Anda di halaman 1dari 5

DESCRIPTIVE ARTICLE

Anatomy Comic Strips


Jin Seo Park,1 Dae Hyun Kim,2 Min Suk Chung3*
1
Department of Anatomy, Dongguk University College of Medicine, Gyeongju, Republic of Korea
2
The Lawrenceville School, Lawrenceville, New Jersey
3
Department of Anatomy, Ajou University School of Medicine, Suwon, Republic of Korea

Comics are powerful visual messages that convey immediate visceral meaning in ways
that conventional texts often cannot. This article’s authors created comic strips to teach
anatomy more interestingly and effectively. Four-frame comic strips were conceptualized
from a set of anatomy-related humorous stories gathered from the authors’ collective
imagination. The comics were drawn on paper and then recreated with digital graphics
software. More than 500 comic strips have been drawn and labeled in Korean language,
and some of them have been translated into English. All comic strips can be viewed on
the Department of Anatomy homepage at the Ajou University School of Medicine,
Suwon, Republic of Korea. The comic strips were written and drawn by experienced
anatomists, and responses from viewers have generally been favorable. These anatomy
comic strips, designed to help students learn the complexities of anatomy in a straightfor-
ward and humorous way, are expected to be improved further by the authors and other
interested anatomists. Anat Sci Educ 00: 000-000. © 2011 American Association of Anatomists.

Key words: gross anatomy; artistic anatomy; cartoons; humor; Korea; medical education

INTRODUCTION Science Comics


The comic medium has largely been ignored in the scientific Comics have been used in science education, including chem-
disciplines, even as it has begun to appear in the humanities. istry (Di Raddo, 2006) and biochemistry (Nagata, 1999).
For long time, comics have been regarded as suitable only for One group created a science curriculum that incorporated
children, because they are neither art nor literature but comic strips and provided students with opportunities to
rather a perverse hybrid arising from popular culture (Locke, read, discuss, and respond to the contents of these comics.
2005; Tatalovic, 2009). And yet comics have enormous The comic strips stimulated students’ interest in science issues
power to tell stories and convey messages (McCloud, 1993). and promoted science literacy (Olson, 2008). In another
Comics can also facilitate efficient and effective communica- study, children exposed to science comics were able to give
tion of complex information. They have been used success- scientific explanations for the comics based on their own
fully to disseminate ideas, and their audience has expanded experiences (Weitkamp and Burnet, 2007). Spurred by curios-
beyond young people to include adults who wish to learn ity from science comics in yet another study, children were
more about myriad weighty issues in fun ways (Green and motivated to look for more information in magazines, news-
Myers, 2010). papers, the Internet, and other sources (Rota and Izquierdo,
2003). Posters that incorporate science-themed comics can
enhance the public’s understanding of science across multiple
generations (Naylor and Keogh, 1999).
Contemporary comics depict the lives of scientists in addi-
*Correspondence to: Dr. Min Suk Chung, Department of Anatomy,
Ajou University School of Medicine, Suwon, Republic of Korea. tion to the subject of science itself. One series, PhD Comics,
E-mail: dissect@ajou.ac.kr depicts the lifestyle of graduate students in the midst of their
Grant sponsor: Basic Science Research Program through the scientific research (Cham, 2002; PhD Comics, 2011). Lab
National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF), with funding from the Bratz, another comic strip, was inspired by the day-to-day
Ministry of Education, Science, and Technology; Grant number: activities of a scientific laboratory and office space (Tatalovic,
2010-0009950; 2009; Lab Bratz, 2011). Such comics have been used for fun
Received 10 October 2010; Revised 28 February 2011; Accepted 11 and education and are increasingly a topic of academic study.
April 2011.
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI
10.1002/ase.224
Medical Comics
Medical comics have been used to promote public awareness
© 2011 American Association of Anatomists and patient literacy regarding various ailments, including

Anatomical Sciences Education MONTH 2011 Anat Sci Educ 00:000–000 (2011)
Figure 1.
Drawing steps of a comic strip. (A) Comic strip is drawn on paper; (B) comic strip is digitized with computer graphics software; and (C) Korean captions are trans-
lated to English.

