characteristics, competencieijjjyalities
Teachers Preparation
Teaching is a distinctively human activity. It is imparting knowledge and the learning process,
the means by which the student assimilates a share of it.
It is concerned with growth and development of whole personality of the student-her mind, spirit,
character and effective behavior.
Definitions
‘Teaching is an interaction process. Interaction means participation of both teacher and student
and both are benefited by this. The interaction takes place for achieving desired GDjcc.’v-o”
Fenders.
Definition of A Teacher
• A teacher is a person who selects and organizes teaching -learning methods, consciously
planning and controlling a situation directed to the achievement of optimum student learning.
• Instructional role
• Faculty role
• Individual role
Instructional Role
• Create and maintain a desirable group climate which will encourage and enhance learning
and will lead to the development of learner self-discipline.
• Adapt teaching and preparing the instructional materials to the varying interests, needs
and abilities of the students.
• Motivate the challenging students to pursue and to sustain learning activities which will
lead them towards acceptance of responsibility for their own learning.
Faculty Role
The rote of faculty will vary according to the philosop y. objectives and setting of teaching
institu ion.
• Chairperson, secretary or member of cne or more committees.
• Counselor of students in matters (academic and nonacademic)
• Researchers
• Resource persons to groups outside the institution, heaflh agencies, or other schools
• A representative to professional nursing organizations and other agencies for her faculty or
for fie institution.
• A public relations agent, she interprets the objectives and policies of her institution and helps in
recruitment.
Individual Role
• Plays a personal role as a member of a family, a community and a citizen
• Dignified and distinct pers onality
Characteristics
• Sense of humor
• Broad interest
• Good communicator
Qualities of a Teacher
All teachers need not be experts in their fields, but possessing knowledge is important. Teachers
must continue building their understandings of their subjects throughout their careers.
2. Patience
No teacher should be expected to have much patience with individuals whose lack of discipline,
immaturity, or indolence interrupts the work of other students. Patience with students who are
trying to leam. however, is part and parcel of the teaching profess>on. Impatience with sincere
students is an indication of the teacher s own shortcomings.
3. intelltectual curiosity
Ai: good teachers are intellectually curious and naturally driven by their interests in keeping
abreast of changes in their fields.
4 Confidence
Good teachers are confident in their abilities to sense where students are BI the teaming process
and in their students’ abilities to leam material that is presented in a logical and graduated
fashion.
5. Compassion
Talented teachers are able to work with students with varying levels of maturity and knowledge.
A college
about his experience as a teacher “Each year teaching is more challenging for me, because I
grow a year older and the students stay the same age. The widening age gap forces me to stretch
in order to reach them."
6. Achievement
Experienced teachers have dear thoughts on what their students should know at the end of the
term, and they understand what they must do along the way in order to reach those goals.
7. Planning
Teachers must have plans and stick to them. This gees deeper than rigidly following a course
svilabus. Effective 'teachers sense when students need more ti»*ic to absorb the material and,
within limitations, are willing to give it to them.
8. Awareness
Teachers in elementary and secondary schools must have eyes in the backs of their heads. They
need to be aware of everything that happens in their classrooms and in adjacent hallways.
Teachers who are awake are able to stop nonsense before it starts and keep students on track.
9. Mentorship
Teachers often serve as mentors to their students. The desire to influence students positively is a
core motivation of many teachers when they enter the teaching profession.
10. Maturity
In no profession is maturity more important than in teaching. Students experience emotional ups
and downs, and insightful teachers are able to sense the changes and respond to them
appropriately. Teachers must be pillars, consistently encouraging students to grow as human
beings and to develop academically.
Maintaining good community relations is part of being a teacher, and teachers’ contact with
parents, administrators, and community leaders enhances their effectiveness in the classroom.
Teacher Preparation
12. Organization
13. Vision
Teaching encompasses far more than passing information from teachers to students. Teachers
should be illuminators who provide their students not only with interesting and useful material,
but also with visions of where they might end up if they leam weH.
14. Context
Every subject has a context, and teachers are responsible for providing it to their students. Since
no one learns in a vacuum, teachers must show their students how the information they are
learning might be used or might lead to the development of some other useful skill.
