Anda di halaman 1dari 9

RESEARCH ARTICLE

The Assessment, Benefits and Delivery of Physical


Activity in People with Schizophrenia: A Survey of
Members of the International Organization of
Physical Therapists in Mental Health
Brendon Stubbs1*, Andy Soundy2, Michel Probst3,4, Marc De Hert3, Amber De Herdt3,4,
Anne Parker5 & Davy Vancampfort3,4
1
School of Health and Social Care, University of Greenwich, Southwood Site Avery Hill Road Eltham, London SE9 2UG, UK
2
School of Health and Population Sciences, College of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Birmingham, 52 Pritchatts Road, Birmingham
B15 2TT, UK
3
KU Leuven, Department of Neurosciences, University Psychiatric Centre, B-3070 Kortenberg, Belgium
4
Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, KU Leuven, Tervuursevest 101, B-3001 Leuven, Belgium
5
Physiotherapy Department, Royal Edinburgh Hospital, Morningside Terrace, Edinburgh EH10, UK

Abstract
Background. People with schizophrenia typically die over a decade before members of the general population.
Physical activity is a low cost and effective intervention that can have a multitude of beneficial effects on people with
schizophrenia. Physical therapists lead in the delivery of physical activity in many of the commonly observed co-
morbidities in schizophrenia, yet their role in the delivery of physical activity in patients with schizophrenia remains
unclear. Objective. This study aimed to establish an international consensus on physical therapists’ beliefs, potential
benefits and practices in the use of physical activity in schizophrenia. Method. All members of the International
Organization of Physical Therapists in Mental Health were invited to take part in a cross-sectional online survey.
All data were analysed using descriptive statistics and quantitative content and/or thematic analysis. Results. One
hundred and fifty-one physical therapists from 31 countries responded. Almost all respondents (92%) felt that
physical activity benefited patients with schizophrenia, and 75.2% and 22.5%, respectively, felt that it was very
important and important that physical therapists oversee in the delivery of physical activity in psychiatric services.
Resultant themes established that physical activity has a plethora of beneficial effects on people with schizophrenia
including physical health benefits and biopsychosocial effects such as improved mental health, socialization and
quality of life. In addition, participants felt they have the necessary theoretical knowledge and clinical skills required
for leading and overseeing physical activity programmes in this complex patient group. Conclusion. Physical ther-
apists identified that physical activity has a plethora of benefits for patients with schizophrenia and that they have
the necessary knowledge and skills to lead and oversee the successful delivery of physical activity in patients with
schizophrenia in clinical practice. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Received 28 October 2013; Revised 13 February 2014; Accepted 11 March 2014

Keywords
physical activity; physical health; schizophrenia; serious mental illness

*Correspondence
Brendon Stubbs, School of Health and Social Care, University of Greenwich, Southwood Site Avery Hill Road Eltham, London SE9 2UG, UK.
E-mail: b.stubbs@greenwich.ac.uk

Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI: 10.1002/pri.1592

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia B. Stubbs et al.

