www.elsevier.com/locate/ijrefrig
Received 5 July 2001; received in revised form 5 March 2002; accepted 14 March 2002
Abstract
An adsorptive solar refrigerator was built and tested in May 1999 in Ouagadougou, Burkina-Faso. The adsorption
pair is activated carbon + methanol. The adsorber is also the solar collector (2 m2, single glazed), the condenser is air-
cooled (natural convection) and the evaporator contains 40 l of water that can freeze into ice. This amount of ice acts
as a cold storage for the cold cabinet (available volume of 440 l). Elements such as valves and a graduated bottle are
installed, but only for experimental purposes. Apart from these valves, and also ventilation dampers which are open at
night time and closed at daytime, the machine does not contain any moving parts and does not consume any
mechanical energy. Within the requirement of vacuum technology, the machine is relatively easy to manufacture, so
that construction in Burkina-Faso is feasible. Experimental performance is presented in terms of gross solar COP.
During the test period, irradiance were quite good (between 19 and 25 MJ m2), but the ambient temperature was
relatively warm (averagely 27.4 C at sunrise and 37.4 C at mid-afternoon). The experimental values of the gross solar
COP lie between 0.09 and 0.13. Despite a warm climate, the performance of the machine compares favourably to
previously published results. # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd and IIR. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Refrigerating system; Absorption system; Carbon; Methanol; Solar energy; Test; Burkina Faso
0140-7007/03/$20.00 # 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd and IIR. All rights reserved.
PII: S0140-7007(02)00018-X
80 F. Buchter et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 26 (2003) 79–86
However, the use of liquid sorption for solar cooling One of our goals is to study and propose a system
induces two features. First, liquid sorption cycles oper- which allows a good compromise between the following
ate continuously, while solar energy is inherently tran- constraints: the possibility of construction in developing
sient during the day and vanishes during the night. A countries, high reliability, and good performance.
large heat-storage must then be installed between the Simplicity of construction largely depends on the
solar collectors and the generator. Second, the solution refrigerant. Systems with ammonia (liquid sorption or
is most often circulated by a pump working all day long. chemical reaction) operate at over-atmospheric pres-
This pump consumes electricity that must be supplied sure. Systems with water or methanol (mainly liquid
by photovoltaic cells or a reliable electricity network. It sorption or adsorption) operate at under-atmospheric
therefore results that hybrid power (solar + fuel) suits pressure. In any case, to maintain good performance,
liquid sorption well [5]. the machine must be made leak proof, with advanced
Solid sorption works differently. First, the cycles are technology (vacuum or pressure) for welding and
by principle transient: heat is accumulated in the sor- connections.
bent resulting in desorption of refrigerant vapour and For the sake of reliability, we preferred solid sorption
only a cold-storage is necessary for providing refrigera- because, first the sorbent bed can be implemented in the
tion over the 24 h period. Second, the cycle itself works solar collector; second, they need no heat storage; third,
without any mechanical input or moving parts. In they need no circulation pump. Indeed, the later would
addition to reliability, full autonomy with solar energy require additional energy supply and special main-
should be achievable, which is very attractive for instal- tenance. However, we must mention two features of
lation in remote areas. solid sorption machines. First, during daily operation,
There are two solid sorption systems likely to be condensation in the evaporator must be prevented. This
solar-powered: chemical reaction and adsorption. After can be done by installing between the condenser and the
pioneering works [6], chemical reaction solar refrig- evaporator a valve that must be operated only twice a
erators are evoking new interest thanks to novel com- day: closed at sunrise, open at sunset. We have chosen a
posite materials impregnated with chloride salts [7–9]. manually operated valve, but we have good hopes of
Solar-powered adsorption systems have been investi- developing a device that would make this manual oper-
gated by several groups. In addition to models [10–16], ation unnecessary. Second, for good efficiency, the sor-
real machines have been developed [17–30]. Some of bent bed must be cooled at night. The efficiency of this
them use sophisticated solar collectors with concentra- cooling is fairly important for the adsorption pair car-
tion [17–19], others use the adsorbent itself, contained bon + methanol [23]. For this purpose, ventilation
in a transparent tube, as the solar-energy-absorbing dampers can be installed on the solar collectors; once
material [18,20], but the most efficient configuration these dampers are open, the cooling of the collectors is
seems to consist of metallic flat-plate solar collectors, significantly enhanced. Here again, these dampers must
single- or double-glazed, covered with a selective sur- be operated only twice a day: closed at sunrise, open at
face and filled with the adsorbent bed [11,14,21–30]. To mid-afternoon.
