(Grades 6-12)
Objective:
Students will investigate questions about how to calculate energy gain and loss and power delivered during putts or
other strokes.
Introduction Notes:
SCIENCE OF GOLF
Work, Energy, and Power
STEM Lesson Plan adaptable for Grades 6–12
Lesson plans produced by the National Science Teachers Association.
Video produced by NBC Learn in partnership with the USGA and Chevron.
(1)
Video Timeline
0:00 0:15 Series opening
0:16 0:35 Highlighting the importance of putting
0:36 1:09 Suzann Pettersen discussing her views on putting
1:10 1:41 Discussing putting as an illustration of work, energy, and power
1:42 2:11 Jim Hubbell discussing conversion of gravitational potential to kinetic energy
2:12 2:44 John Spitzer explaining the energy transfer process
2:45 3:16 Applying the law of conservation of energy to the putter-ball system
3:17 4:14 Defining work as force times distance, with example calculation
4:15 5:12 Defining power as work per unit time, with sample calculation
5:13 5:37 Suzann Pettersen’s summary
5:38 5:55 Closing credits
Language Support: To aid those with limited English proficiency or others who need help
focusing on the video, click the Transcript tab on the side of the video window, then copy and
paste the text into a document for student reference.
Energy
MS-PS3-5. Construct, use, and present arguments to support the claim that when the motion
of an object changes, energy is transferred to or from the object.
(2)
HS-PS3-3. Design, build, and refine a device that works within given constraints to convert one
form of energy into another form of energy.
HS-PS3-1. Create a computational model to calculate the change in the energy of one
component in a system, when the change in energy of the other component(s), and the energy
flows in and out of the system are known.
Engineering Design
MS-ETS1-3. Analyze data from tests to determine similarities and differences among several
design solutions, and identify best characteristics of each that can be combined into a new
solution to better meet criteria for success.
HS-ETS1-2. Design a solution to a complex real-world problem by breaking it down into smaller,
more manageable problems, that can be solved through engineering.
HS-ETS1-3. Evaluate a solution to a complex real-world problem based on prioritized criteria
and trade-offs that account for a range of constraints – including cost, safety, reliability, and
aesthetics, as well as possible social, cultural, and environmental impacts.
(3)
Have students climb a flight of stairs, timing the ascent and calculating the work as their weight times the height of the
steps (e.g., weight of 600 newtons, times height of 4 meters, equals 2400 joules). Then have them divide this by the time
to calculate their power output (e.g., 2400 joules, divided by 5 seconds, equals 480 watts equals 0.64 horsepower).
Connect to Technology
The video uses high-speed camera footage to show the behavior of the ball and club before,
during, and after impact. This technology allows us to visualize and analyze many phenomena
that happen too quickly to see otherwise. In fact, recent research at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology has led to femto-photography – recording so fast that it can show light
itself (ultrashort pulses of light) in motion.
Connect to Engineering
The engineering design process involves identifying problems and finding solutions, usually as
part of an ongoing cycle of innovation. The design of the putter and the golf ball ensure a
significant and repeatable transfer of energy from the club to the ball.
Connect to Math
Inmath, a rate is a relationship between two quantities with different units, with the second
quantity often being time. Occasionally, the term is used for a specific rate called speed, which
may be called (rather vaguely) rate, as in distance equals rate times time (d = rt).
Ask students to use examples of rates to make sketches or graphs showing the numerator of the rate on the vertical axis,
and the denominator on the horizontal axis. For example, students could plot the distances that a car can travel given
different amounts of gas, assuming a fixed rate such as 20 miles per gallon. Have students comment on the shape of the
graph (straight line through origin) and on the meaning of the graph’s slope (vertical change divided by horizontal change);
the slope is in fact the rate for the situation.
Have students carefully and repeatedly watch the portion of the video from 3:44 to 5:09, and take notes on any values
given or calculations done. In particular, there are claims that a force of 105.88 newtons is applied through a distance of
0.85 millimeters, and that this results in 90 millijoules of work. A bit later, the 90 millijoule figure is repeated, this time
with a the video showing a speed of 2.0 meters per second being reached in 0.87 milliseconds, for a power of 103 watts.
Ask students to use the given equations, along with kinematic ones – Newton’s second law (Fnet = ma) and the equation for
kinetic energy (mv2/2), where v is velocity – to check the video’s calculations, and also to see what the mass of the ball
must have been, and whether the two scenarios are consistent (which they very nearly are, allowing for some rounding).
Students might work either alone or in groups. Encourage them to represent their thinking.
Explore Understanding
Find out what students know about how energy is transferred from one form (e.g., gravitational
potential) to another (e.g., kinetic), using the example of a golf club striking a golf ball, or other
examples. Use prompts such as the following.