Introduction
There is an alarming disparity in the physical health of international group of specialist mental health physical
people with schizophrenia compared with members of therapists.
the general population (Hoang et al., 2013; Nielsen
et al., 2013). People with schizophrenia are at an ele- Method
vated risk of a range of physical health conditions
Participants
including cardiovascular disease (CVD), obesity, cancer,
metabolic syndrome and diabetes (Cimo et al., 2012; All members of the International Organization of Phys-
Crump et al., 2013). Despite having twice as much con- ical Therapists in Mental Health (IOPTMH) (n ≈ 480)
tact with health services than members of the general were invited to take part (eligible n ≈ unknown) and
population, it has been estimated that individuals with were asked to forward the survey to other physical ther-
schizophrenia often die between 11 and 15 years prema- apy colleagues working with people with schizophre-
turely (Crump et al., 2013; Nielsen et al., 2013). nia. Ethical approval was gained from the University
Physical activity is an effective, modifiable and of Birmingham (Ref: ERN_13-0151). Participants were
low risk intervention that can improve the health of informed that taking part in the survey was voluntary
people with schizophrenia (Richardson et al., 2005; and all responses were anonymous.
Vancampfort et al., 2010). Physical activity is associated
with improved quality of life (Vancampfort et al., The questionnaire
2011), psychological well-being (Holley et al., 2011) The questions were developed with reference to the
and overall mental and physical health (Gorczynski literature (Vancampfort et al., 2010; Vancampfort
and Faulkner, 2010) in people with schizophrenia. et al., 2012a). The questionnaire included both open-
Despite this, it is apparent that very few people with ended and closed-ended questions and a section on
schizophrenia meet the recommended guidelines for demographic information and physical therapists’
physical activity (Faulkner et al., 2006; Soundy et al., perceived value, assessment and prescription of physi-
2013) and many are sedentary for prolonged periods cal activity in schizophrenia. A small pilot study was
(Janney et al., 2013). conducted (n = 4) to assess face validity and ease of
Physical therapists are in a unique position to pro- use. A copy of the final questionnaire can be obtained
vide personalized programmes of physical activity, from the corresponding author. The survey was
exercise and therapeutic movement while promoting conducted via a secure online survey tool (Qualtrics
self-efficacy and well-being in psychiatric services available at http://www.qualtrics.com/).
(Probst, 2012; Stubbs et al., 2014). Physical therapists
often lead physical activity prescription in clinical Protocol
populations (e.g. diabetes, Hansen et al., 2013, and
The survey was emailed to all members of the
CVD, Eriksson et al., 2006) and could similarly lead
IOPTMH in April 2013. A second email reminder
exercise prescription for individuals with schizophre-
encouraging non-responders to complete the survey
nia. There have been calls to incorporate physical activ-
was sent out after 2 weeks.
ity in psychiatric services for some time (Richardson
et al., 2005), yet little research has documented the
practice of physical therapists in physical activity pre- Data analysis
scription in schizophrenia. Recent work has established The quantitative data were analysed utilizing descriptive
that physical therapists have a central role within statistics with SPSS (version 20) (IBM Corp., Armonk,
psychiatric services (Stubbs et al., 2014) and are well NY). The free text qualitative responses to questions were
placed to help individuals with schizophrenia over- analysed by two different methods. First, a quantitative
come central barriers to physical activity (Soundy content analysis was undertaken (Pope and Mays, 2006)
et al., 2014). However, the current practices of physical for two questions regarding physical therapists’ current
therapists’ prescription and delivery of physical activity use of outcome measures (question 1) and exercises
are not well understood. Given this, the purpose of this (question 2). Second, a thematic analysis was utilized to
paper was to examine the beliefs and practices of an analyse the free text responses of two questions (1. physical

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
B. Stubbs et al. Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia

therapists’ views of the benefits of physical activity and 2. Table 1. Demographic, training, education and clinical
information of respondents
why physical therapists are equipped to lead in the delivery
of physical activity). Within this, the primary author be- Overall survey
came immersed in the data, coding all free text comments, respondents N (%)
and identified a thematic framework that was critiqued by
Number 151
a second author. The second author acted as a critical Age (years) 40 ± 11.2
friend and considered the emergent categories developed. Female 106 (70)
An audit trail is available from the corresponding author Continent
upon request. Indicative verbatim quotations were used Africa 4 (2.6)
Asia and Western Pacific 18 (11.9)
to illustrate the themes and subsequent categories, and
Europe 104 (68.9)
on each occasion, the physical therapists study number North America and Caribbean 24 (15.9)
(P), age, gender and country are also reported. South America 1 (0.7)
What clinical setting do you work in? π
Inpatient 111 (74)
Results Outpatient 69 (45)
Respondents Community 39 (26)
Years of mental health clinical experience 10.17 ± 9.0
One hundred and fifty-one physical therapists from 31 Received educational or clinical training for
different countries completed the survey. Most respon- treating people with mental illness at: π
dents were from Europe (68.9%; 104/151) and female University 75 (49.7)
Mental health placement 52 (34.4)
(70.0%; 106/151). The mean age of respondents was
Another placement 47 (31.1)
40 years (±11.2), and the average number of years of
Received training and/or education in: π
clinical experience in mental health was over 10 years Symptoms of schizophrenia 110 (72.8)
(±9.0). The physical therapists’ experiences of training Physical co-morbidities of schizophrenia 67 (44.4)
in mental health varied. Further details of the demo- Side effects of psychotropic medication 85 (56.2)
graphic, training and education experiences of the Would like further training in schizophrenia 119 (78.8)

