Anda di halaman 1dari 13

See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262801086

The theory-practice gap and physiotherapy in


the UK: Insights from the nursing experience

Article in Physiotherapy Theory and Practice July 2009


DOI: 10.3109/09593989809057168

CITATIONS READS

11 154

3 authors:

Carolyn Roskell Alistair Hewison


University of Birmingham University of Birmingham
58 PUBLICATIONS 390 CITATIONS 108 PUBLICATIONS 1,025 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Stuart Wildman
University of Birmingham
40 PUBLICATIONS 198 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Compassion in Nursing:theory,evidence and practice View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Carolyn Roskell on 12 April 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Physiotherapy Theory and Practice

ISSN: 0959-3985 (Print) 1532-5040 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/iptp20

The theory-practice gap and physiotherapy in the


UK: Insights from the nursing experience

Carolyn Roskell, Alistair Hewison & Stuart Wildman

To cite this article: Carolyn Roskell, Alistair Hewison & Stuart Wildman (1998) The theory-
practice gap and physiotherapy in the UK: Insights from the nursing experience, Physiotherapy
Theory and Practice, 14:4, 223-233

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/09593989809057168

Published online: 10 Jul 2009.

Submit your article to this journal

Article views: 136

View related articles

Citing articles: 3 View citing articles

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=iptp20

Download by: [University of Birmingham] Date: 23 November 2015, At: 02:21


Physialhem@ Thmy andPmclicc (1998) 14,223-233
0 1998 Paychology Press

The theory-practice gap and physiotherapy in the UK:


Insights from the nursing experience

Carolyn Roskell, Alistair Hewison and Stuart Wildman

The existence of a theory-practice gap in physiotherapy has not attracted wide


attention or been the focus of sustained analysis within the profession. This is in
stark contrast to nursing, where consideration of the relationship between theory
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

and practice has received extensive coverage. The argument presented here
suggests that it is an appropriate time for an examination of the role of theory and
its relationship to practice in the discipline of physiotherapy and to draw on the
experience in nursing as a basis for this enterprise. The overall contention is that,
if debate and research around these issues is encouraged, subsequent
examinations of the physiotherapy knowledge base may become better informed.

INTRODUCTION professional education and clinical practice, and


the gap between research evidence and the reality
The recent publication of the new curriculum of practice in the clinical setting.
framework document for undergraduate physio- The aim of this paper is to explore the nature of
therapy education by the Chartered Society of the theory-practice gap in physiotherapy, an area
Physiotherapy (1996) in the UK, highlights a that, until recently, has received little attention in
number of issues in contemporary practice. The the literature. It is suggested that a theory-practice
document may be viewed as an attempt to recon- gap has always existed but has not attracted a great
cile areas of conflict which have developed in the deal of interest or formal analysis because the pro-
discipline of physiotherapy and have been thrown fession as a whole has not regarded the issue as
into sharp relief by changing demands on the UK problematic. The close relationship of physiother-
National Health Service (NHS) as awhole. Central apy to medicine has led to a largely reductionist
to this conflict is what has been described as the approach to practice (Parry, 1997) in which con-
'theory-practice gap', which can be viewed from a cern relating to professional identity and a knowl-
number of perspectives. These include the diver- edge base are minimised through a focus on the
gence of holistic and biomechanical approaches individual patient-practitioner relationship and
to therapy, perceived inconsistencies between the physiological basis of practice. However,
changes in health care organisation in the UKand
the professional response to them make this an
C. Rorkell, Department of Physiotherapy, appropriate time to evaluate how the physio-
S. Wildman, Department of Nursing, University of
Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham 815 2lT, UK therapeutic knowledge base is developing and
A. Hewison, School of Health Sciences, Coventry assess what impact the theory-practice gap is
University, Priory Street, Coventry CV1 5FB, UK having on this development. Similarly, the whole-
(Reprint requests to CR) sale relocation of physiotherapy education into
Accepted forpublication July 1998 the higher education sector has prompted a more
224 PHISIOTHERAPY
THEORYAND PRACTICE

evaluative orientation with respect to all facets of and define the nature and direction of practice
professional affairs. First, however, it is necessary (Thompson, 1995).
to c l a m the theory-practice gap to inform subse- However, the nature of theory is itself multidi-
quent examinations of knowledge development. mensional and there are different ways of viewing
The terms theoryand practiceare defined to it and its relationship to practice. Argyris and
clarify the interpretation to be used in the discus- Sch6n (1974) refer to espoused theory and the-
sion. Then, in view of the paucity of relevant p h p ory-in-useas a means of conveyingthis complexity.
iotherapy literature, the extensivework conducted An espoused theory is one to which someone, or in
in nursing is reviewed and, through a similar this case a profession, pledges allegiance and is
review of physiotherapy literature, comparisons used to explain certain courses of action. On the
made which provide evidence of a theory-practice other hand, a theory-in-use actually governs peo-
gap in physiotherapy. Nursing is used as a com- ples actions and may or may not be compatible
parator, because although it has close working with espoused theories. Incongruity and inconsis-
links with and similarities to physiotherapy as a tency between these two types of theory may occur
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

