The manuscript was received on 5 August 2008 and was accepted after revision for publication on 2 October 2008.
DOI: 10.1243/09544062JMES1315
Abstract: With constraints on size, cost, reliability, and performance for liquid-based cooling sys-
tems, the design of modular micropumps suitable for an integrated thermal management system
still remains a challenge. In this paper, the effectiveness of a low-cost valveless micropump–heat
exchanger on a printed circuit board is investigated for electronic cooling. Signal conditioning
and control electronics are integrated with the fluidic components on the substrate to form a
compact modular unit. Piezoelectric actuation and conical diffusers are utilized to generate pul-
sating flow through a minichannel heat sink. With ethanol as the working fluid, the tested pump
reached a maximum flowrate and a pressure head of 2.4 ml/min and 743 Pa at an input voltage of
6 VDC . Suitability of the system for active real-time temperature control has been demonstrated
at two input heater power levels of 1.45 and 2.5 W. A maximum reduction of 57 per cent in the
average heat sink surface temperature could be achieved at a maximum power consumption of
150 mW by the micropump.
1 INTRODUCTION but noise, cost, and efficiency are still areas of con-
cern for practical implementation [1]. Liquid-cooled
Thermal management at chip and component level microchannel heat sinks have been shown to be one
has emerged as one of the most critical issues for fur- of the more promising solutions for very high heat dis-
ther development of temperature-sensitive electronic sipation in future space-constrained microelectronic
devices and systems. Natural and forced air convec- systems [2].
tion heat sinks used for cooling electronics on single- In a typical forced convective liquid cooling loop,
and multi-chip printed circuit boards (PCBs) are fast heat is picked up by the coolant from the pri-
reaching their limit in terms of performance and size. mary heat exchanger mounted on electronic chip
A number of approaches such as spray cooling, micro- and rejected through a secondary liquid to an air–
jets, and thin-film evaporation have been proposed, eliquid heat exchanger, with a pump providing the
necessary driving force [3]. A number of studies have
been performed during the past decade to miniatur-
∗ Corresponding author: Department of Mechanical Engineer- ize this cooling loop and optimize its performance.
ing, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Hydroturbo- Experimental and theoretical studies on single- and
machine Laboratory, Chennai, Tamil Nadu 600036, India. email: two-phase fluid flow through microchannel heat
dhiman@iitm.ac.in exchangers have shown that heat fluxes on the order
JMES1315 © IMechE 2009 Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science
954 P Verma, D Chatterjee, and T Nagarajan
of kW/cm2 can be dissipated [4, 5]. Microchannel management system. Merkel et al. [25] introduced the
flow geometry offers a very large surface area to vol- concept of integrated fluidic microsystems on PCB
ume ratio, thereby enabling high heat transfer rate. substrates, and its cost advantages over silicon as a
However, it has been hard to implement in commer- substrate material for low-cost batch fabrication have
cial applications, due to the associated penalty of a been investigated by Nguyen and Huang [23]. Hybrid
high drop in pressure. Constraints on size, weight, integration of electronic and fluidic components on
and power requirement for conventional macroscale ceramic substrates with thick-film technology offers a
pumps render them unsuitable for miniaturization very high degree of integration with inherent advan-
and integration, especially in a portable cooling loop. tages on reliability and performance.
With advances in microfluidics technology, an out- From the aforementioned survey of past work, it is
standing diversity in micropumping principles and clear that considerable work has been done to enhance
mechanisms has been proposed [6, 7]. A review of heat flux removal in integrated circuits (IC), using
the state of the art in micropumping techniques liquid-based microchannel cooling. Also, an extensive
with an emphasis on microchannel cooling systems variety in micropumping principles and techniques
has been compiled by Singhal et al. [8]. Reciprocat- has been demonstrated. Further attention should be
ing diaphragm, flexural plate wave, electro-osmotic focused from a device perspective, towards integrat-
and electrohydrodynamic principles were identified ing the heat exchanger and the pumping mechanism.