physical therapists are summarized in Table 1. Key: π = participants were able to answer multiple choices to each
question, and some totals are higher than the total number of
respondents (n = 151).
Physical therapists’ views on the
importance of physical activity assessment to benefit patients with schizophrenia. Two themes
in schizophrenia emerged from the thematic analysis: 1) the physical
The overwhelming majority of respondents agreed that benefits of physical activity and 2) the biopsychosocial
physical activity helped people with schizophrenia benefits of engaging in physical activity. The thematic
(92.1%; 117/127), and three quarters (75.2%; 97/129) analysis is presented and summarized in Table 3.
believed it was very important that physical therapists
lead in prescribing and the delivery of physical activity
Theme 1: the general physical health benefits
for people with schizophrenia. Despite this, under
of physical activity
two-thirds (64.2%; 72/112) currently assessed the levels
of physical activity for people with schizophrenia, and A large number of physical therapists (n = 64) pro-
most were unaware of any guidelines to support the use vided details of the perceived physical health benefits
of physical activity in schizophrenia (69.7%; 83/119). from physical activity. Two emergent categories were
See Table 2 for a summary. apparent: first, the general physical health benefits of
physical activity and avoiding sedentary behaviour
and, second, the disease-specific benefits associated of
Physical therapists’ views on how physical
physical activity in schizophrenia.
activity helps individuals with
A range of physical health benefits were reported
schizophrenia
by physical therapists, this is highlighted by one who
One hundred and four physical therapists (68.9%) pro- reported that ‘Exercise not only promotes physical
vided a range of perceived benefits of physical activity fitness. but also … improves cardio respiratory

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia B. Stubbs et al.

Table 2. Participants use and value of physical activity for health benefits of physical activity, with common ben-
schizophrenia
efits including reduction in depression and anxiety
Overall
and improving self-esteem and even a distraction from
N (%) psychosis. For example, one remarked that physical
activity: ‘improves self-esteem, provides natural endor-
Do you think physical activity helps people with
schizophrenia? (n = 127) phin release so patient benefit from relief of depression,
Yes 117 (92.1) provides a distraction from psychosis’ (Participant 52,
Unsure 10 (7.8) Female, 23 years old, UK). Another reported that
No 0 (0)
‘Physical activity plays an important role in the regula-
Do you assess the physical activity levels of individuals with
tion of endocrine/hormonal function which directly
schizophrenia? (n = 112)
Yes 72 (64.2)
affects mental health.’ (Participant 48, Female, 29 years
No 40 (35.7) old, Namibia).
Are there any guidelines that you are aware of that support A number of physical therapists stated that im-
the use of physical activity in schizophrenia? (n = 119) proved social interactions and engagement with others
Yes 36 (30.3) was a common and welcomed consequence of group
No 83 (69.7)
physical activity in schizophrenia. For example, one
How important is it that physiotherapists prescribe physical
physical therapist reports that physical activity enables
activity for people with schizophrenia? (n = 129)
Very important 97 (75.2) the patient to be
Important 29 (22.5)
‘More relaxed, more safe, more real, not so
Neutral 3 (2.3)
Not important 0 (0) hallucinated (hearing voices), they get a break
Definitely not important 0 (0) from all their thoughts, their self-efficacy grows,
they get to meet other people in a set up without
a lot of talking.’ (Participant 89, Female, 39 years
function and mental fitness preventing physical disor-
old, Denmark).
ders that could develop from a sedentary lifestyle.’
(Participant 74, Female, 29 years old, Malta). Other Another physical therapist stated how the positive
physical therapists were able to report how physical effects of physical activity help achieve increased social-
activity was important for maintenance of the physical ization: ‘I have personally seen how physical activity
health structures and physiology, such as weight can increase individuals’ energy level, attention to task,
regulation and cardiovascular health, and how this is focus, decrease anxiety, decrease weight, improve self-
inextricably linked to quality of life. In the second esteem, and increase socialization’ (Participant 142,
category, a number of physical therapists (n = 33) made Female, 29 years old, Antarctica).
comments about the specific benefits of physical A number of physical therapists (n = 13) reported
activity to prevent common adverse conditions in that physical activity helped with increasing mindful-
schizophrenia, namely metabolic syndrome, diabetes ness and being present. For example, one stated physi-
and weight gain. cal activity helps ‘the individual to be here and now’
(Participant 103, Female, 53 years old, Sweden).
Lastly, a number of physical therapists reported that
Theme 2: the biopsychosocial benefits of
physical activity helped the patients maintain a good
engaging in physical activity
quality of life and be effective in doing their activities
Sixty-six physical therapists made comments within of daily living. One physical therapist remarked that
this theme, and four resultant categories emerged physical activity helps ‘improving quality of life,
including the benefits of physical activity on mental offering healthy coping strategies’ (Participant 10,
health, social integration and engagement, body Male, 31 years old, Belgium). Another directly linked
awareness and image and, finally, activities of daily the physical benefits from being active to an individ-
living and quality of life. See Table 3 for further ual’s ability to perform their ADL ‘it helps to maintain
details. the range of movement, balance by improving the
In summary, a number of physical therapists strength and maintain their daily living’ (Participant 79,
(n = 43) made specific comments about the mental Male, 30 years old, Malaysia).

