To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
* * * * * TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2017 ~ VOL. CCLXX NO. 121 WSJ.com HHHH $4.00
DJIA 23430.33 À 72.09 0.3% NASDAQ 6790.71 À 0.1% STOXX 600 386.39 À 0.7% 10-YR. TREAS. g 5/32 , yield 2.370% OIL $56.09 g $0.46 GOLD $1,274.60 g $21.20 EURO $1.1733 YEN 112.62
Heard on Street.. B13 U.S. News............. A2-6 and revived of Thanksgiving capon coiled at the
Life & Arts....... A11-13 Weather................... A11
Markets............. B12-13 World News........ A7-9
late by the “extra torture”
popular drama “Game of the castrated bird endured to
>
Thrones.”
Inspired by the fantasy se-
make it more plump and juicy.
“There’s something about
IN BRITAIN’S CHARLIE ROSE CHARITIES
ries, Ms. Ni served capon at the male side of you that ‘DARKEST HIT BY SEX WILL SURVIVE
Thanksgiving a couple of just…you relate to it a little
years ago. She kept the bird’s bit more,” he says. He decided
HOUR’ ALLEGATIONS TAX REFORM
s Copyright 2017 Dow Jones &
secret from guests, she says, to never eat capon again.
Company. All Rights Reserved to sidestep any awkwardness Not long after, the couple LIFE & ARTS, A13 BUSINESS & FINANCE, B1 OPINION, A17
over the practice. Answering Please see CAPONS page A10
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A2 | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
A Check on Court Picks Falls Away
BY JOE PALAZZOLO perts said. fied”—ratings Republicans on
AND ASHBY JONES Getting rid of these checks the Senate Judiciary Commit-
could foment distrust in tee dismissed as the product of
The Republican head of the judges’ work if Mr. Trump and what they called a liberal ad-
Senate Judiciary Committee later presidents prioritize ide- vocacy group.
has curtailed one of the last ology over experience or legal The ABA has rejected that
legislative limits on a presi- talent, some experts said. criticism, saying it has rated
dent’s power to shape the fed- “When judges lose legiti- potential judges for more than
eral courts, giving Donald macy in the public eye, they 60 years.
Trump more freedom than any lose the ability to enforce un- Hogan Gidley, a White
U.S. president in modern times popular decisions,” said Arthur House spokesman, said Mr.
to install his judges of choice, Hellman, an expert on the fed- Trump has nominated “highly
legal experts said. eral judiciary and law profes- qualified judges.”
Last week, Sen. Chuck sor at the University of Pitts- Mr. Grassley said that after
Grassley (R., Iowa) reined in a burgh. “And that’s when you his recent move, a negative
tradition that empowered sen- see an unraveling in the rule of blue slip would be a “signifi-
ators to block federal appeals- law.” cant factor” for the committee
court nominees from their Others said the changes to consider but wouldn’t pre-
home state. His decision came were part of a natural progres- vent a hearing, a break with
about four years after Demo- sion away from Senate tradi- the practice of Senate Judi-
crats, citing Republican filibus- tions that allowed the minority ciary Committee chairmen
ters of President Barack party to stall nominations for since at least 2005.
Obama’s circuit court nomi- partisan reasons. He blamed the Democrats
nees, eliminated a Senate rule “If you’re not a fan of the for abusing the blue slip after
that required the majority Senate-wide filibuster, you’re including Brett Talley, a Jus- eschewing the filibuster.
party to mount 60 votes to ad- probably not a fan of a filibus- tice Department lawyer who The median time from nom-
vance a nominee to a confir- ter by one senator,” said Ilya has never argued a motion in ination to Senate confirmation
mation vote. Shapiro, a senior fellow in con- federal court and whose wife for circuit court nominees was
Together, the threat of a fil- stitutional studies at the Cato is the chief of staff for the top less than a month in the ad-
ibuster and the use of “blue Institute, referring to the prac- White House lawyer. ministrations of Lyndon John-
slips”—so-named because sen- tice of senators blocking nomi- The White House declined son and Richard Nixon, said
ators indicate support or op- nees from their states. to address criticisms of Mr. Russell Wheeler, a visiting fel-
position to nominees on blue So far, the GOP-controlled Talley. low at the Brookings Institu-
slips of paper—guarded Senate Judiciary Committee The ABA’s Standing Com- tion who studies federal
against lifetime appointments has approved two nominees mittee on the Federal Judi- courts. That number ballooned
for nominees deemed far out- pronounced unfit to serve by ciary has deemed two other to 229 days during Barack
side the mainstream, court ex- the American Bar Association, Trump nominees “not quali- Obama’s two terms, he said.
CELEBRITY: One of the two gobblers that made the rounds Monday before the presidential Thanksgiving pardoning ceremony on Tuesday.
U.S. NEWS
©T&CO. 2017
NATI HARNIK/ASSOCIATED PRESS
The extended Keystone XL pipeline would connect to the Keystone Steele City pumping station in Steele City, Neb., shown in 2015.
Haitian Migrants
Lose Protections
BY ALICIA A. CALDWELL the country. A senior adminis-
AND ARIAN CAMPO-FLORES tration official on Monday
cited the stability of the local
LOS ANGELES—The Trump government and the departure
ASSOCIATED PRESS
U.S. NEWS
D
of ideas and models” playing while solidifying his vision of guard, to protect the coun- ald Trump was the candidate emographic trends
By Gerald F. Seib out on the world stage. Both an economy built on big and try’s leaders from unspecified they wanted to help win, he also are straining the
Russia and China are holding strong state-owned enter- threats, and has just proposed says. Throughout, though, American model. Be-
up what Mr. Burns calls their prises. He also declared that increasing its power. That the Kremlin had a broader cause of the way the Elec-
J
ust over a year has “authoritarian managed eco- he intends for the resulting sounds like a kind of modern- goal: weaken the image of toral College works, two of
passed since Election Day nomic models” as alterna- economic strength to make day Praetorian Guard. the U.S. by using covert so- the past three presidents
2016, and a special coun- tives to democracy. China a “great power” at the cial-media campaigns to first won office while losing
A
sel plus three congressional Moreover, to the extent center of international affairs. t the same time he is stoke social and cultural divi- the popular vote. And David
committees continue to strug- that the U.S. itself sometimes Implicitly, at least, Mr. Xi thwarting democratic sions and make democracy Birdsell, dean of the school of
gle to figure out whether Rus- seems not to take its own also is creating an authoritar- trends at home, Mr. Pu- look messy and unstable. public and international af-
sia colluded democratic ideals seriously, ian model for others to follow. tin seems determined to dis- The U.S.: His critics fairs at Baruch College, notes
with the or fails to make them work “What’s interesting to me, at credit the Western democratic charge that Mr. Trump ex- that by 2040, about 70% of
Trump cam- well, it can actually help least, is the extent to which model on the world stage. His hibits some authoritarian Americans are expected to
paign to help erode the appeal of a system Xi, in ways I can’t remember intelligence services appear to tendencies of his own, and live in the 15 largest states.
tip that elec- that has long served as an in the last 40 years or so, is have meddled in elections in, his occasional disparaging They will have only 30 sena-
tion. international beacon of hope. holding up the Chinese model among others, France, Britain remarks about “rigged” dem- tors representing them, while
That is a In short, the democratic as an example,” says Mr. and Montenegro, and engaged ocratic institutions seem to the remaining 30% of Ameri-
hugely important question, of model is under threat on Burns. That has particular im- in campaigns to sow discord suggest that. The fact is, cans will have 70 senators
course. But the danger in fo- three fronts. Let’s look at portance in Asia, where other in political systems elsewhere. though, that the American representing them.
cusing on it too much is that them in turn: nations watch China closely. Clint Watts, a former Fed- system of checks and bal- That is the way the sys-
the country could lose sight China: President Xi Jinping Russia: President Vladimir eral Bureau of Investigation ances—a hallmark of the tem works, of course. But
of a broader and more perni- used a recent Communist Putin is busy dismantling no- counterterrorism expert now democratic model—remains there will be a growing need
cious reality: Whatever Rus- Party congress to cement his tions of real democracy in at George Washington Univer- strong and vibrant. for enlightened leaders who
sia did last year amounted to own power, reduce the poten- Russia. He’s widely expected sity, says Russia began insert- Yet there are reasons to can demonstrate that it
an attack on American de- tial for internal challenges to seek and win a fourth six- ing itself into the American worry about the health of works for all.
Sexual-Abuse Judge
Blocks
Battle Comes Sanctuary
To Statehouses City Order
BY NOUR MALAS under the rug, according to
lawmakers and current and BY ALICIA A. CALDWELL
As the outcry against sexual former legislative staff, both
misconduct ripples from Holly- men and women, in several A federal judge in San Fran-
wood to corporations to Wash- states. cisco has found that President
RICH PEDRONCELLI/ASSOCIATED PRESS
ington, D.C., it also is growing “A lot of this is uncharted Donald Trump’s executive or-
in a realm long plagued by territory for everybody,” said der barring some federal grant
such behavior—state capitals. Oregon state Sen. Sara Gelser, money from being awarded to
Allegations of sexual harass- who last week filed a formal “sanctuary cities” is unconsti-
ment or sexual misconduct by complaint against a colleague, tutional.
state lawmakers have surfaced Sen. Jeff Kruse. Ms. Gelser, a Santa Clara County, Calif.,
in at least a dozen states, Democrat, alleges that Mr. and the city and county of San
prompting investigations, Kruse, a Republican, touched Francisco sued the administra-
changes in reporting and in- her inappropriately for years tion in February, arguing that
vestigation protocols, and new and that 15 other women have the federal government
or improved employee train- made similar allegations, ac- Republican Assemblywoman Melissa Melendez, a member of the California Legislative Women’s couldn’t block federal funding
ing. At least seven lawmakers cording to the complaint. Mr. Caucus, has pushed for legislation to protect those who come forward to allege sexual misconduct. to cities and other jurisdic-
face interim or partial suspen- Kruse has denied any inappro- tions with policies in place to
sions from committees or lead- priate touching. Ms. Gelser protect immigrants who are in
ership posts. had earlier reported her Second Franken against the Minnesota Democrat. ture. I feel badly that Ms. Menz the country illegally.
Reports and allegations of claims informally to the State The allegation, by Lindsay came away from our interaction U.S. District Judge William
abusive workplace behavior Senate, and Mr. Kruse was re- Accuser Speaks Out Menz is the first accusation of feeling disrespected.” H. Orrick on Monday issued a
have dominated headlines, and moved from committee assign- improper touching by Mr. Fran- Last week, Leeann Tweeden, a permanent, nationwide injunc-
awareness of the problem is ments. “We don’t have a pro- ken after he became a sena- radio host, said Mr. Franken kissed tion blocking the administra-
growing while tolerance is cess that works quickly when A woman said U.S. Sen. Al tor. Mr. Franken told CNN, which her against her will at a 2006 re- tion from denying the grant
wearing thin. Yet in U.S. state- we have a pervasive problem,” Franken grabbed her buttock while first reported the accusation hearsal and posed for a photo in money to jurisdictions the U.S.
houses, where dozens of said Ms. Gelser, who is seeking taking a photo with her at the Monday, that he takes “thou- which he appeared to grope her Justice Department says aren’t
women have recently alleged his expulsion. Minnesota State Fair in 2010, the sands of photos...and I certainly while she slept. Mr. Franken apol- complying with a law that
misconduct by male col- State legislatures from Cali- second allegation of misconduct don’t remember taking this pic- ogized. —Natalie Andrews governs communications
leagues, corrective responses fornia to Rhode Island have about immigration status.
have been patchy. been struggling with claims “This is a clear rebuke of
Accused lawmakers have re- of sexual harassment or mis- tempts have been largely un- gathered more than 300 signa- tions of misconduct. the Trump administration’s il-
sisted calls to relinquish their conduct. Although no state successful, according to a Na- tures. The letter quickly Mr. Mendoza denies the al- legal effort to take away fed-
elected seats, and many legis- lawmaker has been expelled, tional Conference of State prompted a review of the legis- legations and said he is com- eral funding,” said James R.
lative leaders face criticism some face calls from colleagues Legislatures overview. lature’s policies and practices. mitted to cooperating with the Williams, Santa Clara County
over how they have dealt with and leaders to resign. Workplace misconduct in On Friday, California’s State investigative process. counsel.
allegations. Most legislatures have pro- state legislatures burst into Senate leader moved to sus- The California Senate Rules A Justice Department
The range of reactions high- cedures that can lead to expul- open view last month in Sacra- pend Democratic Sen. Tony Committee will meet in an spokesman said the adminis-
lights how unaccustomed state sion. In a minority of states, mento, Calif., where a letter Mendoza from his leadership emergency session later this tration disagreed with the rul-
legislatures are to acting on a voters can attempt removal describing endemic sexual ha- roles pending an investigation month to consider the suspen- ing and that the court had ex-
problem that was once swept with a recall petition. Such at- rassment in the state capital by an outside firm into allega- sions. ceeded its authority.
A
WEALTH OF
OPPORTUNITIES
When you come to Fidelity, you get a dedicated advisor who gives you straightforward
advice with the goal of helping you grow and protect your wealth. We can:
Help you invest and plan for your full financial picture
at the 2018
day Cup access, a private Louvre tour and much more.
Ryder Cup
© 2017 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ6059
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | A7
WORLD NEWS
Merkel Weighs Options After Talks Fail
German chancellor tory in September's election
Holding Pattern left it needing to form a coali-
vows to stay in office Support for Germany's main tion to govern. In the early
amid coalition setback, parties has remained stable hours of Monday, the small
since the election, suggesting pro-business Free Democratic
looks at new elections a new vote would fail to break Party broke off talks with her
the political deadlock. conservative camp and the
BY ANDREA THOMAS Nov. 15 poll center-left Greens, saying the
Christian Democrats* negotiations had failed to
BERLIN—German Chancel- bring the parties together.
lor Angela Merkel weighed the Social Democrats Investors initially sold the
prospect of new elections after Sept. euro and German stocks on the
election
the collapse of talks to form a news, although markets later
new government posed a Alternative for Germany recovered and German stocks
threat to her leadership and ended the day with gains.
raised doubts about the politi- Free Democrats Ms. Merkel and her party
cal stability of the European have signaled strong reserva-
Union’s most powerful country. tions about Mr. Macron’s plans
The chancellor on Monday The Left to revamp the eurozone—
dismissed suggestions she which include a call for a com-
would step down and said she Greens mon budget for countries that
AXEL SCHMIDT/REUTERS
WORLD NEWS
Black Sea resort city of Sochi. semiautonomous Kurdish re- Mr. Bakir said he was
The conference is something of gion, a top Kurdish official said scheduled to meet with na-
a victory lap for the Russian Monday. tional security adviser H.R. Mc-
president, who intervened in Falah Mustafa Bakir, the Master on Tuesday. A repre-
Syria in the fall of 2015, provid- head of foreign relations for sentative of the Iraqi
ing air power to prop up the Iraqi Kurdistan, told The Wall government declined to com-
regime of President Bashar al- Street Journal that he has ap- ment. The U.S. said it is weigh-
Assad and reversing the tide of proached U.S. officials with a ing the Kurdish request.
the multisided civil war. request for the Americans to The Iraqi Supreme Court on
With Islamic State nearing do more to address friction be- Monday ruled the referendum
defeat, political observers say tween Baghdad and the Kurd- vote unconstitutional.
the three leaders now have a Foreign ministers Sergei Lavrov of Russia, Mevlut Cavusoglu of Turkey and Javad Zarif of Iran ish government in Erbil. —Ben Kesling
chance to hash out what a post- meeting in Antalya, Turkey, on Sunday, ahead of a planned leaders’ summit in Sochi this week.
conflict Syria might look like.
Dmitri Trenin, director of facto theirs in February 1945.” Tehran, Ankara and Moscow over its military mission in Syrian territory and airspace struction efforts, and the U.S.
the Carnegie Moscow Center, Moscow and Tehran are al- meanwhile have supported the Syria, which includes an air above it,” Russian Foreign Min- and the West oppose delivering
said the Sochi meeting carries lies in Syria, with Iran provid- so-called Astana process in re- campaign against Islamic State istry spokeswoman Maria aid to the Assad regime.
echoes of the February 1945 ing advisers and foot soldiers cent months that has led to and the deployment of hun- Zakharova said Thursday. The U.S. position “continues
Yalta Conference, which helped to support Mr. Assad’s troops. the creation of “de-escalation” dreds of ground troops. The clear outlines of a defin- to be that we see no long-term
shape the post-World War II While Ankara supported rebel zones in parts of Syria. A new round of U.N.-bro- itive political settlement remain role for the Assad family or
order. “The similarity lies in groups seeking to oust Mr. “Turkey, Russia and Iran kered talks on Syria is set to be- elusive, particularly over the the Assad regime,“ Secretary
Russia and its current allies Assad—and Russia and Turkey have reached the point where gin in Geneva on Nov. 28. Ahead future of Mr. Assad. The U.S. of State Rex Tillerson said last
having achieved a military vic- edged toward open confronta- we have a common view” on of that, the Russian position is has backed the U.N.-supervised month, adding: “We’ve cer-
tory and setting about organiz- tion after Turkish F-16s shot Syria, Mr. Erdogan said Friday. clear: When Islamic State is fi- peace talks, amid concerns that tainly made it clear in our dis-
ing peace where there used to down a Russian warplane in No- Mr. Putin’s moves come as nally defeated, it wants the U.S. Russia wants to draw momen- cussions with Russia.”
be a battlefield,” he said. “The vember 2015—Messrs. Erdogan the U.S. and Russia search for out. “In our understanding, this tum away from the Geneva pro- —David Gauthier-Villars
dissimilarity is that Russia and and Putin have mended fences common ground on resolving means that immediately after cess. But international officials in Istanbul and
its allies are nowhere near the since the July 2016 coup attempt the Syria crisis. The Russians the liquidation of the terrorist also say Russia will be unable Asa Fitch in Dubai
total victory which was de against the Turkish leader. are at odds with Washington base...Americans must leave to foot the bill for major recon- contributed to this article.
has helped draft U.S. sanctions murderous. ate Foreign Relations Commit- and Syria, because of Pyong-
against North Korea. North Korea “must end its tee, said the move “does noth- yang’s roles in the attempted
Robert King, who served as unlawful nuclear and ballistic ing to hold Pyongyang assassination of the South Ko-
a U.S. special envoy on North missile development” and end accountable for its nuclear or rean president during a visit to
Korean human rights in the its support for international ballistic missile programs” and Myanmar and the bombing of a
Democratic administration of terrorism, the GOP president he urged Mr. Trump to insti- Korean Air jet liner during the
former President Barack said. tute additional targeted sanc- 1980s.
Obama, said Pyongyang is North Korea was on the list tions. Otto Warmbier arrived back in the U.S. from North Korea in June. Months before he left office,
likely to regard the move as a of state sponsors of terrorism Some experts wondered if Mr. Bush removed North Korea
direct affront. North Korea has for two decades before the the designation would have an tional hurdle for normalizing tighten the pressure on the from the list and unveiled a
protested previous efforts by GOP administration of then- effect on North Korea’s behav- relations with the United Kim regime all with an inten- package of humanitarian aid,
the U.S. to sanction Mr. Kim President George W. Bush re- ior—and if so, whether it States.” tion to have him understand inducements that were framed
personally and to label the moved it in 2008 to spur might push Pyongyang toward On Monday, Mr. Tillerson this is only going to get worse as part of a deal to get North
country’s leadership as viola- Pyongyang to give up its nu- a more bellicose posture. said the U.S. isn’t out of diplo- until you are ready to come Korea to give up its nuclear
tors of human rights, calling clear weapons program. “Re-designation is unlikely matic options, but would con- and talk,” he said. weapons.
them acts of war. The redesignation had been to change North Korean behav- tinue to apply pressure to Daniel Russel, who was the North Korea has continued
Officials with North Korea’s signaled by officials ahead of a ior or pressure the regime to North Korea until Pyongyang top diplomat for Asia at the to defy international norms.
United Nations mission trip across Asia that Mr. return to the negotiating table, comes to the negotiating table. State Department and is now Since 2008, it has conducted
couldn’t be reached for com- Trump finished a week ago and at least in the short run,” said He cited recent moves by Ma- at the Asia Society Policy Insti- five nuclear tests and launched
ment on Monday. found quick support Monday Andrew Yeo, a politics profes- laysia, the Philippines, Singa- tute, said the U.S. could use the scores of missiles, while
Officials in Mr. Trump’s ad- among Republican lawmakers. sor at Catholic University of pore and Sudan to curtail trade designation as an incentive in threatening to destroy its
ministration have referred to Rep. Ed Royce (R., Calif.), America in Washington. “In with Pyongyang as evidence of later negotiations. neighbors and the U.S.