HIV and diabetes (Harvey, 1997; Pieper and Homobono, stories (Tatalovic, 2009). One can imagine immunology comics
2000). The comic medium is particularly appropriate for edu- expanding to animated films, where immune cells (heroes) battle
cating patients, because visual learning can be intuitive in against pathogenic microorganisms (villains).
ways that verbal explanations may not (Green and Myers,
2010). Anatomy Comics
Medical comics also benefit health care professional train-
ees. Medical students gain knowledge from comics as well as Anatomy has been explored in some comic books, usually
empathic, observational, and communication skills. Students aimed at children’s curiosity about the human body. The
come to regard the patient as a person, much more than a available commercial comics are not ideal, however, because
mere subject with a disease. Along this line, medical comics most cartoonists who write and sketch them have no formal
are increasingly being used in the medical humanities (Green anatomy training (Hwang et al., 2005). Experienced anato-
and Myers, 2010). mists might be more likely to describe anatomy simply and
Medikidz (medical information for kids) is a comic book correctly. The process of translating scripts to images is also
designed to teach children about common disease processes crucial, as artists can distort writers’ visions (Tatalovic,
(O’Luanaigh, 2010). These serial comic books each deal with 2009). It is, therefore, desirable that an anatomist simultane-
one disease, beginning with asthma, breast cancer, and childhood ously writes and illustrates the comic strip. The project
obesity and continuing on through the alphabet (Medikidz, described here was these authors’ attempt to write and illus-
2011). The immune system is a dramatic source for comic-type trate four-frame comics that would help medical students

2 Park et al.
from the authors’ and colleagues’ memories. Story texts were
written in four paragraphs, matching the final frame count of
each comic strip. The text of each scenario was illustrated
with pencil and paper, and then digitized with Adobe Illustra-
tor CS5 (Adobe Systems Inc., San Jose, CA; Fig. 1), as has
previously been described by our group (Hwang et al., 2005).
To set a light tone and make the comic strips approach-
able for students, Dr. Anatophil was cast as the main charac-
ter, a comical anatomy professor. The corresponding author
of this article (M.S.C.) used himself as the model for the pro-
tagonist (Fig. 2).
These authors lacked the artistic talent to draw realistic
figures, so we used two-dimensional caricatures in our com-
ics. Despite their simplicity, our illustrations include a great
deal of the anatomical detail that medical students are
Figure 2. required to know. Our past experience of board lecturing
without a digital projector helped in drawing these comics.
The comic strip artist uses himself as the model for the leading character, Dr. Over the last decade, 550 comic strips have been created
Anatophil. in Korean, with anatomical terms also translated to English
according to the Terminologia Anatomica (FCAT, 1998). The
first 180 comic strips were published in a Korean comic book
(Chung et al., 2006). Some comics were serially published in
learn human anatomy. The creation and educational use of a popular health science magazine of Korea (Health Chosun,
comics is ongoing. 2007). Others were occasionally introduced in newspapers
and on television.
Thirteen comic episodes have been fully translated into
English (see Figs. 3 and 4), and the process continues. They
CREATING COMIC STRIPS are freely accessible together with all remaining comic strips
Humorous stories related to anatomy and ranging from gross in original Korean language on the Ajou University School of
and neuroanatomy to histology to embryology were collected Medicine Department of Anatomy homepage (Anatomy,

Figure 3.
Two representative anatomy comic strips.

Anatomical Sciences Education MONTH 2011 3


Figure 4.
A single comic episode.

