Anda di halaman 1dari 7

Computer Ethics: A Model of the Influences On

The Individual's Ethical Decision Making

John W. Henry
Margaret Anne Pierce
Georgia Southern University

Abstract - Ethical decision related to computer technology course of action; therefore, there needs to be ethical
and computer use are made based upon one's personal code guidance specific to the use of computers and computer
of ethics, the informal code that exists in the work place, technology.
and formal company codes. These codes as well as factors
influencing these codes were explored in terms of a A PROPOSED MODEL
decision-making model. Practical implications of the model This article proposes a model of ethical decision
are important for educators, organizations, and personnel making to guide training, analysis, and research in
using computers and computer technology. computer ethics. The primary constructs of the model
shown in Figure 1 are the personal code of ethics, the
INTRODUCTION informal code of ethics that exists in the work place, and
As the use of computer technology finds its way the formal company code.
into all areas of business and education, the opportunity for These codes are presented as principal influences
unethical use also increases. The results of computer abuse on individual ethical decision making related to computer
can be expensive in both human and financial terms with use. Indirect factors which affect ethical decision making
valued employees being demoted or fired and the are ethical theory, professional codes, and the law. The
organization being sued for damages. In addition to these model shows that the knowledge and use of ethical theory
operating costs related to computer abuse, organizations impacts the personal code as does an awareness of computer
spend millions on preventative measures such as computer professional codes. Additionally, an understanding of the
related security. Moreover, there is some evidence to law related to the use of computers and computer
suggest that computer related abuse will continue into the technology influences the personal, informal, and formal
future. Since this is a people problem, ethical behavior by codes. Below is a discussion of the direct influences of the
individuals should be a deterrent to computer related abuse. personal code of ethics, the informal code of ethics, and the
Thus, this article proposes a model which defines the major formal code of ethics on individual decision making. This
influences on the on the individual's ethical decision- is followed by a discussion of the indirect influences on
making process when decisions are related to computers and individual decision making of the formal study of ethics,
computer technology. The primary forces in the proposed professional codes, and the law.
model are as follows: 1) the individual's personal code of
ethics, 2) the informal code of ethics that exists in the work PERSONAL CODE OF E T H I C S
place, and 3) the company code of ethics. The value of the An individual's personal code of ethics related to
model lies in its usefulness as a framework for decision computers and computer technology is developed from
making and as a basis to guide training and research. observation and experience. When faced with a familiar
Ethics refers to a set of rules or principles used for situation, individuals typically use "scripts" to guide
moral decision making (Johnson, 1985). Of particular behavior. Generally, "...scripts are cognitive schemes
interest to the present discussion are factors influencing and/or mental maps which serve as guides and models for
decisions involving computer technology and computer use. learning and behavior in individuals." (Wheatley, Maddox,
There are several reasons computer ethics is an important and Anthony, 1991, 33). In essence, a script is a
topic. Firstly, it is generally recognized that ethical manifestation of the individual's personal code of ethics.
dilemmas related to computer technology face technology Scripts are stored in long term memory and are recalled into
users everyday in the work place. Secondly, there are short term memory when triggered by the current situation.
documented computer abuses which cost U.S. companies Moreover, the current situation need not be identical to the
millions of dollars each year (Straub, Nance, & Carlson, previous situation but may simply be perceived by the
1990). Thirdly, some corporate codes of ethics contain individual to have important similarities. Scripts develop
statements which relate to computers and computer or evolve and are influenced by many factors, including
technology, but in general these codes fall short of family, education, and experience. Although an individual
providing real guidance needed by employees. Finally, new may be unaware of any formal or informal code of ethics in
situations often arise in which there is no clearly indicated the work place, these codes not

C o m p u t e r P e r s o n n e l - O c t o b e r 1994 21
FIGURE 1. MODEL OF ETHICAL DECISION
MAKING RELATED TO COMPUTER TECHNOLOGY

