Sarah Johnson
Dr. Laraway
Spanish 346R
While September 11 has become synonymous with tragedy throughout the world, for
those living in the Catalan region of Spain, it is a historic day of pride and celebration. Each year
on September 11, yellow-and-red flags are hung from every window and balcony, paraded
throughout Barcelona, and proudly worn as capes and clothing. The Catalan hymn is sung by
those in the streets and the people dance and celebrate their unique culture. To an unfamiliar eye,
the bright flags may appear to be the familiar Spanish flag. However, these striped flags are
actually the Catalan flag, and in recent times, have become synonymous with the Catalan
separatist movement. The very hymn they sing with such pride contains an overt separatist
Catalonia triumphant
For Catalans, September 11 is the day that celebrates their collective identity and heritage
as their official regional holiday. September 11 was the day that they lost their independence to
Johnson 2
Spain. Because of their annual celebrations, the date and its history have become ingrained in
who the Catalans are and how they define themselves. However, the happy celebration of the
September 11 stands in direct contrast with how the official Spanish national holiday is
celebrated each year just one month later on October 12 in the region. Traditionally, the holiday
has been met with well-attended protests and demonstrations in Catalonia. In fact, popular
protests have taken place annually since the mid-1980s, and include “the ritual burning of
Spanish flags [which] is often accompanied by vandalism against branch offices of banks and the
While many of the most conspicuous protests take place in Barcelona, the national day
has become a source of controversy throughout Spain. Most Spanish citizens have a strong “dual
identity”—many identify as a member of their specific region before they identify as being a
citizen of Spain. This often creates a conflict, as embracing a Spanish identity seems to come at
the sacrifice of their regional identity. As a symbol of the Spanish identity, the national day,
October 12 is celebrated sparsely throughout the country. Perhaps most indicative of the people’s
rejection of the Spanish national identity is Spain’s national anthem. Spain is one of only four
countries in the world whose national anthem has no lyrics. This is not an artistic choice but
rather a political statement. In 2008, the Spanish government held a competition inviting all to
submit possible lyrics for the hymn. The winner’s words would become official lyrics for all of
Spain. However, when people read the winning composition, citizens from all regions rejected
the words by refusing to sing because the words were deemed too nationalistic. The same people
who sing so joyfully their regional hymns refused to sing their national anthem, because many
identify as Catalans, Basques, or Galicians first and Spaniards second. The controversial lyrics
were:
Johnson 3
A hymn of brotherhood
freedom. (Cubero)
The Spanish people objected to the lyrics on several fronts. To some, these seemingly
innocent lyrics invoked memories of the dictatorship to which Spain was subjected for fifty
years. To others, the references to “one heart” or “brotherhood” were too focused on the idea of
a united country instead of a collection of separate cultural regions. It was deemed better to have
no words at all to the national anthem than to have words that emphasized the idea of a united
Spain. The resistance to even the suggestion of a shared Spanish identity highlights a growing
issue in Spain: there seems to be no central, unifying factor to create a Spanish country or
identity.
While some may view national public holidays as simply a day free from work, national
days of commemoration have traditionally held great power over a people and their culture. They
agenda, and they increase the sense of unity and community in a nation. One of the greatest
examples of this is found in Spain’s history. Holidays are so influential that during the regime of
fascist dictator Francisco Franco, all regional holidays were banned and the celebration of all
official public holidays were carefully and specifically dictated. The purpose of this ban was
clear: the dictator wanted to create a central identity in Spain. By controlling what the nation
celebrated, Franco attempted to control what the nation would become. A close historical
Johnson 4
examination of Spain’s relationship with its official holidays shows that days of celebration have
been manipulated by those in power in order to further their own personal goals for the country.
This paper will focus on the changing significance of Spain’s official national day,
October 12. To differentiate between all nationally recognized holidays, meaning non-working
days recognized by the government, and the country’s central national holiday, the terms “public
holidays” for the former and “national day” for the latter will be used. When speaking of days
recognized only in a peripheral region of Spain, the term “regional holiday” will be utilized. This
paper will show that the harsh bans on regional holidays, the militaristic interpretation of Spain’s
national day, and intense governmental debates after the dictator’s death only weakened the
national identity of Spain and heavily contributed to the fractured regions of Spain today.