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
B. Stubbs et al. Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia

Table 3. Themes of the perceived benefits of physical activity for patients with schizophrenia

Theme of benefits Category (n = number of


of physical activity participants commenting) Indicative quotation

1. Physical health benefits General lifestyle benefits of being ‘If physical activity is not undertaken by individuals with schizophrenia,
of physical activity active (n = 47) deconditioning in addition to side effects from psychotropic medication
can lead to significantly reduced physical health and ability. Increased
serotonin levels can improve sleep, diet, affect and also have a positive
effect on memory and learning. individuals with schizophrenia often have
poor hygiene, reduced diet and reduced levels of cognition. affect is also
dictated by disease progression and severity. Regular exercise can in turn
benefit these areas and maintain good physical health’ (Participant 4,
Female, UK)
Disease-specific physical health benefits ‘Being physically active provides great health benefits for all people, also
(e.g. metabolic syndrome, cardiovascular for patients with Schizophrenia since it reduces inactivity, obesity, and
disease, diabetes and neurotransmitter other factors that many patients striving. It can also give good mastery
effects; n = 33) experiences, participation in social relations, etc.’ (Participant 101,
Female, Norway)
‘Helps with physical health. Reducing weight gain, risk of
cardiometabolic problems, diabetes, also it is important for reducing the
risk of osteoporosis (increased risk due to antipsychotic medication) by
increased weight bearing and access to sunlight (vitamin D reducing
fracture risk)’ (Participant 151, Female, UK)
‘Many inpatients with schizophrenia put on masses of weight due to
psychotropic medication and excess eating. Physical activity is essential
to combat this and prevent cardiovascular disease and neuromuscular
deconditioning’ (Participant 35, Female, 39, USA)
2. Biopsychosocial benefits Mental health benefits (n = 43) ‘Stabilization of chemical neurotransmitters that influence mood and
of engaging in physical stress. Learn how to act with incentives like social pressure, connectivity’
activity (Participant 64, Male, Belgium)
‘Physical activity plays an important role in the regulation of endocrine/
hormonal function which directly affects mental health.’ (Participant 48,
Female, Namibia)
Social/interaction and engagement ‘Anxiety management, above and beyond the usual benefits of exercise’
benefits (n = 29) (Participant 139, Female, 57, USA)
‘(Physical activity) builds confidence/self esteem, can give meaningful
structure to their day and increases social opportunities. If they go on to join
a group, it can giver partner/ carer a break’ (Participant 68, Female, UK)
Body awareness/body image benefits ‘I have personally seen how physical activity can increase individuals’
(n = 13) energy level, attention to task, focus, decrease anxiety, decrease weight,
improve self-esteem, and increase socialization’ (Participant 142,
Female, 29, Antarctica)
Quality of life and activity of daily living ‘(physical activity helps) The body helps the individual to be here and
benefits (n = 13) now (if not doing mechanical disembodied movements, of course). It is
a good way to start experiencing the self as a context and not the content
(ones thoughts, emotions, sensations).’ (Participant 103,
physiotherapist, Sweden)
‘Improving quality of life, offering healthy coping strategies’ (Participant
10, Male, Belgium)
‘It helps to maintain the range of movement, balance by improving the
strength and maintain their daily living’ (Participant 79, Male, Malaysia)