profession, its response, in terms of the develop and the behaviour that a practitioner exhibits may
ment of the discipline, is quite different. Although not correspond to the theories he or she claims to
both professions have been exposed to a changing use. In a similar way, Thompson (1995) refers to
organisationaland professional climate in the UK, formal and informal theories. Formal theories are
nursing has actively explored theory-practice published, form the basis of teaching and are open
issues whereas physiotherapy has not. This situa- to debate, whereas informal theories are based on
tion is of interest, worthy of comment and serves as practicewisdom developed through experience,
a useful starting point for analysis. Finally, the are often covert and not amenable to testing. Con-
implicationsof this situation for physiotherapywill sequently, there is an inherent potential for the
be considered and recommendations made con- development of a gap between theory and
cerning potential courses of action. Health care is practice.
changing and physiotherapy must change with it; Acomponent of this incongruityisthe difficulty
and if the change is to come from within, the practitioners experience in recognising the rele-
debate must begin. Failure to review the bases of vance of espoused theories to professional
practice is likely to result in change being imposed practice:
on the profession.
Since students are already anxious about the rele-
vance of their education, they may become even
more anxious when they are exposed to difficultnew
THE NATURE OF THEORY AND concepts that have little apparent connection to the
problems they believe they will face. They may react
PRACTICE negatively to theory that does not immediately apply
The relationship between theory and practice has to realityand may therefore partly or totally reject the
new inputs as not relevant to their profession.
been of interest to people in a range of disciplines (Argyris and Schijn, 1974)
and professions over a considerable period of
time. The result of this interest would seem to be There are also particular difficultieswhen pro-
somegeneral agreement that theory is necessaryto fessionsdepend on different disciplinesto provide
describe, explain, control and predict events and theoretical input to professional courses. In the
phenomena. There is also a presumption that field of education, for example, Hirst (1993)
theory and practice are linked and that the appli- regards the contribution of the disciplines of phi-
cation of theorywill improve and enhance profes- losophy, sociology, psychology and history, which
sional practice. Thompson (1995) maintains there have traditionally formed the curriculum for
is a need for theory as it helps to debunk the teacher training, as essentiallyproblematic.There
commonsense explanations and traditional views is little agreement among these disciplines con-
that professionals often adhere to. Theory pro- cerning what practice should entail, because they
vides a framework of ideas and values that guide all have different perspectives,ways of interpreting
PHBIOTHERAPY THEORYAND PRACTICE 225

issues and contrasting priorities in describing and This is a situation that has been recognised in areas
defining practice. Consequently, it is clear that as diverse as social work, teacher education, law,
this scheme of proceeding from disciplines to architecture, medicine, management and town
principles to particular activities, simply will not planning (Payne, 1991; Eraut, 1994; Schdn 1983,
work (Hirst, 1993). 1987). However, in the discipline of nursing, this
This problem is exacerbated by the fundamen- issue has been a subject of debate for many years.
tal differences between academic and practice Consideration of the dominant themes in this dia-
contexts (Eraut, 1994). In the academic context, logue will now be presented as a means of identify-
value is attached to theory in the traditional disci- ing related areas of concern in physiotherapy.
plines, activity is dominated by the written word
and characterised by open-mindedness through
the exploration of challenging concepts and theo- THE THEORY-PRACTICE GAP IN
ries. This contrasts with the reality of the
NURSl NG
skills-based practice setting where practitioners
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

have little time to examine the implications of The term theory-practice gap has become some-
theory for practice and the ability to write well is thing of a shorthand expression in nursing to
not a priority. It is an action-oriented environment describe situations where there is a divergence
where the need is for practical abilities to deal with between what is stated or taught about practice
real problems and issues from a basis of perceived and what actually occurs. Through its use in the lit-
certainty. erature, the meaning of the word theoryhas been
Schdn (1987) further contends that theory transformed into a catch all designation for edu-
developed through technical-rational means such cational, theoretical and research issues which are
as research is of limited value to professional prac- perceived to have little relevance to practice. For
tice in disciplines, such as medicine, law and busi- example, Hislop et a1 (1996) carried out a study
ness. He uses the metaphors of the high ground into theory and practice in nurse education and
and the swampy lowlands of professional prac- used theory as a summary term for the college
ticed to illustrate particular dilemmas profession- course of the students involved in the research.
als experience as a result of this uneasy However, this is only one element of the gap and
relationship between theory and practice. The the multifaceted nature of the problem is per-
high ground consists of manageable problems that haps best summarised as a series of contrary pair-
lend themselves to solutions through the applica- ings of the key issues, which are: educational
tion of research-based theory and techniques. The theory and practice; clinical theory and practice;
swampy lowlands, however, consist of messy and research theory and practice; professional opera-
confusing real-life problems which are often tional theory and management practice (Table 1).
unique to a particular context and fall outside the It is recognised that placing these elements in
category of existing theory. Schdn contends that opposition is a crude analytical device which does
the practitioner has a choice, either to stay on the not fully convey the complex nature of the p r o b
high ground where he or she can solve relatively lem, and that a more accurate characterisation
unimportant problems according to prevailing may be to regard each pair of factors as extremes
standards of rigor, or descend to the swampof on interlocking and overlapping continua. Never-
important problems and more arduous inquiry theless, the notion of contrary pairings is a useful
(Schdn, 1987). framework which can be used to structure the dis-
If the professions and professional educators cussion and highlight the way the theory-practice
continue to adhere to a model that searches for a gap has been portrayed.
body of professional knowledge that is generated
solely by technical-rational means, then a gap can
occur between the theory and practice of the pro-
Educational theory and practice
fession and also between what is taught to students The basic premise underlying the education and
and what is carried out in the practice context. practice of the gap is that the separation of nurse
226 PHBIOTHERAPYTHEORYANDPRACTICE

