Anda di halaman 1dari 10

Diabetic Neuropathy: Pathogenesis and Therapy

Aaron I. Vinik, MD, PhD

D
Diabetic neuropathies are complex, heterogeneous iabetic neuropathy comprises a number of dif-
disorders that encompass a wide range of abnormal- ferent syndromes, each with a range of clinical
ities affecting both peripheral and autonomic ner- and subclinical manifestations. The main groups
vous systems, causing considerable morbidity and of neurologic disturbance in diabetes mellitus include1:
mortality. Treatment should be based upon the un-
(1) subclinical neuropathy determined by abnormalities
derlying etiology and not symptoms alone, although
symptomatic therapy is needed. Neuropathies may
in electrodiagnostic and quantitative sensory testing; (2)
be focal or diffuse, proximal or distal, and involve diffuse clinical neuropathy with distal symmetric senso-
somatic and autonomic nerves. Focal syndromes rimotor and autonomic syndromes; and (3) focal syn-
are classified as (1) entrapment syndromes or (2) dromes. Proximal neuropathy may be considered as a
mononeuropathies. Entrapment syndromes are separate entity based upon the nature of the pathology
treated by means of relieving compression within and the response to treatment.
confined spaces. Mononeuropathies are due to a
vascular insult and resolve spontaneously. They are
best treated by supportive therapy. Proximal neurop- PATHOGENIC MECHANISMS
athies are usually due to an inflammatory, vasculitic, Figure 1 shows a current view of the pathogenesis of di-
or autoimmune condition and are best treated with
abetic neuropathy. Although there is increasing evidence
specific therapies for the underlying disorder based
that the pathogenesis of diabetic neuropathy is multifac-
on biopsy findings. Therapies for distal polyneurop-
athies include metabolic treatments (e.g., aldose re- torial, the prevailing theory implicates persistent hyper-
ductase inhibitors, aminoguanidine, ␥-linolenic acid), glycemia as the primary factor.2,3 Persistent hyperglyce-
autoimmune therapies, and nerve growth factors. No mia increases polyol pathway activity with accumulation
definitive treatment is available for painful diabetic of sorbitol and fructose in nerves, damaging them by an
neuropathy. Several medications have been used, as yet unknown mechanism. This is accompanied by de-
among them tricyclic antidepressants, antiepileptic creased myo-inositol uptake and inhibition of the Na⫹/
drugs, phenothiazines, calcitonin, local anesthetics, K⫹-adenosine triphosphatase, resulting in Na⫹ reten-
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and dextro- tion, edema, myelin swelling, axoglial disjunction, and
methorphan. Nonpharmacologic therapies include
nerve degeneration. Deficiency of dihomo-␥-linolenic
surgical sympathectomy, spinal cord blockade, elec-
acid (GLA) as well as N-acetyl-L-carnitine have also been
trical spinal cord stimulation, and prostaglandin. Am
J Med. 1999;107(2B):17S–26S. © 1999 by Excerpta implicated.4 Metabolic factors cannot account for all
Medica, Inc. forms of neuropathy or for the heterogeneity of the clin-
ical syndromes.

Immune Mechanisms
In some patients, immune mechanisms may be responsi-
ble for the clinical neuropathic syndrome, especially in
those with proximal neuropathy and those with a more
marked motor component to their neuropathy. Circulat-
ing antineuronal antibodies are present in diabetic serum
in some patients. The circulating autoantibodies directed
against motor and sensory nerve structures have been
detected by indirect immunofluorescence, and antibody
and complement deposits in various components of sural
nerves have been shown.5–7
A cross-sectional analysis of 154 patients with diabetic
neuropathy revealed that 12% had positive anti-GM1-
ganglioside antibody (an antibody subtype) findings.
From the Strelitz Diabetes Institutes, Departments of Internal Medi- Anti-GM1 antibodies were frequently associated with dis-
cine, Anatomy and Neurobiology, Eastern Virginia Medical School, tal symmetric polyneuropathy (DSPN) characterized by a
Norfolk, Virginia. slight emphasis on a motor deficit with electrophysi-
Requests for reprints should be addressed to Aaron I. Vinik, MD,
PhD, The Strelitz Diabetes Institutes, 855 West Brambleton Avenue, ologic signs of demyelination.8 Antiphospholipid anti-
Norfolk, Virginia 23510. bodies (anti-PLAs) were present in 88% of this popula-

© 1999 by Excerpta Medica, Inc. 0002-9343/99/$20.00 17S


All rights reserved. PII S0002-9343(99)00009-1
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

Figure 1. Current view of the pathogenesis of diabetic neuropathy. Diabetic neuropathy is a heterogeneous disorder. Superim-
posed on a genetic predisposition and environmental factors such as smoking and alcohol consumption, hyperglycemia and the other
metabolic abnormalities lead to increased polyol activity, activation of protein kinase C (PKC), and myo-inositol and ␥-linoleic acid
(GLA) deficiency. In addition, there is a tendency to microvascular insufficiency with “oxidative stress,” increase in the vasocon-
strictor endothelin and PKC, and deficiency of the vasodilators nitric oxide (NO) and prostacyclin (PGI). The third arm is perpet-
uation of the nerve insult by autoimmune destruction of nerves. The initial abnormality is functional, culminating in structural
changes with nerve degeneration and impairment of the regenerative response due to deficiencies in important neurotrophic factors.
Ab ⫽ antibody; EDRF ⫽ endothelial-dependent relaxing factor; GF ⫽ growth factor; IGF ⫽ insulin-like growth factor; NGF ⫽ nerve
growth factor; TRK ⫽ tyrosine kinase. (Adapted from Diabetes Rev.4)

tion, compared with 32% in diabetic patients without absolute or relative ischemia exists in the nerves of dia-
apparent neurologic complications and 2% in the general betic persons due to altered function of the endoneurial
population.9 There is evidence that PLAs may be injuri- and/or epineurial blood vessels. Histopathologic studies
ous to neural tissue and that damage may be selective for show the presence of different degrees of endoneurial
specific parts of the nervous system.9 Because PLAs are and epineurial microvasculopathy, mainly thickening
associated with a tendency to vascular thrombosis, their of blood vessel wall or occlusion.13,14 Functional
presence may provide a link between the immune and disturbances have also been demonstrated in the micro-
vascular theories of causation of neuropathy. vasculature of the nerves of diabetic persons. Studies
Microvascular Insufficiency show decreased neural blood flow,15 increased vascular
Microvascular insufficiency has been implicated as a resistance,16 decreased PO2,16,17 and altered vascular per-
cause of diabetic neuropathy.10 –12 The interest in micro- meability characteristics such as a loss of the anionic
vascular derangement arises from studies suggesting that charge barrier and decreased charge selectivity. It has also