Pyongyang’s alleged role in the chairman of the House Foreign fact, it actually closes another the success of the Trump ad- “It’s not unimaginable that —Louise Radnofsky
poisoning death of Kim Jong Affairs Committee, said it door towards diplomatic en- ministration effort. some of the thinking at work and Michael C. Bender
Un’s half-brother in Kuala “rightly exposes the Kim re- gagement by creating an addi- “This just continues to here was we’re better off im- contributed to this article.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * NY Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | A9
ARGENTINE PRESIDENCY/REUTERS
North in 1986 and became a sion arrested one of the coun- Argentina’s naval spokes-
senior official in the Pyongyang try’s most powerful politicians, man Enrique Balbin said the
government. who for weeks evaded question- search for the aging subma-
—Andrew Jeong ing over his alleged role in the rine had entered a “critical
theft of $170 million of public phase” because the vessel
AFGHANISTAN money. could only hold enough oxy-
Attempts to question Setya gen to keep crew alive for
Airstrikes Target Novanto, speaker of Indonesia’s seven days. Authorities last
Opium Production House of Representatives, took heard from the submarine on
an unexpected twist late last Wednesday as it was on its Argentina's President Mauricio Macri speaks to relatives of the missing submarine’s crew members.
U.S. and Afghan forces week when he was involved in a return voyage from the south-
launched a series of airstrikes on car crash and admitted to the ern tip of South America. who determined that they tom or underwater, the esti- Argentina’s vast coast, when
several opium-production plants hospital. The previous day he The U.S. Navy has deployed hadn’t come from the subma- mate is that the crew can it sent its last signal. Capt.
in southern Afghanistan, mark- had evaded arrest in a police four unmanned underwater rine. survive seven days. We be- Gabriel Galeazzi, a navy cap-
ing a new front in the air cam- raid on his home. vessels, in addition to two If the submarine hasn’t lieve that after so much time tain, said the submarine had
paign, the top U.S. military com- Mr. Novanto’s lawyer said he P-8A aircraft and personnel, surfaced since it lost contact we would have found it on been scheduled to return to
mander there said Monday. was badly injured in the crash, to help with the search in the on Wednesday, its crew could the surface by now, so we are its home base in Mar del
Army Gen. John W. Nicholson but Corruption Eradication Com- South Atlantic. The U.S. Air suffocate within 48 hours, searching on the bottom.” Plata on Monday.
Jr. said the latest U.S. and Af- mission spokesman Febri Dian- Force sent four planes, in- said Rear Adm. Andrew Len- Officials said the 43 men Since Argentina issued a
ghan air campaign is intended to syah said that an independent cluding three C-17 Globemas- non, Commander of Subma- and one woman on the San distress call on Friday, ships
weaken the Taliban financially panel of doctors said he could ter aircraft. rines at NATO and head of Juan have been trained to and aircraft from the U.S.,
and push them toward reconcilia- leave the hospital. Briefly raising hopes, a U.S. the international liaison stave off panic and sleep to Britain, Chile and Brazil have
tion within as little as two years. Mr. Novanto, also chairman of Navy plane using sonar equip- group ISMERLO that has preserve oxygen while they arrived off this country’s
Gen. Nicholson said the Golkar, a major party in Indone- ment detected potentially sig- helped coordinate the search. wait for help. coast to help with the search.
strikes, which began Sunday, sia’s governing coalition, has de- nificant sounds during its “In order to extend life as A German-built sub used The dramatic hunt has
marked the “first significant use” nied any wrongdoing. search, Mr. Balbin said. The long as possible, the crew by Argentina’s navy for 32 gripped the nation, coming
of such bombings against the —Associated Press noises, which sounded like does everything they can—it’s years, the ARA San Juan was only weeks after Argentina
crew members banging tools a terrible situation,” Adm. returning from a patrol from was shaken by the death of
against the hull of a vessel, Lennon said. “If the subma- the southernmost tip of South five citizens in the recent
were analyzed by technicians, rine is stranded on the bot- America, some 276 miles off New York terror attack.
REX/SHUTTERSTOCK/EUROPEAN PRESSPHOTO AGENCY
IN DEPTH
M&A
Continued from Page One
stock-market value of about
$57 billion.
Disney’s cable channels are
under pressure from cord-cut-
ting. In August, the company
announced it will launch two
online subscription streaming
services with sports, movies
and TV programming directly
to consumers. Disney said it
would yank its future movies
from Netflix.
Disney approached Fox
about a potential deal that
would provide Disney with
more content and distribution
assets to better compete
against Netflix. (Fox and News
Corp, the parent of The Wall
Street Journal, share common
ownership.)
“Our goal here is to be a vi-
able player in the direct-to-
consumer space, space that we
all know is a very, very com-
THILO SCHMUELGEN/REUTERS
pelling space to be in,” Disney
Chairman and CEO Robert Iger
told analysts and investors
this month.
The Disney-Fox talks
stalled, but they appear to
have unleashed a wider auc-
tion for Fox assets, including An Amazon logistics facility in Dortmund, Germany. The online retailer is pressuring firms that once thought they were largely immune to threats from tech giants.
its movie studio and interna-
tional unit. Those assets have to lower their taxes by moving The recent surge is a sign stores. The possibility that
drawn interest from Comcast their headquarters outside the that other drivers of deal ac- Spurred Into Action Amazon could become a rival
Corp., Verizon Communica- U.S. as part of a deal. tivity are now in control. Debt These three deals show how Amazon and other in CVS’s main business in-
tions Inc., Sony Corp. and pos- The number of deals that remains readily available and technology giants are influencing M&A activity. creased its desire for a deal
sibly other potential buyers, were agreed to and valued in cheap, and high stock prices that would diversify the com-
according to people close to the double-digit billions of often go hand-in-hand with pany further and help repur-
the discussions. dollars broke records. The sig- mergers and acquisitions. pose its drugstores.
AT&T Inc.’s planned pur- nature deal of that era was the Shareholders have rewarded CVS’s board told manage-
chase of Time Warner Inc. for megamerger, such as Pfizer buyers in a number of recent WHY NOW? ment to size up the potential
about $85 billion would com- Inc.’s agreement to buy Aller- deals, which tends to encour- effect of Amazon’s entry into
Amazon's potential entry into the
bine a huge but slowing mo- gan PLC for about $150 billion. age more and is reminiscent of the pharmacy business and de-
pharmacy business helped prompt
bile-phone business and the The Obama administration 2015. vise a counterattack, people
CVS to seek a deal with Aetna.
DirecTV satellite-television later blocked the deal between The biggest deals in the familiar with the matter said.
operation with a content ma- the two drugmakers. current crop are every bit as Market value: $56.48 billion Separately, CVS’s marketing
chine that includes Time big as those from the last department and outside advis-
Warner, owner of CNN and boom. Earlier this month, ers considered whether a part-
HBO. Broadcom Ltd. launched an nership with Amazon would
Randall Stephenson, AT&T’s
This month is on unsolicited offer for rival chip WHY NOW? make sense. That analysis con-
chief executive, said the point pace to be the second- maker Qualcomm Inc. valued cluded an alliance was unlikely
of the deal is to create a bul- at $105 billion. It would be the Netflix competition helped push Disney due to Amazon’s historical re-
wark against Facebook and
biggest for deals since biggest technology takeover to approach Fox. Other potential buyers sistance to such deals.
Google, which have built “in- at least 1995. ever. Qualcomm rejected the are circling.
credibly strong” positions in offer and said it undervalued Market value: $57.17 billion
the advertising market. the company. Tongue depressors
“That’s what this is about,” he It’s still hard for many com- Other parts of the health-
said at an event sponsored by Before the financial crisis, panies to agree to a merger or care industry are feeling the
the New York Times. leveraged buyouts dominated takeover, let alone win ap- heat from Amazon, too.
In a statement to the Jour- the deal environment. During proval from shareholders and WHY NOW? Health-care services compa-
nal, Mr. Stephenson added: the turn-of-the-century tech regulators. Sprint Corp. and T- nies long thought they were
AT&T CEO said combined company
“Tech companies are spending surge, companies rushed to Mobile US Inc. recently aban- largely immune to threats
would be stronger advertising
billions creating content and make deals that were seen as doned their monthslong effort from Amazon, but the e-com-
competitor to Facebook and Google.
distributing it directly to con- offensive moves to launch to combine the third- and merce company began adding
sumers.” AT&T’s planned pur- them into new lines of busi- fourth-largest wireless carri- Market value: $69.08 billion such supplies to its website a
chase “gives Time Warner the ness, like the ill-fated merger ers in the U.S. Disagreements Source: WSJ Market Data Group THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. few years ago.
opportunity to do the same, of AOL and Time Warner. over control and other issues After starting with low-
across multiple platforms and So far this year, the dollar doomed the talks. after the Whole Foods deal and insurers. Aetna is one of margin surgical gloves, tongue
with ad-supported models that volume of U.S. mergers totals Time Warner shares have was announced. Amazon’s the largest health insurers in depressors and other items,
cost consumers less.” $1.22 trillion, down 18% from tumbled since the Journal re- ability to essentially enter the the U.S. Amazon now sells the top 20
Every M&A cycle looks dif- the same period in 2016, ac- ported earlier this month that business overnight sent shiv- Fear of increasing competi- basics that every doctor or
ferent. The boom that crested cording to Dealogic. Invest- the Justice Department could ers through an industry al- tion from Amazon helped spur dentist needs, says Jim
in 2015 was largely defined by ment bankers attribute the de- sue to block the AT&T deal. ready plagued by thin profit CVS to look far afield for a Forbes, vice chairman in in-
deals between direct competi- cline largely to uncertainty The lawsuit was filed Mon- margins. CEOs in other sectors merger partner, according to vestment banking at UBS
tors trying to gain scale and surrounding federal antitrust day. The government alleged wondered if theirs would be people familiar with the mat- Group AG. He says some
cut costs. Some firms wanted and tax policy. the deal could raise prices and next. An Amazon spokesman ter. health-care services compa-
slow innovation. AT&T’s Mr. declined to comment. Amazon wasn’t the only im- nies have begun to explore
Stephenson said the suit “has “I see it across nearly every petus. CVS sees Aetna as a ways to diversify into different
the whole world questioning industry,” says Steven Bar- way to reshape the retailer lines of business, including
what they can and cannot do.” onoff, Bank of America Merrill amid a broader shake-up of M&A deals, as a result of pres-
Still, interest in deal-mak- Lynch’s chairman of global the health-care industry and sure from Amazon.
ing is strong and growing at M&A. “These companies are bolster the combined com- Carl’s Jr. has a cheeky, if-
many companies where com- causing CEOs to realize that pany’s leverage in negotiations you-can’t-beat-them-join-
petition from technology gi- maybe their stand-alone, sta- with drugmakers while giving them attitude about Amazon.
ants such as Amazon looms. tus-quo option is not as via- it a precious stockpile of The fast-food chain, owned by
ble.” health data. CKE Restaurants Holdings Inc.,
Few analysts or investors CVS had begun weighing a tweeted last month: “HEY
Flooded with calls
MICHAEL NAGLE/BLOOMBERG NEWS
saw it coming when the Jour- possible transaction with @Amazon BUY US. Srsly. For
Those tech giants have nal reported in October that Aetna before a CNBC report real. Let’s do this. Let’s change
done few big deals themselves CVS was in talks to buy Aetna. suggested in May that Amazon the future of eating!! #Ama-
lately, with the exception of CVS has a vast network was considering entering the zonBuyUs.”
Amazon’s purchase of Whole that includes more than 9,700 pharmacy business, people fa- There are no signs that Am-
Foods Market Inc. in August retail locations, more than miliar with the matter said. azon is interested in acquiring
for roughly $13 billion. 1,100 walk-in medical clinics As more shopping moves to Carl’s Jr.
Investment bankers who and a pharmacy-benefit opera- Amazon and other online re- —Sharon Terlep
advise grocery chains say they tion that serves as a middle- tailers, CVS already was wres- and Drew FitzGerald
Many investors were stunned by CVS’s interest in buying Aetna. were flooded with phone calls man between drug companies tling with what to do with its contributed to this article.
is necessary.” he says. “It makes the meat nique Kherian’s family in Cali- trated rooster when I was a
Ms. Nair turned to Shake- better.” fornia. They dislike turkey and little child,” says Ms. Strat-
speare in defense, sending a At D’Artagnan, a New Jer- for years roasted a chicken Capon fan Jeni Ni takes a photo of her Thanksgiving meal. man, news that cast her fond
text message to her guests sey-based gourmet food com- stuffed with veal, chestnuts childhood memories in a dif-
beforehand with a line from pany, founder and owner Ari- and pate for Thanksgiving. large chicken that turned out testicles had been removed, ferent light.
Henry IV: “Wherein neat and ane Daguin says capon sales When the extended family to be juicier than expected. she says, her first thought At Thanksgiving this year,
cleanly, but to carve a capon have doubled in recent years needed a bigger bird, a rela- When Ms. Kherian discov- was: Oh well, it tastes deli- she says, they’ll be serving
and eat it?” Mr. Marston and to an estimated 1,200 or so tive delivered a curiously ered it was a cockerel whose cious. Cornish hen.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * NY Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | A10A
2. BUS SPOTTER:
BESS ADLER FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
You don’t have to be inside a subway station to find out when This shortcut through J.C. Penney in the Manhattan Mall cuts
your train will arrive. The Metropolitan Transportation the corner between 34th Street-Herald Square and New York
Authority’s Subway Time app is a countdown clock in your Penn Station, saving time and keeping you warm and dry for
pocket. It shows arrival information for all lines equipped with half a block.
the technology: currently the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, B, C, E, G, L, M, N, There is a similar app for buses. All MTA buses are fitted with On the B, D, F and M lines, take the exit toward 32nd and
Q, R, S and W trains, as well as the Staten Island Railway. GPS tracking equipment. Rather than standing on the street 33rd streets. Instead of turning to exit toward the street, walk
Subway Time also shows arrival times for trains that share a wondering when the next bus will arrive, download the MTA’s straight into J.C. Penney and follow the procession of
station with countdown-clock enabled lines. The MTA expects Bus Time app. You also can view real-time bus information commuters hurrying up the store’s escalators and past the
to have countdown clocks on all lines by the end of this year. at http://bustime.mta.info. Starbucks before making a left toward the 32nd Street exit.
The new West End Concourse at New York Penn Station is E-ZPass transponders issued by the New Jersey service center Avoid long lines on the upper level of New York Penn Station
advertised as a Long Island Rail Road facility. But NJ Transit riders aren’t eligible for a saving of 30% to 50% on the MTA’s nine where Amtrak representatives check your ticket before allowing
can use it as long as their train leaves from tracks 5 and up. The bridges and tunnels, such as the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge, or for you down the escalator. Instead, take the stairs in the center of
trick is finding your platform without descending into Penn a 5% discount on New York State Thruway Authority tolls. To get the concourse or on its south side. They will take you to a
Station’s circles of hell. To do so, download NJ Transit’s mobile app the discounts, New Jersey E-ZPass holders might want to sign up dingy lower level where commuters huddle around departure
and set up DepartureVision for a real-time view of Penn Station’s for a New York account. Because the Port Authority of New York screens. You can wait here for your track to be called and then
departure board. Now, you can check your train information from and New Jersey honors discounts for both states at all of its head straight to the platform without being stopped by an
the street and, if the right track number pops up, head straight to bridges and tunnels, the only benefit of a New Jersey account is Amtrak employee. This is especially useful if you’re traveling in
the pristine $300 million facility on the other side of Eighth Avenue. an off-peak discount of about 25% on the New Jersey Turnpike. a group and want to snag seats together.
event will begin two hours ginning Wednesday morning be no crosstown traffic along
earlier, at 1 p.m., and end at 8 and into Thursday. the parade route. There will be
p.m. instead of 10 p.m. The There are no specific or more trucks filled with sand
change is intended to make it credible threats against the and blocker vehicles to close off
easier for the parade to get city or the parade, said New streets along the route.
going on Thursday morning, a York City Mayor Bill de Blasio. Heavy-weapons and canine
police official said. While last month’s truck at- teams will be stationed along
The Wednesday evening tack in lower Manhattan that the route and some officers
event, which years ago killed eight people remains will be on rooftops. Mounted
mostly attracted local resi- fresh in memory, he said, patrols and radiation detectors
dents, now draws at least “New York’s response is to re- also will be deployed. Police
200,000 people, officials said. main strong and resilient.” said they plan to station an of-
This year, revelers will need “We do not back down in ficer on every block. Police at the 2015 Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Security will be increased for this year’s event.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A10B | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 NY * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
years in prison for smothering party of a liberal political group, wide margin, has struggled to
her toddler son in the bathroom but he swatted away rumors he build a national profile.
of a Manhattan restaurant. is eyeing a run for president in In 2015, he tried to put on a
Latisha Fisher, 38 years old, 2020. political conference in Iowa, but
pleaded guilty in October in “I’m going to be on the job scrapped the idea when he
Manhattan Supreme Court to Latisha Fisher with Gavriel until Dec. 31 of 2021,” Mr. de couldn’t get the leading candi-
SETH WENIG/ASSOCIATED PRESS
first-degree manslaughter in the Blasio said at a news conference dates to attend the event.
death of her 20-month-old son, taurant workers the devil had in Queens on Monday. He has been a vocal critic of
Gavriel Ortiz-Fisher. made her kill the child. Mr. de Blasio’s speech at President Donald Trump, a Re-
On March 30, 2015, staff Ms. Fisher, diagnosed as a Progress Iowa on Dec. 19 will fo- publican, and spent much of his
members at 5 Boro Burger paranoid schizophrenic, was on cus “on the future of the pro- re-election campaign criticizing
found Ms. Fisher in the bath- probation at the time for attack- gressive movement and the ef- Mr. Trump’s policies.
room of the Sixth Avenue eat- ing an acquaintance with a steak fort to resist the conservative The coming trip was first re-
ery, holding her unconscious son. knife. agenda being enacted across the ported by Politico.
Authorities said she told the res- —Thomas MacMillan country,” according to the —Mara Gay Gov.-elect Phil Murphy wants a $15 an hour minimum wage.
ED A
NAT
I DO
#SPREADTHEWORDS
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | A11
LIFE&ARTS
BONDS: ON RELATIONSHIPS | By Elizabeth Bernstein
THOMAS PITILLI
Dietary supplements make lots
of claims and consumers often be-
lieve them: The booming U.S. in-
dustry has grown from $9 billion
in sales in 2007 to $15 billion this
BONDS
year, according to Euromonitor In-
ternational, a market research
firm.
But a new study gives ammuni-
tion to critics of the supplements Continued from page A11
and their potential health risks. personality inventory to advise
The study found two banned marriage therapists, universities
stimulants and two previously un- and corporations in helping
known and little-studied sub- people get along. Companies
stances in six weight-loss and can purchase a new, second-
sports supplements sold in the U.S. generation, 50-question version
The researchers defined “banned” of her questionnaire—focused
as “ingredients for which the U.S. on workplace behavior and rela-
Food and Drug Administration had tionships and different from the
taken enforcement action to re- Chemistry.com survey—through
move from dietary supplements a company she founded with a
prior to August 2016 (when the colleague, called NeuroColor.
samples were purchased).” People who take the test, which
They tested six brands of sup- costs $300, receive a 22-page
plements that listed ingredients on profile of their personality, ex-
the label that appeared to be pos- plaining where they are on the
sible analogs of the stimulant scale, how people can best com-
GETTY IMAGES/ISTOCKPHOTO
$
199 99
zvox.com p u r c h a s e
4 filet mignon
Reg. $249.99 | Save $50*
F O R $ 4 9 . 9 9* A N D R E C E I V E
8 free STEAkburgers
OFF
DAY ER
LI
HO
Can’t Hear
Voices On TV?
Our AccuVoice® Speaker uses hearing aid
technology to make TV dialogue crystal clear.
Can’t hear dialogue on TV? You’re not alone. Today’s
TVs have tiny speakers with weak sound. Our new
AccuVoice® Speaker uses advanced computer
algorithms to lift voices out of background sounds.
Dialogue is incredibly clear, even at low volumes.
Only 17" wide, it fits anywhere. Hookup is simple –
one connecting cord. Room-filling home theater sound,
with the clearest voices we’ve heard on any speaker,
at any price. Read our amazing consumer reviews
on amazon.com.
A DYNAMIC
Hour.’
CHURCHILL
SPORTS
GOLF
TITLEIST CEO
PUSHES BACK
BY BRIAN COSTA
a lot of the competition looks like Beaton reported that some NFL outlier. Love or hate them, his Cow- ritated mood. Are you Team Jerry—
they grabbed 53 tailgaters in the owners had actually discussed trying boys are the NFL’s starriest draw— or Team NFL Roger Goodell? It’s a
parking lot before kickoff. to remove Jones from the Cowboys. Dallas’s surprise 13-3 season last style war between a maverick and
NFL quarterbacking too often The league sent a missive admonish- year gave TV ratings a helpful lift. the company’s company man.
resembles watching a squirrel try- ing Jones for “conduct detrimental Jones prides himself as a visionary It’s most delicious battle in
ing to wedge a styrofoam cup off to the league’s best interests.” who’s always been a step ahead of sports, and if it were up to me, it’d
of his head. Then replacing that Yowza. One imagines Jerry bar- the league at maximizing the brand, be settled the old-fashioned way:
Adam Scott uses a Titleist ball. squirrel…with a backup squirrel ricading himself in the Jerrydome, and he does have a point. He rei- Gulfstreams at dawn.
BASKETBALL
ers can’t.” “The thing about the pick-and- anyone else in the league. Even
He’s become one of the league’s roll is that unless they switch it— something as elementary as drib-
most efficient players in the which with him they can’t because bling shows how different the
league’s most effective play. the big guy can’t guard him— game looks from their perspective.