Table 1
Elements of the theory-prectice gap
Element
(exDressed as a series of continua) Form
Educational theory and practice Knowledge generated in educational institutions bearing little
relationship to the reality of practice experienced by practitioners
Clinical theory and practice The theory of the discipline being derived increasingly from the social
sciences and the work of influentialleaders and academics
Research theory and practice The care delivered in clinical areas that does not conform to principles
of intervention derived from research. Ritual and tradition as a basis
for practice
Professional operational theory Fundamental divergence of views arising from conflicting professional
and management practice and manaaerial DersDectives of contemporary service deliverv
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

training from the delivery of the service has entrepreneurs (Porter, 1995), the concepts of
resulted in a situation where knowledge generated humanism and reflection have become key com-
has little relevance for the realities of practice. In ponents in the nursing curriculum. The short-
the past, this occurred partly because of the physi- hand term that now seems to be used to describe
cal distance between education and practice, this blend of concepts is the New Nursing (Sal-
where educational institutions and the hospi- vage, 1990), wherein the nurses role changes
tals/communities they serve are often geographi- from one of dependence upon the doctor to one
cally distant (Colleen-Stainton, Rankin and of greater autonomy in clinical decision making,
Calkin, 1989), and partly because teachers too working in partnership with the patient. This also
often deliver content in the classroom which is requires a broader knowledge base, which, being
unrelated to practice (Jolley, 1987). This was also derived largely from the social sciences, has fur-
the view of Vaughan (1987), who maintained that, ther potential for introducing students to material
while practice and teaching remain separate in that is difficult to apply directly in the work setting.
nursing, students will experience a disparity In developing an approach to practice which
between theory and practice. In a later study, derives not from experience but from abstract
McCaugherty (1991) suggested theory consisted research, socio/psychological theories about the
of books, nursing curricula and what is taught in nature of man and philosophical discourses about
the classroom. He found that student nurses felt the definition of health and health care, the
these media conveyed an imperfect representa- formal knowledge base of nursing has moved away
tion of practice which made integration of theory from the concrete realities of practice (Procter
and practice difficult. He also commented: To and Reed, 1993). Nurses are also expected to take
move from the generalities of lectures to the spe- responsibility for their own learning and actively
cifics of patient care can require a leap across the reflect on and learn from their practice (UKCC,
theory-practice gap (McCaugherty, 1991).This is 1994). Consequently, leading practitioners and
indicative of one theme in the literature, which academics have re-shaped the academic basis of
suggests that disparities between what is taught nursing and new dilemmas concerning the
and what goes on in the reality of practice consti- theory-practice gap have emerged.
tutes a theory-practice gap.
Research theory and practice
Clinical theory and practice In terms of the discrepancies between what
This situation has been compounded by the i n t r e research evidence demonstrates and what actually
duction of new areas of study to the nursing curric- occurs in practice, it could be argued that this
ulum. Influenced by the work of nursing manifestation of the theory-practice divide has a
PHBIOTHERAPY THEORYAND P R A ~ I C E 227

long history. Walsh and Ford (1989) examined principles and been replaced by a hate culture
some of the fundamental areas in which the prac- which is antipathetic to the values of nursing. Simi-
tice of nursing bears little resemblance to the rec- larly,Antrobus contends that there is a fundamen-
ommendations arising from research and tal clash between current managerial and nursing
suggested that what practitioners do is dominated approaches to the organisation of patient care:
by ritualand habit.More recently, the dissemi- Adopting an approach which involves measure-
nation of research findings to influence practice ment and tests using a reductionist, quantitative
was identified as an issue requiring more collabo- aspect does not fit with a contemporary ideology
rative work between researchers and practitioners for nursing practice within a humanistic aesthetic
ifprogress is to be made (Dickson,1996). Itwould framework (Antrobus, 1997).
seem that a practice lag in nursing remains, This brief review of the main components of the
whereby the reality of clinical care is not always theory-practice gap in nursing is by no means
based on the most recent evidence.The increasing exhaustive; rather, it is intended to serve as a refer-
demand for evidence-based care (Dunning, 1996) ence point in the discussion to follow, which con-
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

