The aim of this article is to describe the surgical, orthodontic, and periodontal treatment of an adult patient with a
lateral open bite, anterior crowding, and gingival recession on the mandibular right lateral incisor. The lateral
open bite, which resisted conventional mechanics, was successfully corrected by the combination of
dento-osseous osteotomies and vertical alveolar distraction using orthodontic multibracket appliances in
conjunction with nickel-titanium archwires and intermaxillary elastics. After the orthodontic treatment, the
denuded root surface of the mandibular right lateral incisor was closed using a coronally advanced flap
technique with platelet-rich fibrin. The results at the 2-year posttreatment follow-up were satisfactory from
both the occlusal and the periodontal standpoints. (Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2015;148:321-31)
A
lateral open bite that causes functional and gingival recession, and root resorption in orthodontic
esthetic problems is characterized by infra- treatments of adults, especially when applied to patients
positioned teeth below the occlusal plane with a thin periodontal biotype or when heavy
and vertical underdevelopment of the dentoalveolar orthodontic forces are used.4-6 One way to remove
processes in the posterior segments. This malocclusion some of the limitations encountered in tooth
can result from ankylosed teeth, mechanical interference movement and to simplify the orthodontic treatment
with eruption such as tongue thrust, or a disturbance and minimize the risk of side effects is distraction
of the eruption mechanism (primary failure of osteogenesis. Case reports have shown that vertical
eruption). The conventional treatment of a lateral continuation of dentulous or edentulous alveolar
open bite involving nonankylosed teeth comprises fixed processes,7-10 extrusion of the ankylosed maxillary
appliances and intermaxillary elastics to obtain dentoal- central incisors,11-19 and correction of lateral open
veoler extrusion in the open-bite region.1-3 bites caused by vertical canting of the lesser segment
Cell mobilization, fibrous tissue reaction, and in cleft palate patients20 can be achieved with vertical
turnover rate of collagen molecules are slower in adults distraction osteogenesis.
than adolescents, and bones are denser in adults. These This article describes an orthodontic treatment com-
factors result in a delayed onset of responses to mechan- bined with distraction osteogenesis using multibracket
ical forces and increase the potential for complications appliances in conjunction with nickel-titanium arch-
such as alveolar bone dehiscence, marginal bone loss, wires and intermaxillary elastics in an adult patient after
traditional orthodontic therapy proved to be ineffective
for lateral open-bite correction and describes the
a
Assistant professor, Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Ege
periodontal treatment of gingival recession on the
University, Izmir, Turkey.
b
Private practice, Izmir, Turkey. mandibular lateral incisor.
c
Associate professor, Departments of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Ortho-
dontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Ege University, Izmir, Turkey.
d
Assistant professor, Department of Periodontology, School of Dentistry, Adnan
DIAGNOSIS AND ETIOLOGY
Menderes University, Aydın, Turkey. The patient was a 23-year-old white woman with the
e
Professor, Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Ege University,
Izmir, Turkey. complaint of a lateral open bite. The extraoral frontal
All authors have completed and submitted the ICMJE Form for Disclosure of examination showed no asymmetry. Her forced smile
Potential Conflicts of Interest, and none were reported. disclosed a unilateral open bite in the right buccal and
Address correspondence to: Işıl Aras, Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of
Dentistry, Ege University, Bornova, 35080 Izmir, Turkey; e-mail, isilaras@ anterior regions, and she had an acceptable gingival
gmail.com. display. She had a straight profile with unstrained lip
Submitted, January 2014; revised and accepted, July 2014. closure. We observed that the tongue was interposed be-
0889-5406/$36.00
Copyright Ó 2015 by the American Association of Orthodontists. tween the teeth on the right side, causing incomplete
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ajodo.2014.07.028 vertical eruption of the dentition. The patient recalled
321
322 Aras et al
August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2 American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Aras et al 323
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2
324 Aras et al
conditions of the mandibular right lateral incisor, and (5) leveling was achieved at the right segment of the
achieve stable treatment results. mandibular arch extending from the second premolar
to the canine (Fig 4). It was postulated that the more
TREATMENT ALTERNATIVES compact structure of the mandibular bone compared
The primary treatment option to achieve dentoalveo- with the maxilla together with the interference by the
lar extrusion was to use conventional orthodontics, tongue thrust resisted the efforts to extrude the
including a multibracket system and intermaxillary posterior teeth when light forces were used. The other
elastics. Other options would be immediate reposition- possibility was ankylosis of the mandibular right
ing of the teeth with segmental osteotomies and canine and premolars. When confronted with these
corticotomy-assisted orthodontic treatment. Also, surgi- possibilities, we planned to move the teeth with the
cal osteotomies followed by distraction osteogenesis to supporting bone via osteotomies followed by distraction
overcome the various shortcomings of conventional osteogenesis.