While Spain’s political borders on the Iberian Peninsula were established for hundreds of
years, its cultural borders existed far longer. The Basques living in the northeast, the Galicians
in the northwest, and the Catalans in the east all lived inside the borders of Spain yet existed for
centuries longer, each having their own language, culture, and regional holiday. After General
Francisco Franco gained control of Spain following his victory in the Spanish Civil War in 1939,
he sought to stamp out these regional identities by banning the speaking of their languages and
the celebration of their holidays. The government dictated that Spanish was the only language to
be spoken and the only days to be commemorated would be specified by the government in
Madrid. To celebrate the anniversary of the military uprising in 1939, its anniversary, July 18,
was dedicated as a public holiday. Three years later, the anniversary of the military victory, April
1 was similarly dedicated. “The regime considered both to be worthy of commemoration, and
various events of symbolic content were celebrated on the anniversaries” (Aguilar 124).
Johnson 5
National holidays are frequently used by politicians and leaders to further a particular agenda, as
“national holidays as such create the space for state representatives to interpret their contents and
through their own holiday activity or by means of speeches from stages at symbolic places…
they instrumentalise the general popularity of holidays among citizens as a means to accomplish
their objectives” (Popelková). Through carefully planned public holidays, Franco sought to
eliminate regional differences and unite the political sides of the country, which had become
heavily divided during the Civil War. He changed the official national day from October 12 to
The military became the focal point of many such holidays during Franco’s regime, with
military parades and events throughout the country. Franco wanted to restore the national
identity of Spain to its “past grandeur as an empire” and as a “sanctuary of Catholicism” (Aguilar
135). While July 18 became Spain’s most prominent national day, October 12, the anniversary of
Columbus discovering America, remained as one of Spain’s primary public holidays. Under
Franco it gained a national significance that it had never previously enjoyed. In fact, “despite the
fact that the Dia de la Hispanidad commemorates the discovery of America by Columbus in
1492, its origins date from the early twentieth century”, as it was first dedicated as the national
day in 1918. It was the “the ultra-right-wing writer” Ramiro de Maeztu who, in the 1930s,
“popularized the concept of Hispanidad, linking it to the fascist imagery and emphasizing the
ideas of the “historical destiny” and Volkgeist”. The concept of “Hispanidad”, refers to:
the Francoist regime as one of its ideological pillars. The concept was
Johnson 6
instrumentalized to exalt the heroic image of the old Spanish empire and the
period when Spain was amongst the most important powers of the world,
stressing the religious and political aspects much more than the cultural and
By associating October 12 with the “heroic image of the old Spanish empire” with military
parades and displays of governmental strength, Franco attempted to promote a strong sense of
nationalism and pride in the Spanish citizens. The “Dia de la Hispanidad” was used to create
unity the people in the Spanish state, and to bring about Franco’s vision of restoring Spain to its
previous international importance. He used the national holiday as a tool to create a vision of
After decades of the deliberate suppression of the peripheral regions, Spain underwent a
drastic transition following the death of Franco in 1975. Significantly, this period of transition
seemed to be the complete rejection of the ideals the dictator had so firmly espoused. First and
foremost was the strong “Spanish” identity. The government under Franco had so emphasized
the importance and supremacy of Spain that “for any Spaniard who had lived under the
dictatorship, expressions such as ‘Spain’ and the ‘Spanish Nation’ or cheers of ‘Viva España’
immediately evoked Francoist discourse… the paraphrases “this country” or “the Spanish state”
were, and still are, accepted ways of referring to Spain if one wants to avoid being associated
with the excesses of the dictatorship” (Aguilar 134). After Franco’s death, the peripheral
regions, such as Catalonia, reinstated their own government and language with a renewed
passion. In fact, “the most unforgiving betrayal of the Francoist legacy was the “rupture” of
Spain, the devolution process by which the entire country was divided into Autonomous
Johnson 7
than create a strong, united Spain, Franco’s policies split Spain apart.
While the fracturing of Spain created certain difficulties in the transition period that
followed Franco’s death, it also ushered in a new era for for the country. On June 15, 1977, the
first democratic elections took place since the beginning of Franco’s rise forty years earlier.