Energy of the putter is initially in the form of….
Before the putter strikes the ball, the putter’s energy is in the form of….
While the ball is briefly compressed, some of the energy is in the form of….
After the impact, the energy is in several forms, including….
The process by which energy is converted between different forms is called….
The time rate at which work is done is called….
Show the video Science of Golf: Work, Energy, and Power. Continue the discussion of the
transfer of energy during a putt with prompts such as these:
When I watched the video, I thought about….
Work is calculated by….
To calculate power, we must also know the….
The golfer controls the amount of energy imparted to the ball primarily by….
(5)
Design Investigations
Choose one of the following options based on your students’ knowledge, creativity, and ability level and
your available materials. Actual materials needed would vary greatly based on these factors as well.
Possible Materials: Allow time for students to examine and manipulate the materials you have
available. Doing so often aids students in refining their questions, or prompts new ones that
should be recorded for future investigation. In this inquiry, students might use materials such as
a golf ball, a putter or a meter stick with a hole drilled near one end (through which a nail can
be placed to serve as a pivot point), a stopwatch, a scale for finding masses, and a smooth floor
(preferably not carpeted).
Safety Considerations: To augment your own safety procedures, see NSTA’s Safety Portal
athttp://www.nsta.org/portals/safety.aspx.
(6)
Note to Teachers: Some physics-based calculations are needed in this inquiry. For example,
gravitational potential energy is given by mgh (mass times acceleration due to gravity, times
height above reference level). In the case of the putter, the height is that of the center of mass
above, say, the floor. In the case of a meter stick, this is simply at the 50 cm mark; for a putter,
one might try balancing it on a finger. Kinetic energy of the ball is generally mv /2, but actually a 2
fraction (about 2/7) of the ball’s total kinetic energy is in rotational form.
1. After students examine the materials you have available for putting a golf ball, have them establish a method for allowing
gravity to make the putter swing to hit the ball.
Will we use a real putter, or another tool?
What will we use as a support or pivot point to allow the putter to swing freely?
How will we locate the center of mass of the putter?
From what height(s) or angle(s) will we release the putter?
How will we ensure that the putter hits the ball?
How can the mass of the putter or other tool be varied?
2. After developing a way to let gravity swing the putter to hit the ball consistently, students might release it from a carefully
measured position, and allow it to strike the ball. At the moment it strikes the ball, they might start a stopwatch to time
how long it takes the ball to reach a certain point, such as a wall. By measuring this time and distance, the average speed
of the ball as it rolls can be calculated. Also, another lab group member might observe the height to which the putter rises
after striking the ball.
We will stop the stopwatch when the ball reaches….
We will calculate the ball’s speed by….
3. Students might now find the masses of the putter and the ball, and use these to calculate the initial gravitational potential
energy of the putter and the final kinetic energy of the ball. Then they might conduct multiple trials.
We will find the putter’s initial gravitational potential energy by….
We will find the putter’s final gravitational potential energy by….
We will find the ball’s kinetic energy by….
Our value for the kinetic energy of the ball is an underestimate because…. (Note that this inquiry ignores the energy associated
with the ball’s rotation.)
The variation among the values is about….
We might find the percentage error by….
4. Students might now estimate the amount of time the putter was in contact with the ball via frame-by-frame analysis of
video from their smart phones. This estimate could also be based on an estimated distance the putter and ball travel while
in contact, along with some kinematic considerations. Students could then estimate the power delivered to the ball during
contact.
We will estimate the time of contact by….
The value we will use for the time of contact is….
We can calculate the power by….
5. Students might consider how their methods, or another group’s methods, might be improved. If time permits, these
improvements could be made and used to gather a new set of data.
I could improve my own method by….
We could improve another group’s method by….
(7)
Compare Findings
Encourage students to compare their ideas with those of others, such as classmates who
investigated a similar (or different) question or system, or to compare their ideas with material
they found on the Internet or in their textbooks, or heard from an expert they chose to
interview. Remind students to credit their original sources in their comparisons. Elicit
comparisons from students with prompts such as:
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those of the experts in the video in that….
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those of my classmates in that….
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those that I found on the Internet in that….
(8)
Reflect on Learning
Students should reflect on their understanding, thinking about how their ideas have changed or
what they know now that they didn’t know before. Encourage reflection, using prompts such as
the following:
The claim made by the expert in the video is….
I support or refute the expert’s claim because in my investigation….
When thinking about the expert’s claims, I am confused as to why….
Another investigation I would like to explore is….
Inquiry Assessment
See the rubric included in the student Copy Masters on page 14.
