1054 REPORTS Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Vol. 88, No. 15, August 7, 1996
permits the rapid return of blocks to the the slides stored for 12 weeks was compared with was used at a 1:450 dilution (Ventana proprietary
originating institution, obviating the need that of the slides on day 0. buffer). DAB was used as the chromogen (Ventana
We also studied three of these 12 cases known proprietary solution), and the sections were lightly
to retain these blocks indefinitely. How- to be ER positive and an additional six cases of ER- counterstained with hematoxylin.
ever, if loss of immunoreactivity is a con- positive invasive ductal carcinomas retrieved from ER immunostaining. Following the microwave
sequence of storage of sections on glass our surgical pathology files to assess antigen loss for antigen retrieval method as described above, we ap-
slides at room temperature, the potential ER and for the Bcl-2 oncoprotein. Slides stored at plied the primary murine monoclonal antibody to
room temperature for 12 weeks and freshly cut ER (clone ER1D5, IgGl kappa; Immunotech,
exists for spurious negative results. This
slides from the same paraffin blocks of these nine Westbrook, ME) overnight at 4 'C at a 1:10 dilution
outcome, in turn, could have serious im- cases were stained for both ER and Bcl-2 protein by in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) supplemented
plications for the results of both clinical use of manual immunohistochemical methods, since with 1% bovine serum albumin (BSA). The slides
and research laboratory studies that util- these antibodies produced suboptimal staining were then sequentially incubated for 30 minutes
ize such material. results with the use of the automated immuno- with biotinylated horse anti-mouse immunoglobulin
stainer. Again, the staining intensity of the slides (immunoglobulin G heavy and light chains; Vector
Since we have previously shown that stored for 12 weeks was compared with that of the Laboratories, Inc., Burlingame, CA) in a 1.5-mg/mL
immunoreactivity for the p53 protein slides on day 0 for both ER and Bcl-2 by use of stock solution diluted 1:500 in PBS supplemented
diminishes over time in stored slides of computer-assisted image analysis. with 1% BSA and for 30 minutes with streptavidin-
breast cancers (5), the purposes of the In addition to quantifying staining intensity by horseradish peroxidase (Zymed Laboratories Inc.,
image analysis, two observers (T. W. Jacobs and S. South San Francisco, CA) diluted 1:200 in PBS sup-
present study were 1) to examine in detail
J. Schnitt) visually examined all slides under the plemented with 1% BSA. DAB (0.6 mg/mL; Sigma
the time course and factors influencing Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO) was used as the chro-
light microscope and categorized them as "negative"
p53 antigen loss on stored slides and 2) to or "positive" for p53, ER, and Bcl-2. Cases were mogen, and the sections were lightly counterstained
determine if loss of reactivity on stored scored as p53 negative, ER negative, or Bcl-2 nega- with methyl green.
slides occurs for several other antigens
Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Vol. 88, No. 15, August 7, 1996 REPORTS 1055
Statistical Methods
Results of computer-assisted image analysis are
presented as percent staining intensity (means ± 100 RT
standard error) of that on day 0. Statistical sig- 4°C
nificance was set at P<.05. Data were analyzed by Paraffin coat, RT
the Friedman Repeated Measures Analysis of Paraffin coat, 4°C Fig. 1. Loss of p53 im-
80
Variance on Ranks. Computations were performed
with the SigmaStat for Windows software (version
1 munostaining over time
following slide storage at
room temperature (RT) or
2.0; Jandel Scientific, San Rafael, CA). at 4 "C, with or without
an additional coating of
paraffin on the surface of
Results the slides. At each time
point, staining intensity
40 - was significantly weaker
Effect of Storage at Room Temperature than that on day 0. In
z
on p53-Staining Intensity < addition, slides stored at
4 *C showed significantly
Nine (75%) of the 12 p53-positive 20 - less loss of immunostain-
ing intensity than slides
cases showed significant loss of p53- stored at RT at each time
staining intensity following storage at point (all /><05).
room temperature. After 2 weeks of
storage, p53-staining intensity had al- 4 6 8 10 12
ready significantly decreased to 30.5% ± STORAGE TIME (WEEKS)
1056 REPORTS Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Vol. 88, No. 15, August 7, 1996
Downloaded from http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on September 13, 2012
Fig. 2. Invasive ductal carcinoma immunostained for p53 at day 0 (A)
and after storage at room temperature for 2 weeks (B) and 12 weeks (C)
(original magnification x200).
factor VIII, and one showed no sig- ing results for several antigens frequently The mechanism of antigen loss in
nificant reduction in staining intensity for used to study breast cancers. fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections
either antigen after 12 weeks of slide The fact that antigen loss can occur mounted on glass slides is not known.
storage at room temperature. in stored slides does not appear to be Our results, however, suggest that this
widely appreciated. To the contrary, the phenomenon is at least in part tempera-
Discussion general perception is that stored, un- ture dependent, since storage at 4 °C
stained paraffin-embedded sections on resulted in less loss of p53 immunoreac-
We have shown that, in most cases, slides "have always been acceptable" tivity than storage at room temperature. It
slide storage at room temperature results for immunohistochemical studies (4). is possible that slide storage at even
in rapid and substantial loss of p53 im- The results of our study, in conjunction colder temperatures might further dimin-
munoreactivity in paraffin-embedded sec- with those of two prior smaller studies ish loss of immunostaining intensity.