Walker scores more than anyone you’re bringing two to the ball,” The average height of Walker’s
who’s in the pick-and-roll as much Hornets coach Steve Clifford said. dribbles on ball screens last season
as him, and he’s in the pick-and- “And one of the basic tenets of was 3.71 feet, which ranked eighth
roll more than anyone who scores good basketball is drawing a sec- in the league, behind shorter play-
as much as him. And it’s because ond defender.” ers like Thomas and Paul, accord-
he shrinks. That’s his game. It doesn’t really matter how ing to SportVU. Of the 50 players The Hornets’ Kemba Walker is at his best when he’s at his smallest.
Walker doesn’t play above the Walker’s defenders respond, his who used the most ball screens,
rim. He stays beneath his defend- coach explained. They can switch. the ones who let their dribbles Magic assistant Jay Hernandez way.
ers because he knows they can’t They can show. They can blitz. The bounce the highest were players stepping over hurdles while drib- “Jameer Nelson,” Walker said of
keep up with him down there. entire vocabulary of basketball who didn’t have to worry about ex- bling underneath them. Then he the journeyman guard now with
“Especially not the bigs,” he terms that describe the defense’s ploiting any edge they could find. put himself through drills this the Pelicans. “He would get down
said. “They don’t want to get that options in the pick-and-roll is use- No. 2 was Giannis Antetokounmpo. summer with 2 Hands Basketball and throw the ball places and go
low.” less when it comes to Walker. No. 1 was LeBron James. trainer Ryan Buhain that included after it. I watched him do that over
The dramatic evolution of bas- Walker scores more than one Walker can dangle the ball in dribbling with one hand as he the years. That’s who I really got it
ketball in recent years has bene- point per possession whether his front of his body with confidence dragged a small cone across the from.” Walker then named one of
fited the very same players who defender goes over the pick, under that only he can retrieve it because court with his other hand. his former teammates as inspira-
might have been marginalized in the pick or into the pick, according it’s something he practices. He also picked up some tips tion. “D.J. Augustin,” he said. “An-
previous eras. The league’s new to Synergy Sports data. And he’s He used to work with now- from players of his size along the other small guy.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | A15
OPINION
Lois Lerner Doesn’t Trust You BOOKSHELF | By Philip Delves Broughton
In his court-
room apologia
in the film “A
this is not the first time Ms.
Lerner has sought to keep the
public in the dark about her
On the flip side, the evi-
dence for fear seems over-
blown. Ms. Lerner and Ms. Paz
In some senses, this battle
is because Congress did not do
its job. It started down the
A Leap
Few
Men,”
Good
Jack
N i c h o l s o n ’s
Col. Nathan
actions. In 2014, when asked
to testify before Congress
about the IRS targeting, she
declared her innocence—and
cite Mark Meckler, a tea party
leader whom they say stoked
feelings against them by call-
ing IRS workers “thugs” and
right path when it held hear-
ings, but once Ms. Lerner in-
voked the Fifth, then-Speaker
John Boehner blinked. Instead
Of Faith
MAIN
STREET Jessup made
the words fa-
then invoked her Fifth
Amendment right to keep
saying “we’re going to have a
lot of fun abusing these gov-
of using Congress’s own pow-
ers—including its right, after
Who Can You Trust?
By William
mous. Now, in quiet. ernment employees.” she was found in contempt, to By Rachel Botsman
McGurn
her bid to Even this latest request to Mr. Meckler told the Times jail her until she talked—he (PublicAffairs, 322 pages, $27)
W
keep her tes- federal Judge Michael Barrett he’s not impressed. “Four settled for passing the buck to
timony in a recently settled is a follow-up to one she made years of harassing innocent the Obama Justice Department hen the founders of Airbnb first pitched their idea to
tea-party lawsuit against the back in May. At the time, American citizens for their po- with a recommendation for a investors, the responses ranged from incredulous to
IRS secret, Lois Lerner has Judge Barrett said he saw litical beliefs, and she’s scared prosecution everyone knew dismissive. It’s one thing for people to buy and sell
picked up the Jessup argu- good reason to limit access to would never come. with strangers on eBay, prospective backers would say, but to
ment: “You can’t handle the the attorneys during discovery. Congress is still paying for invite people you meet online to stay in your home? How long
truth!” But he also said that the par- ‘You can’t handle the that dereliction of duty. The before a host ended up dissolved in acid and washed down the
They used different words ties could eventually ask that various House and Senate in- kitchen sink?
but the meaning is the same. it be made public—the Cincin- truth,’ the former IRS vestigations have been frus- It turned out that millions of people were willing to give
Here’s how lawyers for Ms. nati Enquirer has also asked official tells the trated by lack of cooperation the concept a go, provided they could trust that they wouldn’t
Lerner and her former IRS for the seal to be lifted—and from relevant parties, includ- be exploited. “We bet our whole company,” Joe Gebbia, one of
deputy, Holly Paz, put it in a the burden would be on Ms. American people. ing federal agencies such as Airbnb’s co-founders, said, “on the hope that, with the right
filing aimed at persuading a Lerner and Ms. Paz to prove the FBI. Surely Republicans in- design, people would be willing to overcome the stranger-
judge to keep their testimony why it shouldn’t. vestigating everything from danger bias.”
from becoming public: “Public It’s hard to see what that of a guy in a cowboy hat talk- Hillary Clinton’s emails to Rus- Rachel Botsman, a visiting scholar at Oxford’s Saïd Busi-
dissemination of their deposi- case would be. By contrast, ing to a bunch of little, old la- sia’s mischief in the 2016 elec- ness School, has studied trust for several years and defines it
tion testimony would expose what a crippling precedent it dies at a tea party event?” tions would today enjoy far as “a confident relationship with the unknown.” It is the sib-
them and their families to ha- would be if government offi- And if her fears are legitimate, more cooperation from the rel- ling of risk. It inspires us to take a leap, to pay hundreds of
rassment and a credible risk cials from powerful agencies aren’t there other ways of evant parties had they exer- dollars up front for a room in
of violence and physical such as the IRS were permit- protecting her? cised their full authority in the a stranger’s house, to hop into
harm.” They’re not just think- ted to keep their abuses secret In 2015, the Obama Justice Lerner case. If we ever hope to a private car instead of hailing
ing of themselves, they add. on grounds they fear that the Department declined to prose- restore the accountability the a certified taxi. And thanks in
Young children, family mem- people whom they are sup- cute, explaining in a letter to Constitution built into the sys- part to the internet, the way
bers, might be hurt too. posed to serve might be upset Congress it “found no evi- tem and avoid the corrupting we come to trust others has
That’s quite an argument. if they found out. dence that any IRS official habit of turning to special been undergoing a fundamen-
So enraged would the Ameri- There can be good reasons acted based on political, dis- prosecutors, Congress is going tal change. “The real disrup-
can public become upon to keep a deposition sealed, criminatory, corrupt or other to have to get serious about its tion” going on right now, Ms.
learning what Ms. Lerner and from ensuring the privacy of inappropriate motives that authority as a coequal branch Botsman argues, “is not tech-
Ms. Paz said that they and the innocent to protecting the would support a criminal of government. nology itself, but the massive
those around them would be life of a mafia informant. But prosecution.” But when Attor- Meanwhile, in this case the trust shift it creates.”
in physical peril. Which prob- Ms. Lerner is no innocent. In- ney General Jeff Sessions an- plaintiffs, the government and Trust, Ms. Botsman explains,
ably makes most people won- deed, given all the falsehoods nounced settlements of two a newspaper all say they are began as a “local” phenomenon,
der what the heck must the that have been spread in an lawsuits last month, he con- for disclosure. Is a judge really generated within and bounded by
two have said that would get effort to whitewash what the firmed the IRS during the going to buy Ms. Lerner’s ar- the small communities where
everyone so agitated? IRS had done, the case for Obama years had targeted or- gument that the American peo- people used to live. Then it became
The Washington Times, transparency becomes even ganizations for political be- ple can’t handle the truth? “institutional,” determined by contracts, courts,
which broke the story, notes more compelling here. liefs and not bad behavior. Write to mcgurn@wsj.com. governments and companies. Whereas trust “used to flow
upwards to referees and regulators, to authorities and
experts, to watchdogs and gatekeepers,” that kind of trust has
Fear American Complacency, Not China been eroding in recent years. A 2015 survey by Harvard’s
Institute of Politics, for example, found that 75% of millennials
“sometimes or never” trust the federal government to do the
By David Kline unfortunately, the entrepre- from fitness bands to air purifi- might seem small by U.S. stan- right thing, while 88% “sometimes or never” trust the media.
T
neurial itch seems to have ers to rice cookers. Many of dards but represents the larg- Now trust is more “distributed,” Ms. Botsman says, littered
he last time I visited faded. Today barely 8% of all these products are internet-en- est trademark-infringement across social networks and Yelp reviews, flowing more
China, I had tea with businesses are startups less abled and designed to comple- verdict ever handed down in “horizontally, in some instances to our fellow human beings
Deng Xiaoping. It was than a year old, down from ment Xiaomi-made phones and China. and, in other cases, to programs and bots.”
1978, and the Chinese leader roughly 12.5% in 1980. That smart TVs. They’re also tightly In the U.S., by contrast, a Ms. Botsman gives three reasons for the recent collapse of
outlined for me a plan to mod- should concern every Ameri- integrated with the online ser- series of legislative actions and trust in institutions: the increasing number of people in posi-
ernize his country by unleash- can, given that startups are a vices that Xiaomi offers, such Supreme Court rulings have tions of power caught abusing our trust and then escaping
ing its enormous entrepre- nation’s engine of economic as games and microloans. Oh, weakened patent rights, espe- punishment; the expanding power of digital technology and
neurial energies. At the time, I progress, not to mention its and Xiaomi also runs its own cially for startups. A new way its effect of “flattening hierarchies” and eroding our faith in
thought his approach seemed primary job creator. stores, which inspire in many of challenging patents called the “elites”; and the increasingly isolated “cultural ghettoes”
pie-in-the-sky. Typical of Chinese business Chinese consumers a Costco- “inter partes review” results in and “echo chambers”—pockets within social media, for in-
But today, having just re- zeal is Xiaomi (sha-oh-mee), style loyalty. at least one patent claim being stance—that focus our trust mainly toward the like-minded.
turned from my first visit to the Chinese smartphone maker The complete package is thrown out in roughly 80% of The recent spate of allegations of sexual aggression by power-
China in 40 years, I’m a be- founded in 2010. It is growing more customer-centric than cases, according to an analysis ful men and the diverse responses to them are one example of
liever. Back when I met Deng, so fast, as Strategy Analytics anything I’ve seen in the U.S. by Adam Mossoff, a law pro- trust being eroded by a lack of accountability.
the number of private auto- They like to call it “the Xi- fessor at George Mason Uni-
mobiles in all of China could aomi way,” for lack of a bet- versity. Unsurprisingly, many
be counted in the thousands. Today just 8% of U.S. ter term. “We don’t yet have of these cases were brought by Smartphones, social networks and all our digital
Today there are about 200 the language to describe ex- defendants facing patent in- gossip and griping are altering the way we learn
million. Since 1978, China’s businesses are actly what we do,” a senior fringement lawsuits in federal
economy has grown more than startups, down from vice president, Wang Xiang, court. to trust others and assess risky behavior.
5,000%, and the disposable in- told me. This does not bode well for
come of its citizens has sky- about 12.5% in 1980. China’s entrepreneurs have America’s global competitive-
rocketed. By 2030, China been fueled by reforms in re- ness. The U.S. used to rank It’s not clear, however, that many elites are all that concerned
could surpass the U.S. to be- cent years that strengthened first among nations in the about losing our trust. I’d be amazed if the revelations of the
come the biggest economy in noted earlier this month, that intellectual property rights— strength of its intellectual Panama or Paradise Papers, for example, persuaded the world’s
the world. by next year, “if current mo- ironic for a country long ac- property rights. But the 2017 plutocrats to do anything but tap their brakes on offshore in-
The size of China’s econ- mentum continues, Xiaomi cused of stealing trade secrets edition of the Global IP Index vesting before continuing to the nearest Christie’s showroom.
omy, though, isn’t what could catch or overtake OPPO, and ignoring IP protections. places the U.S. 10th—tied with But there does seem to be a strong link between the narcis-
should worry President Huawei and Apple to become Today Chinese companies are Hungary. sism fed by Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, etc., and mistrust.
Trump. It’s China’s entrepre- the world’s second largest filing for more patents than Hungary? Two-thirds of people now get their news from social media.
neurial dynamism—its in- smartphone vendor.” (Samsung American ones. The patent ap- Here’s my advice to Mr. Can we rely on social media to police itself and become wor-
tense drive for innovation— is the first.) Even more sur- plication and examination Trump: Worry less about what thy of our trust? Should we even expect them to? In February,
that poses the greatest threat prising, Alvin Tang, an analyst process has been streamlined, China is doing and more about Mark Zuckerberg posted an essay on Facebook saying: “There
to America’s economic lead- at Seeking Alpha, suggested in and China has established spe- America’s declining entrepre- are questions about whether we can make a global community
ership. No longer a nation of September that Xiaomi should cialized intellectual property neurship. As for Chinese theft that works for everyone, and whether the path ahead is to
“copycat” industries, China be valued at $69 billion—which courts and tribunals to adjudi- of intellectual property, it isn’t connect more or reverse course.” The subtext, of course, was
today leads the U.S. in a would make it the world’s most cate lawsuits and issue injunc- half as worrisome as the dam- that Facebook has the answer.
number of vital sectors, in- valuable startup, slightly ahead tions against infringers. “IP age the U.S. is doing with its Ms. Botsman isn’t so sure. There’s no question that tech
cluding mobile payments, ad- of Uber. infringers will pay a heavy own self-destructive patent giants like Facebook and Google are on the front lines of
vanced microchips and artifi- Xiaomi also shows the origi- price,” President Xi Jinping policies. modern trust. But the author is suspicious. She calls Mr.
cial intelligence. nality and bold experimental- warned this summer. In Au- Zuckerberg’s company a “system that makes it easy for almost
More than 10,000 new busi- ism of Chinese businesses. Be- gust, the shoe company New Mr. Kline is a journalist and a third of the world’s population to gossip and gripe, share
nesses are registered every yond smartphones, Xiaomi’s Balance won $1.5 million from author of “Rembrandts in the and like, even if the content is false, and without proper
day in China. That’s seven network of over 100 partner Chinese shoemakers who had Attic” (Harvard Business checks and balances or any real redress.”
startups a minute. In the U.S., startups has created everything infringed its logo. The amount Press, 1999). Ms. Botsman has culled a number of wonderfully illustra-
tive examples of how the shift in trust is changing our world,
for better or worse—from the promise of blockchains to
A Substitute for ‘Complaint Free Wednesday’ transform financial services with highly shareable, computer-
coded data to the innovative ways that online babysitter ser-
vices are engaging parent-clients.
By Jerry Cianciolo stress response chronically for having a positive attitude.” brain, receiving a compliment She reports on the Chinese government’s plan to create a
W
purely psychological rea- Capitol Hill curmudgeons is as much a social reward as Social Credit System, in which people are given trust scores
ith Thanksgiving ap- sons”—such as by constantly weren’t swayed and the reso- being rewarded with money,” based on their daily activities: where they shop, their social
proaching, here’s a worrying about pleasing a lution failed to pass. said one of the authors, Nori- activities, how long they spend watching television or playing
question: In the course boss—“you increase your risk If complaining is the ham- hiro Sadato of the National In- video games, their spending habits, their health. It’s horribly
of an average week do you of adult onset diabetes and burger of everyday life, then stitute for Physiological Sci- Orwellian, but China’s plan is to “accelerate the modernization
spend more time complaining high blood pressure,” Mr. Sa- complimenting is the Kobe ences in Japan. It activates the of governmental governance capacity,” turning it into a
or complimenting? For most of polsky told his school’s news beef. Rarely do we serve up sa- same area of the brain, the sharper, more personalized tool. People who don’t rate well
us, it’s probably no contest. If service in 2007. lutes like the one I observed striatum. won’t be hired for certain jobs, will be barred from the civil
we wore hissy Fitbits, we’d all recently on a Manhattan sub- Proof of praise’s salutary ef- service and will even find it hard to enroll their children in the
be startled at the number of way. fect comes from a 2015 work- best schools. But people who do rate well will find life easier.
times we grouse about minor That idea didn’t As he fielded alerts from ing paper at the Harvard Busi- There will no longer be any dividing line between what people
annoyances. catch on, but why not headquarters, the train opera- ness School, which found that choose to do in private and what they do in public. Everything
Not that complaining is tor was also coping with a compliments led people to will be watched and rated.
fruitless. As “Caveman Logic” count compliments? jammed door, monitoring an have “positive changes in their But one man’s “Orwellian” is another man’s “transparent.”
author Hank Davis has argued, argument in the rear, and physiology, creative problem Ms. Botsman cites Tala, a lender that offers low-interest loans
there is a certain joy to railing sniffing around his control solving, performance under to customers through a mobile app. It creates a financial profile
against perceived wrongs, and Rep. Emanuel Cleaver (D., board for an alarming electri- pressure, and social relation- for customers based on 10,000 data points culled from the
activists might even identify Mo.) once saw a palliative role cal smell. A commuter stand- ships.” No wonder Mark Twain phone of applicants—from spending habits and consistency of
like-minded grumblers to pro- for the federal government. In ing nearby took note. “You’re a once wrote “I can live on a income to the size of their address book (and whether entries
mote change. At the very least, 2009 he introduced H.Con.Res. great multitasker,” he said. good compliment two weeks are listed by first and last names, a sign of care and attention)—
carping about the weather, 155 to designate the day be- “You can handle anything they with nothing else to eat.” as determinants of trustworthiness. This system has proved as
poor service or long checkout fore Thanksgiving as “Com- throw at you.” Hearing these With Thanksgiving here, of- valid as any credit score in establishing their likelihood to repay.
lines is an easy conversation plaint Free Wednesday.” Mr. words, the operator regained fering a few compliments Ms. Botsman has found a rich theme here and a fascinating
starter. Cleaver’s resolution estimated his composure instantly. “Try- might not be as weighty as way of interpreting technological change. Blockchain technol-
But as with most things that Americans complained, ing not to let it get the best of passing a House resolution. ogy today, she writes, is where the internet was in 1993 and
there may be a downside to on average, up to 30 times a me,” he said, flashing a smile But you needn’t wait for an act likely to be just as influential. Meanwhile, China’s nationwide
complaining and the agitation day, “resulting in roughly and feeling in control again, as of Congress to brighten the Social Credit System is a scant two years away from launch.
that accompanies it. Stanford 4,500,000,000 complaints spo- pleased as if he’d found a hun- lives of those around you. At this rate, Ms. Botsman will have to update her book every
professor of neurology Robert ken every day.” It encouraged dred-dollar bill. few months to stay relevant.
Sapolsky has conducted exten- “each person in the United Funny enough, that’s the ef- Mr. Cianciolo is chief editor
sive research on stress hor- States to remember that hav- fect praise has on us, accord- of Emerson & Church, Publish- Mr. Delves Broughton is the author of “The Art of the Sale:
mones. “If you turn on the ing a positive life begins with ing to a 2012 study. “To the ers in Medfield, Mass. Learning From the Masters About the Business of Life.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A16 | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Have They Got a Bond for You Should Rich College Endowments Be Taxed?
S
tate and local governments pledge their Hence, Connecticut lawmakers recently au- In their misguided piece about col- I chair the finance committee of
full faith and credit to repay general obli- thorized bonds backed by state income taxes lege endowments, Profs. Thomas Gil- Princeton University’s board of trust-
bert and Christopher Hrdlicka defend ees. Princeton uses its endowment
gation bonds, but politicians in Chicago as a substitute for GOs. The budget noted that
a proposed tax on college and univer- earnings to fund fully half of each
and Connecticut realize their “the new type of borrowing sity endowments and suggest that this year’s operating budget and to help
word is depreciating in value. Connecticut and authorized in the bill may be will help save colleges and universities support major initiatives like ex-
Thus they’re pitching a debt Chicago borrow a debt viewed more favorably in (“A Hedge Fund That Has a Univer- panding the number of students we
arbitrage to reduce their bor- bond markets because it is sity,” op-ed, Nov. 14). Sadly, this dem- enroll, ensuring affordability for stu-
rowing costs. trick from Puerto Rico. linked directly to a large and onstrates a fundamental misunder- dents from all income backgrounds
As part of Illinois’s slow- relatively stable revenue standing of how endowments work and expanding our teaching and re-
rolling bailout of Chicago, source.” Hmmm. and the role they play in funding the search in fields like engineering and
Democrats in Springfield this summer allowed Income-tax revenues in Connecticut have re- very educational opportunities the au- data science.
the city to issue bonds securitized with $700 mil- peatedly fallen short of estimates due to tepid thors purport to support. Far from Under our financial-aid program
lion or so in annual sales tax revenue. Creditors economic growth. Last year they were off by helping higher education, this plan families with incomes below $160,000
will inevitably diminish the resources pay no tuition and families with in-
would have a legal lien on the revenues. Chicago $530 million. Perhaps Democrats consider this
available for student financial aid, comes up to $300,000 can receive
plans to start floating the sales-tax bonds next a rounding error on a $3.5 billion deficit. Chi- teaching and research. some aid. No one is required to bor-
month to refinance existing debt. cago has reassured investors that the new “cor- Endowments are not “rainy-day row, and even our students who don’t
The bonds will be cheaper to finance than poration would be considered bankruptcy-re- funds,” stashed away as a buffer. En- qualify for financial aid pay only about
Chicago’s junk-rated GO bonds, which carry a mote” (our emphasis). However, “in the dowments are designed to provide a half of what their education costs. The
3.5% premium over top-rated municipal securi- unlikely event of a municipal bankruptcy, bond- stable and perpetual source of funding other half is covered by the earnings
ties. Fitch has rated Chicago’s sales tax bonds holders would still be paid.” Not so fast. that underwrites the operation of an from the endowment.