Ethics Study

Professional Codes ~- Personal

Laws

> Informal ~ Situation Action

~ Formal

only influence etMcal decisions but also become internalized This figure was up from 40% in 1964. However, it is
into the personal code or script. A script for ethical shocking that in the 1987 report only 55 % of the companies
behavior in this sense represents one's broader notion of with formal codes chose to distribute the codes to their
appropriate or ethical behavior and is the culmination of the employees. In a similar British study, Schlegelmilch and
influence of numerous events (Lord, R.G., 1985; Lord, Houston (1990) found that only 42% of the companies
R.G., & Maher, K.J., 1990). surveyed had codes, and only 61% of those distributed the
codes to all employees.
INFORMAL CODE OF ETHICS Perhaps these statistics are more clearly understood
The informal code embodies peer expectations and when considering the reasons cited for satisfaction with a
accepted behavior in the work place. Several business company's code of ethics. In a 1980 survey by the Ethics
ethics studies (Wahn, 1993; Trevino, 1986) have found that Resources Center, reasons given for satisfaction with formal
pressures from subordinates and peers within organizations codes related to external relations such as legal protection
cause people to behave unethically. For example, one study for the company (78%) and increased consumer/public
found that 40 % of the respondents had been asked by other goodwill (66%) (Creating a Workable Company Code,
employees to do something which they considered 1990). This suggests that the primary consideration
unethical. In a discussion of the influence of the informal regarding a company code is the image which it conveys to
code on behavior, Witkin and Goodenough (1977) the public and the legal protection it affords the company,
concluded that, when a situation is ambiguous, an employee not the guidance it provides for employee behavior. On the
will cue on the behavior of his peers and conform to other hand, a well-written ethical code can serve to convey
accepted behavior. Clearly the informal code of ethics that the organization's commitment to ethical conduct
exists in the peer group influences individual decision (Molander, 1987); thus, a formal code can clearly
making. communicate expectations and ideals.
Several authors have pointed out that one solution
FORMAL CODE ETHICS to managing the risk of unethical computer use is creating,
In the model, formal code of ethics is used to mean reinforcing, and maintaining an ethical environment
a company code or policy with provisions that apply to supported by top management (Kallman, 1992; Paradice,
ethical guidelines for computer technology/computer use. 1990). A sound company code of ethics with provisions
Many companies consider it important to have a company which relate to computers and computer technology
code or policy covering general topics including ethical provides vital input into the ethical decision-making
considerations. A 1987 study reported that 85% of process. For example, the formal code of ethics for one
American corporations had codes of ethics or similar policy major technology firm not only clearly states that employees
statements (Creating A Workable Company Code, 1990). are expected to obey existing laws (both the spirit and letter