18S August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B)
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

been shown that abnormalities of cutaneous blood flow normal adult rat DRG neurons express the laminin B2
correlate with neuropathy.18 chain gene.29 In other experiments, we described the up-
regulation of laminin B2 gene in regenerating neu-
Growth Factor Deficiency
rons.30,31 This finding indicates its importance in the pro-
Growth factor deficiency may also play a role in the
pathogenesis of diabetic neuropathy. Many of the char- cess of neuronal regeneration. However, laminin B2 ex-
acteristic neuronal changes are similar to those seen after pression under basal conditions and during neuronal
removal of target-derived growth factors by axotomy or regeneration was decreased in diabetic animals.32 If these
depletion of endogenous growth factors by experimental changes are present in patients with diabetic neuropathy,
induction of growth factor autoimmunity. Because neu- it might lay the foundation for exploring the therapeutic
ronal growth factors can promote survival, maintenance, potential of laminin.
and regeneration of neurons subject to the noxious ef-
fects of diabetes, the success of diabetic patients in main- FOCAL NEUROPATHIES
taining normal nerve morphology and function may de- (MONONEURITIS AND ENTRAPMENT
pend on expression and efficacy of these factors.4 SYNDROMES)
It is established that sympathetic and dorsal root gan-
Mononeuropathies (when an individual nerve is af-
glion (DRG) neurons are developmentally dependent on
fected) are due to vasculitis and subsequent ischemia or
nerve growth factor (NGF). Recently, it was shown that
adult DRG and sympathetic neurons, both of which are infarction of individual nerves.33 The isolated peripheral
affected in diabetic neuropathy, are dependent on NGF nerve lesions involve particularly ulnar, median, radial,
for either their maintenance or their survival.19 NGF be- femoral, and lateral cutaneous nerves of the thigh. Com-
longs to a gene family encoding structurally and func- mon mononeuropathies may also involve cranial nerves
tionally related proteins called neurotrophins (NTs). 3, 4, 6, and 7. Their onset is acute, sometimes associated
NGF has been implicated in diverse activities including with pain, and their course is usually self-limiting, resolv-
vasodilatation, gut motility, and nociception.4 Some data ing over a period of 6 – 8 weeks. Mononeuropathies must
suggest that a decrease in NGF synthesis has a role in the be distinguished from entrapment syndromes, which
pathogenesis of diabetic neuropathy, namely, in the func- start slowly, progress, and persist without intervention
tional deficit of small fibers. These fibers have a role in (Table 1). Common entrapments involve the median
pain and thermal sensation. The effect of NGF depletion nerve with impaired sensation in the first three fingers
may be mediated through the downregulation of neuro- and positive Tinel sign. Ulnar entrapment decreases sen-
filament gene expression or mRNAs that encode the pre- sory perception in the little and ring fingers. Medial and
cursor molecules of substance P, both shown to be NGF lateral plantar entrapments decrease sensation in the in-
dependent.4 Another member of the neurotrophin fam- side and outside of the feet, respectively. The entrapment
ily, NT3, may be important for the survival and function neuropathies are common in persons with diabetes and
of the large nerve fibers subserving proprioception, vibra- should be actively sought in every patient with signs and
tion, and, possibly, motor function.4 symptoms of neuropathy because the treatment may be
The insulin-like growth factors (IGFs), IGF-I and IGF- surgical.34
II, have been implicated in the growth and differentiation Carpal tunnel syndrome occurs twice as often in the
of neurons, and IGF receptors are present in nerve tissues diabetic population compared with the normal healthy
(e.g., neurons, Schwann cells, ganglia) involved in diabe- population. Its increased prevalence in diabetes may be
tes-associated nerve disorders. IGFs and their binding related to repeated undetected trauma, metabolic
proteins (IGF-BPs) are regulated by insulin and the gly- changes, or accumulation of fluid or edema within the
cemic state.4,20,21 A consequence of insulin insufficiency confined space of the carpal tunnel. If suspected, the di-
is a reduced circulating IGF-I concentration. Abnormal agnosis can be confirmed by electrophysiologic study.
IGF-I and IGF-II metabolism play causative roles in dia- The physician should be aware that symptoms may
betic neuropathy. However, little is known regarding the spread to the whole hand or arm, and the signs may ex-
other effects of diabetes on local expression, synthesis, tend beyond those subserved by the entrapped nerve. Be-
and transport of these growth factors in nerve tissue. cause the nature of the trouble may go unrecognized, an
Laminin opportunity for therapeutic intervention is often missed.
Laminin is a large, heteromeric, cruciform glycoprotein The mainstays of nonsurgical treatment are avoidance
composed of a large A chain and two smaller B chains, B1 of the use of the wrist, placement of a wrist splint in a
and B2.22,23 Laminin promotes neurite extension by cul- neutral position for day and night use, and anti-inflam-
tured neurons.24 –28 Lack of normal expression of laminin matory medications. Surgical treatment consists of sec-
B2 gene may contribute to the pathogenesis of diabetic tioning the volar carpal ligament. The decision to proceed
neuropathy. In our laboratory, we have shown that all with surgery should be based on considerations such as

August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B) 19S
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

Figure 2. Steps in the proposed pathways that lead to the pathogenesis of diabetic neuropathy and possible interventions at the level
of each proposed mechanism. AII ⫽ angiotensin II; ACE ⫽ angiotensin-converting enzyme; AGE ⫽ advanced glycation end
products; EFA ⫽ essential fatty acid (deficiency); ET ⫽ endothelin; GLA/EPO ⫽ ␥-linolenic acid/evening primrose oil; IGF ⫽
insulin-like growth factor; NGF ⫽ nerve growth factor; Nitrodil ⫽ nitrodilators; NO ⫽ nitric oxide; NT3 ⫽ neurotrophin-3; PDIE ⫽
phosphodiesterase; PGI2 ⫽ prostacyclin.