tions of breast cancer. In fact, some cases (5,5), however, call into question the Exposure of tissue sections to the atmos-
initially categorized as p53 positive were conventional wisdom regarding the phere may be another explanation for an-
scored as p53 negative on slides stored ability to obtain accurate immunostain- tigen loss in stored slides, since this
for 12 weeks. A significant loss of stain- ing results for all antigens on stored exposure could theoretically result in
ing intensity also occurs for factor VIII- slides. Unfortunately, the range of an- oxidation of certain antigens or epitopes.
related antigen, ER protein, and Bcl-2 tigens and tissues for which this is a In our study, however, coating the surface
protein after storage of slides at room potential problem is currently unknown, of the tissue sections with paraffin to
temperature for 12 weeks. These findings but diminished immunoreactivity on diminish contact with the ambient atmos-
indicate that storage of paraffin-em- stored slides is unlikely to be limited to phere did not significantly reduce the loss
bedded sections on glass slides may the antigens studied here or to breast of immunoreactivity for p53 protein.
produce spurious negative immunostain- specimens (6). Nonetheless, it is possible that slide
Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Vol. 88, No. 15, August 7, 1996 REPORTS 1057
Downloaded from http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/ by guest on September 13, 2012
Fig. 3. Invasive ductal carcinoma immunostained for factor VIII at day 0 (A) and after storage at room temperature for 12 weeks (B); for estrogen receptor at day 0
(C) and after storage at room temperature for 12 weeks (D); and for Bcl-2 at day 0 (E) and after storage at room temperature for 12 weeks (F). In these examples,
staining intensity on slides stored for 12 weeks was 28.1% of that on day 0,42.8% of that on day 0, and 8.2% of that on day 0 for factor VIII, estrogen receptor, and
Bcl-2, respectively (original magnification x200).
storage under conditions that result in Another unanswered question is tigens or epitopes that is reversible if a
even less exposure to the atmosphere, whether or not the loss of immunoreac- suitable antigen retrieval method is em-
such as in a vacuum chamber, may be tivity in stored slides is due to irreversible ployed. Some method of antigen retrieval
more effective in this regard. antigen degradation or to masking of an- was used for all four antigens evaluated
1058 REPORTS Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Vol. 88, No. 15, August 7, 1996
in our study, including microwave heat- ly performed on slides only hours to days References
ing for p53, ER, and Bcl-2 and pro- after the paraffin sections have been cut.
(/) Mansour EG, Ravdin PM, Dressier L. Prognos-
teolytic enzyme treatment for factor VIII. Nonetheless, antigen loss could be a tic factors in early breast cancer. Cancer
For each antibody, both stored and un- problem in stored slides used as positive 1994;74(lSuppl):381^00.
stored slides in each case were subjected controls. One of the most unsettling im- (2) Beckstead JH. Improved antigen retrieval in
formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues. Appl
to identical antigen retrieval procedures. plications of our findings relates to the Immunohistochem 1994;2:274-81.
It is possible that more aggressive antigen frequent use of stored slides for immuno- (J) Prioleau JE, Schnitt SJ. p53 antigen loss in
retrieval is necessary to achieve optimal staining in the research environment. It is stored paraffin slides [letter]. N Engl J Med
1995;332:1521-2.
staining in stored than in unstored slides. common practice in many research (4) Mills SE, Fechner RE, Frierson HF, Kempson
Excessive exposure of the tissue sections laboratories to archive unstained paraffin RL, Wick MR, Dehner LP, et al. Guardians of
to heat or to proteolytic enzymes, how- sections for future use. In fact, collabora- the wax . .. and the patient [editorial]. Am J
ClinPathol 1995:104:365-7.
ever, can result in increased background tive groups involved in multi-institutional (5) Bromley CM, Palechek PL, Benda JA. Preser-
staining and/or excessive tissue digestion, clinical trials often establish core or refer- vation of estrogen receptor in paraffin sections.
compromising the interpretation of the ence laboratories to perform immuno- J Histotechnol 1994; 17:115-8.
(6) Kato J, Sakamaki S, Niitsu Y. More on p53 an-
staining results. Nonetheless, an impor- staining and other special studies on such tigen loss in stored paraffin slides [letter, com-
tant goal is determining whether certain material (4). Although storing slides ment]. N Engl J Med 1995:333:1507-8.
antigen retrieval protocols can restore im- clearly has logistic advantages over col-
munoreactivity in stored slides. lection and storage of paraffin blocks, Notes
In most clinical immunohistochemistry these advantages may be offset by the
Supported in part by Public Health Service grant
The Familial Kidney Cancer Program of the National Cancer Institute is interested in seeing:
• Members of families with von Hippel-Lindau disease
• Members of families with two or more members affected with papillary renal carcinoma
• Members of families with three or more members affected with clear cell renal carcinoma
The Familial Kidney Cancer Program of the NCI will provide genetic and clinical diagnosis and
treatment for selected families.
Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Vol. 88, No. 15, August 7, 1996 REPORTS 1059