22 Computer Personnel October 1994


-
of the law) but explicitly mentions compliance with contains the revised ACM code of professional ethics, and
software license agreements. In this company's formal a series of ethical cases along with specific references to the
code, there are references to a manual of policies and portions of the code which provide guidance in the
standards which give guidance in areas such as handling situation. Thus, readers not only are informed about the
ethical issues, security and classification of information, statement of the code but are also presented with concrete
safeguarding trade secrets, conflict of interest, and security examples of the application of the code as a decision-
rules. It is possible that the leadership of this company is making tool. This form of discussion facilitates the
more aware than most management of the need for incorporation of the code into one's personal code and helps
responsible ethical guidance in areas related to computers to build personal scripts appropriate to a variety of
and computer technology. situations. A professional code is only effective to the
extent that individuals incorporate the philosophy of the
INFLUENCE OF OTHER FACTORS code into their own personal code of ethics and,
Study of Ethical Theory. Exposure to various subsequently, into expectations of the peer group of which
ethical theories indirectly impacts an individual's personal they are members.
code of ethics. According to Johnson (1985), the author of Computer Related Laws. Another influence on
the widely used book Computer Ethics, ethical theories personal codes of ethics is the body of law related to
provide a framework for uncovering rationale for moral computer abuse. Laws which apply include Fraud and
arguments and defending a declaration related to right or Abuse Legislation, Electronic Communications Privacy Act,
wrong. Such a framework is especially important if one Computer Security Act, Copyright Act, Trademark
takes action which is in conflict with the informal code of Counterfeiting Act, and various state statutes (Gardner,
the organization. Not only do etMcal theories provide a Samuels, Render, & Coffinberger, 1989). Obviously,
rational as part of the decision-making process, but they legislation influences the context in which decisions are
also provide a structure within which decisions can be made. However, critics suggest that existing laws may be
defended. A study of companies in the United States characterized as inadequate with respect to their associated
(Creating A Workable Company Code, 1990) reported that sanctions and punishments, and those rare cases that do find
28 % of the companies in the study conducted ethics training their way to court often find prosecutors and judges ill-
and 11% provided this training for all employees. These equipped to assess responsibility in the technological
results indicate a willingness on the part of the companies domain (Sacco & Zureik, 1989, 356). For example,
to directly address the issue of ethics training. prosecutions such as the widely publicized case of Robert
Professional Codes of Ethics. Historically, Morris's introduction of a "worm" into the Interact in 1988
direction in the area of computer ethics is provided by often result in penalties involving only fines and probation
professional organizations such as the Association for (Denning, 1990). However, Flanagan and McMenamin
Computing Machinery (ACM) (Anderson, Johnson, (1992) state that penalties seem to be getting stiffer and that
Gotterbarn, & Perrolle, 1993), the Data Processing "today he'd (Morris) probably be thrown in the slammer"
Managers Association (DPMA)(DPMA, 1989), the Institute (1992, 187).
of Electrical and Electronics Engineers-Computer Society In addition, the organization is vulnerable to legal
(IEEE-CS)(IEEE, 1987), and the Institute for Certification prosecution (Gardner et al., 1989). For example, legal
of Computer Professionals (ICCP). These and other groups action has been brought against several colleges and
have taken leadership positions by developing and universities for software copyright infringements (Gray &
disseminating codes of ethics related to computer use and Perle, 1992). One problem is the lack of clarity in the
the profession. Common themes in a number of codes for application of the terminology of the law to computer
computer professionals were identified by Martin and related situations (How do the concepts of copyright and
Martin (1990) as: personal integrity, personal accountability patent apply? What is property? What is invasion of
for work, responsibility to employer, responsibility to the privacy? See Johnson, 1985, for readings on these
profession, privacy of information, conflict of interest, topics.). Another problem related to the impact which laws
dignity of people, public safety, participation in have on individual behavior is the perception of minor
professional societies, and increased public knowledge about punishments for rather major inappropriate and illegal
technology. (The article contains the text of several behavior (See the Morris case above.). Laws are, however,
professional codes which were examined, e.g., the ACM, a deterrent to computer abuse to the extent that they are
IEEE, and ICCP codes.) Areas addressed by the understood by those using the technology, incorporated into
professional codes are areas of concern in computer ethics, the personal code of ethics, and supported and enforced by
and the professional codes provide guidance related to the informal and formal codes of ethics of the organization.
making ethical decisions. Suggestions for ways of strengthening the influence
For example, a paper by Anderson et al. (1993) of legislation related to computer abuse abound in the

