SC
NU
MA
ED
PT
CE
AC