“Esta idea se apreciaba fácilmente en los editoriales de la prensa, repletos de frases como «la
democracia empieza hoy» o «hoy, el primer día de democracia en España»” (Vernt I Llobet).
With democracy reinstated, many policies began to change. Importantly, the matter of a national
holiday was one of the first issues discussed by the new government. The Francoist national
holiday, July 18, was removed from the official calendar and Spain was left without a national
day. October 12, known as “el Dia de la Hispanidad”, to celebrate the Spanish Empire, or “el
Dia de la Raza”, to commemorate the new race that was created from the indigenous people and
the Spanish explorers, was the most prominent official holiday on the calendar. At the time, it
appeared to be the most logical choice for the new national day. As one historian acknowledges,
“de hecho, España solo se hizo España descubriendo y colonizando América” (Humlebaek, “La
Nación” 88). Much of Spain’s historical and national identity was found in its imperial reach
However, it is possible that this strong historical connotation contributed to the weakness
of the day as a national holiday. While October 12, 1492 was the beginning of Spain’s rule in
Latin America, the country had since lost almost all of its colonies and international power. In
many ways, October 12 celebrated what Spain once was, but is no longer. In fact, the peripheral
regions in Spain began to take a strong stand against any Spanish national holiday at all. Some
went as far as to as “deny the very existence of a Spanish nation. Most of them referred to the
Johnson 8
‘Spanish state,’ or even to the ‘Spanish kingdom,’ but they were, and still are, very reluctant to
use the term “nation” to refer to Spain, regarding Spain merely as a political structure composed
of different nations such as the Basque, the Catalan and the Galician” (Aguilar 133).
Newspapers across the country began to call for a new national holiday, recognizing the ability
of a united celebration to bring the fractured country together. Specifically, the prominent
Spanish newspaper El País repeatedly called attention to the fact that Spain lacked a strong,
uniting holiday and urged the government for a new national day. The newspaper appealed for
the Spanish government to make a change, writing, “Los españoles necesitamos, ahora, una
nueva fecha que pueda servir de símbolo del consenso de todo el país; que no provoque
reticencias de ninguno de los sectores que forman la comunidad Española” (Humlebaek, “La
Constitución” 189).
Because of this call for action, many members of the government began to look for a new
national holiday. The government debated heavily over two possibilities. The first option was to
keep October 12 as the national holiday, and run the risk of retaining the legacy of the Fascist
dictatorship. The second option was to choose December 6, which was the anniversary of the
day the Constitution was signed after Franco’s death in 1978 and which ushered in an age of
democracy. To many, the Constitution became the symbol of the new, free Spain, established
facto y dejar mayormente intacta una idea de la nación española heredada del régimen franquista,
mientras que elegir el 6 de diciembre significaba apostar por una concepción nacional diferente
centrada en los valores de la democracia y el consenso” (Humlebaek, “La Nación” 90). The two
Johnson 9
dates, essentially representing what Spain once was and the other what Spain was going to
One of the issues with the debate was that many citizens of Spain’s peripheral regions
didn’t want a national holiday at all. With the fracturing of Spain that took place after Franco’s
death, many Catalans, Gallicians, and Basques wanted to celebrate their own regional holidays
and not the commemorative days that they had been forced to celebrate under Franco’s rule.