ComputerPersonnel - October 1994 23


literature. These include: more laws, stronger penalties, standards (McDonald & Zepp, 1990). Unique decision
inform employees of personal liability for criminal acts situations arise for employees who deal with computers and
reinforcement of the laws by management, and prosecution computer technology; therefore, scripts must be built or
when violations are discovered. Clearly, these steps would modified to cover such situations. Development of
impact personal codes as well as the informal codes and appropriate personal codes of ethics with accompanying
formal codes of ethics within an organization. scripts is difficult (Piper, Gentile, Parks, 1993). In the
business setting, this can best be done through those factors
COMPARISON W I T H O T H E R MODELS in the model which impact the personal code: ethical
The constructs of particular concern in the model theory, professional codes, and computer laws. In addition,
presented in this article are personal codes, informal codes, discussions among employees of work situations and
and formal codes. These are rather broad but useful appropriate action decisions associated with the situations
categories for considering the influences on ethical decision could promote an appropriate personal code of ethics.
making. Many complex models have been developed to Informal Code. Whether or not there is a formal
describe the ethical decision-making process. For example, code relating to computer ethics, there will always be an
in their business ethics model, Bommer, Gratto, Gravander, informal code of behavior. The organization must foster
and Tuttle (1987) consider the impact of the following the development of appropriate ethical expectations related
environments on the decision process: work, to computers and computer technology among employees.
government/legal, social, individual, personal, and In an organization where many employees with varied
professional. The model proposed here is much simpler for backgrounds are using computer technology, information
several reasons. The employer or educator is interested in systems professionals should provide leadership.
factors that can be enhanced or modified by training, Obviously, clarification of appropriate behavior in
reinforcement, or other means. Therefore, a discussion of frequently encountered situations is important. Using the
the personal code in terms such as "social environment, elements of our model of ethical decision making, several
personal environment, and individual attributes," which suggestions for actions within organizations are made
Bommer et al. suggest as separate factors, is not practical. below.
Furthermore, even though "government/legal environment" Actions such as modeling behavior by
is an important force, one might think of it as an indirect management, support of appropriate employee decisions,
influence on the informal code of ethics as well as the and explicit discussion of potential problem areas are ways
personal and formal codes of ethics. The concept of that an appropriate informal code can be promoted. The
"professional environment" is useful to the current model informal code of behavior should be communicated to new
and is also viewed as an indirect influence on the employees by managers through exemplary behavior
individual's personal code of ethics. An additional reason modelling and visible rewards within the organization.
for the simpler model presented here is that it can serve as Having a more experienced peer as a mentor for a new
the focus for research. The identification of a few cogent employee would enhance the transmission of the informal
categories such as those specified in the model can focus the code of ethical conduct. Additionally, it is especially
study of the relative influence of these factors. Later, as important to have a non-authority figure to whom a new
the theory is grounded in empirical data, a more complex employee can turn for sound advice about expectations.
model can be introduced to further refine the influences on Frank dialogue with no fear on the part of the new
ethical decision-making. employee of reprisals or judgements is critical.
Furthermore, open discussion among all employees about
P R A C T I C A L IMPLICATIONS FOR ethically ambiguous situations would facilitate the
ORGANIZATIONS transmission of the informal code. These discussions could
Organizations should focus their efforts and be formalized into a training program or simply be a part
resources on developing appropriate personal, informal, and of already planned periodic meetings of employees.
formal codes of ethics in the work place. In addition Formats for the discussion include role playing, experiential
knowledge of the law, professional codes, and the study of exercises, and case analysis. Explicit discussions between
ethical theory can help guide employee ethical behavior. top management and employees could also serve to
Suggestions in each area are discussed below. strengthen and enhance personal codes of ethics and build
Personal Codes. Personal codes of ethics can be consistent scripts among peers. Informal ethical
effected in a variety of ways. Practical techniques found in expectations should be consistently enforced by the
the business ethics literature for developing and encouraging organizational culture and reward system.
an ethical approach to decision making include basic Formal Code. In addition to the informal code of
awareness programs, ethics-training programs, and explicit ethics, the formal code of ethics (company code) should
efforts to employ individuals having desirable ethical reflect desired behavior within the organization. It is

24 Computer Personnel = October 1994


important that there be a formal code of ethics within the meetings, or more formally as the topic of an employee
organization, and that the code contain provisions which training module (computer assisted instruction, video
specifically address computer technology and computer use. lecture, or with an instructor). Studies suggest that if
Such codes serve to communicate, clarify, and define individuals are presented with ethical questions or situations
expectations for employees. Since the code is endorsed by (scenarios) and led in a discussion of relevant issues, they
the organization, these expectations of behavior convey the are able to analyze and answer questions related to the
stance of senior management (Sclalegelmilch & Houston, ethical issues in a more socially acceptable way (Cohen &
1990). It is also important that such policies be congruent Comwell, 1989; Piper, Gentile, & Parks, 1993). These
with the informal code in the organization, because without strategies are appropriate to the work environment where
support from top management it is difficult to enforce such the discussion might be focused upon "real" ethical
expectations. dilemmas.
Computer-Related Laws. In a study of ethical
standards and computer crime laws, Gardner, Samuels, PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS FOR EDUCATORS
Render, and Coffmberger (1989) found that most people Computer Science and Information Systems (CS/IS)
who use computers and computer resources do not have a educators are constantly looking for ways to help students
clear understanding of relevant legal and ethical issues. develop skill at appropriate ethical decision making.
They conclude that computer crime and unethical conduct Although time is precious when trying to cover all of the
are more likely among individuals who are uninformed. material in a curriculum, ethical training is an important
Consequently, information should be available for part of this body of knowledge. Students should be
employees on current computer-related laws, especially introduced to a framework that can be used as a guide for
those which impact the particular work setting. For studying ethics. The model shown in Figure 1 and
example, a recent company newsletter contained an article suggested as a guide to develop appropriate ethical behavior
outlining provisions of computer related law in areas in the work place can also be used in the classroom. The
relevant to the functions of the company. Moreover, an following student activities are suggested for the computer
awareness of laws related to computer technology and ethics portion of the curriculum:
computer use would not only have an impact upon the
personal code but also the informal and formal codes. 1) A study of a decision-making model. The
Computer Professional Codes. Professionalism model shown in Figure 1 works well as a
among information systems staff might be enhanced by framework for the topics discussed in this paper.
companies sponsoring memberships in professional
organizations and encouraging awareness of professional 2) A study of several ethics theories which have
ethics codes. Unfortunately, some computer professionals very different bases for decision making (See
who belong to DPMA, ACM, IEEE, and other professional Johnson, 1985, for an excellent summary of some
organizations may not be aware of their organization's code theories.).
of ethics, thus removing the impact of the code on the
individual's ethical decision making. In order to use a code 3) A study of the professional codes of several
effectively, one must be aware of the philosophy of the CS/IS professional organizations (See Anderson et
code, committed to the purpose of the code, and able to al., 1993; and others.).
apply the guidelines appropriately. Familiarity with some
CS/IS professional codes by individuals and discussions by 4) A study of computer related laws, definition of
employees of the meaning of these code provisions as they terms, and recent decisions related to these laws
relate to the particular work setting would facilitate (See Denning, 1990; Dejoie, Fowler, & Paradice,
incorporation of the high standards of the professional 1991; as well as recent issues of Communications
groups into the personal code (scripts) of individuals and of the ACM,).
into the peer expectations within the organization.
General Ethics Theory. Researchers agree that it 5) Explicit discussion of the informal code of
is difficult to teach ethics directly. A knowledge of ethical ethics among the CS/IS majors. Data could be gaflxaed
t h e o r y provides a framework within which responsible using anonymous questionnaires on the
decisions can be made. Training involving exploration of approval/disapproval of certain behaviors or open- ended
ethical theories as they relate to personal codes of ethical responses to what-would-you-do type q u e s t i o n s.
decision making could be done to effect the quality of the These results can provide the source for discussion and
decisions being made related to computer technology. clarification of issues.
Exposure to such theories could be done as a series of
articles in a newsletter, short presentations during routine 6) A study of existing formal codes of ethics both