15. Mission
Perhaps the most important thing teachers communicate to students and to the community is a
sense of satisfaction with their choice of teaching as their life mission. Teaching at its highest
level is a calling, and good teachers feel it to their cores.
16. Enthusiasm
Excellent teachers never lose enthusiasm for their profession. They might become temporarily
burdened by administrative hassles or isolated problems, but their underlying engagement with
their work is unwavering. Students feel this energy, and teachers
who project it are much more successful than those who do not.
Competencies of A Teacher
Introduction
India has had its indigenous system of education called the gurukui. The village school in ancient
India was called gurukui, as the schooling took place at the home (kul) of the teacher,.who was
called the guru. It is not known whether a person became a guru because of his scholarship or
was a person from among the educated in the village who had also received training in becoming
a guru. This system continued till the first quarter of the nineteenth century when schools similar
to schools in Europe replaced village schools. It was realized that village schoolmasters could
not be expected to teach that in which they themselves had never been instructed.
Between 1815 and 1854, therefore, opinion in favour of introduction of teacher training
gradually began to build leading to introduction of normal schools in the country. With the first
normal schools that were started in 1856 teacher training became an integral part of the Indian
education system. The Indian Education Commission (1882) approved introduction of separate
teacher education programmes for elementary and secondary teachers. Training colleges
affiliated to universities were opened in a few of the selected towns. These colleges conducted
programmes called the Licentiate in
Teaching, which later gained the status of a degree, called the B.Ed. Thus a formal system of
teacher education came into being which even after a lapse of 1 °ne hundred years carnes close
resemblance with its I original form. The initial division of jurisdiction for | certification of
teacners for teaching at tf»e elementary | stage given to the State Departments of Education and
that for teaching at the secondary stage given to the universities continues to be the practice even
today.
M Certificate for teaching at the elementary stage has | been given different names by states.
Some of them ar® BTC (Basic Teaching Certificate), D.Ed. (Diploma wm in Education), TTC
(Teachers' Training Certificate) and I there are many others. But all of them are considered I
equivalent for the purpose of teaching in primary and I upper-primary schools. The course that
prepares I teachers for teaching in secondary schools is called B B.Ed. and equivalent degrees
are given by as many as S 200 universities.
55 In the post-independence period school education B expanded rapidly. Teacher education also
expanded ■ during this period in response to meeting the B requirement of teachers for new
schools. A large number I of new teachers' education institutions were started by I both the State
and by private management. The 6th All 5 India Educational Survey carried out by the National I
Council of Teacher has revealed that in 1993 there were
r •
in the country. As of now about 2000 teacher education jg institutions are engaged in preparation
of teachers for S different school stages.
Schooling system in India comprises of pre-school, elementary, secondary and senior secondary
stages. The elementary stage is split into primary and the upper¬primary stages. Schooling is
offered in formal, non- formal and distance modes. Teacher education courses, therefore, are
matched with the requirements of teaching-learning for the concerned stage and mode of
schooling. In addition to courses for pre-service education of teachers for teaching academic
subjects specialized pre-service courses for teaching subjects such as physical education, art and
aesthetics are also offered by teacher education institutions.
Face-to-face teacher education programmes could not always meet the growing demand of
teachers. This
situation at times was met by some universities in offering teacher education courses using
correspondence mode.
The correspondence cc.-^es for preparing teachers were viewed with concern. It was realized that
as teaching is a professional activity those who only learnt it theoretically cannot effectively
carry it out. Experts hela the view that for becoming a good teacher face-to-face guidance from
experts was essential. In the wake of such developments the Parliament of India through an Act
set up in 1995 the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) and gave it statutory powers
for framing regulations and norms for maintaining standards of teacher education in the country.
AS the NCTE has been given a broad mandate with legal powers fcr improving the quality of
teacher education and preventing commercialization its functions have had direct bearing on
teacher certification.
Teacher Preparation
Objectives
• To enable them to undertake meaningful educational research tor improving the condition
of education and society.
• To develop among them the desire for iife long learning for removing anachronism from
them.