is stimulating discussion of the nature of practice siders the current state of physiotherapy. Indeed,
and this trend is also likely to focus greater atten- there are many detailed analyses of this phenome-
tion on the theory-practice gap. non in nursing (for example, see Fealy, 1997;
Carter, 1996;Rafferty,Allcock and Lathlean, 1996;
Cook, 1991; McCaugherty, 1991; Antrobus, 1993;
Professional operational theory
Reed and Procter, 1993; Nolan and Grant, 1994).
and management practice
The suggestion here is that these issues are of rele-
Recent events and changes in the organisation of vance to physiotherapy and, through the process
health care have introduced another set of ten- of identifjmg them, an opportunity is created to
sions which may perpetuate the theory-practice understand more about the current state of the
problem. A more subtle yet perhaps more perva- discipline.
sive separation, namely the contrast between the
values of nurse education and those of the new
managerialism,is evident in the reformed NHS in THE THEORY-PRACTICE GAP AND
the UK. The values underpinning much of con-
PHYSIOTHERAPY
temporary nursing education are rooted in con-
cepts of humanism, holism and adult education, In contrast to the high level of interest in the
whereas the contemporary organisation and deliv- theory-practice gap in nursing, there is little p h p
ery of care has, of late, been based on management iotherapy literature on the subject. Relevant issues
principles, derived to a large extent from a superfi- regarding the phenomenon are raised in a variety
cial interpretation and application of manage- of articles, but there is a shortage of papers dedi-
ment theory, which gives undue emphasis to cated solely to the examination of this important
measurement and quantification (Pollitt, 1993). area. Interestingly, however, the physiotherapy lit-
The reality of the environment in which nurses are erature that exists reveals a theory-practice gap
expected to practise is one oriented to through- evident in the areas described in Table 1.
put, numerical targets and financial constraints,
whereas as learners they are exhorted to treat
Physiotherapy educational theory
patients as individuals, implement nursing theory
and advance their own learning. The result of this
and practice
set of circumstancesis that the theory-practice gap The movement of physiotherapy education into
has taken on a new guise (Hewison and Wildman, higher education led to concerns that a reduction
1996). Wilkinson (1995) and Antrobus (1997) in the practical skill component would occur with
have been particularly outspoken in this respect. a corresponding increase in academic content.
Wilkinson (1995) believes that current practices Potts (1996) maintains that these fears have not
within the NHS have moved away from its guiding been realised. However, at a recent meeting of
228 PHSIOTHERAPYTHEORYAND PRACTICE

clinically based and university-based educators of types of approaches are fully evaluated, such
the Association of Chartered Physiotherapists in claims cannot be made with any certainty.
Respiratory Care (September 1996), the prevail- The education process may promote a theory-
ing view was that skill levels had decreased among practice gap by selecting simpler ways of communi-
students and newly qualified graduates. A theory- cating difficult ideas; however, these may become
practice gap is evident when fitness for purpose, so far removed from the real world that they
as perceived by clinicians, is not observed in learn- cease to provide a useful basis for practice. For
ers entering the clinical setting. example, Hollenberys concept of physiothera-
Another contributory factor is that the tradi- peutic intervention illustrates this point:
tional organisation of physiotherapy education
has delivered course content in compartmental- Its easy to teach physiotherapy as an academic sub-
ject whereby in response to a given set of symptoms,
ised subject domains which limit the ability of there is a set response to treatment. It is much harder
learners to integrate information from different to teach physiotherapyas treatmentwhich is sensitive
sources, thereby reinforcing the theory-practice and responsive, which changes appropriately to the
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

