ITPI JOURNAL
4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09 JOURNAL
www.itpi.org.in
D.S. MESHRAM
President, Institute of Town Planners, India
ABSTRACT
Informal sector in fact is functioning as a buffer zone between formal employment generating activities and the
unemployed and under-employed sections of the community who, for various reasons such as lack of skill, education,
or resources, have been denied access to employment avenues in the formal sector, but they are also extremely
intelligent, hardworking, creative and resourceful and endeavoring to solve their own problems to fulfill their own
needs, without depending upon government to support. Both the formal and internal sectors must be recognized
as two separate but complementary sectors of the urban economy, and it is imperative to reshape the settlement
structures of our large cities to enable them to absorb the expanding informal sector along with planned expansion
of formal sector. Therefore, taking into consideration the role of informal sector as employment generator in retail
trade and its share in economic activities of Delhi, the author examines the building up of informal sector in MPD-
2021.
and cities will experience anarchy making urban according to Nick Devas and Carole Rakodi (211)
governance very difficult. the informal sector is a common shorthand term
for small scale, un-enumerated, sometimes illegal
In fact poor in-migrants who migrate to the cities economic activity. Kulshretha defines informal
in search of employment, being unskilled they are sector as the sector of economy where the labor
unable to get jobs in formal sector and opt for force is self employed with family support in
whatever jobs come their way, even though not income activities such as trading and street
very remunerable. Economists underscore that vending that do not have formal structure and
the basic reason for the existence of informal designated areas and is characterized by small
economy is ‘excessive amount of regulations and scale labor intensive operations. In fact, the
licenses that make it difficult to operate with the features that distinguish the informal sector are
formal economy’, while political analysts says that (a) labor and employment; (b) economic activities
vendors constitute a `Safety Value’, for what and enterprises; (c) land and housing settlements;
otherwise would be massive unemployment. They and (d) credit market from their counterparts in
may be illiterate, but they are also extremely the formal sector (see Table 1).
intelligent, hardworking, creative and resourceful
and endeavoring to solve their own problems to Formal commercial uses are planned on
fulfill their own needs, without depending upon hierarchical basis from neighborhood level to the
government to support. town or city level and cater to different levels of
commercial requirements of the urban areas.
As per International Labor Organisation (ILO), an
However, lower order commercial developments
enterprise should be classified as informal if it
which come up in informal ways in the form of
employs only a handful of workers on low income,
petty shops, hand carts selling goods have
using simple equipment, and works outside the
remained unplanned. Such activities occur
framework of laws and regulations. It is
generally at traffic junctions; in front of higher
characterized by the ease of entry, reliance on
order commercial activity centers on foot paths,
indigenous resources; family ownership of
etc. The formal commercial development can be
enterprises; small scale of operations, labor
seen in the form of convenient shops at
intensive and adapted technology, skills acquired
neighborhood level, the pure commercial and
outside the formal school system, and unregulated
mixed commercial cum residential complexes at
competitive market.
district centers and the higher order commercial
The informal sector is usually defined to include all activities at CBD. The lower level commercial
economic enterprises and employment that are service shops and the ancillary commercial shops
not protected or regulated by the government like cycle repairing, pen shops, cloths mending,
laws and social security system. The criteria that tea shops, pan shops, hair cutting shops, sale of
are conventionally used to distinguish the informal fruits, snacks and eatables are the need of sector
sector enterprises, employment and habitat from level commercial center, district centre and CBD.
their formal sector counterparts are size, nature These shop owners can not afford a regular built
of technology, organizational and operation up shop in the formal commercial set up at the
characteristics and coverage by social security initial stage. Any forcible eviction or checking of
system and protection, etc. (Narul Amin, 8). their encroachments by law and order agencies
would exacerbate the problem because they are
Kanpe Ronald Hope Sr. (111) defines informal required by the people. As the spatial planning is
sector as the subterranean sector alternatively for the people their requirements and wants are
referred to as the informal, hidden, underground, needed to be catered by locating these informal
shadow, secondary, black, invisible or parallel activities at appropriate locations which do not
economy – now constitutes an important create hindrance to the residents and do not
component in the economic activities and process create traffic and transportation bottlenecks. The
of development in the Third World. While next section of the paper examines the provisions
2
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
of Master Plans of Delhi with reference to informal the two major contributions of this plan. The plan
sector. also provided a useful base for regulating the
development and building activity in different
3 MPD - 1962 urban sectors. The MPD-62 shall always remain a
To check the haphazard and unplanned growth unique document, being the first attempt on
of Delhi, following the partition of the country and comprehensive urban planning for the Union
the phenomenal growth of the city’s population, Territory of Delhi. Some basic postulates
with its sprawling residential colonies, without enunciated by the plan more than two decades
proper layouts and without the conveniences of
ago, reproduced below, remain as true today as
life and to guide the growth of the city; Central
they were in 1962. In fact they need to be re-
Government established the Delhi Development
emphasized.