Table 1. Comparative Features of Mononeuritis and Entrapment


Feature Mononeuritis Entrapment
Onset Sudden Gradual
Pain Acute Chronic
Multiplex Occurs Rare
Course Resolves Persists without intervention
Treatment Physical therapy Rest/splints/surgery

severity of symptoms, appearance of motor weakness, protein structure, rendering them antigenic and activat-
and failure of nonsurgical treatment. ing immune destruction of neurons or their satellites
(Figure 2).37
DISTAL SYMMETRIC POLYNEUROPATHY:
THERAPEUTIC INTERVENTIONS Aldose Reductase Inhibitors
Glycemic Control Aldose reductase inhibitors (ARIs) reduce the flux of glu-
Retrospective and prospective studies suggest a relation cose through the polyol pathway, inhibiting tissue accu-
between hyperglycemia and the development and sever- mulation of sorbitol and fructose and preventing reduc-
ity of diabetic neuropathy.35,36 The importance of tight tion of redox potentials. Alrestatin, the first ARI studied,
glycemic control is discussed elsewhere in this supple- was shown to improve sensory impairment scores in one
ment by Parry.36a study,38 but in other studies no objective benefits were
Many attempts at reversal of neuropathy focus on the noted.39 – 41 Patient selection (i.e., inclusion of patients
aftermath of hyperglycemia: increased polyol pathway with severe neuropathy) may have complicated interpre-
activity, growth factor insufficiency, and the immune- tation of these trials because more severe neuropathy may
mediated consequences of glycemia-induced changes to be irreversible.

20S August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B)
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

Sorbinil, another widely studied ARI, generated more N-acetyl-L-carnitine


promising clinical effects. In a double-blind crossover N-acetyl-L-carnitine has yielded some exciting informa-
trial, treatment with sorbinil resulted in small but signif- tion on potential therapeutic benefit.18 However, the
icant improvements in both motor and sensory conduc- early promise for this compound was not fulfilled when
tion velocities compared with placebo.42 Additional the essentially negative results of the multicenter Cana-
studies have demonstrated minor improvements in test dian and American study were reported.
results but failed to demonstrate progressive benefit with
long-term therapy.43,44 Enrollment in clinical trials was myo-Inositol
discontinued because of toxic effects such as lymphade- myo-Inositol supplements appear to improve neuropa-
nopathy, rash, fever, and pancytopenia. thy,53 but treatment may have to be prolonged for ⱖ6
In a placebo-controlled, double-blind study of another months to achieve a significant effect.
ARI, tolrestat, 45 diabetic patients with asymptomatic au-
Human Intravenous Immunoglobulin
tonomic neuropathy, as defined by at least one pathologic
Human intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) treatment
cardiovascular reflex, were treated for 1 year.45 Patients
has the potential to ameliorate disturbances in both non-
who received tolrestat had significant improvement in
neurologic and neurologic autoimmune diseases. Kren-
autonomic function tests as well as in vibration percep-
del et al6 reported significant neurologic improvement in
tion, whereas placebo-treated patients showed deteriora-
21 patients with either peripheral diabetic polyneurop-
tion in most of the parameters measured. A large, multi-
athy or a demyelinating form of DSPN who were treated
center trial is under way in the United States and Canada,
with various immunotherapies. Patients with peripheral
using carefully standardized clinical measures of symp-
diabetic polyneuropathy showed favorable responses to
toms and physical findings, as well as quantitative physi-
IVIg, whereas those with DSPN improved during a
ologic testing and sural nerve biopsy.
course of treatment with steroids.
Gangliosides Treatment with immunoglobulin is well tolerated and
Gangliosides have been shown to promote improvement safe. The major toxicity of IVIg has been an anaphylactic
in sensation without changes in nerve conduction or reaction, but this is uncommon and occurs mainly in
small but significant improvements in motor and sensory patients with immunoglobulin (usually immunoglobulin
conduction.46 – 49 Although concerns about slow viruses A [IgA]) deficiency. In patients who do not have hypo-
and transmission of autoimmune neurologic disorders gammaglobulinemia or disorders associated with IgA de-
have been mitigated by refinement of the products, a ficiency, screening for IgA deficiency before IVIg is prob-
moratorium has been placed on their development. ably not justified.

Linoleic3 Linolenic Acid Neurotrophic Therapy


Linoleic acid, an essential fatty acid metabolized to NGF, discussed by Apfel53a elsewhere in this supplement,
dihomo-␥-linolenic acid (GLA), serves as an important is one of several neurotrophic factors that play an impor-
constituent of neuronal membrane phospholipids and as tant role in the development, maintenance, and survival
a substrate for prostaglandin E formation, which may be of neuronal tissues. Recombinant NGF administration
important for preservation of nerve blood flow. In dia- restores these neuropeptide levels toward normal and
betic patients, conversion of linoleic acid to GLA and sub- prevents manifestations of sensory neuropathy in ani-
sequent metabolites is impaired, possibly contributing to mals.54
the pathogenesis of diabetic neuropathy. A recent multi-
center, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial using GLA AUTONOMIC NEUROPATHY
for 1 year revealed significant improvements in both clin-
ical measures and electrophysiologic test results.50 These The development of autonomic neuropathy is of partic-
findings are particularly encouraging when one considers ular significance. Cardiac function is markedly impaired,
that linolenic acid also has lipid-lowering effects and may exercise tolerance is limited, and the ability to withstand
be useful in the management of diabetes in general. heat is impaired, making it essential that the patient be
protected from temperature extremes.
Advanced Glycosylation End Products Diabetic patients with proteinuria have a severalfold
Advanced glycosylation end product (AGE) inhibition increase in mortality risk as compared with nondiabetic
may be of some value in the treatment of diabetic neu- patients. Abnormalities in well-established cardiovascu-
ropathy. Studies in rats with streptozocin-induced diabe- lar risk factors (e.g., dyslipidemia, hypertension, smok-
tes using the AGE inhibitor aminoguanidine show im- ing, and obesity) cannot fully account for this finding.55
provement in nerve conduction velocity.51,52 Controlled Patients with type 1 or type 2 diabetes and albuminuria
clinical trials are needed to determine its efficacy in hu- have a less pronounced nocturnal decrease in blood pres-
mans. sure56,57 compared with nondiabetic persons. The prev-