However, many believed that a national holiday celebrating a new, democratic Constitution, the
most prominent symbol of Spain’s transition from Fascism, would be able to unite the peripheral
regions to central Spain in a way no holiday had been able to do before. In fact, the members of
parliament who first proposed December 6 as a new national holiday were from the Basque and
Catalan regions, reasoning that the new national holiday would be able to symbolize Spain’s new
beginning while not diminishing Spain’s historical legacy. Miquel Roca i Junyent, who was from
the Catalan region and also one of the contributors to the Spanish Constitution, argued for the
ratification of December 6 as the national holiday saying that “el régimen político que la
democracia ha instaurado en España (...) necesita sus propios símbolos. Y no hay mejor símbolo
Constitución” 188). To many Spaniards, both from Madrid and from a minority region,
December 6 was the symbol of a new beginning. Until that point, being proud of both Spain and
being Spanish still had a strong Fascist connotation, yet a “Constitution Day” would foster
national pride of something completely new in Spanish history, and thus untainted by Franco’s
harsh rule. The ratification of the Constitution was an event celebrated throughout Spain, in both
Madrid and the minority regions alike. Fascinatingly, surveys showed that national pride
increased among the general population specifically because of how the people acted during the
Johnson 10
transition from Franco’s regime to democracy. Several international studies showed that the
Spanish people “regarded themselves and the king to have been the crucial actors in contributing
to the peaceful and successful consolidation of democracy in a country that its own people and
elites and even foreign nations had traditionally considered to be intrinsically incapable of living
under a democratic regime without engaging in political violence” (Aguilar 141). Truly,
December 6, symbol of the peaceful transition and lasting democracy, was “la fecha en que el
pueblo español abrió una nueva etapa presidida por y, constituyendo por tanto, una fecha que
Constitución” 190).
December 6 grew in popularity among the population to become the new national
holiday, yet the Spanish parliament continued to debate which day should become Spain’s
holiday. However, all discussion and deliberation became irrelevant when in November 1981,
the nation suddenly received the news that the King, Juan Carlos, had declared October 12 the
new national holiday in el Real Decreto 3217/1981 de la Presidencia del Gobierno, thus
overriding any decision by the Spanish parliament. He named the day “Fiesta Nacional de
España y Día de la Hispanidad” (Vernt I Llobet). From this point forward in the transition
period, there was an effort to redefine the extreme nationalistic and imperialistic version of
“Hispanidad” to a more inclusive, moderate national pride. “The king wanted to give higher
political priority to the promotion of the Hispanic community on both the cultural and the
politico-economic levels and thereby turn Hispanidad into a marker of identity and a reason for
feeling proud of being Spanish” (Aguilar 138). However, the way in which October 12 was
celebrated in Madrid and throughout the country was essentially the same as how it was
Johnson 11
celebrated during Franco’s regime, with military parades and a focus on the power of the
Redefinition of October 12
However, el Dia de la Hispanidad would undergo yet another change just six years later.
In 1987, another law was passed reestablishing October 12 as Spain’s national holiday. This
time, however, there were several significant changes. The first was the change in the title of the
day. In an attempt to remove all Fascist connotations, the title “Dia de la Hispanidad” was
removed from the legislation and the holiday was formally known as simply “el Dia de la Fiesta
Nacional de España”, or “the Day of the National Holiday of Spain.” While the date remained
October 12, all historical context, such as references to Columbus, the Latin America, and the
Spanish empire, was removed from the law. Rather vaguely, the purpose of the day was to
celebrate all things Spanish. The constitution stated that “Sin menoscabo de la indiscutible
complejidad que implica el pasado de una nación tan diversa como la española, ha de procurarse
que el hecho histórico que se celebre represente uno de los mometos más relevantes para la
singularidad nacional de ese pueblo” (Humlebaek, “La nación” 90). Thus, the national holiday
continued to be celebrated on the October 12 with no reference to why that particular date was
chosen. Perhaps the greatest weakness of the law that contributed to its inability to unite Spain
was the very wording used. While the day was called “Fiesta Nacional de España”, the
nationalities. In addition, rather than refer to a “identidad nacional”, the law specifically speaks
of an “identidad estatal”, again deferring to the separate regions of Spain rather than
acknowledging any kind of national identity. With this latest redefinition of the day, the central
Johnson 12
government deferred to the demands of the peripheral regions rather than promote any sort of
One of the main reasons that October 12 was chosen over December 6 was because of the
argument that October 12 had five hundred years of history while December 6 had none.
However, the very law that declared October 12 to be the national holiday of Spain stripped it of
all historical significance and had no strong symbol other than a celebratory “Spain Day”.
December 6, on the other hand, would have had the central symbol of democracy, the newly
signed Spanish Constitution. While October 12, “Fiesta Nacional de España” remains Spain’s
national holiday, support for December 6 was and still continues to be the more popular choice
of the people. In 1984, sixty percent of Spanish citizens supported the idea of changing the
national holiday from October 12 to December 6. In 2000, this number had grown to eighty
percent of the population (Humlebaek, “La Constitución” 204). Not only is the law declaring
October 12 extremely vague in its wording and non-unifying, but also the population would
prefer to celebrate the day the Constitution was signed, the “first day of democracy in Spain”.