Authority in 1957. The DDA with the help of Town
Planning Organisation (TCPO) prepared MPD -
• Delhi should be planned in the context of its
1962 which is the first comprehensive plan, for
region;
the development of Delhi and has been the frame
for guiding developments since then. An efficient • For balanced development of the city and
circulation network and extensive lung spaces are minimum friction, there should be
3
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
decentralization of employment and its right It can thus be noted that MPD - 1962 even though
relationship with residential areas; recognizes the problems of incidence of settlement
of low income group who migrate to Delhi and
• While guiding developments in new areas along
intends to avoid stratification on income or
desirable lines, those areas that have healthy
occupation habits, does not give the informal
organic pattern must be conserved by
sector due recognition.
checking the encroachment of undesirable
and conflicting land uses; and 4 MPD - 2001
• Delhi a beautiful city and its pleasing In the Preamble to MPD - 2001, it is stated that
architecture should not confine to the Delhi, the focus of the socio-economic and political
monumental civic and cultural centers, but life of India, a symbol of ancient values and present
should pervade the design of all public and aspirations, the capital of the largest democracy,
private buildings. is assuming increasing eminence among the great
cities of the world. The city of Delhi has a distinct
Land Use Plan in essence is the translation into personality. Presently, growing at unprecedented
physical form of the planning policies and principles. pace, the city must be equipped to face the
The policies have been based on the realities of contemporary challenges. It should be able to
the present dynamic but rather unregulated and integrate its elegant past as well as the modern
chaotic conditions obtaining in the metropolis. developments into an organic whole. The
Accordingly, land use plan 1962 of Delhi inhabitants of this city should be able to live in
recognizes that to achieve a rational growth of safe, convenient and lively surroundings. They
Delhi, which has been expanding in a most should be able to improve their economic
haphazard way, it is necessary to plan the whole capabilities and share the fruits of modernization.
Delhi Metropolitan Area comprising 800 sq. miles All this demands purposeful transformation of its
and comprising of Delhi and Ring Towns of Loni socio-economic, natural and built environment.
and Ghaziabad in UP, Faridabad, Ballabhgarh and
The plan notes that there are a number of stages
Gurgaon in Punjab and Narela in Delhi territory as
from the enunciation of planning principles to its
a composite unit. Land use plan for urban Delhi
accomplishment. All the postulates, enumerated
has been conceived to find solutions for the entire
in MPD - 1962, during the process needed
complex inter-related urban problems i.e. social,
adequate acceptance, detail planning and
economic and governmental and it aims at
execution during implementation. They
balanced and integrated development to take care sometimes tend to suffer some loss at every
of present and future growth upto1981 for stage; the end results in some spheres have,
estimated population of about 50 lakh. therefore, been insubstantial. There are other
issues of importance like rapid urban population
Plan also recognizes that because of its location and employment growth, land use permissibility,
Delhi will continue to be a major financial, business, land use intensity, informal sector and incompatible
commercial and distribution centre and with the uses which overwhelmed the MPD - 1962 in the
growth of population there would a proportionate process of its implementation. Planning is a
increase in the people employed in trade and continuous process; responding to multifarious
commerce which would provide the necessary developments internal and external, the city has
diversity to the economy. To meet the problems new roles to play and urban development needs
of settlements of low income group people who new directions. With the experience of plan
migrate to Delhi from rural areas every year, implementation of last two decades and on the
suitable sites in several zones were earmarked for basis of planning studies, the Master Plan for Delhi
the low income groups who migrate to Delhi on has been extensively modified in accordance with
account of the relentless ‘push’ from rural areas. the provision of Delhi Development Act and the
It is noted in the plan that physical plans should modified document is entitled as ‘Master Plan for
avoid stratification on income or occupation habits. Delhi Perspective – 2001 (MPD-2001).