2011). Roughly, a quarter of our comics deal with Korean lan- potential to tell such stories has been proposed by previous
guage and history that may not be familiar to English-speaking authors (McDermott, 1989; Pease, 1991; Weitkamp and Bur-
readership. We do not plan to translate these comics. net, 2007; Olson, 2008).
Comics also foster medical students’ empathy by offering
insight into different aspects of illness (Delp and Jones, 1996;
DISCUSSION Leiner et al., 2004; Green and Myers, 2010). Students may
be able to use comics or jokes to teach their patients about
Originality of Anatomy Comic Strips disease processes in appropriate, uncomplicated terms
Few graduating medical students specialize in anatomical
Unlike single-frame cartoons, comics narrate stories through
sciences, often stating that the subject matter seems boring.
a sequence of frames, so one might say that cartoons are to
Anatomy comic strips such as ours could be a novel tool for
comics as photographs are to films (Tatalovic, 2009). Comics
demonstrating the intriguing and worthwhile activities of
require more from their viewer than do films, however,
anatomists to trainees.
because the comic strip reader must reconstruct the story that
Anatomy comic strips are not without limitations. Some
occurs among frames. The reader’s imagination transforms
have argued that providing pictures to learners does them a
the physical space among frames into a coherent story. The
disservice, because they are not given a chance to create their
reader thus becomes an active participant in the narrative
own mental images (Hughes, 2005). With a morphological
and often identifies him or herself with the drawn characters
science such as anatomy, where spatial relationships are so
(McCloud, 1993; O’Luanaigh, 2010).
important, however, expecting learners to imagine accurate
Our anatomy comic strips are quite different from other
mental pictures from verbal descriptions alone is unrealistic.
books or comics. Whereas anatomy coloring books are gener-
It has also been reported that science comics, with their strik-
ally comprised of many unrelated, stand-alone plates (Gold-
ing artwork designed to be fun, might misrepresent the actual
berg, 2007; Goldberg and Ouellette, 2010), each of our
science (Tatalovic, 2009). Yet a different study demonstrated
comic strips tells one complete story within four frames (Figs.
that even children were able to appropriately discern scientific
3 and 4), the typical pattern of such comic strips as PhD
fact from fiction (Rota and Izquierdo, 2003). We believe that
Comics and Lab Bratz (Cham, 2002; Tatalovic, 2009; Lab
medical students are generally able to comprehend the humor
Bratz, 2011; PhD Comics, 2011). Our Dr. Anatophil comic
in our comic strips and, moreover, can learn anatomy from
series also differs from other anatomy comic strips in that its
them.
target audience is medical students rather than young chil-
dren (Tatalovic, 2009; O’Luanaigh, 2010; Medikidz, 2011).
Our comics contain more adult humor that may be more Future of Anatomy Comic Strips
appropriate and interesting to college students.
The authors will continue to draw the Dr. Anatophil comic
Application of Anatomy Comic Strips strip series and hope to improve the quality of the illustra-
tions and translations. We have a goal of publishing 1,000
Many students struggle to learn anatomy, some because of Korean comic strips and translating 750 into English. An
the large amount of material and others because of the diffi- exciting possibility would be to convert the comic strips to
culties associated with cadaveric dissection. There is no short- other media platforms such as an iPhone App (Apple, Inc.,
age of stories, however, that make learning of anatomic Cupertino, CA) or flash animation video.
details more efficient and fun. For example, the median nerve Objective assessment of how our anatomy comics are per-
carries the nickname ‘‘counting nerve,’’ because it innervates ceived by readers and to what degree they aid students’ learn-
the palmar surface of the thumb, index finger, and middle fin- ing is important. We plan to conduct a comparison study of
ger, which are used to count paper currency. Comic strips’ course grades for students with and without exposure to the

4 Park et al.
Table 1. MIN SUK CHUNG, M.D., Ph.D., is a professor in the
Department of Anatomy, Ajou University School of Medicine,
Narrative Remarks from Anatomy Comic Strip Readers Suwon, Korea. He teaches anatomy by drawing comics on
the board.