August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B) 21S
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

alence of sympathetic and parasympathetic autonomic however, if large gastric residuals secondary to severe gas-
insufficiency is increased, indicating a possible role of troparesis are present. If so, gastric suctioning and intra-
persistently high cardiac output and total peripheral re- venous nutrition, as well as intravenous drug administra-
sistance in the pathogenesis of cardiovascular events that tion, may be needed initially. Other medications, such as
occur in this high-risk diabetic population.58 Reduced bethanechol and the pyridostigmine, have been advo-
vagal activity may be an important factor in the patho- cated but generally are of little therapeutic benefit and
physiology of sudden cardiovascular death, and silent may cause side effects including dry mouth, blurred vi-
myocardial ischemia/infarction occurs with loss of sym- sion, and colic.
pathetic innervation. These findings explain the poor Cisapride is effective in some patients and may be ini-
prognosis in diabetic patients with autonomic failure. tiated at a dose of 10 mg at least 15 minutes before meals
Patients at increased risk for cardiovascular complica- and at bedtime. If medications fail and severe gastropare-
tions secondary to autonomic neuropathy may be iden- sis persists, jejunostomy placement into normally func-
tified by examining heart rate variability response to deep tioning bowel may be needed. Feedings can be given at
breathing, Valsalva maneuver, and going from a lying night, freeing patients during the day, and insulin can
down to a standing position. Unfortunately, there is not accordingly be adjusted to accommodate their feeding
yet an accepted treatment for this condition. schedule.
Postural Hypotension Enteropathy
Postural hypotension in the patient with diabetic auto- Enteropathy involving the small bowel and colon can
nomic neuropathy can present a difficult management produce both chronic constipation and explosive dia-
problem. Elevating the blood pressure in the standing betic diarrhea.33 Stasis of bowel contents with bacterial
position must be balanced against preventing hyperten- overgrowth may contribute to the diarrhea. Treatment
sion in the supine position. with broad-spectrum antibiotics such as ampicillin or
Attempts should be made to increase venous return tetracycline (250 mg every 8 hours for either drug) is the
from the periphery using total-body stockings. The pa- mainstay of therapy. Metronidazole (500 mg every 6
tient should be instructed to put them on while lying hours) may also be effective. Treatment may be empiric
down and to not remove them until returning to the su- or, when possible, a hydrogen breath test may be used to
pine position. They can be uncomfortable, especially in determine whether the cause of the diarrhea is bacterial
hot weather, making compliance an issue. In severe cases, overgrowth and whether the overgrowth has been con-
an Air Force antigravity suit may be needed. trolled.
Some patients with postural hypotension may benefit Retention of bile may occur and can be highly irritating
from treatment with 9-␣-fluorohydrocortisone, which to the gut. Chelation of bile salts with cholestyramine
increases plasma volume. This mineral corticoid is usu- mixed with fluid may offer relief of symptoms. Diphen-
ally started at low doses of 50 –200 ␮g at night, but may be oxylate and atropine (Lomotil; Searle, Chicago, IL) may
increased up to 0.4 mg qd, although at these doses there is help to control the diarrhea. However, toxic megacolon
a significantly greater risk of developing hypokalemia and can occur; extreme care should be used.
excessive fluid retention. Supplementary salt intake may Patients with poor digestion may benefit from a glu-
also be beneficial. These treatments must be used with ten-free diet. Certain fibers can lead to bezoar formation
caution, because they may cause edema, and there is a because of bowel stasis in gastroparetic or constipated
significant risk of congestive heart failure and hyperten- patients. The soluble fiber psyllium can be useful for
sion. Various adrenergic agonists may be used instead; diarrhea.
for example midodrine, an ␣1-adrenergic agonist may be
Cystopathy
used in doses of 2.5–10 mg tid. Dihydroergotamine in
Patients with neurogenic bladder may not be able to sense
combination with caffeine, indomethacin, and the ␣2-
when their bladders are full. They should be instructed to
adrenergic antagonist yohimbine may also be tried in re-
palpate their bladders. If unable to initiate micturition
fractory patients.
when the bladder is full, Crede’s maneuver—manual
Gastropathy squeezing of the bladder from all sides in a downward
The first step in management of diabetic gastroparesis motion so that urine is expressed—should be used to
consists of multiple small feedings.33 The amount of di- start the flow of urine. Parasympathomimetic agents such
etary fat should be decreased because it tends to delay as bethanechol are sometimes helpful but often do not
gastric emptying. Metoclopramide, which sensitizes tis- help to fully empty the bladder.33 The patient is given 5
sues to the actions of acetylcholine, stimulating the mo- mg or 10 mg initially and then hourly until a satisfactory
tility of the upper gastrointestinal tract, may be added, if response has been achieved or a maximum dose of 50 mg
necessary. It is often given in 10-mg doses about 30 min- has been administered. The total dose is then used as a
utes before meals. The drug will not be well absorbed, maintenance dose three or four times a day. Extended

22S August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B)
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

Table 2. Responses of Specific Pain Syndromes in Diabetic Neuropathy


Syndrome Treatment Side Effects
Paresthesias, dysesthesias, TCAs ⫹ fluphenazine TCAs: Drowsiness, fatigue,
lancinating lethargy, dry mouth,
blurred vision, urinary
retention orthostasis;
fluphenazine: shakiness
Superficial burning, allodynia Topical capsaicin Care with application to
sensitive areas
Pain of mononeuropathies Gabapentin or Dizziness, nausea, skin rash,
and focal neuropathies carbamazepine marrow toxicity,
leukopenia, idiosyncratic
reactions
TCAs ⫽ tricyclic antidepressants.