4
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
The Perspective Plan-2001 ensures an appropriate employment remains at low productivity in the
balance between the spatial allocations for the absence of proper infrastructure. It is possible to
distribution of housing, employment social create lively shopping areas by suitably introducing
infrastructure, shopping centers, public and informal sector.
individual transport and so on and adequate
arrangements and reservations to accommodate To accommodate, required shopping, commercial
different kinds of physical infrastructure and public offices, offices for undertakings and other related
utility systems. The MDP – 2001, therefore activities like cinema, hotel and needed facilities,
comprises of a set of co-ordinated policies five tier system of commercial activity has been
concerned with virtually all aspects of development envisaged, comprising of Central Business District
in the city. The basic postulates of MPD-2001 are and Sub - Central Business District; District
that Delhi should be planned as an integral part of Centers; Community Centers; Local Shopping
its region, ecological balance to be maintained, the Centers; and Convenient Shopping Centers.
However, large sections of unemployed and under-
Central City area to be treated as ‘special area’,
employed in rural areas and small towns look
urban heritage of Delhi to be conserved, city
forward to the metropolitan cities like Delhi for
centre to be decentralized; Mass Transport
employment and enter the city to move up the
System to be multi model; urban development
economic ladder. This brings forth a multitude of
to be ‘low rise high density’ and also to be
small enterprises, petty trading and casual labor.
hierarchical.
Thus a metropolis like Delhi has modern wage paid
MPD – 2001 recognizes that the genesis of Delhi’s sector; and equally large if not larger traditional
bazaar type informal sector. This sector with highly
growth lies in the increasing urbanization which
reduced needs of equipment and buildings is
continues to offer most important opportunities
important as a source of employment and also
for increasing employment and to provide the
for economic functioning of Delhi.
basis for specialization and increased productivity
in manufacturing and supporting services. Delhi Informal sector units locate themselves strategically
is growing at a rapid pace because of increasing near work centers, commercial areas, outside the
migration being more than 1.6 lakh person per boundaries of schools, colleges and hospitals,
annum and therefore, in the context of transport nodes and near large housing clusters.
urbanization and migration, adopts restrictive As a single item, eatables constitute the highest
policy for employment generation and strives for number (35.14 percent) followed by personal
balanced regional development. As per MPD- service (14.36 percent). The Walled City and
2001, the population of Delhi would 128.10 lakh Trans-Yamuna area particularly show a very high
by 2001 while the NCRPB has assigned the percentage of this activity. The Municipal
population of 112 lakh for Delhi. Corporation of Delhi is charging a certain fee
termed tehbazari for continued use of particular
While taking the cognizance of the informal sector, space by such units. However, a large number of
MPD-2001 states that in the city of Delhi, informal units are either mobile or not covered under the
sector in retail trade plays a very important role. tehbazari. The MPD - 2001 proposes to
About 1.39 lakh informal sector retail units without incorporate informal sector in trade in the planned
roof are working within the shopping areas, along development of various zones for which norms
road side and other areas of public concentration. are given in Table 2.
Delhi has the tradition of weekly markets and at
present there are 95 weekly market site. 1.8 The plan also underlines that it would be desirable
weekly markets per 1 lakh population with about if few standard efficient and colorful designs for
6,000 daily shopping spaces. These markets work mobile as well as stationery units are evolved and
once in a week at one place and the entrepreneurs are placed all over the city. It would add to the
keep moving to different places on different days cityscape and would be bringing in lot of richness
of the week. But this sector which is generator of and experience of the city in a developing country.
5
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
Sr. No. Use Zones / Use premises No. of informal shops / units
1 Retail trade:
Central Business District No. of informal shops / units
Sub-Central Business District 3 to 4 units per 10 Formal shops.