AAA, which is an insult to every triple-A issuer Puerto Rico likewise established a special institution. A federal tax on Princeton’s endow-
including the U.S. Treasury. (Fitch still rates public corporation in 2006 to issue sales-tax “Co- Here’s a simple way to think about ment earnings would drain away tens
Treasurys triple-A, unlike Standard & Poor’s.) fina” bonds, which were billed as more secure it. A tax is a tax. A tax on endowments of millions of dollars that now support
While the city noted in a recent presentation than debt paid from the commonwealth’s operat- will take money from institutions of teaching, research and scholarships.
higher education and transfer it to the C. JAMES YEH
that “ratings agencies rate bonds issued by spe- ing fund. And for a time that appeared true as federal government to help finance Trustee, Princeton University
cial-purpose corporations highly because they politicians raised the sales tax (which was later corporate tax cuts. So while it’s true Princeton, N.J.
are more legally secure than a normal bond,” converted into a VAT) to repay creditors. that an endowment tax would “bene-
that hasn’t historically been the case. But last year Puerto Rico’s governor issued fit” someone, it would not be colleges There is no reason to believe that
Securitized bonds issued by special public a debt moratorium, which led Congress to im- or their students. a 1.4% excise tax on net investment
corporations were once considered less safe pose a fiscal control board and create a quasi- TED MITCHELL income will influence the endowment
than GO bonds because their revenue bases are Chapter 9 bankruptcy process. Cofina and GO President manager to invest in a way that
narrower and can shrink over time. Consider the bondholders are now vying for the same, small American Council on Education would reduce the investment risk. It
2011 bankruptcy of Jefferson County, Alabama, pool of money, and both will be lucky to get half Washington may actually do the opposite. The
which resulted from political corruption at its of what Detroit bondholders recovered. second issue is one of freedom of
Endowments are relied on to gener- choice. Donors, for the most part,
over-leveraged sewer system. Illinois could authorize Chicago to declare
ate earnings that are used year in and know what they are doing when they
Detroit’s Chapter 9 bankruptcy in 2013 set a bankruptcy in the future, and while states can’t year out to support teaching, research make a donation to the endowment
precedent by subverting GO bondholders to pay declare bankruptcy, Connecticut could try to re- and financial aid. The authors’ pro- of their beloved university. Should
public workers and retirees. Prior to Detroit, negotiate the terms of its debt. In the event of a posal that universities should pursue the federal government be empow-
creditors considered GO bonds sacrosanct and default, GO bonds in both places would be less se- an investment policy that “generates ered to make judgments on how that
figured courts would compel local governments cure because of competing creditor claims. almost no investment income” would money should be spent or invested?
to raise taxes or cut pensions to repay them. Investors thirsty for yield may take Chicago be dreadful advice. Universities seek to On that, honorable men may differ,
That assumption proved incorrect. So creditors and Connecticut up on their proposition, but maximize returns with prudent levels but a small excise tax will have little
are now demanding higher yields for GO bonds they shouldn’t complain later if these bets turn of risk precisely so that they have the or no influence.
issued by fiscally irresponsible governments. out to be bad political risks. Caveat creditor. resources they need to pursue their KELLY RUSHING
educational and research missions. Houston
C
Administration’s time. ers” since the 1990s.
hancellor Angela Merkel’s negotiations ing 13% share of the vote in September because The antimenu-labeling bill in Con- Whereas Mr. Pielke finds climate
to form a new coalition collapsed on it promised to be an alternative. And having gress wouldn’t just provide a little scientists, in his excellent commen-
Sunday night, and good riddance. What- punished the FDP in 2013 for bowing too much flexibility for tary on the dangers of taking scien-
pizza makers, it tific disagreements to the courts,
ever else German voters to Mrs. Merkel in a previous
Pragmatism isn’t would make “not particularly political,” my ob-
wanted in September’s murky coalition, voters also rewarded calorie infor- servation is that many are very po-
election, they hoped for more practical when it fails Mr. Lindner with nearly 11% mation mean- litical and of these nearly all are left
political competition. An im- for defending his low-tax, low- ingless and un- to hard-left of center.
plausible coalition of the to inspire voters. regulation views aggressively available to the Climate doesn’t exist in the same
barely willing is the wrong this time around.
ISTOCK
OPINION
F
cratic sovereignty. different possible paths. First, it
or the first time since it The U.S. is not party to the Rome could become yet another embar-
began operating in 2002, Statute, the treaty establishing the rassing irrelevancy like the Interna-
the International Criminal ICC’s authority. Bill Clinton signed it tional Court of Justice or the U.N.
Court has put the U.S. in in 2000, when he was a lame duck. Human Rights Council. That has
its sights. On Nov. 3, ICC But fearing certain rejection, he did been its lot so far. To date, the ICC
Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda initiated not submit it to the Senate. The has been feckless and often in disar-
an investigation into alleged war Bush administration formally “un- ray, acquiring the justifiable reputa-
crimes and crimes against humanity signed” in 2002 before the Rome tion from its caseload that it was a
committed in Afghanistan since Statute entered into force. That project by Europeans to prosecute
mid-2003. This raises the alarming same year, Congress passed support- miscreants in their former African
possibility that the court will seek to ive legislation protecting U.S. ser- colonies. Burundi recently withdrew
assert jurisdiction over American vicemembers from the ICC, a law from the ICC, and others have come
citizens. that was decried by hysterical oppo- close.
nents as the “Hague Invasion Act.” Second, the ICC could go rogue—
ISTOCK/GETTY IMAGES
The U.S. then entered into more than which is what the potential prosecu-
A ‘war crimes’ inquiry in 100 bilateral agreements committing tion of Americans represents. Pursu-
other nations not to deliver Ameri- ing Washington, it seems, finally
Afghanistan shows the cans into the ICC’s custody. became too hard for the ICC to re-
danger of the International Secretary of State Condoleezza sist (having already investigated Is-
Rice later weakened America’s oppo- rael, which is once again the canary
Criminal Court. sition to the ICC. Barack Obama The International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands. in the mineshaft).
manifestly longed to join but none- Under the idea of “complementar-
theless did not re-sign the Rome The U.S. has done more than any its ability to defend Americans. ity,” the ICC could defer to countries
Located in The Hague (alongside Statute. Thus the U.S. has never ac- other nation to instill in its civilian- The ICC prosecutor is an interna- that possess responsible law-en-
such dinosaurs as the International knowledged the ICC’s jurisdiction, controlled military a respect for hu- tionalized version of America’s “in- forcement mechanisms, which the
Court of Justice, which decides and it should not start now. Amer- man rights and the laws of war. dependent counsel,” a role originally U.S. assuredly does. There are plenty
state-versus-state disputes), the ICC ica’s long-term security depends on When American servicemembers vi- established in the wake of Watergate of real criminal states in the world
constitutes a direct assault on the refusing to recognize an iota of legit- olate their doctrine and training— and later allowed to lapse (but now to keep the ICC busy, if it had the
concept of national sovereignty, es- imacy in this brazen effort to subor- which can happen in any human in- revived under Justice Department wit to focus on them. That it doesn’t
pecially that of constitutional, repre- dinate democratic nations to the un- stitution—the U.S. is perfectly regulations in the form of a “special speaks volumes.
sentative governments like the accountable melding of executive and capable of applying our own laws to counsel”). Similarly, the ICC’s prose- America should welcome the op-
United States. The Trump adminis- judicial authority in the ICC. their conduct. These laws and proce- cutors are dangerously free of ac- portunity, as in Churchill’s line about
tration should not respond to Ms. Proponents of global governance dures do not need to be second- countability and effective supervi- Bolshevism, to strangle the ICC in its
Bensouda in any way that acknowl- have always wanted to turn the U.S. guessed by international courts, es- sion. They are not the superhero cradle. At most, the White House
edges the ICC’s legitimacy. Even into just another pliant “member” pecially ones that violate basic “Justice League International.” should reply to Ms. Bensouda with a
merely contesting its jurisdiction of the United Nations General As- rights guaranteed by the U.S. Consti- The ICC fits into no coherent rep- terse note: “Dear Madame Prosecu-
risks drawing the U.S. deeper into sembly or the ICC. They know that tution, like trial by jury. resentative government structure, tor: You are dead to us. Sincerely,
the quicksand. America’s exceptionalism and com- Moreover, the Rome Statute’s real which does not exist internationally. the United States.” Other countries
The left will try to intimidate mitment to its Constitution were targets always have been not merely It also fails a critical constitutional wanted the ICC; let them live with it.
the White House by insisting that among their biggest obstacles, but individual soldiers accused of war test—the separation of powers—in
any resistance to the ICC aligns the they hoped to cajole Washington crimes, but their commanders and that the executive not only prose- Mr. Bolton is a senior fellow at
U.S. with human-rights violators. into joining one day. The new Af- political leaders—all the way to the cutes but determines guilt or inno- the American Enterprise Institute
But the administration’s real align- ghanistan investigation demon- commander in chief of the global he- cence. Decoupling executive and judi- and author of “Surrender Is Not an
ment should be with the U.S. Con- strates why that vision needs to be gemon (as they resentfully see it). cial powers is no mere constitutional Option: Defending America at the
stitution, not the global elite. It confronted now and conclusively The White House should not facilitate nicety; it is a critical mechanism for United Nations and Abroad” (Simon
would not be “pragmatic” to accept defeated. these efforts to constrain and inhibit restraining excesses. & Schuster, 2007).
A
cluding an increase in the standard even extending the charitable deduc- By calling for an additional de- means they get to hang on to more
familiar and largely correct deduction and a cut in the highest tax tion system then in place. According duction for giving, charitable organ- of their hard-earned money next
narrative holds that tax re- rate, the analysts predicted a decline to tax historian Joseph J. Thorndike, izations are essentially arguing that year than they did this year.
form always fails because cor- in noncorporate donations of $13.1 one clergyman warned in 1944 that taxpayer funds should go to them
porate special interests fight to pro- billion, or 4.6% of 2015 donations. Un- the standard deduction would re- instead of to the government. The Ms. Garment is a tax lawyer and
tect the advantages their lobbyists der more optimistic assumptions, the strict “personal freedom” and be a nonprofit and philanthropic world a visiting scholar at Indiana Univer-
have written into existing law. Now predicted reduction was less than 2%. step toward “fascism.” That hasn’t may end up doing a lot of good with sity, where Mr. Lenkowsky is a pro-
organizations representing the na- A recent Tax Policy Center estimate of happened. Americans have contin- those extra funds, but the Ameri- fessor emeritus of public affairs and
tion’s charities are getting into the the drop in giving was slightly larger, ued to give to charities no matter cans they aim to help would almost philanthropy.
act, lobbying Congress to preserve a between 4% and 6.5%.
tax structure that they say maxi- Any net loss of contributions
mizes charitable giving. would probably hurt the valuable
From the left-leaning National work that charities do but, recessions
Committee for Responsive Philan- aside, Americans have steadily in-
thropy to the more conservative Alli- creased their giving despite numerous
ance for Charitable Reform, the chari- tax law changes. Individual donations
table world’s main concern is the increased by 4% in 2015 and another
House bill’s proposal to double the 4% in 2016. If donations continue to
increase at such rates, it won’t take
long to make up for changes brought 60 YEARS OF ADVENTURE
Individual donations to about by tax reform.
charities grew 4% in both Nonetheless, the charity lobby is AND DISCOVERY
pushing hard for a “universal chari-
2015 and 2016. That rate table deduction” allowing all taxpay-
ers, itemizers and non-itemizers, to
will swamp any tax effects. deduct contributions to charities. In-
dependent Sector, which represents
nonprofits and foundations, says
standard deduction to as much as such a deduction would raise nearly
$24,400 per married couple. Today as much in new gifts as the House
around 30% of taxpayers choose to bill would take away.
itemize their deductions instead of But the universal deduction idea
taking the standard deduction. Chari- has problems. For one thing, it
ties reasonably suspect that these would reduce federal revenue by an
Americans would donate less if they estimated $13 billion and burden an
could no longer benefit from itemiza- already overloaded Internal Revenue
tion. Doubling the standard deduction Service bureaucracy with a greater
could drive the percentage of taxpay- number of returns requiring audits.
ers who itemize down to below 10%. More important, a universal charita-
The Joint Committee on Taxation ble deduction would violate the
estimates that doubling the standard widely acknowledged principle that
deduction could reduce the amount reform should create a simpler,
of deductible charitable contribu- more neutral tax system.
tions by nearly $100 billion, from Charities imagine themselves no-
$241 billion to $146 billion. But a bler than other interest groups be-
drop in the amount of deductible cause they look out for people. But
gifts does not necessarily mean an offering tax breaks to sectors of so-
equivalent drop in actual giving. ciety with worthy aims is a danger-
No one can predict with certainty ous political game. Why shouldn’t
how new non-itemizers might adjust mortgage brokers, for instance, get
their expenditures if the House bill as a tax break? They help people buy
currently constructed passes the Sen- homes, and homeownership is a cor-
ate and is signed into law. But in 2016 nerstone of American social and
researchers from the Lilly Family economic mobility.
School of Philanthropy at Indiana Uni- When the standard deduction was
versity, with which we are affiliated, first proposed during World War II
analyzed several decades of data on to ease the process of tax collection,
the responses to past tax-law changes churches and other charities formed
S&P 2582.14 À 0.13% S&P FIN À 0.49% S&P IT À 0.28% DJ TRANS À 0.41% WSJ $ IDX À 0.36% LIBOR 3M 1.446 NIKKEI (Midday) 22488.62 À 1.02% See more at WSJMarkets.com
financial terms. Such an order, velop and produce autonomous Police said the incident was 2021.
though, would account for about cars, but Monday’s agreement caused by a human driver of an- The first taxis from the deal
4.5% of Volvo’s current total represents one of the most con- other vehicle, not the Uber self- will be built in Volvo’s factory in
sales, based on 2016 figures, and crete deals between two big driving car. Sweden. But the company plans
is estimated to be worth more players in the field for the pro- “We believe this is a new seg- to produce the vehicles in the
than $1 billion, a person familiar duction of a large number of real ment, a new business,” said U.S. as well, where Volvo is
with the situation said. cars. The promised delivery Volvo Cars Chief Executive Ha- building a new factory just out-
The auto industry and many date—as little as two years kan Samuelsson. Jeff Miller, side Charleston, S.C. Charlie Rose on Twitter apologized for ‘inappropriate behavior.’
A FanDuel ....................... B6 Q
Acorns Grow ............... B4 Fintech Advisory.......B11 Qualcomm..........A10,B13
Aetna...........................A1 Fleurette ..................... B7
R
Alibaba Group.............B5 G
Alphabet......................A1 Raise Marketplace......B4
Gecamines...................B7 Range Resources......B12
Altice...........................B6 General Electric ........ B13
Amazon.com Roark Capital Group...B5
Glencore ...................... B7
.................. A1,B1,B5,B13 S
I-J
Apple...........................B2 Scale Venture Partners
AT&T.......A1,A6,A10,B13 Intel.............................B4 .....................................B4
Jana Partners ............. B6
B J.P. Morgan Chase....B11
Sony .......................... A10
Bank of America.......B11 Sprint........................A10
K Starboard Value..........B3
Best Buy ..................... B1
Bloomberg...................B1 Katanga Mining..........B7 Sun Art Retail Group.B5
Boeing ....................... B12 Kinder Morgan............B2 T
Boeing.............................. Kweichow Moutai.....B11
Target..........................B1
Broadcom ..... A10,B4,B13 L Time Warner
Buffalo Wild Wings....B5 LendUp Global.............B4 ................ A1,A6,A10,B13
C Locus Robotics............B4 T-Mobile US..............A10
Caterpillar ................. B12 M Toys 'R’ Us..................B1
Cavium............B3,B4,B13 Mahindra & Mahindra B3 21st Century Fox...A1,B6
Cboe Global Markets B12 Marathon Oil.............B12 U
CBS..............................B1 Marvell Technology Uber Technologies ...... B1
Centennial Resource Group............B3,B4,B13
V
A natural-gas flare near a pumpjack in Midland County, Texas. Natural gas is gushing out of West Texas, a byproduct of oil drilling.
INDEX TO PEOPLE
B
Beckerman, Michael...B6
Glyphis, George .......... B2
Goodell, Roger ............ B6
H-I
Mostaque, Emad.......B13
Mugabe, Robert..........A8
O
Gas Glut Threatens Permian Boom
Bratspies, Steve.........B2 BY RYAN DEZEMBER taken to ensure they can move
C Haefele, Mark...........B13 O'Hara, Sean.............B12
Okhuijsen, Dennis.......B6
AND ALISON SIDER Pressure Point gas out of the West Texas.
Canavan, John...........B12 Iger, Robert...............A10 Pipeline operators are
R Natural-gas prices at a West Texas trading hub have fallen below the
D Immelt, Jeffrey.........B13 Natural gas is gushing out poised to benefit from the con-
national benchmark on a glut of fuel from the Permian Basin. Drillers
Delrahim, Makan........A1 J Rose, Charlie...............B1 of West Texas, a byproduct of gestion due to higher volumes
Rowland, Robin...........B5 there hope Mexico will buy more gas.
Drahi, Patrick..............B6 Jones, Jerry ................ B6 frenzied drilling for oil. That is moving through their tubes
Drut, Bastien..............B2 K S a problem for energy produc- West Texas natural-gas price U.S. natural gas pipeline
and in some cases by trading
Saliba, Jean-Michel..B13 discount to Henry Hub exports to Mexico
E Kalmin, Steven ........... B7 ers, who are running out of in the fuel and charging more
Schydlowsky, Andrew B1 $0.60 a million Btu 150 billion cubic feet
Eccles, Nigel................B6 Kitchen, Simon ......... B13
Shu, Susan................B13
places to send it all. for space.
Entner, Roger..............B6 L Simmons, Harris.......B11 Pipelines running from the Kinder Morgan Inc. says
0.50 125
F Lee, Lian Fen ............ B13 Stephenson, Randall region’s Permian Basin to the the glut has spurred producers
Fadlallah, Tarek.........B13 Lowry, Michelle.........B13 ....................... A1,A6,A10 Gulf Coast’s chemical plants, 0.40 100 to sign up for space on a 430-
Faulk, Rick...................B4 Lubbe, Jacques ........... B7 T cities and export terminals are mile-long pipeline that it and
Flannery, John .......... B13 M Tritton, Mark .............. B2 essentially full. Drillers in the 0.30 75 two rivals plan to build be-
G Mahindra, Anand........B3 W Rockies and Canada already 0.20 50 tween WaHa and a trading hub
Gallant, Paul ...............B6 Martínez, David........B11 Weinstein, Harvey......B1 supply markets in the north near Corpus Christi.
Gertler, Dan ................ B7 McAtee, David............A6 Wyeno, Ross...............B2 and west. 0.10 25 That pipeline, the Gulf
There is plenty of room on Coast Express, and three com-
pipelines running south to 0 0 peting trade routes won’t be
Bonds and the Dollar Mexico, which has emerged as 2017 2013 ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17 completed until at least late
The link between the dollar and the extra income available from safe a major market for U.S. pro- Sources: S&P Global Platts (discount); EIA (exports) THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. 2019, though. Meanwhile, pro-
U.S. assets is strong. Unusually, this year the link is stronger with ducers, but there is a catch: ducers’ hopes are pinned to
long-dated bonds than short-dated ones. Much of the gas distribution ergy Corp. said it paid $350 major issue for companies in Mexico, which in August im-
infrastructure and power million in August for a power West Texas. Some drillers are ported nearly 5% of total U.S.
Correlation between euro-dollar exchange rate plants there that would buy plant in Odessa, Texas, to take racing to lock up space on production, according to U.S.
and U.S.-German bond yield differential the fuel haven’t been built yet. advantage of the cheap fuel. pipelines so they can get their Energy Information Adminis-
80% 10 year Two year The growing gas glut is al- But for oil and gas produc- gas out of the Permian. Ana- tration data.
ready weighing on regional ers, the excess supply could lysts say pipeline access could Much of the added demand
60 prices. Natural gas prices at potentially force them to take become important information from Mexico will be piped
the WaHa trading hub in West drastic measures—such as cap- tracked by energy investors. from the Permian—eventually.