sphincter relaxation can be achieved with an ␣1 blocker ment of any given patient with painful neuropathy. Often
such as doxazosin. Self-catheterization can be helpful, it requires patience on the part of the patient and physi-
and the risk of infection is generally low. In male patients, cian who must try a variety of different medications on a
bladder neck surgery may help to relieve spasm of the trial-and-error basis until a satisfactory regimen is estab-
internal sphincter if ␣1 blockade fails. lished.
Sexual Dysfunction The syndrome of acute painful neuropathy is a distinct
For the patient, sexual dysfunction can be one of the most variant of diabetic polyneuropathy, which is character-
disturbing complications of diabetes. A thorough assess- ized by the onset of severe, often unrelenting pain in the
ment of sexual function is useful to determine whether a legs. This pain is usually worse at night. In contrast to the
psychogenic or vascular component is involved in its severe painful symptoms, the neurologic examination is
pathogenesis. Several physiologic and pharmacologic often unimpressive, with only moderate loss of small-
treatment modalities are available.33 fiber sensory modalities. This syndrome is characteristi-
Sildenafil, at a dose of 25–100 mg, can be taken orally cally associated with marked weight loss and poor control
about 1 hour before anticipated intercourse. Men with of hyperglycemia, although it can be precipitated by a
underlying vascular or cardiac disease should use the sudden improvement in glycemic control. Symptoms
drug with caution as sildenafil has serious potential for generally improve with persistent control of hyperglyce-
interacting with nitrates. Sildenafil is effective in ⱕ50% of mia, although it can take 6 –18 months before significant
diabetic patients; for those in whom it is not effective, improvement is achieved. Pharmacologic treatment of
other agents may soon be available. Intrapenile injection acute painful neuropathy is not always effective, although
of regitine and papaverine have been used with some suc- many of the same drugs used have been effective to some
cess,59 but they carry a risk of infection, priapism, and degree in other types of painful neuropathy (Table 2).
fibrosis. Inflatable devices that obstruct venous outflow These agents will be reviewed in detail below. Nonphar-
while promoting inflow have also been used successfully. macologic therapies that have been tried with limited suc-
If these therapies do not help, rigid and semirigid pros- cess include sympathectomy, spinal cord blockade, and
theses are available. electrical spinal cord stimulation.
Analgesics are rarely effective in the treatment of pain-
CONTROLLING THE PAIN OF DIABETIC ful diabetic neuropathy, although they may be of some
NEUROPATHY use on a short-term basis for self-limited syndromes, such
Control of pain is one of the most difficult management as painful diabetic third-nerve palsy, or for chronic pain-
issues in diabetic neuropathy. Many different pain syn- ful neuropathy associated with musculoskeletal and joint
dromes have been described, reflecting pathology at dif- abnormalities. Analgesic use should be restricted to non-
ferent levels of the neuroaxis, including nerve terminals, steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS), because
the length of the axon, abnormal activity at central syn- narcotics are addicting and induce constipation, which
apses in the spinal cord, abnormal activation of periph- may exacerbate features of the autonomic neuropathy.
eral sympathetic neurons, and abnormalities in central Clinical trials have demonstrated efficacy with ibuprofen
pain regions of the brain. The various medications that (600 mg qd) and sulindac (200 mg bid) in relieving neu-
are commonly used are active at these different anatomic ropathic pain.60 NSAIDs must be used cautiously in dia-
sites. There is no single correct approach to the manage- betic patients, however, because of the risk of nephrotox-

August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B) 23S
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