What outcome measures do physical they use to determine physical activity levels. A wide
therapists use to assess physical activity? range of outcome measures were used, but the most
common consisted of subjective assessment/questions
Sixty-one (40.3%) physical therapists provided infor- of a patient’s current level of physical activity (but not
mation about the current types of outcome measures a validated outcome measure; n = 19, 31.4%), 6-minute

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia B. Stubbs et al.

walk test (6MWT, 26.2%; n = 19), mobility or balance ‘Physio’s are physical health specialists, whilst most
assessments such as the Berg balance scale or the others are mental health specialists and do not un-
Barthel Index (18.0%, n = 11), physiological measures derstand the physical nature of schizophrenia.
such as heart rate or VO2 max (9.8%, n = 6), body Therefore, we have to take a lead as it is not safe
awareness scales (4.9%, n = 3) or a range of other mea- for all patients to jump in at the deep end, often
sures (e.g. shuttle walk and bicycle tests, 21.3%, we have to develop graded exercise programmes.’
n = 13). Only six physical therapists (9.8%) utilized a (Participant 1, Male, 32 years old, UK).
valid instrument to measure physical activity including
the International Physical Activity Questionnaire. Others stated that it is important to utilize their special-
ist knowledge to adapt the physical activities to the
individual ‘Physiotherapists are the experts in move-
What types of physical activity do you
ment and are medically based, so they are familiar with
prescribe?
any co-morbidities with the schizophrenic patient and
One hundred and six physical therapists (70.2%) pro- how to modify activities.’ (Participant 135, Female,
vided details of the types and/or frequency and inten- 50 years old, USA).
sity of exercise that they prescribed. The most
common activity recommended was walking (34%, Theme 2: patients with schizophrenia are a
n = 36), and many advocated that this should be en- complex group
couraged in all patients with schizophrenia stipulating
that a 30-minute walk five times a week is beneficial. A number of participants (n = 22) stated that
A number of other aerobic exercises were also advo- physical therapists should lead on the prescription of
cated including general cardiovascular exercises (31%, physical activity in patients with schizophrenia because
n = 33) with circuit training, running, cycling and aero- they represent a complex group at risk of a range of
bics commonly being reported. Twenty-two physical multi-morbidities. This is exemplified by one partici-
therapists (20.7%) recommended team sports such as pant who remarked
soccer, basketball and racket sports, whereas 20
‘This is a complex group, you wouldn’t go and take
(18.8%) also developed specific exercises for patients
a non-mental health patient group that were
to complete using weights in a gymnasium. In addition,
overweight, diabetics, at risk of a heart attack and
31 (29.2%) physical therapists encouraged mind–body
let them start exercising without an assessment.’
interventions such as body awareness therapy, relaxa-
(Participant 111, Female, 38 years old, Republic
tion classes, tai chi and yoga.
of Ireland).

Why is it important that physical


Discussion
therapists prescribe exercise to people
with schizophrenia? Our findings demonstrate that physical therapists
recognize that physical activity can have a range of
Thirty-four physical therapists provided a range of rea-
beneficial effects on the physical and mental health
sons why physical therapists should lead and oversee
of people with schizophrenia in addition to improve-
the delivery of physical activity in people with schizo-
ments in quality of life. Physical therapists also
phrenia, and two themes emerged from the data. These
identified that a ‘one size fits all’ approach to prescrib-
are summarized in Table 4 and will briefly be explored.
ing physical activity in this patient group is not
recommended because of the complex interactions
Theme 1: physical therapists have specialist
between intrapersonal, interpersonal and environ-
knowledge and training
mental and policy-related barriers. Three quarters of
Participants commonly reported that physical thera- the respondents felt that it was very important that
pists had a diverse range of specialist knowledge re- physical therapists oversee the prescription of physical
quired to be optimally placed to develop and deliver activity in psychiatric services. Reasons for this
physical activity programs in patients with schizophre- included the fact that physical therapists have the
nia. This is summed up well by one participant: specialist training and knowledge and have a great

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
B. Stubbs et al. Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia

Table 4. Themes why physiotherapists should prescribe physical activity in schizophrenia