as having significant potential for integration with Minichannels may be used in applications where
the heat exchanger. Recently, micropumps mono- portability and cost restrict the use of high pumping
lithically integrated within microchannels have been power and the requirements for heat removal are mod-
demonstrated [9–11]. Since the pump shares the same erate. Piezoelectric elements have been widely used
footprint as the channels, a considerable reduction for sensing and actuation, and several investigations
in the overall system size is obtained. With important have been performed to characterize and optimize
technologies for assembly, interconnection, and hous- their performance [26–28]. Previous investigations by
ing being still explored for a practical micropump–heat the authors have shown the suitability of piezoelec-
exchanger unit, the need for portable, low-cost, and tric actuators for integration with fluidic elements on
low-power consuming micropumps, suitable for sys- PCB [24]. High actuation voltage has often been men-
tem integration, is apparent. Reciprocating diaphragm tioned as a bottleneck towards its development in
micropumps with valveless designs are good candi- portable applications [29]. However, piezoelectric ele-
dates due to their amenability to miniaturization and ments are, in principle, low power consuming devices
absence of any internal moving parts. Moreover, a and as shown in this work, with appropriate signal con-
broad range in pumping fluids, actuators, substrate ditioning, portable batteries can be used for meeting
materials, and fabrication technologies are available. the power requirement of the micropump.
Stemme and Stemme [12] presented the first pro- In this paper, the design and development of an inte-
totype valveless micropump in brass utilizing piezo- grated micropump–heat exchanger unit on portable
electric actuation and conical converging/diverging PCB is investigated for electronic cooling. The working
channels to deliver a pulsatile flow. The principle of principle of the piezoelectrically actuated micropump
variable resistance to fluid flow in opposite directions with conical diffuser elements is initially introduced.
in the conduit was utilized to direct the fluid flow from This is followed by a description of the fabrication
inlet to outlet. Spatial and planar designs with pyrami- steps involved in manufacturing the modular stand-
dal [13], Tesla valve [14], and enhanced vortex-shaped alone micropump, including the design and perfor-
flow channels [15] have been presented as alternate mance of the signal conditioning and control unit.
forms for valveless pumping. The mature state of sili- The experimental set-up and associated instrumen-
con micromachining has provided further impetus tation used for characterizing the integrated system
and several planar valveless micropumps have been are described next. Results for the hydraulic and ther-
fabricated using isotropic etching [16], anisotropic mal performance of the modular micropump–heat
etching [17], and deep reactive ion etching [18]. Due exchanger are then presented, and finally relevant
to the high cost involved in mask making, clean room conclusions are drawn.
processes, and packaging required for silicon-based
micropumps [19], alternate fabrication technologies
have been explored. Thermoplastic replication [20], 2 PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION OF THE VALVELESS
numerically controlled machining [21], powder blast- MICROPUMP
ing [22], and PCB [23, 24] techniques have been shown
as low-cost solutions for small-scale fabrication of The basic elements of the valveless micropump are
valveless micropumps. Among these technologies, two similar conical diffuser/nozzle elements attached
PCB technology allows hybrid integration of elec- to the pump chamber in reverse orientation, and a
tronic and fluidic components on a common substrate thin circular diaphragm, actuated periodically using
and is economically favourable for a portable thermal the piezoelectric element (Fig. 1). The pump principle
Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science JMES1315 © IMechE 2009
Design and development of a modular valveless micropump 955
JMES1315 © IMechE 2009 Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science
956 P Verma, D Chatterjee, and T Nagarajan
Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science JMES1315 © IMechE 2009
Design and development of a modular valveless micropump 957
Fig. 5 Schematic of the experimental set-up used to characterize the integrated cooling system
JMES1315 © IMechE 2009 Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science
958 P Verma, D Chatterjee, and T Nagarajan
Fig. 6 Half-sectional schematic of the tested heat sink. Fig. 7 Frequency response of the 20 mm diameter actu-
All dimensions are in mm. Material A is alu- ator without liquid loading
minium, B is the fluid zone, C is Perspex, and D
shows the plane of symmetry. Tw1 –Tw4 indicate
the locations of surface mounted thermocouples first resonance frequency of the actuator appears at
approximately 5 kHz. The inertia of the diaphragm can
thus be neglected at frequencies much lower than this
and in the plastic tube downstream of the heat sink frequency and its mechanical response under such
(To ). The entire assembly was thermally packed using conditions can be assumed to be quasi-static.