icity in patients who may already have compromised kid- enne pepper with a jarful of cold cream. The mixture is
neys. applied to the painful area. Capsaicin works by depleting
Tricyclic antidepressants used in combination with or the neuropeptide substance P, which is involved in pain
without the phenothiazine fluphenazine have been transmission. Several studies have demonstrated efficacy
shown to be effective in treating painful diabetic neurop- with capsaicin in treating neuropathic pain,70,71 although
athy.61,62 In a meta-analysis of 21 different clinical trials, it is still somewhat controversial.72 Capsaicin is applied at
tricyclics provided significant pain relief to 30% of pa- a dose of 0.075% four times a day to the skin over the
tients with neuropathic pain.63 Tricyclics act on the cen- painful areas. Neuropathic pain may frequently worsen
tral nervous system, preventing the reuptake of norepi- for several days after therapy is initiated before improv-
nephrine and serotonin at synapses involved in pain in- ing.
hibition. The benefits of tricyclics appear to be unrelated Lidocaine provides relief of intractable pain for 3–21
to relief of depression. The most commonly used tricyclic days. This therapy is most useful in self-limited forms of
antidepressants for the treatment of neuropathic pain are neuropathy. If successful, therapy may be continued with
amitriptyline and nortriptyline. There is no evidence to oral mexiletine, a structural analogue of lidocaine. Mexi-
suggest that one is more efficacious than the other; how- letine has demonstrated efficacy in several clinical
ever, nortriptyline may have fewer anticholinergic side trials.73–75 It is initiated with doses of 150 mg daily and
effects such as dysautonomia, sleepiness, and dry mouth. then increased weekly until the pain is improved or until
Initial doses are usually low (10 or 25 mg at night) and a maximum of 600 –900 mg a day is achieved.
then gradually increased until some relief is attained or Although there is no single correct way to treat every
until side effects become prohibitive. Precautions should patient with painful neuropathy, there are some guide-
be taken to avoid precipitating cardiac arrhythmias, uri- lines that might be useful for the physician to follow.
nary retention, and glaucoma, especially in older pa- Many initiate treatment with either a tricyclic or an anti-
tients. convulsant. The choice of which particular drug to use
Anticonvulsants have also been used to control neuro- within these general classes of agents may depend on the
pathic pain. Diphenylhydantoin (DPH) has been used in individual side-effect profiles. These drugs should be in-
the past; however, double-blind crossover studies have creased until the maximum dose or until side effects be-
not demonstrated a therapeutic benefit in diabetic neu- come prohibitive before trying other therapies. Some-
ropathy.64,65 In addition, DPH has been shown to sup- times a combination of an anticonvulsant plus a tricyclic
press insulin secretion, resulting in the precipitation of is effective. If this regimen is ineffective and the pain is
hyperosmolar diabetic coma. Carbamazepine has also burning and restricted to particular anatomic sites or re-
been widely used and has been shown to be efficacious in flects allodynia (a marked hypersensitivity of the skin), it
clinical trials.66,67 When initiating carbamazepine, it is is reasonable to add capsaicin to the regimen. If the pain is
advisable to begin with a low dose, 100 mg bid, and then still refractory to therapy, then other drugs discussed
increase gradually until side effects are encountered or above may be tried as well as nonpharmacologic treat-
until there is significant relief of symptoms. Complete ments.
blood counts should be checked at the outset and then on
a frequent basis over the first 3 months because leukope- CONCLUSION
nia is a common complication. Gabapentin is a relatively It was once said that all we could do for patients with
new anticonvulsant that has been used with increasing diabetic neuropathy was commiserate with them. We
frequency for the relief of neuropathic pain. Gabapentin now can offer more hope. Some forms of pain respond to
has demonstrated significant efficacy in a recent multi- drugs, but better options are needed. Proximal neuropa-
center, double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled thies are likely to be inflammatory or vasculitic and gen-
study of 165 patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes.68,69 erally respond to immunotherapy. A large, definitive
Gabapentin significantly decreased the mean pain score clinical trial of the various forms of immunotherapy ver-
and improved the profile of mood states and quality of sus placebo therapy is needed. Distal symmetric polyneu-
life. Adverse effects were, however, significant. Dizziness ropathy remains a therapeutic challenge, but ongoing tri-
was reported in 24%, somnolence in 23%, headache in als, particularly those targeted at specific nerve fiber def-
11%, and diarrhea in 11% of patients. Gabapentin should icits, hold great promise for arrest and even reversal of the
be started at a dose of 300 mg per day, and gradually disorder.
increased until either efficacy or until a maximum dose of
2,400 mg per day is reached. REFERENCES
1. American Diabetes Association, American Academy of
Marked hyperesthesia with burning, lancinating, dys-
Neurology. Consensus statement: report and recommen-
esthetic pain is typical of C-fiber pain and may respond to dations of the San Antonio conference on diabetic neurop-
capsaicin. Capsaicin is extracted from chili pepper and athy. Diabetes Care. 1988;11:592–597.
can be prepared at home by mixing 3 teaspoons of cay- 2. Brownlee M. Advanced products of nonenzymatic glyco-

24S August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B)
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