gap (Richardson, 1992). Richardson states that patient and not to a predetermined set of rules
even the introduction of problem-solvingmethods which apply to each specific condition. (Hollenbery,
1994)
of teaching and learning cannot recreate the com-
plexity presented to the learner in real-lifeclini- This highlights the limits of textbook cases, which
cal situations: are often simplistic representations of complex
It would seem of paramount importance to buildup a real-world phenomena. Practical experience
profile of physiotherapy practice today and to try to based in a classroom using normal subjects is also
explore any discrepancy which may exist between the subject to the same limitations. Reduction of this
kinds of knowledge credited in the schools of physio-
therapy and the kinds of competence which are val-
component of the theory-practice gap requires
ued currently in professional practice. (Richardson, appropriate context-specific experience - that is,
1992) suMicient quantities of clinical practice.
The presence of physiotherapy in higher edu-
cation has also led to an expansion in postgraduate Physiotherapy clinical theory and
opportunities. However, concern has also been practice
expressed that this provision may not meet the
needs of practice: Academics offering higher The establishment of physiotherapy departments
degrees should address the issue of pursuing phys- in universities has been accompanied by an
iotherapy excellence in practice as well as pushing increased interest and involvement in research
back the frontiers of knowledge (Thomson, and scholarly activity. This is indeed timely, as the
1994). However, the geographical distance drive towards evidence-based practice has
between educational institutions and the clinical assumed a high profile. However, the theoretical
context have reduced the opportunities for uni- base on which clinical physiotherapists can draw to
versity-based s t a f to have contact time with support their practice is lacking. Parry (1992) con-
patients. A theory-practice gap exists for the edu- tends that, Much of what physiotherapists do is
cators who may see a refinement of their educa- passed on by tradition, guesswork and faith.
tional and knowledge-based skills at the cost of Others have expressed similar concerns regarding
degradation of their previously well-honed clinical the lack of established theory (Tyni-LennC, 1989;
skills. This was recognised by Lane (1992), who Bell, 1994; Richardson, 1993; Krebs and Harris,
stated that skills need to be taught well by experts, 1990; Robertson, 1995a), and Roberts has noted
and therefore lecturers need to maintain clinical that physiotherapy should stop borrowing others
contacts and develop their clinical expertise. The theory and create its own:
recruitment of lecturer/practitioners and the A profession which is attempting to define its own
involvement of specialised external speakers may knowledge base without an examination of the fun-
go some way to reducing this effect, but until these damental beliefs which underpin it is bound to be
PHYSIOTHERAPYTHEORYANDPRACTICE 229

confused...[leading to] ...conflicts and tensions in to be fulfilling expectations. Ellis (1996) states:
practice, management, education and research. Currently much postgraduate work is laboratory
(Roberts, 1994)
focused. Robertson (199513) surveyed the journal
A theory-practice gap is very clear here. How can Physical Therapy and discovered that a large
practice be informed by theory that does not exist? number of studies utilised group designs, most
Given this deficit, it is little wonder cliniciansadopt commonly with normal subjects, despite evi-
custom and practice as a rationale for their own dence demonstrating the weakness of this
interventions. However, it is possible that this approach in providing generalisable results to
approach may lead to incorrect hypotheses being practice (Parry, 1991; Grieve, 1993). Physiothera-
formed and, as a consequence, the perpetuation pists appear to be choosing this method in prefer-
of less than optimal practices (Sim, 1995). ence to others. A trend was also observed towards
the study of topics not directly related to clinical
efficacy and, in response to this, Robertson
Physiotherapy research theory and (1995b) called for more research that is clinically
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

driven.
practice
Some authors have suggested that research has
Another element in this dimension of the not informed clinical practice in more significant
theory-practice gap is the pressure on university ways because it fails to acknowledge the private
staff to pursue scholarly activity and contribute to knowledge (Robertson, 1996) and tacit skills
the body of knowledge arising largely from the (Richardson, 1993) which characterise expert
Research Assessment Exercise (RAE) in the UK. practice. These elements of intuitive practice are
The outcome of this exercise is used as a criterion difficult to verbalise to others and stimulating
for the allocation of research funds to universities. debate in these areas is vital if coherent research
Merely increasing the output of physiotherapy questions and appropriate methodologies are to
research is not in itself sufficient, as findings may be forthcoming.
actually contribute to the theory-practice gap if
they arise from poorly constructed studies and are
read uncritically by practitioners. Grieve (1993)
ProfessionaI operationa I theory
cautions that research with fundamentallyflawed
and management practice
methodology is being used to condemn practices A more recent factor in the divergence of theory
unjustifiably and to make false claims. and practice in physiotherapy is the widespread
Problems even exist with the limited amount of market-based reforms of the public sector in the
theory that is available. The UKChartered Society UK. The reshaped NHS, with its recent drive
of Physiotherapy Research Development Group towards promoting evidence-based practice,
(1996a) concluded, The problems of translating demands high-level technical skills and supporting
research into practice are well known; and the evidence for their use; in other words, evidence
Physiotherapy Research Society also acknowl- predicated on a technical-rationalmodel of knowl-
edged this problem at its recent meeting entitled edge. Physiotherapy curricula, in common with
From Theory to Practice - Bridging the Gap nursing, suffer from overload in terms of content,
(November 1996).Itwas noted that research capa- much ofwhich is from diverse disciplines. This puts
ble of informing practice was not being used by pressure on the time spent developing high levels
physiotherapists in the clinical setting. The UK of skill and, as a consequence, graduates ability to
Chartered Society of Physiotherapy Research provide what managers demand is reduced: If we
Development Group (1996b) concluded that do not produce graduates with the practical skills
increases in workload and productivity were ham- which are required, we can rest assured that some-
pering the utilisation of research in practice. one else will take over the job for us (Lane, 1992).
Given the calls for the development of physiu- This element of the theory-practice gap has the
therapy theory, it is surprising that the type of potential to enable managers, sceptical of the
research that has been undertaken does not seem claims of the efficacy of physiotherapy, to take
230 PH~OTHERAPY
THEORYANDPRACTICE