Types of Teacher Education
Inservice Education
This is self explanatory, it refers to the education a teacher receives when he has enterea the
teaching profession after he has had his education or training in a teaching institute or college. It
includes all the fields i.e. the refresher courses etc that he receives at different institutions.
Functions
• Building confidence
• Methodology of teaching
• Improving standards
• Training colleges for special education, example:- handic^DS, deaf and dumb ek
• Training colleges for special subjects. Exarnpie:- preparing teachers in certain subjects
like physical education, home science, craft etc.
Regional colleges of education
• Comprehensive colleges
• Good physique
• Right tools for evaluation of pupil teacher performance example:-serf-assessment and pre
-lessons and post -lesson discussion
• Miscellaneous >
Introduction
The National Council for Teacher Education has defined teacher education as. A programme of
education, research and training of persons to teach from pre- primary to higher education level.
Teacher education is a proofsmme thai .s re! ifed to the development of teacher prof:c;encv and
competence that would enable and empower the nacher to meet the requirements of the
profession and face the challenges therein.
According to Goods Dictionary of Education Teacher education means, all the formal and non-
formal activities and experiences that help to qualify a person to assume responsibilities of a
member of the educational profession or to discharge his responsibilities more effectively.
In 1906-1956, the program of teacher preparation was called teacher training. It prepared
teachers as mechanics or technicians. It had narrower goals with its focus being only on skill
training. The perspective of teacher education was therefore very narrow and its scope was
limited. As W.H. Kilpatric put it, Training is given to animals and circus performers, while
education is to human beings (Fig 10.6)
Training, preparation of teaching aids and evaluation needs continuity to achieve quality
education. Considering this aspect, Maharashtra state has established 'State Institute of
Education(SIE). Initially, SIE looked after primary education only. Later on, its scope is widened
to pre-primary, secondary and higher secondary education. In 1984, it secured constitutional
status like NCERT and is renamed as "Maharashtra State Council of Education Research and
Training (MSCERT)
State council is the apex institute of the state. In Maharashtra, it was established in 1964 - 65 as a
state CHI mutinn rsiR It was uDarade and renamed as Maharashtra State Council of Education
Research and Training in 1984. For quality improvement of school education it (MSCERT)
carries the responsibility of teacher education, research and evaluation.
Objectives
Structure
The Role and functions are primarily concerned with ensuring quality in respect of:
• Planning
• Management
• Research
• Evaluation and
• Training
Kothari Commission for the first time in 1966 recommended for establishing SBTE, whose main
function was to develop teacher education in the state to be administered by the stale board. State
boards were established in M.P in 1967, and Maharashtra, Jammu and Kashmir and Tamil Nadu
in 1973. Ministry of education forced states to have SBTE suggestions NCERT such boards
almost all states established.
Functions
• Modifying and improving the curriculum, text books and the system of TE of the state.
• Developing the criteria for admission in TE and evaluating the teacher efficiency of pupil
teachers.
• Preparing the plan for the qualitative and quantitative development of teacher education.
• Providing guidance to the Universities and State institutes for improving and modifying
curriculum, textbooks and examination system of teacher- education.
© Determining the educational and physical conditions of the teacher education institutions for
affiliations.
• Developing the sense of cooperation among university departments and other training
institutions
Education is now considered an independent field of study; UGC provides the grants to the
University Department of education. Higher level training is essential for teachers for their
development. Department of Education (DOE) provide training for educational administrators
and curriculum specialists to improve evaluation procedures as well examination system.
University DOE organize the M.Ed, B.Ed, and M.Phil classes as well as research work for
Ph.D and D.Litt degree in education. In 1917, first education department was started at Calcutta
University. At present there are departments of education in all the Indian Universities for M.Ed
and Ph.D Degrees.
Functions
•Provide solid programmes for teacher education and developing research work.
•Starting and organize some programmes for post graduate teachers which are not organized at
other centers.
•Developing language laboratory, preparing instructional material and use new innovations and
practices in TE.
Encouraging the interdisciplinary courses and interdisciplinary research studies so that the
requirements of other departments can be fulfilled.
Organize extension lectures and programmes to encourage the teachers and research workers to
contribute in the discipline of education.