Theme (n = number of physiotherapists


commenting on the theme) Indicative quotation

1. Physiotherapists have specialist ‘PTs are most likely to have a clinical understanding of all the person’s diagnoses as they relate to exercise.’
knowledge and training (n = 26) (Participant 139, Female, 57, USA)
‘Physiotherapists are the experts in movement and are medically based, so they are familiar with any
co-morbidities the schizophrenic patient may have and how to modify activities.’ (Participant 135,
Female, 50, USA)
‘Physio’s are physical health specialists working in mental health teams, whilst most other members are
mental health specialists through training and do not understand the physical nature of schizophrenia.
Therefore, we have to take a lead as it is not safe for all patients to jump in at the deep end, often we have
to develop graded exercise programmes the same way you would within a cardiac rehabilitation
programme for instance.’ (Participant 1, Male 32, UK)
‘Physiotherapists are in the best position to prescribe physical activity. It is important the they have a full
understanding of the condition and the physical and mental connections. Also to be in a position to
understand resistance, non compliance and he presenting features demonstrated by the patient. It is very
important for physical activity to be prescribed so that quality of life can be improved. patients
demonstrate poor self care and knowledge of physical and mental health benefits of activity. The
physiotherapist can develop a positive therapeutic relationship with the patient and encourage
motivation.’ (Participant 129, Female, 49, UK)
‘As we are trained to look and understand all areas of the body and use this knowledge to treat the whole
person’ (Participant 149, Female, UK)
‘physiotherapists are physical health experts in the clinical team, we have an awareness of the physical
needs of the population.’ (Participant 91, Male, 37, UK)
‘Physio should lead with developing exercise as most other professionals in Mdt (multidisciplinary team)
are mental health specialists not well versed in physical health’ (Participant 46, Female, 48, UK)
2. Patients with schizophrenia ‘The prescription of exercise is much more complex than in the general population due to the high
are a complex group (n = 22) comorbidity and risk of mortality e.g. cardiometabolic manifestations of the illness including obesity.
Physio’s lead in exercise prescription in CVD, diabetes, arthritis etc so we should also lead in this condition
where the typical physical presentation is very complex. Physio’s are experts in physical health and ideally
placed to lead in safe prescription of exercise in this group therefore.’ (Participant 151, Female, 39, UK)
‘This is a complex group, you wouldn’t go and take a non mental health patient group that were
overweight, diabetics, at risk of diabetes and let them start exercising without an assessment. Due to
complex presentation, we should lead’ (Participant 111, Female, 38, Republic of Ireland)
‘People with schizophrenia have suboptimal physical health, more likely to have CVD, diabetes mellitus,
metabolic syndrome. The prescription of exercise is not straight forward and physios should lead with this’
(Participant 109, Female, 39, UK)
‘With an increased risk of metabolic syndrome, CHD, diabetes, osteoporosis,, respiratory conditions,
deconditioning - we can lead on the assessment and intervention. Exercise prescription is not straight
forward in this population to develop a blanket rule’ (Participant 91, Male, 37, UK)
‘Many patients are grossly overweight, reduced respiratory and cardiovascular health ….With our
expansive knowledge we have to take the lead in particular when patients are very overweight.’ (Participant 1,
Male, 32, UK)

understanding in the barriers encountered by this Clinical implications


population (Soundy et al., 2014). Our findings
suggest that physical therapists have the theoretical Physical therapists have an important role in the
knowledge and clinical experience to oversee and lead multidisciplinary treatment of patients with schizo-
in the delivery of physical activity programmes in phrenia (Vancampfort et al., 2012a, 2012b). Physical
psychiatric services. However, it is surprising that therapists in the present study reported that physical
most (64.2%) physical therapists do not currently activity represents a valuable intervention that has a
assess the levels of physical activity in patients they range of benefits for people with schizophrenia.
work with and that over two-thirds (69.7%) are Although it is the task of all members of the
unaware of any guidelines that support the use of multidisciplinary team (MDT) to promote healthier
physical activity in schizophrenia. lifestyle choices, including the promotion of physical

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia B. Stubbs et al.