complete this short review about solar refrigeration Lastly, considering the performance of solid sorption
with sorption systems, let us also mention Ref. [31] that systems, the largest COP’s (0.10–0.12) were obtained with
compares the three sorption systems: liquid, chemical the adsorption systems zeolite + water [11] and activated
and adsorption. carbon + methanol [22,23,28]. The latter system offers
F. Buchter et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 26 (2003) 79–86 81
that additional advantage that methanol can easily eva- Burkina-Faso, latitude 12.292 N. As mentioned in the
porate at temperatures below 0 C, so that ice can be introduction, the adsorption pair is activated carbon
produced to act as the above-mentioned cold storage. plus methanol.
From this development, it can be deduced that the We selected the technique of single-glazed flat-plate
adsorption pair activated carbon + methanol, operated selective solar collector, which is a good compromise
in a 24 h cycle, with the carbon implemented in flat- between simplicity and efficiency at temperatures around
plate, single-glazed solar collectors covered by a selec- 100 C. Fig. 3 presents a schema and Table 2 summarizes
tive surface, can be the basis for efficient solar-powered the main characteristics of the collector-adsorber. The
refrigerators that would not require much advanced ventilation dampers mentioned in the previous sections
technology except for weldings and connections, so that consist of a mechanism that opens the thermal insulation
such machines could be manufactured in developing on the rear side of the collector, as shown in Fig. 3
countries. Parallel finned tubes make a condenser cooled by nat-
As far as self-sufficiency in terms of energy is con- ural convection, which should guarantee a temperature
cerned, we think that the manual valve can be replaced difference with the ambient temperature lower than 10 K.
by an automatic device. The only remaining bottleneck The evaporator consists of parallel tubes welded at
is the need for ventilation dampers, and this is why we each end to a manifold. The evaporator is submerged in
have focused the present study on this point. An acti- water. During the evaporation of methanol, part of this
vated carbon + methanol machine with dampers was water turns into ice, which acts as a cold storage, keep-
tested in France [28,29] while others without dampers ing the cold chamber below 5 C during the next day,
were tested in Morocco [22,23]. The ambient tempera- and also for a theoretical period of three days with low
ture is, of course, of high importance for the nocturnal irradiance. The cold cabinet is of the chest-type, and is
cooling of the collector. well insulated.
Our study presents the design of an activated carbon The only valve necessary is located between the grad-
+ methanol machine for a typical sahelian hot and uated bottle and the evaporator, see (4) in Fig. 4. Other
dusty climate, together with its test results in Ouaga- valves have been implemented for experimental pur-
dougou, Burkina-Faso. This machine is equipped with poses.
manually operated dampers. After the presentation of Fig. 4 shows the general arrangement of the machine:
experimental measurements and performance over a the collector is placed on the roof of the building, while
period of 3 weeks, our analysis focuses on the effect of all the other components are located under the roof in
the ventilation dampers, especially by comparison with order to protect them from the sun.
Refs. [22,23]. The temperature is measured (Pt100 probes and ther-
mocouples type K) on the collector-adsorber (see G in
Fig. 3), on the condenser, and on the evaporator; and
2. Principle of the adsorption cooling cycle the ambient air temperature is also measured. The
vapour pressure is measured (piezogauge 0–1 bar)
The basis of the adsorption cooling cycle is an alter- between the condenser and graduated bottle. The global
nation of heating and cooling periods, where the adsor- solar irradiance is recorded by a pyranometer (Kipp
bent pumps the vapour in and out like a thermally- Zonen) parallel to the collector. A graduated bottle (12 l)
driven piston. All the tests reported in the references [6– collects the liquefied methanol, see Figs. 1 and 4. The
30] fit this alternative cycle (also called intermittent) to level of liquid methanol is read from time to time during
the alternation day/night as we did. An ideal cycle is desorption, more closely when desorption approaches
presented in the Clausius–Clapeyron diagram (lnP vs.