Because of “Spain Day’s” relative unpopularity among the population, “the event is reported
very sparsely in the media, usually only in the news section on the following day, and there is
hardly any reflection on the commemoration’s symbolic and historical meaning… Hence, what
was envisioned as the National Holiday of Spain is destined to become a very sparsely attended
event” (Aguilar 141). In many ways, October 12 was a wasted opportunity to unite the country.
Because it was stripped of its historical significance and has no strong unifying message, Spain’s
National Holiday does not remind citizens of Spain of love and loyalty to their country. From
this perspective, the lack of harmony throughout Spain becomes understandable and even
predictable. Spain’s national day does not inspire or unite. It does not invite citizens to embrace
Johnson 13
their country before their region. Because October 12 has lost its importance, the Spanish
El Diada
Catalonia, the northeast region of Spain that borders France, has been struggling against
Spanish rule for centuries. In 1714, Catalonia, which had been an independent region, was
conquered by the Spanish and French during the War of Spanish Succession. Catalonia, which
had its own well established government, language, and culture, struggled with this transition,
and, as history shows, has continued to struggle to this day. Almost two hundred years after the
conquering of Catalonia, the people have preserved their own regional identity and remained
separate from Spain in both language and culture. One of the most effective instruments that the
Catalans have used to retain their own identity is their official regional holiday. The Catalans
themselves were given the freedom to decide their holiday in 1886, and, significantly, they chose
September 11, the anniversary of their own surrender to Spanish troops and the loss of their
independence. As one historian observed, “choosing this, of all days, as the national day, might
seem to be rather bizarre and perverse, and it is a source of amusement to some in the rest of
and of rekindling the desire to recover her lost autonomy” (Hargreaves 19). This holiday,
officially called “El Diada de l'Onze de Setembre” or “el Diada Nacional de Catalunya” in the
Catalan language, was used as a day to not only commemorate Catalan culture, but also to
remind the Catalan people what they wanted to one day become again: a free, independent state.
Under this historical context, the lyrics of the national anthem, “Catalonia triumphant / Shall
again be rich and bountiful / Drive away these people, / Who are so conceited and so arrogant /
Strike with your sickle, defenders of the land!” which were written in only 1899 (“Els”), appear
Johnson 14
far more aggressive as they are sung year after year by thousands of Catalans.
With such a strong regional identity, and with such persistent separatist ideals, Catalonia
was a clear target for General Francisco Franco after he rose to power. Almost immediately, the
dictator began to ban any symbol of the region and to punish those who did not comply.
[Franco’s regime] promptly instituted the most thorough attempt in the history of
Spain to subordinate the country to central control, and Catalonia was singled out
integrity. Thousands were executed or imprisoned or forced into exile; the region’s
virtually total control from the center. A policy of cultural genocide was
identity and nationhood, such as the flag (the senyara), the national hymn (‘Els
Segadors’) and the national dance (the sardana), were proscribed. Any sign of
consequently the Catalan nation were threatened with extinction (Hargreaves 28).
