MOTIONS

NATIONAL HEALTH POLYTECHNIC ENGLISH DEBATING COMPETITION

(NHPEDC) VI
POLTEKKES KEMENKES JAKARTA III
TAHUN 2018

No Motions
1 This House Supports Medical Tourism
2 This House Would Make Organ Donations after Death Mandatory
3 This House Would Put High Taxes on Unhealthy Products
4 Information: Fat Camp is a type of program where people who are overweight or
obese go to lose weight through exercise and lifestyle changes.

Motion: This House Would Force Parents of Obese Children to Send Their Children
to Fat Camp.
5 This House Would Ban Zoos
6 This House Believes That It is Immoral to Donate to Animal Welfare Charities While
There are Charities which Aim to Alleviate Human Suffering Still in Need
7 This House Should Provide Paramedics Immunity from Lawsuits Stemming from
Their on-the Job Actions
8 This House Would not Make State Health Care Available to Smokers
9 Information: “Collective parenting” refers to child-rearing by multiple adults, which
may or may not include the child’s birth parents. “Multiple adults” here could mean
the entire community, a subset of the community, or one or more multi-parent
households.

Motion: This House Prefers Collective Parenting

10 This House Believes That when Doctors discover a Patient Has STDs, They Should
Reveal that information to the Patient’s Partner
11 This House Believes That We Should Prohibit Public Hospitals to Proscribe
Alternative Treatments (like homeopathic treatments, acupuncture or Bach flower
remedies)
12 As Feminists, This House Supports Weight Loss Program
13 This House Supports Hybrid-embryonic Cloning
14 Information: Androgen insensitivity syndrome (AIS) is a condition that affects sexual
development before birth and during puberty. People with this condition are
genetically male, with one X chromosome and one Y chromosome in each cell.
Because their bodies are unable to respond to certain male sex hormones (called
androgens), they may have mostly female external sex characteristics or signs of both
male and female sexual development.

Motion: This House Believes That Athletes Suffering from AIS Should be Excluded
from the Gender Testing Regulations
15 Information: Kartu Indonesia Sehat (KIS) is a State Program Privileging of
Mainstream Biomedical Knowledge over Indigenous healing practices and traditions.

This House Believes That the KIS is Harmful for Indigenous People.