activity, physical therapists are ideally placed to oversee interventions on the health and well-being of people
the successful implementation of this in clinical prac- with schizophrenia, and this should be delivered
tice (Stubbs et al., 2014). Physical therapists should ad- through randomised controlled trials. This would help
vise other members of the MDT on the frequency, consolidate the evidence base and necessity of physical
types and intensity of physical activity that is suitable therapy in psychiatric services. Particular physical ther-
for people with schizophrenia on an individual level. apy interventions may choose to focus on the use of
The commencement and continuation of a physically cognitive–behavioural and motivational interviewing
active lifestyle is complex in people with schizophrenia, techniques, which have been demonstrated to be effec-
and careful support for an individual’s motivation and tive in individuals with high risk of CVD (Hardcastle
self-efficacy is known to be important (Vancampfort et et al., 2013). Further research should also explore the
al 2013, Soundy et al., 2014). The IOPTMH recently effects of physical activity on mental health, physical
published physical activity guidelines for patients with health and quality of life when the current evidence-
schizophrenia (Vancampfort et al., 2012a). However, based physical activity guidelines (Vancampfort et al.,
more than two-thirds of the physical therapists in the 2012a) are adopted in state and local government
current study were not aware of these guidelines. Dis- departments. This work should consider the benefits
semination of the current physical activity guidelines of such interventions on weight reduction and the risk
for patients with schizophrenia therefore is needed, of cardiometabolic risk factors and also on quality of
and IOPTMH is committed to working with the na- life and mental health measures.
tional organizations to help ensure this happens.
Strengths of this study include the large number of
countries represented (31 in total), the plethora of clin-
Conclusion
ical experience by respondents (mean 10 years) and the This international survey of specialist mental health
fact that all respondents were specialists in mental physical therapists established that physical therapists
health. There are however a number of limitations to are ideally placed to lead and oversee in the delivery
our study. First, it is not possible to establish an exact of physical activity for people with schizophrenia.
response rate because the survey was sent to a large Respondents stated that physical activity can have a
number of IOPTMH members (≈480), and the exact range of benefits for people with schizophrenia and
number of those who are working with people with physical therapists have the necessary skills to ensure
schizophrenia and were eligible to take part is not the successful implementation of physical activity in
known. In addition, IOPTMH members were encour- people with schizophrenia.
aged to pass the survey on to colleagues working with
people with schizophrenia, yet we have no way to es-
tablish if any did so or if any of the respondents were
Conflict of interest
recruited this way. This means that there is likely to One of the authors is the president of the IOPTMH.
be a high social desirability bias in the respondents to
our survey, with members who were not working with
REFERENCES
patient with schizophrenia much less likely to respond
to our survey. In addition, the survey was only sent out Cimo A, Stergiopoulos E, Cheng C, Bonato S, Dewa CS.
in English, and it is possible that a number of non- Effective lifestyle interventions to improve type II diabe-
English-speaking members of the IOPTMH may not tes self-management for those with schizophrenia or
have been able to respond to our survey. However, in schizoaffective disorder: a systematic review. BMC
Psychiatry 2012; 12: 24.
an attempt to negate this, we offered help with
Crump C, Winkleby MA, Sundquist K, Sundquist J.
translation in other languages known to the research
Comorbidities and mortality in persons with schizo-
team (Dutch, French, German and Spanish).
phrenia: a Swedish national cohort study. The American
Journal of Psychiatry 2013; 170(3): 324–333.
Eriksson KM, Westborg CJ, Eliasson MC. A randomized
Future research
trial of lifestyle intervention in primary healthcare for
Future research is urgently required to establish the the modification of cardiovascular risk factors. Scandi-
value and efficacy of physical therapy delivered navian Journal of Public Health 2006; 34(5): 453–461.

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
B. Stubbs et al. Physiotherapy in Schizophrenia