glass wool to reduce convective losses to air. Numerical analyses were performed using the finite
Temperature from the thermocouples was acquired element package ANSYS. In these simulations, tetra-
and monitored continuously using a data logger (HP hedral structural element solid-92 and coupled field
34970A) and stored in a computer for further analysis. element solid-98 were chosen to model the passive
AC power to the heater was supplied through a Variac brass plate and the PZT layers, respectively. It has
in order to control the heat flux input to the heat sink. been seen that for bonding layer to passive plate
Voltage and current across the heater and the modular thickness ratio (hb–p ) below 0.3, minor changes in
micropump were monitored during the experiments deflection characteristics are obtained for a circu-
using an oscilloscope (Agilent, Model DSO3102A) and lar PZT actuator in a valveless micropump [26, 27].
current and voltage meters. Moreover, for PZT/passive plate thickness ratio (hpzt–p )
above 0.4 the bonding layer effects were seen to be
insignificant. Considering the values (hb–p ∼ 0.1 and
5 EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
hpzt–p = 1) used in the present actuator, the bond-
ing layer effects on the displacement were considered
Investigations were initially performed to determine negligible and not modelled. The cylindrical passive
the performance characteristics of the piezoelectric plate and PZT volumes were glued such that the com-
actuator used to drive the fluid flow. Hydraulic testing mon areas, lines, and key points were merged during
of the micropump with a heat sink in series between the modelling. The material properties of PZT-4 were
the inlet and outlet reservoirs was then conducted. used during simulations and all the degrees of free-
Finally, experiments were performed at the optimal dom of the bottom edge of the passive plate were
pump frequency to determine the effectiveness of the constrained, to simulate the simply supported case.
pumping system in controlling the temperature rise in Grid independence studies were initially performed in
the heat sink. order to minimize the computational resources and
verify the accuracy of the finite element model. Sim-
5.1 Piezoelectric actuator characterization ulation results for the harmonic frequency analysis of
the actuator are shown in Fig. 7. There is a reason-
Experimental and numerical investigations were per- able match between the experimental and numerical
formed to study the effect of frequency and voltage results.
on the static and dynamic deflection characteris- To further validate the numerical approach and
tics of the actuator, without liquid loading. A Laser determine the volume of fluid displaced by the actu-
Doppler Vibrometer (POLYTEC OFV-551) was inter- ator, simulation results for the displaced volume are
faced with a data acquisition system (NI PXI-1033) compared with the experimental results obtained by
to determine the frequency response, by applying the present authors using Digital Speckle Pattern
a sinusoidal signal through an arbitrary waveform Interferometry [24]. The actuator used in that study
generator (Agilent 3325a). As shown in Fig. 7, the included a 35 mm brass diaphragm with a 25 mm
Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science JMES1315 © IMechE 2009
Design and development of a modular valveless micropump 959
Fig. 8 Effect of applied DC voltage on the volume Fig. 9 Effect of excitation frequency on the performance
displaced by the actuators characteristics of the micropump
JMES1315 © IMechE 2009 Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science
960 P Verma, D Chatterjee, and T Nagarajan
Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science JMES1315 © IMechE 2009
Design and development of a modular valveless micropump 961
Q̇ = ρ V̇ Cp (To − Ti ) (2)
Fig. 12 Effect of liquid flow on the rise time and average
steady-state temperatures of the heat sink for
1.45 W heater input power where ρ and Cp are the density and specific heat of
ethanol, respectively. The heat flux per unit area can