40 Texas have fallen to much as ping wells and curtailing oil Some companies, like Cen- “If Mexican pipelines are
57 cents per million British drilling—until new pipelines to tennial Resource Development not on by the end of next year,
20 thermal units—or about 20%— the Gulf Coast are built and Inc., are paying for guarantees we could even see shut ins and
below spot prices at Louisi- planned power plants come that their gas gets delivered. flaring,” Sanford C. Bernstein
0
ana’s Henry Hub, the national online in Mexico. The oil producer’s finance chief, & Co. analysts said, referring
–20 benchmark, according to S&P So far, Permian drillers have George Glyphis, recently told to extreme measures like cap-
Global Platts. Analysts forecast been unresponsive to falling analysts that a roughly 14% in- ping wells, curtailing drilling
1999 2000 ’10 the gap exceeding $1 next year, local gas prices, focusing in- crease in the company’s third- and setting gas aflame in the
Correlation between yen-dollar exchange rate or about a third of the $3 that stead on U.S. crude prices quarter gathering and transpor- desert instead of selling it.
and U.S.-Japanese bond yield differential U.S. natural gas futures have which are trading around a tation costs was mostly due to “There is a very pertinent
hovered around this year. two-year high at about $57 a paying pipeline operators to timing issue,” said Ross Wy-
80% 10 year Two year That is good news to re- barrel. Last week, 391 rigs guarantee space. eno, an analyst at S&P Global
gional gas consumers, such as were operating in the Permian, Permian producers includ- Platts. “Will this Mexican ca-
60 power producers, who can up 71% from a year ago, ac- ing Encana Corp. and WPX pacity come online in late 2018
profit from the lower price. cording to Baker Hughes. Energy Inc. have also recently to help alleviate this looming
40
Electricity provider Vistra En- But gas is fast becoming a highlighted steps they have constraint?”
20
–20
0
BUSINESS NEWS
TECHNOLOGY WSJ.com/Tech
ApplePodcasts.com/FOE
Proudly Sponsored By
© 2017 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ6039
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | B5
BUSINESS NEWS
Alibaba Sees
Growth in
The Stores
Online shopping giant economy,” Alibaba chief execu-
tive officer Daniel Zhang said
to pay $2.88 billion for in a statement.
a 36% stake in a Wal- Alibaba’s wager follows on-
line retailer Amazon.com
Mart China competitor Inc.’s roughly $13.5 billion pur-
chase of U.S. grocer Whole
BY LIZA LIN Foods. While Amazon is com-
peting head-on with super-
HONG KONG—E-commerce markets, Alibaba says it is fo-
giant Alibaba Group Holding cused instead on joining with
Ltd. is making another big bet retailers.
KIM KYUNG-HOON/REUTERS
on brick-and-mortar, saying it The rush by Alibaba into
will pay $2.88 billion for a physical retail in recent years
36% stake in China’s second- has already involved invest-
largest big-box retailer, Sun ments of at least $5 billion, as
Art Retail Group Ltd. it took stakes in companies
Alibaba, which runs the including shopping-mall op-
world’s largest online shop- erator Intime Retail Group
ping operation, sees tradi- (Co.), Sanjiang Shopping Club Sun Art, China’s second-largest big-box retailer, runs over 450 supermarket-department stores under the RT Mart and Auchan brands.
tional retail venues as a way Co. and electronics retailer
to expand its reach into fresh Suning Commerce Group Ltd. stores in China under the RT needs, such as stocking hot China operation is third with such tie-ups of physical and
foods while also creating new Alibaba also runs the small Mart and Auchan brands. Ali- sauce on shelves alongside live 10.2%. online retailers, based on
demand for its Alipay mobile- Hema supermarket chain in baba is buying both a direct clams in tanks where shoppers Annual sales growth at Sun conversations his team is
payment business and its lo- China, which offers internet stake and indirect stake. As could pick and choose. Art has been slowing in the having with other Asia Pa-
gistics services. purchases and deliveries part of the transaction, Sun Art’s 14.6% share of past three years, as more Chi- cific clients.
“Physical stores serve an within the hour for customers Auchan Retail, Sun Art’s main China’s hypermarket sector nese move their grocery shop- China International Capital
indispensable role during the nearby. shareholder, its raising its last year made it second only ping online. Revenue grew Corp. advised Alibaba on the
consumer journey, and should Hong Kong-listed Sun Art is stake to 36.2%. to China Resources Holding 4.1% in 2016, compared with deal, while Citigroup Inc. ad-
be enhanced through data- a French-Taiwanese joint ven- Sun Art gained popularity Co., at 15.5%, according to in- 5.0% a year earlier. vised the Taiwan-based seller.
driven technology and person- ture that runs more than 450 for customizing its store prod- dustry researcher Euromonitor One banker involved in the —Julie Steinberg
alized services in the digital large supermarket-department ucts and formats to local International. Wal-Mart’s transaction expects more contributed to this article.
ASSET CLASS
JPMORGAN GLOBAL BOND
GBOSX
OPPORTUNITIES FUND
TO YOUR
Globally diversified core holding
JPMORGAN GLOBAL
GAOSX
ADVANTAGE
ALLOCATION FUND
jpmorgan.com/funds/4solutions
Investors should carefully consider the investment objectives and risks as well as charges and expenses of a fund. The
prospectus contains this and other information about the fund and should be read carefully before investing. To obtain a
prospectus for Mutual Funds: Contact JPMorgan Distribution Services, Inc. at 1-800-480-4111 or visit jpmorganfunds.com.
Exchange Traded Funds: Call 1-844-4JPM-ETF or visit jpmorgan.com/ETF. International investing has a greater degree
of risk and increased volatility due to political and economic instability of some overseas markets. Changes in currency
exchange rates and different accounting and taxation policies outside the U.S. can affect returns. Investing involves risk,
including possible loss of principal. J.P. Morgan ETFs are distributed by JPMorgan Distribution Services, Inc., which is an
affiliate of JPMorgan Chase & Co. Affiliates of JPMorgan Chase & Co. receive fees for providing various services to the funds.
J.P. Morgan Asset Management is the brand for the asset management business of JPMorgan Chase & Co. and its affiliates worldwide. This communication is issued
by Distribution Services Inc. and J.P. Morgan Institutional Investments, Inc., both members of FINRA/SIPC.; and J.P. Morgan Investment Management Inc.
© JPMorgan Chase & Co., November 2017
B6 | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BUSINESS NEWS
Current Business Tax Return Req. said Monday, months after Fan- LLC disclosed a large stake and
Duel and rival DraftKings Inc. plans to push for change, includ-
www.fundswired.com called off a merger. ing a possible sale.
!
" # 877-600-FUND(3863) Est. 2000 Matt King, who was Fan- The stock surged 12% to close
Duel’s chief financial officer from Monday at $20.54, its biggest
2014 to 2016, will succeed Mr. one-day gain in nearly four years.
MASTERMIND SEEKS Eccles, effective immediately, the The roughly eight million
Reduce Your Tax Liability EMPLOYMENT company said. share stake, or about 8.74% of
CONSERVATION EASEMENTS Please visit Mr. King was most recently a shares outstanding, would make
Eligible Deductions Available Now partner and president at insur- Jana the second-largest share-
256.390.2777 www.mastermindseeks.com ance company Cottingham & Jana says stock in Outback Steakhouse’s owner is undervalued. holder in the company, according
1-855-TAX-CUT-0 Butler. to FactSet data.
Conservation Easement Advisers, LLC
conservationeasements.net In July, FanDuel and Draft- BUSINESS EQUIPMENT October’s lending and lease On Monday, Jana said in a
TRAVEL Kings scrapped plans to merge originations by the respondents securities filing that it believes
after facing opposition from an- Loans and Leases fell 3% from September, but year Bloomin’s stock is undervalued
PARTNER WITH A Save Up To 60%
titrust regulators. Both compa- Rise to $8.4 Billion to date the volume is up 4% and plans to push for a review
nies, which allow players to as- from last year. of strategic alternatives, which
PHYSICIAN’S OFFICE First & Business semble virtual teams and Loans and leases for business Financing volume tends to could include a sale.
FDA APPROVED MEDICAL DEVICE INTERNATIONAL compete for cash, have had equipment rose 2% to $8.4 bil- weaken in the fall before surging The portfolio of Florida-based
EARN ON EVERY PATIENT TESTED Major Airlines, Corporate Travel
THE ULTIMATE IN PASSIVE INCOME Never Fly Coach Again!
trouble attracting enough new lion in October from a year ear- in December as companies rush Bloomin’ Brands also includes
CALL TODAY! (877) 670-1134 www.cooktravel.net players to make their business lier, according to a survey of 25 to complete budgeted purchases Carrabba’s Italian Grill and Bone-
Answered 7 days a week (800) 435-8776 models viable. major lenders by the Equipment before the end of the year. fish Grill.
—Cara Lombardo Leasing and Finance Association. —Bob Tita —Maria Armental
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. NY Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | B6A
Travel
LU X U RY
2018
Hotels You Need Nest, where you can trek to see mountain gorillas
in their natural habitat.Further south,in Botswana,
acclaimed conservation outfit Wilderness
to Know
Safaris will relaunch a new-build, new-look
Mombo Camp in the Moremi Game Reserve of
the Okavango Delta.
Across the Atlantic in Argentina, Awasi, the
uber-stylish eco brand, opens tiny Awasi Iguazu,
Is there ever a dull moment in the hotel industry? comprising 14 wooden villas a mere 15 minutes
Certainly there won't be in 2018, when the world welcomes from the famous falls. In the Chilean capital,
even more contenders to the stage, says Pamela Goodman Hotel Santiago is rebranding as a Mandarin
Oriental, the hotel group behind a similar
rebranding exercise is happening on the Caribbean
- Sleep in the Bali rainforest
T
aking a global overview, let’s start in island of Canouan, where The Pink Sands Club
Indonesia, where two new openings in will also adopt Mandarin Oriental management. at Capella Ubud.
Bali are about to steal the limelight. The much-loved Jumby Bay on Antigua switches
;
;
&
;
First up is Echo Beach from allegiance to the Oetker Collection, and beautiful
heavyweight design brand Como, which promises Cap Julucca on Anguilla, after a post-Hurricane
surfing, yoga and spa treatments on the south Irma refurbishment, will reopen toward the end In warmer climes,
coast; second is Capella Ubud, where 22 of the year under Belmond.
extravagant tents designed to capture the spirit of In Europe, London’s most exciting openings Seven Pines Resort
19th-century explorers are situated in the include The Bloomsbury Hotel by the Doyle
rainforest. And, new to the renowned diving Collection, a refashioning of a famous Edwin will be Ibiza's
waters of Raja Ampat and beyond, comes Lutyens building close to the British Museum,
the Kudanil Explorer. It boasts eight huge and L’Oscar, a high-design boutique hotel on new all-suite,
balconied cabins which are sold, like a hotel, on a Southampton Row.
cabin-by-cabin basis. Next, a jump to South-East In France, in the grounds of the iconic clifftop hotspot for
Asia where Shinta Mani Wild from The Bensley 16th-century Château de Chambord in the Loire
Collection is likely to be Cambodia’s most radical Valley, Relais de Chambord will open with freshly the summer
opening: a tented, jungle safari camp—accessed designed interiors under the management
via zip line—in a remote forest setting. Equally of Marugal hotels, while Belmond will launch
dramatic, albeit from an urban two new river-barge hotels, Pivoine and Lilas, in
perspective, Rosewood Hotels’ new venture in
- The elegant Sitting Room lobby, at The Champagne and Alsace respectively. The French
Cambodia will occupy the top 14 floors of Phnom Bloomsbury in London. show-stealer, however, will be the three new
Penh’s most iconic modern skyscraper—yet this
- Modern styling meets traditional Grand Suites aboard Belmond’s legendary train,
big brand can do tents, too, as will be seen in the refinement at the Rosewood, Phnom Penh. the Venice-Simplon-Orient-Express.
company’s first luxury tented villa encampment at Design Hotels has some interesting new
picturesque Luang Prabang in Laos.Off Malaysian members on the horizon, not least Hotel St.
shores, perennial favorite The Datai on the island Resorts opens the ambitious and long-awaited George in Helsinki, where art plays a pivotal role:
of Langkawi re-emerges in July 2018 after a major Amanyangun on Shanghai’s outskirts; and Edition a large sculpture of a dragon by Ai Weiwei will be
renovation project, while a fraction further north Hotels (set to open seven properties in 2018, in on display in the opening months.
in the little-known Andaman Islands, Taj cities including Bangkok, Abu Dhabi and New In warmer climes, Seven Pines Resort will be
Hotels is all set to open a luxury beach resort on York) will occupy two separate towers, just five Ibiza’s new all-suite, clifftop hotspot for the
Havelock Island. minutes’ walk from The Bund. In the Himalayan summer, and on the beautiful Greek island of
Heading north into China, Shanghai is where Kingdom of Bhutan, the so-called “happiest place Santorini the owners behind Vedema and
it’s at with no fewer than four signature on earth,” Six Senses opens five intimate lodges Mystique, two Starwood Luxury Collection
openings: Swire Hotels launches The Middle to create a scenic countryside trail. resorts, will open a small hotel on Perivolos beach,
House (to complement The Upper House in Hong To the Maldives next, where LUX* adds a the first of its kind on the island.
Kong and the Opposite House in Beijing); Rocco second property to its Maldivian portfolio, this one
Forte Hotels will take center stage at the city’s in the North Ari Atoll, while across the ocean in Pamela Goodman is a freelance writer and
new urban complex known as West Bund; Aman the Seychelles, Four Seasons does the same with a magazine travel editor.
T E C H N O L O G Y & T R AV E L
AT YOUR BLEISURE Smart business travelers are personalizing their work trips and adding in some down time, says Rachel Spratley
Once associated with back-to-back Spare time on a recent business trip objectives. And more than half of the profiles of each. This profile builds and experience for employees.
meetings and bland hotels, business to Kansas City allowed Dr. Sara companies in a Booking.com survey creates a more enhanced, personalized Activity-booking engine Musement
travel is now viewed by many employees Martin, from Santa Rosa, Calif., to from Sept. 2016 said that adding service with every conversation, (musement.com) acquired travel-
as a perk of the job. explore the city’s vibrant jazz scene. leisure time to their employees’ making it easier for business travelers content platform Triposo (triposo.
In June 2017, a study published by Such travel opportunities not only business trips improved performance to factor time- and cost-effective com) in Oct. 2017 in order to mix
the Global Business Travel Association strengthen Dr. Martin's professional in meetings, solidified relationships leisure breaks into work trips. Triposo’s travel recommendations with
(GBTA) revealed that 37% of North networks, but also allow her to discover and strengthened cultural Hotel review website and booking Musement’s bookable activities,
American business travelers had new cities and reconnect with family understanding. engine LuxuryBARED (www. thereby creating a more intuitive user
extended their trips at least once and friends. Consequently all types of technology luxurybared.com) features luxury experience.
during the past year to incorporate Booking.com acknowledged the companies across the travel industry hotel reviews from top industry Capitalizing on bleisure down-time
leisure time. bleisure traveler’s influence back in are streamlining and personalizing the professionals, and the website’s state- means that business travelers will have
And, with this number rising to 2015, when it launched Booking.com customer experience, shaking off the of-the-art booking technology far more interesting things
nearly half among the emerging for Business (booking.com/business) cookie-cutter stereotype of traditional connects viewers directly to those than work to talk about around the
millennial workforce, “bleisure” so companies could manage employees’ corporate travel. hotels’ reservation sites in order to offer water cooler.
(business combined with leisure) stays bookings and connect travelers with Mezi (mezi.com), a personal travel competitive rates and exclusive
are set to become a more significant accommodation that reflected both assistant application, is able to engage benefits, which means a good deal for Rachel Spratley is Junior Content
part of corporate travel. personal preferences and business-trip with users and keep living, dynamic companies and a first-class travel Editor for Sarah Miller and Partners.
WSJ. Custom Studios is a unit of The Wall Street Journal Advertising Department. • The Wall Street Journal news organization was not involved in the creation of this content.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B6B | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Time to change
where you buy
business travel.
POWERED BY
The Wall Street Journal Business Travel Service is operated independently of the Journal's news department.
All international and domestic travel must start in the U.S. and all buyers must be U.S.-based.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. NY Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | B6C
Six Senses
Krabey Island
in Cambodia.
WINTER SUN
Things Are
Hotting Up
Do you want to surf, hike,
or just chill on the beach?
It’s time to decide where you’ll
go to keep winter at bay,
says Francesca Syz
WINTER SPORTS
Whether you’re a Generation X-er looking to
unwind or a Generation Z-er embracing that
bucket list, at this time of year everyone craves
for 2018
of Coronado. “You can spend a few nights in
Honolulu before heading to another island. I
particularly like Lanai, which is often overlooked
but is just a short hop from Maui—and home to
the Four Seasons.”
With limited vacation time a reality for many, More lifts, more hotel rooms, more space on the slopes.
Hawaii and other easily reachable destinations Stephen Wood navigates this year’s winter-sports landscape
like California (be one of the first to experience
the re-vamped Ventana Big Sur, an Alila Resort),
Mexico (new suites at Esencia on the Riviera
Maya) and Costa Rica (fabulous year-round, but
S
even better in December when turtles nest their ki destinations are like currencies: they go
eggs) are hugely popular over the holiday season. up and down. Consider Switzerland, for
And what of the Caribbean in 2018? “Despite example. Until 1864 nobody sold ski
the ravages of Hurricane Irma, St. Barths is holidays there, but then, with a money-
back to business,” says Kristen Pike of KK Travels back-if-not-satisfied offer, an enterprising
Worldwide. Some hotels will remain closed hotelier in St. Moritz enticed some summer
over Christmas, she adds, but “it’s a great time to visitors to return in winter. The hotelier won his
support the destination and instead rent, wager, the Alpine winter holiday was born, and
say, a beautiful home through Eden Rock St. Moritz flourished. Switzerland, too.
Villa Rental.” A century-and-a-half later, selling ski holidays
British export Black Tomato has always in Switzerland is difficult: the strength of the
trailblazed with its destinations. This Christmas, franc makes them too expensive, even for some
it is sending winter-sun seekers to Nicaragua, to Swiss skiers. Hence the big news: “St. Moritz
be Robinson Crusoe’d in style at the exclusive slashes ski-pass prices.” This season, the resort
new Calala Island resort. One of the least- aims to attract even more skiers with the offer of
explored countries in Central America, Nicaragua a CHF38 (€33) per-day ski pass (reduced from
offers a unique combination of pristine nature, CHF79) for guests staying more than one night
colonial towns and gorgeous beaches on its in selected hotels.
;
;
FA M I LY C I T Y B R E A K S
HOMEWORK FOR THE HOLIDAYS Family spring breaks are for fun, but they can also help teenagers learn by stealth, says Claire Wrathall
Next year’s European Capital of Culture monnaiedeparis.fr), has opened an them Anya Gallaccio, Julie Mehretu
,
is Valletta (www.valletta2018.org) on inventive museum that tells the story of and Oscar Murillo. It may appeal more
the Mediterranean island of Malta, money and trade, with exhibits and to parents than their offspring, but the
promising a wide-ranging 140 arts interactive displays aimed at youngsters university has a host of other museums:
projects and 400 events, with more than and adults alike. Located on the Left of polar exploration; natural history;
1,000 artists and performers. In Bank, its vast site also incorporates a sciences; archeology and anthro-pology,
anticipation of this, two new places to contemporary art space and Guy and fine art in the Fitzwilliam.
stay will have opened: luxury hotelier Savoy’s three Michelin-star restaurant. In addition, there’s the highly
Gordon Campbell Gray’s recently Also this side of the Seine is the imaginative Museum of Technology in
remodeled, though still-stately Hotel Lutetia (www.hotellutetia.com), a former pumping station, the
Phoenicia (campbellgrayhotels.com), originally created by retail tycoon pioneering Centre for Computing
and the sleek Iniala Harbour House History, and the Norman Foster-
(iniala.com/malta). designed American Air Museum. In
The island’s great art treasures are the
Caravaggios in St. John’s co-cath-edral,
“Paris is eternally short, something for everyone and a
veritable inspiration to study.
two paintings with an extraordinary appealing, but there 2018 marks the centenary of the
backstory: a tale of murder and intrigue deaths of two innovators of the Vienna
that will engage all but the most are renewed reasons Secession, the artists Gustav Klimt and
resistant teenagers. Not that art is all
Valletta has to offer: there are megalithic
to visit it.” Egon Schiele, whose tortured figures
tend to resonate with the young. Not
ruins (the Tarxien Temples), the ancient surprisingly, the Austrian capital
forts of St. Elmo and St. Angelo, an Aristide Boucicault, who also founded - Egon Schiele's "Self-Portait with will honor them both with
armory, a prehistoric burial site in the France’s first modern department store, Lantern Fruits". The artist will be concurrent exhibitions: Klimt at the
Hal Saflieni Hypogeum, even an Le Bon Marché, reopening in spring honored with a major exhibition in Belvedere (www.belvedere.at) and
Inquis-itor’s Palace that boasts, for after a €100 million refit. Vienna in 2018. Kunsthistoriches (www.khm.at); Schiele
those with a robust constitution, a Meanwhile in the U.K., Kettle’s Yard
- The cigar lounge at Hotel at the Leopold (www.leopoldmuseum.
torture chamber. (kettlesyard.co.uk), Cambridge Lutetia, Paris. org); Wagner at the Wien Museum
Paris is eternally appealing, but there University’s modern and contemporary (wienmuseum.com).
are renewed reasons to visit. First, the art collection, will have reopened after
city’s historic functioning mint, a root-and-branch makeover with new Claire Wrathall writes about the arts
Monnaie de Paris (www. commissions from 38 artists, among and travel.