orthodontic treatment, such as the long treatment
time and the limited amount of tooth movement, could SURGICAL PROCEDURE
be efficient alternatives.
Mandibular unitooth and segmental osteotomies
were performed using a Lindermann single-piece car-
TREATMENT PROGRESS bide bur (Dental Burs USA, Napa, CA) after a mucoper-
Before commencement of the orthodontic treatment, iosteal flap was reflected under local anesthesia.
the patient was advised to consult a periodontist Vertical cuts were made on both the mesial and distal
because of her poor overall oral hygiene and gingival interproximal areas of the teeth in the mandibular right
recession on the mandibular right lateral incisor. quadrant starting from the first molar and ending at the
Full-mouth scaling was performed by the periodontist. distal aspect of the right canine, beginning 2 to 3 mm
Periodontal surgery to cover the root was recommended below the alveolar crest and extending 3 mm beyond
after active orthodontic treatment because there is a risk the estimated root apex. Additionally, a segmental os-
of recurrence of gingival recession during treatment as teotomy ending at the mesial aspect of the left canine
the tooth is being moved; additionally, a well- with a vertical cut was incorporated at the incisors.
positioned tooth will simplify the achievement of a Then a buccal horizontal cut was made 3 mm below
correct gingival contour.21 Moreover, the patient was the root apices connecting the vertical cuts and extend-
referred to the oral surgeon for removal of the mandib- ing from the distal aspect of the right first molar to the
ular right third molar to aid in the uprighting of the first mesial aspect of the left canine. These cuts were made
molar. We placed 0.018-in preadjusted edgewise appli- as deep as possible into the bone from the labial side.
ances simultaneously in both arches, and 0.012-in, Hence, single-tooth osteotomies consisting of the
0.014-in, and 0.016-in nickel-titanium archwires were mandibular right first molar and the second and first
used for leveling and aligning. Additionally, the patient premolars, as well as a segmental osteotomy comprising
was instructed to use 100-g intermaxillary elastics from the right canine and incisors were done (Fig 5). During
the palatal buttons on the maxillary right premolars to the osteotomies, great care was taken not to injure the
the buccal hooks on the mandibular right premolars; lingual periosteum and mucosa. The alveolar segments
the elastics also acted as a barrier to the tongue thrust. were mobilized with an osteotome. The mucoperiosteal
Although the maxillary teeth were almost leveled and flap was then closed without repositioning the mobilized
aligned by 6 months after the start of treatment, no segments.
August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2 American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Aras et al 325
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2
326 Aras et al
whereas the most apical portion of the flap was raised throughout the treatment. Although the maxillary
split thickness to allow coronal repositioning of the incisors proclined by an acceptable amount (1-SN,
flap without tension. All papillae were de-epithelialized 106.3 ), the mandibular incisors almost reached their
to create a connective tissue bed. The fibrin membrane ideal value (IMPA, 87.8 ) as a consequence of the efforts
was positioned over the recession defect just below the to resolve the anterior crowding. Even though the upper
cementoenamel junction (Fig 12, B) and sutured with lip still had a retrusive soft tissue value, the facial profile
6-0 propylene sutures. Stabilization of the blood clot showed a mild improvement (lower lip to the S-line,
was achieved by the application of gentle pressure for 2.2 mm; upper lip to the S-line, 4.1 mm). The
2 minutes. The gingival flap was repositioned with its panoramic radiograph confirmed that the roots of all
margin located on the enamel and sutured (Fig 12, C). teeth were parallel with no obvious evidence of the
The sutures were removed after 7 days, and coverage root resorption. Also, the bone levels of the extruded
of the root surface was obtained. teeth relative to the adjacent teeth were corrected as a
result of distraction, and the mandibular right first molar
was uprighted (Fig 13, Table).