Providing awareness of new .nethodofogy and technology to upgrade the standard of TE.
A very strong academic and administrative machinery at the state level should further aim at
economy and integration of divergent elements, avoid duplication of efforts, consider and
examine the needs of different types of institutions, give a proper turn to arising ideologies and
tendencies and eliminate corruption and exploitation.
There should be a University of teacher education in every state on its own. It should be unitary
as well as affiliating for all the teachers', colleges at graduate and post graduate levels within the
state.
Established on 28th December, 1953, at New Delhi. UGC was given autonomy by govt of India
in 1956.
Functions
It extends the financial aid for the development of Universities and maintenance.
it provides a guide-line to Center and State Govt, for giving grant to a University.
It provides the grants for five years to establish as new University in the state.
It provides the grants for five years to start new department or any academic programme in the
University but now state concurrence is essential.
It encourages higher level research work and teaching activities by providing financial
assistance.
• It provides the grants for higher education and new programmes in the Universities and
colleges.
• It provides the fellowship for teachers and project work for University and college
teachers.
• The national fellowship and teacher fellowship are granted for encouraging research and
teaching work.
UGC provides travel grants to tne university lecturers for attending international conferences and
seminars.
• Visiting professors are appointed from among the University professors for inter change
programmes and delivering lectures.
• Residential facilities for university and college teachers are also provided.
Research
The main purpose of the scheme is to provide facilities for research which, in many instances,
has been held up owing to dearth of funds. It is to be carried on by the staff of the training
colleges assisted by some research fellows assigned to them and some financial facilities.
Equipment is provided to facilitate the completion of the projects.
Functions
• Providing training of educational planning and administration to develop the abilities and
competencies in the educational administration as the in-service program.
« Providing training facilities in educational planning and administration at state level and
regional level to develop efficiency at their level.
• Integrating educational studies and researches under the area of educational planning and
administration and make co ordinations in these activities.
• Arranging extension programs for new developments and innovations in the area of
planning and administration.
• Establishing contact with other countries to understand the developments and innovations of
the developed countries.
Objectives
Functions
• Undertake survey and studies relating to various aspects of teacher-education and publish
the results.
• Making recommendations to the center and State government Universities, the U.G.C and
other institutions in the preparation of plans and pfogrammme's in the field of teacher education.
EstJBfch-'cnt
Objectives
• "lbpublish necessary textbooks, journals and other literature tor achieving the objectives.
aflrtudes, ideas and values essential to maintain high quality nursing care.
• To meet job related learning needs of the nurse - (eg, continuing education, in-service
education, extramural education and post basic education)
• Learning is active process i.e., teacher and learner should be active in learning.
• Use variety of sources for learning as adult learners have wide range of previous
experience.
• It is based on goal achievement of the health care agency, the nurse and nursing
profession.
• Goal - high quality care through the mutual goal oriented efforts of the health care
agency, nursing profession and nurses.
• Education
• Experience
• Socio-economics
Staff nurse is self-motivated for learning. She may accept any type of staff developmental
activity, comes under local agency or outside agency (educational activities/ different courses).
Experience:
Nursing practice and experience in daily life are integral parts. The activities are benefited to
both, for her and patient. For quality care - experiences may be planned or unplanned.
Experiences are curricular and co-curricular and self.
Socio-economic component
It involves health care agency, the nurse and nursing association in management (in man power
planning, counseling and employee - employer relations).
• It is first aspect of orientation. It starts with explanation of H/o, purpose philosophy and
then information related job. Give organizational manual for proper self understanding.
Purposes:
Important points:
2. Job orientation:
After induction programme the employee should be oriented to specific job for she is hired. It is
needed because, each organization has lot of variations. Duration of this depends upon the unit.
3-4 weeks for general wards whereas 3-4 months for super specialized units like OT and ICCU’s.
Forms of orientation:
• Centralized.
• Decentralized.
• Individual programme.
• Help the nurse/ nurses to adjust more easiiy with her new environment (for that
opportunities are provided).