E D I T E D b y S A R A H M I L L E R f o r I LT M
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B6D | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 NY THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
The Wall Street Journal news organization is not involved in this partnership.
© 2017 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ6175
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | B7
IntlValEq
CapWGrA 52.29 -0.06 21.1 500IdxInstPrem 90.53 +0.12 17.4 H MCapGro 92.67 +0.34 23.0 LifeMod 26.95 +0.04 12.7
based in the Democratic Re- EupacA p 57.34 -0.01 29.8 500IdxPrem 90.53 +0.12 17.4 Harbor Funds MCapVal 31.46 +0.02 8.3 PrmcpCor 27.12 +0.13 22.3
FdInvA p 63.47 +0.05 18.8 33.27 +0.02 15.6
public of Congo. Investigators GwthA p 51.56 +0.06 22.6
ExtMktIdxPrem r 63.07 +0.31 14.9 CapApInst 76.54 +0.22 35.1 N Horiz 55.47 +0.05 28.1
SelValu r
IntlIdxPrem r 42.95 +0.03 21.7 IntlInst r 69.76 +0.04 19.4 STAR 27.24 +0.03 15.8
are probing financial state- HI TrA p 10.38 ... 6.1 N Inc 9.48 -0.01 3.6
SAIUSLgCpIndxFd 13.88 +0.02 17.4 Harding Loevner 10.65 -0.01 2.0
OverS SF r 11.29 +0.01 24.5 STIGrade
ments and disclosures by To- Copper from Katanga province, where Glencore has operations. ICAA p 41.01 ... 14.5 TMktIdxF r 75.15 +0.15 17.0 IntlEq NA ... NA R2020 23.23 +0.02 13.8
TgtRe2015 15.93 +0.01 9.8
IncoA p 23.32 +0.03 10.0 TMktIdxPrem 75.13 +0.14 16.9 TgtRe2020 31.63 +0.04 11.9
ronto-listed Katanga related to N PerA p 45.14 -0.01 27.8 USBdIdxInstPrem 11.58 -0.01 3.1 I R2025 17.92 +0.02 15.6
TgtRe2025 18.54 +0.02 13.4
26.41 +0.03 17.2
international bribery and anti- sulted in the inadvertent the Securities and Exchange NEcoA p 48.27 +0.19 34.3 Fidelity Advisor I Invesco Funds A
R2030
TgtRe2030 33.49 +0.04 14.7
NwWrldA 67.08 +0.14 30.4 R2035 19.32 +0.03 18.6
corruption laws, Glencore and dumping of a large amount of Commission with New York SmCpA p 56.79 +0.16 23.5
NwInsghtI 33.49 +0.05 25.4 EqIncA 11.22 -0.01 7.4 R2040 27.76 +0.04 19.6
TgtRe2035 20.57 +0.03 16.0
TgtRe2040 35.43 +0.05 17.3
Katanga Mining said in sepa- copper into a waste dam. hedge fund Och-Ziff Capital TxExA p 13.02 ... 5.0
Fidelity Freedom
FF2020 16.74 +0.01 13.5 J Value 38.89 +0.08 15.6
TgtRe2045 22.26 +0.04 17.8
rate statements disclosing the Glencore suspended opera- Management Group LLC. WshA p 45.22 +0.13 14.7 FF2025 14.49 +0.01 14.4 John Hancock Class 1
PRIMECAP Odyssey Fds
Growth r 36.86 +0.20 28.7
TgtRe2050 35.81 +0.06 17.8
investigation on Monday. tions at Katanga in 2015. The Justice Department B FF2030 18.16 +0.02 17.0 LSBalncd NA ... NA Principal Investors
TgtRetInc 13.58 +0.01 7.3
Freedom2020 K 16.75 +0.01 NS LSGwth TotIntBdIxInv 10.99 +0.01 2.2
Three Katanga directors, in- The Wall Street Journal re- said Och-Ziff went into busi- Baird Funds Freedom2025 K 14.49 +0.01 NS John Hancock Instl
NA ... NA DivIntlInst 13.92 +0.03 26.5
WellsI 26.94 +0.01 8.0
Prudential Cl Z & I
cluding Glencore’s billionaire ported in July that Glencore is ness with Mr. Gertler despite a AggBdInst 10.88 -0.01 3.8 Freedom2030 K 18.16 +0.01 NS DispValMCI 24.08 +0.07 12.2 TRBdZ 14.51 -0.01 5.7
Welltn 42.59 +0.02 11.1
CorBdInst 11.24 ... 4.2 Freedom2035 K 15.24 +0.01 NS JPMorgan Funds WndsrII 38.70 +0.01 11.2
copper chief, Aristotelis Mis- subject to an investigation by consultant’s warnings that he BlackRock Funds A Freedom2040 K 10.71 +0.01 NS MdCpVal L S VANGUARD INDEX FDS
takidis, are stepping down Canada’s OSC regarding more used political connections in GlblAlloc p 20.23 ... 11.3 Fidelity Invest
NA ... NA
500 238.99 +0.31 17.3
JPMorgan R Class Schwab Funds
from its board following an in- than $100 million in payments Congo to benefit himself and BlackRock Funds Inst Balanc 23.71 +0.01 14.3
CoreBond NA ... NA S&P Sel
ExtndIstPl 204.47 +1.02
40.40 +0.05 17.4 SmValAdml 55.46 +0.24
14.9
EqtyDivd 22.94 +0.01 12.4 BluCh 88.44 +0.16 34.0 8.0
ternal review that found “ma- Katanga Mining made to a his associates. GlblAlloc 20.36 ... 11.5 127.19 +0.23 30.0 TotBd2 10.72 ... 3.2
Contra L T
terial weaknesses” in the com- company owned by an Israeli The Justice Department said HiYldBd 7.79 ... 7.2 ContraK 127.19 +0.22 30.1 TotIntl 17.88 +0.03 23.7
StratIncOpptyIns 9.93 ... 4.1 Lazard Instl TIAA/CREF Funds
pany’s controls over financial businessman. An OSC spokes- a business associate of Och- Bridge Builder Trust
CpInc r 10.27 +0.02 10.5
EmgMktEq 19.66 -0.10 23.8 EqIdxInst
TotSt 64.68 +0.12
19.40 +0.04 16.9 VANGUARD INSTL FDS
16.8
DivIntl 41.42 +0.04 24.4
reporting, Glencore said. woman confirmed the agency Ziff’s, who people familiar with CoreBond NA ... NA GroCo 184.01 +0.09 34.5
Loomis Sayles Fds IntlEqIdxInst 20.16 +0.03 21.8 BalInst 34.13 +0.03 11.3
14.13 -0.01 6.6
Glencore nominated three has an active investigation re- the matter said is Mr. Gertler, GrowCoK 183.97 +0.09 34.6 LSBondI Tweedy Browne Fds DevMktsIndInst 14.14 +0.02 22.7
D Lord Abbett A GblValue 28.27 +0.07 12.9 DevMktsInxInst 22.10 +0.03 22.7
new directors to the board, in- garding Katanga Mining. paid more than $100 million in InvGB 7.92 -0.01 3.5
ShtDurIncmA p 4.26 ... 2.1 82.86 +0.42 14.9
Dimensional Fds InvGrBd 11.27 -0.01 3.9 ExtndInst
cluding its chief financial offi- The OSC investigation bribes to Congolese officials, 5GlbFxdInc 11.01 -0.01 2.1 LowP r 53.11 +0.19 15.9
Lord Abbett F V GrwthInst 70.92 +0.04 24.9
cer, Steven Kalmin. Katanga’s stems from payments Katanga though he hasn’t been charged. EmgMktVa 30.09 -0.07 27.4 LowPriStkK r 53.07 +0.18 16.0 ShtDurIncm 4.26 ... 2.4 VANGUARD ADMIRAL InPrSeIn 10.52 -0.01 2.3
EmMktCorEq 22.56 ... 31.9 MagIn 105.99 +0.20 22.8 500Adml 239.03 +0.31 17.4 InstIdx 235.83 +0.31 17.4
CFO, Jacques Lubbe, resigned, was expected to make to A spokesman for Mr. Gertler’s IntlCoreEq 14.11 +0.03 23.2 OTC 109.46 +0.11 37.4
M BalAdml 34.12 +0.03 11.3 InstPlus 235.85 +0.31 17.4
Katanga said. Glencore, in a sep- Congo’s state-run mining com- company, Fleurette, has denied IntlVal 19.75 +0.01 20.6 Puritn 23.14 +0.01 Metropolitan West
16.0 CAITAdml 11.79 -0.01 4.7 InstTStPlus 58.05 +0.11 16.9
arate statement Monday, said it pany, Gecamines, that were allegations of bribery. Daniel IntSmCo 21.25 +0.06 24.2 SrsEmrgMkt 21.76 +0.02 TotRetBd
38.6
TotRetBdI
NA
NA
...
...
NA
NA
CapOpAdml r156.54 +0.59 26.0 MidCpInst 41.22 +0.10 15.7
IntSmVa 23.03 +0.07 21.8 SrsGroCoRetail 18.07 +0.01 35.3 EMAdmr 37.40 +0.11 28.1 MidCpIstPl 203.31 +0.50 15.7
plans to implement “various instead sent to a Caymans Is- Och, chairman and chief execu- US CoreEq1 22.13 +0.07 16.2 SrsIntlGrw 16.31 +0.06 TRBdPlan
27.4 NA ... NA EqIncAdml 76.31 +0.18 13.8 SmCapInst 69.13 +0.32 12.9
structural and control changes” land company owned by the tive of Och-Ziff, has said the US CoreEq2 21.00 +0.08 14.1 SrsIntlVal 10.75 -0.01 MFS Funds Class I
17.4 ExtndAdml 82.86 +0.42 14.9 STIGradeInst 10.65 -0.01 2.1
36.45 +0.29 8.5 ValueI 40.41 +0.10 12.8 GNMAAdml 10.48 -0.02 1.8 TotBdInst 10.75 -0.01 3.2
across its copper department. businessman Dan Gertler, the firm’s conduct scrutinized by US Small TotalBond 10.66 -0.01 3.9
MFS Funds Instl GrwthAdml 70.92 +0.05 24.9 TotBdInst2 10.72
US SmCpVal 38.74 +0.28 4.1 Fidelity Selects ... 3.3
Monday’s disclosures reveal Journal reported. Glencore the Justice Department was “in- US TgdVal 25.15 +0.16 5.6 Biotech r 213.35 -1.35 22.6 IntlEq 25.41 +0.03 25.4 HlthCareAdml r 87.97 -0.64 16.1 TotBdInstPl 10.75 -0.01 3.2
a chaotic situation at the giant had acknowledged the shift in consistent with our core values.” USLgVa 39.05 +0.10 12.9 First Eagle Funds Mutual Series HYCorAdml r 5.91 +0.01 6.3 TotIntBdIdxInst 32.96 +0.02 2.3
60.25 -0.09 11.0 GlbDiscA 32.04 -0.01 6.5 InfProAd 25.82 -0.03 2.3 TotIntlInstIdx r119.61 +0.20 23.8
Congolese copper mine, in payments and said it was done Glencore in February pur- Dodge & Cox
Balanced 108.91 +0.09 8.8
GlbA
FPA Funds IntlGrAdml 95.54 +0.30 41.9 TotItlInstPlId r119.63 +0.20 23.8
which Glencore first invested at the request of Gecamines. chased Mr. Gertler’s stake in GblStock 13.89 +0.02 16.6 FPACres NA ... NA O ITBondAdml 11.38 -0.02 3.6 TotStInst 64.72 +0.12 16.9
in 2008 as it ramped up oper- Mr. Gertler was a central fig- Katanga Mining, as well as his Income 13.81 -0.01 3.9 FrankTemp/Frank Adv Oakmark Funds Invest ITIGradeAdml 9.78 -0.01 4.0 ValueInst 39.68 +0.08 11.6
Intl Stk 46.21 -0.01 21.3 IncomeAdv 2.32 ... 6.3 EqtyInc r 34.07 +0.10 12.0 LTGradeAdml 10.64 +0.01 9.7
ations. Recurring spills, power ure in a $412 million settlement stake in another jointly run Stock 201.48 +0.39 12.4 FrankTemp/Franklin A Oakmark 84.42 +0.18 16.5 MidCpAdml 186.61 +0.46 15.7 W
outages and plant modifica- in September 2016 between the Congo copper mine, for nearly DoubleLine Funds CA TF A p 7.47 ... 5.5 OakmrkInt 28.49 +0.03 25.5 MuHYAdml 11.41 -0.01 7.2 Western Asset
tions from 2010 to 2013 re- U.S. Justice Department and $1 billion including debt. TotRetBdI NA ... NA Fed TF A p 11.96 -0.01 3.1 Old Westbury Fds MuIntAdml 14.15 -0.01 4.4 CorePlusBdI NA ... NA
ADVERTISEMENT
Legal Notices
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
BANKRUPTCIES
:
M K==9 <KK7I=; 7 9 M 'I'9 ;=7';K 0 & " "
' # # ###%
B 95 ?5
+=
5 & !
%
5
=
) # "
) " "#
) +
&
$
+
)
-,
)
% +
!"#$ !% &'( ) &'' *%
,
)
" & +
+
"
&'' +' # ! @,
' 0 #
' 1
"
#
"
"
&
,-. , /
' # #
/
" &
0 ) %
#$ P 13 9 :
* Q''= " "
" "
/ 1 2 3 45 K5=A
8 !# $% ) # "
) "
) # "
) "
6##
% 71389
13
+
32
&
2
"
:
- * 13 9 :
* ::2C " "
"
"
"
&
;<< = >5 5,5 ?? @9
5A Q=5'I
+
&
) "
) " $ %
! !#
! %
" 6 7) ::2 QKI5;
) # " $ $" "" "
89 B
5A ;
. $" "" " " "
)
%
!# "
" 6 7 $% P 13 9 :
* QK5K; " "
##
+
. )
" - 2 +
"%
- :: C P 13 9 :
* "
" "
#' D ## #C Q5
Q5
"
"
&
& &
#
% 7$% ### #
& E##% I * +
.
- *&%
,
'
(): , 5 P
Q=5'I
13
"
0 # '' % C +
Q=
%
&
%
'' # ! # C
1
-
2
" "
1
"
5
F- -
*9. "
) " +
5 3+
4
*5 +
G P >, 1 45 13H F " " - " + "
6
-
% # F
<A & # ' ###% #$ *&
+
5
F >, 1 45 :7 9
. . 9
0 9 . . 9
3 . 9
+
"
"# % % #C'# ' #
- 3
-
. 9
*1 3. 9 1C %
>: : - : -
* : : >, 1 45
- 3
. 9 >,.
9 > . 9
555 4 * C
2
" " "
13 : - :
: -
9 *1
';A
C . -9
+ . )9
+
) " +
" "
, !
, ! E##%
F >, 1 45 :7 . % #% &#' !##
" , * # *
! #
6 7E##% P : 1 > , . 9
:
3
, * # *
895
13 >:
,
: , 9
)9
3 -
%+
" &
, *
!" #
$$
%
: ,
. 3 H
- H C # *
& ,
& '(&) *+ , -
P * 2 , /
* , /
, - F
C * # * &
" + -
. ,
#
#
# #% #% #%% ## ## ' 32: * ##
% # # ###%
' '(& (/(( )) 0
1
, >:
(): , .
: F
C
/ 9
. . 9 - ::
,
:C
)
*+ , 0 2
%
31) P ,
: ,
- :: : ,
: . 9
- 3
0
+' % # % #' #% #
,# - : C
-
. 9
*1 3. 9 1. 9 >,.
:
*
- (): , .
13 Q<5=
# #
#C 9 > .
9
+
:
#% # #
E##%
# C !# )
' C
:
5
0 :: . 9
'
+' # #
0 :: Q=5
$,
) #
% :
0 :: . -9
5 !#
' C
&
+ . )9
:
- 4,
, 56
&#' !## ' #
32% 4 + " 3 -
3H
-
F
. C ,
3 3 .
&
" - H F
-C
-
* / P >, 1 45 > R
:
" # # ' ### #% '
C
9 . 13 *C
" " " - :
9 :
(): 0
4 (): 0 R
> 13 #
& & & 0
# #
#
! # # ' : >,5
+ &
:
5
(): ,. #
' # # 0 & " "
% 6
) 72 #) 82' 9,) 7 ))/. 8:, ,* 2' /#*
6% "# % : - 13H
: 5
C
& "
& 8 ;8 8/,<#2,8*) ,))= 8 >=, 28 #, = )=#*2 28
# % "# ' ##% ( #
% # # # C *-.- /
% 2' /#* 8 2' 8*;, ?#2,8* 8 #// *2,2,) 2'#2 '#: '/
13.
*5" & " " & '8/ 8 ?#. '8/ /#,?) 8 ,*2 )2) 2'#2 '#: * /#)
9
:
- . 6 ) )
* +
= )=#*2 28 2' /#* ,*/=,*< #*. /#,?) #)) 2 ,* 8*%
9 -
, )
> (): ,
,
# "
% *2,8* 9,2' 8 2'#2 8=/ '#: * #)) 2 ,* 8**2,8*
:
,
! # # !
##%
&
" #
% 9,2' 2' *-.- /,2,<#2,8* 8,*< )'#// ,)'# < = %
A
1 0 .5 .H
/
3 L
" #
) )
)=#*2 28 2' /#* 8 # )=@2 28 7=/#2,8* = )=#*2 28
:
. ,# A * +
2' /#* # ?#**2/. *@8,* ; 8? #* #;2 2' ;;%
6 ###%
9
2
13H
: - : . /
* 3 L ,
# " *-.- /
2,: #2 ; 8? 2#A,*< #*. 8; 2' ;8//89,*< #2,8*) #<#,*)2
; -
(): ,
,# A & & &
" #) #/,#/ 2' 28 ) 2' 8 <#*,B 28 ) 8 2'
6 ###%
% #
# %
'
% !7889 ) K;5=A 7
/#) # 2,)C , 8??*,*< 8 8*2,*=,*< ,* #*. ?#*%
: '/(( )) 0
1 " )# 3 L
;<5A& ! #$ * #*. #2,8* 8 82' 8,*< 8; #*. A,* 8* #8=*2
; '(& / 9 13
3 4
* ;5=A 7
& 8; 8 ,* 8**2,8* 9,2' 8 9,2' )2 28 #*. )=' /#,?)
I )# 3 L
5) '' 5/
3 . 9 :: 13 6)
5;A & &
8 ,*2 )2) ,*/=,*< 9,2' )2 28 2' 7'#*< = )=%
2 3 44* <
4 ,
+ ''=I 5/ *) J5
1 '
" "% #*2 28 9',' 2' #,2,8*#/ *82) 9 ,))=5 ,, *;8 ,*<
3 L
J5 *5,5 1 35 * . 9
& ,# ,# A "
& & #22#',*< 8//2,*< 8 8: ,*< . #*. ?#** 8 ?#*)
6 ###%
13H 0 3
<
!
#*. @=<?*2 #9# 8 8 #<#,*)2 )=' *2,2,)
5) 5) ;7' 5/ 4 05 ) )##% 3 L ) # "
) "
8* #8=*2 8; 8 ,* 8**2,8* 9,2' 8 9,2' )2 28 #*.
,# A
1 4) . 9
# ) ) 6 ###%
)
% )=' /#,?) 8 ,*2 )2)5 ,,, #2,*< ;2,*< 8 *;8 %
) 1 2 , 44* K 4 5) 5) ) 3 L
" & ,*< #*. /,* 8 *=? #* 8; #*. A,* #<#,*)2 )=' *2,2,)
,# A
=7I< 5/
5 0
* . 9 13 6 ###% 1
"
8 2' 8 2. 8 2' )2#2) 8; )=' *2,2,) 8* #8=*2 8;
+
.
44* ;=
6
!
" " 8 ,* 8**2,8* 9,2' 8 9,2' )2 28 #*. )=' /#,?) 8
5) 5) <' 5/
J5 ( 35
0 # # "# D## #
C "
) " ,*2 )2)5 ,: #)) 2,*< #*. ,<'2 8; )28;; )= 8<#2,8* 8
1 . 9
# &#
L+++
*
# 5
& 8=?*2 8; #*. A,* #<#,*)2 #*. 8/,<#2,8* = ; 8? )='
2 1 44*
5) 5) <'7 "5 : 5 < " : ? 5? ?
" "
" *2,2,) 8 #<#,*)2 2' 8 2. 8; )=' *2,2,) 8* #8=*2 8;
KI 5/ 1 5 1 :
7 . 9 ? ? ?B ?5? ? C 5?
&
8 ,* 8**2,8* 9,2' 8 9,2' )2 28 #*. )=' /#,?) 8
:: 13H
: . 9
/- 5:5? "5 4" * <<) ) "
) # " $ ,*2 )2) =*/)) )=' *2,2. '#) 2,?/. #)) 2 )=' )28;;
> >5 5 3 /- ( L)
4
D# 5 $" "" ,<'2 ,* # 8=?*2 ;,/ 9,2' 2' #*A =2. 8= 2 7/,,2/.