unilateral decisions regarding service provision, pendulum may swing the other way. Criticism of
because the supporting evidence, in the form of teacher education in the 1980s centred on a belief
results from randomised controlled clinical trials, among politicians and others that it was too aca-
is not available (Allison, 1996). demicand did not prepare teachers adequately to
Future physiotherapy service provision, there- deliver real education. This led to pressure on
fore, is under threat from a narrow perception of training/educational institutions to make teacher
what constitutes admissibleevidence in the new education more practice-based. Will nursing and
health care environment. physiotherapy suffer the same fate? Will courses
eventuallybe returned to the practice sector?Phys-
iotherapy must learn from nursing to the extent
that, although the issue of the theory-practice gap
DISCUSSION has been extensively examined in the literature,
The basic premise of this paper is that a this seems to have had little influence in shaping
theory-practice gap exists in physiotherapy. In future educational developments.
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

making this explicit, it is not our aim to create


more anxiety and dissonance for practitioners; Research as the vehicle for closing
rather, it is to stimulate a debate to enhance devel- the theory-practice gap
opment of the discipline.The dilemmasand issues
discussed also hold the key to how the problems It is also apparent that there is little point generat-
identified can be resolved. Three fundamental ing evidence that is not going to be used. Dissemi-
questions seem to emerge: nation of findings and feeding them into powerful
institutions which are able to invoke change
0 What has nursing learned from its preoccupa- appear currently to be areas of major weakness for
tion with the issue? nursing and physiotherapy in the UK.
0 Is this debate necessary for the discipline of The preoccupation in nursing with the
physiotherapy? theory-practice gap has been accompanied by
0 Are there insights to be gleaned from the work strenuous efforts to generate a distinct body of
undertaken in nursing? theory, including the development of numerous
models of nursing. Physiotherapy has not fol-
lowed this course and, it has been argued, has an
A similar experience? impoverished theoretical base, lacking in models.
Comparisons between nursing and physiotherapy Roberts (1994) states: A gap in physiotherapists
reveal some interesting points. Both disciplines understanding of theoretical models is matched
have recently seen a move of its educational struc- by a gap in the professions understanding of its
ture into institutions of higher education and the own theoretical knowledge base. It is evident that
links with the workplace have been weakened. this lack of attention to theory is limiting the gen-
Also, students now have supernumerarystatus and eration of a coherent and rigorous knowledge
are no longer regarded as workers.As courses base which may inform more specific aspects of
have become more academic, the university-based patient care. For clinicians to be able to provide
tutors have become less practice-focusedand, con- evidence-based practice, research, education and
sequently, they may generate research questions practice need to be considered as complementary
that lack a clear practice orientation. This could components of one overarching entity, offering a
result in the expanding body of knowledge having seamless perspective on physiotherapy practice.
little to offer the practitioner. Nursing seems to The importance of this process is emphasised by
have identified this problem much sooner than Sackley (1994):Physiotherapistsare guardians of
physiotherapybut appears to have had little influ- a body of knowledge;it is fundamental to the exis-
ence in overturning the educational structure tence of the profession.
which is perpetuating the problem. Comparison Nurses have built their academic tradition on a
with the teaching profession shows how the variety of bases drawn from the social sciences.
PHSIOTHERAPY THEORYAND PRACTICE 231

Physiotherapists, by contrast, have traditionally The policy process


adopted the biomedical model of investigation and
All of this suggests that both disciplines need to
have utilised basic scientific method. Examination
engage with the policy process in a more active
of the physiotherapeuticbody of evidence demon-
way. Although there are competing definitions
strates an incompleteness generated by a reliance
surrounding health policy (Ham, 1992), it is per-
on positivist approaches. Physiotherapistsare corn-
haps most usefully regarded as a cyclicalprocess in
ing to this via observationsof a theory-practice gap
which government statements of interest can be
and therefore the experience of nursing as a disci-
identified as starting points but that policies are
pline should be looked to and lessons learned. This
often adapted and distorted by interpretations,
is not to suggest that nursing has produced a neat
actions or inertia of lower-level actors (Allsop,
package of solutions;this is far from the case. How-
1995). If nursing and physiotherapycan intervene
ever, a thorough examination of the issues has cer-
and exert influence at these lower levels, some of
tainly occurred and those wishing to pursue these
the problems arising from the theory-practice gap
matters in physiotherapy could save a great deal of
may be offset.Antrobus and Brown (1997) feel this
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