At the time of sanction of the building plans or Although there are large number of informal sector
layout plans, the provision of informal sector trade eating units in the city but there are no organized
units should be ensured so that the poor clientele clusters. There is a need for this to provide for
to which informal sector serves are not exploited evening and late evening eating places to be
upon, and informal sector units are developed to located strategically all over the city. On
cater to the target groups. experimental basis, locations are identified. These
are (i) Behind Andrews Ganj in South Delhi; (ii)
The traditional style of retail shopping is quite Proposed community center near Mandi House;
popular in Delhi, specially among the lower and (iii) Near Revolving T.V. Tower Pitampura; and (iv)
middle income groups. These markets are Near C.B.D. Trans Yamuna Area. In the urban
operating in a systematic manner choosing extension such places could be part of the planned
locations central to a large population either on development on the norm of one sub-cluster for
vacant land or road sides. The largest city level one lakh population at community level. Thus, it
weekly market is held every Sunday on the Ring is quite clear that MPD – 2001, taking the
Road at the rear of the Red Fort. Norms for the cognizance of existence of informal sector as a
provision of weekly markets has been worked out source of employment and its share in the
as 1 to 2 locations per one lakh population with economic activities of Delhi has made the
300 to 400 units per location with area 0.4 ha. provisions for the informal sector activities.
Parking and other open spaces within the
commercial centers could be so designed that 5. MPD – 2021
weekly markets can operate in these areas during MPD-2021, in its visions statement mentions that
non-working hours. The areas of informal sector Delhi, a symbol of ancient values and aspirations
should have suitable public conveniences and solid and the seat of national governance and a center
waste disposal arrangements. of business, culture, education and sports today
6
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
stands at the crossroads. The choice is between net shortage and the rest by dilapidated and
either take a road to indiscriminate uncontrolled Kutcha structures requiring replacement. The
development and slide towards chaos or a housing strategy of this Plan incorporates specific
movement towards making Delhi a world-class city. approaches for development of new housing
Adopting later option, the Vision–2021 is to make areas, upgradation and intensification through
Delhi a global metropolis and a world-class city, redevelopment of existing housing areas including
with a decent standard of living and quality of life unauthorized colonies, housing in villages and
in a sustainable environment. This will necessitate Special Area.
planning and action to meet the challenge of
population growth and in-migration into Delhi; As stated earlier the large sections of unemployed
provision of adequate housing particularly for the and under employed population in rural area and
weaker sections of the society; addressing the small towns look forward to the metropolitan cities
problems of unorganized informal sector; dealing like Delhi for employment and enter the city to
with the issue of slums, and shelter; provision of move up the economic ladder. This brings forth a
adequate infrastructure services; conservation of multitude of small enterprises and petty trading
the environment and preservation of Delhi’s activities in the informal sector. Thus, a metropolis
heritage and blending it with the new and complex like Delhi has organized sector and an equally large
modern patterns of development. The Master informal sector. This sector with highly reduced
Plan - 2021 would be the first plan of the 21st needs of floor space and investment is important
century catering to 230 lakh people on an area of as a source of employment and services in the
1,483 sq. km. economic fabric of Delhi. A survey conducted by
the Directorate of Economics and Statistics on
Delhi as a mega metropolis and as the National unorganized trading activity in Delhi estimated the
Capital Territory has a distinct and unique total number of unorganized trading enterprises
character and attracts the people from all across as 2 lakh and the number of persons employed
the country. Therefore, planning of Delhi can not about as 3.18 lakh. The contribution of this sector,
be limited within its boundaries. It inevitably which is measured in terms of Gross Value added
influences developments in the immediate to the economy of Delhi, was estimated at Rs.
surrounding areas and in turn gets influenced by 1.01 lakh per enterprise per annum.
them. Therefore, the stipulations of Regional Plan
- 2021 have been taken into consideration in the Keeping in view the National Policy of Urban Street
draft MPD–2021 elaborately. As already mentioned Vendors the following provisions are made in MPD
Delhi has a limited area of 1,483 sq. km out of - 2021:
which about half of the area is already urbanized.
For the remaining area, optimum utilization of land • The location and concentration of present
is required to be taken to cater to additional stationary informal units shall be considered
requirements. on case to case basis and steps for relocation
and improvement shall be taken. It should be
The policy of MPD-2021 regarding shelter is based ensured that such activities do not spillover
on ‘The National Housing and Habitat Policy’, which on the right of way. The Government and
has the ultimate goal to ensure ‘Shelter for All’ by concerned local agency should coordinate the
harnessing the potential of the public, private or policy;
corporate and household sectors. Based on the
• The areas of informal sector shall have suitable
projected population of 230 lakh by 2021, the
public conveniences and solid waste disposal
estimated additional housing stock required will be
arrangements;
around 24 lakh dwelling units. This includes an
estimated housing requirement of 20 lakh DUs • Formulation of guidelines for schemes would
for additional population added during 2001 to include ‘Hawking’ and `No Hawking’ Zones.