sylation and the pathogenesis of diabetic complications. In: noassay for human and rat fluids. Endocrinology. 1991;128:
Rifkin H, Porte D, eds. Diabetes Mellitus: Theory and Prac- 805– 814.
tice. New York: Elsevier Science, 1990:279 –291. 22. Timpl R, Rohde H, Robey PG, et al. Laminin—a glycopro-
3. Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group. tein from basement membranes. J Biol Chem. 1979;254:
Effect of intensive diabetes treatment on nerve conduction 9933–9937.
in the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial. Ann Neu- 23. Timpl R. Structure and biological activity of basement
rol. 1995;38:869 – 880. membrane proteins. Eur J Biochem. 1989;180:487–502.
4. Vinik AI, Newlon PG, Lauterio TJ, et al. Nerve survival and 24. Baron–Van Evercooren A, Kleiman HK, Ohno S, et al. Nerve
regeneration in diabetes. Diabetes Rev. 1995;3:139 –157. growth factor, laminin and fibronectin promote neurite
5. Said G, Goulon-Goeau C, Lacroix C, Moulonguet A. Nerve growth from human fetal sensory ganglion cultures. J Neu-
biopsy findings in different patterns of proximal diabetic rosci Res. 1982;8:179 –193.
neuropathy. Ann Neurol. 1994;35:559 –569. 25. Lander AD, Fujii DK, Reichardt LF. Laminin is associated
6. Krendel DA, Costigan DA, Hopkins LC. Successful treat- with the “neurite outgrowth-promoting factors” found in
ment of neuropathies in patients with diabetes mellitus. conditioned media. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1985;82:
Arch Neurol. 1995;52:1053–1061. 2183–2187.
7. Vinik AI, Pittenger GL, Milicevic Z, Knezevic-Cuca J. Auto- 26. Longo FM, Hayman EG, Davis GE, et al. Neurite-promoting
immune mechanisms in the pathogenesis of diabetic neu- factors and extracellular matrix components accumulating
ropathy. In: Eisenbarth G, ed. Molecular Mechanisms of in vivo within nerve regeneration chambers. Brain Res.
Endocrine and Organ Specific Autoimmunity. Austin, TX: 1984;309:105–117.
R.G. Landes Company, 1998:217–251. 27. Manthorpe M, Engvall E, Ruoslahti E, et al. Laminin pro-
8. Vinik AI, Milicevic Z. Preventive measures and treatment motes neuritic regeneration from cultured peripheral and
options for diabetic neuropathy. Contemp Intern Med. central neurons. J Cell Biol. 1983;97:1882–1890.
1994;16:41– 42,47–55. 28. Rivas RJ, Burmeister DW, Goldberg DJ. Rapid effects of
9. Vinik AI, Leichter SB, Pittenger GL, et al. Phospholipid and laminin on the growth cone. Neuron. 1992;8:107–115.
glutamic acid decarboxylase antibodies in diabetic neurop- 29. Le Beau JM, Liuzzi FJ, Depto AJ, Vinik AI. Differential
athy. Diabetes Care. 1995;18:1225–1232. laminin gene expression in dorsal root ganglion neurons
10. Malik RA, Tesfaye S, Thompson SD, et al. Transperineurial and non-neuronal cells. Exp Neurol. 1994;127:1– 8.
capillary abnormalities in the sural nerve of patients with 30. Le Beau JM, Liuzzi FJ. Laminin B2 mRNA is up-regulated in
diabetic neuropathy. Microvasc Res. 1994;48:236 –245. sensory neurons and Schwann cells during peripheral
11. Dyck P, Hansen S, Karnes J, et al. Capillary number and nerve regeneration. Soc Neurosci Abstr. 1991;17:1500.
percentage closed in human diabetic sural nerve. Proc Natl 31. Le Beau JM, Liuzzi FJ, Depto AJ, Vinik AI. Up-regulation of
Acad Sci USA. 1985;82:2513–2517. laminin B2 gene expression in dorsal root ganglion neurons
12. Low P, Lagerlund T, McManis P. Nerve blood flow and and non-neuronal cells during sciatic nerve regeneration.
oxygen delivery in normal, diabetic, and ischemic neurop- [Brief communication.] Exp Neurol. 1995;134:150 –155.
athy. Int Rev Neurobiol. 1989;31:355– 438. 32. Depto AS, Le Beau JM, Liuzzi FJ, Vinik AI. Laminin gene
13. Yasuda H, Dyck P. Abnormalities of endoneurial microves- expression in diabetic rat dorsal root ganglia. Soc Neurosci
sels and sural nerve pathology in diabetic neuropathy. Neu- Abstr. 1993;19:835.
rology. 1987;37:20 –28. 33. Vinik AI, Holland MT, LeBeau JM, et al. Diabetic neuropa-
14. McNeil HP, Chesterman CN, Krilis SA. Immunology and thies. Diabetes Care. 1992;15:1926 –1975.
clinical importance of antiphospholipid antibodies. Adv Im- 34. Dawson DM. Entrapment neuropathies of the upper ex-
munol. 1991;49:193–280. tremities. N Engl J Med. 1993;329:2013–2018.
15. Tuck RR, Schmelzer JD, Low PA. Endoneurial blood flow 35. Pirart J. Diabetes mellitus and its degenerative
and oxygen tension in the sciatic nerves of rats with exper- complications: a prospective study of 4,400 patients ob-
imental diabetic neuropathy. Brain. 1984;107:935–950. served between 1947 and 1973. Diabetes Care. 1978;1:
16. Newrick PG, Wilson AJ, Jakubowski J, et al. Sural nerve 168 –188.
oxygen tension in diabetes. BMJ. 1986;293:1053–1054. 36. Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group.
17. Zochodne DW, Ho LT. Normal blood flow but lower oxygen The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes on the devel-
tension in diabetes of young rats: microenvironment and opment and progression of long-term complications in in-
the influence of sympathectomy. Can J Physiol Pharmacol. sulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. N Engl J Med. 1993;
1992;70:651– 659. 329:977–986.
18. Hotta N, Koh N, Sakakibara F, et al. Effect of propionyl-L- 36a.Parry GJ. Management of diabetic neuropathy. Am J Med.
carnitine on motor nerve conduction, autonomic cardiac 1999;107:27S–33S.
function, and nerve blood flow in rats with streptozotocin- 37. Pittenger GL, Liu D, Vinik AI. The apoptotic death of neu-
induced diabetes: comparison with an aldose reductase roblastoma cells caused by serum from patients with insu-
inhibitor. J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 1996;276:49 –55. lin-dependent diabetes and neuropathy may be Fas-medi-
19. Rich KM, Luszczynski JR, Osborne PA, Johnson EM Jr. ated. J Neuroimmunol. 1997;76:153–160.
Nerve growth factor protects adult sensory neurons from 38. Fagius J, Jameson S. Effects of aldose reductase inhibitor
cell death and atrophy caused by nerve injury. J Neurocy- treatment in diabetic polyneuropathy: a clinical and neuro-
tol. 1987;16:261–268. physiological study. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1981;
20. Merimee TJ, Gardner DF, Zapf J, Froesch ER. Effect of 44:991–1001.
glycemic control on serum insulin-like growth factors in 39. Handelsman D, Turtle J. Clinical trial of an aldose reductase
diabetes mellitus. Diabetes. 1984;33:790 –793. inhibitor in diabetic neuropathy. Diabetes. 1981;30:459 –
21. Bowsher RR, Lee W-H, Apathy JM, et al. Measurement of 464.
insulin-like growth factor-II in physiological fluids and tis- 40. Culebras A, Alio J, Herrera JL, Lopez-Fraile MI. Effect of an
sues, I: an improved extraction procedure and radioimmu- aldose reductase inhibitor on diabetic peripheral

August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B) 25S
A Symposium: Diabetic Neuropathy—Pathogenesis and Therapy/Vinik