time by consulting this body of literature as a start-


is essential and comment that, A new language is
ing point. The reason for characterisingthe theory-
therefore required which does not lose nursings
practice gap as a series of opposites (Table 1) was to
essentialvalue system,yet fits the context of power,
highlight the different dimensions in a way that
politics, targets and indicators, as part of a scien-
could also act as a stimulusfor empirical study. Each
tific objective approach to health care.
of the continua could serve as a starting point for
This is one means of trying to influence policy
developing important research questions of value
and ensure nursings voice is heard. Robinson
to the profession. This would help offset the con-
(1991) and Cox (1993) also believe that active
duct of detailed but often esoteric work of ques
involvement in the policy process is necessary, but
tionable relevance to the profession as a whole.
that it must be imbuedwith professionalethics and
The intended outcome of this process, which will
a compassionate concern for the best interests of
take many years, is to reduce the gap between
patients. This is more likely to be achieved if the
theory and practice through the production of a
sound research base noted earlier is available,
distinct and appropriate body of knowledge. Only
which brings the argument full circle. Ifresearch is
then can appropriate methods of dissemination of
undertaken which closes the theory-practice gap,
this knowledge occur by undergraduate and con-
in both nursing and physiotherapy,the probability
tinuous professional development routes. A
is that it will also be instrumental in having a posi-
framework for this will include evidence-based
tive influence on the policy process, ultimately
practice, facilitated by evidence-based education
improving patient care.
and developed by evidence-based research.
There is a possibility that professional work
could become increasingly fragmented and CONCLUSION
redistributed in the narrow pursuit of cost reduc-
tion and flexibility. Addressing the issues raised This paper has examined the phenomenon of the
through this brief review of the theory-practice theory-practice gap, focusing on its manifesta-
gap will also provide evidence that will effectively tions in nursing and physiotherapy. As
challenge this short-sighted approach to the physiotherapeutic theoretical bases are still evolv-
organisation of patient care. Work in Nursing ing, clinicians are currently unable to offer ade-
Development Units, designed to study the contri- quate evidence-basedjustification of practice. It is
bution nursing can make to patient care (Pearson, proposed, therefore, that physiotherapistsshould
Punton and Durant, 1992), has clearly demon- examine the theory-practice gap more thor-
strated that professionally led care is both of high oughly to inform the direction of hrther research
quality and cost-effective.It is vital that physiother- and contribute to the developing body of
apy marshals a similar body of evidence to support physiotherapeutic knowledge.The first step in this
its practice. process is to engage with the debate; once this
232 AND PRACTICE
PHYSIOTHERAPYTHEORY

debate has been joined, a reduction of certain neg- Dunning M 1996 Leading by example. Kings Fund News 19: 6
Ellis E 1996 Physiotherapyin Australia in the year 2000.
ative aspects of the theory-practice gap becomes a AustralianJournal of Physiotherapy 42: 95-96
realistic prospect. Consideration of the positive Eraut M 1994 Developing professional knowledge and
effects of the gap, namely those of stimulating competence. Falmer Press, London
Fealy GM 1997 The theory-practice relationship in nursing:
questions driven by movement on either side of An exploration of the contemporary discourse.Journal of
the gap, as has been examined in nursing, is also Advanced Nursing 25: 1061-1069
an issue worthy of further exploration. This is nec- Grieve E 1993 A fair trial for physiotherapy: The controlled
trial. Physiotherapy 79: 304
essary to subsequently generate those specific Ham C 1992 Health policy in Britain, 3rd edn. Macmillan,
questions which will make the research thrust of Basingstoke
the profession germane to its continued growth Hewison A, Wildman S 1996 The theory-practice gap in
nursing: A new dimension. Journal of Advanced Nursing
and development. It is envisaged that encouraging 24: 754-761
debate surrounding the theory-practice gap in Hirst P 1993 Educational theory. In: Hammersley M (ed.)
physiotherapy will produce a framework which Educational research: Current issues, pp. 149-159. Paul
Chapman, London
can ensure that professional growth and develop Hislop S, Inglis B, Cope P, Stoddard B, McIntosh C 1996
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