To survive decades of repression, all symbols and traditions of Catalonia had to be passed on in
secret. However, rather than stamp out Catalan identity, Franco’s brutal persecution seemed to
strengthen the drive of the Catalans to not only preserve their culture but to make their
traditions—such as their language, games, dance, and even food— an engrained part of their
daily lives. Rather than be only “folkloric relics” brought out once a year during their regional
holiday, Catalonia’s strong traditions are integrated into daily Catalan life and celebrated further
every September 11 (Hargreaves 21). As such, the survival of the Catalan culture in the harshest
of persecutions has caused the Catalans as a whole to became extremely protective of their
Johnson 15
culture and more aggressive towards any form of Spanish culture thrust upon them. As one
Catalan historian espoused, “el franquisme erosionava directament la identitat nacional a traves
de les expressions culturals mes importants de Catalunya. Imposarà una nova identitat u
nacional catalana fou un dels esforços importants del grups culturals, historiadors i literats
catalans” (Lladonosa Latorre). The “la lluita contra l’espanyolització”, or “fight against
After Franco’s death, the autonomous governments of the peripheral regions were fully
reinstated. Significantly, the very first official act of the Catalan government was to reinstate El
Diada as their official regional holiday, describing the day as “una jornada que, si por una parte
y Resistencia active frente a la opresión, suponía también la esperanza de una total recuperación
nacional” (Humlebaek, “La Nación” 89). Reestablishing their holiday, one of the strongest
symbols of Catalan identity, was perhaps the most effective way for the Catalans to begin to
separate themselves from Central Spain. In an unabashedly public message to the Spanish
government, Catalonia also declared October 12 to be a normal working day in 1981 (90). This
was, most likely, one of the factors causing King Juan Carlos to suddenly declare October 12 to
be Spain’s national holiday, forcing Catalonia to recognize the day and make it a non-working
day. However, October 12 has continued to be met with protests and demonstrations in
Barcelona, as the Catalans oppose the imposition from the central government to celebrate a
Catalonia’s resentment of Spain’s interference seems to have only grown in recent years.
“The Catalan government vigorously promotes Catalan culture in every shape and form”, as it
Johnson 16
promotes the idea that “ethnic nationalism predominates over civil nationalism” (Hargreaves 34).
Catalan flags that used to be hung only around September 11 are now commonly displayed
throughout the year as an expression for support for Catalonia’s secessionist movement
(Parravano). The dissonance between Spain and Catalonia culminated in the recent referendum
by the Catalan government attempting to declare Catalonia a new country and the chaos that
ensued after the harsh response from the National Police. While the Spanish government was
successful in disrupting the referendum vote, it has been unsuccessful in its attempts to better
National holidays allow a country’s people to pause for a moment and reflect on their
heritage. Their daily routines are interrupted to commemorate an important time in their
country’s past. Catalonia derives its identity from the strong historical significance of its
national holiday. It is a continual reminder that the goal for the region is independence from
Spain. October 12 has undergone so many transformations, from el Día de la Raza to el Día de la
Hispanidad to la Fiesta Nacional de España, that its celebration has lost much of its unifying
potential. While the lack of a strong, national holiday in Spain is not the cause of all of Spain’s
conflict, it is symptomatic of the lack of a strong, national identity. Perhaps Catalonia will soon
celebrate a new national holiday, commemorating the day it regained its independence from
Spain. As the last verse of the Catalan anthem, sung with so much passion every September 11,
Works Cited
Aguilar, Paloma, and Carsten Humlebaek. “Collective Memory and National Identity in the
Spanish Democracy: The Legacies of Francoism and the Civil War.” History & Memory,
Anguera, Pere. “El 11 de septiembre. Orígenes y consolidación de la Diada.” Los días de España,
Hargreaves, John. Freedom for Catalonia? : Catalan Nationalism, Spanish Identity and the
Barcelona Olympic Games, Cambridge University Press, 2000. ProQuest Ebook Central,
https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/byu/detail.action?docID=147304.
Humlebaek, Carsten. “La Constitución de 1978 como lugar de memoria en España.” Historia y
Politica: Ideas, Procesos y Movimientos Sociales, no. 12, 2004, pp. 187–210.
EBSCOhost,content.ebscohost.com/ContentServer.asp?EbscoContent=dGJyMNXb4kSep
q84zOX0OLCmr0%.
Franco.” Iberoamericana (2001-), vol. 4, no. 13, 2004, pp. 87–99. JSTOR, JSTOR,
www.jstor.org/stable/41675393.
Parravano, Antonio, et al. Field Evidence of Social Influence in the Expression of Political
Preferences: The Case of Secessionist Flags in Barcelona. 2014, Field Evidence of Social
Johnson 18
Barcelona, arxiv.org/abs/1409.7579v1.
Popelková, Katarína. "Holidays – the Mirror of Society. The Social and Cultural Contexts of
Present-Day Holidays in the Slovak Republic." Slovak Enthology 65.2 (2017): 171-
Vernt I Llobet, Jaume. “El dabate parlamentario sobre el 12 de octubre, Fiesta Nacional de
España.” Los días de España, vol. 51, Revista de Historia Contemoránea, 2003, pp. 135-
152.