TREATMENT RESULTS At 2 years posttreatment, the posterior occlusion
At the termination of treatment, the asymmetric appeared to be stable, with a minimal relapse of the
appearance on smiling was resolved. Class I canine and incisor open bite and a slight Class II relationship
molar relationships with good interdigitation of the of the right canines. No problems were observed
lateral segments, normal overjet, a 3-mm overbite, and concerning the vertical levels of the gingival margins
well-aligned and symmetric dental arches were obtained (Fig 14).
(Figs 10 and 11). The distracted teeth showed no The pretreatment, posttreatment, and 2-year post-
gingival recession, except for the mandibular right treatment cephalometric records and superimpositions
lateral incisor, which also had gingival recession before showed that no skeletal changes had occurred. The
the treatment. The distracted teeth were vital when maxillary and mandibular incisors were proclined and
checked with electric pulp testers. The suspicion of extruded slightly during treatment, with a minimal
ankylosis was ruled out because the teeth responded to relapse of the extruded maxillary incisors (Fig 15, Table).
the orthodontic forces after bone healing.
No important skeletal changes were seen in the
cephalometric appraisal because no intervention was DISCUSSION
undertaken to correct the sagittal discrepancy. Likewise, Patients with a vertical growth pattern and posterior
the hyperdivergent skeletal pattern was consistent rotation of the mandible might end up with an open-bite
August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2 American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Aras et al 327
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2
328 Aras et al
Fig 12. A, Gingival recession on the mandibular lateral incisor; B, position of the fibrin membrane over
the recession defect; C, repositioning of the gingival flap.
malocclusion, depending on the extent of the vertical weeks later on the buccal side, can provide a successful
dentoalveolar compensation. Whereas the vertical outcome, the advantage of distraction is that it is
dentoalveolar compensation was complete on the left completed in a 1-stage procedure on the buccal side
side of the jaws, no compensation, including a negative only, maintaining the lingual periosteum and
compensation, was present on the right side at the mucosa.23,26 Without interfering with the blood supply
canine and premolar levels because of this patient's of the teeth and the alveolar segment, the distracted
tongue thrust. Thus, the lateral open bite was segment can be repositioned gradually under the control
associated with vertical underdevelopment of the of the orthodontist.20
dentoalveolar process; similar to a previous case report, Vertical traction of dento-osseous blocks can be
dentoalveolar extrusion was planned as the treatment achieved by nickel-titanium archwires,16,17,20 vertical
goal.3 extrusion bends,11 stainless steel archwires with
In a previous case report, an 18-year-old patient T-loops,18 or a simple distraction device.12-15,19
with a 3-mm unilateral open bite involving the Ohkubo et al18 used stainless steel archwires with
maxillary posterior teeth and a crossbite was treated T-loops that were activated once every 7 to 14 days,
successfully with conventional mechanics including exerting a force of 300 to 400 g to produce vertical
intermaxillary elastics. However, for our patient, this distraction of the maxillary central-incisor osseous
method was ineffective in closing the lateral open bite. block, although some authors prefer nickel-titanium
This could be a result of the following. The apical archwires that deliver constant and light forces.16,17,20
third of the root might have been anchored more We supposed that the distraction osteogenesis for the
firmly in a denser mandible compared with the maxilla mandibular posterior teeth should probably be
and might have resisted the efforts to extrude the undertaken with a higher force than that applied for
canine and the premolars with elastics.4 Also, a the maxillary incisor. In this patient, intermaxillary
tongue-thrusting habit in the open-bite space acting elastics exerting 200 g of force at the mandibular right
as a barrier to the vertical movement of the teeth must segment and nickel-titanium archwires were used for
be considered. the distraction osteogenesis.