Faulkner G, Cohn T, Remington G. Validation of a physical Stubbs B, Soundy A, Probst M, De Hert M, De Herdt A,
activity assessment tool for individuals with schizophre- Vancampfort D. Understanding the role of physiother-
nia. Schizophrenia Research 2006; 82(2-3): 225–231. apists in schizophrenia: an international perspective
Gorczynski P, Faulkner G. Exercise therapy for schizophrenia. from members of the International Organisation of
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2010; 12(5): Art. Physical Therapists in Mental Health (IOPTMH). Journal
No. CD004412. DOI:10.1002/14651858.CD004412.pub2. of Mental Health 2014. [Epub ahead of print]
Hansen D, Peeters S, Zwaenepoel B, Verleyen D, Soundy A, Wampers M, Probst M, De Hert M, Stubbs B,
Wittebrood C, Timmerman N, Schotte M. Exercise Vancampfort D. Physical activity and sedentary behaviour
assessment and prescription in patients with type 2 in outpatients with schizophrenia: a systematic review and
diabetes in the private and home care setting: clinical meta-analysis. International Journal of Therapy and
recommendations from AXXON (Belgian Physical Ther- Rehabilitation 2013; 20(12): 588–596.
apy Association). Physical Therapy 2013; 93(5): 597–610. Soundy A, Stubbs B, Probst M, Hemmings L,
Hardcastle SJ, Taylor AH, Bailey MP, Harley RA, Vancampfort D. Barriers to and Facilitators of Physical
Hagger MS. Effectiveness of a motivational interviewing Activity Among Persons With Schizophrenia: A
intervention on weight loss, physical activity and cardio- Survey of Physical Therapists. Psychiatric Serv. 2014;
vascular disease risk factors: a randomised controlled trial DOI:10.1176/appi.ps.201300276. [Epub ahead of print]
with a 12-month post-intervention follow-up. Interna- Vancampfort D, Knapen J, Probst M, van Winkel R,
tional Journal of Behaviour Nutrition and Physical Deckx S, Maurissen K, Peuskens J, De Hert M. Consid-
Activity 2013; 10: 40. ering a frame of reference for physical activity research
Hoang U, Goldacre MJ, Stewart R. Avoidable mortality in related to the cardiometabolic risk profile in schizo-
people with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder in phrenia. Psychiatry Research 2010; 177(3): 271–279.
England. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. 2013; 127(3): Vancampfort D, Probst M, Sweers K, Maurissen K,
195–201. Knapen J, De Hert M. Relationship between obesity,
Holley J, Crone D, Tyson P, Lovell G. The effects of phys- functional exercise capacity, physical activity participa-
ical activity on psychological well-being for those with tion and physical self-perception in people with schizo-
schizophrenia: a systematic review. British Journal of phrenia. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2011; 123(6):
Clinical Psychology 2011; 50(1): 84–105. 423–430.
Janney CA, Ganguli R, Richardson CR, Holleman RG, Tang Vancampfort D, Probst M, Skjaerven L, Catalán-Matamoros D,
G, Cauley JA, Kriska AM. Sedentary behavior and psychi- Lundvik-Gyllensten A, Gómez-Conesa A, Ijntema R,
atric symptoms in overweight and obese adults with De Hert M. Systematic review of the benefits of physical
schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorders (WAIST therapy within a multidisciplinary care approach for
Study). Schizophrenia Research 2013; 145(1-3): 63–68. people with schizophrenia. Physical Therapy 2012a;
Nielsen RE, Uggerby AS, Jensen SO, McGrath JJ. Increasing 92(1): 11–23.
mortality gap for patients diagnosed with schizophrenia Vancampfort D, De Hert M, Skjaerven L, Gyllensten A,
over the last three decades — a Danish nationwide Parker A, Mulders N, Nyboe L, Spenser F, Probst M.
study from 1980 to 2010. Schizophrenia Research International Organization of Physical Therapy in
2013; 146(1-3): 22–27. Mental Health consensus on physical activity within
Probst M. The International Organization of Physical multidisciplinary rehabilitation programmes for
Therapists working in Mental Health. Mental Health minimising cardio-metabolic risk in patients with
and Physical Activity 2012; 5: 20–21. schizophrenia. Disability and Rehabilitation 2012b;
Pope C, Mays N. Qualitative research in health care. BMJ 34(1): 1–12.
Publications: London, 2006. Vancampfort D, De Hert M, Vansteenkiste M, De Herdt A,
Richardson CR, Faulkner G, McDevitt J, Skrinar GS, Scheewe T, Soundy A, Stubbs B, Probst M. The impor-
Hutchinson DS, Piette JD. Integrating physical activity tance of self-determined motivation towards physical
into mental health services for persons with serious activity in patients with schizophrenia. Psychiatry
mental illness. Psychiatric Services 2005; 56(3): 324–331. Research 2013; 210(3): 812–818.

Physiother. Res. Int. (2014) © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Anda mungkin juga menyukai