neuropathy: preliminary report. Arch Neurol. 1981;38:133– CE. Diurnal blood pressure variations in normoalbuminuric
134. type 1 diabetic patients. J Intern Med. 1993;234:175–180.
41. Daniele E, Coco MP. Tolrestat in the therapy of diabetic 58. Mann S, Altman DG, Raftery EB, Bannister R. Circadian
peripheral neuropathy: Is this drug really useful? Clin Ther. variation of blood pressure in autonomic failure. Circulation.
1995;146:793–799. 1983;68:477– 483.
42. Judzewitsch R, Jaspan J, Polonsky J. Aldose reductase 59. Shmueli J, Israilov S, Segenreich E, Baniel J, Livne P.
inhibition improves nerve conduction velocity in diabetic Progressive treatment of erectile dysfunction with intracor-
patients. N Engl J Med. 1983;308:119 –125. poreal injections of different combinations of vasoactive
43. Young R, Ewing D, Clarke B. A controlled trial of sorbinil, an agents. Int J Impot Res. 1999;11:15–19.
aldose reductase inhibitor, in chronic painful diabetic neu- 60. Cohen KL, Harris S. Efficacy and safety of nonsteroidal
ropathy. Diabetes. 1983;32:938 –942. anti-inflammatory drugs in the therapy of diabetic neurop-
44. Christensen J, Varnek L, Gregersen G. The effect of an athy. Arch Intern Med. 1987;147:1442–1444.
aldose reductase inhibitor (sorbinil) on diabetic neuropathy 61. Davis J, Lewis S, Gerich J, et al. Peripheral diabetic neu-
and neural function of the retina: a double-blind study. Acta ropathy treated with amitriptyline and fluphenazine. JAMA.
Neurol Scand. 1985;71:164 –167. 1977;238:2291–2292.
45. Boulton A. Effects of tolrestat, a new aldose reductase 62. Gomez Perez F, Rull J, Dies H, et al. Nortriptyline and
inhibitor, on nerve conduction and paresthetic symptoms in fluphenazine in the symptomatic treatment of diabetic
diabetic neuropathy. (Abstr.) Diabetologia. 1986;29:521. neuropathy: a double-blind cross– over study. Pain. 1985;
46. Abraham R, Wynn V. A double-blind placebo-controlled 23:395– 400.
trial of mixed gangliosides in diabetic peripheral and auto- 63. McQuay HJ, Tramer M, Nye BA, Carroll D, Wiffen PJ,
nomic neuropathy. Adv Exp Med Biol. 1984;174:607– 624. Moore RA. A systematic review of antidepressants in neu-
47. Naarden A, Davidson J, Harris L, et al. Treatment of painful ropathic pain. Pain. 1996;68:217–227.
diabetic polyneuropathy with mixed gangliosides. Adv Exp 64. Ellenberg M. Treatment of diabetic neuropathy with diphen-
Med Biol. 1983;174:581–592.
ylhydantoin. NY State J Med. 1968;68:2653–2655.
48. Crepaldi G, Fedele D, Tiengo A. Ganglioside treatment in
65. Saudek C, Werns S, Reidenberg M. Phenytoin in the treat-
diabetic peripheral neuropathy: a multicenter trial. Acta Dia-
ment of diabetic symmetrical polyneuropathy. Clin Pharma-
betol Lat. 1983;10:265–276.
col Ther. 1977;22:196 –199.
49. Horowitz S. Ganglioside therapy in diabetic neuropathy.
66. Rull JA, Quibrera R, Gonzalez-Millan H, et al. Symptomatic
Muscle Nerve. 1986;9:531–536.
treatment of peripheral diabetic neuropathy with carba-
50. Keen H, Payan J, Allawi J, et al. Treatment of diabetic
mazepine (Tegretol): double blind crossover trial. Diabeto-
neuropathy with ␥-linolenic acid. Diabetes Care. 1993;16:
logia. 1969;5:565–568.
8 –15.
67. McQuay H, Carroll D, Jadad AR, Wiffen P, Moore A. Anti-
51. Miyauchi Y, Shikama H, Takasu T, et al. Slowing of periph-
convulsant drugs for management of pain: a systematic
eral motor nerve conduction was ameliorated by aminogua-
review. BMJ. 1995;311:1047–1052.
nidine in streptozocin-induced diabetic rats. Eur J Endocri-
68. Rosenberg JM, Harrell C, Ristic H, et al. The effect of
nol. 1996;134:467– 473.
52. Schmidt RE, Dorsey DA, Beaudet LN, et al. Effect of ami- gabapentin on neuropathic pain. Clin J Pain. 1997;13:251–
noguanidine on the frequency of neuroaxonal dystrophy in 255.
the superior mesenteric sympathetic autonomic ganglia of 69. Backonja M, Beydoun A, Edwards KR, et al. Gabapentin for
rats with streptozocin-induced diabetes. Diabetes. 1996; the symptomatic treatment of painful neuropathy in pa-
45:284 –290. tients with diabetes mellitus: a randomized controlled trial.
53. Gregersen G, Bertelsen B, Harbo H, et al. Oral supplemen- JAMA. 1998;280:1831–1836.
tation of myoinositol: effects on peripheral nerve function in 70. Capsaicin Study Group. Treatment of painful diabetic neu-
human diabetics and on the concentration in plasma, eryth- ropathy with topical capsaicin. Arch Intern Med. 1991;151:
rocytes, urine and muscle tissue in human diabetics and 2225–2229.
normals. Acta Neurol Scand. 1983;67:164 –172. 71. Capsaicin Study Group. Effect of treatment with capsaicin
53a.Apfel SC. Neurotrophic factors in the therapy of diabetic on daily activities of patients with painful diabetic neurop-
neuropathy. Am J Med. 1999;107:34S– 42S. athy. Diabetes Care. 1992;15:159 –165.
54. Apfel SC, Kessler JA. Neurotrophic factors in the therapy of 72. Low PA, Dotson RM. Symptomatic treatment of painful
peripheral neuropathy. Baillieres Clin Neurol. 1995;4:593– neuropathy. JAMA. 1998;280:1863–1864.
606. 73. Dejgard A, Petersen P, Kastrup J. Mexiletine for treatment
55. Nielsen FS, Voldsgaard AI, Gall M-A, et al. Apolipoprotein(a) of chronic painful diabetic neuropathy. Lancet. 1988:8575–
and cardiovascular disease in type 2 (non-insulin-depen- 8576.
dent) diabetic patients with and without diabetic nephrop- 74. Stracke H, Meyer UE, Schumacher HE, Federlin K. Mexil-
athy. Diabetologia. 1993;36:438 – 444. etine in the treatment of diabetic neuropathy. Diabetes
56. Schmitz A, Pedersen MM, Hansen KW. Blood pressure by Care. 1992;15:1550 –1555.
24 h ambulatory recordings in type 2 (non-insulin depen- 75. Oskarsson P, Ljunggren J-G, Lins P-E, the Mexiletine Study
dent) diabetics. Relationship to urinary albumin excretion. Group. Efficacy and safety of mexiletine in the treatment of
Diabetic Metab. 1991;17:301–307. painful diabetic neuropathy. Diabetes Care. 1997;20:1594 –
57. Hansen KW, Pedersen MM, Christiansen JS, Mogensen 1597.

26S August 30, 1999 THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE威 Volume 107 (2B)

Anda mungkin juga menyukai