C o m p u t e r P e r s o n n e l - O c t o b e r 1994 25
at your college and other institutions (Voss & REFERENCES
Scott, 1993, suggest use of the Internet resources
to obtain these formal codes.). If your institution Anderson, R.E., Johnson, D.G., Gotterbarn, D., and
has no formal code, have the students write one. Perrole, J. (1993). Using the new ACM Code of Ethics in
decision making. Communications of the ACM, 36(2), 98-
7) Application of the material listed above to cases 107.
in class discussion, presentations, or debates
(Staehr, 1993). Sources of these cases are found Bommer, M., Gratto, C., Gravander, J., and Tuttle, M.
in newspaper articles, news magazines as well as (1987). A behavioral model of ethical and unethical
professional journals and books (See Huff & decision making. Journal of Business Ethics, 6, 265-280.
Finholt, 1994; Dejoie, Fowler, & Paradice, 1991;
Johnson, 1985; Denning, 1990; proceedings Cohen, E., and Comwell, L. (1989). A question of ethics:
articles such as Voss & Scott, 1993; and various Developing information system ethics. Journal of Business
introductory IS texts.). Ethics, 8, 431-437.

Although some educators prefer to treat computer Creating a workable company code of ethics. (1990).
ethics and societal issues in one course required by the Washington, D.C.: Ethics Resource Center.
major, the topic can be developed using a spiral approach
throughout the curriculum. If the latter approach is taken, Dejoie, R., Fowler, G., & Paradiee, D. (1991) Ethical
adequate coordination needs to be done among faculty to Issues in Information Systems. Boston, MA: Boyd &
ensure that all aspects of the model are developed and Fraser.
applied.
The goal is to provide entry-level computer Denning, P.J. (Ed.). (1990). Computers under attack. New
professionals with adequate background knowledge and York: ACM Press.
script development to handle the difficult computer related
ethical decisions in the ever-changing work environment.
After all, if students graduating from CS/IS programs are DPMA. (1989, January). DPMA position statement
well prepared to make ethical decisions, the entire burden handbook. Park Ridge, IL: DPMA.
for decision-making process development will not be on the
organizations which employ them. Flanagan, W.G., and McMemamin, B. (1992, December
21). The playground bullies are learning how to type.
Forbes Magazine, pp. 184-189.
THE BOTTOM LINE Gardner, E.P., Samuels, L.B., Render B., and
Something must be done to help all computer users Coffmberger, R.L. (1989, Fall). The importance of ethical
make informed, appropriate decisions related to the use of standards and computer Crime Laws for data security.
computers and computer technology since, Journal of Information Systems Management, pp. 42-50.