In orthodontic treatments of adults and cleft palate In conventional orthodontics, extrusion constitutes
patients, and in some special situations such as atrophic the type of tooth movement that requires minimal forces
alveolar processes and ankylosed teeth, segmen- (35-60 g) to bring the alveolar bone and gingival tissues
tal osteotomies,23-25 corticotomy-assisted orthodontic along with the tooth.27 Heavy forces and a rapid rate of
treatment,26 and vertical distraction osteogenesis11-20 movement can cause a risk of gingival recession and
are the surgical alternatives. The immediate denudation of the root, especially in adults, because
repositioning of a tooth or teeth with the supporting their gingival tissues cannot proliferate as fast.4 Because
bone through a 1-stage procedure of segmental the cortical bone was thin on the labial side of the
osteotomy can risk the blood supply of the segment and mandibular anterior teeth, with gingival recession on
can be limited by the mucosa's restricted ability to extend the mandibular right lateral incisor, distraction
up to the vertical correction,11,24 especially resulting in osteogenesis was planned for the mandibular anterior
osseous and gingival margin problems; therefore, teeth as well because traditional extrusion could have
osteodistraction remains the therapy of choice to cover been more risky regarding their periodontal health.
greater distances of correction, as for this patient.14,16,20 Eventually, the gingival margins of the distracted teeth
Although 2-stage segmental osteotomies or corticoto- became healthy with no complications such as loss of
mies, first performed on the palatal side and repeated 3 tooth vitality and denudation of the root surface because
August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2 American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Aras et al 329
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2
330 Aras et al
Fig 15. A, Pretreatment (black line), posttreatment (green line), and 2-year posttreatment (red line)
superimposed cephalometric tracings; B, local superimpositions: maxilla and mandible.
of the ability of distraction osteogenesis to regenerate stability of the lateral open-bite correction. Cabrera
soft tissues simultaneously with growth of the alveolar et al3 reported that the teeth maintained in position
process. Also, no injury to the lingual mucoperiosteum with intermaxillary elastics for 5 months and subsequent
and preservation of the lingual and buccal attached application of leveling archwires for an additional
gingivae are of the utmost importance to maintain basic 5 months reduced the relapse tendency resulting from
periodontal health. supra-alveolar fibers. However, these procedures
The connective tissue graft is the most predictable lengthen the orthodontic treatment. Although the active
procedure for the treatment of recession defects and is orthodontic treatment was reported to be 2 years
called the gold standard.28 However, the connective 9 months with conventional mechanics,3 our patient
tissue graft technique requires a second surgery to with a more severe lateral open bite was treated in
harvest the graft; this is associated with surgical 1 year 7 months. The short active treatment time and
challenges for the clinician. Also, donor site availability the stability of the open bite correction in our patient
is limited, and the procedure causes discomfort for can be attributed to the distraction osteogenesis. We
patients. Because of these limitations of connective think that the minimal relapse of the incisor open bite
tissue grafts, a coronally advanced flap with a platelet- and a shift toward a Class II canine relationship at the
rich fibrin membrane was chosen to close the denuded right side were attributable to the maxillary incisors
root surface in this patient. The platelet-rich fibrin and canines rather than to the distracted mandibular
membrane contains platelets, growth factors, and teeth.
cytokines that may enhance the healing potential of
the soft tissues. However, the initial thickness of the CONCLUSIONS
flap and the type of dissection alter the success of The combination of dento-osseous osteotomies
connective tissue microcirculation, and the interposition and vertical dentoalveolar distraction with a nickel-
of the platelet-rich fibrin membrane may restrict the titanium archwire and intermaxillary elastics aided in
collateral circulation, which is essential for a thin flap closing the lateral open bite that resisted conventional
to revascularize and heal.29 orthodontics. The advantages of this method were
Although correction of an anterior open bite is prone good gingival margins of the distracted teeth, reduced
to some relapse,30 the 2-year posttreatment evaluations time of orthodontic treatment, stable results, and lower
of the previous patient3 and our patient showed good costs with no dental complications.
August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2 American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Aras et al 331
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics August 2015 Vol 148 Issue 2