Philosophy: It is believed 'Jvt tr.o s»stemof higher education which provides the ocpc''unities to
keep update knowledge and SVJC
Definition: Any extension of opportunities for reading, study & training to any person/ adult
following their completion of or withdrawal from full time school /college programme."
Nurse internship
It is traditional orientation program. Now a days internship is part of programme e.g., medical
internship and nursing internship (GNM)
Purposes
• To improve recruitment.
• To decrease demands upon the head nurse to provide basic skill training.
It is short & well-planned programme. Duration of each differ from one to another. It has special
evaluation system.
• To improve workers morale and motrvafion by eliminating dead ends jobs. ^' - -
• Vast career opportunities are available in nursing It needs shot term or long-term
specialties and super specialties.
Management development:
programs were initiated to help the nurse to expand IPR. skills and develop more democratic
leadership.
Staff development is needed at all the level of management. Especially at front line as they gives
big success.
It should start with establishment of agreement. Many expert agree the help of management is
essential This programme content individualized action to meet needs of agency Topics are like
favorable factors for agency from inside and outside. How to use them effectively. This
programme is more educational than training. Here supervision is the main key.
Management is complex and multi layer process so this is the best way to reach to each one.
5. Organizational development:
Definition:
It is process by which employees relate to each other and work together to realize organizational
goals
Hospital management is becoming more and more complex. Team spirit and teamwork is
required for smoothing functioning organizational development
includes various activities like role clarification. Process, consultation, team building, skill
training and management by objectives.
Here external consultants help to the manager to set goals and effective and economical use of
resources.
Roles of consultants:
Purpose of evaluation:
It can be done by
1. Participants
2. Evaluation committee
2. Attitude test
3. Observation of skills
4. Questionnaire
5. Videotape.
Types
A chain of state institutes of education was sta.tcJ ii 11964. At present U.P. is the only state with
two such institutions at ALLAHABAD and LUCKNOW
• Teacher education.
This was set up by the national council for teacher education in May 1973.
• Provide various training course for supervisors of elementary schools or elementary
teacher educators.
• Provide conduct and supervise extensive services to training institutions for elementary
teachers.
• Orga. .ize research in elementary education and Provide corroscc::denes course for
teachers.
These are organized to schedule pre-services and in- service courses for elementary teachers and
for personnel working in a non-formal and adult education
It’s the apex organization at the national level which is designed to undertake research and
training in education at the school stage. It co-ordinates the entire work of the in-service teacher
education. It also formulates syllabi for the education or training of teachers at different levels.
This organizes in-service education for educational administration, planners and supervisors.
• To advise the government of India on all matters concerning teacher education, including pre-
service and in-service training, evaluation of curricula for teacher education and periodical
review of progress in reviewing of progress n revising the curricula.
• To advise the state government on any matters referred to the council by them.
• To review the ^lograms of plan schemes, both central and state, concerning teacher
education.
Teacher education, Eraut argues needs a map of professional knowledge for four reasons
• To correct the over simplified notion about teacher education that are in circulation.
• To illuminate the debate about theory -practice links and the role of experiential learning.
Knowledge must be seen as a means of teacher empowerment rather than of gaining power.
Hammond(1997) puts it ‘empowerment must occur through knowledge rather than through new
controls that would enfranchise teacher at the cost of others, especially parents, who have a deep
interest in chidren learning and success.
• Lop-sided curriculum.
In this we can be freed from the thoughts, values, systems and structures that hinder authentic
development.
In this education enables us to discover and develop Iterating elements which creates a more filly
human life and appreciate our culture.
« Education must attune us to diverse process at work and teaci' us t!»e meaning r-f responsible
COnsumpSnn ann
In this we are asked to appr.rciate , sh*ie 3')d nurture the life giving resources and processes.
• Education is human conversation with life:
This impies about the needs .problems .pains .joys, dreams, and hopes of people and the world a
huge dassroom where life is a continuing
process cf education.
• Education must teach a “new value orientation" to motivate and inspire the new
generation in the understanding of and reverence for life.