To determine the rise time required to reach a steady be expressed as q = Q̇/2(2Ab + As ), where Ab and As
surface temperature with liquid flow in the heat sink, are the base and side areas of the heat sink exposed to
the micropump was activated before the heater was ethanol. The top of each channel was covered with per-
turned on. The variation of average heat sink temper- spex as coverslip and is not considered to contribute
ature Tw with time at 1.45 W input power is shown in to heat transfer in these calculations. The experimen-
Fig. 12. It is seen that the steady wall temperature drops tal heat transfer coefficient and the Nu can thus be
with increasing liquid flowrate and a steady state could determined from equations (3) and (4)
be reached within a much shorter time (from over
30 min without liquid to around 10 min at 2 ml/min q
h= (3)
flowrate). [Tw − 1
2
(To + Ti )]
A normalized heat sink temperature can be defined
to examine the effectiveness of the micropump–heat hDh
Nu = (4)
exchanger unit for thermal management. k
Tw − Ta
θ= (1) where Dh is the hydraulic diameter of the channel
Tw,max − Ta and k is the thermal conductivity of ethanol. The
where Tw,max is the maximum wall temperature in experimentally obtained heat transfer coefficient var-
the absence of liquid and Ta is the ambient temper- ied from 40 to 110 W/m2 K and the corresponding Nu
ature. Figure 13 shows the variation of the normalized values varied between 0.8 and 2.3 over the entire range
heat sink surface temperatures against the flowrate. It of flowrates and heater power levels considered. The
values are lower than that reported for steady flow in
literature. Since pulsating flow has been used in the
experiments, it is expected that Nu would additionally
depend on the amplitude and frequency of pulsation.
Moreover, it has been observed that except for a small
window of this frequency, the time-averaged Nu value
could be lower than the corresponding steady state Nu
numbers [34]. A weak dependence of Nu on Reynolds
number seen in the experimental data is because the
length of the channel (25 mm) is only slightly longer
than the thermal entry length (23 mm) and this might
have influenced the average heat transfer coefficient
calculated here, as reported in reference [35].
Since a commercially available heat sink with non-
optimized minichannel geometry and low flowrates
were utilized in this study, the heat tranfer rate is small.
Fig. 13 Effect of liquid flowrate on normalized average It is expected that by improving the pumping perfor-
surface temperature of the heat sink and electri- mance further and employing microchannels, much
cal power consumption by the micropump higher heat tranfer coefficients can be obtained.
JMES1315 © IMechE 2009 Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science
962 P Verma, D Chatterjee, and T Nagarajan
Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science JMES1315 © IMechE 2009
Design and development of a modular valveless micropump 963
30 Olsson, A., Stemme, G., and Stemme, E. Numerical and 33 Pan, L. S., Ng, T. Y., Wu, X. H., and Lee, H. P. Analysis of
experimental studies of flat walled diffuser elements valveless micropumps with inertial effects. J. Micromech.
for valveless micropumps. Sens. Actuator A, 2000, 84, Microeng., 2003, 13, 390–399.
165–175. 34 Moschandreou, T. and Zamir, M. Heat transfer in a flow
31 Sun, C. L. and Huang, K. H. Numerical characteriza- with pulsating flow and constant heat flux. Int. J. Heat
tion of the flow rectification of dynamic microdiffusers. Mass Transf., 1997, 40(10), 2461–2462.
J. Micromech. Microeng., 2006, 16, 1331–1339. 35 Kandlikar, S. G. Single phase liquid flow in minichannels
32 Thakkar, D. and Ganguli, R. Use of single crystal and soft and microchannels. In Heat transfer and fluid flow in
piezoceramics for alleviation of flow separation induced minichannels and microchannels (Eds S. G. Kandlikar, S.
vibration in a smart helicopter rotor. Smart Mater. Struct., Garimella, D. Li, S Colin, and M. R. King), 2006, pp. 87–136
2006, 15, 331–341. (Elsevier Publications, UK).
JMES1315 © IMechE 2009 Proc. IMechE Vol. 223 Part C: J. Mechanical Engineering Science