Ethical issues are ever present in uncertain Gray, A.P., and Perle, R.J. (1992). Attitudes o n legality
conditions where multiple stakeholder, interests, versus ethics in software copyrights. Interface, 14(4), 27-
and values are in conflict and laws are unclear 34.
(Trevino, 1986, 601).
Huff, C., & Finholt, T. (Eds.). (1994). Social issues in
When it comes to computer technology and computing putting computing in its place. New York:
computer use the rules of the game are seldom clear. McGraw-Hill.
Ethical decisions related to computers and
computer use are becoming increasingly important. The ICCP. ICCP code of ethics. ICCP, 2200 E. Devon Avenue,
study and development of proper ethical behavior is critical, Suite 268 , Des Plaines, IL 60018.
since computer technology pervades almost every aspect of
our professional and business life. This paper argues that IEEE. (1987). Ethics source sheet. New York: IEEE.
there should be a greater emphasis on the study of computer
ethics and suggest that the model shown in Figure 1 can be Johnson, D.G. (1985). Computer Ethics. Englewood Cliffs,
used to develop an effective structured approach to the NJ: Prentice-Hail, Inc.
development of standards for ethical decision making for
both working professionals and students. Kallman, E.A. (1992). Developing a code for ethical

26 Computer personnel - October 1994


computer use. Journal of Systems Software, 17, 69-74. Wheatley, W . J . , Maddox, E.N., and Anthony, W.P.
(1991). Enhancing guided mental imagery scripts utilized in
Lord, R. G. (1985). An information processing approach to the classroom. Education, 110, 33-39.
social perceptions, leadership, and behavioral measurement
in organizations. Research in Organizational Behavior, 7, Witkin, H.A., and Goodenough, D.R. (1977). Field
87-128. dependence and interpersonal behavior. Psychological
Bulletin, 84, 661-689.
Lord, R.G., and Maher, K.J. (1990). Alternative
information-processing models and their implications for Voss, R.B., and Scott, T.J. (1993). Teaching computer
theory, research, and practice. Academy of Management ethics electronically. Proceeding of the Computers on
Review, 15(1), 9-28. Campus Conference, Myrtle Beach, SC.

Martin, C.D., and Martin, D.H. (1990). Professional codes


of conduct and computer ethics education. Social Science John W. Henry
Computer Review. 8(1), 96-108. Department of Management
Landrum Box 8152
McDonald, G.M., and Zepp, R.A. (1990). What should be Georgia Southern University
done? A practical approach to business ethics. Management Statesboro, Georgia 30460
Decision, 28(1), 9-14.

Molander, E.A. (1987). A paradigm for design, Margaret Anne Pierce


promulgation and enforcement of ethical codes. Journal of Department of Math / Computer Science
Business Ethics, 6, 619-631. Landrun Box 8093
Georgia Southern University
Paradice, D.B. (1990) Ethical attitudes of entry-level MIS Statesboro, Georgia 30460
personnel. Information and Management, 18, 143-151.

Piper, T.R., Gentile, M.C., and Parks, S.D. (1993). Can


ethics be taught? Boston, MA: Harvard Business School
Press.

Sacco, V.F. and Zureik, E. (1990). Correlates of computer


misuse: Data from a self-reporting sample, Behavior and
Information Technology, 9(5), 353-369.

Schlegelmilch, B.B. and Houston, J.E. (1990). Corporate


codes of ethics. Management Decisions, 28(7), 38-43.

Staehr, L. (1993). Debating: Its use in teaching social


aspects of computing SIGCSE Bulletin, 25(4), 46-49.

Straub, D.W., Jr., Nance, W.D., and Carlson, C.L.


(1990). Discovering and discipline computer abuse in
organizations: A field study. MIS Quarterly, 14(1), 45-60.

Trevino, L.K. (1986). Ethical decision making in


organizations: A person-situation interactionist model.
Academy of Management Review, 11(3), 601-617.

Wahn, J. (1993). Organizational dependence and the


likelihood of complying with organizational pressures to
behave unethically. Journal of Business Ethics, 12, 245-
251.

Computer Personnel - October 1994 27


l

Anda mungkin juga menyukai