• estabSsh:ng educator training and certification standards for obtaining and maintaining a
.teaching certificate
• setting standards for approving and evaluating educator preparation programs at colleges,
ur . ensues, and ioca school districts for teachers and other professional school personnel
• .rshrc e tewing suspencfing, and 'evoking the certrj cates z* professions; schooTpersonnel
• ma rtar hg data anc submits ng reports on trends in leather cerflcaflion and employment
• set ng poKaes tor atoretrve train ing progfams; prc / deng programs resiiCng ir
certification for experts arc: professorate *rfx> ha ve so ege but rot educator decees to become
tiassroorr,teachers and admnetrascrs
• dev escpro e ortfeasixa code of etfiics as 'eo- es bylaw
• Add .ona restons o • es were legisfar'ed n 2000 *s .s rg broader responds 7 ?or educator
p«para*or> arc ^iennra Off^rjprrerr rdjJrc
• ten 'c aocred a tor standards hat net ec? national standards lor co eges of education
do TO* ~ee* ftandards or whose stude'ts tal to nee* shlena estabtired by the board
* ■ **tr ’ .. i •>
• creating guidelines for and overseeing alternative routes to ceitiTication for teachers and
administrators
Professional Preparation
Wt v
recommends that an integrated multiple subject teacher preoaratvon program should dedicate
approximately 25% of the teta number of units to professional preparation courses and field
study. To illustrate the rationale for this recommendation, we use a student taking an average of
15 units pe' semester in a traditional education program. In such
Programs. a stude^ t typicafy spends 8 semesters earning a baocala Jreate and then between 2
and 3 semesters of profess -oral preparation course work and field experience to earn a multiple
subject credential. This is a total of 10 to H semesters ‘or the undergraduate degree and the *ea"h
ng credential. The percentage o* professional P'eoara* or in s JCh a program s between 20 and
27% of the total number of units.
' ealeu a’ ng a percentage for a specific program, it may be differ to distinguish professional
p'eparation and subject matter courses for a variety of reasons. Some courses "a/ combine
professional prepa'3*on with .b,ect matter preparatior Other courses may have a professional
preparation course designation but actually pe pr man / a sub act matter course. In determining
whether a course is best class fied as professional preparation, subject
content of the course focuses primarily on pedagogy and other professional preparation areas,
then it is a professional preparation course, ft the content of the course focuses primarily on
subject matter and not pedagogy, then it a subject matter couise. In many cases particularly
where courses blend subject matter and pedagogy, it will be difficult to make these distinctions.
In attempting to make such distinctions, it is important to note that the 25% devoted to
professional preparation is "approximate" and a guideline.
General Considerations
Although all program requirements are not fulfilled until 135 credits (or less, if the program is
comprised of fewer credits than the maximum allowed under Title 5), the program may award an
undergraduate degree as near to 120 credits as possible; further, the Task Force strongly
encourage students to take the CSET at such time that toe student and advisor can use the results
ctiegnoctically when oe-ermining hew io compfeto to— **-*msr -** sdidy Finaify.programs for
native students do not have to De identical (course-by-course) as those for transfer students.
What the framework requires is that transfer students who fo ow the prescribed program in
completing 60 semester units wi have all 60 units counted toward the requirements of an
integrated multiple subject teacher preparation program without additional units required above
the unit cap for the program.
• Include relevant work-based teaming, e.g. experience in mentoring a student under the
supervision of a qualified mentor, and have the opportunity to critical y reflect on such an
experience.
Should provide a foundation for undertaking an NMC approved practice teacher programme.
student s proficiency ard therefore they may be placed immediately on the local regster wtt an
annotation to identify this.
•selfandoeer .
Peer Review of Teaching is one of a number of methods or techniques that can be used to ga ther
evidence about one s teaching. Other methods include erbeal self evaluation of teaching and
Student Evaluation of Teaching and Learning (SETL).
Peer assessment car nvotve formative re^ews to provide constrwcirve feedback. as we* as
sunmatrve g.adiiv3. •: cen a-sc rndude Jocferi rr/crfvraerif in the setting of maikirg criteria and
decisions aboj*. evidence of achievement. Sem assessment enables students to become refiective
and se^-managr g, to identify next steps in teaming and move forward unde' the* owr steanr.