2021 and backlog of about 4 lakh units. Four lakh Specific areas should be earmarked for
backlog as per Census 2001 comprises of 1 lakh stationary and mobile street vendors by the
7
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
concerned local authority in consultation with strategically in the city and at the identified
RWAs; locations like: near TV Tower Pitampura; near sub
CBD Trans Yamuna Area; Rohini; Geeta Colony;
• The local authorities should take up new
and adjacent to transport nodes including ISBT.
designs of stalls, push-carts and mobile vans
Implementing agency may identify locations as
of various sizes and with cleaning facilities,
per requirement for such activities. The norms for
giving due consideration to urban design
organized informal bazaars are given in Table 3.
requirement of specific area, where informal
shopping is being permitted; In new urban areas, informal bazaars could form
• Defining the role and responsibility of NGOs part of the planned commercial areas at two levels.
along with specific obligations on part of These could be implemented in the initial planning
hawkers towards the society for maintenance stages along with development of residential area.
of law and order within the hawking zones and Weekly market, which is the traditional style of
weekly markets; and retail shopping, is quite popular in Delhi especially
• An informal unit shall not be permitted within among the lower and middle income groups.
a distance equivalent to half the width of the These markets are held in various areas. Further,
road, from an intersection. parking and other open spaces within the service
markets and commercial centers should be so
There is large number of informal sector units in planned that weekly markets can operate in these
the city but no organized clusters. There is a need areas. The specific locations and timings of
to provide for organized informal eating places operation of such markets should be specified and
along with casual shopping, etc; to be located regulated by the concerned local body.
8
D.S. Meshram / ITPI Journal 4 : 3 (2007) 01 - 09
Informal sector trade would be incorporated in informal sector as employment generator in retail
the planned development in various use zones. trade and its share in economic activities of Delhi,
Provision of informal sector trade units should be MPD–2021 has made the adequate provisions to
ensured at the time of sanction of building plans incorporate this activity along with formal sector
and layout plans as per the norms given in the of economy and accordingly, given prescriptions
Table 2, i.e. planning norms for informal trade are in terms of norms and standards. However, it is
the same as prescribed in MPD – 2001. The pertinent to mention here that in MPD–2021, Delhi
informal activities permitted in use premises are has been divided in 15 zones (A to P, except I)
given in Table – 4. and Zonal Plans are required to be prepared (within
12 months of the approval of MPD – 2021)
6 CONCLUSION
detailing out the policies of Master Plan.
According to various estimates, contrary to
Accordingly the Delhi Development Authority is
popular belief, the contribution of the informal
engrossed in the preparation of Zonal
sector to the national product is much greater
Development Plans on priority in order to
than originally believed and has possibilities for
complete the work by targeted date. Therefore,
accumulation of a capital which would enable
it can be hoped that the proposals of informal
informal enterprises to expand. Relationships
sector would be appropriately and adequately
between the formal and informal sectors should
be strengthened in order to bring a harmonious incorporated in the Zonal Plans.
co-operation between them for their mutual REFERENCES
advantage. They must be recognized as two
National Commission on Urbanisation, Vol. II – 1988
separate but complementary sectors of the urban
The Compulsions of Accommodating the Informal Sector
economy of Third World cities, each with its own in the Asian Metropolises and Changes necessary in the
institutional facilities, rationales and structures. Urban Planning Paradigms, A.T.M. Narul Amin
However, the prevailing under development and Development in the Third World – From Policy Failure
backwardness of the informal sector can be to Policy Reforms – Kampe Ronald Hope, Sr.
brought to an end only through restructuring the Managing Fast Growing Cities: New Approaches to Urban
urban economy. In the context of this scenario, Planning and Management in Developing World, edited
it becomes imperative to reshape the settlement by Nick Devas and Carole Rakodi.
structures of large cities to enable them to absorb Dictionary of Urban and Regional Planning - Dr. S.K.
the expanding informal sector along with planned Kulshretha
expansion of formal sector activities, and facilitate Master Plan for Delhi, 1962
efficient functioning of both (NCU, Vol. II: 67). Master Plan for Delhi, Perspective – 2001
Accordingly, taking into consideration the role of Master Plan for Delhi - 2021