' 5) 5) I. 29
2 :
F 13
- " " "
) :,*< )=' )28;; #* *829,2')2#*,*< #* ,*,#2,8* 8;
: F : (): 0 5
: 13 F
>5 5 ?5 F )
# /#,? 8 ,*2 )2 8 82' 9,) 2'#2 )=' *2,2. #)) 2) '#)
- 13 :
:C : <I
(): "
8 ,*2*) 28 ) : #*. ,<'2 8; )28;; = )=#*2 28 #/,%
13H 9 , 5
* "
"
#/ /#9 8 82' 9,)5 #* : 8??*,*< 8 8*2,*=,*< ,*
): : -
(): ,H )
=
* . 5
- *&% #*. ?#** #*. #2,8* 8 82' 8,*< 8; #*. A,* 8*
13 :
- 13H
: 5 /
4, 5
>: -
:
#8=*2 8; 8 ,* 8**2,8* 9,2' 8 9,2' )2 28 #*. )='
-
-
()C : : - 13H
:
%
/#,?) 8 ,*2 )2) /#) 8 )22/ = )=#*2 28 2' /#*-
: ,5 56
,
(): ,H - 555
2
"
-
, , *,30 : *,30 :
*,30 " "
) "
,:9
-
*+ , )
:/BB: 5:559
+
" "
" , *
*5
*
:: 2
<
, =
:/BB 5: )5B 5 # * , * # * % # '
-
,
,
$
, *
# *
=
,
%+
" & "
6 7# !895
, +
6
!
&
&
" + -
F-
*5 +
*+ , , ,
)
&' # ' ###% #$
G
>) 6% +
' # +
###
*
*
5
4,
5
!
### #'
# "
# # ! % " #$
% 0 % # # %
) #
/ 9
* , ) 44,
8!#
&
" % ## #
555 4 * . 9
- 3
-C
'$% :
M K==9 <KK7I=; 7 9 M 'I'9 ;=7
5
. 9
*1 3. 9 1. 9 >,. 9 > . 9
I
';K B 9. 9 13 N: )5 &
"
555 4 * .
9
+ . 9 0 :- :: 5
8138
-
. <9
13H
" " #
"%
.
0 9 .
3 . -9
&
0 #"# #
% + )
:/BB 5: )5B 5 &
" :
.
0 9 .
3 +
3 3 5
3
13H
: : "
3 9
9
3C
0 #"# #
% +
-
:
-
, )
#$ & &
H -
3 H
QKI5;
3 3
E##%
! # " O# '
" (
" - H - F
< : >, 1 45H
0 IK 4
* 5) '
8, )H /- 895 + #
&
) )
* +
6' # #% #%% F5
;5=A 5;A
: - 13H
: :
,
# " ## ## ' ###
, 1
>, 1 45H
13H
:/BB 5: )5B 5 *-.- /
& & : - : F :
# # % & + & % ##
# #
5
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B8 | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
23430.33 s 72.09, or 0.31% Trailing P/E ratio 20.63 20.68 2582.14 s 3.29, or 0.13% Trailing P/E ratio 24.44 24.19 6790.71 s 7.92, or 0.12% Trailing P/E ratio * 26.10 23.75
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 19.17 17.74 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 19.36 18.25 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 21.25 19.12
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.19 2.53 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.93 2.14 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.05 1.25
All-time high 23563.36, 11/08/17 All-time high: 2594.38, 11/08/17 All-time high: 6793.29, 11/16/17
30-year fixed-rate 3.00 1.50 Uruguay peso .03400 29.4100 0.2 Poland zloty .2774 3.6052 –13.9
mortgage Cherry Hill, NJ 609-216-7912 –5
Venezuela b. fuerte .095616 10.4585 4.6 Russia ruble .01686 59.328 –3.2
2.00 Great American Lending 3.75% 0.75 s Yen
t –10 s Asia-Pacific Sweden krona .1179 8.4832 –6.9
North Ogden, UT 800-706-6648 One year ago
t
WSJ
TR/CC CRB Index -1.18 166.50
stocks, new highs/lows and mutual funds. Plus, Compare the performance of selected global stock Crude oil, $ per barrel 56.09 -0.46 -0.81 57.35 42.53 18.11 4.41
deeper money-flows data and email delivery of key indexes, bond ETFs, currencies and commodities at Natural gas, $/MMBtu 3.047 -0.050 -1.61 3.93 2.56 3.29 -18.18
.COM WSJ.com/TrackTheMarkets
stock-market data. Available free at WSJMarkets.com Gold, $ per troy oz. 1274.60 -21.20 -1.64 1346.00 1127.80 5.37 10.83
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | B9
COMMODITIES WSJ.com/commodities
Metal & Petroleum Futures Milk (CME)-200,000 lbs., cents per lb. Currency Futures
Agriculture Futures Nov 16.79 16.83 16.78 16.83 .04 4,342
Contract Open Dec 15.25 15.44 15.25 15.40 .13 4,320 Japanese Yen (CME)-¥12,500,000; $ per 100¥
Open High hi lo Low Settle Chg interest Corn (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Cocoa (ICE-US)-10 metric tons; $ per ton. Dec .8926 .8949 .8881 .8885 –.0044 266,047
Copper-High (CMX)-25,000 lbs.; $ per lb. Dec 342.50 345.25 341.50 345.00 2.00 466,868 March'18 .8978 .8992 .8930 .8933 –.0043 4,669
Dec 2,105 2,105 2,066 2,084 –42 473
Nov 3.0510 3.0885 3.0510 3.0905 0.0280 286 March'18 354.50 357.00 353.25 356.50 1.50 652,379 March'18 2,120 2,121 2,081 2,089 –42 137,469
Canadian Dollar (CME)-CAD 100,000; $ per CAD
March'18 3.0950 3.1165 3.0730 3.1155 0.0245 115,692 Oats (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Dec .7833 .7843 .7801 .7809 –.0028 135,640
Coffee (ICE-US)-37,500 lbs.; cents per lb. March'18 .7839 .7847 .7811 .7818 –.0028 3,553
Gold (CMX)-100 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Dec 256.25 256.75 251.25 255.00 –2.00 2,692 Dec 122.50 123.70 121.15 122.90 –.90 10,974
Nov 1275.90 1275.90 1275.90 1274.60 –21.20 10 March'18 270.50 272.00 267.50 271.00 –1.25 4,382 British Pound (CME)-£62,500; $ per £
March'18 126.90 127.20 124.85 125.75 –1.50 120,438 Dec 1.3226 1.3290 1.3196 1.3247 .0019 168,504
Dec 1294.10 1295.10 1274.10 1275.30 –21.20 268,091 Soybeans (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Sugar-World (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. March'18 1.3253 1.3329 1.3240 1.3290 .0019 3,630
Feb'18 1300.00 1300.00 1278.50 1279.70 –21.20 212,772 Jan 990.00 992.00 983.00 990.00 –.50 319,186 15.30 15.30 14.92 14.98 –.39 400,124
April 1302.00 1303.60 1282.90 1284.00 –21.20 23,469
March Swiss Franc (CME)-CHF 125,000; $ per CHF
March 1000.75 1002.75 994.00 1001.25 –.25 143,963 May 15.29 15.29 14.92 14.99 –.34 137,117 Dec 1.0120 1.0140 1.0080 1.0085 –.0049 82,841
June 1305.40 1306.70 1287.20 1288.30 –21.10 22,192 Soybean Meal (CBT)-100 tons; $ per ton.
Dec 1318.90 1318.90 1301.20 1301.50 –21.10 11,468
Sugar-Domestic (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. March'18 1.0208 1.0212 1.0157 1.0159 –.0048 300
Dec 318.60 320.30 315.30 319.80 1.60 63,897 March 27.32 27.32 27.32 27.32 –.01 2,794 Australian Dollar (CME)-AUD 100,000; $ per AUD
Palladium (NYM) - 50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Jan'18 320.30 322.20 317.50 322.00 2.00 122,796 Cotton (ICE-US)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Dec .7555 .7572 .7541 .7544 –.0020 128,157
Dec 990.45 998.25 982.75 986.10 –6.80 20,346 Jan'18 .7551 .7563 .7544 .7542 –.0020 630
March'18 987.90 993.45 979.15 982.45 –6.35 14,711
Soybean Oil (CBT)-60,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Dec 69.80 71.50 69.79 71.37 1.59 12,492
Dec 34.38 34.42 33.69 33.95 –.49 94,943 March'18 69.42 70.92 69.41 70.85 1.50 148,077 Feb .7551 .7569 .7546 .7541 –.0020 583
June 981.55 982.90 981.55 975.45 –6.75 411 March .7551 .7565 .7539 .7540 –.0020 1,280
Platinum (NYM)-50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Jan'18 34.51 34.56 33.85 34.10 –.49 138,175 Orange Juice (ICE-US)-15,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
June .7541 .7541 .7541 .7538 –.0020 264
Nov 928.20 928.20 926.40 920.40 –31.00 4 Rough Rice (CBT)-2,000 cwt.; $ per cwt. Dec … … s … 166.80 …
Jan'18 166.15 167.70 166.10 167.30 .50 7,522
Mexican Peso (CME)-MXN 500,000; $ per MXN
Jan'18 954.20 954.20 921.80 923.60 –31.00 70,601 Jan 1228.50 1238.00 1214.00 1237.50 9.00 9,186 Dec .05256 .05259 .05222 .05239 –.00019 181,568
Silver (CMX)-5,000 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. March 1251.50 1266.50 1241.00 1266.00 10.00 1,090 March'18 .05155 .05160 .05145 .05160 –.00019 809
Nov ... ... ... 16.827 –0.531 3 Wheat (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Interest Rate Futures Euro (CME)-€125,000; $ per €
Dec 17.335 17.335 16.820 16.842 –0.531 97,984 Dec 427.75 428.00 419.25 422.00 –5.25 134,999 Dec 1.1787 1.1827 1.1740 1.1750 –.0066 457,904
Crude Oil, Light Sweet (NYM)-1,000 bbls.; $ per bbl. Treasury Bonds (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% March'18 1.1854 1.1895 1.1812 1.1820 –.0065 7,195
March'18 443.00 443.75 436.00 438.50 –5.00 241,033
Dec 56.69 56.76 55.57 56.09 –0.46 29,051 Dec 154-010 154-140 153-190 153-210 –4.0 748,630
Wheat (KC)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. March'18 152-290 153-100 152-160 152-170 –4.0 60,533
Jan'18 56.80 56.93 55.75 56.42 –0.29 587,805 Dec 422.00 422.50 414.25 416.00 –6.00 64,714 Index Futures
Feb 56.88 56.98 55.85 56.53 –0.28 190,458 Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
March'18 439.00 439.75 431.75 433.75 –5.75 161,202 Dec 124-310 125-045 124-220 124-220 –7.0 3,282,603 Mini DJ Industrial Average (CBT)-$5 x index
March 56.93 57.00 55.90 56.60 –0.27 300,909
Wheat (MPLS)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. March'18 124-230 124-280 124-135 124-135 –6.5 196,713 Dec 23318 23427 23241 23395 79 152,299
June 56.55 56.69 55.67 56.36 –0.29 234,318
Dec 636.50 636.50 625.75 626.25 –8.75 24,084 5 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% March'18 23326 23418 23236 23389 82 2,518
Dec 54.84 54.87 53.91 54.54 –0.27 263,048
NY Harbor ULSD (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. March'18 650.00 651.00 639.25 639.75 –10.25 35,002 Dec 116-312 117-015 116-245 116-245 –5.5 3,188,291 S&P 500 Index (CME)-$250 x index
Dec 1.9467 1.9500 1.9056 1.9321 –.0145 67,932 Cattle-Feeder (CME)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. March'18 116-247 116-275 116-182 116-185 –5.2 189,072 Dec 2574.40 2583.10 2567.80 2582.10 5.80 65,885
Jan'18 1.9493 1.9522 1.9081 1.9343 –.0143 126,648 Jan 151.000 151.850 149.300 149.550 –2.175 27,250 2 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$200,000; pts 32nds of 100% March'18 2579.50 2583.60 2578.60 2583.00 5.90 5,180
Gasoline-NY RBOB (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. March 149.375 150.200 147.775 148.050 –2.075 16,881 Dec 107-155 107-162 107-137 107-137 –1.5 1,768,384 Mini S&P 500 (CME)-$50 x index
Cattle-Live (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Dec 2576.00 2584.00 2567.75 2582.00 5.75 3,205,145
Dec 1.7455 1.7479 1.7174 1.7438 –.0009 73,663 March'18 107-105 107-110 107-080 107-082 –2.0 160,706
March'18 2577.00 2584.75 2568.75 2583.00 6.00 96,272
Jan'18 1.7480 1.7480 1.7148 1.7378 –.0064 178,201 Dec 118.500 118.800 116.775 117.100 –1.750 56,209 30 Day Federal Funds (CBT)-$5,000,000; 100 - daily avg. Mini S&P Midcap 400 (CME)-$100 x index
Natural Gas (NYM)-10,000 MMBtu.; $ per MMBtu. Feb'18 124.275 124.500 122.650 123.025 –1.650 155,663 Nov 98.843 98.845 98.843 98.843 … 206,345 Dec 1838.50 1848.70 s 1833.40 1847.10 6.90 93,314
Dec 3.070 3.089 3.026 3.047 –.050 74,121 Hogs-Lean (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Jan'18 98.610 98.610 t 98.605 98.610 … 341,998 Mini Nasdaq 100 (CME)-$20 x index
Jan'18 3.165 3.179 3.125 3.140 –.051 326,218 Dec 60.825 62.425 60.775 62.025 1.375 43,715 10 Yr. Del. Int. Rate Swaps (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% Dec 6312.0 6329.3 6291.3 6316.0 2.8 288,828
Feb 3.161 3.176 3.124 3.141 –.049 109,951 Feb'18 67.300 68.950 66.975 68.475 1.400 92,977 Dec 101.125 101.125 100.766 100.766 –.219 28,064 March'18 6332.3 6346.3 6308.0 6332.0 2.5 2,377
March 3.123 3.138 3.088 3.107 –.045 180,135 Lumber (CME)-110,000 bd. ft., $ per 1,000 bd. ft. Mini Russell 2000 (ICE-US)-$100 x index
1 Month Libor (CME)-$3,000,000; pts of 100%
April 2.941 2.957 2.929 2.948 –.013 126,335 438.50 440.30 429.70 429.70 –10.00 5,679 Dec 1492.90 1504.40 1486.30 1504.00 11.10 67,326
Jan Dec 98.5400 98.5425 t 98.5375 98.5400 … 2,264
May 2.929 2.941 2.915 2.933 –.010 96,909 March'18 1504.00 1505.00 1504.00 1505.50 11.60 139
March 426.90 428.90 417.60 418.00 –9.60 901 Jan'18 98.5200 98.5200 t 98.5200 98.5225 –.0025 1,054
Mini Russell 1000 (ICE-US)-$100 x index
Eurodollar (CME)-$1,000,000; pts of 100% Dec 1431.10 1432.90 1430.20 1432.90 3.80 298
Dec 98.4575 98.4625 98.4500 98.4500 –.0075 1,632,388 U.S. Dollar Index (ICE-US)-$1,000 x index
Cash Prices | WSJ.com/commodities Monday, November 20, 2017 March'18 98.3000 98.3050
June 98.1650 98.1700
98.2700 98.2750 –.0200 1,403,777
98.1300 98.1350 –.0250 1,266,341
Dec
March'18
93.73
93.41
94.02
93.69
93.49
93.18
94.00
93.68
.42
.42
38,327
2,732
These prices reflect buying and selling of a variety of actual or “physical” commodities in the marketplace— Dec 98.0100 98.0250 97.9650 97.9700 –.0400 1,631,076 Source: SIX Financial Information
separate from the futures price on an exchange, which reflects what the commodity might be worth in future
months.
Monday Monday Monday Bonds | WSJ.com/bonds
(U.S.$ equivalent) 17.1450 Soybeans,No.1 yllw IL-bp,u 9.3950
Energy Coins,wholesale $1,000 face-a 12749 Wheat,Spring14%-pro Mnpls-u 7.7625 Tracking Bond Benchmarks
Propane,tet,Mont Belvieu-g 0.9974 Other metals Wheat,No.2 soft red,St.Louis-bp,u 4.3350
Butane,normal,Mont Belvieu-g 1.0405 LBMA Platinum Price PM *937.0 Wheat - Hard - KC (USDA) $ per bu-u 3.7850
Return on investment and spreads over Treasurys and/or yields paid to investors compared with 52-week
Correcting previous 1.0625 Platinum,Engelhard industrial 938.0 Wheat,No.1soft white,Portld,OR-u 5.2600 highs and lows for different types of bonds
NaturalGas,HenryHub-i 3.050 Platinum,Engelhard fabricated 1038.0 Total Total
NaturalGas,TranscoZone3-i 3.000 Palladium,Engelhard industrial 1005.0
Food return YTD total Yield (%) return YTD total Yield (%)
NaturalGas,TranscoZone6NY-i 2.960 Palladium,Engelhard fabricated 1105.0 close return (%) Index Latest Low High close return (%) Index Latest Low High
Beef,carcass equiv. index
NaturalGas,PanhandleEast-i 2.580 Aluminum, LME, $ per metric ton *2077.0 choice 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 187.44 Mortgage-Backed Bloomberg Barclays
NaturalGas,Opal-i 2.780
Broad Market Bloomberg Barclays
Copper,Comex spot 3.0905 select 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 170.44
NaturalGas,MarcellusNE PA-i 2.430 Iron Ore, 62% Fe CFR China-s 62.3 1938.49 3.1 U.S. Aggregate 2.680 2.380 2.790 1984.20 2.2 Mortgage-Backed 2.890 2.660 3.120
Broilers, National comp wghtd-u,w 0.8580
NaturalGas,HaynesvilleN.LA-i 2.930 Shredded Scrap, US Midwest-s,w 276 1.7
Butter,AA Chicago 2.2100 U.S. Corporate Indexes Bloomberg Barclays 1951.15 Ginnie Mae (GNMA) 2.840 2.630 3.090
Coal,C.Aplc.,12500Btu,1.2SO2-r,w 59.850 Steel, HRC USA, FOB Midwest Mill-s 621 Cheddar cheese,bbl,Chicago 164.00
Coal,PwdrRvrBsn,8800Btu,0.8SO2-r,w 12.100 2773.08 5.4 U.S. Corporate 3.270 3.030 3.520 1163.73 2.4 Fannie mae (FNMA) 2.900 2.670 3.120
Fibers and Textiles Cheddar cheese,blk,Chicago 160.00
Metals Milk,Nonfat dry,Chicago lb. 71.50 2612.25 3.6 Intermediate 2.860 2.530 3.010 1792.03 2.5 Freddie Mac (FHLMC) 2.910 2.680 3.130
Burlap,10-oz,40-inch NY yd-n,w 0.6150 Cocoa,Ivory Coast-w 2381
Gold, per troy oz Cotton,1 1/16 std lw-mdMphs-u 0.7010 3848.06 9.5 Long term 4.150 4.100 4.710 521.27 4.5 Muni Master 2.056 1.736 2.516
Coffee,Brazilian,Comp 1.2246
Engelhard industrial 1292.84 Cotlook 'A' Index-t *79.80 Coffee,Colombian, NY 1.4219 565.89 3.9 Double-A-rated 2.760 2.470 2.870 364.61 5.0 7-12 year 2.045 1.744 2.618
Engelhard fabricated 1389.80 Hides,hvy native steers piece fob-u 61.000 Eggs,large white,Chicago-u 1.5750
Handy & Harman base 1286.20 Wool,64s,staple,Terr del-u,w n.a. 715.55 6.0 Triple-B-rated 3.560 3.340 3.870 409.83 6.2 12-22 year 2.456 2.213 3.047
Flour,hard winter KC 15.55
Handy & Harman fabricated 1427.68
LBMA Gold Price AM *1283.85
Grains and Feeds Hams,17-20 lbs,Mid-US fob-u 0.76 High Yield Bonds Merrill Lynch 396.49 6.8 22-plus year 2.863 2.770 3.622
LBMA Gold Price PM *1284.35 Hogs,Iowa-So. Minnesota-u 63.07 Global Government J.P. Morgan†
Barley,top-quality Mnpls-u n.a. 414.80 6.7 High Yield Constrained 5.819 5.373 6.649
Krugerrand,wholesale-e 1326.52 Pork bellies,12-14 lb MidUS-u 1.4208
Bran,wheat middlings, KC-u 93
Maple Leaf-e 1339.28 Pork loins,13-19 lb MidUS-u 0.8446 414.53 7.8 Triple-C-rated 10.842 9.584 12.812 544.46 1.4 Global Government 1.420 1.300 1.560
Corn,No. 2 yellow,Cent IL-bp,u 3.1900
American Eagle-e 1339.28 93.1 Steers,Tex.-Okla. Choice-u n.a.