When these two strategies work we*, the advantages are significant to all concerned and many of
the identified issues can be addressed by :
maxirr s*r-g opportunities for students to team trorr peer and self-assessment ,
Advantages
• Help' students to devetop r^sight into their owr performance by assessing the work of
ofhers.
increases motivation.
• Treats assessment as part erf lean i ng, so rr stagesare seen as c-pperi unities father than a
sign of
• Time for reflection or discussion with a critical friend can help individuals to 'stand back
from’ their own work and make sense of others’ comments.
• Provides more accurate feedback about processes such as collaborative working (students
are cften in a better r•coition 'in teachers to judge individual contributions}
Possible issues
• Validity of student assessment (address this by providing clear learning objectives and
marking criteria; have more than one assessor for each piece of work; build in teacher
moderation).
> Debate about whether peer assessment should be used for formative assessment only, or can be
used summatively.
supervisor, parent, or expert. The precise form and nature of the peer evaluation varies according
to the context.
* . ••• i / * %| *
1. Peer Reviews
• Peer evaluations are used within professional and creative fields as a means to establish and
maintain uniform quality of performance within the field. For example, many professional
journals use peer evaluations to weed out articles that do not meet rigorous professional
standards.
Utility
• Despite reluctance on the part of those who are being evaluated by peers, peer evaluations in
varied settings appear to have at least modest associations with other measures.
Peer review can be categorized by the type of activity and by the field or profession in which the
activity occurs. In general, those involved in a given profession or particular organization
identify' their particular process by the generic term "peer review". So, even when qualifiers are
applied the elements of peer review may appear to be inconsistent. For example, medical peer
review can refer to clinical peer review, or the peer evaluation of clinical teaching skills for both
physicians and nurses, or scientific peer review of journal articles, or to a secondary round of
peer review for the clinical value of articles concurrently published in medical journals.[3]
Moreover, "medical peer review" has been used by the American Medical Association to refer
not only to the process of improving quality and safety in health care organizations, but also to
the process of rating clinical behavior or compliance with professional society membership
standards.
• Make sure that students understand the assessment criteria and the d'kirsck.lctics of work
at different levels (see example on the opposite page of text from booklets produced to help
pupils understand their tasks, the marking criteria to be used, and how to peer-assess); this might
involve discussion and looking at examples of work which meels/does not meet the criteria.
« Provide prompt questions and a structure for recording the responses - a template can be useful
in eliciting a rigorous approach.
• Use anonymous feedback to begin with (to overcome any feelings of ‘betrayal’ among
friends).
• Try using peer assessment ir medical groups (eg Year 6 assess vtar 5 and vioe-vnrso', to
depersonalise the process and estab!irJ • a culture of consultation.
" WV- * ~
• Start with manageable tasks that are well suited to self or peer assessment.
• Establish some ground rules for supportive student- to-student feedback (perhaps
developed with colleagues as well as students themselves, to ensure consistency).
activities are:
• proposing a grade for their own work, after seeing/ assessing others’work --
• discussing and suggesting improvements to others’ work
Teachers should encourage self-evaluation because self-assessment makes the students active
participants in their education (Sloan, 1996). There are a variety of ways for teachers to provide
the students with self-assessments. Research suggests that the simplest tools to encourage student
self-assessment are evaluative questions that force students to think about their work (Hart,
1999). Some examples of these questions include the following:
1. How much time and efforj did you put into this?
2. What do you think your strengths and weaknesses were in this assignment?
4. What are the most valuable things you learned from this assignment?
It is important for teachers to model self-assessment too. Teachers need to show their students
that it is important for everybody to self-evaluate by doing their own self-evaluations. One thing
teachers can do is to ask their students for feedback on how the class is going and what the
teacher is doing well and not so
We|l- in this way the teacher is showing that they want to rnake improvements where needed.
Teachors could put up a suggestion box, and they can hand out evaluation forms at different
times of the year. This shows the students that continuous improvement is important.
Self evaluation
One of the most neglected for of explicit evaluation is self-evaluation. Ideally and logically, this
should proceed all other forms of evaluation.
• identify the professional education you need to further develop your capacity to teach
well