Reader Remarks
LITERATURE CITED
Medical students The comics promoted memorization of Anatomy. 2011. Department of Anatomy. Ajou University School of Medicine,
Suwon, Republic of Korea. URL: http://anatomy.co.kr [accessed 27 March
anatomy contents. 2011].
Cham J. 2002. Piled Higher and Deeper: A Graduate Student Comic Strip Col-
I could laugh at the comical situations lection. 1st Ed. Los Angeles, CA: Piled Higher and Deeper Publishing. 176 p.
only after acquisition of anatomy Chung MS, Park JS, Hwang SB. 2006. Diary of Mr. Anatophil. 1st Ed. Seoul,
knowledge. I recognized how anatomy Korea: DesignSOHO. 320 p.
enriches me. Delp C, Jones J. 1996. Communicating information to patients: The use of car-
toon illustrations to improve comprehension of instructions. Acad Emerg Med
3:264–270.
The awkward illustrations of
anatomical structures have both merits Di Raddo P. 2006. Teaching chemistry lab safety through comics. J Chem Educ
83:571–573.
and drawbacks. Schematic drawings
FCAT. 1998. Federative Committee on Anatomical Terminology. Terminologia
are easy to comprehend, but they are Anatomica: International Anatomical Terminology. Stuttgart, Germany:
also difficult to apply to the real Thieme. 292 p.
features of cadaveric dissection. Goldberg S. 2007. Clinical Neuroanatomy Made Ridiculously Simple. 3rd Ed.
Miami, FL: MedMaster, Inc. 96 p.
Anatomists I included a couple of comics in the Goldberg S, Ouellette H. 2010. Clinical Anatomy Made Ridiculously Simple.
PowerPoint slides that I show my 4th Ed. Miami, FL: MedMaster, Inc. 175 p.
students during lecture. Green MJ, Myers KR. 2010. Graphic medicine: Use of comics in medical edu-
cation and patient care. BMJ 340:c863.
Clinicians Several comic strips reminded me of Harvey J. 1997. Design of a comic book intervention for gay male youth at
risk for HIV. J Biocommun 24:16–24.
unforgettable medical school
Health Chosun. 2007. Diary of Mr. Anatophil. Seoul, Republic of Korea: Cho-
moments. sun Media. URL: http://health.chosun.com/cartoon_list.html?catid511J2&pn51
[accessed 11 April 2011]
I found anatomy jokes relevant to my Hughes S. 2005. Comic Book Science in the Classroom. National Public Radio
specialty and use them to relax (NPR): Washington, DC. Audio File 5:04 min. URL: http://www.npr.org/tem
patients. plates/story/story.php?storyId54581832 [accessed 5 February 2011].
Hwang SB, Chung MS, Park JS. 2005. Anatomy cartoon for common people.
Korean J Anat 38:433–441.
Laypeople As a child viewing the comic strips, I
could confirm my goal to enter medical Lab Bratz. 2011. Lab Bratz by Ed Dunphy & Helber Soares. Miami, FL: Jimbo
Inc. URL: http://labbratz.com/ [accessed 27 March 2011].
school with a better sense of the real
Leiner M, Handal G, Williams D. 2004. Patient communication: A multidisci-
experiences of that training. plinary approach using animated cartoons. Health Educ Res 19:591–595.
Locke S. 2005. Fantastically reasonable: Ambivalence in the representation of
I did not understand the jokes. science and technology in super-hero comics. Public Underst Sci 14:25–46.
Regretfully, I developed negative McCloud S. 1993. Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. New York, NY:
opinions toward the perceived HarperPerennial. 215 p.
privileges of medical personnel. McDermott TJ. 1989. Cartooning: A humorous approach to medical and
health education. J Biocommun 16:20–27.
Medikidz. 2011. Medical Information for Kids. URL: http://www.medikidz.com
[accessed 5 February 2011].
Dr. Anatophil comics. Evaluative narrative comments from Nagata R. 1999. Learning biochemistry through manga—Helping students
readers in different countries would also be worthwhile learn and remember, making lectures more exciting. Biochem Educ 27:
(Olson, 2008). A few examples of narrative comments 200–203.
regarding Dr. Anatophil comic strips are included in Table 1. Naylor S, Keogh B. 1999. Science on the underground: An initial evaluation.
Public Underst Sci 8:105–122.
Anatomy comic strips are a fun teaching tool that we have
O’Luanaigh C. 2010. Graphic medicine: How and why medical practitioners
used for several years at our medical school. We hope that and patients are using comics in medical communication. Masters in Science
other artists and educators will draw comics and distribute Dissertation. London, UK: Imperial College London. 60 p.
them freely through the Internet as we do. Competition Olson JC. 2008. The Comic Strip as a Medium for Promoting Science Literacy.
Northridge, CA: California State University. URL: http://www.csun.edu/
among anatomists would lead to higher-quality comics and ~jco69120/coursework/697/projects/OlsonActionResearchFinal.pdf [accessed 5
better anatomy teaching resources. February 2011].
Pease RA. 1991. Cartoon humor in nursing education. Nurs Outlook 39:
262–267.
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS Pieper C, Homobono A. 2000. Comic as an education method for diabetic
patients and general population. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 50:31.
JIN SEO PARK, Ph.D., is an assistant professor of anatomy PhD Comics. 2011. Piled Higher & Deeper Life (or the Lack Thereof) in Aca-
demia. A Comic Strip. Jorge Cham, Chico, CA. URL: http://www.phdcomics.
at the Dongguk University College of Medicine, Gyeongju, com/ [accessed 27 March 2011].
Korea. He teaches gross anatomy to undergraduate and grad- Rota G, Izquierdo J. 2003. ‘‘Comics’’ as a tool for teaching biotechnology in
uate medical students. primary schools. Electron J Biotechnol 6:85–89. URL: http://www.ejbiotechnology.
info/content/vol6/issue2/issues/2/i02.pdf [accessed 5 February 2011].
DAE HYUN KIM is a student in the Lawrenceville
Tatalovic M. 2009. Science comics as tools for science education and commu-
School, Lawrenceville, New Jersey, and an applicant for med- nication: A brief, exploratory study. JCOM 8:1–17.
ical school. He translates the anatomy comic strips from Ko- Weitkamp E, Burnet F. 2007. The Chemedian brings laughter to the chemistry
rean to English. classroom. Int J Sci Educ 29:1911–1929.

Anatomical Sciences Education MONTH 2011 5

Anda mungkin juga menyukai