1/T) (Fig. 1). This figure and Table 1 summarize the
main phases of the process. A complete description of
the adsorption cooling cycle is available in other pub-
lications [28,29]
Table 1
Main steps in the adsorption refrigerating cycle, especially when solar-powered
Table 2
Main characteristics of the machine
Constitutive parts
12 Tubes, external diameter 70 mm, 7 Tubes, 2 m length 8 Tubes, external Water tank of 40 l
thickness 1 mm diameter 50 mm
40 kg Acticarbone AC40, CECA Pitch between fins of 12 mm Insulation: 150 mm of
expanded polystyrene
Selective layer (1Maxorb)
Absorptance 0.9
Emissivity 0.10–0.15
Central tube (metal grid)
Diameter 10 mm
Insulation: 30 mm glass-wool
84 F. Buchter et al. / International Journal of Refrigeration 26 (2003) 79–86
Table 3
Meteorological data and experimental performance measured over 3 weeks. The last column contains the gross solar COP evaluated
for the BLM unit according to Eq. (3)
Global irradiation Ambient air temperature Experimental gross Evaluated gross solar
(MJ/ m2) solar COPs (–) COP (BLM) (–)
Day At 6.30 a.m. At 4.00 p.m.
( C) ( C)
in the present case can only be the gross cold produc- Eq. (3) and the meteorological data reported in
tion. Although this data is not available in the articles of Table 3 permit an evaluation of the probable gross cold
Boubakri et al. [22,23], thanks to a recent article of this production of a BLM ice-maker if it had been operated
author (Boubakri et al. [32]) the heat losses and the heat in Ouagadougou during the same test period. Fig. 6
capacity of the evaporator plus cold chamber can be shows the comparison of this evaluated gross cold pro-
reasonably evaluated, leading to the following expres- duction to that actually recorded in Ouagadougou; also
sion for the gross cold production of the BLM ice- the values of the net cold production calculated with
maker with AC40, see Eq. (3) here: Eq. (2) are reported. It appears that, on average, the
gross cold production of the BLM ice-maker would
qeðgrossÞ ¼ 1000 þ 0:095 qh 5 Td 46 Tn ð3Þ have been lower than that recorded in Ouagadougou by
26%. The net cold production would have been lower
where the heat quantities q are in kJ m2 and the tem- by 55%. These two ratios are shown by dashed lines (see
peratures T in Celsius. Fig. 6).
At first sight, it could be deduced that the machine in
Ouagadougou is 35% more efficient than the BLM
machine tested in Agadir (1/0.74=1.35). However, our
analysis is different because the two machines differ on
an important point: the BLM machines were not equip-
ped with ventilation dampers opened at night. As a
result, the nocturnal cooling of the adsorber was much
less efficient than for the present machine. Indeed, Bou-
bakri et al. [32] recently mentioned that with efficient
nocturnal cooling of the collector,the performance of
the BLM machine would be increased by one third
(from 6 to 8 kg of ice per square meter collector), prac-
tically the same proportion as the +35% mentioned
Fig. 5. Typical measurements over a 24 h period: global irra-
above. In other words, it can be said that the machine in
diance (I), temperature of collector-adsorber (II), condenser
temperature (III ‘*’), ambient air temperature (IV ‘*’), eva- Ouagadougou is roughly as efficient as the BLM
porator temperature (V ‘&’), volume of condensed methanol machine, except that the opening of ventilation dampers
(VI ‘’), vapour pressure (VII ‘+’). Peculiar points of Fig. 1 during the night improves the performance by one third.
are displayed: A (6.23 a.m.), B (9.40 a.m.), D (4.04 p.m.), and F This proportion is quite significant and efforts should
(6.48 p.m.). probably be made to develop systems that would auto-
matically open the dampers in late afternoon and close
them in the morning, e.g. with photovoltaic cells and a
small motor.
6. Conclusion