Corn gluten feed,Midwest-u,w 2843.70 6.0 High Yield 100 5.584 4.948 6.220 755.64 0.3 Canada 2.040 1.570 2.190
Mexican peso-e 1545.87 Corn gluten meal,Midwest-u,w 483.9 Steers,feeder,Okla. City-u,w 170.88
Austria crown-e 1253.25 Cottonseed meal-u,w 225 377.06 7.1 Global High Yield Constrained 5.274 4.934 6.300 372.80 1.0 EMU§ 1.039 0.933 1.363
Fats and Oils
Austria phil-e 1339.28 Hominy feed,Cent IL-u,w 95 715.26 1.2 France 0.770 0.710 1.210
Corn oil,crude wet/dry mill-u,w 34.8500
306.04 6.6 Europe High Yield Constrained 2.299 1.897 3.814
Silver, troy oz. Meat-bonemeal,50% pro Mnpls-u,w 213
Engelhard industrial 17.1500 Oats,No.2 milling,Mnpls-u 2.8750 Grease,choice white,Chicago-h 0.2500 U.S Agency Bloomberg Barclays 510.07 -0.9 Germany 0.430 0.210 0.620
Engelhard fabricated 20.5800 Rice, 5% Broken White, Thailand-l,w 374.00 Lard,Chicago-u n.a.
1637.81 2.0 U.S Agency 2.090 1.660 2.090 288.48 0.1 Japan 0.390 0.270 0.460
Handy & Harman base 16.9300 Rice, Long Grain Milled, No. 2 AR-u,w 25.00 Soybean oil,crude;Centl IL-u 0.3308
Handy & Harman fabricated 21.1630 Sorghum,(Milo) No.2 Gulf-u 7.6338 Tallow,bleach;Chicago-h 0.2650 1463.51 1.2 10-20 years 1.950 1.460 1.950 563.55 -0.5 Netherlands 0.540 0.360 0.760
LBMA spot price £12.9400 SoybeanMeal,Cent IL,rail,ton48%-u 316.30 Tallow,edible,Chicago-u 0.3400
3370.32 7.8 20-plus years 2.930 2.730 3.460 921.81 0.9 U.K. 1.580 1.340 1.790
KEY TO CODES: A=ask; B=bid; BP=country elevator bids to producers; C=corrected; E=Manfra,Tordella & Brooks; G=ICE; H=Hurley Brokerage; I=Natural Gas Intelligence; 2453.52 4.6 Yankee 2.920 2.610 3.090 799.98 8.2 Emerging Markets ** 5.596 5.279 6.290
L=livericeindex.com; M=midday; N=nominal; n.a.=not quoted or not available; R=SNL Energy; S=Platts-TSI; T=Cotlook Limited; U=USDA; W=weekly, Z=not quoted. *Data *Constrained indexes limit individual issuer concentrations to 2%; the High Yield 100 are the 100 largest bonds † In local currency § Euro-zone bonds
as of 11/17
Source: WSJ Market Data Group ** EMBI Global Index Sources: Merrill Lynch; Bloomberg Barclays; J.P.Morgan
lan officials with direct knowl- can and lives in London, has
edge of the matter. benefited from Latin American
The government sought Mr. bond restructurings before,
Martínez’s advice as it was buying distressed debt at a
running out of money and fraction of its face value. He
overdue bond payments were has said he has participated in
piling up. Days after the meet- almost every sovereign re-
ing, President Nicolás Maduro structuring in the past quar-
went on state television to say ter-century. After Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro said he wanted to restructure the country’s debt, its bonds initially went into a tailspin.
he wanted to restructure the Mr. Martínez made a big
country’s debt. To lead the ne- bet on Argentina’s distressed Aissami invited investors to a El Aissami was appointed to them from unpaid investors ready distressed bonds went
gotiations, he appointed Mr. El debt, allying himself with Ar- presentation in Caracas last head Mr. Maduro’s debt-re- who may try to seize the re- into a tailspin, before recover-
Aissami, whom the U.S. sanc- gentina’s late president, Nés- week to discuss the restructur- structuring task force, the public’s assets. ing somewhat.
tioned for alleged drug traf- tor Kirchner, and his wife and ing, every major Wall Street Trump administration issued a Mr. Martínez’s proposals Since then, Venezuela has
ficking. Mr. El Aissami denies successor, Christina Fernán- asset manager stayed home. reminder not to negotiate with generated heated discussion in continued scraping together
the allegations. dez, in their battle against Several people said in inter- Venezuelans targeted under Venezuela’s economic cabinet, interest payments, sometimes
Mr. Martínez has a vested holdout bondholders. views that they were avoiding U.S. sanctions. said Venezuelan officials, with transferring the money days
interest in the outcome of debt By advising the Maduro ad- the legal risk of appearing in Among Mr. Martínez’s pro- the government eventually after the deadline. The pay-
talks. His New York-based ministration, “he’s now doing the same room with him. Mr. posals to Venezuela’s debt task settling on a middle course of ment delays have allowed in-
company, Fintech Advisory in Venezuela what he did in Martínez sent his fund man- force were those that involved muddling through payments as vestors last week to start
Inc., received bonds with a Argentina,” said one of the ager, Andrés Lederman, to at- restructuring oil contracts to it tries to strike an amicable claiming more than $1 billion
face value of $1.3 billion as a Venezuelans with direct tend, said other participants. give foreign trading companies agreement with the bondhold- in insurance-like derivatives
guarantee for a $300 million knowledge of the meeting. The U.S. prohibits any deal- legal ownership of Venezuelan ers. on Venezuelan bonds.
loan to the country in March. U.S. sanctions against Mr. El ings with sanctioned Venezue- oil exports, said people with After Mr. Maduro said he —Mariana Martínez
The loan allowed Venezuela Aissami add another wrinkle lan officials, including Mr. El knowledge of the meeting. wanted to restructure Venezu- and Ian Talley
to make a crucial bond pay- to the process. When Mr. El Aissami. Last week, after Mr. That, he argued, would protect ela’s debt, the country’s al- contributed to this article.
MARKETS
Growing Apart
Projections for fourth-quarter U.S. growth sharply diverge.
6% Quarterly change in GDP* New York forecast
OPEC Uncertainty Weighs on Oil
BY STEPHANIE YANG With many market partici- Big or Go Home’ event in our fore that shale production can
Atlanta forecast
AND SARAH MCFARLANE pants anticipating an extension view.” respond immediately,” Mr. An-
Average of
economists forecast as long as through the end of As U.S. shale production has sari said. Oil-field-services pro-
4 Oil prices pulled back Mon- next year, “anything less could increased and crude stockpiles vider Baker Hughes reported
day as doubts arose over easily produce a selloff sequel have built up in recent weeks, Friday that the number of U.S.
whether a meeting of global to the May meeting meltdown” the possibility of more U.S. rigs drilling for oil was un-
crude producers next week when oil prices dropped even supply also damped market changed at 738, having risen
2 would result in an extension of as OPEC announced the first sentiment. “Even if they by nine the previous week.
output cuts. deal extension, RBC Capital [OPEC] do extend the deal, I Gasoline futures fell 0.05%,
Light, sweet crude for De- Markets analysts said Monday. don’t see too significant a price to $1.7438 a gallon and diesel
0 cember delivery settled down “The stakes for this meeting rise because the market under- futures lost 0.7% to $1.9321 a
46 cents, or 0.8%, at $56.09 a are high indeed and it is a ‘Go stands even more than ever be- gallon on Monday.
barrel on
COMMODITIES the New
–2 York Mer-
2010 ’11 ’12 ’13 ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17 cantile Ex-
*3Q’17 is an estimate change. Brent, the global bench-
Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (GDP); Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Federal mark, declined 50 cents, or
Reserve Bank of New York, DataTrek (forecasts) THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. 0.8%, to $62.22 a barrel.
The Organization of the Pe-
gauge the economy’s health. “There is still time, there- gets haven’t been reached.”
The estimates have been fore, for the numbers to slip,” Analysts warn that since oil
the subject of some contention Mr. Colas said. With stocks al- has already priced in an ex-
as they often offer diverging ready pricing in stronger tended reduction of OPEC out-
views on the health of the growth, a string of weak data put, any disappointing news
economy. The recent harmony could put pressure on the could lead to a sharp drop for
between the two measures rally. prices. An oil terminal near Nakhodka in Russia’s far east. Russia will join an OPEC meeting set for next week.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 21, 2017 | B13
MARKETS
Saudi Turmoil Hits Middle East Markets
Kingdom itself has One explanation for the
been shielded by Widening Gulf Domestically focused stocks in the rest of the Gulf region
fell in the aftermath of Saudi Arabia’s political turmoil.
comparative resilience of
Saudi Arabian markets offered
state-led buying, hope Saudi Arabia’s political 2% by investors is interventions
by state institutions and funds.
of change, oil stability tensions have rippled Simon Kitchen, head of
through markets in Index performance macrostrategy at Cairo-based
BY MIKE BIRD neighbors such as Qatar 0 EFG Hermes, said anecdotal
and Bahrain, with less evidence and precedent sug-
Political upheaval in Saudi gest government money has
impact on Saudi assets. MSCI Saudi
Arabia has sent shares, curren- supported buying from local
cies and bonds in the Middle –2 Arabia Domestic mutual funds.
East lower—but not in the MSCI Gulf Cooperation “The pattern of trading ac-
kingdom itself. Council Domestic tivity does seem as if there’s
Riyadh’s internal crackdown (excluding Saudi Arabia) an orchestration of buying,”
and escalating tensions with –4 said Tarek Fadlallah, Middle
Iran have barely affected do- East chief executive at Nomura
mestic markets but have ampli- Last close before Saudi Asset Management.
fied troubles in smaller neigh- crackdown began The Saudi government
bors like Qatar and Bahrain. –6 didn’t respond to a request to
Saudi markets have likely October November comment.
been cushioned by state-led The political upheaval
buying, no disruption to the Five-year currency-forward points* Yield on Saudi Arabia’s dollar bond maturing Saudi Arabia’s stock of foreign-exchange shows no sign of affecting
massive oil industry and hopes on Bahrain’s dollar-pegged dinar in 2021 has risen since the crackdown, but reserves has declined with the price of Saudi Arabia’s oil industry,
of financial overhaul. While show growing speculation this some debt of the same maturity in nearby oil but remains higher than in much of which is responsible for the
Crown Prince Mohammed bin month that the currency will weaken. countries has reacted more sharply. the country’s recent history. vast majority of its revenue.
Salman’s consolidation of Increase in yields since Nov. 3, 2017 “Saudi tanker shipments ap-
power may add uncertainty, it 1,500 points $800 billion pear to have continued as nor-
could also further a program mal and policy makers who fa-
Bahrain 0.42 percentage point
of economic changes that in- vor a modest restriction of
cludes the privatization of 600 supply remain in place,” said
state assets and opening mar- 1,000 Oman 0.26 Mark Haefele, global chief in-
kets to foreign investors. vestment officer at UBS
On Monday, Standard & Saudi Wealth Management.
0.19 400
Poor’s held the kingdom’s Arabia Supply cuts by some of the
credit ratings stable, saying world’s largest oil producers,
“structural reforms could em- 500 Abu 0.18 including Saudi Arabia, have
Dhabi
power Saudi citizens and make 200 supported the price of crude in
Saudi Arabia more attractive 2017.
Dubai 0.07
to investors.” As the crown prince has
Saudi Arabia’s resil- 0 0 consolidated power, some in-
ience follows a 2017 global Qatar 0 vestors expect a boost to the
trend in which geopolitical 2015 ’16 ’17 2003 ’05 ’07 ’09 ’11 ’13 ’15 ’17 local economy and more for-
concerns have failed to make a *Points measure expected depreciation against the U.S. dollar in the coming five years. eign investment in local assets.
lasting impact on bigger mar- Sources: FactSet; Thomson Reuters (five-year currency-forward points) THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. According to Riyadh-
kets, as investors avoid trying based Al Rajhi Capital, only
to price in major events. crown prince’s effort to consoli- wait, United Arab Emirates, der pressure. ticularly vulnerable to low oil around 4.2% of Saudi-listed
Saudi markets are less likely date power as he spearheads Bahrain, Qatar and Oman—is In comparison, three-year prices, given relatively small shares are owned by foreign-
to react to domestic political far-reaching changes. down 4.9%. forward rates for the Bahraini foreign-exchange reserves and based investors.
ructions than the kingdom’s Meanwhile, Saudi Ara- There has been a small sell- dinar have climbed, suggesting high debt. “A deepening of financial
neighbors, according to Emad bia blamed Iran for a missile off in Saudi government debt, investors believe its peg to the Elsewhere, Lebanese mar- markets, increased trade open-
Mostaque, co-chief investment fired by Yemeni rebels toward but yields on the country’s dol- dollar may break and the cur- kets have been hard hit by po- ness, improved business envi-
officer of Capricorn Fund Man- Riyadh’s airport this month, lar-denominated bonds matur- rency depreciate. litical turmoil, with the coun- ronment and improved labor
agers, an emerging-market-fo- adding to tensions as the two ing in 2021 have risen less Saudi Arabia’s troubles have try acting as a staging ground force skills are likely to pro-
cused hedge fund. vie for regional influence. sharply than their equivalents highlighted some of the prob- for Iranian and Saudi foreign vide a supply-side boost to po-
This month, Saudi Arabia de- Nonetheless, MSCI’s index in Bahrain and Oman. In addi- lems of its neighbors. Qa- policies. tential growth,” said Jean-
tained dozens of princes, gov- for Saudi stocks has fallen just tion, bets that the riyal’s long- tar has been isolated by other Yields on Lebanese govern- Michel Saliba, an economist at
ernment officials and business- 0.3% in the last month. But the standing peg to the dollar will countries in the region, which ment bonds, maturing in 2019, Bank of America Merrill Lynch,
men as part of what it called MSCI’s index of stocks listed in break barely shifted upward, accuse it of backing extremist touched a high of 8% earlier in in a recent note.
anticorruption efforts that the other five members of the as they often do when the groups, something it de- November, up from 5.1% at the —Nikhil Lohade
marked an escalation in the Gulf Cooperation Council—Ku- country or its economy is un- nies. Bahrain’s economy is par- end of October. contributed to this article.
Email: heard@wsj.com
HEARD ON THE STREET FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY WSJ.com/Heard
Marvell Adds
Some Bulk
AT&T Girds for Fight of Its Life OVERHEARD
Wall Street was sailing If AT&T loses, it will need Cult leader Charles Man-
Sinking Feeling
To Its Frame into the end of 2017 with
markets calm, deal making
on a tear, and high confi-
Share-price performance
to pay Time Warner a $500
million breakup fee, but it
would save itself from over-
son’s death Sunday night
closes the book on a dark
chapter, but it also seems to
Sometimes confused with dence that one of the biggest 5% paying. Valuations in the me- have prompted people to
the comic-book company, media transactions in history dia world have come down open a book, literally, on his
Marvell Technology Group would be approved by a 0 since the deal was reached crimes.
has lately been pulling off business-friendly administra- more than a year ago, and The classic account of the
superheroic feats of its own. tion. –5
AT&T doesn’t have the best criminal trial, “Helter Skelter:
A small-but-telling indica- Two out of three isn’t record in paying attractive The True Story of the Man-
tor of this is how Wall bad, but the Justice Depart- prices. The company bought son Murders,” co-written by
Street’s analysts now view it. ment’s legal challenge to the –10 satellite-TV provider DirecTV prosecuting attorney Vincent
Half now recommend buying $85 billion AT&T-Time War- AT&T at the peak of the market. Bugliosi, was a best seller in
the stock compared with the ner agreement is a tough –15 Time Warner The government action 1974.
13% who held that view two blow for the deal makers, came during one of the big- Those looking for the origi-
years ago. analysts and investors who gest months of M&A on re- nal mass-market paperback
–20
Here is another indicator: were exceedingly assured cord, but some companies published in 1975 will have to
Marvell’s share price has that the merger would go October November appear to know how to han- dig a lot deeper to own a
jumped nearly 10% since The through. It would be chal- Source: WSJ Market Data Group THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. dle the administration. Be- “new” (in other words, un-
Wall Street Journal first re- lenging for hedge funds to fore its bid for Qualcomm, read) copy than before its
ported this month that the make up their losses this the media business is so CNN. The telecom will be Broadcom’s CEO moved the subject’s death, though.
company was in talks to ac- late in the year. fluid right now that it is con- able to argue the conven- company’s headquarters Website CamelCamel-
quire chip maker Cavium. The flaw in Wall Street’s ceivable that government tional: that mergers between back to the U.S. and held a Camel.com, which tracks the
Acquiring companies often thinking was that precedent lawyers could build a con- companies that don’t com- smiling photo opportunity prices of new and used books
weaken. Its offer was for- would hold in an administra- vincing case that consumers pete haven’t typically been with President Donald on Amazon.com, shows that
mally announced Monday, tion that doesn’t highly would be hurt by the pro- blocked. It also could make Trump. Masayoshi Son, the the best price available
valuing Cavium at $80 a value precedent. The Justice posed deal. the unconventional argument CEO of SoftBank Group, also jumped from $119.19 most re-
share for a total deal value Department will have a AT&T appears undeterred, that the president may have flattered him. For Wall cently to $1,698 on Monday
of about $6 billion, nearly 24 tough time winning the case which ultimately might be a overstepped the bounds of Street to maintain its mo- morning.
times Cavium’s adjusted for- in court, or at least that is blessing. If AT&T wins, it policy to get the Justice mentum, more CEOs may The markup is almost
ward earnings. what Wall Street believes. gets to do the deal without Department to try to block have to travel to Washing- criminal.
Marvell’s cash portion of And that may be true, but selling assets, including the deal. ton. —Ken Brown
the deal comes to about $2.6
billion, net of Cavium’s cash
on hand. That is about $1
billion more than what Mar-
vell has in the bank, which
Don’t Ground Your Company’s Private Jet Fleet Just Yet
makes investors’ early vote General Electric’s execu- Street Journal’s flight Scottsdale, Ariz., West Palm larized the use of public da-
of confidence notable. The tives are getting reac- Cruising Altitude tracker database, published Beach, Fla., and Las Vegas. tabase searches to track
combination should make quainted with the joys of Percentage of S&P 1500 in 2011, the trio of academics Companies that had other- planes, executives and com-
Marvell a stronger competi- commercial air travel. But firms that disclose use collated the routes of private wise poor corporate gover- panies have gone to great
tor to Broadcom in areas the decision by the com- of a corporate jet jets with the location of nance metrics benefited the lengths to obscure flights.
such as network equipment pany’s new chief executive to company subsidiaries. least from using private jets. Clever hedge funds may still
55%
processors. But Broadcom is cut the use of company- The findings were stron- If corporate jets were be able to track tail num-
expanding as well, as indi- owned jets may pay off in 50 gest for firms that had the purely seen as excessive, bers, but the investing public
cated by its surprise bid for symbolism rather than per- 45 most widely spread business their use would probably be is mostly in the dark.
Qualcomm that would make formance. operations and would seem on the wane. But, in fact, Investors could demand
it the fourth-largest semi- GE became the latest 40 to benefit from being able to roughly half of public com- another solution: Ask compa-
conductor company globally high-profile case of corpo- 2006 ’08 ’10 ’12 ’14 have executives hopscotch panies report jet use in some nies to voluntarily disclose
based on revenue. rate aviation misadventures, Sources: Lian Fen Lee, Michelle Lowry from location to location. form in corporate docu- in broad strokes how private
Marvell has spent the past when the company disclosed and Susan Shu Also benefiting from jet ments. The actual number is jets are used. If, say, 95% of
year getting in better shape, that it had been sending a travel: firms in industries probably higher. And that trips were to subsidiaries or
both through a restructuring backup plane to fly with for- and communication facili- with high research and de- hasn’t changed much in re- finance centers like New
that helped trim costs and mer boss Jeffrey Immelt. tated by private jet travel velopment costs, for which cent years, even as activist York, rather than vacation
divestitures that helped nar- The decision by new chief generates improved operat- complicated information investors and corporate gov- spots like Honolulu, that
row its focus. This puts Mar- John Flannery is a welcome ing performance in terms of sharing requires face-to-face ernance pressure has in- would be a sign of judicious-
vell in the right place to sign of improved gover- measures such as return on explanations. creased in other areas of ness.
start adding the necessary nance, but for a company assets, notes a recent work- The risk is that companies boardroom conduct. Investors would feel bet-
muscle needed to battle chip with as many locations and ing paper by finance and ac- don’t use the jets for legiti- The trouble is how to de- ter and executives might not
titans that also are trying to operations as GE, it risks go- counting professors Lian Fen mate business purposes. termine whether the plane is feel guilty about one of the
tap their inner Hulk. ing too far. Lee, Michelle Lowry and Su- Abut 10% of flights are to re- being used for work or plea- key perks they enjoy.
—Dan Gallagher In fact, the time saved san Shu. Using The Wall sort destinations such as sure. After the Journal popu- —Alex Frangos
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B14 | Tuesday, November 21, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
But how do we keep that promise within reach, when innovation and
structural shifts are transforming work faster than the nation’s policies
and safety nets can keep pace?
These are daunting challenges. But when leaders from all sectors,
private, public and not-for-profit, collaborate on finding ways to
reconnect work and wealth, these are challenges we can meet.
Nearly
610 out
of
prudential.com/workers
0312082-00001-00