ment proceeds on both sides of the gap Situating theory in practice: Student views on
symbiotically. theory-practice in project 2000 nursing programmes.
Journal of Advanced Nursing 23: 171-177
Hollenbery S 1994 Looking to the future: An alternative view.
Physiotherapy80: 103A-104A
References Jolley J 1987 Too little, too late? Nursing Times 83: 28-29
Krebs DE, Harris SR 1990 Elements of theory presentations in
Allison G 1996 Functional rehabilitation -whats in a name? physical therapy. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 6
AustralianJournal of Physiotherapy 42: 3-6 57-63
Allsop J 1995 Health policy and the NHS: Towards 2000. Lane REJ 1992 Management: The enabling function.
Longman, London Physiotherapy 78: 885-890
Antrobus S 1993 Nursings nature and boundaries. Senior McCaugherty D 1991 The theory-practice gap in nurse
Nurse 13: 4 6 5 0 education: Its causes and possible solutions. Findings from
Antrobus S 1997 An analysis of nursing in context: The effects an action research study.Journal of Advanced Nursing 1 6
of current health policy. Journal of Advanced Nursing 25: 1055-1061
447-453 Nolan M, Grant G 1994 Mid-range theory building and the
Antrobus S, Brown S 1997 The impact of the commissioning nursing theory-practice gap: A respite care case study. In:
agenda upon nursing practice: A proactive approach to Smith J (ed.) Models, theories and concepts, pp. 58-70.
influencing health policy making.Journal of Advanced Blackwell Scientific, Oxford
Nursing 25: 309-315 Parry AW 1991 Physiotherapy and methods of inquiry:
Argyris D, SchBn D 1974 Theory in practice: Increasing Conflict and reconciliation. Physiotherapy 77: 435-438
professional effectiveness.Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA Parry A 1992 Talking to ourselves. Physiotherapy 78: 887
Bell AJ 1994 Mechanotherapy, man and machines. Parry A 1997 New paradigms for old: Musings on the shape of
Physiotherapy 80: 61-65 clouds. Physiotherapy 83: 423-433
Carter D 1996 Barriers to the implementation of research Payne M 1991 Modern social work theory: A critical
findings in practice. Nurse Researcher 4: 30-50 introduction. Macmillan, Basingstoke
Chartered Society of Physiotherapy 1996 Curriculum Pearson A, Punton S, Durant I 1992 Nursing beds - an
framework. Chartered Society of Physiotherapy,London evaluation of the effects of therapeutic nursing. Scutari
Chartered Society of PhysiotherapyResearch Development Press, Harrow
Group 1996a Physiotherapy research and continuing Pollitt C 1993 Managerialism and the public services, 2nd end.
professional development: The way forwards. Physiotherapy Blackwell Business, Oxford
82: 58-62 Porter S 1995 Nursings relationship with medicine: A critical
Chartered Society of Physiotherapy Research Development realist ethnography. Avebury, Aldershot
Group 1996b Physiotherapy research and continuing PottsJ 1996 Physiotherapyinto the next century:
professional development: The way forwards. Physiotherapy Opportunities and challenges. Physiotherapy 82: 150-155
82: 9 Procter S, Reed J 1993 Teaching reflective practice:
ColleenStainton M. RankinJA, Calkin JD 1989 The Possibilities and constraints. In: Reed J, Procter S (eds)
development of a practising nursing faculty. Journal of Nurse education: A reflective approach, pp. 30-44. Edward
Advanced Nursing 14: 20-26 Arnold, London
Cook SH 1991 Mind the theory/practice gap in nursing. Rafferty AM, Allcock N, Lathlean J 1996 The theory/practice
Journal ofAdvanced Nursing 1 6 1462-1469 gap: Taking issue with the issue.Journal of Advanced
Cox C 1993 Closing thoughts on hidden agendas: An Nursing 23: 685-691
epilogue. In: Jolley M, Brykcynska G (eds) Nursing: Its Reed J, Procter S 1993 Nursing knowledge: A critical
hidden agendas, pp. 160-170. Edward Arnold, London examination. In: Reed J, Procter S (eds) Nurse education:
Dickson R 1996 Dissemination and implementation: The A reflective approach, pp. 14-29. Edward Arnold,
wider picture. Nurse Researcher 4: 4-14 London
PHYSIOTHERAPYTHEORYAND PRACTICE 233

Richardson B 1992 Professional education and professional Schon D 1987 Educating the reflective practitioner.
practice today - do they match? Physiotherapy 78: 23-26 Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA
Richardson B 1993 Practice, research and evaluation -what is Sim J 1995 Sources of knowledge in physical therapy.
the link. Physiotherapy 79: 317-322 Physiotherapy Theory and Practice 1 1 : 193-194
Roberts P 1994 Theoretical models of physiotherapy. Thompson N 1995 Theory and practice in health and social
Physiotherapy 80: 361-366 welfare. Open University Press, Buckingham
Robertson \(I 1995a Research and the cumulation of knowledge Thomson A 1994 Postgraduate education and continuing
in physical therapy. Physical Therapy 75: 223-236 professional development. British Journal of Therapy and
Robertson VJ 1995b A quantitative analysis of research in Rehabilitation 1: 117-1 18
physical therapy. Physical Therapy 75: 31 3-327 Tyni-Lenne R 1989 T o identify the physiotherapy paradigm: A
Robertson VJ 1996 Epistemology, private knowledge and the challenge for the future (editorial). Physiotherapy Practice
real problems in physiotherapy. Physiotherapy 82: 534-539 5: 16!3-170
Robinson J 1991 Power, politics and policy analysis in nursing. UKCC 1994 What PREP will mean for you? UKCC Register 15:
In: Perry A, J o k y M (eds) Nursing: A knowledge base for 4-5
practice, pp. 271-304. Edward Arnold, London Vaughan B 1987 Bridging the gap. Senior Nurse 6 30-31
Sackley C 1994 Developing a knowledge base: Progress so far. Walsh M, Ford P 1989 Nursing rituals, research and rational
Physiotherapy 80: 24A-28A actions. Heinemann Nursing, Oxford
SalvageJ 1990 The theory and practice of the new nursing. Wilkinson MJ 1995 Love is not a marketable commodity: New
Nursing Times 86: 42-45 public management in the British National Health Service.
Downloaded by [University of Birmingham] at 02:21 23 November 2015

SchBn D 1983 The reflective practitioner: How professionals Journal ofAdvanced Nursing 21: 980-987
think in action. Arena, Aldershot

View publication stats