Compare and Contrast: The words “work,” “energy,” and “power” have very precise definitions
in physics, including mathematical expressions and units. The same words have wider usage in
everyday English language, with several (or even dozens of) definitions listed in dictionaries. Ask
students to first define the words carefully as they are used in physics, including formulas and
units, and then find dictionary definitions for them. Have students explain ways in which the
physics and everyday meanings of these words are similar, and ways in which they are
different. Note that in some cases, two or more of these words are used synonymously. Ask
students to discuss how and why this can cause confusion for students in learning physics.
As an extension, students might consult classmates who speak other languages, or refer to
foreign-language physics textbooks or sources online, to see if the words used in physics in
these languages correspond to the same general-use words as they do in English.
(9)
as to how many times greater these values are than the ones for a putt. To extend this further,
have students brainstorm to think of a few non-golf energy transfers (e.g., kicking a soccer ball,
a bullet leaving a gun, a sprinter leaving the blocks and reaching full speed), and then do
research and calculate the work and power for these events.
Connect to … Economics
“Energy” is a broad concept encompassing many phenomena that may seem different, but that
are similar in the deeper sense, that energy in them can be converted into other forms. In this
regard, energy is a lot like money, which we use to ascribe similar value to widely different
goods and services. A golf putt is a sort of transaction, in which some (but not all) of the club’s
potential energy is used to “purchase” some kinetic energy of the ball, though with some
“hidden fees” like heat and sound. Power, in joules per second (watts) is a rate of energy usage,
much like a pay rate in dollars per hour. Many units for work and energy have been used
through the centuries, including calories, foot-pounds, and joules, but there has been a
tendency – or effort – to standardize such units (mainly joules now), much as diverse currencies
may be subsumed into a few or just one (dollars being nearly universal, or various European
currencies now replaced by euros). Energy and money are both man-made concepts, but are so
useful that they are generally regarded as real. In fact, energy costs money! Start a discussion
with students to elaborate on such ideas, and see how close of an analogy can be drawn
between energy and money, including any ways in which the analogy fails.
(10)
COPY MASTER: Open Choice Inquiry Guide for Students
Science of Golf: Work, Energy, and Power
Use this guide to investigate a question about how one might putt a golf ball, and calculate
energy gain and loss and power delivered. Write your lab report in your science notebook.
Design Investigations
Choose one question. How can you answer it? Brainstorm with your teammates. Write a
procedure that controls variables and makes accurate measurements. Look up information and
add safety precautions as needed.
Information we need to understand before we can start our investigation is….
We will construct any equipment needed by….
The procedure to be used with our equipment is….
The variables we will be measuring are….
We will determine gravitational potential energy by….
We will determine kinetic energy by….
To conduct the investigation safely, we will….
Compare Findings
Review the video and then discuss your results with classmates who investigated the same or a
similar question. Or do research on the Internet or talk with an expert. How do your findings
compare? Be sure to give credit to others when you use their findings in your comparisons.
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those of the experts in the video in that….
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those of my classmates in that….
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those that I found on the Internet in that….
Reflect on Learning
Think about what you found out. How does it fit with what you already knew? How does it
change what you thought you knew?
The claim made by the expert in the video is….
I support or refute the expert’s claim because in my investigation….
When thinking about the expert’s claims, I am confused as to why….
Another investigation I would like to explore is….
(11)
Design Investigations
Brainstorm with your teammates about how to answer the question. Write a procedure that
controls variables and allows you to gather valid data. Add safety precautions as needed. Use
these prompts to help you design your investigation.
We will raise the putter to an angle or height of….
The center of mass of the putter will fall a distance of….
The gravitational potential energy lost by the putter will be….
We will find the speed of the golf ball by….
We will find the final gravitational potential energy of the putter after impact by….
We will account for any difference between lost gravitational potential and gained kinetic energy by….
To conduct the investigation safely, I need to….
GPE down
1
2
3
Ave.
Key for example data table:
Compare Findings
Review the video and then discuss your results with classmates who did the investigation using the same or a similar system or
with those who did the investigation using a different system. Or do research on the Internet or talk with an expert. How do
your findings compare? Be sure to give credit to others when you use their findings in your comparisons.
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those of the experts in the video in that….
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those of my classmates in that….
My ideas are similar to (or different from) those that I found on the Internet in that….
Reflect on Learning
Think about what you found out. How does it fit with what you already knew? How does it change what you thought you knew?
The claim made by the expert in the video is….
I support (or refute) the expert’s claim because in my investigation….
When thinking about the expert’s claims, I am confused as to why….
Another investigation I would like to explore is….
(13)
(14)